Monthly Archives: July 2016

The Unfinished Swan (PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4 & PlayStation Vita)

The Unfinished Swan

Developer(s) – Giant Sparrow, SCE Santa Monica Studios & Armature Studios

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Ian Dallas

Producer – Max Geiger

PEGI – 7

First released in 2012, around the time when the idea of art in video games was perpetuated with other releases such as Journey, The Unfinished Swan went on to garner critical acclaim as well as two BAFTA awards, for gaming innovation and best debut game. Unfortunately, I was less lukewarm to this title than many others were. And whilst it does have its unique aspects, I certainly don’t think it was enough to warrant a BAFTA award.

Graphics – 6/10

Many may argue that the visuals of the game are rather unique. And provide something that most gamers won’t have been used to at the time. But from my point of view, that couldn’t be further from the truth. Not only has the general art style been replicated many times since Frank Miller’s Sin City. Indeed, it’s the same style I incorporate in many of my own paintings for Frame Over. But it wasn’t even the first time that this style had been used in video game development. There was Madworld before this title, which also continued the influx of cel-shaded visuals in gaming, which started out with Jet Set Radio. Nevertheless, they aren’t terrible graphics. And there are very few glitches to further mar them down.

Gameplay – 3/10

I couldn’t help but feel, while playing, that the developers decided to prioritize aspects. Such as visuals and stories ahead of gameplay. Since the core concept may be fairly unique. But in the long term, it provides next to no entertainment value. The object of the game is to solve puzzles and bypass obstacles by shooting ink to reveal hidden locations. And to also collect balloons along the way to buy in-game items. It seemed like it could have developed into something bigger as it progressed. But by the third level, I found myself deeply bored by the entire experience.

Controls – 9/10

As it is essentially a first-person shooting game, the control scheme plays out fairly simply, even more so than the average shooter, since there are fewer control mechanics to have to worry about. The only gripe I have with it is that the movement speed is somewhat slower than in other FPS games, which can make the game drag on more than it probably should have.

Lifespan – 4/10

Completing each level, as well as collecting all the balloons within each level, will take under 10 hours, even though the game does have a small amount of replayability. However, I think it was just as well that the game lasted that little time, since the game’s total lifespan outlasted my own personal interest in the game itself. It was a sure sign that developers at any kind of level can end up prioritizing all the wrong aspects ahead of the one that truly counts.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of the game takes the influence of many different children’s books and merges them into a fairly interesting and fully cohesive concept. It follows a boy called Monroe, who is pursuing an incomplete swan, which has escaped from a painting. The most interesting element of it is the backstory, which can be discovered as the player progresses through the game. Though it does seem to play out like a children’s story, for the most part, there are certain elements. These make the story take on a much darker tone, going against the seemingly calm and tranquil atmosphere of the game and the soundtrack accompanying it all.

Originality – 6/10

The gameplay mechanics of using ink as a projectile weapon to uncover hidden objects and areas are definitely the most unique thing about it. However, I was left thinking that they could have been put to so much better use in order to keep the entire game as interesting as possible. There could have been much more added to each level for players to do. The lack of enemies throughout alone is enough to keep avid gamers from playing this title for any extended amount of time, in my opinion.

Niiutral

Overall, The Unfinished Swan, though with fairly unique gameplay mechanics, was not entertaining enough for me to be able to praise it as many other reviewers have done since its release. The influx of indie games to come throughout the next few years following this game would yield more and better titles, but along with Journey, it started with too much emphasis on visuals and story as opposed to entertaining gameplay.

Score

35/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

Uncharted Territory: The History of Indie Video Games

(Written as of 2014)

Whilst there is no universally accepted definition of what an indie game actually is, it is a generally shared commonality that they mainly consist of games developed by independent video game companies. But the term “indie game” can also refer to games developed with insubstantial financial backing, or games, which are simply considered to be generally inferior to mainstream titles. To have indie games funded, indie developers can choose to rely on either establishing crowd-funded campaigns to fund their games, or building community support whilst their games are in development; communities most commonly found on the internet, as a majority of indie games originate on PC before they are considered to be ported for home consoles, depending on their level of popularity and critical acclaim as well as sales figures. The difference between indie game development and hobbyist game development being that indie developers are much more product-orientated.

Although most people may think that the indie game development scene is generally a new phenomenon, it’s origins can actually be traced back to the late 70’s during the arcade era, when there was next to no established computer gaming industry at all. Indie games were first most commonly distributed amongst friends, coining the term “shareware” titles; most notably throughout the 1990’s. But the most notable story throughout this early period of the movement was the founding of the company Activision back in 1979. When Atari were at their apex, they saw their game developers as nothing more than disposable commodities. They did not promote their developers, or even credit them for their work, insisting that they remain anonymous; even in interviews, Atari had their names changed in order to keep knowledge of their involvement in the development of their games a secret. Four Atari employees, David Crane, Larry Kaplan, Alan Miller and Bob Whitehead, one day decided that they’d just about had enough of it, following their failure to demand from Atari that they change these policies; the end result being the four developers regarded as “towel designers”, and that “anyone can do a cartridge”. So they then decided to leave Atari, and form Activision; the world’s first independent games development company. They took the name Activision for the sole purpose of appearing before Atari in the phonebook.

In the early stage of their existence, the problem was that rather than create a new console from the ground up, they instead decided to continue developing games for the Atari 2600 console, as well as venture in other form of software rather than merely video games. Atari, infuriated by this, attempted to sue Activision, as the newly found outfit’s titles consisted of over half of Atari’s cartridge sales at the time. The court case wasn’t settled until 1982, which resulted in things going Activision’s way, which ultimately ended in the legitimization of third-party games development.

As the industry was almost finished in the early 80’s, and as it then began to rebuild in the middle and late periods of the decade, video games were cited as becoming increasingly more difficult to publish. In particular, it was then-prominent game designer Chris Crawford who was quoted as saying:

“I will point out the sad truth. We have pretty much passed the period where hobbyists could put together a game that would have commercial prospect. It’s much more difficult to break in, much less stay in. Right now … I would discourage anyone. If you want to do a game, do it for fun, but don’t try to do game designs to make any money. The odds are so much against the individual that I would hate to wish that heartbreak on anyone.”

So judging from what was considered a professional opinion at the time, but what may not be considered by some now, it seemed that hobbyist games development had a bleak future ahead of it, and was looking most like a very fleeting thing in the industry. This fire seemed to be even further fuelled before the mid 90’s, when commercial game distribution was solely controlled by the biggest names in publishers and retailers. Things looked even worse for indie game developers, as at the time, they were forced to self-publish their games by building their own publishing companies, find a publisher willing to distribute their games or distribute their games in some form of shareware. However, doing so was made a very considerable risk, given the heightened production costs implemented in the early 2000’s.

However, some indie developers were able to begin taking the opportunity of making their games open source, thus creating a much larger group of potential participants, depending, of course, on overall interest in their games. The method of making games open source was adopted to also prevent their games becoming Abandonware. This also allowed games to be ported onto multiple systems, and thus further increasing their potential audience, whilst also providing software support by themselves, when developers ended official support.

Digital distribution, which has been made available since the 2000’s, continued to offer new possibilities to indie game developers, who now have the ability to bypass big-name publishers in order to have their games more widely distributed. The rise of online video games shopping and digital distribution has seen a huge boost in the development of independent video games created on small budgets. Probably the greatest example of which is Minecraft.

Since the release of the game back in 2009, Minecraft has become a global success, becoming the second best selling video game of all time. Swedish programmer Markus Perrson began to develop the game as an independent project for King.com. The inspiration for Minecraft came from such games as Dwarf Fortress and Dungeon Keeper. It was visualized as an isometric 3D building game, which would also later become influenced by a title called Infiminer; another independently developed game. It was released on May 17th 2009 as a developmental alpha release. Since then, it was built on and heavily modified by Perrson and has garnished an unprecedented amount of universal acclaim, global popularity and commercial success. When games like this are released, it’s no wonder that big-name game companies such as Sony have chosen to delve deeper into this market and potentially uncover a few diamonds in the rough. Overall, I believe the future of independent games development looks increasingly more exciting, with the release of Don’t Starve on the PlayStation 4, and of course, the release of other games in recent years, which have garnished much popularity, such as Castle Crashers, Super Meat Boy and World of Goo. I hope that Sony can just keep continuing this good run of form in putting out indie games that are of undeniable quality, but with several big-name titles on the way in the near future, it will by no means be a walk in the park for indie game developers to compete in this ever-growing and ever-thriving industry.

 

Thinking Outside the Xbox: The History of Microsoft in Video Gaming

(Written as of 2014)

By the end of the fifth generation of gaming, the two dominant forces in the industry were Nintendo and Sony. Nintendo, by that time, had lost their number one spot, following Sony’s PlayStation outselling the Nintendo 64. In the early 2000s, the sixth generation of gaming came about, with Nintendo releasing the GameCube, and Sony releasing the PlayStation 2, which would later become the highest selling console of all time. Another long-running company, who unfortunately failed to make as big an impact in the sixth generation was Sega, as many gamers chose to opt for the PlayStation 2 ahead of the Dreamcast, which although an excellent console with an already decent library of games, could not play DVDs, which were becoming evermore popular at the time, as VHS tapes had become well and truly obsolete. But little did they know of the level of competition they would soon be faced with on the release of a new fourth competitor, when Microsoft released their home console back in 2001 in America, and 2002 in Europe and Japan; the Xbox.

It all began in 1998, when Otto Berkes, Kevin Bachus, Seamus Beakley and Ted Hase of Microsoft’s DirectX team disassembled a series of Dell laptop computers in order to make a prototype video games console based on Microsoft Windows. They hoped to make this console in order to mainly compete with the PlayStation 2, which gamers seemed to be aligning with in favour of PC games. The combo approached Microsoft’s then head of game publishing, Ed Fries, and plugged what they had come up with, under the name of the DirectX Box. Fries was lukewarm to the idea, and decided to support it. The name of the console was shortened to the Xbox some time during the early stages of development.

However, Microsoft’s marketing department were not at first adamant about the name Xbox, and suggested many alternatives; among them being the MAX (the Microsoft Action Experience), and the AIO (All In One); that last one, in particular, being a prelude to the ideas behind the Xbox One’s marketing strategy, interestingly enough. However, further marketing research showed that consumers favoured the name Xbox over Microsoft’s other suggested names, and thus it finally became the official name of the product and brand.

The Xbox would actually be the second console produced by an American company since the Apple Pippin, which was discontinued in 1997, which followed the release of the Nuon in 2000, co-developed by Samsung, Motorola and Toshiba. It was also the first time that Microsoft had looked into releasing a home console since they had collaborated with Sega to create the Windows CE add-on for the Dreamcast. I suspect that America’s unwillingness to release many gaming consoles had a lot to do with the video game crash of 1983, which almost finished the industry. Due to a number of factors, video games were no longer seen as a viable form of business, and when the original Nintendo came out, gaming was a much more casual interest in America than it had been throughout the 70s and early 80s.

Since Bill Gates first publicly announced the console back in 1999, it was continuously delayed. But Gates was obviously desperate to get this effort right, as he expressed in an interview that gaming/multimedia devices were the future, and were essential for multimedia convergence at the time. He even suspected that if they didn’t release the Xbox and had not looked into console gaming at all, Microsoft could have very well faced falling behind their main competitors; Apple.

The Xbox was officially announced on March 10th 2000, at the Game Developer’s Conference, and it got audiences extremely excited ahead of its release, being impressed with the console’s staggering level of technology and number of features. It was at this time that sales of the Sega Dreamcast started to fall and the PlayStation 2 was released in Japan. At Las Vegas’s Consumer Electronics Show in 2001, the Xbox was unveiled to the public by Bill Gates and a celebrity guest, professional wrestler, The Rock. The release date of November 15th, 2001 was announced at the E3 conference the same year, along with the reveal of most planned launch titles, such as Dead or Alive 3, Project Gotham Racing, and the future blockbuster, Halo: Combat Evolved.

Microsoft decided to delay the release of the game in Europe and decided to first release the console in Japan, due to video gaming being considered a cultural phenomenon there. But despite this, the console was still more of a commercial success in Europe, following its release in 2002.

As of may 2006, the original Xbox sold had over 24 million units worldwide, making it the sixteenth highest selling video games console of all time, ahead of many of Sega’s previous efforts, including the Master System and the Game Gear. The best selling game on the console to date is Halo 2, which has since sold over 8 million copies. Although Sony ultimately came out on top with the PlayStation 2 in the sixth generation ahead of the both the Xbox and GameCube, Microsoft were never far behind at the time. In addition, they had big plans for the next generation, and felt as if they could continue to compete with Sony with the Xbox’s successor, the Xbox 360.

Going through another array of alternative names, such as the Xbox Next and the Xenon, development started on Microsoft’s next console as early as 2003. In February of that year, planning for the so-called Xenon software began, with the project being overseen by Microsoft Vice President, James Allard. In a bid to increase third-party support for the console, Microsoft held an event attended by 400 developers in Bellevue, Washington, whist they also recruited former president of Sega of America, Peter Moore. Later on in August, ATI signed on to assist in the console’s hardware development, producing its graphic processing unit. After a deluge of hardware issues and the revelation that IBM had hidden from Sony that the Xenon software used a slightly modified version of the PlayStation 3’s Cell Processor, the Xbox 360 was launched in late 2005 in the US, Canada, Japan and Europe.

Although the console, since before release, was in high demand, it was in short supply. The reason for this was because of an unusually high rate of hardware failure. Many consoles were returned to Microsoft as damaged or defective; the most recurring problem being the fabled Red Ring of Death, which indicates a general hardware error. This naturally led to Microsoft having to repeatedly re-think they’re warranty policies, and has also led to Microsoft releasing a wide variety of different models of it. At first, there was the Xbox 360 Core System. Then there came the Arcade edition, the Pro edition, the Elite edition, and then finally, the Slim edition. But at first, the rate at which the console failed was enough to raise a great amount of eyebrows. Many unusual and impractical techniques to fixing the Xbox 360 were also broadcast across YouTube in a bid to combat these issues, including wrapping the entire console in a towel and powering it on for ten minutes to loosen the solder joints and establish a better connection. But despite Microsoft’s initial issues, the Xbox 360, whilst losing out to Nintendo’s Wii console, outsold the PlayStation 3 and has since become the sixth highest selling console of all time, selling over 80 million copies worldwide. But what I found to be a surprise is that the best selling game on the system was actually Kinect Adventures, which has sold over 18 million copies, being bundled with the Kinect. Wanting to even further capitalize on what success they had garnished with the Xbox 360, The Xbox One was first unveiled at a press conference on May 21st, 2013. Unfortunately, gamers were not so lukewarm to Microsoft’s latest foray into home console gaming.

Reaction was varied following the Xbox One’s unveiling, with critics citing the great extent the Xbox One’s hardware capabilities such as the instant switch feature, permitting gamers to instantly switch from one game to another. The biggest limitation that critics would highlight was the console’s lack of adequate launch titles; many of them being called uninspired. Others were quick to point out that most of the launch titles simply displayed what the console was capable of graphically, and displayed no real gameplay innovations. The term, “Xbone” was insultingly coined by many to describe the system. Another deterrent was that the Xbox One was considerably more expensive than the PlayStation 4 initially, since the Kinect came with it as standard.

Controversy was ignited when Microsoft unveiled a number of seemingly ridiculous policies regarding digital content delivery, which was said to bring benefits to gamers, such as sharing games via cloud-based technology. However, this feature would only be available on the conditions that the console is connected to the Internet all day every day, and failure to do so would result in the games being unplayable until the console is again connected to the Internet. Gamers would only apparently be able to trade games at “participating retailers” at no extra charge, and could transfer games to friends for 30 days only one time. Outrage from gamers at these controversial suggestions prompted Sony fully to emphasize Microsoft’s misfortunes and cited their stupidity when Shuhei Yoshida announced that Sony’s DRM (Digital Rights Management) policies, which would allow for used games and sharing, and that they had been established some time before the unveiling of the Xbox One, citing the public’s reception as “a very useful source” for how to present the capabilities of their console.

After Microsoft announced their abandonment of their initial ideas for a console more closely resembling the Xbox 360, the Xbox One was released in most regions on November of 2013.

 

The Point of It The History of the High Score

(Written as of 2014)

The high score is much older than many modern gamers may realize. The concept first achieved cultural significance and recognition with the rise of the popularity of Pinball throughout the 70s. Players who could achieve a high score on a Pinball machine were often greeted with a simple congratulatory message, and would then enter their initials into the machine as a proof of their achievement. The initials and score would remain until someone could beat the previous record. It’s because of this that the high score was and still is considered to be one of the most competitive aspects in video games to this day, involving a strong level of one-upmanship against other players. In arcades, many games offer players a free session on another game if they are able to beat the high score of a cabinet. In recent years, however, this trend has decreased in popularity, since they are allowed to play games for as long as they can without losing, but are not given free sessions, even after beating high scores.

The first video game developed to use the high score system was Sea Wolf, developed by Midway and released in 1976. Playing out much differently to the convention set by future games, players had to attempt to beat a pre-determined high score in an allocated amount of time, with the reward being bonus playing time. Though the term high score was not yet used before Sea Wolf, the same system used in the game had been used by Taito in their racing game Speed Race, released two years prior.

However, the convention was thoroughly defied upon the release of Taito’s timeless arcade classic, Space Invaders, back in 1978. High scores were then determined by players being able to play for as long as they could until they would lose all lives. It was the first game released with the facility to save players’ own personal high scores. Since this marked the first time that players could truly compete against one another, the popularity of Space Invaders skyrocketed, spawning a sequel the following year, and inspiring the development of such games as Star Fire and Galaga.

The popularity and legacy have since continued on to each gaming generation. Video game publications, such as Nintendo Power and Sega Visions, would publish high scores set by players in their magazines; a tradition, which has continued to this day with the founding of Twin Galaxies scoreboard back in 1982. The high score also continues to exist in many modern games of today, such as Resogun, Dead Nation, and most recently, InFamous: First Light. This has also inspired the origin of many video gaming tournaments, such as that of Halo and Call of Duty, upon the rise in popularity of the first-person shooting genre throughout the 90s. Though they may seem finite to many gamers today, there is no denying the legacy the concept has left behind, and how players still try to complete the objective to this day. Though open worlds and multiple weapons seem to be among the most valued video gaming tropes today, the competitive side of gaming all started with the concept of the high score, and many gamers still see it as the ultimate appeal of playing them.

 

Super Mario Bros: From A to B

(Written as of 2015)

After the immense popularity and critical acclaim garnished from the original Mario Bros arcade game, the character’s creator Shigeru Miyamoto and long-time Nintendo employee Takashi Tezuka, actually intended to create Super Mario Bros in order to give a last hurrah to the Famicom (the NES in Japan), which was at that time considered to be fading out ahead of the release of the Famicom Disk System and to further progress the development of what Nintendo was calling “athletic” games.

At first, the game was going to involve shooting mechanics, which would have likely involved the NES zapper if history had taken a different direction. Eventually, it was decided that his may have featured as a bonus level at the end of the game, but the developers instead decided to focus more on the platforming and jumping, as that was considered to be more enjoyable, and would also keep true to Mario previous namesake, Jumpman; though the shooting element would later make an appearance in Super Mario Land under the direction and influence of Gunpei Yokoi and his own NES series, Kid Icarus.

Unlike in the original Mario Bros game, in which Mario would be hurt if he stood on turtles without first flipping them onto their backs, it was decided that Mario would be able to defeat them by stomping on their upright shells since the developers decided on the previous mechanic to be illogical. But although a lot of elements of Mario Bros appear to be very illogical, this element, along with every other, has helped to popularize the series immensely. The feature of having Mario change size upon eating a mushroom was the result of basing the game’s level design around the smaller incarnation of Mario, afterward intending to make his size bigger in the final product; but ultimately, it was decided that this feature should be included as a power-up, as it would provide a greater level of challenge for players.

The intention behind some of the earliest level designs of the original Super Mario Bros was to help players be able to differentiate between the mushrooms and the Goombas; as in the first level, for example, the first mushroom was difficult to avoid. Folk tales, whereby people wander into forests and eat magical mushrooms, influenced the use of mushrooms as a power-up in the game. I also have a theory that the use of flowers in the game as a power-up was inspired by Nintendo’s earliest history, whereby they manufactured playing cards for a popular Japanese card game called Hanafuda (Japanese for Flower Cards). The use of mushrooms in the game would also inspire the developers to name the in-game world the Mushroom Kingdom.

But one of the main intentions of the developers during the entire process was to keep things simple when they created Super Mario Bros, in order to have the new game out to retail by the end-of-year shopping season. But Nintendo’s hardships paid off, and Miyamoto’s vision was fully realized for the first time. The game has left a long-lasting legacy, helped to re-popularise video games all over the world, and has garnished a level of critical and commercial acclaim that very few other video games have been able to achieve as well as helping to spawn the most successful and recognizable franchise in video gaming history, as well as the most recognizable video game character of all time. Nowadays, Mario is even officially more recognizable than Mickey Mouse. It suggests to me how far the franchise has come since the NES days and the power of what one good idea can do. Although the idea of Super Mario may seem ridiculous to some on paper, the fact of the matter is that it has captivated people’s imaginations and bedazzled gamers all over the world for over 30 years.

Stop N’ Swop: The Mystery of Banjo Kazooie

(Written as of 2015)

The game Banjo-Kazooie was released on the Nintendo 64 in 1998 and became an instant success, as well as one of Rare’s most popular games overall. It garnished perfect reviews from critics and players alike, and went on to become one of the highest-selling games on the console, as well as appearing on many publication’s top 10 and top 100 lists. But what gamers would eventually come to realize is that this game harbored a great secret, which would become one of the biggest mysteries in video gaming.

Throughout the game, many players found that there were many areas that were inaccessible, which was fairly common in games at the time, and has continued to be so to this day. It wouldn’t have even been an issue in the first place, but there were players who started noticing not only locked off areas but locked off items. In the level Freezeezy Peak, there’s an anthropomorphic Walrus named Wozza, who retreats to a cave every time Banjo goes to try and talk to him. What the player must do is have the game’s shaman character Mumbo turn Banjo into a walrus himself. Once this is done the player will be able to talk to Wozza, who will then give Banjo a jiggy; one of the many items that must be collected in the game.

Not only that, but Banjo will then be able to enter Wozza’s cave, where one of the level’s Jinjo collectibles are, as well as a very well hidden honeycomb piece. However, the more intrepid player will also notice another secret area in the cave that is blocked off by a wall of ice. Most players will have assumed that this was for later on in the game and that there existed a means of entering areas like it to be obtained later on. But this never happens, however. The wall of ice is completely impenetrable, and no conventional means can be used to enter the room. The only thing players could do was enter the first-person mode and see what was behind the wall of ice, If players do this, they will be able to see that the opening leads to a cave with a giant icy key rotating in the middle of it.

What this key did remained a complete mystery for the most part, since there was nothing in the game to indicate any possible use for it, such as an ice door or ice treasure chest, etc. However, if the player manages to beat the game after collecting every jiggy, the game’s ending will be expanded slightly, and the mole Bottles will show Banjo a series of photos illustrating hidden areas of the game, including the cave with the ice key inside. The other items were two hidden eggs of different colors. It was explained that these items had something to do with the game’s upcoming sequel Banjo-Tooie, and there would exist a means in the second game of gaining access to the items in the first game.

However, not everyone was willing to wait. Two Internet users named Alan Pierce and Mitchell Kleiman, who went under the Internet pseudonyms Ice Mario and SubDrag respectively, created a Banjo-Kazooie fansite named Rare Witch Project and managed to hack into the game, endeavoring to find out exactly what the deal was with these hidden items. What they found proved to be a lot more interesting than they had initially hoped. They found that aside from the ice key and the two hidden eggs, there were four additional eggs hidden throughout inaccessible areas of the game. They found that inputting cheats into the sandcastle area of the level Treasure Trove Cove could give the player the means to collect these items and that the second game would have supposedly provided these cheats upon playing it. The items can be collected, and placed on a newly added menu in the game called the Stop N’ Swop menu. And for anyone curious, I will reveal how to get them.

To get the cyan egg, input the sentence “cheat, don’t you go and tell her about the secret in her cellar”. Head off to Mad Monster Mansion, and the egg will be in the cellar, inside a previously inaccessible barrel marked 1881, which interestingly is a reference to an old Rare game called A Tick A Tack.

To get the pink egg, input the sentence “cheat, out of the sea it rises to reveal more secret prizes”. Stay in Treasure Trove Cove, and an island will be raised from the ocean, which the player will be able to enter and traverse a raised area inside with the pink egg on top.

To get the blue egg, input the sentence “cheat, a desert door open wide, ancient secrets wait inside”. Head to Gobi’s Valley, and the egg will be behind the door where the Gobi was previously, and in the sarcophagus in the middle of the room.

To get the green egg, input the sentence “cheat, amidst the haunted gloom, a secret in the bathroom”. Head back to Mad Monster Mansion, and the egg will be in the bathroom on top of the anthropomorphic toilet.

To get the red egg, input the sentence “cheat, the secret you’ll be grabbin’ in the captain’s cabin”. Head to Rusty Bucket Bay, and break into the captain’s quarters of the boat by smashing one of the windows from the outside. The red egg will be in there.

To get the yellow egg, input the sentence “cheat, now Banjo will be able to see it on Nabnut’s table”. Head over to Click Clock Wood, and the yellow egg will be in Nabnut’s treehouse, and on top of his table.

Finally, to get the ice key, input the sentence “cheat, now you can see a nice ice key, which you can have for free”. Head back to Freezeezy Peak, and the ice barrier will be gone, allowing the player to collect the ice key.

The downside to all this is that the items were revealed to do absolutely nothing since they were originally intended for use in the game’s upcoming sequel and that the second game would indeed give the players the means to get these cheat codes, and thus secrets would, in turn, be unlocked within the second game. However, in the few years leading up to the release of Banjo-Tooie, Rare seemed very coy about what method would be using to achieve this feature, leading to a whirlwind of speculation. The most prevailing theory was that the cartridge would use lock-on technology; similar to what Sega did with Sonic & Knuckles as an expansion to Sonic the Hedgehog 3. However, when Banjo-Tooie was finally released, the method was never revealed, and the entire concept seemed to be abandoned. It was instead substituted for a means of finding the ice key in Banjo-Tooie, along with three hidden eggs, which offered a range of different abilities. Most notably, the ice key revealed a creature called the Mega Glowbo, which could be taken to the level Pine Grove in order to transform Kazooie into a dragon.

Therefore, it became obvious that whatever the original plan was to implement this whole feature to begin with, Rare had abandoned it. However, the speculation was far from over; especially as Rare wanted to go out of their way to taunt players with the mystery of what the original plan was with every opportunity that presented itself; even after their relationship with Nintendo. In the Xbox game, Grabbed by the Ghoulies, one of the blackboards contained a reference to it, with an illustration saying “collect ice key, collect four eggs, unlock secret area”, but it doesn’t hold up to closer scrutiny, since no secret level was ever found in Banjo-Kazooie’s ROM file. In the game Banjo Pilot, there was yet another reference. Upon completion, the character Cheato will have an item called Stop N’ Swop available to buy for 999 Cheato pages. I bought, Cheato will taunt the player by saying:

“So, you wanna know about Stop N’ Swop, eh? I hope you’re ready, here goes… why don’t you stop annoying me, and swap this game for a nice book or something?”

The speculation continued, especially as EGM printed their own theory that the Stop N’ Swop feature would make use of hot-swapping; the practice of swapping cartridges in a console with the power still on, allowing for a small window of time for something like this to be implemented. But again, this theory didn’t hold up to closer scrutiny, since the practice would inevitably have been too dangerous for Nintendo to have allowed for use in a licensed game from a second-party developer. But believe it or not, the truth wasn’t a million miles off.

The truth was finally revealed in 2004 but in a particularly low-key and obscure fashion. In 2004, the US government made public a patent that was filed in 1999 by Rare themselves; patent 6820265 B1, the patent of system method and data storage medium for sharing data between video games. In layman’s terms, the Nintendo 64 had a specific kind of memory called RD-RAM. The idea of which was that Banjo-Tooie would give the player the cheat codes to access the items in Banjo-Kazooie, and once added to the inventory, the console would be turned off, storing this information in the console’s memory for a total of ten seconds, giving the player an adequate amount of time to quickly switch the two cartridges and power the console back on. It wasn’t too different from hot swapping in its basic premise, but since the console would have been turned off, it would pose no danger to either the console or the cartridges. The reason why this practice wasn’t implemented, however, was because it would only work in early models of the console.

In 1999, the Nintendo 64 went through some internal technological changes. It wouldn’t affect the playing of games, but it would drastically affect the idea of the Stop N’ Swop since the window of opportunity was narrowed from ten seconds down to one second, and whilst many would have been able to use the feature at the time, many others wouldn’t have; and so, the entire idea was dropped.

However, if players wish to experience the Stop N’ Swop feature as it was originally intended, it’s now possible to do so, since both Banjo-Kazooie and Banjo-Tooie have since been ported to the Xbox Live Arcade, and Banjo-Tooie now gives players the facility to unlock the items in Banjo-Kazooie, and Banjo-Tooie had additional secret items available. The ultimate purpose of all of this, however, was to unlock more trinkets in the third game, the ill-fated Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts N’ Bolts. But whilst the end goal would prove to be extremely anti-climactic, the entire thing still makes for an interesting story, and for the longest time remained one of the biggest mysteries in gaming.

 

Spyro the Dragon: Out of the Fire

Spyro the Dragon has been around for longer than many young Skylanders fans may have realized. Since the days of the PlayStation, Spyro has been one of the most prominent video game characters around, appearing in many video games over a wide variety of many different consoles. Designed by Charles Zembillas of Insomniac Games, he is an energetic and somewhat cocky purple dragon with little regard for his own safety and a penchant for saving the day whenever the need should arise.

During the initial development cycle of the character, Spyro was actually to be colored green at first, but the problem with this was that developers became concerned that the character would blend in too much with the grass areas in the original game. So it was eventually decided that the character should be colored purple instead. The developers wanted the character to appeal to the 8-10 demographic, as a lot of the most popular video game characters at the time were mainly marketed to kids; Mario and Crash Bandicoot to name but a few. Spyro was designed to look cute, but at the same time, somewhat immature, with the added element of unpredictability to make the character exciting.

Amidst the low sales of their previous game Disruptor, the first Spyro the Dragon game was a do or die attempt from Insomniac Games against potential bankruptcy. But thankfully for them, the game was very well received upon release, garnishing aggregate scores of eights and nines out of ten from reviewers, and it also sold extremely well. So much so that a sequel was developed called Spyro 2: Ripto’s Rage; or as it is known in Europe, Gateway to Glimmer. It was also at this time when Spyro got the second of five different voice actors, Tom Kenny, who replaced the original voice actor for the character, Carlos Alazraqui. Once again, Insomniac Games managed to impress critics and players alike, going leaps and bounds ahead of its predecessor, and delivering improvements on an already excellent gaming formula. In a time when Sony were struggling to put out a decent 3D platforming game to compete with the many excellent games in the genre on the Nintendo 64, the original Spyro the Dragon trilogy was a monumental step in the right direction, having the right kind of movement controls implemented, as opposed to earlier PlayStation efforts, such as Blasto, Croc: Legend of the Gobbos and Bubsy 3D.

The third game in the trilogy, Spyro: Year of the Dragon, was even better received by critics, with the inclusion of multiple playable characters, and an extensive set of mini-games thrown in for good measure. But it would be the last game in the series developed by Insomniac. Their CEO, Ted Price, cited the reasons for doing so in an interview being that Spyro’s actions were limited, as the dragon could not hold anything with his hands, and therefore, the development team was out of options as to how they could further improve on variety in the gameplay of the series. As the development rights were passed around to such companies as Check Six Games, Equinoxe, and Traveller’s Tales, two more games in the series, Spyro: Enter the Dragonfly and Spyro: A Hero’s Tail, was released for consoles of the next generation such as the PlayStation 2, GameCube and Xbox, but were met with a considerably more negative reaction from critics, who cited that they were simply replica games and added nothing new to the table, highlighting the concerns voiced by Ted Price and Insomniac Games.

After the failure of the last two games, the developmental rights to Spyro the Dragon then fell to Krome Studios, who then attempted to revive the series with the Legend of Spyro trilogy, which spanned both the sixth and seventh generations of gaming. Interestingly, after Jess Harnell stepped down as Spyro’s voice actor, he was replaced by Elijah Wood of Lord of the Rings fame, who is an avid gamer himself, having dominated in gaming sessions of the Lord of the Rings games between himself and fellow Lord of the Rings cast member, Dominic Monaghan, Sean Aston, and Billy Boyd. However, the newly re-vamped Spyro the Dragon series was once again met with mixed reception from critics; the most well-received in the trilogy being the third game, Spyro: Dawn of the Dragon, which received aggregate scores of merely 50-60%. But in 2011, the franchise would be given a second reboot, and I believe no one in a million years could have predicted the outcome.

Video game developers Toys For Bob were given the option of reviving a single Vivendi Games franchise, and they plumped for Spyro the Dragon. At first, the CEO of Toys For Bob, Paul Reiche III, had low expectations for the outcome of their attempted reboot of Spyro, citing that previous attempts to revive long-running video game franchises in the past had not been met with the previously expected huge reception, and that reinventing the character to have a more realistic feel to him didn’t seem like a good idea. But for a number of years prior, Reiche III had been dabbling with the idea of integrating toys into video games and believed it was an idea so outlandish that it could possibly end up working in their favor.

Originally, Skylanders: Spyro’s Adventure was designed to be a much more mature game entitled Spyro’s Kingdom, with a much darker tone than in previous games in the series, even going so far as to include blood. But after enthusiasm for this idea was lost, they instead decided that their target audience should be children, as they would have next to no prior knowledge of the character of Spyro the Dragon, and of course, toys would appeal more to them than they would do to adults; indeed, I remember an instance when I was on a bus, and a child sitting in the seat in front of mine noticed I had two Skylanders figures in my bag, and asked me if they were for my children… I don’t have any children.

Skylanders: Spyro’s Adventure, was released in the summer of 2011, and whilst it didn’t receive greatly impressive reviews from critics, it, later on, became the third most profitable game in North America and Europe by the first quarter of 2012, even exceeding sales of the number one action figure line of the time; Star Wars. To date, over 30 million of the original Skylanders toys have been sold worldwide and have garnished profit of over $500 million in the US alone. The game has since generated into a hugely popular franchise, with additional merchandise being sold all around the world including books and different kinds of toys, and of course, has so far warranted the development of several sequels on most seventh and eighth generation consoles; Skylanders: Giants, Skylanders: Swap Force, Skylanders: Trap Team, Skylanders: Superchargers and the upcoming Skylanders: Imaginators. So thanks to an addictive gameplay concept and a stroke of marketing genius, Spyro the Dragon has come from facing a fall into video game obscurity to becoming an integral part of one of the most profitable and popular video game franchises of the modern-day. It all gives testament to me of what kind of overwhelming impact that the reinvention of a character can have on the video gaming industry, and how one development team’s loss can be the substantial gain of another.

Shooting Up My Ride: The Development History of Duke Nukem Forever

(Written as of 2014)

Duke Nukem Forever, though by in large a terrible game, is considered one of the most historical titles in the history of the business. Development started back in 1996 and the game was finally released in 2011 by a different development company. Back in earlier gaming generations, many people believed that if a game took a long time to be released, it was simply because the developers wanted to make it as well as they could. But there was a lot more than that going on behind the scenes during the development of Duke Nukem Forever.

The buzz surrounding the game all began during the late 90s, following the release and commercial and critical success of the third game in the series, Duke Nukem 3D. Made in the same vein as Doom and Wolfenstein, Duke Nukem quickly became one of the leading first-person shooting franchises, with Duke Nukem 3D being regarded ad one of the best games of all time, with a fourth game seemingly round the corner. For the longest time, many people believed the title Duke Nukem Forever referred to the development cycle, but the real joke slowly became lost on people, as the word forever was intended as a pun on the number 4, just as 3D was a pun on the number 3. But there was a huge array of factors that led to the development cycle being as long as it was.

Following the overwhelming success of Duke Nukem 3D back in 1997, consumer confidence was high for the sequel. The development company 3D Realms, formerly known as Apogee Software, first announced the game in April of the same year. The original plan was that it was to be released the following year; likely for the Nintendo 64, PC, and the original PlayStation.

The first derailment came in the form of an engine change. To develop Duke Nukem 3D, 3D Realms used an engine called the Build Engine, but they felt that it wasn’t enough for what they wanted to do with the fourth game. So they abandoned it in favor of the more powerful Quake II engine, which they had to license from one of their main competitors; id Software. Though development costs would already through the roof (3D Realms reputedly spending in excess of $500,000 to license the engine), the development team felt adamant about doing this as opposed to building a new engine from scratch. Believe it or not, they thought that doing so would save time. Another factor of this was that at this moment in time, the developers could afford such a fee. Duke Nukem Forever was being self-funded by the two creators of Duke Nukem; Scott Miller and George Broussard. Following overwhelming sales of the previous game, they felt very confident in the idea.

The first glimpse of Duke Nukem Forever was first published in an issue of PC Gamer Magazine, but screenshots were quickly revealed to be false, as 3D Realms hadn’t actually acquired the Quake II engine by the time the magazine went to print. Footage of the game was first shown at E3 in 1998 and got everyone excited about how well the game would play out, and how great it looked for the time. The problem was there were certain members of the development team who were unsatisfied with how development was progressing. The Quake II engine had issues with rendering wide open spaces in the game, in particular the open desert level. The choice was ultimately made to scrap the Quake II engine in favor of the even more advanced Unreal engine, which they licensed from Epic Games. But this meant the development team had to start from scratch. So everything was effectively thrown in the bin, and 3D Realms subsequently announced later in 1998 that Duke Nukem Forever would be “delayed significantly”, that it would take them up to half a year tops to get back to where they had been, and falsely stating that none of the content shown at E3 was lost.

The pressure was mounting by 1999 to come up with something, as development was not progressing according to plan. Broussard simply attributed their dilemma to that “Games are complicated” and reasoned that it inherently takes longer to released greater modern games than simpler older ones. But behind the scenes, Broussard was actually largely the cause of the problem by constantly forcing changes on the project. He observed new features coming out on different games in the meantime, and he would want to add a lot of these features to Duke Nukem Forever. It was said that by this point, the game simply became a collection of features as opposed to a fully cohesive concept. When the next trailer was shown at E3 in 2001, it was a success and got gamers extremely excited about the gameplay and features as well as its level of detail. So from the surface at least it looked like the game was on the right track, but unfortunately, it was a very different story behind the scenes.

GT Interactive, who had published Duke Nukem 3D was facing ongoing dilemmas, and eventually merged with Infogrames Entertainment, and the publishing rights to the Duke Nukem brand fell to a company called Gathering of Developers. But soon, they also faced struggles, including the tragic passing of co-founder Doug Myres and progressively deeper financial issues, and the company was finally absorbed into its parent company, Take-Two Interactive. Take-Two descended like vultures onto 3D Realms, calling shenanigans on the development of Duke Nukem Forever by citing factors such as there were merely 18 people developing the game. 3D Realms struck back by saying “they were financing the game on their own, they could do it however they wanted, and that it’ll get done when it’s done. Take-two responded by pointing out how 3D Realms issues were affecting their stock prices as well as the company itself. In an interview, Broussard controversially responded by telling Take-Two Interactive to “STFU”.

So under even further pressure, 3D Realms announced the estimation that the game would be released around mid-2004 or early 2005, amidst a rumor that they were now using the Doom 3 engine to develop the game. But when magazines started publishing the rumor as fact, Broussard came forward and finally said it wasn’t true. But no news was given until 2006 when 3D Realms claimed the game was more or less done, and the finishing touches were being put on it. But when it was next shown in a demo, it turned out to be in an obviously unfinished and unpolished state, resulting in Broussard profusely apologizing and acting frantic. In response, Take-Two Interactive re-negotiated payments to 3D-Realms, who would be receiving significantly less then before upon the game’s release, but offered a bonus of around $500,000 if they could get it out by late 2006. In response, Broussard clarified that the game would not be released by then, acting as if the expectation was ridiculous, despite the fact that the game had now been in development for over a decade. This prompted many of the staff to leave the project, hampering development considerably, since there were only 18 of them. Some reasoned that Duke Nukem Forever was the only game they’d worked on in all that time, and their CVs rendered unimpressive as a result.

However, Broussard ignored the problem and began to hire a lot of new staff, who were all actually surprised at how close the game was to being finished. Founder of HELM Studios, Raphael Van Lierop was a new hire at the time, and he was quoted as saying that if they could get the game out in a matter of months, then people would be blown away by it. But once again, Broussard dismissed the idea and claimed that the game was at least two years away from completion. It was at this point that Broussard’s previously silent partner, Scott Miller, came out and said that something had to happen as soon as possible. In 2007, screenshots were revealed confirmed to be screenshots of gameplay, and more people were hired, including a new project leader able to assert himself against Broussard’s constant demand for change.

A new trailer was also shown later on that year, but rumors of the game being released the following year were once again shot down by Broussard, who reverted to “when it’s done”. Once more, the game failed to make an appearance at E3 in 2008, which Scott Miller disregarded since he considered E3, the biggest video gaming event of the calendar year, to be irrelevant.

Following this, 3D Realms claimed the game was almost done, and they needed another $6,000,000 from Take-Two Interactive, as the company had finally run out of money to fund the game themselves. Take-Two responded by saying they would give them $5,000,000; half immediately and half upon completion. But Broussard unbelievably rejected the offer, and as a result, the staff at 3D Realms was dismissed and development on the game came to a halt, with Take-Two Interactive claiming that they would not fund the game. Take-Two subsequently sued 3D Realms, claiming they had spent $12,000,000 on a game that would never be released. 3D Realms countered by claiming that they never said the game wasn’t going to be released, and that because the staff had been laid off didn’t mean people weren’t still working on it. At about the same time the court case was settled, screenshots and concept art was also unceremoniously leaked out onto the Internet.

However, it turned out that 3D Realms were somewhat correct, since whilst people weren’t officially working on the game, people were in fact working on it. Several employees who had been laid off actually continued to work on the game at home, forming their own company named Triptych Games, eventually finishing it. It was at this point that 3D Realms contacted a different development company Gearbox Software, telling them that people they’d laid off had finished Duke Nukem Forever, and asked if they would help them. It turned out that Randy Pitchford, the CEO of Gearbox Software, was a big Duke Nukem fan and wanted to see the series revived.

So Pitchford subsequently contacted 2K Games and convinced them that he would be able to attain the funding required to port the game to both the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3. So the developmental rights fell to Gearbox Software, and the publishing rights fell to 2K Games, and the game was shown in a fully playable form for the very first time at the Penny Arcade Expo in 2010, and a release date was subsequently announced; May 3rd, 2011. There was more delay, as the game wound up being released on Jund 14th of the same year, but Duke Nukem Forever, after so many setbacks throughout a developmental period of 15 years, finally saw the light of day. And though it didn’t sit at all well with fans, it turned out to yield a profit for Gearbox Software, and Pitchford has since even expressed an interest in creating a fifth game in the series. Here’s hoping that if the project is greenlit, it doesn’t take anywhere near as long as Duke Nukem Forever did.

Running Spikes: The Origins of Sonic the Hedgehog

(Written as of 2014)

During the latter years of the third generation of gaming, when Sega’s Master System console was competing against Nintendo’s NES, Sega was at that time looking to create a flagship series in order to compete with Nintendo’s Super Mario series, which was quickly becoming a global phenomenon. They also wanted to create their own mascot to replace their then-unofficial mascot, Alex Kidd. Sega’s AM8 Research and Development Department came up with numerous character designs; mostly in the form of anthropomorphic animals, such as a dog, a rabbit, and an armadillo, which would later inspire the creation of the character Mighty the Armadillo. They also considered a Theodore Roosevelt look-alike, which would also become the inspiration behind the inception of Sonic’s primary antagonist, Dr. Eggman.

Eventually, Sega employee, Naoto Oshima, created a spiky teal hedgehog, which initially was codenamed Mr. Needlemouse; but later renamed Sonic, and subsequently chosen as Sega’s mascot. Sonic was colored blue to match the color of Sega’s logo, and the design of his shoes was inspired by a combination of both Santa Clause and a design inspired by a pair of boots worn by prominent pop artist at the time, Michael Jackson; who interestingly, would go on to be the initial composer for Sonic the Hedgehog 3. And finally, Sonic’s personality was also inspired by Bill Clinton’s “get it done” attitude. Ironically, Sonic’s first video game appearance was not as a playable character. He first appeared in an arcade racing game called Rad Mobile, as the air freshener of one of the cars.

However, the origins of the character can be traced even further back than that. Another long-running Sega employee, Yuji Naka, had created a tech demo, containing a gaming algorithm, which allowed an in-game character to move smoothly on curves around a video game level. Naka’s tech demo would then evolve into a game requiring the character to move fast and roll into a ball in order to traverse long winding tubes. It was then that both Yuji Naka and Naoto Oshima decided to put both their creations together, and thus the concept of the first Sonic the Hedgehog game was born, with Hirokazu Yasuhara brought on board to head level design.

Sonic was also given the inability to swim based on Yuji Naka’s assumption that not all hedgehogs could do this; although Sonic would be able to traverse through the water in later games in the series. The development of the first Sonic the Hedgehog game consisted of a mere fifteen people, who renamed themselves as Sonic Team, and Masato Nakamura of the band Dreams Come True was brought on board to compose the game’s soundtrack. As thanks, Sega then subsequently sponsored the band’s Wonder 3 tour and even painted Sonic the Hedgehog on their tour bus. Dreams Come True also advertised the game by giving out pamphlets, and showed footage of the game at their live shows.

Sonic’s original conceptual design included the character having fangs, as well as his inclusion in a band featuring his human girlfriend named Madonna. Unhappy with this, Madeleine Schroeder, self-proclaimed as “Sonic’s mother”, led a team from Sega of America in a bid to remove these elements, and thus soften the character up, making him more marketable to kids upon the game’s American release. At the time, it sparked a heated debate between both Sega of America and Sonic Team, but Yuji Naka would later go on to admit that these changes were for the best.

But ever since, Sonic the Hedgehog has gone to appear in 33 major titles, as well as a library of spin-off games, and still remains Sega’s mascot character to this day. Although many consider the series to have been long phased out and be much less artistically credible than many other video game series’ of comparable longevity, the franchise has garnished a cult following over the last 30 years.

Pretty as a Pixel: The History of Cel-Shading in Video Games

(Written as of 2014)

Cel-shading, or toon shading as it’s alternatively called, is a non-photorealistic rendering technique used to make 3D computer graphics appear flat; most commonly used to imitate the visual style of a comic or cartoon. Becoming more commonly used in animation in the early 2000s, the world cel is an abbreviation of the word celluloid. Cels are clear sheets of acetate, painted on for use in traditional 2D animation.

First creating a black-ink outline of the animator’s desired shape, then having the shape subsequently drawn with a basic texture, and lastly adding the shading effect typically creates the effect of cel-shading.

The first video game to incorporate the use of real-time cel-shaded visuals was Jet Set Radio for the Dreamcast, released back in 2000. The game garnished a lot of press attention for implementing this unique visual style, when Sega, at the Tokyo Game Show of 1999, first unveiled it. The game was a critical success upon release, winning three major gaming awards. It won an E3 Gamer Critics Award for the best console game in 2000, a Game Developers Choice Award for excellence in visual arts and game innovation spotlights in 2001, and in the same year also won an Annual Interactive Achievement Award.

Jet Set Radio was so influential that many upcoming game developers began to use the cel-shading technique in their games as well as a number of developers implementing it for more long-running franchises, such as Bomberman and Harvest Moon. The next notable releases to use the same technique were of course a sequel to Jet Set Radio entitled Jet Set Radio Future and Sly Cooper & the Thievius Raccoonus, which were released to moderate critical success. But from there, however, the technique would prove to be even more popular. A lot of other titles were released for multiple systems over the coming years, including Dark Chronicle, Cel Damage, XIII, and the Viewtiful Joe series. But for all the critical acclaim that these games were met with at the time of their release, sales figures were less than impressive. That is until Nintendo took a gamble by taking this new visual technique and incorporating it into one of their longest-running franchises.

The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker was released in 2003 for the Nintendo GameCube, and had a visual style rendered by using the cel-shading technique. At first, it was met with a particularly cold reception, which divided both game critics and fans of the series. A lot of people saw this style of graphics as an example of vivid artistry whilst others stated that the game lacked a sense of newness compared with the previous big-name entry in the series, The Ocarina of Time when that was first released. Many fans of the series saw the implementation of cel-shaded visuals as a step down from the more realistic look that came with its Nintendo 64 predecessor. However, the game was more importantly praised for having similar gameplay to Ocarina of Time and its heightened sense of freedom coming with players having a much bigger world to explore and a greater amount of side quests. Famitsu gave the game a perfect score (only the fourth game out of twenty-two to achieve this honor throughout the publication’s history) and Nintendo Power also ranked The Wind Waker 2nd only behind Resident Evil 4 in their list of best GameCube games of all time. IGN even advised gamers to forget about the fact that Wind Waker looks so dissimilar to Ocarina of Time and simply concentrate on the great gameplay. Nintendo has adopted cel-shading in the development of almost every single main entry in the Legend of Zelda series. Interestingly, the only main Zelda game not to have cel-shaded visuals since Wind Waker has been Twilight Princess.

The release of games like The Wind Waker and Viewtiful Joe would also prompt a huge influx of games using cel-shaded graphics in the next three years. 2005 in particular saw the highest number of games with this style of visuals released in a single year to date. By that time, developers found that licensed games could also be made using this method, as a lot of licensed games released were based on cartoons and what better way is there to make games based on cartoons than to use toon shaded visuals? 2005 saw the release of several licensed games, which would garnish both critical and commercial success, such as the Dragonball Z Budokai Tenkaichi series. But I think the most significant success story to emerge concerned the Dragon Quest franchise. For many years, Dragon Quest had been one of the most successful video game franchises in Japan and still remains so to this day. But Enix had had less of an impact on the rest of the world with Dragon Quest, having initially had to release the game in North America as Dragon Warrior so as to avoid trademark conflict with the pen-and-paper role-playing game of the same name; Dragon Quest. Following the bankruptcy of the company who published the pen-and-paper game, Enix (who were Square Enix by that time) finally registered the Dragon Quest trademark in America and released Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King, which used cel-shaded visuals and was the first Dragon Quest game to find both a great amount of critical and commercial success outside of Japan, with the game being praised particularly well in both America and Europe; it also remains to this day as the biggest selling PlayStation 2 game in Japan.

The influx of cel-shaded games would also continue throughout the late 2000s, with critically successful games like Okami, Crackdown, No More Heroes, Super Paper Mario, Team Fortress 2, Zak & Wiki, Afro Samurai and a direct sequel to Wind Waker released for the DS called The Phantom Hourglass. And the library of licensed games developed with cel-shaded visuals continued to grow with games based on big-name franchises such as Family Guy and The Simpsons. However, 2009 proved to be extremely significant, as another amazing cel-shaded game was to be released and take the gaming world by storm.

In 2007, Gearbox Software gave the public their first glimpse of a game they were working on called Borderlands. As with many science fiction-based first-person shooters, the game actually first adopted a more realistic look in contrast to what it would eventually become. At 2K Games’ E3 press conference in 2008, a brief demo of Borderlands was shown, but the game subsequently disappeared from public view. This prompted people to believe that Gearbox had maybe scrapped the project and that it would never have a release date attached to it. However, this was to be far from the case, as, in the early quarter of 2009, Borderlands re-surfaced again, but with a radically changed visual style rendered by using cel-shading techniques. It was cited by Gearbox themselves as being a huge gamble since it involved scrapping a lot of expensive work prior to this sudden change.

The game was released in the fourth quarter of 2009 and was met with overwhelming success. The game became a surprise hit in terms of both sales and reception, with some analysts comparing its release to that of BioShock, which also surprised a lot of people with how good a game it was. Since release, the original Borderlands has sold over 4.5 million units worldwide, received several game of the year awards, and having a game of the year edition released the following year with the four additional DLC packages along with it; The Zombie Island of Dr. Ned, Mad Moxxi’s Underdome Riot, The Secret Armoury of General Knoxx and Claptrap’s New Robot Revolution. A sequel was also released back in 2012 and had similarly great success, several DLC packages released for it and a game of the year edition released in late 2013. Borderlands has since become a fairly big franchise in itself, seeing the release of comic strips, novels, and even toys of characters in the series.

Since 2009, cel-shaded visuals continue to be a huge trope used in video games. Many notable games to use cel-shaded visuals since Borderlands include a re-vamp of the classic Nintendo arcade game Punch-Out for the Wii, sequels to both Crackdown and No More Heroes, a sequel to the Zelda game Phantom Hourglass called Spirit Tracks, Catherine, The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword, Killer is Dead; even renowned Japanese film studio, Studio Ghibli, assisted Level-5 Studios in the development of a cel-shaded RPG called Ni No Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch.

All this just goes to show how far cel-shaded visuals have come in the world of gaming over the best part of twenty years. In my opinion, graphic styles like cel-shading are great ways to tell gamers that at the end of the day, games don’t have to look as realistic as possible for them to be any more enjoyable than others, as many people may think. Having specific styles can add artistic merit to games as well as make them stand out among others. Personally, I find that as long as a game has excellent gameplay and plenty to do in it, it doesn’t really matter if the game’s graphics don’t push the boundaries of a console’s graphical capabilities. The overwhelming popularity of cel-shaded visuals clearly gives testament to this, and I hope that tropes like cel-shading will continue to be used in future games to serve as this valuable reminder to gamers that realistic looks aren’t everything.