Tag Archives: Puzzle

Monument Valley (Android, iOS, PC, PS4, PS5, XOne, X/S, Switch)

Developer(s) – Ustwo Games

Publisher(s) – Ustwo Games

Director(s) – Neil McFarland

Programmer(s) – Peter Pashley, Manesh Mistry & Van Le

PEGI – 3

Initially released on iOS, later Android, and then a host of different consoles over multiple generations, Monument Valley is an indie puzzle game. It incorporates a standout visual style and relaxing atmosphere. Similar to the likes of Fez, Braid, and The Witness. It relies on players manipulating each environment in various ways to progress the character through a series of levels. It was an immediate hit on the app stores when it first came out. And has since spawned two sequels. 

I’d had this game on my radar for quite some time. But I’d never gotten around to playing it until recently. Ultimately, while I found that there was a fair bit to enjoy with this title, I felt that there wasn’t enough of what it was offering for it to be able to stand as a gaming classic. 

Graphics – 8/10

Inspired by Japanese art and a multitude of indie games that came before it, the game’s visuals are by far the most impressive thing about this title. They are aesthetically pleasing. Making exceptional use of colour and lighting to portray a wide variety of different captivating scenes. Even though the visual style is consistent throughout, the developers did really well to make each level feel unique and memorable in its own right. The soundtrack also complements the game perfectly. Making for one of the most relaxing gameplay experiences I’ve known for a long time. 

Gameplay – 7/10

The player must guide the player character, Ida, through a series of different levels and puzzles. These are solved by moving objects and building around them to pave the way to the next area until the game is complete. One of the two common criticisms I was aware of going into this game was how easy a lot of reviewers thought it was. And that it doesn’t present the level of challenge that it had the potential to do. To me, it presented around the right amount of challenge. Especially given that this is the first game. And for a puzzle game, something like this was a relatively new concept at the time. 

Controls – 10/10

Regardless of what platform the player is playing this game on, be that mobile, PC, or console, the controls pose no issues whatsoever. If I were forced to choose, I’d say the best way of playing is on PC with a mouse. The visuals are too good to enjoy on just a smartphone, in my opinion. And playing it with a mouse simplifies things the most out of any other means of controlling the game.

Lifespan – 2/10

The other aspect for which this game was commonly criticised at the time of its release was just how short a game it is. And I agree with the general consensus when it comes to this. Clocking in at just short of an hour and a half, it falls well short of industry standard. Especially that of a typical smartphone game. Which can be made to last as long as players care to keep coming back.

There was simply far too much scope for expansion and potential for this game to have lasted as short a time as this does. Even at the time, the first game came out. Like I pointed out before, there have been two sequels created to Monument Valley. But each entry clocks in at the same amount of time as the others. It has been disappointing to learn.

Storyline – 3/10

The story of Monument Valley follows the player character, Ida. Who journeys through each of these optically illusory environments? To be forgiven for some unnamed transgression she has committed. The story is pretty minimalistic. And I’m flabbergasted as to how there is supposedly a film of this game coming out sometime in the future, as it would take quite some imagination to build on a story concept as underdeveloped as this. 

It may be that the sequels built on this as they went on, and that the filmmakers have more source material to work with now. But it would be interesting to see how that pans out. But based on the first game alone, there’d need to be quite some work done to it. Because for me, it’s too hard to imagine how they’d pull that off. 

Originality – 6/10

But as the story is minimalistic, the concept of gameplay does relatively well to make this title stand out among the indie scene. It was certainly a very different experience at the time of its release from what players would’ve normally been used to. Puzzle games seem to be one of the few genres of focus for indie games, with titles like The Bridge, Puzzledorf, and The Swapper (among many others). But whilst having drawn inspiration from several different titles, this game still does well to stand out as its own fully cohesive concept.

Niiutral

Overall, Monument Valley is an enjoyable, visually appealing, and standout game. But there’s just not enough to warrant repeated playthroughs. Though it is worth going through once. In the criminally short time that it lasts, I do wish that this concept would be worked on more than it has been since the release of the first game.

Score

36/60

6/10 (Average)

Kurushi

Kurushi (PlayStation)

Developer(s) – G-Artists

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director(s) – Kenji Sawaguchi

Programmer(s) – Yukio Watanabe

PEGI – 3

Conceived by Professor Masahiko Sato of the Tokyo University of the Arts and released on the original PlayStation throughout 1997, Kurushi is a puzzle game. Whereby the player is confronted by cubes approaching the end of a stage. The objective is to eliminate these cubes (or capture them as the game describes) to prevent too many from falling off the end of the stage. Or avalanching the player character to the end. Leading to game over.

The player can also use advantage cubes to capture multiple cubes at the same time, but must not capture the forbidden cubes. For every time too many cubes fall off the stage without being captured, or for too many forbidden cubes being captured, the player will lose one or multiple rows of the stage. Thereby making survival evermore difficult. But they are rewarded with an additional row for every perfect round played. 

This was one of the earliest PlayStation games I played back around the time when the original console was in its heyday. Although I enjoyed the Nintendo 64 more than the former, there were more than a few outstanding titles on the original PlayStation that I thoroughly enjoyed. And have gone back to enjoy long since its initial release. And Kurushi is most definitely one of them. 

Graphics – 6/10

Whilst not exactly cutting edge for the time, the visuals are, more importantly, very minimalistic; both conceptually and technically. I say this is important because I think if the visuals were too elaborate, it would have most likely thrown players off too much from the gameplay. And with a gameplay concept as unique as this, the gameplay needed to be the main focus. If games like Tetris or Space Invaders had been too flashy, it would’ve caused similar problems. It’s not often that I come across games like this. Whereby if the graphics were too distracting, it would work against the game overall. But Kurushi is definitely one of these rare exceptions. 

The developers did diversify in ways that don’t affect gameplay too much. Such as different coloured stages to keep each level relatively fresh. But that’s about as much as they could’ve done. The soundtrack, however, is pretty impressive. Making use of a full orchestra in all of its tracks. And ranging from awe-striking to downright creepy at times. 

Gameplay – 9.5/10

Out of every aspect to talk about regarding this, however, the gameplay takes precedent. It wasn’t particularly often throughout the fifth generation that a gameplay concept like this would captivate gamers in the way it did. Since a lot of the focus in the early days of 3D gaming was more geared towards adventure games and RPGs. So it made for an interesting change of pace. To go from a game like Super Mario 64 to a game like Kurushi. But even more significant than that was the level of challenge this game offered at the time compared to others. It’s certainly not an easy game. And it does take a level of critical thinking to progress as far as possible. 

Controls – 10/10

The game’s control scheme, as well as its general layout, also works particularly well. As they both are (and had to be) very minimalistic. For the same reasons, the graphics had to be minimalistic. If there were too many commands and options, it would’ve inevitably complicated things to a needless extent. Even using the D-pad works just fine, despite the fact that it’s a 3D game. Which with other early PS1 titles, such as Croc: Legend of the Gobbos, proved to be much more of a problem. 

Lifespan – 6/10

The original Kurushi spans 9 stages. It takes an hour and a half to play through. Although much longer games would be developed for the original PlayStation, and already had been at the time, it would’ve been around the average amount of time for a game to last in the previous generation. And again, since this concept was very new at the time, the developers would’ve been limited to how far they could expand on the concept at this early stage. 

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

Originality – 9/10

Even so, the game remains one of the most unique experiences on the original PlayStation. It remains one of the most unique puzzle games ever developed. Though the developers would’ve been limited to how they could’ve thought to expand on this concept at the time, taking a step back afterward and thinking about it would’ve most likely yielded many ideas on how the formula could be built upon. And although there were alternative game modes introduced with the sequel, Kurushi Final, I’ve always thought that there could be even more ways in which this concept could have been expanded. And it’s always remained a shame to me that they never were after the second game. 

Happii

Overall, the original Kurushi is a visually simplistic game, with an aesthetically unique style of play that had gamers feeling challenged throughout. And it can still offer players that same level of challenge to this day. It’s a game that remains vastly enjoyable to play. It deserves to be expanded upon more than what it was, rather than be lost to video gaming obscurity as it unfortunately has been. 

Score

50.5/60

8/10 (Verdict)

Puzzledorf

Puzzledorf (PC)

Developer(s) – Stuart’s Pixel Games

Publisher(s) – Stuart’s Pixel Games

PEGI – 3

Released in 2021, Puzzledorf is a puzzle game whereby the player must push different colored boxes into their corresponding slots around different stages to progress. It’s an example of how, in certain games, less can be more. And how games don’t have to have innovative mechanics or cutting-edge graphics to be enjoyable. 

Graphics – 7/10

The game makes use of 16-bit graphics reminiscent of games on the Super NES or the Sega Genesis/Mega Drive. It’s set in summery environments consisting of sand, palm trees, beaches, and ocean-blue seas. It’s the same for every level, so things can become quite repetitive in terms of the visual side of things. As can the game’s soundtrack. But the visual style that the developers stuck to is very well done. And it doesn’t do too much to detract from where the fun is.

Gameplay – 7/10

Puzzledorf is also the same throughout, though very enjoyable. It’s very similar to how the block puzzles are handled in The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past, where players have to move stones into the same-colored slots to solve each puzzle and progress to the next. There are 3 main stages to the game, as well as a mirror mode to keep things challenging. And it’s the challenge that is the best aspect of this game. It looks calm and serene on the surface, but players can strip it back away from that to uncover something wonderfully manic. 

Controls – 10/10

There are also no problems with the controls, as the concept is as simple as it could be. You use up, down, left, and right to move the character, and you have a button to reset each level when you need to start again. There are no experimental mechanics present to complicate things. And nor should there have been. 

Lifespan – 5/10

Completing Puzzledorf will take around 4 hours, depending on skill level. There is a heightened level of challenge in the game’s additional mirror mode for more intrepid players, but ultimately may leave certain players wanting more. There is scope to expand on the core concept if ever a sequel is made. But as a standalone title, it is a little too short in my opinion.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

The game has no storyline, nor did there need to be. I suppose there would be scope to expand on this if the developers ever did make a sequel. But for now, we have a guy in a white shirt going on puzzle-based adventures. Similar to Anodyne, but just not quite as elaborated on. 

Originality – 7/10

The most unique thing about this game is its core concept. It’s an example of taking a certain element from a popular game and making it its standalone concept. Which is fairly impressive. I expected less from this game than others in terms of substance. But as I said at the start of the review, it’s an example of less being more. And ultimately, the game didn’t disappoint.

Happii

Overall, Puzzledorf is a fairly enjoyable game for the little amount of time it lasts. I can recommend it to any fan of the puzzle game genre or any gamers out there looking for a stern challenge. 

Score

46/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Beavis and Butt-Head

Beavis and Butt-Head (Genesis/Mega Drive)

Developer(s) – Viacom New Media & Radical Entertainment

Publisher(s) – Viacom New Media

Programmer(s) –  Michael Gyori

ELSPA – 11+ 

Released in the holiday season of 1994 in America and Europe the following year, some years before the series reached its commercial height, Beavis and Butt-Head was ported to several systems, and each of these ports plays out very differently. But by far, the best was the Genesis/Mega Drive version. It was widely panned by critics at the time of its release for similar reasons that the show itself had its fair share of detractors. Because it only caters to a certain audience.  Without a strategy guide, the only people who could truly enjoy it are fans of the show. Regardless of whether you’re a fan or not, it is worth at least one playthrough with the aid of a guide.

Graphics – 7/10

One of the main factors that make this game superior to the other ports is the visuals. There are far more details than the Game Boy version (As is expected), but they’re far more detailed than the Super NES version as well. The characters and settings look far more akin to the show. And even the sound quality is better than the Super NES port. This is especially surprising since that was an advantage the Super NES was known for having over the Mega Drive. I think the reason for this is that the somewhat scratchy sound quality of the Mega Drive fits better with the tableau of the show, which has a heavy focus on rock and metal music.

Gameplay – 6/10

The game is a 2D side scroller with point-and-click elements. The objective is to traverse several locations synonymous with the show, such as Highland High School, Burger World, and the Turbo Mall, and collect missing ticket fragments for a heavy metal concert. As I alluded to earlier, the biggest reason why this game was quite negatively received at the time is that there are things that have to be done in the game that newcomers to the series wouldn’t know to do unless they’d watched the show, as a lot of the game’s objectives are reminiscent of past episodes. 

But as I said, if players consult a strategy guide to find out what it is they have to do, then there is a decent gaming experience to be had out of it. Players can also be made to feel a lot more incentivized by playing through the Mega Drive version. There is a secret ending to unlock by doing additional things in the game.

Controls – 9/10

The only gripe I had with the controls was that it’s a little harder to run while platforming with the size of the Mega Drive controller compared to that of the Super NES controller. But this is only a very minor criticism. Otherwise, the game plays out as well as any other platformer at the time. The consolation is there’s no time limit like there is with other side scrollers. So players can afford to take their time. And they will have to at first to get the best feel for the game. 

Lifespan – 6/10

Clocking in at about the average lifespan for a game at that time, experienced players can beat the game within an hour. Most players will end up playing for longer to get used to how the game plays out and learn what they have to do to progress. So I can’t take too much away from it for not lasting as long as an average Metroidvania, for example, even though the game is more open-ended than other side scrollers. There’s a fair amount for players to do compared to other games of its kind released at the same time. And within the confines of its genre, players can do worse. 

Storyline – 6/10

Another aspect in which each port differs slightly is in the story. In the Mega Drive version, Beavis and Butt-Head buy tickets to see a Gwar concert. After which, they’re destroyed by various means, and they set out to retrieve the ticket pieces and put them back together in time for the concert. It works better if you’re a fan of the show. And a fan of the brand of humour that it perpetuates. A lot of that may be lost on audiences today. Since Beavis and Butt-Head is very much a by-product of its time. And really could only have taken off in the 90’s. 

That being said, I had no idea who Gwar was before playing this, and have since come to enjoy their music a lot. So that was something that I was at least able to take from it. But in addition, its style of humour is something that did cater to me back in the day. So I was at least able to enjoy it for what it is. 

Originality – 6/10

In terms of uniqueness, the game is more evolutionary than revolutionary. It didn’t break new ground at the time. But it did well enough to stand out among other 2D side scrollers and give players something slightly new to try out compared to what they were used to. Again, without the use of a strategy guide, there is a good chance players will lose patience with it. As I did at first. But going back and playing it again, and sticking to it, I did end up enjoying it for what it is.

Niiutral

To summarize, Beavis and Butt-Head is certainly a game that caters to a specific audience. But I don’t think it deserved to get as badly panned as it did back in the day. It was a decent game released at the time, based on a pre-existing license. Back in a time when there was more of a preconception about the quality of licensed games. 

Score

40/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Goliath Depot

Goliath Depot (PC & Switch)

Developer(s) – Vidvad Games

Director(s) – David Langlois

PEGI – 7

Initially released in the third quarter of last year on PC, and most recently ported to the Nintendo Switch, Goliath Depot is a title developed by Canadian indie outfit Vidvad Games. It expands upon the aesthetics of Hotel Mario. One of the ill-fated Mario games released for the Philips CD-i. Although the latter title has been universally panned by critics years after its release, Goliath Depot takes the core concept and elaborates on it in many positive ways. Making for a far superior experience.

Graphics – 7/10

Incorporating the 8-BIT graphic style synonymous with the third generation of gaming, it presents a world reminiscent of our own, with two white-collared characters to choose from who must navigate their way through four levels, perpetuating the modern age. Such as a warehouse, an industrial factory, and a parking lot. The enemies, as well as the bosses, are also anthropomorphic objects fitting in with these tableaus. Like computers, gears, and cardboard boxes. 

Although it doesn’t have the abundance of fantastical elements associated with games that typically come out of Nintendo, like the likes of Legend of Zelda, Metroid, and Pikmin, it does provide an interesting twist on that concept. It asks the question of what supernatural things would look like in the modern day. And it makes for an interesting conceptual feast for the eyes. 

Gameplay – 8/10

Like what a selection of indie games have done in recent years, Goliath Depot takes the core design of a game that is very much laughed at these days, and refines the concept to give us a very enjoyable gaming experience. It adds elements such as special abilities and additional characters to unlock, more creative boss fights, and even an online leaderboard, adding more of a competitive element than Hotel Mario. There’s much more incentive and replayability to be had in this title than in the former. 

Controls – 10/10

Initially, it took me a bit of time to get used to differentiating between the jump and action buttons and using them in conjunction with individual abilities unlocked throughout the game, but once I got used to it, the control of the game posed no problems. It makes for a very fluent and natural gaming experience. Especially for gamers who are more used to retro arcade experiences. But although gamers don’t feel nostalgic toward Hotel Mario, they will end up appreciating this game more. 

Originality – 8/10

Where Goliath Depot is concerned, the developers have refined a withered style of gameplay to an extent that has rarely been seen among indie developers over the best part of 20 years. Games like Titan Attacks and Curses ‘N’ Chaos have offered their modern takes on classic arcade titles. But to take something that many gamers may not be aware of and create this is impressive. If not, more so. 

Happii

Overall, I ended up enjoying Goliath Depot to a great extent. It’s a challenging, long-lasting, and incentivizing gaming experience that can be appreciated by retro and modern gamers alike.

Score

33/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Nubarron: The Adventure of an Unlucky Gnome (PC, Xbox One & Switch)

Nubarron

Developer(s) – Nastycloud

Publisher(s) – Hidden People club

Designer(s) – Ignacio Rud & Federico Segovia

PEGI – 3

Released on Steam in early 2020 to a mixed critical reception from gamers and reviewers, Nubarron is a semi-open world 2D side-scroller following the adventures of a Gnome being pursued by an ever-changing cloud. Tasked with recovering the pages of a magic book. For the first hour of playing, it seemed like a pretty generic platforming game; I can best compare it to Chronology by Bedtime Digital. But after getting past that initial period, it did become progressively better. And I ended up enjoying it very much.

Graphics – 8.5/10

To begin, the game’s hand-drawn visuals are quite stunning. Almost on par with the best games to use this graphical style. Such as the Ori games, Dust: An Elysian Tail, and Hollow Knight. It takes place in a fantastical forest home to many weird and wonderful creatures. With a blend of both medieval fantasy and science fiction elements. The reason I say that this game is almost on par with the aforementioned games is that it doesn’t quite stand out as much on the conceptual level. Nevertheless, it is one of the better-looking indie games developed in 2020. 

Gameplay – 7/10

The game is a semi-open world puzzle-solving 2D side-scroller that requires some tracking back to previous areas to complete quests. Gameplay is made as variable as possible with the acquisition of new abilities throughout, and the unusual combat system. Combat is engaged through the cloud that follows the player’s character. It can be used to subdue enemies. But in certain sequences throughout the game, the cloud can become either more difficult to control or out of control altogether. The player has to avoid being killed by the cloud when it becomes uncontrollable. Aside from the combat element being wonderfully outlandish compared to other games, the puzzle-solving element is also pretty well-executed, with some of which. Especially towards the end of the game, which is particularly challenging. 

Controls – 10/10

One of the main reasons why I would still most closely compare Nubarron to Chronology is that the controls are almost the same. Nearly to the point where you would think both games were made on the same engine. The movement controls are somewhat wooden compared to other side scrollers. But with so much more functionality and abilities to take advantage of than the former, it’s a far better game to control. The slowness of the movement commands is also not hindering enough to be considered a significant problem. The game’s control scheme poses no unnecessary complications, as any good game should be made. 

Lifespan – 5/10

The aspect that lets this game down, however, is its lifespan. The problem is that the games I have compared this to in terms of graphics are Metroidvanias and therefore require far more backtracking. I can’t help but feel that if this game were made in the style of Metroidvania, then it would’ve been made to last far longer than it does. But since there is only a minimal amount of backtracking to be done, the game clocks in at only around 5 to 6 hours. Which, in this day and age, is pretty underwhelming. 

Storyline – 8/10

What wasn’t underwhelming, however, was the story of Nubarron. It follows a Gnome, simply named Gnome. He one day has not only, unfortunately, lost his lucky hat, but is also persistently followed by a cloud, whose behavior changes on a whim. Wanting to get rid of the cloud and find his hat, he enlists the help of a magical omniscient owl who requests that Gnome recover all the missing pages from a spellbook called the Nubarron, and so Gnome sets out on his quest.

At first, my first impression of the game’s story was that it was quite typical. A bog-standard fantasy story, if you will. However, as the game progresses, it becomes something far better than that. Without spoiling the details of the ending, it’s perfectly poised for a sequel to happen, and I’m very much hoping that it does happen. There’s a lot of scope to expand on the mythology of the series. As well as the gameplay mechanics and the lifespan. So here’s hoping that this game gets the follow-up it deserves. 

Originality – 7/10

It’s not until after the first hour or so that players will be able to fully appreciate the depth and the unconventional aesthetics that this game truly has to offer players. So it is something that will have to be borne with at first. But when that initial period passes, there’s so much to be had in terms of uniqueness. Sure, I was left thinking to an extent that if a little more effort was put in, this game could’ve ended up being even more than what it is. But for what there is here, it’s still a pretty standout experience.

Happii

Overall, Nubarron was a game that I looked at and thought was going to be a very generic gaming experience. It turned out to be anything but that. It’s enjoyable to play with a surprisingly in-depth narrative. And I would advise anyone looking at this game to ignore the mixed reception that it has received. It’s certainly worth at least one playthrough. 

Score

45.5/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Lucy Dreaming

Q&A With Tall Story Games

Whilst once again scouring Kickstarter for more new video game prospects. I came across a couple of games in a genre that, generally speaking, I don’t spend enough time covering. But this game captured my attention in a way that few others do. Lucy Dreaming is a point-and-click adventure game made as a love letter to the works of LucasArts. Including Day of the Tentacle, the Monkey Island series, and Full Throttle.

Developed by Tall Story Games, based in the English West Midlands, it centers around a young girl named Lucy. She must travel between dreams and reality to discover a disturbing truth about Lucy’s subconscious. Eager to know more, I contacted the game’s lead developer, Ton Hardwidge, to pose some questions in regards to not only the game but also in regards to the point-and-click adventure genre itself. I was curious to get an indie developer’s perspective regarding how well the genre is represented compared to the likes of the 2D Side Scroller, Metroidvania, or 3D platforming genres. So that being said, here’s what Tom Hardwidge of Tall Story Games had to say about Lucy Dreaming:

Lucy Dreaming 2

What were the influences behind your game?

It’s fairly obvious to anyone looking at the pixel artwork or user interface of Lucy Dreaming that the LucasArts adventure classics from the 1990s are a huge inspiration for the game. I’ve made no effort to hide this fact. And I am proud to call it a love letter to all of the titles that gave me so much joy growing up. Monkey Island and Day of the Tentacle made a huge impression on me. And I never, even in my wildest dreams, thought it would be possible to create my own point-and-click adventure games.

The initial concept for the game came from the fact that our house is littered with children’s books. We have a six-year-old son who loves reading and often dreams about characters and scenarios in his books. I was already trying to think of a concept that would provide flexibility in terms of scenes, characters, and artwork. And dreams were the perfect candidate. I won’t divulge too much about the mechanics of the full game. But books play an important part.

What has the developmental process been like?

This is our first full-length title, so we knew it was going to need a bit more planning than some of our previous, shorter games. That said, a lot of the puzzle development in the game is organic. Having a narrative plan mapped out, which contains all of the important milestones and plot points along the way. But in terms of the puzzles themselves, a lot of them are created in situ. I will design a scene and start cramming it with random objects.

I hate large areas of space, so I always want to put a picture on the wall or stuff the shelves to help add interest to the scene and support the wider story of the game. Once I have filled up a scene with bits of random crap, I then look at the task in hand and think to myself, “If I were in this scene, what would I do next?” or “I wonder what’s in that cupboard over there.” As I oversee the story, artwork, and development, I can change anything on a whim if I think I can make it work better. Or there’s an opportunity for a gag.

How close are we to seeing the finished product?

We’re aiming to have a finished game within 12 months of the Kickstarter campaign ending. I tend to get carried away and over-deliver. So, although we have proposed 8-10 hours of playtime, it may well be a bit over that. The version of the demo available to play on Steam and Itch.io is actually the second one that we’ve produced. The first one was finished at the end of 2020. When tested, it had an average playtime of over two hours. We felt this gave away a bit too much of the full game’s mechanics and story, so we decided to “bank” it as the first two hours of the full game instead and create an entirely new demo prequel that had unique puzzles not found in the full game.

For anyone backing the game on Kickstarter, we will be involving them in discussions about the game on our VIP Discord channel, too. So they can help to shape the game they have supported.

Lucy Dreaming 3

What has been the most exciting aspect of development?

As I’m doing the whole lot, it’s very hard to separate them into different aspects. It’s all a single, intertwined process. If I had to pick one element, it would probably be the puzzle design itself. It involves a little bit of everything. Sometimes a puzzle will be purely visual,

sometimes it relies heavily on the dialogue and other little clues. Honing a puzzle so that it’s just the right level of difficulty is so much fun. I’ll watch testers and streamers play through a puzzle and try to spot where they get frustrated, bored, or delighted. I can then tweak the whole experience to make it as smooth as possible without handing them the answer on a plate.

What has been the most challenging aspect of development?

Without a doubt, it’s been the publishing of the game to the various app platforms (namely, Steam and the Google Play Store). As a first-timer to the process, I can honestly say that it’s been one of the most confusing and frustrating things I’ve had to deal with. It’s like a badly designed adventure game puzzle in itself. The clues are poorly signposted, and the dialogue is unhelpful. But, as an adventure game puzzle, there is immense satisfaction in finally figuring it out on your own.

How well has the game been received so far?

So far, it’s been received well, and anything that has been picked up in terms of bugs or potential improvements to the puzzles has been sorted in subsequent releases. I’ve watched a lot of gamers playing the demo since it launched, and so far, it seems to have been universally enjoyed. A few people find a northern British accent inherently annoying, but they are vastly outweighed by the number of players who love Lucy and the voice actor’s sassy northern lilt (which is just as well, because it’s my wife and business partner, Emma!)

There’s nothing more satisfying than watching people laugh out loud at the jokes. And there are hundreds in there if you like exploring. The demo alone contains over 1,100 unique responses and dialogue. If you want to suffer an onslaught of bad puns and “dad jokes,” try talking to all the objects in each scene. You might discover a few hidden references and Easter eggs, too.

Lucy Dreaming 4

What platforms are you looking to bring the game to?

The game engine that I’m using is called Visionaire Studio, it’s purpose-built for point-and-click adventure games and supports a huge number of platforms. For the basic level of funding on Kickstarter, I am promising releases for Windows, macOS, and Linux. But there’s also a stretch goal for iOS and Android (the demo is already available to download from the Google Play Store). Point-and-click games with a traditional SCUMM-style interface lend themselves to touchscreens. I would love to release Lucy Dreaming on Nintendo Switch, too. But publishing a game for Nintendo is a bit of an unknown for me, even though the game engine supports it from a technical point of view.

Can you tell us anything about the pending stretch goals planned for the Kickstarter campaign?

Since the campaign launched, a lot of people have reached out to me to ask about support for different platforms and languages. So in the name of transparency, I have actually made the decision to publish the initial plan for stretch goals. At the time of writing, we haven’t fully funded. Although we did manage to reach 50% of our goal in the first 11 hours of the campaign, and were handpicked as a Kickstarter “Project We Love”, so we’re hopeful!

Have there been any ideas at this stage of development that have since been scrapped or reworked?

Probably more than I think! If I got back and checked my original notes, there would undoubtedly be things that I’ve forgotten or moved away from since I started this project 12 months ago. The main thing that has changed is the name of the game itself. We originally called the game “Lucid Adventure”. Subsequently, we had to scrap a couple of months into the project. I had failed to do my research properly and completely missed the fact that there was already a game with the same name. After a quick brainstorming session with other indie developers and game industry professionals, we settled on “Lucy Dreaming,” which is a play on “Lucid Dreaming”, the key concept behind the full game.

Lucy Dreaming 5

Do you believe the point-and-click adventure genre has been adequately represented throughout the indie community?

Absolutely, the indie game community is keeping the genre alive, and some spectacular new titles are being produced all the time.

I am relatively new to the whole indie game dev scene. Starting by making a browser-based point-and-click adventure for The Roman Baths in 2019, programming the whole thing from scratch in HTML, CSS, and JavaScript. Then, a year later, I used the same “engine” to build another game to raise money for charity Women’s Aid during the first UK lockdown. After this was well-received by adventure game fans online, I looked into game development in more detail and discovered a whole world of professional game engines. And the most welcoming, creative, and supportive community it’s ever been my pleasure to be a part of. A year later, here I am, constantly rubbing my eyes in disbelief and immensely proud to call them my friends.

How instrumental has player feedback been in terms of shaping the course of the project?

Feedback from players, other devs, publishers, friends, and everyone around me is a huge factor when producing a game like this. There’s no room for arrogance. If players falter and don’t have a smooth, enjoyable experience, it’s my fault.

At the beginning of the project, I went back and forth for a long time just working out which verbs to include in my SCUMM UI, there are strong opinions in both the “I want all of Ron Gilbert’s original verbs” and “No verbs, just a left, and right-click!” camps. And I wanted to strike a balance between the two.

It seemed like a huge deal in the early stages of the development, but now that the demo has been honed and polished, no one playing the game has had any cause to complain or even mention the UI. That, for me, is the greatest compliment. As it means it is doing its job perfectly. I still welcome feedback on all platforms and on all subjects. I am new to this industry. And if I don’t listen to my peers and my audience, I’m going to fall at the first hurdle.

Lucy Dreaming 6

Do you find that taking such a self-reflective approach to making this game through your own blog posts has improved your personal developmental skills?

I think it’s helped me retain my humility. I don’t plan my blog posts. Rather, I just open up a blank screen and let my brain spew out all over it. It’s hugely cathartic. And the blogging process has helped me to understand how I feel at each stage in the process. If I’m happy, frustrated, or confused, I let it all out. And it somehow solidifies into something I can reflect on. I’ll read them back and think “Oh, so THAT’s why I’m so annoyed.” Or “Tom, you’re being a nob, just listen to your critics.” It’s also great to have a record of all my transient thoughts and feelings throughout the project. I’m sure if I read some of my early posts now, I would have forgotten nearly everything I wrote at the time.

If you had the opportunity to develop a game with any company or for any franchise, which would it be, and why?

Ooh, that’s a tricky one. I’ve been running my own design agency for over a decade, and I’m not used to being told what to do. I’m also not very good at managing other people. So if I were going to develop something for another company, it would probably have to be a client/agency relationship as opposed to working within a larger games studio.

Under these circumstances, I think I’d probably like to work on a point-and-click adventure for a book like Luke Pearson’s Hilda. The characters and settings are an absolute wonder. And if I had similar freedom to expand and build on the world he’s created. As Netflix has done, that would be truly magical. Of course, it would need to be a pixel-art interpretation, which is probably sacrilege, hey, this is my fantasy!

It’s also mentioned on the Kickstarter page that your young son, Robin, has made unintentional contributions to the game, too. Do you see a lot of your own creative side in your son from an early age, and would you like him to possibly follow in your footsteps as a developer?

I will be delighted with whatever he decides to do as long as he’s happy. At the moment, I love collaborating with him as we walk over a mile to school every morning. We play a game called “puzzles” where we take turns to make up a puzzle that needs solving, then look around us and solve it with whatever comes to hand. This has created some incredible ideas that I would have never thought of. And I write them all down. From a penny-farthing skateboard to a woodpecker-on-a-stick for digging holes. The little chap is a veritable goldmine!

He also draws and writes a lot! I have a whole stack of Lucy Dreaming “fan art” on my desk, created by Robin. And I hope that his delight in creativity stays with him.

Lucy Dreaming 7

Do you have any advice for aspiring developers who may be reading this?

Get involved in the indie dev community. Anything and everything can be learned from the best and nicest people in the industry. Don’t be daunted by the prospect either. You’ll assume that everyone knows more than you do, but your thoughts and feelings are valid too. Have confidence in your own ability and don’t forget to have fun. I mean, that’s why you’re doing it, right? Getting involved in a wider community gives you a sounding board for ideas, collaborators for the future, and constructive criticism when you don’t think you need it. And tremendous support when you do.

Where on the Internet can people find you?

I’m on Twitter mainly, but we also have spots in all the usual haunts. Facebook, Discord, Instagram, Steam, YouTube, Itch.io, our website … take your pick!

https://twitter.com/tallstorygames

https://www.facebook.com/tallstorygames

https://www.instagram.com/tallstorygames/

https://lucy-dreaming.com/

https://discord.gg/aExm5ZhtdE

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCByVD7k0-JiLw5Cv80mS8kA

https://store.steampowered.com/search/?publisher=Tall%20Story%20Games

https://tallstorygames.itch.io/

Do you have anything else to add?

I love what I am doing and am always happy to talk (at length) about it. So if anyone has any questions or just wants to say “hello,” you know where to find me!

Oh, and back Lucy Dreaming on Kickstarter now!

Lucy Dreaming 8

I’d just like to thank Tom for taking the time out of development to answer my questions regarding this exciting title. It was quite interesting to get his take on this game. As well as the point-and-click adventure game in general. It looks like the genre has a brighter future than I’d realized. And I’m looking forward to this title. As well as any more upcoming games within it that may be coming out soon, in addition. If you like the look of Lucy Dreaming and want to see the project brought to life, you can back the Kickstarter campaign via this link:

Kickstarter Page

But in the meantime, I hope you’re looking forward to this game and enjoyed learning more about it from Tom as much as I did.

Game on,

Scouse Gamer 88

Where’s Wally? (NES)

Wheres Wally

Developer(s) – Bethesda Softworks 

Publisher(s) – THQ

Designer(s) – Paul Coletta & Randy Linden

PEGI – Not rated (Suitable for children)

Released in 1991 late into the NES’s shelf life by Elder Scrolls developers Bethesda, Where’s Wally is a puzzle game based on the puzzle books written by Martin Handford. Players must find or guide Wally across 8 different stages within varying time limits, depending on the difficulty setting. Released to overwhelming critical vitriol, it’s most definitely one of the worst games on the system. As well as being one of the worst games I’ve played based on a pre-existing license. 

Graphics – 1/10

For a development company that would later go on to set new standards in visual quality with games like Skyrim and Oblivion, it’s shocking to see how much this game lacks in graphical quality. Both on the technical and conceptual levels. Especially considering this game was released after the Super NES. And developers were pushing the boundaries of what the original NES could do at the time. This game perpetuates many of the limitations of the consoles in a way that many classic games released before this overcame those limits.

The lackluster use of the NES’s color palette is the most visible flaw this game has. The only nice-looking part of the game is the ending. Whereby Wally lands on the Moon. The moon’s surface is actually quite well-detailed. But that is literally the only positive thing it has going for it. To think that players have to beat the game to see one good example of 8-BIT visuals will seem like an insult. 

Gameplay – 1/10

Again, Where’s Wally is a puzzle title that follows the mantra of the books. The player must find Wally on 6 different screens, which expand depending on difficulty. The time limit is 10 minutes on easy mode and 7 minutes on medium mode. And 5 minutes on hard mode. 2 additional levels mix up the gameplay a little. But not to a great extent.

However, the poor graphical quality, it makes it almost impossible to identify Wally without the aid of a strategy guide. There have been worse games released throughout the years that have been inadvertently rendered unplayable due to either graphical errors or fatal glitches. But especially given how late into the console’s cycle this game came out. And how so many other developers were able to release classics on the system, there was no excuse for the developers at Bethesda to have screwed this up as much as they did. 

Controls – 4/10

The control scheme, in its basic premise, is simple enough. But it comes with many different issues; those being most evident in hard mode. In order to increase the difficulty, the developers made the cursor the player uses to pick out Wally smaller. But the problem is that the control’s sensitivity is quite high. So it creates an unnecessary complication when the player ends up finding Wally on hard mode. 

Lifespan – 1/10

Where’s Wally can be made to last a total of 10 minutes per playthrough, again depending on what difficulty setting it’s on. But to be honest, I’d be surprised if many players were willing to go through even one playthrough. There’s no further incentive for beating the game on the harder difficulty settings either, as the same thing happens at the end regardless of which one. There would’ve been plenty of things the developers could’ve added to give players an incentive to do this, but because they offered players hardly anything, it certainly doesn’t warrant even one full playthrough, let alone three.

Storyline – 0/10

The game involves nothing but Wally being led across a series of areas in order to reach a launchpad to get to the Moon. The game’s story, as with many titles of that era, exists in its basic premise, but with many other classics, they at least offered whole mythologies for players to indulge in; but it’s even more surprising how little the developers paid attention to the source material, even though there was a fair bit of that at the point of this game’s development. 

Originality – 5/10

The game is original to an extent, in that there weren’t many video games like it at the time, but it seems more bland than unique, given how little the developers did with it compared to what they could’ve potentially done with what was one of the most beloved children’s book series of that era. It’s a bad example of how to develop a licensed game, since not only is it poorly designed and not fun to play at all, but it doesn’t celebrate the license in the same meaningful ways that games like Batman: Arkham Asylum or even Rugrats: Search for Reptar did.

Furiious

In summation, Where’s Wally is a game to be avoided at all costs. It’s a game with several flaws, is almost unplayable, and has since become a black mark on a development company that would later become one of the powerhouses of gaming. All I’ll say is that it just didn’t seem to get off to the greatest of starts at Bethesda with games like this. 

Score

11/60

1.5/10 (Painful)

Beacon Pines

Q&A With Hiding Spot Games

Once again, looking for more indie video game prospects over the last few weeks, I came across a new game in development. Somewhat reminiscent of my recent interview with Chris Seavor:

https://www.scousegamer88.com/2021/01/24/the-full-twelve-tales-of-chris-seavor/

Beacon Pines is a hand-drawn, open-ended 2D adventure game combining cuteness with horror. Developed by Dutch indie outfit Hiding Spot Games, the player takes control of both the characters in the story as well as the story’s narration itself in order to determine the outcome for themselves by filling in the gaps with words. The game also gives the player the option to reverse decisions made in order to reshape events as they see fit. The game has since been successfully funded on Kickstarter. It continues to gather momentum with several stretch goals having since been funded in addition.

Wanting to know more about this game, I contacted its soundtrack composer Matt Meyer and put forward to him and the team a few questions I had. And how the game will completely take shape by the time of its full release. Here’s what Matt Meyer and Hiding Spot Games had to say about Beacon Pines:

Beacon Pines

What were the influences behind your game?

There have been lots of influences on the game. Some that come to mind are shows like Dark, Twin Peaks, and Stranger Things, sci-fi books and old pulp novels, and other games like Undertale, Night in the Woods, and Life is Strange. 

 

What has the developmental process been like?

It’s been long and wandering. I’d reference this Reddit post as a good summary of the development journey over the past few years:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Unity3D/comments/lb1wzw/the_absurd_journey_designing_beacon_pines/

 

How close are we to seeing the finished product? 

We’re shooting for a September release date.

 

Beacon Pines 2

What has been the most exciting aspect of development? 

By far the most exciting part has been finally seeing people play the game on Twitch and YouTube after releasing the demo. Seeing people’s faces light up when they reach important or surprising moments, laugh at funny dialogue, or comment on how they love the art and music. It has been an absolute joy.

 

What has been the most challenging aspect of development?  

Getting all the parts of the game mechanics to just click was the most difficult. I could go through the details, but again, the Reddit article probably does a better job of describing the challenges.

 

On the Kickstarter page, it says in Ilse Harting’s description that “There must be something in the water in the Netherlands that produced great artists!” Did any aspect of Dutch culture or Dutch artists in particular influence the design of the game?

Absolutely. Ilse takes a lot of influence from her surroundings: the people and places in the Netherlands have been a big influence on the art she created for Beacon Pines.  Even many of the names of characters and places in Beacon Pines were her suggestions based on Dutch names.

 

Beacon Pines 3

How well has the game been received so far?

It has been lovely. We weren’t sure if people would get absorbed into the story or understand how the mechanics work (with words, story branching, etc.), but most people seem to jump right in and enjoy it. 

 

What platforms are you looking to bring the game to?

Steam, itch, Switch, and hopefully Xbox and PlayStation

 

Is Beacon Pines a deliberate attempt at subverting the traditional cutesy adventure game to any kind of extent, similar to what Chris Seavor did with Conker’s Bad Fur Day?

No, we aren’t deliberately trying to subvert expectations with the art vs the story. We just want to make a game that both looks mysterious/fantastical, but also has a mature story that we as adults would want to play.

 

Beacon Pines 4

Have there been any ideas at this stage of development that have since been scrapped or reworked?

Lots (again, the Reddit article has some great examples)

 

What lessons have been brought into the development of Beacon Pines from past developmental experiences?

Not all that many, to be honest. I often work with different people, and it depends on how they prefer to work. Beacon Pines is also a very different kind of game than what I’ve made in the past.

 

If you had the opportunity to develop a game with any company or any franchise, which would it be, and why?

That Game Company has probably been the most influential on me as a game developer. I’d love to work with them and experience their process up close.

 

Beacon Pines 5

Do you have any advice for aspiring developers who may be reading this?

Making things, in my experience, is the best and most rewarding way to learn things. It is also massively beneficial to get work in the field if you already have examples of completed projects. And when you make something of your own, try to pick a project that you will want to play yourself. That’ll help keep you motivated and focused. 

 

Where on the Internet can people find you? 

We’re pretty active with our Discord community. That’s a great place to find us and chat: https://discord.gg/K4tbFWf.

 

Do you have anything else to add?

Thank you to everyone who has supported us on Kickstarter and those who have checked out the Beacon Pines demo.

Beacon Pines 6

I’d also like to take the opportunity to thank Matt for his unique insight into this very unique-looking title. It certainly affords a deep look into a game that I’d made some incorrect assumptions about previously, and how the final product will pan out. I’m sure it will turn out to be a very enjoyable and addictive experience, and I’m very much looking forward to its release. In the meantime, if you like the game and think you’d like to contribute to its stretch goals, you can visit the Kickstarter page via the link below:

Beacon Pines Kickstarter

There is also a playable demo to download online via the game’s Steam page:

https://store.steampowered.com/app/1269640/Beacon_Pines/

But in the meantime, I hope you guys had fun learning about this upcoming game as much as I did.

Game on,

Scouse Gamer 88

The Unlikely Legend of Rusty Pup (PC)

The Unlikely Legend of Rusty Pup

Developer(s) – Gory Details

Publisher(s) – Gory Details 

Designer(s) – Chris Seavor

PEGI – Not rated (some horror elements)

Released in 2018 and designed by the lead programmer of Conker’s Bad Fur Day, Chris Seavor, The Unlikely Legend of Rusty Pup is an open-ended puzzle game following a robotic dog named Rusty trying to find his way home through a wonderfully dark and dank 2D world. This game is an example of how I came into an indie title completely unprepared for what it had in store, and I was pleasantly surprised with the result.

Graphics – 8/10

The game is set in a steampunk-inspired world made up of cogs and machinery. It bears somewhat of a resemblance to games like SteamWorld Dig and SteamWorld Heist. But with a far more surreal and compellingly bleak atmosphere. Darkness follows the player character everywhere, with few specks of light made available to players to activate along the way in order to guide Rusty throughout each stage. The soundtrack is also suitably creepy to go along with the game’s settings. The environments, in particular, made me wonder about the world’s backstory and how it was created. And who created it, similarly to what Shadow of the Colossus did. It’s almost a character in and of itself.

Gameplay – 8.5/10

Rusty Pup relies heavily on the player’s initiative in order to solve what are at times mind-bending, challenging puzzles. Players must make use of light in each stage, as well as robots that can be used to temporarily stop time and guide Rusty through certain areas. There’s also a small world-building element, whereby players must set up platforms for Rusty to follow in order to access otherwise impassable areas or to break falls that Rusty would otherwise not be able to survive.

This mechanic can also be used to the detriment of NPCs by setting up traps for them. Aesthetically, it takes influence from the likes of Lemmings and Flockers. But it offers an entirely different experience from the aforementioned games that, as I said, were not prepared for in the slightest. It can take some patience to get into, as it’s a game unlike any other. But once the player figures out the core mechanics, it makes for a very enjoyable and mystifying experience.

Controls – 10/10

A simple point-and-click game by design, there are no issues with the controls whatsoever. It can be played either on PC or on iOS, and for both platforms, the game works out just fine. It may offer a different experience if the game were ever ported to conventional consoles. But it wouldn’t create anywhere near enough of a problem for it to render the game unplayable. If Plants Vs. Zombies can be ported to consoles; this game certainly can be as well. 

Lifespan – 8/10

The base game can be made to last a minimum of 20 hours. But to complete the game to 100% will take a fair bit of additional time. There is also DLC planned for the game in the future, so this will further add to the game’s lifespan in turn. But ostensibly, to make a puzzle game last for the amount of time it does is an impressive feat in any case, with or without DLC. And there would certainly be scope to expand the series at a later date, given how potentially extensive the series’ mythology is. 

Storyline – 7/10

The game’s story follows Rusty Pup, a mechanic dog on a single wheel who has apparently been flushed down a drain prior to the start of the game. With ambiguity about whether or not he fell down or if someone or something pushed him down there. Alone. But with an optimistic attitude, he resolves to find his way out of the steampunk labyrinth and make it back home. The game’s story is as ominous and as wonderfully dark as its settings, with a lot of mystery surrounding how Rusty got to this stage in the first place. And with how wistful he sounds at times, in stark contrast to the foreboding situation he finds himself in. All characters, including Rusty, speak in rhyme, which again adds to this contrast. Seemingly carefree, yet obviously in a terrible situation.

Originality – 9/10

Especially over the last gaming generation, coming across a unique indie title has become exceedingly difficult, with me looking for unique settings, unique gameplay, unique control schemes, and unique stories. But much to my delight, this game ticks all the boxes flawlessly. After having interviewed Chris Seavor himself:

https://scousegamer88.com/2021/01/24/the-full-twelve-tales-of-chris-seavor/

It became obvious to me that his creative talent was nurtured during his time at Rare. And having played Rusty Pup, he has demonstrated that he is certainly as capable as Rare’s most standout alumni, such as Gregg Mayles, Kevin Bayliss, Martin Hollis, David Doak, etc., of creating wonderfully weird and delightfully fun games to play as the likes of Banjo-Kazooie, Goldeneye 007, and Perfect Dark. 

Happii

Overall, The Unlikely Legend of Rusty Pup is unbelievably well thought out. And a compelling title that’s every bit as enjoyable to play as any top indie title. And I can’t recommend it enough. To me, it’s no wonder why Chris Seavor is most proud of Rusty Pup, as, in my opinion, it’s his best project to date. 

Score

50.5/60

8/10 (Very Good)