Tag Archives: Scouse Gamer 88

Super Mario Sunshine (GameCube)

Super Mario Sunshine

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Yoshiaki Koizumi & Kenta Usui

Producer(s) – Shigeru Miyamoto & Takashi Tezuka

PEGI – 3

Following on from the immense success of Super Mario 64 back in 1996, Nintendo released Super Mario Sunshine on the GameCube in 2002 and went on to receive overwhelmingly positive critical acclaim, with many publications giving it a perfect score. And the Japanese website Famitsu also gives a near-perfect score. One of the very few games at that time to achieve such an honor. Personally, however, I can understand why critics and players alike appreciate this game to the extent that they do. With it presenting a new and outlandish style of play that had never been seen in a Super Mario game prior, it seemed like too much of a step down from Super Mario 64. And there were fundamentals that I feel the developers didn’t handle as well as they should have.

Graphics – 7/10

In terms of conceptual design, Nintendo was at least able to break away from many of the normal conventions that were within the series at that time. And take it to an entirely new setting with new types of supporting characters. Very effectively expanding the mythos of the entire Super Mario universe. Something that arguably needed to happen for some time before the release of this game. It was also the first time FMVs had been implemented in a Mario game. This helped it to showcase what kind of graphics the Nintendo GameCube was capable of processing in its early shelf life.

Gameplay – 5/10

After the prolonged success of 3D platforming games on the Nintendo 64, Super Mario Sunshine was Nintendo’s attempt at bringing something new to the table. Introducing new gameplay mechanics in the form of Mario’s new companion, F.L.U.D.D. A water hose, which Mario must use to clean areas of land in order to get around. And to use a weapon against enemies and bosses. The problem I had with this game, however, is that there are several game-breaking glitches throughout. This made me believe that it was left unfinished overall. It was highly unorthodox by Nintendo’s standards, making this game one of the first true signs of weakness I personally witnessed within the gaming industry. Yoshi’s Story did little to impress me when I was a kid. But I naturally expected much more from a Mario game. And unfortunately, in this instance, my expectations were not met.

Controls – 8/10

Another way in which Nintendo could be seen as going back on itself in this instance is in the game’s control scheme. It ultimately plays out almost identically to Super Mario 64. But the new mechanics can take some getting used to at first. And even after this, I found them to be somewhat unresponsive at times. Overall, it was a little dissatisfying to see this after Nintendo had pioneered such a sophisticated control scheme with Super Mario 64.

Lifespan – 8/10

One good thing I can say about this game, however, is that for those who may not experience as much of a problem with it as I did, there is certainly a fairly lengthy experience to be had. It lasts just as long as any 3D platforming Mario game, around 30 to 40 hours can be clocked. Which is pretty impressive. In general, it surprised me how such long games could be stored on mini discs when I first started playing the GameCube. I saw it with both Wind Waker and Metroid Prime. But his game is yet another shining example of this.

Storyline – 6.5/10

The story of Super Mario Sunshine takes place on a vacation island called Delfino. In which an unidentified figure has been vandalizing large sections of the resort. Once Mario and the company touch down, ready to take their own vacation, Mario is immediately and wrongfully identified by the Delfino authorities as being the vandal. And is sentenced to clean up the mess that has been made with the aid of F.L.U.D.D. At first, it seemed like a positive change from the damsel in distress story that had become synonymous with the series, even at that point. But over time, that’s exactly what it unfolds into, overall making it not much different from any other Mario game.

Originality – 7/10

Despite Nintendo’s unwillingness to provide a great deal of uniqueness in terms of story, I do respect their willingness to try something new in terms of gameplay. Which, after all, is much more important than the former. There would be many more 3D platformers released throughout the sixth generation of gaming that would blow this title out of the water. Such as Jak & Daxter and Ratchet & Clank. But this game was able to at least stand out among these others to the extent that it did.

Niiutral

Overall, Super Mario Sunshine is my least favorite 3D Mario game. But it’s by no means the worst game in the franchise overall. There are gamers out there who hold this title in much higher regard than I do. And this is understandably so. But to me, there were far too many faults found with it to be able to call it a classic game.

Score

41.5/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Super Mario Maker (Wii U)

Super Mario Maker

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Group No 4

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Yosuke Oshino

Producer(s) – Tazashi Tezuka & Horiyuki Kimura

PEGI – 3

Partly inspired by the Super Nintendo classic Mario Paint, Super Mario Maker is a game in which players are given the ability to design their own Super Mario courses. And share them across the Internet with players from around the world. Personally, whilst I was mightily impressed with the practically infinite amount of replay value there is to be had with this title, I did have a few issues with it preventing me from being able to call it the ultimate Mario experience.

Graphics – 8/10

The templates available to players to create their own Super Mario levels consist of the conceptual and technological design of the original Super Mario Bros, Super Mario Bros 3, Super Mario World, and New Super Mario Bros U. By proxy, players will already know that they will eventually be in for a whirlwind of customization options. It involves some of the most wonderfully outlandish conceptual designs in video game history.

If that weren’t enough, Nintendo has also added a few new elements into the mix that can be implemented. Such as distorting scenery to add to a stage’s level of challenge. And a whole range of sound effects and scenery effects like fireworks. And funny noises are activated whilst interacting with a certain object in each stage. In some of the better-level designs I’ve encountered so far, I’ve been impressed with how Nintendo has managed to keep the franchise relatively fresh and creative even after thirty years.

Gameplay – 7/10

As mentioned, what Super Mario Maker entails is players designing, sharing, and playing a multitude of different Super Mario courses based on four templates of four classic Mario games. Different elements can be unlocked through either playing other people’s courses or through the nine-day unlocking cycle. But there is another way of getting around this for anyone who would prefer to have these features unlocked even sooner. All that the player must do is experiment with the creation mode for 5 minutes at a time.

At this point, they will receive a notification that new features will soon be available. After this, the player can then set the date forward by a day in the system settings. And reload the game. And the new features will become available. This can be done multiple times until all the features are unlocked. However, one problem that I think will always apply to this game is that the levels present will always vary in quality from either masterful to exceedingly boring. Since the content is almost solely user-generated. I’ve already encountered this problem whilst playing, and I don’t think this, at least, is likely to ever change.

Controls – 10/10

There is hardly anything to say about the game’s controls since it consists of a control scheme. Which has already been around for thirty years, and has been perfected all this time. Super Mario Bros. set the standard for how a 2D side-scrolling video game should be correctly developed. And by proxy, there was never going to be an issue with controls.

Originality – 6/10

Though the entire concept of user-generated content. And modding is by no means anything new to the world of gaming; Nintendo has still managed to at least keep the Mario franchise relatively fresh by adding a gameplay concept new to it. Whilst along the way, adding new elements never been seen in Super Mario stages before. Ultimately, the majority of what uniqueness this game holds lies in the player’s ability to design as many rich and varied courses as possible. And from what I’ve seen so far, the quality of that has ranged from captivatingly unique to courses that Nintendo itself would despair at if they were to see them for themselves.

Happii

Overall, Super Mario Maker is a very decent game. It also has the potential to be even better still if Nintendo decides to provide players with even more course templates. And elements as the next few months or years go on. In my opinion, it could potentially pave the way for Nintendo to make even more of these kinds of games. Which could be extremely interesting if they decide to do so. It would be just another example of how this franchise could continue to establish new trends in the world of gaming.

Score

31/40

7.5/10 (Good)

Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins (Game Boy)

Super Mario Land 2 6 Golden Coins

Developer(s) – Nintendo R&D1

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Hiroji Kiyotake & Takehiko Hosokawa

Producer – Gunpei Yokoi

PEGI – 3

As another Game Boy Game developed under the watchful eye of the late great Gunpei Yokoi at Nintendo R&D1, Super Mario Land 2 is, in many ways, a massive improvement on the original Super Mario Land. Introducing a new world in the Mario series. As well as a new objective. It was also the first time gamers were introduced to the character of Wario, giving the Mario universe a new and more stable villain than Tatanga from the previous Mario Land game. After having first played this game only very recently, I can say it is definitely a must-have for anyone with a Game Boy. Or a 3DS since it is on the Virtual Console.

Graphics – 9.5/10

One of the most noticeable improvements is most definitely in the visuals. Whilst settings and character sprites may take up more of the screen than they did in the original game, that sacrifice is most definitely worth it. Not only does everything in the game look in far more detail. But unlike in Metroid 2, there is a very even balance between graphical detail. And how much of the screen is taken up by this?

Not causing as much of a hindrance as many people have cited about the second outing of Samus Aran for the Game Boy. Also. Whilst the game’s soundtrack may not be as stellar as the original Super Mario Land, one noteworthy thing is that Kazumi Totaka composed it. And the fabled Totaka’s Song Easter egg can indeed be found within the game. On the game over screen, wait for 2 minutes and 30 seconds, and it will play.

Gameplay – 9.5/10

Although the visuals have been drastically improved, and an adequate level of variety in setting design has been very much adhered to, the most significant improvement to me is the gameplay. Playing out less like the classic Super Mario Bros. game. And offering a gameplay experience more akin to Super Mario World, it offers greater variety in gameplay as well as the ability to finish it in any order the player so desires. Indeed, 6 Golden Coins was actually one of the largest games ever developed on the Game Boy at a whopping 4 megabits. It may seem like a very small amount by today’s standards. But at the time, that was a big deal. Especially for a handheld monochromatic system. As well as that, the same amount of stern challenge is also present as it was in the original game.

Controls – 10/10

The only gripe I had with the control scheme in the original Super Mario Land was that the controls could be somewhat unresponsive at times. And that it could cause a bit of pretty unnecessary frustration. Thankfully, however, the developers didn’t repeat the same mistake with this title. And there are fortunately no issues to address.

Lifespan – 5/10

Another improvement made was to the lifespan. The original Super Mario Land could be completed in a time of merely half an hour. But the second game can last closer to 2 hours. Whilst that isn’t really that significant an improvement. Especially compared to Super Mario World itself. The thing to bear in mind is that a Game Boy cartridge could only hold so much memory. And it would still be a fair few years before advancement in cartridge technology would allow for significantly bigger open worlds and even more gameplay. Like that which would be seen in the Pokémon games.

Storyline – 7/10

Aside from the gameplay being an improvement, there is also a slight positive deviation from the regular story of Mario having to travel to save a princess in the form of something quite different. In this title, Mario must retake his castle. It has been stolen by a new villain named Wario. To do this, he must travel the land to find the 6 golden coins needed to regain access to the castle. And thereby entering to defeat Wario.

Originality – 7.5/10

With a new world, a new villain, and even a couple of new power-ups thrown in for good measure, I’d say that the second Super Mario Land game keeps the series a fraction fresher than the original game did. The difference is that more things that were introduced to the franchise in the second game would go on to become staples of the series. This was good in the way that, in itself, would lead to Nintendo taking the character to greater heights of success in the future. With the likes of Super Mario 64 and Super Mario Galaxy.

Happii

In summation, Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins is a thoroughly enjoyable Mario game. And I would recommend it to anyone else who may not have played it yet. Or have been sitting on the fence about trying it out. It may be a considerably aged game. Especially compared to the many Mario games that have come out on other handhelds since. But it plays out just as well. If not better.

Score

48.5/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Super Mario Land (Game Boy)

Super Mario Land

Developer – Nintendo R&D 1

Publisher – Nintendo

Director – Satoru Okada

Producer – Gunpei Yokoi

PEGI – 3

Super Mario Land is one of the most outstanding Game Boy games for me for several reasons. Developed by Nintendo R&D 1 and produced by the late great Gunpei Yokoi. Super Mario Land, for me, definitely earns its place as one of the more fairly memorable installments in the illustrious Super Mario franchise.

Graphics – 9/10

Super Mario Land presents players with a pretty decent level of variety in level design. With courses ranging from being influenced by Egyptian and Chinese cultures. As well as other courses having a more classic Super Mario feel to them. The variety in level design compensates for the initial lack of color on the Game Boy’s screen nicely. But what I absolutely love about this game and the biggest source of childhood memory for me personally, is its stellar soundtrack. Composed by Hirokazu Tanaka, the theme for the first level, in particular, has had a huge nostalgic impact on the gaming community. It does a flawless job of setting the happy-go-lucky tone of the entire game.

Gameplay – 9/10

Whilst Super Mario Land pretty much plays out like any other typical Mario game before it. And other future Mario games afterward, what stands out about Super Mario Land for me is its surprising level of challenge. Especially compared to that of previous installments in the series. Though Super Mario Land is short, many levels do require a bit of lateral thinking to get through, I find. Even after over 20 years, there were parts of the game that I struggled with when I played it to finalize my review.

Another standout feature that came with Super Mario Land. What had never been seen in any other Mario game before, and few since, is the rail-shooting aspect of gameplay. Inspired by Gunpei Yokoi’s Kid Icarus series, Super Mario Land presents players with the challenge of guiding Mario through the level on either a plane or in a submarine. With guns attached to them to shoot enemies along the way. This made for a very nice change of direction in terms of gameplay. One of many examples of Yokoi’s philosophy of lateral thinking with withered technology.

Controls – 9.5/10

Compared to other installments in the series, prior, Super Mario Land’s controls seem a little bit unresponsive. Mario sometimes may not jump when the appropriate button is pressed, which can cause some mild frustration. But otherwise, the entire formula works as it was intended, which. As it had been long since perfected in the video games industry, it was to be expected.

Lifespan – 3/10

For me, this is the aspect by which the game falls short the most. As it can be completed within half an hour. Whilst the game is extremely enjoyable to play, like most titles in the franchise’s history, it still feels like far too fleeting an experience. Given how short a time it can be made to last. Beginners will spend quite some time losing lives, but for experienced players, it can be completed in less than twenty minutes. Which, even for a Mario game, was just far too short.

Storyline – 6.5/10

The story of Super Mario Land follows Mario’s adventure to rescue a character new to the franchise at the time, Princess Daisy. From the mysterious alien Tatanga, who plans to force her into marriage. Whilst the basic premise is identical to any typical Super Mario game, it is fractionally different from other prior entries in the series. And did introduce a few new characters who would later become much more stable in the years to come. It incorporates a new villain to the Mario series as opposed to simply bringing back Bowser again. But overall, the game’s story is not exactly what one would call a blockbuster. Especially as this game was designed at a time before video games were officially considered to be a valid form of artistic expression.

Originality – 7/10

Although Super Mario Land does ultimately play out like most other Super Mario installments, it was kept fresh enough with the introduction of new gameplay elements as well as new characters and scenery to go with it. I think it’s pretty regrettable that the rail-shooting aspect of gameplay has appeared in no other mainstream Super Mario title since, as it was a good idea. And it kept gameplay intense as well as challenging.

Happii

In summation, Super Mario Land is a must-have for old and new fans of the series. For me personally, it doesn’t get any more nostalgic than this and will keep newcomers to the series for the short time it lasts. And present them with a fairly stern challenge along the way.

Score

44/60

7/10 (Fair)

Tank! Tank! Tank! (Wii U)

Tank Tank Tank

Developer(s) – Bandai Namco Games

Publisher(s) – Bandai Namco Games

PEGI – 7

First gaining prominence in Japan as an immensely successful arcade game, Tank! Tank! Tank! was then ported to the Wii U as a launch title in all regions and has since become a free-to-play eShop download, and I would personally recommend anyone with a Wii U to play it. It is a critically wonderful console port of an arcade game and offers a level of gameplay variety unusually fantastic for a game of its kind.

Graphics – 7/10

Though the graphics may not be cutting edge, as with many titles on the Wii U at this present moment, there is no shortage of vibrant and sharp cartoon-like visuals. There is a plethora of different monster designs, such as giant spiders and a robotic hydra. The main criticism I have about the game’s visuals, however, is how generic the design of each tank is. There is a series of different weapons that can be picked up throughout each level. This gives tanks different looks within the level. But each tank that can be selected for the beginning of a level does look pretty much the same as the others.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

The objective of the game is to take out every monster in each level within an allocated time limit. That may seem like all there is to the game. But regardless, it is extremely satisfying to do. A fair bit of incentive is also offered to the player for playing through each level. Such as new tanks to unlock and level up in a traditional RPG fashion. It is rare that so much variety is ever added to an arcade game. Most arcade games, like House of the Dead, are simply straight ports with little to no forethought put into them. And I need to commend Namco Bandai for their efforts with this port.

Controls – 9/10

The only bad thing I can say about the controls is that moving the tank can be a little awkward at first. But players can get to grips with it fairly quickly. It certainly isn’t awkward enough to the point of completely annoying players or hindering gameplay to any great extent. Otherwise, however, there are no other issues to address.

Lifespan – 6/10

It can take a good few hours to collect every tank in the game and their respective upgrades, as well as finish the main game. It’s particularly impressive since one playthrough of a traditional arcade game tends not to last an hour; for example, The House of the Dead 2 can take an average of 40 minutes to finish. It’s just another way in which the Wii U port has been effectively adapted for consoles. And how much thought went into the entire process, as opposed to simply porting it as it was.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

There is no clear-cut story to this game. But instead, simply a basic premise. Your character, modeled after your own likeness, must undertake a series of missions whereby certain cities and landscapes are being overwhelmed by menacing and towering monsters, and must be taken down with your little green tank. I think that it’s acceptable that this is the case, because oftentimes when arcade games try to incorporate a plot, it’s either not very good or well thought out. Or because the games generally tend to last for so little time, not enough time can be invested on the player’s behalf to care about anything that’s happening.

Originality – 6/10

The game does have influences in terms of both visuals and gameplay. It looks a lot like many other generic games set in urban cities. It plays out a lot like games such as BattleTanx and Battle City. But having said that, it also provides a unique gameplay experience from the point of view of Nintendo console owners compared with a lot of other games they are most well-known for releasing. Because of that, I think it’s pretty regrettable that this game has been disregarded to the extent that it has been outside of Japan.

Happii

In summation, Tank! Tank! Tank! is a pretty enjoyable game. And I would highly recommend anyone who owns the console to try it out for themselves. Though it may not have the same charm as the original arcade version, with the added feature of having the cabinet chair jerk the player around with every shot fired, the gameplay has been greatly handled for the console port and will keep players entertained for an abnormally long time for an arcade game.

Score

45.5/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Super Mario Galaxy (Wii)

Super Mario Galaxy

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Tokyo

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Yoshiaki Koizumi

Producer(s) – Takao Shimizu & Shigeru Miyamoto

PEGI – 3

The official 3D platformer in the series since Super Mario Sunshine on the GameCube, Super Mario Galaxy presented players with the most innovative Mario game since the days of the Nintendo 64. And has since become a cult classic. It is considered a must-have game for anyone who owns a Wii. It is indeed a very unique game and makes for one of the better titles on the Wii overall. Even at the time of its release, I did have one or two issues with it. This prevented me from being able to personally consider it to be one of the best Mario games of all time.

Graphics – 9/10

The conceptual design of Super Mario Galaxy is also unlike any other Mario game to have ever been developed prior. Introducing players to a world made up of standalone galaxies and traversable planets. There is also a wide variety of new characters and settings, which have since become staples of the series. Appearing in the likes of Mario Kart 7 and 8. On top of that, there is also an extremely effective use of lighting and textural detail. Indeed, factors like that make the final cutscene one of the most breathtaking I’ve ever seen in any video game in general.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

Playing out very similarly to Super Mario 64. But going unanimously beyond the quality of Super Mario Sunshine, it involves simply traversing each stage of the game to collect as many stars as possible. And thereby ultimately reaching the last boss. There are a good few stars to collect, with the added incentive of being able to play as Luigi once this is done. And then being given additional objectives afterward. There is also a ton of new power-ups for players to take advantage of in order to progress through the game. Such as the ability to transform into a bee or even one of the boos.

Controls – 9.5/10

Normally, when video games try to incorporate a new or unique control scheme, it usually becomes a question of trial and error. Such as in Lair or Sunset Overdrive. But it’s surprising to see how few issues there are in Super Mario Galaxy. Considering how different and off-the-wall it is compared to not only other Mario games before it, but other video games in general. There is one or two issues regarding the camera angle. But they don’t become anywhere near enough of a problem to render the game unplayable by any means.

Lifespan – 6/10

The one thing I was disappointed by, however, was the game’s lifespan. To do everything will take an average of roughly 20 hours. Taking into account things like larger-level designs than in Super Mario 64. And more to play for than in Super Mario Sunshine seems evermore underwhelming. It wasn’t until three years later that every single issue I had with this game was addressed in the sequel, including lifespan. But I don’t think the game should lose out on too many marks. Since it lasts considerably longer than many other mainstream releases.

Storyline – 7/10

Although the story follows the same basic premise as most other Mario games (Mario must save Peach from Bowser, and the job is done), it does have a few things differentiating it from other Mario games. The basis of the game’s story involves Mario having to travel through outer space through various portals within an observatory occupied by the new character Rosalina and her companions, the Lumas. A race of people resembling stars. It makes for settings and characters very different from anything else seen in either most Mario or most other Nintendo games, for that matter. And the fact that the basic objective remains the same also remains forgivable as well.

Originality – 9/10

Super Mario Galaxy is undoubtedly one of the most unique games on the Wii. And one of the most unique titles of the seventh generation in general. Introducing gameplay mechanics that gamers may have thought couldn’t possibly work otherwise, it was popular enough to spawn a second game and did extremely well to expand on the Super Mario mythos even further. It could be argued that a lot of the ideas in this game stemmed from the canceled Sega Saturn game Sonic Xtreme. But I think this game would have been more impressive if the latter had been released anyway. Since it takes advantage of an entirely new control scheme and way of playing games.

Happii

In summation, Super Mario Galaxy is indeed a must-have for Nintendo Wii owners. And one of the better Mario titles in recent years. Though the sequel would arrive sometime later and blow this game out of the water, in my opinion, this was an extremely good starting point and remains something that players come back to again and again.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Styx: Master of Shadows (PC, PlayStation 4 & Xbox One)

Styx Master of Shadows

Developer(s) – Cyanide Studios

Publisher(s) – Focus Home Interactive

PEGI – 16

Taking place in a dark and gritty medieval fantasy setting, Styx: Master of Shadows is a 3D platforming stealth game with a few thorough espionage mechanics. And somewhat of a quirky sense of humor. However, the same problems arose in this game that I have found in many other stealth games since. As well as a few other problems.

Graphics – 6.5/10

Firstly, the best thing about the game’s presentation is its atmosphere. Everything is extremely dark and gloomy. It is even used to the player’s advantage to remain undetected by enemies. However, the game runs on Unreal Engine 3, which makes it look outdated compared to even late games on the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3; defeating the entire object of porting it to eighth-generation consoles. In terms of its general conceptual design, it’s about as original as Dark Souls II was. Particularly typical of what a medieval setting should be, having no truly outstanding elements to it.

Gameplay – 5/10

The gameplay, in my opinion, is even less enjoyable. Aside from the few half-decent stealth mechanics of being able to put out fires to better hide from enemies, using sand as a projectile, and the few magic abilities at the player’s disposal, I found the main problem with it was how many times I found myself resetting the game to pass certain areas undiscovered. Since there’s also a very intermittent auto-save mechanic, it made playing through even more unnecessarily complicated.

Controls – 8/10

The control scheme of Styx: Master of Shadows is extremely reminiscent of that of Blood Omen 2. Movement is somewhat stiff. And it can be gratuitously hard to perform certain commands. Such as climbing and strafing. In particular, the carpet on which Styx must land in order to soften the sound of his fall towards the beginning of the game is very clumsily placed. I assume that it was done that way to add to the challenge. But even if the landing is softened, it’s too easy for the guard to spot the player afterward. Thus, compelling the player to once again reload the game an undetermined number of times.

Lifespan – 7/10

For a 3D platformer, the length at which this game lasts is passable, coming in at roughly 16 hours. This will provide a fairly long experience for those willing to look past the qualms I have with it. It doesn’t have the open-world factor, which has made many classic 3D platformers last for exceptional amounts of time. But for a linear game, that is fairly impressive. The concern after that would be whether or not the player can spend as little time as possible having to reset the game in order not to add to the game’s lifespan for the wrong reason.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of Styx: Master of Shadows follows a master goblin thief called Styx, who is on a quest to steal the heart of a World Tree within the Tower of Akenash. The best things about the narrative are the occasional wisecracks that Styx comes out with, as well as his own narration of the events that unfold throughout the game. Though it concerns the concept of the protagonist coming of age to a certain extent, there have been a few games to come along over the years to present that scenario better than this, such as Ocarina of Time, Ni No Kuni, and the original Fable.

Originality – 4/10

As both a 3D platformer and a stealth game, it doesn’t bring a great deal new to either genre. If anything, judging by the game’s control scheme, I actually saw it largely as a step back from many of the innovations that have been made concerning both categories of the game in the last ten years. There have been many more stealth mechanics introduced in many more games, which the developers neglected to either implement or work upon, it would seem, and whilst they may have designed to be evolutionary as opposed to it being revolutionary, they failed to execute that in my opinion.

Niiutral

Overall, whilst Styx isn’t entirely god-awful, it’s certainly no game-of-the-year contender. For this year or the last. It has a good few problems that could’ve been addressed with a coat of looking at before release, and it wasn’t the best start to Cyanide Studio’s venture outside the plethora of sports games they have developed over the years.

Score

36.5/60

6/10 (Average)

Super Mario 3D World (Wii U)

Super Mario 3D World

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Tokyo & 1-Up Studios

Publisher – Nintendo

Director(s) – Koichi Hayashida & Kenta Motokura

Producer(s) – Yoshiaki Koizumi

PEGI – 3

Super Mario 3D World has been incredibly well received by critics even before its release in all regions in November 2013. With publications such as Eurogamer, Joystiq, and Destructoid giving the game perfect scores. Both the critical and commercial standpoints seemed to be that this was the reason why people should own a Wii U. But sadly, despite what a good game this is, it has been very much overlooked in both the US and the UK, in particular.

In my opinion, it’s nowhere near as great as a lot of the old Mario games. And not even as great as Super Mario Galaxy 2. However, I don’t think Nintendo deserved to have this game so widely neglected in the Western market. It’s an enjoyable game and definitely one of the best Mario games in recent years. Surpassing the likes of the New Super Mario Bros 2. And its predecessor, Super Mario 3D Land, in quality by some margin.

Graphics – 8/10

Whilst the visuals aren’t exactly cutting-edge, as indeed they’re not really supposed to be, the conceptual design of the in-game world and its inhabitants is typical of any Mario game. Wonderfully weird. There’s a nice blend of both classic and new enemies to contend with. As well as a mixture of old and new settings. Most of the different levels in the game are also very intricately designed. And greatly encourage a certain level of exploration in order to find hidden items. Which is always a plus.

But sometimes, I can’t help but feel as if some of the levels are also recycled versions of old ones. As indeed has been the case in other recent Mario games. I also found a few of the boss fights pretty generic. They were clearly recycled from Super Mario 3D Land. However, what sets this game apart from 3D Land is the fact that this game thankfully includes more original bosses than generic ones. A lot like the bosses found in the Super Mario Galaxy series. I’m also a sucker for water effects in games. And Super Mario 3D World certainly has great water design, too.

Gameplay – 8/10

The gameplay is the most important aspect of any game, and Super Mario 3D World certainly delivers in style. Massive improvements have been made to Super Mario 3D Land. In that, there is a lot more variety and things to do. As with the settings and enemies, the gameplay is a very exciting blend of both old and new elements of the Mario franchise. The most classic example is the option to play as Mario, Luigi, Peach, or Toad, just like in the NES classic, Super Mario Bros 2. Each character handles differently, and there is a level at which different characters need to be played in order to gain certain collectibles.

The new catsuit also provides some very interesting new gameplay mechanics. Giving characters the ability to climb up walls in order to take shortcuts. And collect hidden items. There’s also another feature whereby the player can collect cherries. Which spawn multiple Mario sprites to control at the same time in order to solve puzzles and reach hidden areas. This element was inspired by The Legend of Zelda game, The Four Swords. Which would always be considered compelling. My only gripe with it is that there could’ve maybe been a few more side quests added. Or at least the side quests that were included could’ve had more of a purpose. If only to make it stand out further as a platform game. For example, the stamps to be collected in the game are used to merely customize Miiverse posts.

Controls – 10/10

There’s honestly not much to say about the controls, as there are no problems with them. As I mentioned before, the Four Swords mechanic of controlling multiple sprites at one given time is particularly impressive. Along with the character choice mechanic, which might have been missed by some fans of the series. My rule of thumb is that when a game has a perfect score in terms of controls, it simply means that there are no complications with them. Even if there’s not much to say beyond that. Unless, of course, there are some overly innovative elements worth talking about, which might make them even more deserving of a perfect score. But even if there are no new control elements, I don’t think there’s any need for a game to lose marks if the controls are implemented correctly, with no problems.

Lifespan – 7/10

On average, this game will take players around 15 hours to complete. Whilst this is a fair amount of time, I don’t think it’s that great. It seems to me to be somewhat deficient. Especially given the amount of time Nintendo had to get this game out. And that there are a fair few recycled elements of Super Mario 3D Land thrown in there. I think if they really wanted this game to have the impact that Nintendo clearly banked on having over the holiday season, they should’ve made it longer to again make it a lot more notable when talking about the platforming genre. Nevertheless, 15 hours is just about acceptable for a platform game, and it’s worth playing; if only once.

Storyline – 6.5/10

This, for me, is the aspect in which the game falls short in my opinion. Although it indeed strays away from the thoroughly exhausted plot of Princess Peach being the damsel in distress, as of course, she is a playable character this time around, the story still follows the basic premise of a typical Mario game. Bowser has this time captured seven fairy-like creatures called Sprixies, and Mario and company follow Bowser into a new world known as the Sprixie Kingdom in order to save them and defeat him once again.

Personally, I liked the plot of the Super Mario Galaxy series, which introduced several new characters and creatures relevant to the story and mixed it up a little bit more than usual. Unfortunately, I don’t see anything about this game’s story that makes it stand out among most others in the franchise. This is another element of the game that Nintendo probably should’ve spent a bit more time on to have the desired lasting impression they were looking for.

Originality – 7.5/10

Any Mario game is always going to stand out to at least a small extent. Whilst there’s not a great deal in this game to differentiate it from many other Mario games, there’s certainly enough to distinguish it from most of the more recent ones. Various new bosses and some fantastic settings separate it from most of the newest 2D side-scrolling games in the franchise, and there are also a few new gaming elements added that I previously discussed. I think if not for some of the recycled elements of Mario games placed into the mix, I think this game could certainly have had the intended effect on markets away from Japan that Nintendo sorely required to give the Wii U a much-needed boost in sales figures throughout Christmas.

Happii

In summary, Super Mario 3D World is a fun game, and it is indeed worth playing through. There were many other titles released over the 2013 holiday period that unjustifiably hogged attention away from such a good game as this, but I believe Nintendo is capable of doing more with Mario than what they did with Super Mario 3D World.

Score

47/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Super Mario 3D Land (3DS)

Super Mario 3D Land

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Tokyo

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Koichi Hayashida

Producer – Yoshiaki Koizumi

PEGI – 3

Released relatively early into the shelf life of the 3DS, Super Mario 3D Land was universally praised upon release and has since sold over 10 million copies. Making it the third best-selling game for the system, as of this writing. The series has been lacking in innovation for the past few years. This game can be seen as an example of this; it’s nevertheless a fairly enjoyable game. It has a decent level of challenge, which is unusual for a Mario game. Even to veteran players.

Graphics – 7.5/10

As with most installments in the series, the conceptual design of the game is quite varied. The game is set in several differently themed worlds and levels. There aren’t a lot of new elements to most of the scenery. The same boss is recycled a good number of times, as in New Super Mario Bros 2. But there are also a few hidden secrets to be found. Along with many of the hidden coins throughout the game. Such as a dungeon area, paying homage to The Legend of Zelda series. References to Mario have been rife in The Legend of Zelda series since its inception. But it’s interesting to see that in this case, it’s very much the other way round.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

In a lot of ways, 3D Land plays out a little like a mixture of Super Mario Galaxy 2. In that, levels have to be unlocked via the discovery of three hidden coins in each level. And any classic Super Mario game, due to its linear progression. As opposed to the free-roaming style of play synonymous with many 3D Mario games. It’s quite satisfying to solve each elaborate puzzle placed in the game. And to complete it to 100%. However, I think I would have been bitterly disappointed if one-half of the game hadn’t been unlockable after finishing the first half. I think if it had ended at the point of rescuing Peach, I would feel very differently about it.

Controls – 10/10

Super Mario 64 pioneered the 3D platforming genre, and an integral reason why was that it had a very innovative control scheme. Yet one that was simple to get to grips with whilst players were experiencing the transition from 2D to 3D gaming. Since this game uses more or less the same control scheme. And because each level is of a much more linear progression, there are absolutely no complications. And it’s interesting to see how many more functions have been added to the overall formula.

Lifespan – 7/10

As I alluded to, the first half of the game can take up to an average of 7 and a half hours to finish, which is why if it had ended at that point, even after taking in the side quest, I would have been left feeling much more jaded by the entire experience. Taking the second part of the game into account, however, it can be made to last roughly 15 to 16 hours, which for a linear Mario game is fairly impressive.

Storyline – 4/10

As thoroughly milked over the past 30 years, Mario is on yet another expedition to stop his arch-nemesis, Bowser, and save Princess Peach. The only difference is that afterward, he must save Luigi. Mario games are generally not played for their story. But for what great gameplay there is, I can’t help but think that even after repeating the same story beyond the release of this game in 2011, Nintendo could have come up with something different. They have since worked to alter this formula slightly in recent games by introducing new characters and elements to the series. But to me, there isn’t enough of that in this game in particular.

Originality – 6/10

Though combining gameplay elements from different Mario games and makes the entire thing into a fairly cohesive concept, this game is, regardless, most definitely not one of the most unique titles of the time. It certainly isn’t even one of the most unique Mario games throughout the series’ chronology, since some of the others have helped to pioneer gaming in many different ways. Certain elements give the game a fair bit of charm in its own right, such as new power-ups for Mario, but many things made me think that more effort could have been made in this respect.

Happii

Overall, Super Mario 3D Land, whilst pretty unoriginal and lacking in story, in lieu of the franchise’s tradition, it would seem, is still pretty enjoyable to play and satisfying to complete. Things would pick up with the arrival of its Wii U counterpart, Super Mario 3D World, and various other spin-off Mario games, but none of this is to say that this game is a failure.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Super Castlevania IV (Super Nintendo)

Super Castlevania IV

Developer(s) – Konami

Publisher(s) – Konami

Director – Masahiro Ueno

Producer – Kazumi Kitaue

PEGI – 7

Released relatively early on in the Super Nintendo’s shelf Life, Super Castlevania IV was a game directed by Masahiro Ueno. Who was credited under the name Jun Furano. Since Konami at the time prohibited the use of real names, Whose favorite game in the series at that point was the first, and wanted to create a similar experience. Minus the frustrations that came with the first. To me, this game is the perfect jumping-on point for people who want to indulge in the series. It is vastly superior to the original game in quite a few different ways.

Graphics – 10/10

The most obvious improvement is in the game’s visuals. They are not only many times more realistic-looking than the NES classic but also present a darker and even grittier atmosphere than the former. The opening sequence, in particular, has been cited as one of the scariest moments in video gaming by many other critics. Another massive talking point is the soundtrack. Ueno also wanted the environments of this game to be a lot more interactive and believable. He has stated how proud he is of how well the music and sound effects were implemented. And to me, this is rightfully so.

Gameplay – 9/10

Aside from the extensive improvements made to the game’s visuals and sound quality, dramatic enhancements were also made to the gameplay. The difficulty has been greatly toned down. Which I believe is a pivotal factor in determining why this is the best possible starting point for prospective fans of the saga. The original game was much more difficult. Therefore much less accessible to as wide a variety of players as there could have possibly been otherwise. Not only that, but there are also longer levels. And by proxy, it makes for a longer game overall.

Controls – 10/10

Another extremely positive change is that the control scheme has also been improved to a great extent. The player can now attack in 8 different directions instead of just one. Allowing for more of an edge in combat, as well as the elimination of enemies delivering sucker punches that can’t possibly be avoided otherwise. Another feature introduced to the series was the facility to swing from hook to hook using the whip to get around certain obstacles in the game.

Lifespan – 7/10

Super Castlevania IV will take around an hour and a half to finish. This may not seem like very much today (or a lifespan even passable in most modern games). But at the time, it was longer than the average side scroller. Quite literally, three times longer than the original game. The levels are longer and much more drawn out. Featuring a bigger map and more enemies added to slow players down. I would be shown what a truly great lifespan was in the following generation. But at the time, a game like Super Castlevania IV was fairly impressive.

Storyline – 3/10

The biggest problem with this game, however, is the fact that the story is the same as that of the original game, and no real innovation or improvement has been made in this aspect. It is simply a retelling of Simon Belmont’s quest to destroy the newly resurrected Dracula. And rid the world of his castle. The fact that it’s the same story being told again isn’t the only problem, either. It’s also still extremely typical of the kind of story that was being attached to most video games at the time, and throughout the previous generation as well.

Originality – 6/10

2D side scrollers were the industry standard at the time, so consequently, there’s not a great deal present to make this game stand out to any great extent. It loses a lot of its uniqueness in the fact that it isn’t as challenging as the first game, but that isn’t necessarily a bad thing. What is bad, however, is that the general setting and basic premise have been presented before, and despite improvements, there wasn’t much innovation made outside of this.

Happii

Overall, despite the few things wrong with it, Super Castlevania IV is easily the best game out of the original four, and I would recommend it to any gamer who has yet to experience any other facet of the series before they try any game in the original trilogy. It would get better from here on with the release of Symphony of the Night, but this game is most definitely the best possible place to begin.

Score

45/60

7.5/10 (Good)