Max Payne (PC, PlayStation 2, Xbox & Game Boy Advance)

Max Payne

Developer(s) – Remedy Entertainment

Publisher(s) – Rockstar Games

Director – Sami Vanhatalo

Producer(s) – Scott Miller & George Broussard

PEGI – 18

Inspired by the success of the likes of games such as Loaded and Tomb Raider, Rockstar decided to put out their own third-person shooting game. One of the better games of its kind during the sixth generation. Max Payne combines moderately well-handled gameplay with a pretty intense story throughout.

Graphics – 6.5/10

I believe the best things about the game’s visuals are the maintenance of how dark and gritty the game’s atmosphere is. And how lighting comes into play very prominently. From a graphical standpoint, however, the techniques used to render the facial expressions of character sprites are very reminiscent of how Rareware handled the same thing in games like GoldenEye 007 and Perfect Dark. They may have looked extremely realistic at the time. But it was considerably less powerful hardware. So by that token, the visuals actually look outdated in my opinion. To me, it’s shocking how superior the graphics of Max Payne 2 are to those of its predecessor. Especially considering that they were released only two years apart from one another.

Gameplay – 6/10

As I said earlier, the gameplay of this title was fairly well handled. But there was definitely room for dramatic improvement. What I enjoy most about playing this game, which I’m sure a lot of people would agree with, is the facility to slow down time during combat, allowing players to pull off very stylish and cinematic displays of gunplay. It was a pretty good novelty and gave the game a great bulk of its charm. However, even for a linear game, there is a considerable lack of substance; even for a linear sixth-generation title. There are absolutely no side quests and no cause for any kind of exploration whatsoever, with players simply having to get from point A to point B, and nothing more.

Controls – 8/10

Though the control scheme in most third-person shooters was flawed in one way or another, the control scheme in this game is at least much easier to cope with. Of course, the slow-motion mechanics make combat a lot more bearable than it would have been without them, but regardless, I think they can also feel a bit stiff at times, too, in that moving the character can seem like a chore after a while.

Lifespan – 7/10

Regardless of how little substance there is in gameplay, the game is still exceptionally long under the circumstances. Max Payne can actually take about 20-25 hours to finish. I think it is one of those games whereby its lifespan outlasts its level of gameplay value, but for those who are more lukewarm to this game, it will last them a fair amount of time, at least. I would most certainly have been more disappointed if it lasted about half as long as that.

Storyline – 9/10

Instead of what would become an uncomfortable tradition in the seventh generation of gaming, the best thing about Max Payne is the story. A private detective, Max Payne, is living a very stable and full life reminiscent of the classic American dream until his wife and infant daughter are tragically murdered by a group of drug addicts high on a new kind of drug, which Max subsequently investigates upon his transfer to the DEA. But it turns out that the entire drug operation runs much deeper than Max previously thought, and events unfold into something much darker and convoluted. There are plenty of unexpected twists and turns throughout, which, to me, make for more than enough to keep players engaged for at least one playthrough.

Originality – 7/10

Though there were quite a few third-person shooters during the sixth generation, Max Payne was one of the first, and one of the few, in my opinion, to present a control scheme and style of play that gamers could get to grip with well enough. It’s also interesting to know about the history behind slow-motion mechanics. At the same time as the release of this game, the film The Matrix was the biggest thing around, and a sequel and spin-off game were just around the corner.

Inevitably, gamers started comparing the slow-motion mechanics to the cinematic techniques used in The Matrix and suggested it influenced the game profusely. But in fact, Max Payne had been in development before the original Matrix film, and the slow-motion mechanics had been considered since the very beginning of the game’s development. The slow-motion mechanics featured in the spin-off game Enter the Matrix would have actually been inspired by Max Payne.

Happii

So to summarize, Max Payne, though lacking in gameplay substance and not having the best control scheme, does have its charms in the form of the slow-motion mechanics, differentiating it from any other game at the time, and, of course, has an exceptional story. It made for a fairly standout sixth-generation experience, but I just wish there could have been side quests or two thrown in for good measure.

Score

42.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

Mark of the Ninja (PC & Xbox 360)

Mark of the Ninja

Developer(s) – Klei Entertainment

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Studios

PEGI – 16

Mark of the Ninja is an indie 2D platformer with a strong element of stealth. And using weapons and equipment to keep the player hidden from the enemy. As opposed to attacking them head-on. This game is an incredibly unique experience for many reasons. And to me, one of the most standout indie titles to have been developed before the recent influx of them throughout the eighth generation.

Graphics – 9/10

Very much like in their later game, Don’t Starve, the game’s visuals seem to be based on a pre-existing artistic style. In this case, that of Genndy Tartakovsky, who worked on the creation of such cartoon series as Dexter’s Laboratory, and most significantly, Samurai Jack. The whole thing looks like something out of Cartoon Network. But only with a much darker and grittier atmosphere. The sound effects throughout are also put to good use to maintain that atmosphere. As they are also integral to the structure of gameplay.

Gameplay – 8/10

I would best describe this game as Splinter Cell with a hint of Feudal Japan. The objective is to sneak past enemies. Using various tools, weapons, environmental shortcuts, and hiding places to get around. Points are awarded for remaining undetected and going through levels without killing enemies. And hiding bodies if the player decides to kill. Light and sound sources can be used to manipulate enemy behavior to the player’s advantage. And attacking them head-on is very ill-advised. It provides a very different take on games, including ninjas. It makes for an incredibly immersive 2D side-scrolling experience.

Controls – 10/10

In terms of controls, although there should never have been any real issues, the control scheme has been handled quite well. Movement is very smooth, and there is a multitude of different features that players can use to get around. Several things that are unusual for a game of its kind.

Lifespan – 4/10

Clocking up at about 5 hours, it, unfortunately, lasts about as long as the average modern-day 2D side scroller. And I can’t help but think that if this had been a Metroidvania game, then it would have lasted a greater amount of time longer. There was certainly more room for a greater number of side quests in the game anyway. And I believe it’s criminal for such a unique experience to also be a very fleeting one. Klei Entertainment would go on to address this issue in Don’t Starve. But if a sequel ever does happen, then I think it would be easy to expand upon what they achieved with this game.

Storyline – 8/10

The story of Mark of the Ninja follows an unnamed ninja. After waking from an extensive irezumi tattoo, he realizes his clan is under attack and manages to save his sensei, Azai, with the help of his ally, Ora. He learns that the tattoo he has acquired affords him heightened sensory abilities. But it will ultimately drive him progressively deeper into madness. The Ninjas resolve to take their revenge against the organization responsible for the attack on their clan. After the ninja vows to commit seppuku, the madness starts to take hold of him.

As far as the ninja archetype goes, the developers hit the nail on the head. The main character’s name is never revealed, he never speaks, he keeps his face hidden, wears navy blue attire, uses his tools for things other than attacking enemies, and he does his best to preserve his stealth and not go kill-crazy. But as far as the main story goes, it’s also very engrossing and has a good few twists and turns before the end.

Originality – 10/10

Especially in this day and age, it’s particularly difficult to create an original game in the 2D side-scrolling genre, since the formula has long been perfected and worked on by a multitude of big-name developers over the last 30 years. This game is perhaps one of the most unique side scrollers I’ve seen for many years now, since gameplay elements are taken from newer genres, adding a great deal to the 2D platforming formula, making it go leaps and bounds against many other games released in the genre today.

Happii

Overall, Mark of the Ninja is an exceptional indie game, and I would highly recommend it to anyone who owns an Xbox 360. It could have been made to last longer, but I’m hoping that’s where a possible sequel may come in.

Score

49/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Heart of Darkness (PlayStation)

Heart of Darkness

Developer – Amazing Studio

Publisher(s) – Infogrames Entertainment (Europe) & Interplay Entertainment (North America)

Designer(s) – Eric Chahi, Frederic Savoir, Fabrice Visserot & Daniel Morais

Producer – Bruce Broughton

ELSPA – 11+

Heart of Darkness was released for the PlayStation in mid-1998. So, just looking at the year, most gamers would know that it will have been up against some of the sternest competition the industry has ever seen. Competing against games such as Ocarina of Time and Banjo-Kazooie, which was released a day before. But having played this game, it’s not much of a surprise that it made as little of a commercial impact as it did. In my opinion, it’s about average. The most surprising element of this game for me was what age rating it got at the time. In both America and Europe, the ESRB (Electronic Software Rating Board) and ELSPA (European Leisure Software Publishing Association) rated this game as being suitable for all ages.

Despite the fact that there are numerous horrible ways in which the in-game character can be killed. Including him getting burnt to death, being eaten by carnivorous plants, being crushed, and being torn apart by enemies. And even falling from mountainsides. The Wikipedia article for the game says that it was rated 11+ by ELSPA. But according to the back of the box, it was also deemed suitable for children of 3-10 years as well as 11-14. But regardless, after playing this game and researching its background, I get the feeling that Eric Chahli was focusing more on the story than on the gameplay. He tried to emulate the success he garnered with the game Another World. But, in my opinion, it ended up thoroughly backfiring on him.

Graphics – 8/10

The best aspect of this game, and seemingly what the majority of the seven years it took to develop the game was spent on, is the visuals. The transition from the normal world into the Darklands was very intriguing. And it only gets even more so as the game progresses. The game’s settings and conceptual design actually somewhat remind me of the film Labyrinth. With the mountains and marshlands found around the beginning of the game. The gripe I have with the visuals is that the enemies are pretty generic. And it didn’t seem to me that a lot of thought was put into anything else other than the environmental design.

Gameplay – 7/10

I like it when games are challenging. And Heart of Darkness does indeed present a good few challenges throughout the game. Making it one of the hardest 2D side-scrollers I’ve ever played. But there are instances where the game is marred by its level of difficulty. One thing is guaranteed. Whether players are experienced 2D side-scrolling game players or not, they are guaranteed to die over and over and over again.

It can be particularly frustrating at times. And I don’t like games where difficulty can make them infuriating enough to just not play them past a certain point. This is the problem I had with the original Castlevania and Mega Man games. Although they are considered to be classics by many gamers, I just found both of them too hard and found myself dying too many times. Heart of Darkness, whilst it was instrumental in keeping the 2D side-scrolling genre alive in the midst of the transition into 3D, is certainly not without its off-putting difficulty, in my opinion.

Controls – 8/10

Another complication with this game is that the controls can be somewhat difficult to get to grips with at times. In a game, which may already seem too difficult for many gamers, including me, less-than-satisfactory controls can only add to any frustration. But for the most part, it is down to the player’s level of skill. And the core concept of the control scheme can be gotten to grips with after a while.

Lifespan – 3/10

On average, it can take experienced players to complete this game in about two and a half hours, which, for a PlayStation game, is unacceptable. Believe it or not, the game is also on two discs. Despite lasting such an intolerable amount of time. It’s hard to understand why people hold this game in such high regard today. Especially for the time that it was released. When there were so many other greater games for both the Nintendo 64 and PlayStation. In my opinion, like Tunguska, which I previously reviewed, I think it’s a good thing that this game remained so obscure. Although Heart of Darkness is nowhere near as bad a game as Tunguska.

Storyline – 5/10

Although the game’s story also reminded me of Labyrinth to a certain extent, it was still pretty average and certainly contained its flaws. The game’s story involves a boy named Andy. He is having problems with authority in school and is not doing very well. After getting in trouble, he runs away and meets his dog Whiskey in a park, where Whiskey is then subsequently sucked into a strange eclipse. And transported to another dimension, obligating Andy to get him back.

Luckily, Andy happens to be a genius inventor who specializes in inter-dimensional travel. Despite doing poorly at school, he finally finds a use for a ship he has coincidentally made in his treehouse to embark on an adventure to get his dog back. A lot of the story’s flaws come from how many plot details are so abruptly sprung on players trying to follow it. I’ve heard of things like this happening in games, films, etc. But they are much more elaborated on than this. And it just makes the story simply look like a collection of different things being randomly put together.

Originality – 8/10

Although the story is pretty far-fetched, it’s also unique to a certain extent. But most of the originality found in this game is through its settings and conceptual design. But as I said earlier, Eric Chahi focused originality and effort mostly on the story and scenery. And strayed too far from the gameplay aspect, in my opinion. Eric Chahi had previously designed another game called Another World, which is seen nowadays as a game best known for setting standards in video game storytelling. But with Heart of Darkness, it just seems to me that he simply banked on making a game just like Another World. And hoped that it would have the same impact on people. But it ended up not going in his favor this time around.

Niiutral

In summation, Heart of Darkness is a good-looking game, but that’s about it. It can be unfairly difficult at times, in my opinion at least. And it is far too short-lived for a late 90s video game. Whilst also having a pretty weak story to accompany it.

Score

36/60

6/10 (Average)

Legacy of Kain: Defiance (Xbox, PlayStation 2 & PC)

Legacy of Kain Defiance

Developer(s) – Crystal Dynamics & Nixxes Software

Publisher(s) – Eidos Interactive

Director – Amy Hennig

Producer – Rosaura Sandoval

PEGI – 16

Developed at the back end of the sixth generation of gaming, and the last game in the series to be released following the cancellation of both the MOBA Nosgoth and Legacy of Kain: Dead Sun, Legacy of Kain: Defiance offered a pretty different take on gameplay compared to the rest of the series. Whereby the player would assume control of both the central characters of the series, as opposed to them being alternated between games. To me, although it is the worst game of the series, that isn’t to say that it’s bad. Not by a long shot.

Graphics – 8/10

The visuals are about as extremely varied and as wonderfully disturbing as any other game in the series. Taking place across multiple time frames, like Soul Reaver 2, it portrays the land of Nosgoth from a multitude of different perspectives. From the time before the pillars collapsed to the time before Moebius would revive the Sarafan order and proceed to extinguish the vampires. The game also still maintains the dark and morbid atmosphere associated with the prior four games. As well as a feeling of isolation and helplessness. Adding a great deal of tension to the overall experience.

Gameplay – 6/10

Though three of the five games are generally linear in their style of play, Defiance took this to a whole other level. Largely to my disappointment. The combat is still quite varied, and there exists a very strong puzzle element reminiscent of the other games in the series. But there is considerably less to do than in the likes of the original Blood Omen or Soul Reaver. From a gameplay perspective, it is indeed the least enjoyable in the franchise. But in retrospect, the basic premise does have its strong points. And it is certainly worth at least one playthrough.

Controls – 7/10

The biggest problem I had with the game’s control scheme is that the camera angles can make playing the game needlessly complicated in some instances. Oftentimes, I found that the camera can be zoomed out a little bit too much. Making it hard for players to see what they are doing with the character. This becomes an especially big problem if they are trying to overcome certain platforming sequences that can be found throughout the game.

Lifespan – 7/10

Lasting about as long as either Blood Omen 2 or Soul Reaver 2, gamers can clock in around 15 to 20 hours. Which, whilst it isn’t a terrible lifespan, doesn’t go above and beyond anything that had already been released within the series at that point. The developers started with a game that lasted an exceptionally long time. And the lifespan of each game gradually became shorter and shorter. Which is an issue I have with the series in general. But Defiance clocks in as the shortest game from my experience.

Storyline – 10/10

A key difference between this game garnishing a 7 instead of a 6 for me, however, is that it has a fantastic storyline. Developed in a time when vampires could be considered cool. And before Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart spent five films staring at each other, Legacy of Kain: Defiance presents the latest chapter, portraying two vampires worth investing time into. The former ruler of Nosgoth, Kain, and his former lieutenant, Raziel.

Kain is in search of Raziel in order to deliver a warning to him. This will prevent any further catastrophe from happening within the land of Nosgoth. And to fulfill his own destiny as the fabled scion of balance. And Raziel, meanwhile, escapes from the underworld and his captor, the Elder God. To return to the physical world and find answers regarding his own purpose, and to realize his own free will. My brief synopsis really doesn’t do the story justice, in honesty. And it is worth playing the game to simply find out what happens. Something that I personally rarely advocate in my reviews.

Originality – 7/10

In terms of its narrative, the entire Legacy of Kain series easily has the best story ever told in a video game, in my own personal opinion. It went leaps and bounds ahead of any other video game story. And presented players with something reminiscent of classic literature and epic fantasy. From a gameplay perspective, however, there have been many different games like this, but with even greater variety. And Defiance doesn’t really stand out in that respect. Though it is fairly enjoyable to play through, there was most definitely room for improvement as well in terms of gameplay.

Happii

Overall, Legacy of Kain: Defiance is the worst game in the series, but it is nevertheless a joy to play through. If only for the story. Even so, the Issues I encountered with gameplay don’t make the title unplayable by any stretch of the imagination. And there’s plenty of addictive combat and puzzle-solving to keep players relatively busy throughout.

Score

45/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Mario Paint (Super Nintendo)

Mario Paint

Developer(s) – Nintendo R&D1 & Intelligent Systems

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Hirofumi Matsuoka

Producer – Gunpei Yokoi

PEGI – 3

Released on the Super Nintendo in 1992, and making use of the SNES mouse peripheral, Mario Paint allowed players to create their own personalized artwork within a video game. It was extremely well received by critics. AllGame even stated that it was  “perhaps the most ingenious and inspired idea Nintendo ever came up with for a product”. Although I personally wouldn’t label it as such, nor even give it a perfect score as they did, I do need to state, as a prerequisite, that I spent a lot of time playing this game. And I still think it holds up for various reasons.

Graphics – 6/10

Though many people may argue that Nintendo didn’t include much within the game to give players a rough idea of what possibilities lay before them. And the general layout of the games looks extremely empty; that was the point. The game was all about players having to use their own imagination to create whatever they saw fit. Though Nintendo had failed to put out a decent educational game before this, it was successful due to the fact that it would encourage creativity. Eventually, even led to schools contemplating using the same method. This game was also one of the first to include the famed Totaka’s song. This would become synonymous with many other big-name Nintendo releases.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

As well as creating pictures, the game also offers a variety of different activities. Including composing music pieces, animations, and even a hidden mini-game called Gnat Attack. Whereby players must swat various insects flying across the screen in a somewhat Galaga-esque fashion. Though the picture-drawing aspect may have been rendered redundant over the years, the game still retains a fair bit of replay value in these other activities. And whilst not deserving of a perfect high score, it does provide quite a bit of entertainment.

Controls – 10/10

Since this game primarily relied on the use of a mouse and pad, there were never going to be any problems. Especially at this point. Since home computers were well on their way to becoming something more than only used to play video games to a household necessity.

Originality – 9/10

Even though many of the ideas this game perpetuated have since been fazed out by PCs and laptops, the fact of the matter remains that there was no game like it at the time of its release. Many video games at the time may have spoken of creativity in their own ways. Despite the lack of technology compared to what is available now. But his game encouraged it in its players. As well as presenting them with a retro arcade gaming experience in the process.

Happii

Overall, Mario Paint stands out as one of the most unique gaming experiences on the Super Nintendo. It isn’t one of the greatest games to have ever been developed and hasn’t held up well with the times like many other games of the era have. But many gamers will still be able to find a use for it.

Score

31.5/40

7.5/10 (Good)

Mario Kart: Super Circuit (Game Boy Advance)

Mario Kart Super Circuit

Developer(s) – Intelligent Systems

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Takashi Ando & Yukio Morimoto

Producer(s) – Shigeru Miyamoto & Kenji Miki

PEGI – 3

Handing over the development of the series to Intelligent Systems, Mario Kart: Super Circuit marked the first time that the series appeared on a handheld console. It was well-received by critics upon release. Going on to become the fourth best-selling game on the system behind Pokémon Ruby & Sapphire, Pokémon Fire Red & Leaf Green, and Pokémon Emerald. Speaking as a long-time fan of the series, the contenders for the worst game, in my opinion, were this and Mario Kart: Double Dash!! But after having replayed both of them in recent years, I’ve come to the conclusion that Super Circuit is indeed the worst game in the series. But still, this is not to say that it’s a bad game. It’s just the worst of an excellent series.

Graphics – 5/10

One of the worst things about it is most definitely the conceptual design. The track-by-track ranges from good to barely passable. A lot of the ideas Nintendo tried for new track designs outside the usual tropes of the series are pretty poorly designed. Such as Cheese Land and Riverside Park. But at the same time, many tracks go along with the motifs of the series. Such as Peach Circuit and Mario Circuit, are also quite poorly designed. The best kinds of tracks in the game are those following the themes of Bowser’s Castle and the haunted house courses. The uniquely themed tracks also get fractionally better as the game progresses. But the best in conceptual design throughout the series would be yet to come.

Gameplay – 7/10

The game plays out like a mixture of both Super Mario Kart and Mario Kart 64. And for the most part, the courses do provide a fair level of challenge. But again, some courses can be criticized in this respect, too. Mario Circuit is a prominent example since it was placed in the Flower Cup. Yet I personally found it easier to win than Peach Circuit in the Mushroom Cup, which goes against not only the tradition of Mario Kart but that of gaming in general. Since games are supposed to get harder as they progress. Otherwise, it plays out just as well as any other game in the series.

Controls – 10/10

By proxy, there are also no issues with the controls. Both the prior games in the series had been largely a test of trial and error since they were drastically different from each other (with both of them passing that test). But somehow, the controls feel a lot smoother than Super Mario Kart, with elements of the control scheme of Mario Kart 64 thrown in. It seems easier to make narrow turns and easier to accurately aim weapons than in the original game.

Lifespan – 8/10

If players don’t have another gamer to partake in multiplayer with (which would make the game last for as long as their own interest in it), it can take fractionally longer than the original two games to complete. Since it has five tournaments as opposed to the traditional four. There are also additional game modes to add to the title’s longevity in the battle mode, quick run, and time trial modes. So fans of the series will have more than enough to do throughout.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

The Mario Kart series has never had a story attached to it, and it never should, I don’t think. At this point, especially, I believe that trying to add a story to a Mario Kart game would be a pretty bad move on Nintendo’s part unless they can do it in such a way that it does nothing to hinder gameplay to any kind of extent. It worked particularly well in Diddy Kong Racing. So if Mario Kart were to ever become an open-world kart game, a story may work.

Originality – 2/10

The Mario Kart series would later become quite innovative. Including several new features with each installment. But in Super Circuit, there is next to no innovation. As it was indeed largely influenced by the two prior games. Nintendo tried to create a game that was more evolutionary rather than revolutionary, but due to the mixed quality of track design, I didn’t find it to be the evolutionary experience that Nintendo intended it to be.

Happii

However, much as I’ve complained about Mario Kart: Super Circuit, it remains a solid gaming experience, and much better than any generic racing game that was either out at the time or what had been released prior, or even that has been released since. To me, it’s acceptable since it plays out as any Mario Kart game should, but other games in the series have since gone above and beyond what was on offer here.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Mario Kart: Double Dash (GameCube)

Mario Kart Double Dash

Developers(s) – Nintendo EAD

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Kiyoshi Mizuki, Yasuyuki Oyagi, Futoshi Shirai & Daiji Imai

Producer(s) – Shigeru Miyamoto, Tadashi Sugiyama, Shinya Takahashi & Takashi Tezuka

PEGI – 3

The fourth installment to the most successful spin-off series in video gaming history, Mario Kart: Double Dash provided gamers with a slightly different take on the kart racing genre, by adding the feature of having two characters to each kart allowing for more weapons to be held at any one given time, and also allowing for online play; though in a much-limited capacity to what gamers of this day and age are accustomed to. Unfortunately, however, I’ve never thought as much of this game as many other entries in the franchise. It would be a choice for me between this and Super Circuit as the two main contenders for “the” worst game in the series, for several reasons.

Graphics – 5/10

One reason why I believe this game doesn’t match the quality of most other Mario Kart titles is that the visuals are not the best on the GameCube, either from a graphical or conceptual standpoint. The tracks are some of the worst in the series, even including my all-time least favorite track, Baby Park. Aside from that, it also had most probably the worst incarnation of Rainbow Road in the entire series. There are a select few tracks that stand out, but nowhere on the same level as the track in entries such as Mario Kart 8, Wii, or even 7.

Gameplay – 6/10

For the most part, the game plays out pretty much like any other Mario Kart game, and the addition of a second driver does make for an interesting twist in gameplay since players can be at a disadvantage if the passenger falls off after taking too many hits from items. The problems are that most of the tracks in the game don’t necessarily make for a particularly grueling challenge, instead of the series’ tradition, and they also added something else, which has been a recurring thing in other Mario Kart games, something I have never been a fan of: cannons. In some tracks, some cannons transport players from one area of the course to the other, and to me, it’s always been a sign of developers literally cutting corners.

Controls – 10/10

The best thing I can say about this game is that despite the introduction of new mechanics, it stays true to the classic Mario Kart formula, and consequently, there are no complications to address. The only problem that can be even vaguely associated with it is that the sound effects of switching drivers can become relentlessly repetitive.

Lifespan – 8/10

Completing each tournament in each class can take up to 5 to 6 hours, but after that, if players have access to the Internet via the GameCube, they can, of course, indulge in online play, which will add even more to the lifespan; an idea which, in all fairness, I am pretty happy to have seen become a staple of the series. There is also a little bit more incentive added in the unlockable characters and unlockable cars; something else that would become a regular feature, much to my delight.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

The Mario Kart series has never had a story attached to it, and it never should, I don’t think. At this point, especially, I believe that trying to add a story to a Mario Kart game would be a pretty bad move on Nintendo’s part unless they can do it in such a way that it does nothing to hinder gameplay to any kind of extent. It worked particularly well in Diddy Kong Racing, so if Mario Kart were to ever become an open-world kart game, a story may work.

Originality – 3/10

As I’ve reiterated, Double Dash ultimately plays out like most other games in the series, only being much less enjoyable. It does have the one saving grace of having two characters to every one kart, but the cannons throughout a good few of the tracks in this series started a trend, which I personally would rather not have seen started, making this game original, but for what are, in my opinion, the wrong reasons.

Happii

To summarize, however, although Mario Kart: Double Dash makes for a bad Mario Kart game, it doesn’t necessarily make for a bad game in general. It’s much more enjoyable than a fair few other sixth-generation games released at the time, and it still beats any other generic racing game out there hands down.

Scores

43/60

7/10 (Fair)

Mario Kart 8 (Wii U & Switch)

Mario Kart 8

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Group No 1

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Kosuke Yabuki

Producer – Hideki Konno

PEGI – 3

Boasting new tracks, anti-gravity mechanics, and, of course, online multiplayer, Mario Kart 8 has warranted a small boost in Wii U sales over the last two weeks. But for how good this game is, and how good past games for the system have been, I think the Wii U deserved more than a small boost in sales.

Graphics – 9/10

The majority of the new tracks, namely Sunshine Airport, Twisted Mansion, Thwomp Ruins, and Cloudtop Cruise, among others, are exceptionally brilliant in design. And posthumously make up for the traditional inclusion of some of the more generic ones. Such as Mario Kart Stadium and Mario Circuit. The level of detail put into every other track is staggering. Making it even more possible than in previous games to get too caught up in the scenery to concentrate on the race.

Furthermore, the retro stages are also visually breathtaking. Most of which are redesigned to the point of being scarcely recognizable. For example, Grumble Volcano from Mario Kart Wii, a track I’d thought to be somewhat generic in the original version, has been given an extremely different feel. Now looking comparable to the land of Mordor, it’s as if The Lord of the Rings has taken over for a part of the game. And it’s a massive improvement on the original version.

Gameplay – 9/10

As a veteran Mario Kart player, I already had a very good idea of what I would be getting. Deceptively unforgiving as normal, Mario Kart 8 presents a challenge on a particularly large scale, even on 50cc at times. Though I’ve yet to play online, I can already tell that I am in for something, particularly testing. In terms of gameplay, however, I did find a fault with the implementation of anti-gravity segments. I found that whilst the novelty is there, it doesn’t add as much to the table as I’d anticipated, and doesn’t necessarily add to the challenge either.

There are some tracks where it works a bit better than others. But for the most part, it seems a little redundant. But the worst thing about Mario Kart 8, I believe, is the inclusion of coins as part of the item roster. People may say that adds to the challenge. But in my opinion, that can add quite a bit of unnecessary frustration when players are in front and need something to defend themselves with. It may be in homage to the original game, but there’s a good reason why they were removed. However, despite these two faults, this game is still exceptionally fun to play.

Controls – 10/10

Tailored to play using a variety of different means, I can say that there are no problems with the game’s control scheme. I did have concerns that the controls would suffer because of the anti-gravity feature. But Nintendo has handled it flawlessly. And players can virtually skip from Mario Kart Wii to Mario Kart 8 without skipping a beat. There are two changes to playing the game with the Wii remote. But that doesn’t take any time at all to get used to.

Lifespan – N/A (10/10)

It will take about half an hour to play through each tournament. And there are four traditional classes to complete each tournament. So that should take about 16 hours overall. But after that, there’s the online play to immerse players, which will make for hours upon hours of entertainment. As a racing game, there is no fixed lifespan, simply making for a game that can be picked up and played without much worry about making conventional progress beyond the Grand Prix mode.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

The Mario Kart franchise has never needed a story attached to it. And there was no reason why they would start now. Maybe in the future, a sort could be implemented to make an installment play out more like Diddy Kong Racing as opposed to staying in line with tradition in order to mix things up. But lack of story is nothing that Mario Kart 8 should lose marks for, in my opinion.

Originality – 5/10

A lack of uniqueness, on the other hand, is something I think that the game should lose marks on. On the one hand, it’s wonderful how the developers have designed the latest tracks. And how they’ve painstakingly remastered old tracks for the retro tournaments. But on the other hand, I was sorely disappointed by how underwhelming the anti-gravity feature is. Bearing in mind that it has been one of the game’s main selling points for the longest time. Also, I found that the character roster is a little bit generic compared to others in the series. I think the inclusion of Bowser’s minions may have been a mistake, as I can think of many more standout Mario characters than they are, who could have been included instead.

Deliirious

Overall, however, I think Mario Kart 8 is a particularly impressive game with all the fun and challenge of a traditional game in the franchise, and it makes for one of the best gaming experiences of 2014. I would have advocated people buy the Wii U over the Xbox One before the release of this game, but I think this game warrants a lot more units to be sold.

Score

53/60

8.5/10 (Great)

Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour (GameCube)

Mario Golf Toadstool Tour

Developer(s) – Camelot Software Planning

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Designer – Shigeru Miyamoto

PEGI – 3

Developed simultaneously alongside another Mario spin-off game, Mario Power Tennis, Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour was released to widespread critical acclaim. And went on to sell over 1 million units as of 2007. Common criticisms stemmed from reviewers who believed that it was far too similar to the first game. But personally, I strongly disagree with this opinion. Toadstool Tour is far better than the original for several reasons.

Graphics – 8/10

Though the graphics were expectedly better on a technical level than the first Mario Golf game on the Nintendo 64, there also conceptually better. The courses are a lot more varied. And obstacles within them do better to fit in with the overall tableau of the Super Mario series itself. But the most significant improvement in terms of conceptual design is most definitely in the character roster. All of the generic characters seen in the previous game, such as Plum, Vinnie, and Charlie, have been removed and replaced with more varied and familiar characters. Such as Birdo, Diddy Kong, and Boo.

Gameplay – 8/10

The gameplay formula was also greatly refined in Toadstool Tour. It’s much easier for players to be able to judge their shot and take into account all the different factors that may affect it. Such as wind direction and required distance. I also like the fact that the developers abandoned the small RPG element that was present in the first in order to unlock each different course and replaced it with the much simpler system of winning each tournament to unlock the next.

Controls – 10/10

Toadstool Tour’s control scheme functions almost identically to the original game. So consequently, there was never going to be a problem. With players basically being able to jump between the two games without skipping a beat. It’s also simple enough for people who have never tried any of the Mario Golf games. Making it the ideal introduction to the series.

Originality – 7/10

Whilst it is indeed somewhat similar to the original game, it’s nowhere near as similar to what other critics have made it out to be in the past, in my opinion. Several different factors make this game much greater than the first one. But the majority of the many licensed golf games have been developed prior; it’s a lot more fun to play, and the game modes are much more varied. It’s just one of many examples of how Nintendo has managed to implement as much creativity as they have in their spin-off games, as well as main entries in their series.

Happii

Overall, Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour is one of the more entertaining yet one of the more relaxing games on the GameCube as well. The developers went leaps and bounds ahead of what they had created with the first game, and as a result, I personally spent a lot of time playing it at the time of its release and would recommend anyone pick it up and give it a try.

Score

31/40

7.5/10 (Good)

Malice (PlayStation 2 & Xbox)

Malice

Developer(s) – Argonaut Games

Publisher(s) – Mud Duck Productions & Evolved Games

Director – Phil Morris

Producer – Andy Pang

PEGI – 7

Malice was a game released back in 2004, loosely based on Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland. But truth be told, the finished product is nowhere near as imaginative or culturally impactful. In fact, the most interesting thing about this game is its development history. At first, it was intended for release on the original PlayStation back in the late 90s. However, due to the first of many production management mishaps, the idea was subsequently scrapped in favor of releasing the game as an Xbox launch title in late 2001.

In 2002, having failed to get the game out in time, it was announced that members of the band No Doubt were to lend their voice talents to the project. With lead singer Gwen Stefani providing the role of the game’s titular main character, Malice. The band said in an interview that they were particularly excited to see their music reach a wider audience in the video gaming industry. By early 2003, Argonaut had yet to get the game out to retailers. The company faced hardships, including financial problems (as they’d spent millions of dollars developing the game) and further corporate meddling. And even the untimely death of one of their conceptual artists, Alecsandar Ilic, who tragically passed away at the age of 30. It was announced on May 30th that the game had been canceled.

Afterward, a different company got publishing rights, and the project was subsequently revived. And the game was eventually released in 2004 to a very mediocre reception from both gamers and reviewers alike. And after having played it, it’s no wonder why.

Graphics – 4/10

Everything about this game is seemingly rushed, and the visuals are no exception. From the get-go, I kept thinking to myself that it looks like it could indeed easily run on the original PlayStation. As the game looked a generation old for the time. On top of that, I think the game just looks inherently generic. In that, the settings and the character, enemy, and boss designs are all pretty unimaginative and annoying in some cases. Like the crows in suits who let out irritating noises as they attack or take damage. Another issue I have with it is that it baffles me how it only runs at 30 frames per second when it just looks like it ought to run at 60, and how bad it looks.

Gameplay – 3/10

Even though it was released on the original PlayStation, the game’s play is too simplistic, insubstantial, and boring to have held up. A 3D platforming game, it has merely one side quest, unrefined combat, no replay value whatsoever, and terrible, drawn-out boss fights. I was fighting the second boss for about ten minutes with very little difficulty, just wanting above all else for it to be over.

Controls – 6/10

The main gripes I have about this game’s control scheme involve jumping mechanics. If jumping mechanics aren’t done right in a platforming game, players will know instantly that there’ll be problems throughout. One of the most stable elements of platforming games is the ability to jump from platform to platform. Another problem I had with this game was the inability to move my character while trying to attack. Every time the player presses the attack button, Malice stands completely still and swings her weapon, which eliminates any fluency in combat and unnecessarily complicates things.

Lifespan – 5/10

For even a late 90s platforming game to last less than 10 hours is absolutely unacceptable. If Argonaut Games truly wanted this game to last longer or do well, they needed an extra push in every department before launch. But unfortunately, they couldn’t do that. Presumably having blown a lot of their budget on hiring No Doubt to provide voice acting for the game. Which didn’t happen anyway.

Storyline – 3/10

The game’s story follows the quest of a red-haired goddess called Malice. Who is aiming to save the world by restoring power to a machine called the orrery and defeating an evil demon called Dog God? It’s laughable at best. No character can be taken seriously because the voice acting that was eventually used in the end is farcical. In addition, the story is extremely flawed and hardly makes any sense.

Originality – 0/10

There is absolutely nothing in this game that I haven’t seen before, and would never want to see again. I never want to see a combat system so unrefined, an in-game world that looks like someone threw up in the console. And a story that no one in their right mind would care to follow.

Furiious

My biggest piece of advice to anyone who picks this game up in a shop and reads the part of the synopsis on the box that says “fantastic graphics, fluid gameplay, compelling storyline, and funny characterization” is to not pay attention to it because of its false advertisement. Malice has none of those things.

Score

21/60

3.5/10 (Very Poor)