Tag Archives: 3D Platformer

Knack (PlayStation 4)

Knack

Developer(s) – SCE Japan Studios

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Mark Cerny

Producer – Yusuke Watanabe

PEGI – 12

Released as a launch title for the PlayStation 4, Knack showcased early on in the console’s shelf life what it was capable of doing on a graphical level. Mainly through the visual aspects of the game’s titular character. It is a pretty nice-looking game. And I did find it kept me entertained for a few hours. But that’s as far as it went. As with many launch titles, it was ultimately very insubstantial compared to what games would be released for the console in its first full year.

Graphics – 9/10

As was undoubtedly intended by the developers, the visuals are by some distance the best thing about the game. The level of graphical detail is represented through Knack as he absorbs different materials into his body to gain different abilities. Such as ice, wood, and metal, were unlike anything I’d ever seen in any other video game. There were some glitches throughout. But they were barely noticeable. Instead, attention will be drawn to not only the design of Knack but to many of the different locations throughout the game. Some of them stand out really well from the rest of the game. Such as the Legendary Land and the many different underground temples. Former Naughty Dog employee Mark Cerny directed the game. And his influence is made extremely apparent.

Gameplay – 7/10

Another aspect whereby Cerny’s influence shines through is within the gameplay. Playing out very much like the classic Crash Bandicoot games, it is a linear 3D stage-based 3D platformer with an emphasis on combat (albeit somewhat more varied) and collecting hidden treasures throughout the game. However, I thought it was a little bit repetitive at times. And it does fall short of what could potentially have been done with it. Such is the nature of most launch titles.

Perhaps the developers may be saving a greater level of variety for a possible sequel. Which I think should be an open-world game. That’s what I think they should have done with the Crash Bandicoot series, even before those games ended up on sixth-generation hardware. Certainly, if the developers had a desire to make a franchise out of Knack, following the release of the sequel, then they needed to make a game worlds apart from the first.

Controls – 6/10

For a launch title, though there aren’t many problems with the actual control scheme, I was underwhelmed with how little it did to show off the controller’s new features, such as the touch screen. Even some basic buttons have no use at all. I think it’s partly because of this that the game’s combat system greatly adds to the game’s sense of repetition.

Lifespan – 5/10

Overall, the game can be completed to 100% within about ten hours. That being said, after two playthroughs. There is a small amount of replay value to be had within the game in playing through it a second time and collecting hidden items that may have been missed the first time around. But other than this, there’s really next to no cause for playing through it again.

Storyline – 6/10

The game’s story also does very little to impress or engross. The story follows Knack, a creature discovered by a scientist, Dr. Vargas, who can harness the power to bind ancient relics together and give them consciousness. Vargas believes that Knack could potentially be an invaluable weapon in the ensuing war between mankind and a race of goblins. But it gradually comes to light that there is an even bigger threat for Knack to prevent.

The problem is that there’s nothing really unique about it apart from its basic premise. There is hardly any character development involved. And it is consequently extremely hard to identify or show any concern for any of them. I’ve also noticed that in terms of story, it is very similar to most other video game stories about treasure hunting, such as Uncharted, Tomb Raider, etc. Despite setback after setback, the heroes always find a way to save the day. Perhaps this could be seen as Cerny’s influence yet again cropping in. Though in this case, in a much more negative way.

Originality – 5/10

The most original thing about the game is simply the design of Knack himself, the in-game locations, and a couple of the enemy designs. Granted, however, a lot of them, in particular, are heavily recycled throughout the game. In terms of both story and gameplay, there isn’t a great deal present to differentiate it from other games. This makes me believe that with the sequel, a lot of drastic changes and improvements would have to be made.

Niiutral

Overall, Knack can draw from players a few hours of fun, but there was most definitely room for improvement in almost every aspect. People may be surprised by my opinion of this, given how happy I was with the console’s launch period, but that was mostly down to the plethora of indie games released for it early on; the console’s early mainstream scene paled in comparison, and Knack is a shining example of that.

Score

38/60

6/10 (Average)

Kameo: Elements of Power (Xbox 360)

Kameo Elements of Power

Developer(s) – Rare

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Game Studios

Designer – George Andreas

PEGI – 12

Kameo: Elements of Power is an adventure game developed by Rare.  Originally, it was intended to be a launch title for the GameCube back in 2001. A screenshot of the GameCube game can actually be seen on the box for early GameCube consoles. Alongside another canceled title, Donkey Kong Racing. It was eventually re-imagined as the very first title announced for release on the Xbox 360 back in 2005. Though launch titles are, for the most part, hit or miss, and this game has its flaws, I didn’t find Kameo anywhere near as bad as I thought I would.

Graphics – 6/10

Conceptually, the game reminded me very much of Spyro the Dragon. Even the title logo is extremely similar. By that token, there’s not a great deal in the game to make it stand out to an exceptional extent. But there are a few elements, such as the multiple playable character design, for example. In terms of visuals, the best thing that was achieved with this title was showing gamers what the Xbox 360 was capable of on a graphical scale. As indeed a launch title should. In particular, the water effects are very realistic-looking for the time. But gamers would be treated to better-looking games in the future.

Gameplay – 7/10

The game relies heavily on the player assigning different controllable creatures to different buttons on the controller. And using these creatures to access different areas in the game, and for use in combat. There’s also a fair amount of emphasis put on things like adventure, puzzle-solving, and exploration. I found it to be moderately enjoyable to play. There’s a fair amount of variety to experience in the multiple playable characters that accumulate throughout the course of the game. Which, in a sense, reminded me a lot of Skylanders. Only six years earlier. There are also a fair few side quests throughout the game, which is always a plus.

Controls- 7/10

The main problem I found with the controls as they were pretty stiff and difficult to cope with at times. Movement, especially in combat, can feel like quite a chore. And it adds a lot of unnecessary complication to the game overall. Also, I can’t help but feel that the controls were stiff, which also hindered gameplay because there is a lot to keep up with, since different characters had entirely different abilities. And by that token, the stiff controls took a lot of fluency out of the game, too. But it is also interesting to understand how the game would have possibly worked better on the GameCube in terms of controls.

Lifespan – 5/10

In total, Kameo can take less than 10 hours to play, which is particularly underwhelming for a game. Especially as it puts a fair amount of emphasis on elements such as exploration and adventure. I couldn’t help but feel even more let down by this due to the fact that the game had been in development for so long, and Rare did have a fair amount of time to add more to it before it was released.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of Kameo: Elements of Power involves its titular character, a shape-shifting fairy, on an adventure to rescue the elemental ancestors and defeat the evil dark troll king, Thorn. I found the story to be a little less generic than I first expected it would be. Although the basic premise has been repeated many times in video gaming as well as in other forms of media, there are a few twists and turns before the end; although I found one fairly major plot twist, in particular, to become virtually from the get-go.

Originality – 6/10

In terms of gameplay, Kameo: Elements of Power seems to vaguely serve as a precursor to the idea behind Skylanders’ style of gameplay. But in terms of things like visual concept and story, I don’t think it stands out even as well as other launch titles have done in the past. If it had been released on the GameCube, I think it would have had a tough time competing with Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem in particular, given how unique that game was and still is.

Niiutral

In summation, Kameo: Elements of Power does have its gameplay value, and did showcase the Xbox 360 graphical power very capably. For the generic-looking launch title, it would appear, on the surface, it’s actually not as bad a game as a player may expect it to be, especially for a Microsoft-published Rare title.

Score

37/60

6/10 (Average)

Journey (PlayStation 3 & PlayStation 4)

Journey

Developer(s) – Thatgamecompany & Tricky Pixels

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Jenova Chen

Producer – Robin Hunicke

PEGI – 12

Developed by Thatgamecompany and first released back in 2012, Journey went on to become one of the most critically acclaimed video games of the seventh generation. Winning five BAFTA awards among many others, as well as nominations. And becoming a catalyst for proving that video games can be considered a valid art form. Personally, whilst I can appreciate this game for the different direction it has helped to take the industry in and helped to popularise the medium among a greater number of people, it does have its faults. These compelled me to rate it significantly lower than many other video game critics have.

Graphics – 10/10

The aspect that I couldn’t possibly fault, however, is the game’s visuals. A unique and beautiful blend of cel-shaded graphics and wonderful conceptual design. And some very realistic-looking sand and sea textures thrown in for good measure, Journey is one of the most elegant video games I’ve ever laid eyes upon. It reminds me of Shadow of the Colossus, in that there is also an air of mystery about where the game is set. And the events that take place long before it begins.

Gameplay – 4/10

The objective of the game is simply to get from A to B, whilst along the way, solving a few puzzles here and there. There is a side quest of collecting runes across the land, which extends the length of the player character’s scarf. For all its artistic value, I’ve always found there is far too little substance in gameplay for me to be able to label it quite the ground-breaking experience that most reviewers are willing to label it as. Especially given how linear it is, too.

Controls – 10/10

As a 3D platformer, there are no problems with the control scheme of the game. Since the genre came into true prominence throughout the fifth generation of gaming. It was further developed throughout the sixth, with Sony themselves being at the forefront of it since the days of the PlayStation 2. In terms of innovation, however, there is very little present with respect to controls. Since there aren’t any unique mechanics present. Even the flying mechanics were perpetuated in Super Mario 64 long before the release of this title.

Lifespan – 2/10

Disgustingly, to me, Journey can only last up to 3 to 4 hours. Depending on how much of the game the player wishes to complete in a single playthrough. Also, aside from the sake of passing by different players each time with vague elements of interaction with them, there is very little replay value to be had, in my opinion. Rushed, it can take as little as 2 hours to complete. A standard that had long since proven to be below par. With the advent of the entire 3D platforming genre back in the late 90s.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of the game is very compelling, but in a much more abstract sense than in many other video games. It follows the player character’s journey to reach a huge mountain. With a glowing crevice in the middle of its top. Whilst simultaneously being shown insights into the history of the long-forgotten civilization, he/she finds ruins strewn across the land. The story does extremely well to bring out raw emotion in players and to make them feel the awe, fear, and struggle that their character goes through along the way.

Originality – 5/10

As I stated, I can fully understand and value what Thatgamecompany strived to achieve in this title. It was clearly a game made for the sake of art. And that’s where the majority of its innovation lies. It has changed the way many people look at video games forever. However, in terms of gameplay, there is no innovation to experience. There have been many gamers who have come and gone long before Journey, which has presented players with a lot more substance and entertainment.

And yet have done just as good a job representing video games as a valid art form. Many are even greater than this. It made me excited that this title worked to bring that frame of mind to light. But at the same time, I also fear that many more video games in the future may be developed with the same state of mind. And that more and more developers may simply choose to concentrate on the artistic aspect. As opposed to that which matters most, the gameplay.

Niiutral

Overall, Journey does have a lot of redeeming value in some aspects. And it deserves critical acclaim to a certain extent. But as a gamer who believes the most important aspect is the gameplay, I can’t help but look at it as being vastly overrated. Ryan Clements of IGN once said of it that not all gamers would appreciate a game with a deliberate, melancholic pace and short duration. And I believe he hit the nail on the head.

Score

38/60

6/10 (Average)

Jet Force Gemini (Nintendo 64)

Jet Force Gemini

Developer(s) – Rareware

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Peter Beanland

Producer – Chris Stamper

ELSPA – 11+

Developed by Rare and inspired by numerous works of science fiction and previous Nintendo games such as Super Metroid and Super Mario 64, Jet Force Gemini is a run-and-gun shooter emphasizing exploration, intense combat, and item collecting. It was warmly received by critics upon release. Albeit not without criticism. In my opinion, the criticism levied against this game was justified. I personally found it far too problematic to be able to call it one of the better games for the Nintendo 64. I ran into numerous issues with this title that I found impossible to overlook.

Graphics – 7/10

With a conceptual design influenced by several popular sci-fi series like Star Wars, Stargate, Dune, and Battle of the Planets, the game’s visuals are most definitely the best redeeming quality it has to offer. It takes place in wonderfully varied locations ranging from spaceships and caves to castles and swamps. The different types of locations are reminiscent of many of Rare’s previous games developed under Nintendo, like Diddy Kong Racing or Donkey Kong 64. And to me, it was a positive demonstration of how Nintendo’s influence had a very positive effect on the once-renowned development company before being bought out by Microsoft.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

The objective of Jet Force Gemini is to explore wide-open locations, collect items, and save the NPC inhabitants, known as the Tribals. And gun down everything else in sight. The combat is indeed quite intense. But for what lack of a stable control scheme there is, it can also seem very unreasonably demanding. Not only is it not the most accessible game on the Nintendo 64, but there is a needless insistence on fulfilling most criteria within the game in order to properly complete it. Not everyone may be able to save all the Tribals, as it demands. This may also lead to a level of repetition depending on how many times players are forced to replay each level.

Controls – 4/10

By far the worst thing about Jet Force Gemini is how relentlessly bad the control scheme was handled. Although there is an auto-aim mode in place to help players pick off enemies on the ground, the game insists players use a clunky precision targeting mode to take care of enemies on higher ground. This is extremely easy to lose patience with. In a lot of ways, it reminds me of how the ground missions in Star Fox Assault played out. A lot of unnecessary complications, which, if excluded, could have made for a much greater game than what it turned out to be.

Lifespan – 6/10

The title can be made to last an average of around 7 to 8 hours. For those who are willing to look past the bad controls. Emphasis on exploration does fairly well to add to its longevity. And there is also additional gameplay value to be had in the numerous different multiplayer modes. The biggest concern going into the game for the player will, however, ultimately be how well they can adapt to the control scheme. And speaking from experience, it will not be an easy task.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of the game follows the titular Jet Force Gemini team as they battle the evil Mizar and his horde of insect drones. In a time when video games were in the process of being established as a viable art form, Jet Force Gemini does have some redeeming qualities in this respect. But nowhere near as much as many other Nintendo 64 games would portray; notably The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask. The fifth generation was a wonderfully weird and varied time for video games. And whilst this title didn’t have anywhere near as much of an impact in the way of storytelling as many others, it certainly wasn’t one of the worst video game stories either.

Originality – 6/10

This title does stand out among many other releases for the Nintendo 64. Albeit for some of the wrong reasons. Though gameplay was much different than the likes of Super Mario 64 or Goldeneye 007, I don’t think Rare was quite able to make as much use of the analog stick controls. As they did with Goldeneye 007, and then later, Perfect Dark. If they had perhaps made a follow-up to Jet Force Gemini, the control scheme may have come with much-needed improvements. But unfortunately, this is a supposition, and impossible to know for certain.

Angrii

In summation, despite some redeeming qualities this game has going for it, Jet Force Gemini has far too many problems for me to be able to call it one of Rare’s greatest works before the Microsoft acquisition. The company released some of the best games on the Nintendo 64, but unfortunately, this is not one such title.

Score

35.5/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

InFamous: Second Son (PlayStation 4)

InFamous Second Son

Developer – Sucker Punch Studios

Publisher – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Nate Fox

Producer – Brian Fleming

PEGI – 16

InFamous: Second Son follows on from the dramatic improvements that Sucker Punch made with the second game. It delivers an even greater gaming experience than its predecessor. A lot of issues I’d previously had with the InFamous gaming formula were answered. As well as the few initial reservations I’d had when I played the demo at the lock-in event earlier this month. And this is my verdict.

Graphics – 9.5/10

When I first looked at actual gameplay, I noticed that the setting of Seattle, Washington, was a lot darker, gloomier, and grittier than either Empire City or New Marais from the first and second games, respectively. Although I found that most of the game’s story takes place in the daytime, I felt that it did retain that foreboding atmosphere whenever it turned nighttime, or when it started raining. I felt by that token, the game could also be taken more seriously than its predecessors.

The fact that the player character’s skin doesn’t turn either black and white or pale if the player decides to take the evil route also means that Second Son can be taken more seriously than in the first two games. A graphical element that took me some time to warm to with both InFamous 1 and 2 was the comic book-like cutscenes. But this time around, they play a less prominent role. Only being used to explain the backstories of certain characters. To me, that also gave Second Son an even more heightened sense of realism.

Cont…

Another interesting thing I found about the game’s setting is that, whilst it takes place in an entirely different city, there are some elements which are very reminiscent of the previous games. For example, the DUP booths remind me of the wooden huts in New Marais. And both the Space Needle and the DUP headquarters remind me of Alden’s Tower in the first game. But that’s not to say that they are the only nods to previous games made by Sucker Punch.

Their take on Seattle is also littered with Sly Cooper Easter eggs. Such as neon signs, billboards, and a badge of the Sly Cooper logo on the main character’s jacket. And in a children’s playground, there are drawings on the wall of the three main characters from that series: Sly, Bentley, and Murray. But whilst the game is painstakingly detailed and atmospheric, the visuals lose out on a perfect score on account of a few graphical glitches here and there. But otherwise, this is one of the most visually compelling games I’ve played for some time.

Gameplay – 9.5/10

Playing the game was equally as exciting as looking at it. And I found it just as enjoyable to play as the other entries in the series. There has never been as much gameplay variety in the series as there is in Second Son. With a much greater arsenal of superpowers at the player’s disposal than ever before. And a plethora of unique side quests to do aside from the main story. And even a side quest played through the PlayStation 4 and the internet via the website infamouspapertrail.com.

Although I was sorry to see the departure of the facility, to create missions and shared them over the PlayStation Network. And the melee combat isn’t as stylish as in InFamous 2. But the final product still makes for some serious fun to be had. The side quests are also literally a lot more creative. One of which involves painting graffiti art around the city. There is also a great incentive for completing the game in the form of an additional superpower.

Controls – 10/10

The fact that I am able to give InFamous: Second Son a perfect score in terms of controls is particularly significant as far as I’m concerned. I had previously had issues with the control scheme whilst playing through the first two games. This game answered my previous reservations. I found that the biggest problem came with trying to climb walls to reach the top of buildings.

But Sucker Punch addressed these issues in several extremely subtle ways. For example, having smoke powers meant that the character could travel through air vents. Instantly taking him from the bottom of a wall to a rooftop with much less difficulty. When the player acquires the neon power, it is also possible to run at inhuman speeds as well as run up walls to the top of buildings. This also made Second Son much easier to cope with than InFamous 1 and 2.

Lifespan – 8/10

Lasting just as long as the previous two games, InFamous: Second Son can make for over 40 hours of gameplay if players choose to play through twice. Taking both the good and evil routes. By the same token, there is quite a bit of replay value to be had. However, I do hope that Sucker Punch brings out a few DLC packs in addition to the ongoing InFamous Paper Trail sidequest because the world of InFamous: Second Son is very much worth expanding on further.

Storyline – 8.5/10

Taking place seven years after the events of InFamous 2, the story of InFamous: Second Son follows Delsin Rowe. A member of a Native American tribe situated on the outskirts of Seattle. After realizing he is a conduit (a human who can harness superpowers), he and his tribe are attacked by Brooke Augustine. A powerful conduit and the leader of the DUP. Authorities are intent on protecting humans from the threat of conduits (re-branded by them as “bio-terrorists”).

Delsin travels to Seattle along with his brother Reggie to harness Augustine’s power and reverse the damage she has done to the rest of Delsin’s tribe. When I first heard that Delsin was going to be an anti-hero in contrast to the previous InFamous protagonist, Cole MacGrath, it made me question how big a role morality would have compared to the previous two games. However, I found that the element of morality plays a much more prominent role in terms of both gameplay and story.

Moral choices affect the outcome of the game to a greater extent. And I also felt that the knock-on effects of how the player chooses to play out the story have much more of an impact on the narrative. But I think the most significant improvement made to the story is that the characters are much more believable and either likable or detestable. Depending on the direction the story is taken in. Either way, how Delsin’s character develops throughout the course of the game makes him an even more compelling character than Cole, in my opinion.

Originality – 8.5/10

Overall, despite the improved amount of variety in gameplay, side quests, visual presentation, and story, InFamous: Second Son essentially plays out like the previous two games. And the general premise remains the same. But in all honesty, that’s why I like it so much. I’ve been a fan of InFamous since the series’ inception back in 2009. And although the formula is somewhat similar to Grand Theft Auto, I find InFamous much more enjoyable to play. And what elements have been added to keep it fresh do well enough to differentiate it from its predecessors. As well as many other games.

Deliirious

In summation, InFamous Second Son to me represents the first look of mainstream excellence in the eighth generation of gaming. It’s intense, atmospheric, explosive, and incredibly exciting. To me, it is definitely the best game of 2014. Unanimously, my game of the year.

Score

54/60

9/10 (Excellent)

InFamous: First Light (PlayStation 4)

InFamous First Light

Developer(s) – Sucker Punch Studios

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Nate Fox

Producer – Brian Fleming

PEGI – 16

Also acting as a standalone game as well as DLC, InFamous: First Light brings players back to Central Seattle to play through a prologue to the original game. Documenting the back story of the supporting character, Abigail “Fetch” Walker. Though most of the gameplay largely remains the same, I was both impressed and somewhat disappointed by it at the same time.

Graphics – 9.5/10

Just as in the original game, First Light portrays a very dark and gritty take on Central Seattle. It went leaps and bounds ahead of what Sucker Punch Studios has ever done with the InFamous series in terms of presentation. The heightened sense of realism compared to previous games in the series is also very prominent. And I think the further emphasis the developers put on using neon as scenery and a general constant adds a further presence of grittiness to the setting of the entire saga. Although there is less scenery to look at overall, I think the developers have done a very good job of adding something very interesting to their already existing artwork.

Gameplay – 9/10

Since Infamous: First Light is essentially an add-on to an already existing game, I expected there would be considerably less content and substance in gameplay. But I found that while there is much less than in Second Son, it was still a great joy to play for how long it lasts. There are a few side quests scattered here and there, and also a fair amount of variety. I was disappointed by how toned down the range of abilities was compared to the original game and how the morality mechanics aren’t present, as they are in every other game in the series, but the training programs that can be done give it a fair bit of replay value, at least.

Controls – 10/10

Just like in Second Son, Many of the control issues that had been apparent in the first two games in the series had been addressed. It is much easier to move around and to engage enemies. And there aren’t any unnecessary complications present that are annoying, as opposed to being innovative. It can be somewhat hard to control the new neon graffiti art mechanics. But to me, it’s not annoying enough for it to lose any marks.

Lifespan – 3/10

In relation to the much more restricted gameplay, DLCs usually last considerably less time than the original game. And I’m sad to say that First Light is no exception. The main story can last merely two to three hours. Even taking in side quests. However, the game isn’t without replay value, of course, since the ultimate objective of undertaking the various training programs found in the DLC is to simply beat the high score. Interestingly, introducing the franchise to a grassroots video gaming basis.

Storyline – 8.5/10

The story of InFamous: First Light tells the backstory of Abigail “Fetch” Walker. A conduit that can harness the power of neon, imprisoned in the DUP facility, Curdan Cay. All the while being trained to harness her powers by the DUP leader, Brooke Augustine. Whilst simultaneously documenting the chain of events that led her there. And of her life on the streets of Seattle with her brother, Brent. In my opinion, the story is just as gripping and full of twists and turns as the original game. And although morality mechanics have been taken out of the gameplay formula, the theme of morality is very much present in the game’s story, as well as the contemplation of the effects of making tough decisions, story elements that have been stable throughout the entire series.

Originality – 7/10

Although I wish that more could have been added to First Light to make it last longer. And by the same token, I hope that this is merely the first of many DLC packages for the original game. I think that adding as much replay value as they have to it in a way that is fairly unusual for a game of the same caliber as InFamous: Second Son is pretty unique. And also a very smart move. It’s by that token that I believe First Light also works relatively well as a standalone game.

Happii

Overall, InFamous: First Light is a decent add-on to what is still my pick as the greatest game of 2014. InFamous: Second Son. Though it lasts a pretty short amount of time, the time players will spend on it will be enjoyed. And replay value can be had on top of that.

Score

47/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Ico (PlayStation 2 & PlayStation 3)

Ico

Developer(s) – Team Ico (SCE Japan Studios)

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Fumito Ueda

PEGI – 12

Inspired by Eric Chahi’s Another World, Fumito Ueda developed Ico, which was released in 2001. It has since become a cult classic among gamers. Personally preferring Ueda’s next game after this, Shadow of the Colossus, I found this game enjoyable to a certain extent. But I don’t think I would go so far as to call it a cult classic.

Graphics – 7/10

Whilst the setting of the game is fairly well-designed. And there are a few standout individual areas, such as the windmill and the graveyard, but the game’s visuals seemed a little repetitive to me after a while. But what I do have to respect this game for in terms of graphical presentation is the fact that it has gone on to inspire not only other game developers, such as Phil Fish and Vander Caballero, but also film directors. Such as Pan’s Labyrinth director, Guillermo del Toro. This game has also gone on to inspire the creation of such games as Twilight Princess, one of my personal favorites. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time, which I personally respect the game for.

Gameplay – 6/10

An aspect I don’t entirely respect this game for is its style of play. On the one hand, the game can get very samey. As the concept of what to do is to simply solve a puzzle, then kill some shadowy creatures, and rinse and repeat. Combat to me isn’t particularly fluent, and annoyingly, the hit detection isn’t great either. I found myself growing bored about two hours in. But on the other hand, the puzzles are very well thought out, which provides the game with a fair amount of challenge. So Ico isn’t completely unplayable. Its linearity for how big the setting of the game is doesn’t do it any favors either, the way I see it.

Controls – 9/10

As I pointed out before, the hit detection can be irritatingly inaccurate at times. And camera angles can seem somewhat awkward whilst climbing or traversing along buildings. But apart from that, there are thankfully no other problems to address.

Lifespan – 3/10

At best, Ico can only be made to last roughly 4 to 5 hours, which is unacceptable. As many side quests could easily have been added to make it last considerably longer. Despite its level of linearity. Its lack of additional content seems extremely unsavory. Especially as this was made in a time when 3D platforming had just about been perfected. And there were more games released at the time with much more substance to them. So by that logic, Ueda was always going to have a hard time competing with the likes of Jak & Daxter. As in Ico, there simply isn’t enough to do.

Storyline – 9/10

Although Ico could not have been able to compete with other games in terms of gameplay, it excels above many in terms of story. The tale involves a small boy called Ico, who has been imprisoned in a castle and manages to set himself free from the coffin he is put in. Finding a captive girl called Yorda, he releases her and resolves to help her escape from the castle along with him. Like Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, certain aspects of the story are told through gameplay. In that the two rely on each other to do certain things for both of them to progress. Conveying the themes of trust and cooperation, it all makes for an inspiring and emotional tale, with a few plot twists thrown in for good measure.

Originality – 8/10

Though I have my reservations about this game, the fact of the matter is that a game like Ico, which has gone on to inspire so many people across the last decade, has to be considered unique. However, the lack of imagination on the developer’s part stems from its lack of content in gameplay, in my opinion.

Happii

In summation, Ico can make for 4 or 5 hours of moderate entertainment and the telling of a well-written and well-conceived story, but to me, it is really missing a lot of gameplay variety and side quests, and again, it seems like a little bit too much of a fleeting experience.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Haven: Call of the King (PlayStation 2)

Haven

Haven

Developer(s) – Traveller’s Tales

Publisher(s) – Midway

Director – Jon Burton

Producer – Arthur Parsons

ELSPA – 3

Throughout the era of the PlayStation 2, GameCube, and Xbox, Midway was facing hard times in the industry. And they knew something needed to be done to make a lasting impression on gamers at the time. They decided to collaborate with Traveller’s Tales and release an almost all-or-nothing salvo on the PlayStation 2 (initially also planned for release on the GameCube and Xbox until the idea was ultimately dismissed). As one of their last hurrahs before they would eventually be absorbed back into their parent company, Warner Bros., though Haven: Call of the King was met with positive reviews by critics, it was also met with poor sales figures. The way I see it, I can understand one of these outcomes, but not the other. And my final opinion may surprise readers.

Graphics – 6.5/10

Even though the developers did try to create a vast world unlike any ever seen in a video game before, I found that influence certainly played a huge part in this title from the very beginning. The most obvious influence is behind the design of Vetch’s tower, which resembles a flaming cat’s eye. It should sound familiar, as The Lord of the Rings film trilogy was riding high at the time. And the main antagonist of the film, Sauron, took the form of a huge cat’s eye hovering over his tower of Barad-Dur. Even after the opening sequence, where this is first seen, I found that most of the rest of the game also seemed fairly generic to me.

Gameplay – 6/10

The best thing about the game’s play is the amount of variety that is on offer to players. Players can explore to a small extent, take part in races, rail-shooting sequences, and some fairly well-executed 3D platforming. But I can’t help but feel that the back of the game’s box presents a false advertisement. As the developers boasted “massive planets to visit and explore”. This suggested to me that there was much more of an open world than there actually is within the game. By that token, it’s my opinion that the game has far too much linearity. For one, of either the magnitude of the ambition that the developers clearly had regarding it.

Controls – 9/10

A positive that I can point out about this game is that, whilst the movement can seem a little bit stiff at times, there are no other issues with its control schemes for me to report. Once more, for a game with so many different ways of playing, this is quite impressive. It can sometimes prove pretty difficult for developers to keep track of games like that. I think if there had been any outstanding issues with the control scheme, then it may have turned players away from the many excellent 3D platformers that were being released on the PlayStation 2 at the time.

Lifespan – 7/10

With players being able to make Haven last for an average of 15-20 hours, I’d say the game has a fairly good lifespan for a 3D platformer. However, I can’t help but feel that the game could have easily been made to last considerably longer. If the developers had taken the time to fully realize what potential this game could have had if they had fully delivered on the exploration factor. It’s because of this that the game left me wanting considerably more than what I was given.

Storyline – 4/10

For me, the most disappointing thing about this game was its narrative. The story follows a slave called Haven. He embarks on a quest to save his people, and the rest of the universe, from its tyrannical ruler, Vetch. Attempting to provide an interesting take on the classic tale of the pawn reaching the end of the board, it was originally planned to be the first part of a video game trilogy. However, thanks to poor sales figures and most gamers taking merely a niche interest in the title, this never happened. And although I won’t give away what happens, what players were left with was a particularly unsatisfying and depressing cliffhanger ending.

It also made me regret that I had taken any time at all to invest in the characters. Such as Haven, Athellion, or even Vetch. As well as the voice acting being somewhat below par, there are also a lot of plot threads. Such as Haven accidentally striking his boss’s foot with a pickaxe, mistaking it for a rock. And remarking that anyone could have made the same mistake. As if people can’t tell the difference between a rock and someone’s foot. It was also very convenient that one of Vetch’s guards neglected to lock Haven’s cell later on in the game. Allowing him to escape from his prison.

Originality – 6/10

Despite the amount of ambition that both Midway and Traveller’s Tales had for Haven, it ultimately seemed to simply be a collection of many different video gaming tropes and ideas, as opposed to being a fully cohesive concept. I always find myself asking what the point of doing this is. Why develop a game when developers are going to neglect to add any flair to it and make it their own? Although it is somewhat interesting to be able to spot what kind of things influence a video game, it’s much more interesting to see what kind of new things developers can bring to the table. And I think the developers held back in that respect.

Niiutral

Overall, whilst Haven is by no means the worst 3D platformer to have been released on a PlayStation console, the fact that it remains overshadowed by many other great games of the time is justified in my opinion. Everything about it has been influenced by a collection of different games and media in one way or another. And while there is a small level of excitement to be had while playing, there isn’t enough for me to mention it in the same breath as some of either Midway or Traveller’s Tales’ better efforts.

Score

35.5/60

6/10 (Average)

Fez (PC, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4 & PlayStation Vita)

Fez

Developer(s) – Polytron Corporation

Publisher(s) – Trapdoor & Microsoft Studios

Director(s) – Marie-Christine Bourdua & Dominic Allair

Designer – Phil Fish

PEGI – 3

Released in 2012 after a five-year development cycle, which attracted an unusual amount of public exposure, as well as controversy stemming from the game’s lead designer, Phil Fish, Fez remains one of the most prominent examples of innovation amongst the indie gaming scene and was met with an overwhelmingly positive response upon release. Becoming one of only 13 games in the following year to receive a Metacritic aggregate score of over 90. Even though I did find it to be a fairly enjoyable game, it did have issues that need addressing.

Graphics – 9/10

One aspect, I have hardly any issues with, however, is the game’s visuals. There is an exceptional amount of variety in each different location throughout this title. And a great deal of imagination had clearly been put into it. Locations vary from forests to sewers to factories to lighthouses to hotels, even. In addition, there are also locations based on video gaming itself. Causing a good few cracks in the fourth wall, which I found to be particularly interesting.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

The objective of the game is to collect cubes and cube pieces (8 of which make an entire cube) to advance to each different location. There is a total of 64 cubes to collect, but the challenge of finding everything lies within the player’s ability to leave no stone unturned. This is made even harder by the fact that this game is presented through both a 2D and 3D perspective simultaneously. Players have the ability to rotate the scenery to uncover hidden items and even different locations.

It’s an extremely enjoyable experience. But in my opinion, severely marred by the fact that there are many overly convoluted puzzles that must be solved in order to find certain types of cubes. The anti-cubes. The infamous obsidian block puzzle is definitely the most prominent example of this since it was only solved after members of the Fez community got together and started pressing random buttons. And the solution was eventually stumbled upon.

Controls – 10/10

The game also has a perfectly good control scheme. Since the 2D side-scrolling formula had long since been perfected. And switching perspectives is seamless. It’s amazing how some of the most innovative ideas can also be some of the most simplistic in design. The map system can be somewhat difficult to follow at first. But that would largely be splitting hairs.

Lifespan – 5/10

To complete the game to 100% can take experienced players around 2 hours. But for players going through the game for the first time, it can take around 5 hours at most. Which, especially for an open-world game, is still quite below par. Part of the problem is that there are only a few objectives to undertake throughout the game of collecting cubes and cube bits. And unlike most conventional games, it doesn’t feature stable elements such as enemies to fight or a lot of side quests.

Storyline – 5/10

There isn’t a great deal in the way of the story either. It follows a character named Gomez, who one day stumbles upon a magic fez. This allows him to change perspectives in order to collect the cubes and restore the universe. Apart from that, not much else is elaborated upon. The game does break the fourth wall at the beginning by glitching out as soon as the chaos begins to ensue. And the game must then be started back up at that point. But after this, it becomes a case of simply finding the various references to games such as Super Mario Bros and The Legend of Zelda.

Originality – 8/10

Whilst it may be one of the simplest-looking games of the modern day, Fez is also one of the more creative. Two different concepts from two different genres of gaming were brought together to make something rather unique. And since being a source of inspiration behind games such as Monument Valley and Secrets of Raetikon. Whilst the conduct of its designer may have left a feeling of bitterness towards this game by the industry as a whole, it also left a strong impression on it.

Happii

In all, Fez, despite what faults I personally found with it, is by no means a bad game and is easy enough to cope with, given the aid of a strategy guide to go along with it. However, I, along with the entire industry, can only imagine what Fez 2 would have been like if it had been developed as originally planned.

Score

44.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

Darksiders (PC, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Wii U, Switch, Stadia PS3 & PlayStation 4)

Darksiders

Developer(s) – Vigil Games

Publisher(s) – THQ

Director(s) – David Adams & Joe Madureira

Producer – Timothy Bell

PEGI – 18

Part of the legacy of the now-defunct Vigil Games, Darksiders garnered an unprecedented amount of critical acclaim upon release, including a perfect score from the UK publication Play Magazine. Combining elements of God of War, Devil May Cry, and The Legend of Zelda series, it was most definitely another one of the greatest titles of the seventh generation, in my opinion. And a key reason why I was sorry to see Vigil Games disbanded.

Graphics – 9/10

Like another big-name hack-and-slash game that came out in the same year, God of War III, this game made an extremely explosive and intense first impression on gamers. In terms of gameplay, but also in terms of its impressive visuals. There is an incredibly detailed FMV sequence to start with. Depicting the coming of the apocalypse and the arrival of the game’s main character, the Horseman War. But aside from this, the conceptual design throughout the rest of the game is nothing short of spectacular. Combining a post-apocalyptic Earth with elements of Christian mythology and Gothic architecture, it all gives the game an insanely unique and wonderfully dark atmosphere.

Gameplay – 9/10

Playing out very much like a combination of both God of War and Ocarina of Time, it was inevitable that I would personally enjoy Darksiders from start to finish. The combat system is extremely fluent, working largely on the same principles as Ocarina of Time. But aside from that, there is also a fair amount of side quests to keep players busy in between undertaking the main story segments, and even elements of different kinds of games to keep things diverse. For example, the game also has mechanics similar to Portal, which must be used to solve various puzzles and even beat one of the game’s fascinating boss fights. The first boss in the game, in particular, Straga, is on my personal list of top ten favorite boss fights.

Controls – 10/10

The core control scheme of Darksiders would have been simple enough to have gotten right. But aside from this, what is most impressive is how the developers managed to incorporate a plethora of additional gameplay mechanics. Such as portal traversing, horse riding, platforming, and even third-person shooting. And they make the entire experience extremely simple to get to grips with. It may all seem over-complicated at first. But it’s delightfully surprising how quickly players will be able to adapt to it all.

Lifespan – 6/10

Clocking in at about 10 to 15 hours, it’s a fairly impressive lifespan for a game of its kind. Since God of War games tend to last for around 5 to 6 hours. But after playing it for the first time 5 years ago, I couldn’t help but think that there could have been so much added to it to give it even a small amount more longevity than it ended up having. Luckily, the sequel would arrive and address this issue flawlessly. Ultimately, making for an even better game than the first, in my opinion. But the original game was obviously a way to simply test the waters. And see how much the developers could add to a game like this.

Storyline – 9/10

Aside from there being great visuals, great gameplay, and wonderfully executed control mechanics, Darksiders also has an exceptional story attached to it. As the apocalypse falls upon humanity, as prophesied, the horseman War is summoned. But the other three, Strife, Fury, and Death, are strangely absent from the battlefield in the midst of the war between Heaven and Hell. It soon comes to light that the seventh seal has not been broken. And the horsemen’s governing body, the Charred Council, accuses War of disrupting the balance by bringing about the apocalypse prematurely.

War asserts his innocence and asks the Charred Council for a chance to be returned to Earth to find the one who is truly behind this. The Council agrees, and War is set on his path. Bound by another servant of theirs called the Watcher, who has the power to kill War if he strays from his objective. The story is filled with a plethora of twists and turns before the end. And features voice talent from some of the best in the industry. Including Troy Baker as Abaddon, and even Mark Hamill as the Watcher, who delivers one of the most interesting performances I’ve seen in any video game.

Originality – 7/10

Combining elements from many different games can simply be considered unoriginal. And if not done effectively enough, it can lead to a game going disastrously wrong and not working at all. This game, however, does it both right and in an extremely effective manner. All the mechanics influenced by many other games that have been released throughout the years come together flawlessly to provide players with a surprisingly cohesive concept. It’s a compelling blend of both old and new video game elements. And they all work together, forming a truly fantastic and unique title.

Happii

Overall, Darksiders is an amazing gaming experience. And I would highly recommend it as a must-have for anyone with a seventh-generation console. The sequel would go on to blow the original game out of the water. But that’s not to say that this game should be skipped. Even if they both take place in the same time frame story-wise.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)