Tag Archives: Nintendo

Pikmin (GameCube & Wii)

Pikmin

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Shigefumi Hino & Masamichi Abe

Producer – Shigeru Miyamoto

PEGI – 3

Released as a launch title for the GameCube, heavily based on the Super Mario 128 tech demo showcased shortly before the launch of the console, Pikmin is the only first-party Nintendo series falling under the genre of real-time strategy and introduced an entirely new mythos, cast of characters, and basic gameplay premise. It would turn out to be yet another successful series for Nintendo and develop a pretty loyal fan base, and I think the developers did a fairly good job of introducing gamers to the series with the first installment.

Graphics – 9/10

On a technical level, this game is nothing short of brilliant. It was inspired by the aforementioned early tech demo, which displayed 128 Mario sprites running around and performing various actions. Several separate character sprites with AI were not possible on the Nintendo 64 and were, at the time, considered a huge deal and a major technical breakthrough in gaming. But aside from that, there is also some extremely interesting conceptual design in the form of not only the Pikmin themselves but also in the form of the various different environments and enemies, hints of which would also find their way into other GameCube games, such as Wario World.

Gameplay – 6/10

The concept of the game’s play was extremely well thought out and is particularly enjoyable to indulge in, as well as satisfying to be able to excel in. The reason I have issues with it is very much the same issues I had with Majora’s Mask. The time limit. Each in-game day equates to about half an hour. Gamers have 30 days to collect as much as possible. This can make gamers feel like they are being needlessly rushed, in my opinion. With a world this big and full of things to do, it’s better if players are given the option to take their time to enjoy every ounce of it. And complete as much as possible, and I think Nintendo realized that whilst making the sequels.

Controls – 10/10

Whilst there aren’t really any technical issues with the game’s control scheme, at the time, it was also astonishing to think that so many different characters containing such textural details could all be controlled and moved around at the same time in the fashion that is presented. To me, it was amazing enough that the same could be accomplished in a conventional real-time strategy game on PC. But at the time, this game seemed to take that idea to a whole new level.

Lifespan – 6/10

Taking the time limits into consideration, it is fairly impressive that this game can be made to last for almost 20 hours. And consequently, I don’t think the game should lose many marks in this category. But as the sequels would highlight, there was potential to make a game like this last considerably longer. And so in this respect, the first game can be seen as a question of trial and error.

Storyline – 8/10

Of course, with a new mythology and set of characters came a new story premise from Nintendo. And they certainly didn’t disappoint. The narrative follows a space-faring extraterrestrial named Captain Olimar. He crash-lands on a mysterious planet after a meteorite hits his ship. He realizes the planet has high levels of oxygen. A gas deadly to his species. He will die within the next 30 days if he can’t find a way to repair his ship and escape the planet.

To do this, he employs the help of the Pikmin. The planet’s strange native species that Olimar must use to gather parts of his ship and protect himself from other hostile wildlife. What I like about the plot is that it seems to be slightly darker than most other Nintendo games, having a fairly morbid premise. And pushing the boundaries of what they were able to get away with on a 3+ rating. And behind a colorful and vibrant visual style.

Originality –10/10

Of course, Pikmin wasn’t the first real-time strategy developed, nor the last. But the fact of the matter remains that there is no other game of its kind like it. Differentiating from not only every other series of real-time strategy series but from every other video game in general. The only video games even remotely like Pikmin are Overlord and Overlord II. And whilst they both have their own unusual traits, they aren’t even anywhere near as wonderfully unusual as in the games they drew inspiration from.

Happii

To summarize, whilst the formula would be improved with the arrival of both the second and third games, Pikmin was nonetheless an extremely enjoyable launch title and was a strong title for Nintendo to start the sixth generation with. Alongside Luigi’s Mansion and Super Smash Bros Melee. I’ve played many real-time strategy games throughout the years, but those in the Pikmin series stand out among the best in my opinion.

Score

49/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Operation WinBack (Nintendo 64 & PlayStation 2)

Operation Winback

Developer(s) – Omega Force

Publisher(s) – Koei

ELSPA – 11+

Operation WinBack, or WinBack: Covert Operations, as it was known in America, was a late Nintendo 64 title. And an early PlayStation 2 title, ported to the following generation console. Most likely due to the unprecedented amount of critical acclaim it received at the time. I do have to say, as a prerequisite, that I spent a lot of time playing this game during the early years of the PlayStation 2’s shelf life. But as fairly good as it still is, and how influential it would later prove to be, I don’t think it entirely holds up to this day.

Graphics – 6/10

The best thing I can point out about this game’s visuals is how good it looked from a graphical standpoint at the time. On both the Nintendo 64 and PlayStation 2. It looked far better than most other games of its kind on the original PlayStation. And then its subsequent PlayStation 2 port did a pretty good job of showcasing what the console was capable of in its early stages. However, what I can’t wax poetic about is the conceptual design. It looks pretty generic. It was heavily influenced by the original Metal Gear Solid game. And I think the resemblances are plain to see.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

One of the better third-person shooters released at the dawn of the genre, WinBack’s cover system was revolutionary. And made playing the game that much easier to cope with than other future releases, such as Second Sight. Although the running and gunning aspect of this game is fairly addictive, there’s not much else the game has to offer in terms of gameplay. No side quests or collectible items throughout. The only objective is to play through as fast as possible to get the best ending. The fact that the players are encouraged to rush through the game is very foreboding in itself.

Controls – 9.5/10

The movement mechanics are a little bit stiff, but otherwise, there are no problems. It’s actually quite interesting to see how well the developers handled this early attempt at a third-person shooter compared with many other future releases. Not only was the cover system revolutionary. But the manual aiming system that players could use would go on to influence a variety of different games. Though the original Metal Gear Solid influenced the visual style of WinBack, there were these gameplay mechanics that would go on to in turn influence the development of Metal Gear Solid 2.

Lifespan – 4/10

When rushed through, the game can take about 5 hours to finish. Considering this is a game influenced by the original Metal Gear Solid, it is unacceptable. It was bad enough finding out that there was no way in which to save the other members of the S.C.A.T team (indeed, that’s what I thought the purpose of having their stats on the pause menu might have been for. Though in reality, it has no bearing on the gameplay at all, which makes me question the reason for having them there in the first place. But the fact that there are no other activities in the game other than to run and gun when there could have easily been something else added to it, is very disappointing in my opinion.

Storyline – 5/10

The narrative follows the main character, Jean-Luc Cougar, and the S.C.A.T team during their efforts to take back a powerful government weapon. From a terrorist group called the Crying Lions. Not only is the plot extremely influenced by and reminiscent of the first Metal Gear Solid. But the voice acting is also extremely below-par. There was the use of spoken dialogue in the Nintendo 64 version. Which, in hindsight, is preferable to having to listen to the half-hearted efforts of the voice actors in the PlayStation 2 version.

Originality – 7/10

Despite the fact that there isn’t a great deal of originality in terms of the overall gameplay formula. This will leave players thinking that so much more could have been added to give them a lot more to play for throughout. The fact of the matter remains that the control scheme not only went on to influence Metal Gear Solid. But also some of the more successful future titles in the third-person shooting genre. Such as Kill Switch, Second Sight, and Gears of War. The fact that this game served as an early prototype for some of the most successful game series in history. As well as being a prototype for many other games in the early stages of the genre, it makes it stand out a fair bit.

Niiutral

Overall, Operation WinBack’s running and gunning mechanics can be fairly addictive for how short the game lasts. But I do think the game is wanting in content. I can’t help but feel that with either better voice actors or no voice actors at all. As well as a good few side quests are thrown in for good measure, this game could have stood out even more among early PlayStation 2 titles than it ended up doing. But sadly, this wasn’t the case.

Score

37/60

6/10 (Average)

No More Heroes (Wii, PS3 & Switch)

No More Heroes

Developer(s) – Grasshopper Manufacture

Publisher(s) – Marvellous Entertainment, Ubisoft & Rising Star Games

Designer – Goichi Suda

PEGI – 16

Developed as a social commentary to a certain extent, and tame by Suda51’s standards, though still pretty violent, No More Heroes is a hack-and-slash semi-open world game. Many critics and fans of the game regarded it as being one of the better third-party video games on the Wii. Whilst I personally think that’s true. And I did spend a lot of time playing this game at that point; I did have a few issues with it.

Graphics – 8/10

Making use of cel-shaded visuals popularised by many games released on Nintendo’s previous console, the GameCube, No More Heroes takes place in an open world somewhat reminiscent of Vice City called Santa Destroy. Although the setting doesn’t stand out among many other games, the many different characters certainly do. With opponents such as Bad Girl, Destroyman, Holly Summers, and Dr. Peace. In conjunction with the comic book-like art style, the characters are very reminiscent of either classic heroes or classic villains throughout comic book history. But they all have a twisted sense of uniqueness about them.

Gameplay – 7/10

I think the best way to describe this game is what would happen if Grand Theft Auto met God of War. The game thrives on intensity and violence. And at times, context-sensitive combat, with a fair amount of challenging boss fights thrown in for good measure. But at the same time, exploration is encouraged to a degree, with side quests available to players. They must complete in order to advance to each subsequent stage of the game. I did find it quite satisfying to play through. But for the size of the in-game world, I felt as if more could have been added to fill a lot of dead space.

Controls – 8/10

At this point, the Wii was a relatively new console and early into its shelf life. So motion controls will still have been a question of trial and error to a certain extent. However, there are a select few fundamentals that this game didn’t get right. The bike riding mechanics, for example, are pretty difficult to get the hang of. And even when the basics of it are mastered, a lot of time will still be spent crashing into cars and walls. Aside from that, the remote and nunchucks can also prove to be unresponsive at times during context-sensitive combat sequences. Otherwise, there are no other issues to address, and basic combat is handled quite well.

Lifespan – 6/10

To complete the game to 100% the first time around, players can generally spend about 20 to 25 hours doing it. Which, whilst not unforgivable, is still a little bit underwhelming for a game of its size and potential. There is replay value to be had since there is an extended ending to unlock after completing the game on hard mode. But that also makes it inaccessible to a certain extent. Now every gamer will be comfortable with taking on playing the game at a greater difficulty in order to unlock something offering no real incentive.

Storyline – 8/10

The story of No More Heroes follows a stereotypical otaku named Travis Touchdown. For purposes unknown to the gamer for the longest time, he is competing within the United Assassins’ Association to become their foremost-ranked assassin. The story does unfold into something much more interesting. And more convoluted than it seems at first glance, I think it’s marred down severely by Travis’s persona. I think he is one of the most annoying video game protagonists of all time. His persona gradually changes for the better in the second game. But throughout the first installment, I couldn’t help but get a sense of dramatic irony. Travis is being manipulated to suit somebody else’s needs. And the fact that he couldn’t seem to realize it sooner was cringeworthy in my opinion.

Originality – 7/10

Though there had been a fair few games made in the same vein before this effort, I do have a fair bit of respect for Goichi Suda’s ability to come up with many different and twisted concepts and designs for his video games. And this is no exception. In terms of gameplay, I have criticized a few of his efforts. such as Killer is Dead and Shadows of the Damned. But what they’ve all had in common is that they have had no problem standing out among other video games in terms of visual presentation.

Happii

Overall, No More Heroes is indeed one of the better third-party experiences on the Wii despite its faults. And I would recommend it to anyone who may be in the mindset that the console is solely for playing party games. Though the second game would make some drastic improvements, that’s not to discount the first by any stretch of the imagination.

Score

46/60

7.5/10 (Good)

New Super Mario Bros 2 (3DS)

New Super Mario Bros 2

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Group No 4

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Yusuke Amano

Producer(s) – Takashi Tezuka & Hiroyuki Kimura

PEGI – 3

A direct sequel to the well-received DS revival of the classic 2D side-scrolling formula of the series, New Super Mario Bros 2 was described by Satoru Iwata as being a “completely new side-scrolling action Super Mario in 2D as a key title for the Nintendo 3DS”. To me, however, whilst it was a fairly decent game in its own right, it doesn’t have the kind of innovation in gameplay, as Iwata seemed to imply that it did.

Graphics – 7/10

Where this game impresses most in terms of visual presentation is from a technical standpoint, in my opinion. It is certainly one of the better-looking titles on the system in this respect, and I think compared with other portable Mario games, there is a lot more textural detail. Mostly made evident by the many objects and elements made out of gold, which go along with the entire tableau of the game. It does suffer somewhat from a conceptual standpoint, however. Since many of the different themes of the individual world had been seen not only in the original New Super Mario Bros but also in New Super Mario Bros Wii before it.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

Playing out like most other classic Super Mario games, it follows the same 2D side-scrolling formula that Nintendo built upon vastly with the creation of the original NES classic. The difference is that in this game, coin-collecting has a slightly greater bearing on gameplay than in most other titles in the series. The problem is that it doesn’t have as much bearing as players would most probably have expected before playing, and the reward for collecting one million coins is nothing more glorious than a new title screen. Nonetheless, it plays out as well as any other 2D side-scrolling Mario game. And there’s not much wrong with that.

Controls – 10/10

Nintendo not only reinvented the overall idea of what a good 2D side scroller should be, but also for the better. But they also fine-tuned the control scheme of any typical game of its kind. Making it much easier to cope with than in other 2D side scrollers prior. Therefore, there should have been no problems with the controls of this installment, and there are not. I’ve always found the tiny Mario a little bit hard to cope with, but that’s semantics.

Lifespan – 7/10

With a lifespan of around 15 to 20 hours, depending on how many coins the players wish to end up collecting, it may not be the longest experience ever developed. But it still exceeds the average lifespan of most other 2D side scrollers. From the third and fourth generations of gaming or otherwise. I don’t begrudge games like this lasting that long, since they can seem linear. Especially these days. Since the formula has been repeated time and again, they still make for exceptionally fulfilling experiences if done right.

Storyline – 4/10

Once again, Mario is pitted against Bowser to save his constant damsel in distress, Princess Peach. This concept has been exhausted since even the later days of the NES. And it is, in my opinion, one of the most beaten dead horses in video game history; if not, the most. These days, it can be automatically assumed that people don’t play Super Mario Bros for the plot. Except for a few standout games, like most games in the Super Mario RPG series, for example.

Originality – 4/10

Although it is always entertaining to pick up a new Super Mario Bros game, they aren’t always kept as fresh as most gamers would probably like them to be. New Super Mario Bros 2 is literally a shining example of this with all the gold riddled across it. Another huge gripe I have about this game is the exceptionally poor quality of the majority of boss fights. Most of which are increasingly harder variations of the four rotating rhino bosses first found in Super Mario World. The Super Mario series has never been particularly renowned for its boss fights anyway. But this takes the cake.

Niiutral

Overall, despite its many different faults, New Mario Bros 2 may be one of the worst entries in the series, in my opinion. But that isn’t to say it’s a terrible game; just a very unoriginal and repetitious one. Nintendo has gone on to make a few more varied and unique games in the series. But this isn’t one of their most standout efforts, unfortunately.

Score

39/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Mortal Kombat II (Various Platforms)

Mortal Kombat II

Developer(s) – Midway Games, Probe Entertainment & Sculptured Software

Publisher(s) – Midway Games & Acclaim Entertainment

Designer(s) – Ed Boon & John Tobias

Producer(s) – Ken Fedesna & Neil Nicastro

PEGI – 18

One of the first examples of a video game appearing on prime-time news across America, Mortal Kombat II gained media attention for its use of excessive violence compared to other video games at the time. But it was also met with a high level of critical and commercial acclaim. In my opinion, it was certainly a positive departure from the first game and a massive improvement to it.

Graphics – 9/10

One of the main improvements made to the series with the release of Mortal Kombat II was that, since the developers weren’t pressed for time, they added a plethora of new characters to the roster, such as Kitana, Mileena, Baraka, Noob Saibot, Smoke, and Kung Lao, to name but a few. People will argue that this was the point at which the developers got out of hand, using palette swapping to create new characters, but I think the point where they got truly out of hand with that was with Ultimate Mortal Kombat III, when not only new characters were made with this technique, but more or less every other previous character had been added to the roster as well.

Gameplay – 7/10

The core gameplay concept of Mortal Kombat II remains largely the same as in the first installment, but it was made a lot more diverse with the second, since the multitude of different characters also provided players with a lot more variety in terms of not only fatalities but also different character abilities. Indeed, having Shang Tsung as a playable helped a lot in this respect. As well as introducing such characters as Jax and Kung Lao.

Controls – 7/10

Before Street Fighter II came along and properly introduced fans of the fighting game genre to the concept of pulling off combos, things started relatively primitively. Especially given how poor the original Street Fighter was. Fighting games relied on combining attacks in a much more spaced-out and precise manner than combo systems of today, which in fact started as a glitch. And it was all fairly well handled in Mortal Kombat II.

Originality – 8/10

Since its inception, the Mortal Kombat franchise has been particularly unique for many different factors. Such as its core story concept and selection of characters. But the second game took all that to the next level, so to speak. Introducing not only different characters, but also the different directions in which the story went at the time, or where it would go in the future. Ever since, there have been spin-off films and TV series of the game. And I think the second installment proved to be a huge step in making a lot of all that happens.

Happii

Overall, Mortal Kombat II, though not the perfect fighting game by any stretch of the imagination, was a massive improvement over the first. And one of the more standout games of the time. It would have inevitably been difficult for a fighting game to hold up after the release of Street Fighter II. But Mortal Kombat II did that very well.

Score

31/40

7.5/10 (Good)

Menace Beach (Nintendo Entertainment System)

Menace Beach

Developer(s) – Color Dreams

Publisher(s) – Color Dreams & Hacker International

Programmer – Vance Kozik

Rating – N/A

Like many games of its kind, the most interesting thing about this game is its history. Back in the days of the NES, Nintendo included the 10-NES lockout chip inside the console to prevent developers from releasing unlicensed games for it. Regardless, there were several unlicensed games released for the NES. As development companies found a way of circumventing the 10-NES chip. Perhaps the company that did this more than any other was Color Dreams. Amongst their NES repertoire was Menace Beach.

One of their most well-known games is known for its level of violence and mature content. But when Nintendo threatened to stop doing business with retailers who carried unlicensed NES games, Color Dreams renamed itself Wisdom Tree. And then took to re-developing their games and selling them in Christian bookstores instead. Menace Beach was redeveloped and renamed Sunday Funday, and toned down considerably. Though there was a strong level of violence. But in my opinion, Menace Beach stands out more as being one of the first genuinely mature games on the NES.

Graphics – 7/10

The visuals are, by some distance, the best element that I can attribute to this game. Since they were fairly advanced for the time. For example, the characters have black outlines for the most part, which effectively separates them from the scenery. Which though may have been pioneered by Capcom with the Mega Man series, it still makes the game stand out somewhat from many others. There is also an unprecedented amount of variety in level design. As the last level, in particular, is set in Hell, and the last boss is a demon.

Gameplay – 5.5/10

As for the gameplay, however, I found it extremely typical for what was being released for the NES at the time. As well as being typical of the type of game that Color Dreams would release back then. It’s a 2D side scroller, whereby the player must simply get from A to B without dying. And even then, there’s not a great amount of variety in it compared with many other Nintendo-licensed titles. Such as Mario or Zelda. Plus, the fact that the main character rides around on a skateboard doesn’t have as much bearing on gameplay. As it might sound as if the idea was presented on paper.

Controls – 10/10

I am happy, however, to say that there aren’t any issues with the game’s control scheme. Which, at the time, at least, did seem fairly difficult for developers to execute. Many 2D platformers had some issues with controls, such as Castlevania and Mega Man. Though riding on a skateboard doesn’t really make any kind of difference, the point is that the formula was done as well as it could have been. And the game is due credit for that, at least.

Lifespan – 6/10

Menace Beach can be made to last for just under half an hour. Which was about the average lifespan for an NES game. Though it doesn’t last any longer than a game like Super Mario Bros or Mega Man, there’s nothing in gameplay that would suggest to me that it would or could be made to last any longer without players becoming bored with it, so to me, it’s just as well that it lasted as long as it did.

Storyline – 5.5/10

Also adding to the game’s typicality is its storyline. The main character is an unnamed skateboarder who must rescue his girlfriend Bunny, who has been kidnapped by a gang led by a villain called Demon Dan. The standout story element is the series of cutscenes played in between each level, whereby Bunny is tied to a table demeaning her boyfriend for not rescuing her faster, whilst her clothes are gradually falling off until she is left in her underwear. I think the inclusion of that element, similar to Killer is Dead, which I reviewed earlier this year, was a particularly cheap way to get players to continue with it, and can only be seen nowadays as being much less believable, since Menace has long since been graphically outdated.

Originality – 4/10

Although this game stands out for how violent it is for the time, as well as including other mature elements and fairly advanced graphics, there’s not much else to distinguish it from others. It is a very typical NES game, which has the misfortune of not having the official Nintendo seal of quality.

Niiutral

Overall, I think Menace Beach is worth one playthrough, but not really worth bothering with for an extended amount of time. Though Color Dreams did release quite a few 2D platformers for the NES, none of them really stand out in terms of gameplay to any great extent, and Menace Beach is no different.

Score

37.5/60

6/10 (Average)

Mega Man (Nintendo Entertainment System)

Mega Man

Developer(s) – Capcom

Publisher(s) – Capcom

Director – Akira Kitamura

Designer – Akira Kitamura

PEGI – 7

Before I played Mega Man for the first time, I had a pretty decent idea of what I would be getting. But I wasn’t prepared for its relentless level of difficulty. For how innovative and groundbreaking it was for the time, I couldn’t help but think that like the original Castlevania, it would’ve done better if it had appealed to the more casual gamer. As well as gamers looking for a challenge. But regardless, this game had become a cult classic, and I decided to judge for myself.

Graphics – 9/10

The visuals not only hold up in comparison to indie 8-bit games developed today. But for the time, they were revolutionary. The most notable technique Capcom used was to give the character sprites black outlines. Which was something rarely seen on the NES prior. A problem with the original Nintendo was that it had a limited color palette. And game developers had to compromise accordingly; but with Mega Man, Capcom simply realized that colors could be made much more distinctive from one another. By merely separating them with thin lines of black between the scenery and the character sprites. And it worked flawlessly. Not only that, but the diversity in level design was also top-notch. The game takes place in locations like futuristic laboratories and vast, rocky canyons.

Gameplay – 5/10

This aspect is where the game posthumously fell short on in my opinion. My feelings towards it are too mixed. On one hand, this game incorporates so many innovations that would go on to become industry standards. Such as non-linearity, giving players the choice of which order they complete levels in. And variety in the array of different abilities that the player can acquire throughout the course of the game. But on the other hand, the game is notoriously hard. And for the most part, I just felt marred by its level of difficulty. It’s because of that, I found it too hard to enjoy. And in turn, hurts its replayability overall. I think part of the problem has to do with that back in the time of its release, video gaming was a much more casual interest in America and Europe than it was in Japan.

And the Western world wasn’t used to such challenges in video games. But there were a few of these games, like Mega Man and Castlevania, that were met with decent reception. And so they worked for many players, but not for all. This is part of the reason why Nintendo was apprehensive about releasing the original Super Mario Bros 2 in the Western world. So they took another game they previously developed called Doki Doki Panic. And re-imagined that game as our version of Super Mario Bros 2. And the original Japanese take was re-released as part of Super Mario All-Stars. Where it was called Super Mario Bros: The Lost Levels. Although there is much more to the story than that, the fact of the matter remains that Mega Man was just far too hard for me to enjoy overall.

Controls – 9/10

Like Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze, I did sometimes find the controls to be somewhat unresponsive. Which made it hard to time jumps properly and not fall from platforms and lose lives. However, for the most part, it is down to the player’s own individual skill. And my advice to anyone looking to try this game out is to be prepared and be patient because players will inevitably die over and over again.

Lifespan – 5/10

As I alluded to before, past linear 2D side scrollers don’t tend to last for overly long periods of time. And Mega Man is no exception. I think experienced players are able to complete this game in about four hours, but for inexperienced players, most time will be spent dying. And as I said before, the game’s level of difficulty will inevitably hinder its replayability for many players. Also, as Mega Man is not exactly a linear 2D side scroller, giving players the choice of what path to take, I think the game’s short lifespan is made that little more intolerable as a result.

Storyline – 7/10

For a time when there was considerably less emphasis put on a story in video games, Mega Man’s storyline is actually fairly well done. What made it different is that there is a little bit more back-story in Mega Man than there was in other games at the time. It follows a humanoid robot called Mega Man. He is deployed by his co-creator, Dr. Light, to stop his former assistant Dr. Wily. The two scientists created Mega Man and six other humanoid robots for industrial labor.

But Dr. Wily chose to use the other six humanoid robots in a bid to take over the world. And Mega Man must prevent this from happening. An interesting fact about the story is that Mega Man was originally going to be called Rock Man to fit in with the other six humanoid robots. But also as a reference to rock music. But the problem was that the developers were afraid of the name Rock Man being mistaken for a reference to drugs, so it was changed. This is also why Mega Man’s sister is called Roll. As it would have been Rock and Roll if the name change hadn’t happened.

Originality – 7/10

Although I found the game too difficult to enjoy playing, the fact of the matter is that a lot of innovations were made in this game that would become stable elements of video games to this very day, and I have to at least respect it for that. For me, it loses marks for the fact that the more difficult games back in the time appealed to a lesser demographic overall, and therefore the game was different, but in a more negative way. I can’t help but feel that if they’d toned down the difficulty for the Western release of the game, then it would have done better at the time.

Happii

In summation, whilst it’s not a terrible game, it is only open to specific kinds of gamers; the kind who don’t mind the challenge of playing through such a hard game. But for a lot of other people, it will just become nothing but frustrating to play. But with its outstanding visuals for the time, and groundbreaking gameplay features, it most definitely earned its place in video gaming history.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Mario Paint (Super Nintendo)

Mario Paint

Developer(s) – Nintendo R&D1 & Intelligent Systems

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Hirofumi Matsuoka

Producer – Gunpei Yokoi

PEGI – 3

Released on the Super Nintendo in 1992, and making use of the SNES mouse peripheral, Mario Paint allowed players to create their own personalized artwork within a video game. It was extremely well received by critics. AllGame even stated that it was  “perhaps the most ingenious and inspired idea Nintendo ever came up with for a product”. Although I personally wouldn’t label it as such, nor even give it a perfect score as they did, I do need to state, as a prerequisite, that I spent a lot of time playing this game. And I still think it holds up for various reasons.

Graphics – 6/10

Though many people may argue that Nintendo didn’t include much within the game to give players a rough idea of what possibilities lay before them. And the general layout of the games looks extremely empty; that was the point. The game was all about players having to use their own imagination to create whatever they saw fit. Though Nintendo had failed to put out a decent educational game before this, it was successful due to the fact that it would encourage creativity. Eventually, even led to schools contemplating using the same method. This game was also one of the first to include the famed Totaka’s song. This would become synonymous with many other big-name Nintendo releases.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

As well as creating pictures, the game also offers a variety of different activities. Including composing music pieces, animations, and even a hidden mini-game called Gnat Attack. Whereby players must swat various insects flying across the screen in a somewhat Galaga-esque fashion. Though the picture-drawing aspect may have been rendered redundant over the years, the game still retains a fair bit of replay value in these other activities. And whilst not deserving of a perfect high score, it does provide quite a bit of entertainment.

Controls – 10/10

Since this game primarily relied on the use of a mouse and pad, there were never going to be any problems. Especially at this point. Since home computers were well on their way to becoming something more than only used to play video games to a household necessity.

Originality – 9/10

Even though many of the ideas this game perpetuated have since been fazed out by PCs and laptops, the fact of the matter remains that there was no game like it at the time of its release. Many video games at the time may have spoken of creativity in their own ways. Despite the lack of technology compared to what is available now. But his game encouraged it in its players. As well as presenting them with a retro arcade gaming experience in the process.

Happii

Overall, Mario Paint stands out as one of the most unique gaming experiences on the Super Nintendo. It isn’t one of the greatest games to have ever been developed and hasn’t held up well with the times like many other games of the era have. But many gamers will still be able to find a use for it.

Score

31.5/40

7.5/10 (Good)

Mario Kart: Super Circuit (Game Boy Advance)

Mario Kart Super Circuit

Developer(s) – Intelligent Systems

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Takashi Ando & Yukio Morimoto

Producer(s) – Shigeru Miyamoto & Kenji Miki

PEGI – 3

Handing over the development of the series to Intelligent Systems, Mario Kart: Super Circuit marked the first time that the series appeared on a handheld console. It was well-received by critics upon release. Going on to become the fourth best-selling game on the system behind Pokémon Ruby & Sapphire, Pokémon Fire Red & Leaf Green, and Pokémon Emerald. Speaking as a long-time fan of the series, the contenders for the worst game, in my opinion, were this and Mario Kart: Double Dash!! But after having replayed both of them in recent years, I’ve come to the conclusion that Super Circuit is indeed the worst game in the series. But still, this is not to say that it’s a bad game. It’s just the worst of an excellent series.

Graphics – 5/10

One of the worst things about it is most definitely the conceptual design. The track-by-track ranges from good to barely passable. A lot of the ideas Nintendo tried for new track designs outside the usual tropes of the series are pretty poorly designed. Such as Cheese Land and Riverside Park. But at the same time, many tracks go along with the motifs of the series. Such as Peach Circuit and Mario Circuit, are also quite poorly designed. The best kinds of tracks in the game are those following the themes of Bowser’s Castle and the haunted house courses. The uniquely themed tracks also get fractionally better as the game progresses. But the best in conceptual design throughout the series would be yet to come.

Gameplay – 7/10

The game plays out like a mixture of both Super Mario Kart and Mario Kart 64. And for the most part, the courses do provide a fair level of challenge. But again, some courses can be criticized in this respect, too. Mario Circuit is a prominent example since it was placed in the Flower Cup. Yet I personally found it easier to win than Peach Circuit in the Mushroom Cup, which goes against not only the tradition of Mario Kart but that of gaming in general. Since games are supposed to get harder as they progress. Otherwise, it plays out just as well as any other game in the series.

Controls – 10/10

By proxy, there are also no issues with the controls. Both the prior games in the series had been largely a test of trial and error since they were drastically different from each other (with both of them passing that test). But somehow, the controls feel a lot smoother than Super Mario Kart, with elements of the control scheme of Mario Kart 64 thrown in. It seems easier to make narrow turns and easier to accurately aim weapons than in the original game.

Lifespan – 8/10

If players don’t have another gamer to partake in multiplayer with (which would make the game last for as long as their own interest in it), it can take fractionally longer than the original two games to complete. Since it has five tournaments as opposed to the traditional four. There are also additional game modes to add to the title’s longevity in the battle mode, quick run, and time trial modes. So fans of the series will have more than enough to do throughout.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

The Mario Kart series has never had a story attached to it, and it never should, I don’t think. At this point, especially, I believe that trying to add a story to a Mario Kart game would be a pretty bad move on Nintendo’s part unless they can do it in such a way that it does nothing to hinder gameplay to any kind of extent. It worked particularly well in Diddy Kong Racing. So if Mario Kart were to ever become an open-world kart game, a story may work.

Originality – 2/10

The Mario Kart series would later become quite innovative. Including several new features with each installment. But in Super Circuit, there is next to no innovation. As it was indeed largely influenced by the two prior games. Nintendo tried to create a game that was more evolutionary rather than revolutionary, but due to the mixed quality of track design, I didn’t find it to be the evolutionary experience that Nintendo intended it to be.

Happii

However, much as I’ve complained about Mario Kart: Super Circuit, it remains a solid gaming experience, and much better than any generic racing game that was either out at the time or what had been released prior, or even that has been released since. To me, it’s acceptable since it plays out as any Mario Kart game should, but other games in the series have since gone above and beyond what was on offer here.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Mario Kart: Double Dash (GameCube)

Mario Kart Double Dash

Developers(s) – Nintendo EAD

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Kiyoshi Mizuki, Yasuyuki Oyagi, Futoshi Shirai & Daiji Imai

Producer(s) – Shigeru Miyamoto, Tadashi Sugiyama, Shinya Takahashi & Takashi Tezuka

PEGI – 3

The fourth installment to the most successful spin-off series in video gaming history, Mario Kart: Double Dash provided gamers with a slightly different take on the kart racing genre, by adding the feature of having two characters to each kart allowing for more weapons to be held at any one given time, and also allowing for online play; though in a much-limited capacity to what gamers of this day and age are accustomed to. Unfortunately, however, I’ve never thought as much of this game as many other entries in the franchise. It would be a choice for me between this and Super Circuit as the two main contenders for “the” worst game in the series, for several reasons.

Graphics – 5/10

One reason why I believe this game doesn’t match the quality of most other Mario Kart titles is that the visuals are not the best on the GameCube, either from a graphical or conceptual standpoint. The tracks are some of the worst in the series, even including my all-time least favorite track, Baby Park. Aside from that, it also had most probably the worst incarnation of Rainbow Road in the entire series. There are a select few tracks that stand out, but nowhere on the same level as the track in entries such as Mario Kart 8, Wii, or even 7.

Gameplay – 6/10

For the most part, the game plays out pretty much like any other Mario Kart game, and the addition of a second driver does make for an interesting twist in gameplay since players can be at a disadvantage if the passenger falls off after taking too many hits from items. The problems are that most of the tracks in the game don’t necessarily make for a particularly grueling challenge, instead of the series’ tradition, and they also added something else, which has been a recurring thing in other Mario Kart games, something I have never been a fan of: cannons. In some tracks, some cannons transport players from one area of the course to the other, and to me, it’s always been a sign of developers literally cutting corners.

Controls – 10/10

The best thing I can say about this game is that despite the introduction of new mechanics, it stays true to the classic Mario Kart formula, and consequently, there are no complications to address. The only problem that can be even vaguely associated with it is that the sound effects of switching drivers can become relentlessly repetitive.

Lifespan – 8/10

Completing each tournament in each class can take up to 5 to 6 hours, but after that, if players have access to the Internet via the GameCube, they can, of course, indulge in online play, which will add even more to the lifespan; an idea which, in all fairness, I am pretty happy to have seen become a staple of the series. There is also a little bit more incentive added in the unlockable characters and unlockable cars; something else that would become a regular feature, much to my delight.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

The Mario Kart series has never had a story attached to it, and it never should, I don’t think. At this point, especially, I believe that trying to add a story to a Mario Kart game would be a pretty bad move on Nintendo’s part unless they can do it in such a way that it does nothing to hinder gameplay to any kind of extent. It worked particularly well in Diddy Kong Racing, so if Mario Kart were to ever become an open-world kart game, a story may work.

Originality – 3/10

As I’ve reiterated, Double Dash ultimately plays out like most other games in the series, only being much less enjoyable. It does have the one saving grace of having two characters to every one kart, but the cannons throughout a good few of the tracks in this series started a trend, which I personally would rather not have seen started, making this game original, but for what are, in my opinion, the wrong reasons.

Happii

To summarize, however, although Mario Kart: Double Dash makes for a bad Mario Kart game, it doesn’t necessarily make for a bad game in general. It’s much more enjoyable than a fair few other sixth-generation games released at the time, and it still beats any other generic racing game out there hands down.

Scores

43/60

7/10 (Fair)