Monthly Archives: March 2019

The Witness (PC, PlayStation 4 & Xbox One)

The Witness

Developer(s) – Thekla Inc

Publisher(s) – Thekla Inc

Director – Jonathan Blow

Producer – Jonathan Blow

PEGI – 3

Created by Jonathan Blow, the man behind the classic indie title Braid, and released back in 2016 following an initially planned release on seventh-generation hardware, The Witness is a first-person open-world puzzle game requiring the player to solve a plethora of puzzles throughout to progress to new areas across a variety of different themed locations. At first glance, I actually thought that I would hate this game; like it would be another generic story-driven title with a minimal amount of things to do. Similar to Proteus or Gone Home. However, after playing it, I ended up enjoying it much more than I thought I would for various reasons.

Graphics – 8/10

First of all, the visuals, though not quite cutting edge on a technical level, are wonderfully varied and well done on a conceptual level. Each area of the world map focuses on a central theme. For example, there is one based on Japanese culture, one on Ancient Egyptian culture, etc. How each area is additionally integrated into the gameplay is also unique on a level that I’ve rarely seen in gaming. Jonathan Blow used similar traits whilst developing Braid. But to see these traits implemented in a 3D open-world game as opposed to a 2D side scroller is particularly interesting.

Gameplay – 7/10

The Witness revolves around the player having to solve a series of puzzles in order to progress through the game. In addition to a series of main set puzzles in each area, there is also a plethora of hidden puzzles players can encounter. In many cases, the player must use the surrounding areas of the world around them in order to solve. For example, simple things like tree branches can be angled in front of a puzzle to reveal a solution. And designs of buildings, in a lot of cases, are also the basis of entire puzzles within the game.

Although the entire objective of the game can become repetitive after a while, the puzzles within are varied to the point that they will quite easily hold the player’s interest for the duration. Puzzles primarily center around interacting with computer screens throughout the in-game world and drawing lines through on-screen obstacles to get from the start point to the endpoint. But over time, different elements are introduced, such as having to draw two lines at once. And drawing them through and around different obstacles on each screen.

Controls – 10/10

The control scheme is that of any standard first-person video game, centering on only a few basic functions. As such poses no unnecessary complications. Getting to grips with the controls is particularly straightforward. Though there may not be as much innovation in this aspect of the game as there is in the core gameplay mechanics, it’s simply a reassurance that the developers were able to get the fundamentals right before developing the game into what it became.

Lifespan – 9/10

Another aspect of this game that I was particularly surprised by was how long it lasted. Normally, with games like this with no combat elements or other additional gameplay mechanics of well-known titles, they only tend to last less than a few hours, given how little there is to do in them. Games like Journey, Shape of the World, and Contrast. But contrary to that. Although there is essentially only one objective in this game, it can be made to last hours upon hours since, despite this one objective, it takes a great deal of time to accomplish 100%. Even completing the main story mode can take up to 25 hours. I was impressed with this title, as well as surprised, because of this.

Storyline – 6/10

In The Witness, there isn’t actually a forward-going narrative, and therefore, nothing exists to resolve itself. Rather, the game focuses more on the backstory and is left quite open to interpretation in this respect. The world that exists within it clearly has some kind of history attached to it, given certain elements such as the natural formations and abundant evidence of man-made civilization based on numerous different cultures. But what that history is exactly isn’t really explained definitively. But this, in and of itself, gives the game its own relatively exciting dimension. If the point of art is truly to create debate, then this game can potentially do a good job of that.

Originality – 8/10

In the circle of independent game development, in particular, The Witness stands out from many in a lot of different ways, on a technical, graphical, and fundamental scale. It provides the player with a unique twist on puzzle-solving. And lasts a great deal longer than many games of the same ilk. I was pleasantly surprised by this game in almost every aspect. And it’s been a while since I’ve experienced an example of this. Particularly throughout the eighth generation of gaming, very few games have taken me by surprise as this one has.

Happii

In summation, The Witness is a vast, enjoyable, and refreshing gaming experience that I’m happy to say that I can recommend after playing it myself. Jonathan Blow had already earned a well-deserved spot in the history of independent development with Braid. But this game is a clear further example of what innovation he is capable of presenting to players.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Luigi’s Mansion 2 (3DS)

Luigis Mansion 2

Developer(s) – Next Level Games & Nintendo SPD

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Bryce Holliday

Producer – Shigeru Miyamoto

PEGI – 7

Released in 2013 to worldwide critical acclaim, Luigi’s Mansion 2, or Luigi’s Mansion: Dark Moon as it’s known in the US, is the sequel to the much-loved GameCube launch title, Luigi’s Mansion. It takes the formula of the original game and expands upon it. As well as introducing gameplay elements that were ultimately cut from its predecessor. My verdict is that whilst I didn’t enjoy this game as much as I did the first, it’s still a particularly good game in its own right for a variety of different reasons.

Graphics – 7/10

On a technological level, the second game is about on par with the first. But what makes this game different from its predecessor is that the player is not just confined to one place to explore. But rather, there is a much wider variety of locations in and around the mansion to explore in addition. Such as a museum, a dining area, and a botanical garden. All with their own unique look, further adding to the lore of the series.

The biggest problem I had with this game’s visuals in comparison to the first is that there is much less effective use of lighting to create the same kind of atmosphere that the first game had. Mainly due to the fact that there is more light shining in each area, even before ghosts are subdued. As a result, it doesn’t have the same sense of wonderful foreboding that the original game had. The soundtrack to this game is also much less imposing, which, to me, further bogged down the experience.

Gameplay – 8.5/10

Luigi’s Mansion 2 provides players with a very different experience from the first game. Structured as individual stages within each area of the map, as opposed to letting the player come and go around the individual areas as they please. This is to encourage replay value, as previous stages require newly acquired items to explore in full. There are also many more side quests, with collectibles rife throughout, along with a further incentive to collect coins. This is now done to upgrade Luigi’s equipment, giving the game a small RPG feel to it. There is also the addition of boss fights located in each area of the game.

Boss fights are an element that Mario creator Shigeru Miyamoto wanted to put particular emphasis on. The further scope provided for backtracking throughout the game was a good idea on Nintendo’s part. It made the overall experience far more interesting than what I thought it would be going into it. Although I miss being able to explore the given areas at will, like in the first game, the new structure of gameplay nevertheless made this game an extremely enjoyable experience, and it made me glad that Nintendo decided to expand on the series further. The boss fights are just as creative as they were in the first game, if not more so, as some require more varied strategies to defeat.

Controls – 10/10

With the second game, there also came the refinement of the control scheme. In my reviews of the original Luigi’s Mansion, I mentioned that it could take some time to adjust to the control scheme, as there was simultaneous action required to direct Luigi while capturing ghosts with both the C-stick and main control stick on the GameCube. But the second game doesn’t have these issues, with players having a choice between using the 3DS’s gyroscopic controls or using the X or B buttons to look up or down, respectively. This playstyle makes it much easier to capture ghosts more easily than it was in the first game.

Lifespan – 8/10

The second game can also be made to last considerably longer than the first. To complete this game to 100%, players must invest at least 16 hours into it, as opposed to the mere 6 hours it can take to complete the last game. Since the original Luigi’s Mansion was an unjustifiably short game, the lifespan certainly needed to be extended, and with the sequel, Nintendo has not failed to deliver; not only is there a longer game to enjoy, but there are also many more things to do within it to keep players occupied.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of Luigi’s Mansion 2 takes place sometime after the events of the original Luigi’s Mansion. Professor E. Gadd has found a way to pacify ghosts using a device called the dark moon. However, trouble soon starts as King Boo shatters the dark moon, causing the ghosts to once again become hostile. Gadd immediately enlists Luigi’s help to recapture King Boo and all of the other ghosts in and around the mansion and restore the dark moon to working order.

Although the series is kept fresh with a new story to further expand upon the lore of the series, and by proxy, Luigi’s part in the Super Mario series in comparison to Mario, the problem I found with it was a problem I find with many other survival horror sequels; I knew what to expect going into it. If the threat remains the same, the sense of tension or horror doesn’t. The fact that the game is less atmospheric also contributed to the marring down of this game’s story. But nonetheless, it is a solid plotline that also contains a small comedic element to balance the scales.

Originality – 8/10

Whilst the overall concept of the series has remained relatively the same with the release of the second game, the elements within the series have been kept fresh with the introduction of new ideas and elements in most aspects that players can come to expect. It introduces new ideas in terms of gameplay, it introduces more scenery and more enemies to match, and it also constitutes a longer in-game experience, something that this series desperately needed if it were indeed to be expanded upon.

Happii

In summary, Luigi’s Mansion 2 is one of the best Nintendo-exclusive experiences on the 3DS. It delivers on everything that players can come to expect from a sequel and more. It’s not quite as good as the original game, but it’s close.

Score

48.5/60

8/10 (Very Good)