Monthly Archives: July 2016

Tekken 3 (Arcade, PlayStation & PlayStation 2)

Tekken 3

Developer(s) – Namco

Publisher(s) – Namco

Director – Katsuhiro Harada

PEGI – 12

Tekken 3 is not only considered to be one of the greatest fighting games of all time. But many regard it as one of the greatest games of all time. It received almost perfect scores from most publications at the time, citing its inclusion of a more diverse character roster and its improved soundtrack and graphics over its predecessors. Overall, I think Tekken 2 is the better installment out of the original trilogy. But this is a more than worthy sequel in my opinion.

Graphics – 8/10

The most noteworthy aspect of Tekken 3 is the dramatic change in artistic direction. Some classic characters are swapped out for new ones. And the appearances of many classic characters left were also re-imagined. Especially Yoshimitsu. It reminds me very much of how Midway tried to drastically branch out in terms of visuals whilst developing Mortal Kombat 3 when most of the palette-swapped ninja characters were either re-tooled or swapped out for more original-looking characters. The arena designs in the third game are also massively improved. The FMV cutscenes featured in each character’s arcade mode ending are also very well done. Tekken 3’s graphics were among some of the best that the PlayStation had to offer. Comparable to the likes of Final Fantasies VII, VIII, and IX. And it is made very apparent.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

What I like about Tekken 3 is that it is extremely accessible in the sense that it is open to both amateurs and professional fighting game players. And both sets of players can enjoy it regardless of experience. Tekken 3 has a good few game modes, including the Tekken Force mode. This presents a 2.5D side-scrolling form of gameplay very similar to Streets of Rage.

But what I like most about playing through Tekken 3 is the plethora of unlockable characters available to obtain. It’s extremely satisfying to play through the arcade mode with each of these characters and see how their stories end. But I think that if the Tekken Force mode was built on much more than it was, then Tekken 3 could have potentially been a lot more addictive than it is. It was actually one of the first examples of 2.5D side-scrolling gameplay. And it could have done with having more emphasis put on it to make the game much more interesting.

Controls – 10/10

My opinion of this game’s control scheme is identical to that of the original game, or most other fighting games; there are no problems. And it’s all down to either how fast players can mash buttons. Or how effectively they can execute combos.

Lifespan – 10/10

I would estimate that it would take even inexperienced players a maximum of 3 hours to unlock every character and complete the arcade mode with every character. But after that, it simply becomes a game that can be picked up and played at the player’s leisure. Without the worry of making conformist progress.

Storyline – 5/10

The story of Tekken 3 revolves around a young fighter called Jin. He enters the third King of Iron Fist Tournament announced by his mentor, Heihachi, in order to take revenge on the creature Ogre, who had presumably killed his mother. The basic premise is easy enough to understand. And each character has their own unique ending. Apart from this, however, the game’s story is not elaborated on any further than that. People don’t generally play fighting games for their story, but the fact of the matter is that the story is present, but there isn’t very much depth to it. But still, it makes a lot more sense than the story of Injustice: Gods Among Us, and it’s much easier to follow.

Originality – 7.5/10

Of course, with the inclusion of the Tekken Force mode, Tekken 3 stands out among more or less every other fighting game of its time, and the developer’s expression of a desire to branch out from an artistic point of view is more than apparent, as when I first played this game back in the day, whilst I knew I was playing an installment of Tekken, I was quick to notice the amount of change that was implemented.

Happii

To sum up, Tekken 3 is indeed one of the greatest fighting games I have ever played, and I would recommend it to not only hardcore fighting game fans who may not have played it, but I would especially recommend it as a starting point to people who haven’t tried playing fighting games yet, as they will be able to make progress without throwing their controllers across their living rooms.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Tekken 2 (PlayStation & Arcade)

Tekken 2

Developer(s) – Namco

Publisher(s) – Namco

Director – Masamichi Abe

Producer – Hajime Nakatani

PEGI – 12

Making significant improvements over the original game, Tekken 2 was a best-seller in the UK in particular. But it is also often regarded by most critics to be one of the greatest fighting games of all time. Including me. Back around the time of its release, I spent a lot of time playing this game. Not only was there more to do and unlock than in the first, but it also seemed a lot more accessible.

Graphics – 7/10

The first of many enhancements made by the developers with the second game was in the graphics. Most notably, the increased diversity in both level and character design. In many ways, it reminds me of the transition from Mortal Kombat II to III. Only, in this case, there was less for the developers to worry about. Since there were considerably fewer palette-swapped characters in the original Tekken than in Mortal Kombat II. But regardless, they still managed to branch out in very different artistic directions in the way Midway did with Mortal Kombat III.

Gameplay – 8/10

As well as there being new modes added to keep things fresh compared to other fighting games of the time, there are seven more characters to unlock than in the first, with the introduction of a few new faces. As well as the classics. But with new characters also came new movesets for players to become accustomed to over time. This in itself added more variety to the game than before. Though many of the movie sets are simply recycled for all of the secret characters to use, unlocking them still felt particularly rewarding.

Controls – 10/10

I’ve always found it impressive how seamlessly fighting games made the transition from 2D to 3D throughout the fifth generation of gaming. The first Tekken had a particularly impressive control scheme, which presented no complications whatsoever. But the second game perfected this formula. As combat and movement were made a lot more fluent and even easier to cope with. To me, this is most probably the reason why the second game is a lot more accessible than the first by proxy.

Originality – 7/10

The developers also did relatively well to differentiate the Tekken franchise from other games in the genre. Especially because the franchise was not originally intended to be a fighting game at all. It was one of the first to establish a stable storyline, as well as one of the first to include 2D backdrops in 3D environments, which is still one of my favorite forms of graphical rendering to this very day. The second game built greatly upon what had already been accomplished with the first game, making it one of the most standout titles of the fifth generation, in my opinion.

Happii

To summarize, Tekken 2 went leaps and bounds ahead of its predecessor and still remains a very entertaining experience, which I would recommend to any fan of the fighting genre who may not have played it yet. As well as being one of the best fighting games I’ve ever played, it’s also my favorite in the Tekken franchise overall.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Fall of the Foot Clan (Game Boy)

Fall of the Foot Clan

Developer(s) – Konami

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Designer – Naoki Matsui

PEGI – 12

Based on the hit cartoon TV series of 1987, of which my brother and I were pretty big fans, Fall of the Foot Clan focuses on another one of the Turtles’ efforts to save their damsel in distress, April O’Neil, from Krang, Shredder, and their lackeys and Foot Soldiers. And in my opinion, this game makes for quite possibly their most exciting adventure yet.

Graphics – 10/10

To me, Fall of the Foot Clan represents the very pinnacle of what the Game Boy was capable of producing in terms of both conceptual and graphical design. There’s diversity not only in level design but also in the enemies and bosses. There’s also a very stable balance of both sprite size and level size; an issue seen in other Game Boy games such as Metroid II: Return of Samus.

Not to mention, Fall of the Foot Clan easily has one of the most stellar 8-bit soundtracks I have ever heard; if not, the most stellar. Besides all this, I’ve yet to encounter a single glitch in the game, playing it on and off for almost 20 years. To achieve all this on a monochromatic system, in particular, was a fairly hard feat to achieve, but with this title, I think Konami hit the nail on the head in terms of visual presentation.

Gameplay – 9.5/10

I also believe Konami hit the nail on the head in terms of gameplay. To play this game is to feel excited and exhilarated, as well as feel challenged. Another thing I like about Fall of the Foot Clan is that it is a challenging game, but without being too hard, like many other 2D side-scrollers around at the time. Although there aren’t many side quests, having only two bonus stages to undertake throughout the game, there is still a great deal of satisfaction to be had whilst playing this game for a game of its kind, as much as the likes of Super Mario Land or Duck Tales.

Controls – 10/10

I’m also happy to be able to say that there are no issues with the control scheme at all, which I believe has a lot to do with why it plays out better than most other challenging 2D side-scrollers, such as Castlevania or Mega Man. A lot of the time with games like that, the controls tend to be pretty sketchy, and it takes away a great portion of any legitimate challenge, the way I see it. But in Fall of the Foot Clan, I think Konami got the balance between challenge and controls right.

Lifespan – 3/10

The game’s lifespan, to me, is where it drastically falls short of what it could have potentially been. It’s the same reason why I was partially disappointed with Super Mario Land when I played it for the first time. Though there is enough in the game to make players want to play it on multiple occasions, I have always wished that the level structure could have been a bit more attuned to resemble a Mario game, whereby there are multiple levels making up multiple worlds. I think adopting an idea like that would have brought much more to the table.

Storyline – 6.5/10

As I outlined before, Fall of the Foot Clan follows the four turtles, Leonardo, Raphael, Michelangelo, and Donatello, in another attempt to save April O’Neil from Krang and Shredder from captivity. I think it’s about as imaginative as most games were at that time in regard to the story, and there’s nothing overwhelmingly special about it. Although some developers tried to put more emphasis on the story at around that time, like what Nintendo tried with EarthBound, this was a time before video games were accepted in the mainstream as a viable art form. And consequently, all Fall of the Foot Clan’s story does is do a half-decent enough job of adding to the overall atmosphere of the game.

Originality – 7/10

Although the game plays out like most games of that era, indeed the 2D side-scrolling genre was the dominant of the third, fourth, and fifth generations of gaming, this game me stands out as being one of the best for a few reasons; because of how exciting, challenging and intense it is, and since it also does a very good job of presenting a pre-existing license through the medium of video games. Especially in a time closer to the video game crash of 1983, which was inevitably going to be a much harder feat to accomplish, and since then, there have been few games to do this.

Happii

Overall, I think anyone who owns a Game Boy should own Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Fall of the Foot Clan. It’s a very entertaining title, and although it does have its flaws, it is certainly worth far more than merely one playthrough. This game came out back in 1990, and it still very much holds up to this very day, in my opinion.

Score

46/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Sword Master (Nintendo Entertainment System)

Sword Master

Developer(s) – Athena

Publisher(s) – Athena & Activision

Designer(s) – Hironobu Tamai & R. Nakashima

PEGI – 3

Released late into the shelf life of both the NES and the Famicom back in 1990, with the overseas release not happening until 1992, Sword Master was the sequel to Athena’s previous NES game, Castle of Dragon, and is today considered an extremely weak effort on their part, and thus has fallen into considerable obscurity compared to many other NES games. And I must say, after having examined this title and having come across a plethora of flaws, it’s very much deserving of its status.

Graphics – 2/10

Aside from bearing a striking resemblance to the original Castlevania, in terms of things like overworld map layout, color scheme. And character and enemy design, it also happens to be one of the most unpolished games I’ve ever played. A fair few NES games suffered from graphic glitches. But this game took it to new heights, with graphical errors appearing whenever a player attacks or is defeated. Just like in Castlevania, enemies are also engulfed in flames whenever they are defeated. This makes me question how much of this game can actually be attributed to its respective developers.

Gameplay – 4.5/10

The game is also extremely similar to the original Castlevania in many more ways than one, including the gameplay. The objective, as in many other video games at the time, is simply to get from point A to point B. Fighting any or all enemies that stand in the way. And with the added challenge of a few boss fights thrown in for good measure. But the main reason why I believe this game should lose many marks is that it’s extremely bland, even compared to the many different games that followed these tropes. Though this happened, games like Castlevania, Mega Man, and Super Mario Bros had things going for them that no other game at the time did. Such as heightened challenge, a heightened sense of non-linearity, or greater gameplay variety. Unfortunately, this game has none of these things associated with it.

Controls – 10/10

The one positive thing I can point out about this game, however, is that, unlike Castlevania, the controls don’t feel quite as stiff. And therefore, there is much less of a sense of unnecessary complication with the controls scheme. The movement speed may be more or less the same as the original Castlevania. But that doesn’t really do much to hinder what little gameplay there is.

Lifespan – 6/10

Though by today’s standards, 20 minutes will seem laughable to most gamers, it was about the average lifespan of a game for the time, indeed. Even Super Mario Bros would take around that much time to complete, given the right amount of experience. That being said, it’s hard to imagine that the developers wouldn’t have been able to add even a few more levels to make this game last a little bit longer. I guess they didn’t share Nintendo’s reservations about leaving space on a cartridge whilst developing their games.

Storyline – 3/10

The story is also practically non-existent, most likely confined to the game’s manual. A regular occurrence at this time, when the emphasis on story in video games was a rarity. It involves a knight called Sword Master out to slay the evil duo of a demon and a wizard. Which he apparently summoned. So not only is it very half-hearted. But it’s also very typical of the kind of story most video games would utilize. Only in this game, there isn’t a princess seemingly being taken from one castle to the next.

Originality – 0/10

As well as this game being very boring, it’s also very unimaginative. Although console gaming was still in a primitive form and had yet to evolve into the highly standardized industry it is today, far better games than this had already been developed before on the NES or Famicom, and as I’ve thoroughly outlined, this title failed to deliver the same kind of classic gaming experience synonymous with other NES games.

Angrii

To summarize, Sword Master is a classic example of developers creating a game haphazardly and failing in almost every aspect imaginable. Activision has since gone on to publish much greater games than this, but things started primitively upon their breakaway from Atari, and this game is a prominent example of this.

Score

25.5/60

4/10 (Poor)

Super Stardust Ultra (PlayStation 3 & PlayStation 4)

Super Stardust Ultra

Developer(s) – Housemarque

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Harri Tikkanen

Producer – Ivan Davies

PEGI – 7

Conceived by the same team that developed both Resogun and Dead Nation, Housemarque’s Super Stardust was another arcade shoot-’em-up similar to Resogun. But with arguably more variety in gameplay. As well as an endless mode thrown in for good measure. Personally, I think both this game and Resogun are as good as each other for various reasons.

Graphics – 7/10

The conceptual design of the game was fairly well done and technically brilliant for what hardware was available at the time. The drawback it has when compared with Resogun is that there isn’t as much customization as there is in the former. For example, it isn’t possible for players to build their own ships. However, each level has the same degree of variety. This helps it to stand out among not only Resogun but many other arcade indie titles, too.

Gameplay – 9/10

Like many others, I believe that Super Stardust Ultra does indeed have much more variety than Resogun, with not only more game modes. However, players have to adapt to different styles of play by using different weapons for different situations. There are also not many arcade games in general that have been able to accomplish this to as great an extent as this game does, which is something to be greatly commended, as even some of the greatest arcade games could end up feeling repetitive after a while.

Controls – 10/10

As a gaming formula having been long since perfected, despite it taking place on a very different kind of stage than in many other arcade games, there would have been major issues if Housemarque messed it up, and inevitable criticisms from old-school gamers and negative comparisons would have been drawn between it and almost every other classic arcade game of the first and second generations. Thankfully, however, Housemarque got it spot on, and there are no complications with the game’s control scheme.

Originality – 6/10

The capacity in which this game stands out as best as it can, much like Resogun, is in comparison with every mainstream AAA title that is being released today. At the moment, it is becoming increasingly difficult to develop an original indie title, and its re-release on the PlayStation 4 may seem finite to those who may not have played it beforehand when it was released on PlayStation 3 back in 2012. Back then, the game was a breath of fresh air. So by that logic, there’s no reason for it to lose out on too many points in my opinion.

Happii

Overall, Super Stardust Ultra is an extremely worthwhile game. And one of Housemarque’s better efforts. The Finnish development company has made waves throughout the eighth generation of gaming. But arguably, it was this game that allowed them to begin their ascendance.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Super Smash Bros Wii U

Super Smash Bros Wii U

Developer(s) – Sora Inc. & Namco Bandai Games

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Masahiro Sakurai

Producer – Shinya Saito & Masaya Kobayashi

PEGI -12

Super Smash Bros Wii U game is a new variation of one of Nintendo’s most brilliant ideas for a series (one of which many gamers dreamed of before it was finally invented). With new characters, new game modes, new unlockables, and new features in the form of compatibility with Nintendo’s Skylanders-esque Amiibo toy line. In my opinion, though, it doesn’t match up to the quality of many other Nintendo games. And it is not the best in its series, it’s certainly a worthy sequel. And one of the best video games on the Wii U so far.

Graphics – 8/10

Many people have argued the case that the newest game in the series either looks the same as Super Smash Bros. Brawl or even that Brawl actually looks better. Although I think there is some basis in the opinion that Brawl looks better, with more textural detail, there is also just as much diversity in stage design. If not, more so. So I happen to think that both games look as good as each other. Since the visuals in both games have their own strengths. And they are played extremely effectively.

Gameplay – 7/10

With most of my preferred features of the series kept intact, such as the trophy hoarding, variety in game modes, and a plethora of characters, I’ve found the latest game in the series to be particularly enjoyable. And definitely one of the standout titles of the 2014 holiday season, following the disappointment I felt after playing Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric. That being said, I was very sorry to see the departure of the story mode. Since I believe that alone made Brawl the best game in the series, in my opinion. The story mode was handled exceptionally well for one within a fighting game. And I see no reason why the same could be repeated. And kept fresh at the same time with the inclusion of so many new characters. Such as Pac-Man, Mega Man, and Palutena from Kid Icarus.

Controls – 10/10

With so many different kinds of peripherals compatible with the Wii U, including the GamePad, the Wii remotes, and third-party controllers. And even with a compatible GameCube controller, there’s no reason why either fans of the series or newcomers shouldn’t find a style of play to suit them. Especially fans of the series, since virtually every previous control scheme is available, bar the one from the original game. However, I would impose the same precaution as I did in my review of Hyrule Warriors when playing with the GamePad. Regarding not tensing your hands around it too much. This can result in prolonged cramping in the hands and/or fingers.

Originality – 7/10

However, there isn’t much present to differentiate this game from other fighting games. Especially since the basic premise of Super Smash Bros. itself has been around since 1999, the series’ general formula has been kept relatively fresh. With the inclusion of new characters, stages, game modes, and incentives. There have certainly been many fighting games throughout the years that have come and gone, trying to be the next Street Fighter II and failing profusely. Especially during the fourth generation of gaming. The difference with many of them compared to Super Smash Bros is that elements such as character design are much weaker.

Happii

Overall, Super Smash Bros Wii U, whilst not living up to the overwhelming hype spanning over 3 years, is, regardless, an enjoyable game. And it comes highly recommended by me. I’ve been a fan of Super Smash Bros. since the GameCube era. And this game does an excellent job of bringing one of my favorite Nintendo franchises into the current generation of gaming.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Super Smash Bros Melee (GameCube)

Super Smash Bros Melee

Developer(s) – HAL Laboratory

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Masahiro Sakurai

Producer(s) – Masayoshi Tanimura, Hiroaki Suga, Shigeru Miyamoto & Kenji Miki

PEGI -12

Developed as a launch title for the Nintendo GameCube back in 2001, along with Luigi’s Mansion, Pikmin, and Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem, Super Smash Bros Melee made a multitude of significant improvements on the original game in every imaginable way. And it made for what was ultimately one of the greatest games on the system. Although the likes of Wind Waker and Metroid Prime had yet to come along by that time, this game was more than just a suitable placeholder in anticipation of greater titles.

Graphics – 7.5/10

I don’t think that this game did as good a job showing off what the GameCube was capable of on a graphical level as Luigi’s Mansion did. With its very effective use of lighting and textural detail. Melee certainly makes up for that, however, by including a level of variety in stage design comparable to any other great fighting game. Featuring many different universes from Nintendo’s vast repertoire of game series. In particular, they did a particularly decent job of presenting the Metroid universe. By that time, they had considerably less source material to go from than many other Nintendo franchises.

Gameplay – 8/10

The most significant improvements made in the original game were undoubtedly in the gameplay. There was increased variety, more unlockable characters, the advent of unlockable trophies, and additional game modes on top of that. It can be argued that Nintendo had to introduce variety on this kind of scale to continue to perpetuate the series in the long term. But the variety introduced in Melee was unlike anything I’d ever seen in a fighting game prior. And it would have been a major factor in turning the series. From a casual interest into a major system-seller for Nintendo.

Controls – 10/10

The control scheme employed in Melee was also a massive improvement on that of the original game. Since more characters, in turn, meant more move sets for each of the characters, and therefore made for more to do on a smaller controller than the preceding system. The Nintendo 64. Aside from that, however, despite the lack of the immensely popular combo system synonymous with the fighting genre, I find there to be no issues with the control scheme.

Originality – 8/10

At the time, the Super Smash Bros formula was fairly new anyway, but with significant improvements made after the first installment, it felt like an entirely new game at this point. And in my opinion, it surpasses the quality of many other great fighting games to have come before it as a result.

Happii

In summation, Super Smash Bros Melee is one of the best games of the sixth generation of gaming. And a must-have for anyone with either a GameCube or a Wii. The series may have gotten even better after this once Brawl came out. But for me, this was the installment that said to me that Masahiro Sakurai meant business with this series.

Score

33.5/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Super Princess Peach (DS)

Super Princess Peach

Developer(s) – TOSE

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Akio Imai & Azusa Tajima

Producer(s) – Shigeru Miyamoto, Yasuhiro Minamimoto & Hitoshi Yamagami

PEGI – 3

Released in the early years of the shelf life of the original DS, Super Princess Peach was designed to be a unique take on the classic 2D side-scrolling formula pioneered by Nintendo. Whereby players take control of Princess Peach for the first time. She assumes the role of the heroine as opposed to the damsel in distress. Though it does have some basis in uniqueness, I found the game to be particularly easy compared to most Mario games. And by proxy, nowhere near as good or interesting.

Graphics – 7/10

Instead of the Super Mario tradition, the atmosphere is happy-go-lucky. The game has no shortage of vibrant and colorful environments. And an array of different enemies and worlds. An interesting element of this game is Peach’s weapon. An anthropomorphic umbrella named Perry. Which was actually a young man once. As revealed through various flashbacks throughout the game. Back when the original Super Mario game was relatively new, there was a cartoon film made of it in Japan, featuring a dog. Which turns out to be Peach’s prince, and it returns to normal at the end of the film. I can’t help but think that this particular element of the film may have inspired this game in turn.

Gameplay – 6/10

As in most Mario games, the objective is simply to get from point A to point B. But in this title, there are 3 Toads to find in each level. As well as an array of different abilities for Peach to use in the form of different emotions. For example, crying projects water, which may be used to water beanstalks, growing them to advance. Though there is that small element of puzzle-solving to it, it is still a particularly easy game. Since Peach is at a great advantage with her umbrella, which can be used to attack enemies. To me, it highlights why it was such a bad idea that Nintendo originally wanted to give Mario a gun.

Controls – 10/10

As far as the control scheme goes, whilst there shouldn’t have been any problems with the basic layout (and so there aren’t any), at this point, it wouldn’t have been particularly hard to add other features to the mix along with them. I was pretty happy to see the touchscreen being put to decent use, at least. Other than this, however, there isn’t much else to say about it, unfortunately.

Lifespan – 4/10

Though it does indeed last around the same time as most other conventional Mario games, clocking at about 3 to 4 hours, the game’s paltry difficulty level can make it seem as if it lasts a great deal shorter than even that. The side quest can keep more intrepid players busy for a short while longer. But not as long as its world layout would suggest. The map looks a lot like that of Super Mario RPG, so I was somewhat disappointed to learn that it lasts nowhere near as long.

Storyline – 3/10

Not differing to any great extent from the plot most typically associated with Super Mario, Princess Peach, along with her umbrella friend Perry, are on a quest to save Mario and Luigi from Bowser, as opposed to it being the other way round. Though the game didn’t necessarily need a decent story at all, what I don’t like about it is how much it contradicts the entire premise of the series. If Peach has always had these different abilities, then it makes me suspicious of why she couldn’t use them against Bowser whenever she is kidnapped.

Originality – 6/10

The game does have at least some basis in uniqueness, at least, with the different range of abilities Peach has throughout the course of the game. Ultimately, however, it plays out essentially like any other Mario game and doesn’t stand out to any significant extent. I think the developers could build on what they achieved with this game if they ever decided to make a sequel, but the first game in this potential series was a question of trial and error.

Niiutral

Overall, whilst Super Princess Peach isn’t one of the worst games I’ve ever played, it, unfortunately, doesn’t stand out as one of Nintendo’s better efforts. I can’t help but think that with a bit more challenge, it could have been much more than what it turned out to be, but given the less-than-satisfactory sales figures this game has garnered, a sequel seems unlikely.

Score

36/60

6/10 (Average)

Super Mario Sunshine (GameCube)

Super Mario Sunshine

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Yoshiaki Koizumi & Kenta Usui

Producer(s) – Shigeru Miyamoto & Takashi Tezuka

PEGI – 3

Following on from the immense success of Super Mario 64 back in 1996, Nintendo released Super Mario Sunshine on the GameCube in 2002 and went on to receive overwhelmingly positive critical acclaim, with many publications giving it a perfect score. And the Japanese website Famitsu also gives a near-perfect score. One of the very few games at that time to achieve such an honor. Personally, however, I can understand why critics and players alike appreciate this game to the extent that they do. With it presenting a new and outlandish style of play that had never been seen in a Super Mario game prior, it seemed like too much of a step down from Super Mario 64. And there were fundamentals that I feel the developers didn’t handle as well as they should have.

Graphics – 7/10

In terms of conceptual design, Nintendo was at least able to break away from many of the normal conventions that were within the series at that time. And take it to an entirely new setting with new types of supporting characters. Very effectively expanding the mythos of the entire Super Mario universe. Something that arguably needed to happen for some time before the release of this game. It was also the first time FMVs had been implemented in a Mario game. This helped it to showcase what kind of graphics the Nintendo GameCube was capable of processing in its early shelf life.

Gameplay – 5/10

After the prolonged success of 3D platforming games on the Nintendo 64, Super Mario Sunshine was Nintendo’s attempt at bringing something new to the table. Introducing new gameplay mechanics in the form of Mario’s new companion, F.L.U.D.D. A water hose, which Mario must use to clean areas of land in order to get around. And to use a weapon against enemies and bosses. The problem I had with this game, however, is that there are several game-breaking glitches throughout. This made me believe that it was left unfinished overall. It was highly unorthodox by Nintendo’s standards, making this game one of the first true signs of weakness I personally witnessed within the gaming industry. Yoshi’s Story did little to impress me when I was a kid. But I naturally expected much more from a Mario game. And unfortunately, in this instance, my expectations were not met.

Controls – 8/10

Another way in which Nintendo could be seen as going back on itself in this instance is in the game’s control scheme. It ultimately plays out almost identically to Super Mario 64. But the new mechanics can take some getting used to at first. And even after this, I found them to be somewhat unresponsive at times. Overall, it was a little dissatisfying to see this after Nintendo had pioneered such a sophisticated control scheme with Super Mario 64.

Lifespan – 8/10

One good thing I can say about this game, however, is that for those who may not experience as much of a problem with it as I did, there is certainly a fairly lengthy experience to be had. It lasts just as long as any 3D platforming Mario game, around 30 to 40 hours can be clocked. Which is pretty impressive. In general, it surprised me how such long games could be stored on mini discs when I first started playing the GameCube. I saw it with both Wind Waker and Metroid Prime. But his game is yet another shining example of this.

Storyline – 6.5/10

The story of Super Mario Sunshine takes place on a vacation island called Delfino. In which an unidentified figure has been vandalizing large sections of the resort. Once Mario and the company touch down, ready to take their own vacation, Mario is immediately and wrongfully identified by the Delfino authorities as being the vandal. And is sentenced to clean up the mess that has been made with the aid of F.L.U.D.D. At first, it seemed like a positive change from the damsel in distress story that had become synonymous with the series, even at that point. But over time, that’s exactly what it unfolds into, overall making it not much different from any other Mario game.

Originality – 7/10

Despite Nintendo’s unwillingness to provide a great deal of uniqueness in terms of story, I do respect their willingness to try something new in terms of gameplay. Which, after all, is much more important than the former. There would be many more 3D platformers released throughout the sixth generation of gaming that would blow this title out of the water. Such as Jak & Daxter and Ratchet & Clank. But this game was able to at least stand out among these others to the extent that it did.

Niiutral

Overall, Super Mario Sunshine is my least favorite 3D Mario game. But it’s by no means the worst game in the franchise overall. There are gamers out there who hold this title in much higher regard than I do. And this is understandably so. But to me, there were far too many faults found with it to be able to call it a classic game.

Score

41.5/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Super Mario Maker (Wii U)

Super Mario Maker

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Group No 4

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Yosuke Oshino

Producer(s) – Tazashi Tezuka & Horiyuki Kimura

PEGI – 3

Partly inspired by the Super Nintendo classic Mario Paint, Super Mario Maker is a game in which players are given the ability to design their own Super Mario courses. And share them across the Internet with players from around the world. Personally, whilst I was mightily impressed with the practically infinite amount of replay value there is to be had with this title, I did have a few issues with it preventing me from being able to call it the ultimate Mario experience.

Graphics – 8/10

The templates available to players to create their own Super Mario levels consist of the conceptual and technological design of the original Super Mario Bros, Super Mario Bros 3, Super Mario World, and New Super Mario Bros U. By proxy, players will already know that they will eventually be in for a whirlwind of customization options. It involves some of the most wonderfully outlandish conceptual designs in video game history.

If that weren’t enough, Nintendo has also added a few new elements into the mix that can be implemented. Such as distorting scenery to add to a stage’s level of challenge. And a whole range of sound effects and scenery effects like fireworks. And funny noises are activated whilst interacting with a certain object in each stage. In some of the better-level designs I’ve encountered so far, I’ve been impressed with how Nintendo has managed to keep the franchise relatively fresh and creative even after thirty years.

Gameplay – 7/10

As mentioned, what Super Mario Maker entails is players designing, sharing, and playing a multitude of different Super Mario courses based on four templates of four classic Mario games. Different elements can be unlocked through either playing other people’s courses or through the nine-day unlocking cycle. But there is another way of getting around this for anyone who would prefer to have these features unlocked even sooner. All that the player must do is experiment with the creation mode for 5 minutes at a time.

At this point, they will receive a notification that new features will soon be available. After this, the player can then set the date forward by a day in the system settings. And reload the game. And the new features will become available. This can be done multiple times until all the features are unlocked. However, one problem that I think will always apply to this game is that the levels present will always vary in quality from either masterful to exceedingly boring. Since the content is almost solely user-generated. I’ve already encountered this problem whilst playing, and I don’t think this, at least, is likely to ever change.

Controls – 10/10

There is hardly anything to say about the game’s controls since it consists of a control scheme. Which has already been around for thirty years, and has been perfected all this time. Super Mario Bros. set the standard for how a 2D side-scrolling video game should be correctly developed. And by proxy, there was never going to be an issue with controls.

Originality – 6/10

Though the entire concept of user-generated content. And modding is by no means anything new to the world of gaming; Nintendo has still managed to at least keep the Mario franchise relatively fresh by adding a gameplay concept new to it. Whilst along the way, adding new elements never been seen in Super Mario stages before. Ultimately, the majority of what uniqueness this game holds lies in the player’s ability to design as many rich and varied courses as possible. And from what I’ve seen so far, the quality of that has ranged from captivatingly unique to courses that Nintendo itself would despair at if they were to see them for themselves.

Happii

Overall, Super Mario Maker is a very decent game. It also has the potential to be even better still if Nintendo decides to provide players with even more course templates. And elements as the next few months or years go on. In my opinion, it could potentially pave the way for Nintendo to make even more of these kinds of games. Which could be extremely interesting if they decide to do so. It would be just another example of how this franchise could continue to establish new trends in the world of gaming.

Score

31/40

7.5/10 (Good)