Tag Archives: 3D Platformer

Yoshis Woolly World

Yoshi’s Woolly World (Wii U)

Developer(s) – Good-Feel Co.

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Atsushi Kono & Naoya Abe

Producer(s) – Etsunobu Ebisu, Keita Kawaminami & Takashi Tezuka

PEGI – 3

The first Yoshi game to be released on a home console since Yoshi’s Story back in 1998, Yoshi’s Woolly World stays true to the core mechanics of all the other Yoshi games released throughout the years. But also provides a level of challenge unseen in most other games on the Wii U. Whilst this game isn’t as creative or unique as Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker, for example, it’s certainly a stern effort from Nintendo, and certainly goes above and beyond its Nintendo 64 counterpart.

Graphics – 8/10

Deriving influence from the Wii game Kirby’s Epic Yarn, the scenery and style of the game are made up of cloth and woolly textures, which look extraordinarily realistic. Even against video games developed with more advanced hardware than the Wii U, the many different worlds found in the game, in lieu of the franchise’s tradition, also have their own themes and elements similar to any Super Mario game. Whilst it may not be as varied as Yoshi’s Island, which had much more menacing locations. As well as innocent-looking ones, it still has quite a bit of variety about it compared to most other games.

Gameplay – 8/10

The mechanics and the objective of the game are more or less identical to those of both Yoshi’s Island and Yoshi’s Story. Clear each level and fight the boss at the end of the world, rinse, and repeat. What makes Woolly World different from the others, however, is not the level of challenge involved in simply clearing each level. But the challenge is completing every level to 100%.

The secret levels, in particular, can prove extremely testing to clear. Nintendo wanted gamers to be able to explore every nook and cranny of every level to find every secret. But they certainly didn’t make doing that easy. But this isn’t to say that the game is inaccessible. For those who are having too much trouble with it, there is a simplified version that can be played instead to suit both parties of a gamer. Something I think should be done with every other video game that can be considered overly hard.

Controls – 10/10

Since this game plays out identically to every other previous Yoshi side scroller, there are no unnecessary complications with the control scheme. However, I did think it was somewhat interesting to be able to move Yoshi around in 3D environments throughout each overworld. It made me think about what may have been if Nintendo and Argonaut Games had still been in partnership with one another throughout the fifth generation of gaming. And that if a 3D Yoshi game had been released instead of Argonaut breaking off and making Croc: Legend of the Gobbos out of what ideas were left from the previous project.

Lifespan – 7/10

To complete everything in the game will take around 15 to 20 hours, which, whilst being about the average of most side scrollers on the Wii U, is still fairly impressive. Classic side scrollers could only be made to last a fraction of that timescale. But their respective franchises have been kept fresh with the inclusion of new side quests and extracurricular activities. And Woolly World is no exception. I’ve highly anticipated this game since its announcement at last year’s E3. And I was satisfied to see that it lasted this long.

Storyline – 6/10

The plot of the game, again in lieu of the Super Mario tradition, is very straightforward; Yoshi must rescue all the other Yoshis after being unraveled and scattered by the wizard Kamek. And must then take the fight to Bowser Jnr. The story of Yoshi’s Island was a little more interesting. Not only did it put players in the shoes of another character from the series. But it also explored the origins of Mario himself. Unfortunately, Woolly World doesn’t have very many interesting elements like that. And consequently, it makes much less of an impact in terms of story.

Originality – 6/10

In addition to having an unoriginal story, Yoshi’s Woolly World itself is also somewhat unoriginal, bar the inclusion of a much longer lifespan. And a heightened level of challenge. The art direction may be much different from that of the rest of the Yoshi games. But, of course, the same developer used the same visual gimmick in Kirby’s Epic Yarn. It may look very good and very realistic in this game. But it’s been done before. I don’t think recycling boss characters helped matters either.

Happii

However, despite what it lacks in both story and uniqueness, Yoshi’s Woolly World makes up for its gameplay above all else. It’s still a very enjoyable experience. And I recommend it to anyone with a Wii U. It’s certainly a better exclusive than many Xbox One games. It will prove a challenge to any fan of the platforming genre.

Score

45/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Wario World (Nintendo GameCube)

Wario World

Developer(s) – Treasure

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Kouichi Kimura & Hitoshi Yamagami

Producer(s) – Takahiro Izushi & Masato Maegawa

PEGI – 3

Released somewhat late into the GameCube’s shelf life, Wario World provided a different take on what players had seen on that particular console. But not so different from what they had already seen on past systems. I have played many worse games. But this is the first and last Nintendo game that Treasure ever developed, and understandably so.

Graphics – 7/10

One aspect I don’t think I should criticize too much is the visuals. There is some diversity present in both level and boss designs. The enemies and characters that can be found throughout the game are not as generic as they seem at first glance. To list a few examples, the five Spritelings to be found in each level (in itself a reference to the Jinjos in the Banjo-Kazooie series) closely resemble Pikmin, and the fact that the purple flying dinosaur enemies can be seen as an homage to Ridley from the Metroid series. The Magon enemies found from the very first level closely resemble Bowser from the Super Mario series. The fact that there is a skeletal variation of the Magon would seem to clarify this even further.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

The game is a 3D platformer. But not made in the same vein as what was popular at the time. But rather made to be much more linear. And as a result, I think it suffered. It is enjoyable for a time. But it could be argued that it is far too easy. Even for a Mario game, and even to complete it to 100%.

Its level of difficulty is made obvious to me by the fact that there are even the Magons in the first few levels that don’t attack the player. However, it is interesting to be able to identify the different influences the developers took to create the game’s play. Not just from Nintendo games. For example, the level and world layout are very similar to the first three Crash Bandicoot games. And the ability to spin enemies around and throw them hearkens back to the strategy of defeating Bowser in Super Mario 64.

Controls – 10/10

Another thing I shouldn’t complain about is the game’s control scheme. Although it is an easy game regardless, it could have done with no complications in terms of controls. And thankfully, there are none.

Lifespan – 4.5/10

As a 3D platformer made in the same vein as classic Crash Bandicoot, the linearity of it, unfortunately, made for a particularly disappointing and short experience of about 5 hours. Particularly from Nintendo’s point of view, I imagine that it would have seemed like a particularly underwhelming experience, since many other games released on that system, including 3D platformers, were made to last considerably longer. And provide much more entertainment.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of the game follows Super Mario antagonist Wario, who is on a quest to reclaim his riches after they are turned into monsters by the evil anthropomorphic black jewel. Which Wario had recently acquired. The only good thing I would say about it is that it is slightly different from most other plots across the Super Mario franchise since it tells a story from the point of view of evil as opposed to that of good. But it still can be seen as nothing overly special and pretty mundane.

Originality – 4/10

Although the game does have its charms here and there, in lieu of Nintendo tradition, it’s still bland enough and far too packed with recycled elements for me to be able to legitimately call it original, especially in terms of gameplay. After pioneering the 3D platforming genre with Super Mario 64, and then going on to make a ton of successful games in the same genre, it seems to me that with this game, Nintendo was actually going back on themselves; something that they rarely do. Nintendo had always pioneered itself as innovators, but it’s evident to me that innovation wasn’t a watchword at Treasure during development.

Niiutral

In summation, Wario World isn’t the worst game ever developed, but it’s certainly not one of the best either. It was below par by any level of standards ever set by Nintendo and gives testament to the fact that not all developer collaborations can work out well.

Score

38/60

6/10 (Average)

The Hobbit (Xbox, PC, PlayStation 2, GameCube & Game Boy Advance)

The Hobbit

Developer(s) – Inevitable Entertainment, The Fizz Factor & Saffire

Publisher(s) – Sierra Entertainment

Designer – Chuck Lupher

Producer(s) – Jaime Grieves

PEGI – 7

Amidst the newfound popularity of the Tolkien mythos surrounding the Lord of the Rings film trilogy directed by Peter Jackson, and amidst an ongoing dispute regarding the rights to the Tolkien license, with multiple games based on the books and films being developed at the time, The Hobbit was released to mixed reviews from critics. Who cited the gameplay as being uninspiring, and its failure to appeal to younger gamers.

In the industry, licensed games have, for the most part, been generally frowned upon. And seen as simply being a modern form of shovelware. With the owners of their respective licenses simply releasing games to coincide with films for the most part. However, there are a select few licensed games that go above and beyond what is expected of them. And end up offering some legitimately enjoyable gaming experiences. In my opinion, whilst The Hobbit may not be among the best, it’s certainly not among the worst, I find.

Graphics – 6.5/10

One aspect that the game falls short on somewhat is the visuals. Whilst they may have looked fairly impressive at the time, they don’t hold up nearly as well on a technical level as many other games of their kind do. Such as Final Fantasy X and Metal Gear Solid 2, to name but a few. Like the game based on the first volume of The Lord of the Rings trilogy, developed by WPX Games & Surreal Software, it largely conforms to the same conceptual design as in the films. But there are a couple of standout elements that did fairly well to separate it from both the initial Peter Jackson film trilogy. And the aforementioned game at the time of its release, at least (before the Hobbit film trilogy came out years later, as well as Lego The Hobbit). Such as locations like Lake Town, Mirkwood, and Erebor.

Gameplay – 7/10

For the most part, playing out like a traditional 3D platformer, the game also has a few little side quests thrown in for good measure during the first half of it. Like the previously mentioned Lord of the Rings game. Most notably involving completing the tasks for the dwarves before the party departs for The Lonely Mountain. There is also a small stealth aspect. This fits in fairly well with the tableau of the story of Bilbo Baggins being hired as a thief. And which I moderately enjoyed. Stealth can be quite a tricky aspect to pull off in games. As it can eliminate fluency if it requires players to play through the same area a certain number of times. But for the most part, it’s done fairly well in this title, in my opinion.

Controls – 10/10

As far as 3D platforming in this game goes, I had no gripes with it whatsoever. Which, in all fairness, was to be expected, I think. As the genre had well and truly taken prominence at this time. Following the release of games such as Super Mario 64 and Jak & Daxter. Combat and stealth are also both handled adequately well. And there are no unnecessary complications with the game’s control scheme present to add any kind of unwarranted level of frustration.

Lifespan – 6/10

The game can be made to last an average of 8 hours, even taking in the completion of side quests throughout the course of the game, which, whilst it isn’t great by any means, is still fractionally longer than the game based on The Lord of the Rings license, which can be made to last around 6 to 7 hours. As the game conforms to a very linear progression, it wasn’t expected to have a great lifespan in any case, but I can’t help but think that with a little bit more imagination on the developer’s part, it could have been made to last at least a little while longer; certainly, the first part of the game is set in the Shire.

Storyline – 8/10

Depicting the events of the classic children’s novel written by JRR Tolkien, The Hobbit follows the exploits of Bilbo Baggins of the Shire. He is persuaded by the wizard Gandalf and his band of 13 dwarves to accompany them on an adventure to retake the dwarven city of Erebor from the dragon Smaug. The story itself isn’t an issue at all since it’s enjoyable in any form that it’s told. Be that through a game, a film, or most notably, of course, a classic book. The biggest problem I had with it, however, is that the voice acting is quite lackluster. Even by video game standards at that time. And thus, it’s much more difficult to take seriously than in other forms of media in which the story would be told.

Originality – 6/10

The game does retain a slight element of uniqueness. It incorporates the aforementioned stealth element. Which, at this point, was only really seen in the Sly Cooper games. However, for the most part, it plays out like most other 3D platformers that were released before their time, and consequently, I don’t think it can be considered either evolutionary or revolutionary. The stealth mechanics in the Sly Cooper games were much more sophisticated than in this title. And in terms of normal 3D platforming mechanics, it fails to stand out amidst many of the classics in the genre that had been released prior.

Happii

In summation, despite its lack of originality and less-than-satisfactory voice acting, The Hobbit is nevertheless a fairly enjoyable gaming experience. And shouldn’t be entirely overlooked. Whilst the visuals may not hold up to this day on a technical level, and whilst more could have been added to increase the game’s longevity, the developers did a good job for the most part, and it’s certainly worth at least one playthrough, for both fans of the Tolkien mythos and the 3D platforming genre.

Score

43.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

Super Mario Sunshine (GameCube)

Super Mario Sunshine

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Yoshiaki Koizumi & Kenta Usui

Producer(s) – Shigeru Miyamoto & Takashi Tezuka

PEGI – 3

Following on from the immense success of Super Mario 64 back in 1996, Nintendo released Super Mario Sunshine on the GameCube in 2002 and went on to receive overwhelmingly positive critical acclaim, with many publications giving it a perfect score. And the Japanese website Famitsu also gives a near-perfect score. One of the very few games at that time to achieve such an honor. Personally, however, I can understand why critics and players alike appreciate this game to the extent that they do. With it presenting a new and outlandish style of play that had never been seen in a Super Mario game prior, it seemed like too much of a step down from Super Mario 64. And there were fundamentals that I feel the developers didn’t handle as well as they should have.

Graphics – 7/10

In terms of conceptual design, Nintendo was at least able to break away from many of the normal conventions that were within the series at that time. And take it to an entirely new setting with new types of supporting characters. Very effectively expanding the mythos of the entire Super Mario universe. Something that arguably needed to happen for some time before the release of this game. It was also the first time FMVs had been implemented in a Mario game. This helped it to showcase what kind of graphics the Nintendo GameCube was capable of processing in its early shelf life.

Gameplay – 5/10

After the prolonged success of 3D platforming games on the Nintendo 64, Super Mario Sunshine was Nintendo’s attempt at bringing something new to the table. Introducing new gameplay mechanics in the form of Mario’s new companion, F.L.U.D.D. A water hose, which Mario must use to clean areas of land in order to get around. And to use a weapon against enemies and bosses. The problem I had with this game, however, is that there are several game-breaking glitches throughout. This made me believe that it was left unfinished overall. It was highly unorthodox by Nintendo’s standards, making this game one of the first true signs of weakness I personally witnessed within the gaming industry. Yoshi’s Story did little to impress me when I was a kid. But I naturally expected much more from a Mario game. And unfortunately, in this instance, my expectations were not met.

Controls – 8/10

Another way in which Nintendo could be seen as going back on itself in this instance is in the game’s control scheme. It ultimately plays out almost identically to Super Mario 64. But the new mechanics can take some getting used to at first. And even after this, I found them to be somewhat unresponsive at times. Overall, it was a little dissatisfying to see this after Nintendo had pioneered such a sophisticated control scheme with Super Mario 64.

Lifespan – 8/10

One good thing I can say about this game, however, is that for those who may not experience as much of a problem with it as I did, there is certainly a fairly lengthy experience to be had. It lasts just as long as any 3D platforming Mario game, around 30 to 40 hours can be clocked. Which is pretty impressive. In general, it surprised me how such long games could be stored on mini discs when I first started playing the GameCube. I saw it with both Wind Waker and Metroid Prime. But his game is yet another shining example of this.

Storyline – 6.5/10

The story of Super Mario Sunshine takes place on a vacation island called Delfino. In which an unidentified figure has been vandalizing large sections of the resort. Once Mario and the company touch down, ready to take their own vacation, Mario is immediately and wrongfully identified by the Delfino authorities as being the vandal. And is sentenced to clean up the mess that has been made with the aid of F.L.U.D.D. At first, it seemed like a positive change from the damsel in distress story that had become synonymous with the series, even at that point. But over time, that’s exactly what it unfolds into, overall making it not much different from any other Mario game.

Originality – 7/10

Despite Nintendo’s unwillingness to provide a great deal of uniqueness in terms of story, I do respect their willingness to try something new in terms of gameplay. Which, after all, is much more important than the former. There would be many more 3D platformers released throughout the sixth generation of gaming that would blow this title out of the water. Such as Jak & Daxter and Ratchet & Clank. But this game was able to at least stand out among these others to the extent that it did.

Niiutral

Overall, Super Mario Sunshine is my least favorite 3D Mario game. But it’s by no means the worst game in the franchise overall. There are gamers out there who hold this title in much higher regard than I do. And this is understandably so. But to me, there were far too many faults found with it to be able to call it a classic game.

Score

41.5/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Super Mario Galaxy (Wii)

Super Mario Galaxy

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Tokyo

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Yoshiaki Koizumi

Producer(s) – Takao Shimizu & Shigeru Miyamoto

PEGI – 3

The official 3D platformer in the series since Super Mario Sunshine on the GameCube, Super Mario Galaxy presented players with the most innovative Mario game since the days of the Nintendo 64. And has since become a cult classic. It is considered a must-have game for anyone who owns a Wii. It is indeed a very unique game and makes for one of the better titles on the Wii overall. Even at the time of its release, I did have one or two issues with it. This prevented me from being able to personally consider it to be one of the best Mario games of all time.

Graphics – 9/10

The conceptual design of Super Mario Galaxy is also unlike any other Mario game to have ever been developed prior. Introducing players to a world made up of standalone galaxies and traversable planets. There is also a wide variety of new characters and settings, which have since become staples of the series. Appearing in the likes of Mario Kart 7 and 8. On top of that, there is also an extremely effective use of lighting and textural detail. Indeed, factors like that make the final cutscene one of the most breathtaking I’ve ever seen in any video game in general.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

Playing out very similarly to Super Mario 64. But going unanimously beyond the quality of Super Mario Sunshine, it involves simply traversing each stage of the game to collect as many stars as possible. And thereby ultimately reaching the last boss. There are a good few stars to collect, with the added incentive of being able to play as Luigi once this is done. And then being given additional objectives afterward. There is also a ton of new power-ups for players to take advantage of in order to progress through the game. Such as the ability to transform into a bee or even one of the boos.

Controls – 9.5/10

Normally, when video games try to incorporate a new or unique control scheme, it usually becomes a question of trial and error. Such as in Lair or Sunset Overdrive. But it’s surprising to see how few issues there are in Super Mario Galaxy. Considering how different and off-the-wall it is compared to not only other Mario games before it, but other video games in general. There is one or two issues regarding the camera angle. But they don’t become anywhere near enough of a problem to render the game unplayable by any means.

Lifespan – 6/10

The one thing I was disappointed by, however, was the game’s lifespan. To do everything will take an average of roughly 20 hours. Taking into account things like larger-level designs than in Super Mario 64. And more to play for than in Super Mario Sunshine seems evermore underwhelming. It wasn’t until three years later that every single issue I had with this game was addressed in the sequel, including lifespan. But I don’t think the game should lose out on too many marks. Since it lasts considerably longer than many other mainstream releases.

Storyline – 7/10

Although the story follows the same basic premise as most other Mario games (Mario must save Peach from Bowser, and the job is done), it does have a few things differentiating it from other Mario games. The basis of the game’s story involves Mario having to travel through outer space through various portals within an observatory occupied by the new character Rosalina and her companions, the Lumas. A race of people resembling stars. It makes for settings and characters very different from anything else seen in either most Mario or most other Nintendo games, for that matter. And the fact that the basic objective remains the same also remains forgivable as well.

Originality – 9/10

Super Mario Galaxy is undoubtedly one of the most unique games on the Wii. And one of the most unique titles of the seventh generation in general. Introducing gameplay mechanics that gamers may have thought couldn’t possibly work otherwise, it was popular enough to spawn a second game and did extremely well to expand on the Super Mario mythos even further. It could be argued that a lot of the ideas in this game stemmed from the canceled Sega Saturn game Sonic Xtreme. But I think this game would have been more impressive if the latter had been released anyway. Since it takes advantage of an entirely new control scheme and way of playing games.

Happii

In summation, Super Mario Galaxy is indeed a must-have for Nintendo Wii owners. And one of the better Mario titles in recent years. Though the sequel would arrive sometime later and blow this game out of the water, in my opinion, this was an extremely good starting point and remains something that players come back to again and again.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Super Mario 3D World (Wii U)

Super Mario 3D World

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Tokyo & 1-Up Studios

Publisher – Nintendo

Director(s) – Koichi Hayashida & Kenta Motokura

Producer(s) – Yoshiaki Koizumi

PEGI – 3

Super Mario 3D World has been incredibly well received by critics even before its release in all regions in November 2013. With publications such as Eurogamer, Joystiq, and Destructoid giving the game perfect scores. Both the critical and commercial standpoints seemed to be that this was the reason why people should own a Wii U. But sadly, despite what a good game this is, it has been very much overlooked in both the US and the UK, in particular.

In my opinion, it’s nowhere near as great as a lot of the old Mario games. And not even as great as Super Mario Galaxy 2. However, I don’t think Nintendo deserved to have this game so widely neglected in the Western market. It’s an enjoyable game and definitely one of the best Mario games in recent years. Surpassing the likes of the New Super Mario Bros 2. And its predecessor, Super Mario 3D Land, in quality by some margin.

Graphics – 8/10

Whilst the visuals aren’t exactly cutting-edge, as indeed they’re not really supposed to be, the conceptual design of the in-game world and its inhabitants is typical of any Mario game. Wonderfully weird. There’s a nice blend of both classic and new enemies to contend with. As well as a mixture of old and new settings. Most of the different levels in the game are also very intricately designed. And greatly encourage a certain level of exploration in order to find hidden items. Which is always a plus.

But sometimes, I can’t help but feel as if some of the levels are also recycled versions of old ones. As indeed has been the case in other recent Mario games. I also found a few of the boss fights pretty generic. They were clearly recycled from Super Mario 3D Land. However, what sets this game apart from 3D Land is the fact that this game thankfully includes more original bosses than generic ones. A lot like the bosses found in the Super Mario Galaxy series. I’m also a sucker for water effects in games. And Super Mario 3D World certainly has great water design, too.

Gameplay – 8/10

The gameplay is the most important aspect of any game, and Super Mario 3D World certainly delivers in style. Massive improvements have been made to Super Mario 3D Land. In that, there is a lot more variety and things to do. As with the settings and enemies, the gameplay is a very exciting blend of both old and new elements of the Mario franchise. The most classic example is the option to play as Mario, Luigi, Peach, or Toad, just like in the NES classic, Super Mario Bros 2. Each character handles differently, and there is a level at which different characters need to be played in order to gain certain collectibles.

The new catsuit also provides some very interesting new gameplay mechanics. Giving characters the ability to climb up walls in order to take shortcuts. And collect hidden items. There’s also another feature whereby the player can collect cherries. Which spawn multiple Mario sprites to control at the same time in order to solve puzzles and reach hidden areas. This element was inspired by The Legend of Zelda game, The Four Swords. Which would always be considered compelling. My only gripe with it is that there could’ve maybe been a few more side quests added. Or at least the side quests that were included could’ve had more of a purpose. If only to make it stand out further as a platform game. For example, the stamps to be collected in the game are used to merely customize Miiverse posts.

Controls – 10/10

There’s honestly not much to say about the controls, as there are no problems with them. As I mentioned before, the Four Swords mechanic of controlling multiple sprites at one given time is particularly impressive. Along with the character choice mechanic, which might have been missed by some fans of the series. My rule of thumb is that when a game has a perfect score in terms of controls, it simply means that there are no complications with them. Even if there’s not much to say beyond that. Unless, of course, there are some overly innovative elements worth talking about, which might make them even more deserving of a perfect score. But even if there are no new control elements, I don’t think there’s any need for a game to lose marks if the controls are implemented correctly, with no problems.

Lifespan – 7/10

On average, this game will take players around 15 hours to complete. Whilst this is a fair amount of time, I don’t think it’s that great. It seems to me to be somewhat deficient. Especially given the amount of time Nintendo had to get this game out. And that there are a fair few recycled elements of Super Mario 3D Land thrown in there. I think if they really wanted this game to have the impact that Nintendo clearly banked on having over the holiday season, they should’ve made it longer to again make it a lot more notable when talking about the platforming genre. Nevertheless, 15 hours is just about acceptable for a platform game, and it’s worth playing; if only once.

Storyline – 6.5/10

This, for me, is the aspect in which the game falls short in my opinion. Although it indeed strays away from the thoroughly exhausted plot of Princess Peach being the damsel in distress, as of course, she is a playable character this time around, the story still follows the basic premise of a typical Mario game. Bowser has this time captured seven fairy-like creatures called Sprixies, and Mario and company follow Bowser into a new world known as the Sprixie Kingdom in order to save them and defeat him once again.

Personally, I liked the plot of the Super Mario Galaxy series, which introduced several new characters and creatures relevant to the story and mixed it up a little bit more than usual. Unfortunately, I don’t see anything about this game’s story that makes it stand out among most others in the franchise. This is another element of the game that Nintendo probably should’ve spent a bit more time on to have the desired lasting impression they were looking for.

Originality – 7.5/10

Any Mario game is always going to stand out to at least a small extent. Whilst there’s not a great deal in this game to differentiate it from many other Mario games, there’s certainly enough to distinguish it from most of the more recent ones. Various new bosses and some fantastic settings separate it from most of the newest 2D side-scrolling games in the franchise, and there are also a few new gaming elements added that I previously discussed. I think if not for some of the recycled elements of Mario games placed into the mix, I think this game could certainly have had the intended effect on markets away from Japan that Nintendo sorely required to give the Wii U a much-needed boost in sales figures throughout Christmas.

Happii

In summary, Super Mario 3D World is a fun game, and it is indeed worth playing through. There were many other titles released over the 2013 holiday period that unjustifiably hogged attention away from such a good game as this, but I believe Nintendo is capable of doing more with Mario than what they did with Super Mario 3D World.

Score

47/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Super Mario 3D Land (3DS)

Super Mario 3D Land

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Tokyo

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Koichi Hayashida

Producer – Yoshiaki Koizumi

PEGI – 3

Released relatively early into the shelf life of the 3DS, Super Mario 3D Land was universally praised upon release and has since sold over 10 million copies. Making it the third best-selling game for the system, as of this writing. The series has been lacking in innovation for the past few years. This game can be seen as an example of this; it’s nevertheless a fairly enjoyable game. It has a decent level of challenge, which is unusual for a Mario game. Even to veteran players.

Graphics – 7.5/10

As with most installments in the series, the conceptual design of the game is quite varied. The game is set in several differently themed worlds and levels. There aren’t a lot of new elements to most of the scenery. The same boss is recycled a good number of times, as in New Super Mario Bros 2. But there are also a few hidden secrets to be found. Along with many of the hidden coins throughout the game. Such as a dungeon area, paying homage to The Legend of Zelda series. References to Mario have been rife in The Legend of Zelda series since its inception. But it’s interesting to see that in this case, it’s very much the other way round.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

In a lot of ways, 3D Land plays out a little like a mixture of Super Mario Galaxy 2. In that, levels have to be unlocked via the discovery of three hidden coins in each level. And any classic Super Mario game, due to its linear progression. As opposed to the free-roaming style of play synonymous with many 3D Mario games. It’s quite satisfying to solve each elaborate puzzle placed in the game. And to complete it to 100%. However, I think I would have been bitterly disappointed if one-half of the game hadn’t been unlockable after finishing the first half. I think if it had ended at the point of rescuing Peach, I would feel very differently about it.

Controls – 10/10

Super Mario 64 pioneered the 3D platforming genre, and an integral reason why was that it had a very innovative control scheme. Yet one that was simple to get to grips with whilst players were experiencing the transition from 2D to 3D gaming. Since this game uses more or less the same control scheme. And because each level is of a much more linear progression, there are absolutely no complications. And it’s interesting to see how many more functions have been added to the overall formula.

Lifespan – 7/10

As I alluded to, the first half of the game can take up to an average of 7 and a half hours to finish, which is why if it had ended at that point, even after taking in the side quest, I would have been left feeling much more jaded by the entire experience. Taking the second part of the game into account, however, it can be made to last roughly 15 to 16 hours, which for a linear Mario game is fairly impressive.

Storyline – 4/10

As thoroughly milked over the past 30 years, Mario is on yet another expedition to stop his arch-nemesis, Bowser, and save Princess Peach. The only difference is that afterward, he must save Luigi. Mario games are generally not played for their story. But for what great gameplay there is, I can’t help but think that even after repeating the same story beyond the release of this game in 2011, Nintendo could have come up with something different. They have since worked to alter this formula slightly in recent games by introducing new characters and elements to the series. But to me, there isn’t enough of that in this game in particular.

Originality – 6/10

Though combining gameplay elements from different Mario games and makes the entire thing into a fairly cohesive concept, this game is, regardless, most definitely not one of the most unique titles of the time. It certainly isn’t even one of the most unique Mario games throughout the series’ chronology, since some of the others have helped to pioneer gaming in many different ways. Certain elements give the game a fair bit of charm in its own right, such as new power-ups for Mario, but many things made me think that more effort could have been made in this respect.

Happii

Overall, Super Mario 3D Land, whilst pretty unoriginal and lacking in story, in lieu of the franchise’s tradition, it would seem, is still pretty enjoyable to play and satisfying to complete. Things would pick up with the arrival of its Wii U counterpart, Super Mario 3D World, and various other spin-off Mario games, but none of this is to say that this game is a failure.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Spyro the Dragon (PlayStation)

Spyro The Dragon

Developer(s) – Insomniac Games

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Artist – Charles Zembillas

Producer – Mike Cerny

PEGI – 3

Back when the PlayStation was first released, the control scheme seemed to be a cause for concern. When it came to developing 3D platformers for the system. That is, until Spyro the Dragon came along. Not only is it symbolic to me of a time when Sony finally got the formula right, but it’s also a very enjoyable title. And it still stands out as one of the better games on the system.

Graphics – 9/10

When I was growing up, the medieval era and dragons always captivated my imagination. So it seemed to me that the first Spyro game would be right up my alley. And I wasn’t disappointed. Its medieval settings (as well as an array of other different kinds of settings) and its level of graphical detail were absolutely astounding for the time. After playing Super Mario 64, I was astonished to see another superbly designed in-game world. Which was just as big as the one in the Nintendo 64 classic. If not bigger. Although the conceptual design falls slightly short of that of Super Mario 64, it was still a very good effort from Insomniac Games in terms of presentation. I’m also actually pretty sure that this was the first game I played that featured multiple overworlds.

Gameplay – 8/10

Overall, the first Spyro was a very decent experience. I liked it for its amount of variety in gameplay. In addition to the standard 3D platforming exploration elements, there are also stages that feature flying challenges that I particularly enjoyed. To me, those sequences not only make the game stand out greatly among other 3D platformers at the time, but also But they also provide a very stern challenge. There is also a small incentive for completing the game to 100% in the form of an alternative ending. But that was somewhat commonplace for the time. And the truth is told, it is now considered non-canonical to the rest of the series. This makes it somewhat redundant in the long run.

Controls – 9/10

For the most part, the controls are fine. The only problem I had with them concerned the various degrees of speed the character can move and the issues surrounding it. When the character moves normally, it can be fairly slow, and gameplay can be somewhat hampered by it in turn. But when the character is dashing, it sometimes makes moving Spyro around a little bit difficult. It can be easy to bump into a lot of things along the way. But what needs to be kept in mind is that this was one of Sony’s first decent 3D platforming games. As such, it was going to be a case of trial and error when it came to controls, as there were a lot of issues to be addressed at the time. But overall, Insomniac handled things more than well enough.

Lifespan – 8/10

For an early PlayStation game, this was fairly long. It may not have been on the same level as Final Fantasy VII. But 100% completion would take in excess of 7 to 8 hours, which was fairly long for the time. The longer a game can be made to last, the better. Nowadays, that may seem like a fraction of what quite a few games of today can deliver, but I was left wanting for nothing after I finished this game when I was a kid. It still makes for a very fulfilling experience to this day; being aware of the game’s historical importance and what impact it subsequently had on Sony only makes the experience ever more enthralling.

Storyline – 6/10

This is where the game falls a little bit for me. As with a lot of video game stories for the time, it is somewhat basic. Insomniac had a bit of a way to go before they would eventually expand on this area in other installments. The story follows a young purple dragon called Spyro, who lives among a colony of dragons.

During a television interview (bizarrely), one of the dragons insults the game’s main villain, Gnasty Gnorc, who then becomes enraged and decides to use his magic to turn all the dragons into crystals. Spyro escapes his wrath and sets out on a journey to find and free the imprisoned dragons and defeat Gnasty Gnorc. The best thing about this story is its element of humor; instead of the Insomniac tradition, it would seem. It’s been seen throughout the Ratchet & Clank series, but it’s interesting to see where it all stemmed from.

Originality – 8/10

Even though this game was heavily based on Super Mario 64, and there is overwhelming evidence to suggest that Sony and Insomniac Games were influenced by Nintendo’s success, the developers did add quite a lot of flair to Spyro the Dragon and indeed made the overall concept their own. It had many different gameplay elements, which made it fairly unique in its own right. One Super Mario 64 element they did improve on was the flying mechanics, as it could sometimes be pretty difficult to control Mario in the air when he was equipped with the wing cap, but with the free-flying sequences of Spyro, it was all down to the player’s individual skill.

Happii

In summary, I believe Spyro the Dragon is a game that should be owned by anyone who has either a PlayStation 1 through 4. If not, it’s definitely worth downloading from the PlayStation Network, as it is very much worth playing through. It’s an excellent experience, and it paved the way for the series to reach for the skies, just like Spyro himself.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Sly 3: Honour Among Thieves (PlayStation 2, PlayStation 3 & PlayStation Vita)

Sly 3

Developer(s) – Sucker Punch Productions

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

PEGI – 7

Taking place sometime after the events of Sly 2: Band of Thieves, the third Sly game kept to the core mechanics of the previous installment. But also presented a few changes to it as well. In my opinion, those changes were made for the worse. Since it took away much of what made the second game as exceptional as it was. And I was left pretty disappointed by it.

Graphics – 8.5/10

The one thing the developers didn’t take away, at least, was the exceptionally great cel-shaded style of the visuals. An outlandish conceptual take on the modern world, filled with plenty of anthropomorphic animals. The settings are also as wonderfully diverse as they were in the previous game. Taking place in various parts of the world, ranging from Venice to Yuendumu to Kinderdijk. It also features an interesting blend of old and new supporting characters. From both the first and the second game, add more to the story element.

Gameplay – 4/10

As I mentioned, Sly 3 sticks to the same core concept as Sly 2. The player must travel from city to city, advancing the plot and using stealth mechanics. With a range of different abilities to overcome a multitude of different perilous situations, the characters find themselves in perilous situations everywhere they go. With the added feature of some new characters to control.

The problem is that many of the side quests that made the second game as immersive as it was were substituted for side quests. These have the player redoing certain challenges found throughout the story, but having to fulfill additional criteria. Such as doing them in a certain amount of time, etc. To me, whilst many there consider it to be better than the second game, it was a massive step down in my opinion. It demonstrated a lack of imagination on the developer’s part. Especially when I think of all the imagination that went into Sly 2. And how much it was a genuine improvement in the first game.

Controls – 10/10

Since the game runs on the same core principles as both the first and the second, the control scheme hasn’t changed. And thus, the developers didn’t take it upon themselves to try to fix something that wasn’t broken. The controls are as wonderfully fluent as many of the greatest 3D platformers to have ever been developed over the years. And regardless of what installment may be coming under review, the stealth mechanics make them stand out greatly.

Lifespan – 3/10

Clocking in at a mere 9 hours on average, this is yet another reason why I view this game as being a drastic step down from its predecessor. The second game could easily be made to last around 20 to 25 hours. With everything that there was to do outside the main story quests. But since the side quests are different, I think many gamers will inevitably be disinclined to undertake the side quests. Upon discovery of what they are. As indeed I was.

Storyline – 8/10

Set one year after Sly 2, Sly Cooper, along with his colleagues Bentley and Murray, as well as a plethora of new allies, venture out to seek the fabled Cooper Vault, reputed to hold a vast amount of heirlooms. Collected by Sly’s descendants over the years. Personally, the ending of Sly 2 blew me away. But Sly 3 continued that level of character development and built upon it even further. For a game series that started by relying on a strong element of comedy, I never thought I would be able to take it as seriously as I ended up being able to.

Originality – 4/10

To me, because the developers took away a lot of the elements that helped to take the Sly series to the next level, there is considerably less originality about the third game. They did try something new with the inclusion of more than three playable characters, a concept that would carry on into the fourth game. But to me, it meant considerably less than what it could have potentially meant if the developers had chosen to handle the side quests in a fashion more reminiscent of Sly 2. I think Sanzaru took this on board whilst developing Sly Cooper: Thieves in Time. And I’m glad they changed as much from this game as they did.

Niiutral

In summation, Sly 3, in my opinion, is so much less than what it could have been had the developers not decided to make as many negative changes as they did following Sly 2. Even though the original game had less substance, I think the developers misused what substance they added to the third, making it worse. A classic case of quantity over quality.

Score

37.5/60

6/10 (Average)

Sly Cooper & the Thievius Raccoonus (PlayStation 2 & PlayStation 3)

Sly Cooper and the Thievius Raccoonus

Developer – Sucker Punch Productions

Publisher – Sony Computer Entertainment

PEGI – 7

The Sly Cooper series first appeared in 2002 on the PlayStation 2. Around that time, Sony started to find much greater success with developing 3D platforming games than they had done previously with the original PlayStation. Having released games such as Jak & Daxter and Ratchet & Clank. Whilst sales of the game were pretty poor during the time of its release, the game has become a cult classic among gamers. It has warranted the development of three sequels. Though I don’t believe the first to be the best (Indeed, I believe that honor goes to Sly 2: Band of Thieves), I don’t think it’s a terrible game. It just needed an extra push, and I think the developers saved that for the sequel.

Graphics – 8/10

Relating to Week 4’s unique article, Sly Cooper was released at a time when cel-shading was first established as a popular form of visual representation in video games. Consequently, this game was always going to stand out. At the time, it was an extremely significant change from the norm. It also made for several compelling level designs as well as character designs. Although some of the bosses look a little bit bland, the last boss, in particular, was very well designed. And the main character is cast equally so. Looking at some of the levels, which are set on rooftops, it’s also plain to see where the developers took inspiration from when they were creating InFamous. Though this would become even more evident in the sequel and onwards, the opening level of the first game alone is enough for players to make this assumption.

Gameplay – 5.5/10

Sly Cooper & the Thievius Raccoonus is a 3D platforming game with stealth elements reminiscent of games like Metal Gear Solid and Splinter Cell. But even with this somewhat unique aspect of gameplay, I still felt playing it left a lot to be desired. There are so few side quests that completing the game to 100% can simply be done as the player goes along, as normal. And there’s not much call for re-visiting levels, save for completing the time trial challenges. In this respect, it reminds me of the third Crash Bandicoot game, Warped, only with less content and fewer side quests. There is a bit of incentive to play the game to 100%, however, in the form of additional abilities. Such as running faster or being invisible. The game also has a bit of variety in that respect, too.

Controls – 10/10

At least in terms of controls, there are no problems. Sucker Punch had found critical success before Sly Cooper with their first game. Another debatably unfairly obscure game for the Nintendo 64 called Rocket: Robot on Wheels. So that there would be no problems with the controls would have been expected. Especially taking into account the elaborately challenging nature of Sucker Punch’s first game, released back in 1999.

Lifespan – 4/10

Unfortunately, even completing the game to 100% can take players less than 10 hours. Which, compared with other platformers, especially at the time, is nothing. With games like Jak & Daxter and Ratchet & Clank came more content and substance in gameplay, and I found that the original Sly Cooper game severely lacked that. And by that token, it would seem no wonder that the first game couldn’t compete with other games. Such as the two aforementioned examples.

Storyline – 7.5/10

The game’s story is just about as simple in general concept, and as crazy in design as many other video gaming franchises before it. But I found that it wouldn’t really be greatly expanded on or elaborated on until the next game. The plot follows an anthropomorphic raccoon thief called Sly Cooper. He, along with his two closest friends, a turtle called Bentley and a hippo called Murray, set out to recover missing pages from the book passed down from generation to generation of Sly’s family.

The Thievius Raccoonus. Overall, the game’s story is okay. But it only starts to get most interesting towards the end, and I don’t think there was enough added to keep it overly compelling. At least the story is simple enough not to create any confusion, I guess. I believe it to be the worst-case scenario when games or films become so convoluted that they become nigh-on impossible to follow.

Originality – 5/10

Although the game would inevitably be considered unique in terms of visuals, it’s by no means unique in terms of gameplay. The unique gameplay mechanics were the stealth element, which would again be more elaborated on with future installments.

Niiutral

Overall, the original Sly Cooper game isn’t an overly terrible game. It was a simple case of trial and error. Only compared to future games in the series, as well as other games around at the time, it seems to me that it was extremely obvious that it was a case of trial and error.

Score

40/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)