Tag Archives: FPS

Perfect Dark Zero (Xbox 360)

Perfect Dark Zero

Developer(s) – Rare Ltd

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Game Studios

Director – Chris Tilston

Producer(s) – Richard Cousins, Lee Schuneman & Chris Kimmel

PEGI – 16

Released as a launch title for the Xbox 360 in 2005, following Microsoft’s purchase of Rare from Nintendo as a second-party developer back in 2003, Perfect Dark Zero, like Kameo: Elements of Power, was originally intended to be a GameCube game. But instead released on the Xbox 360. Garnishing critical acclaim and generating profits equivalent to four times its development costs. After playing this game myself, I see very little special about it, especially compared to the original Nintendo 64 game. It was one of two games I played on the Xbox 360. This made me think that the console’s early years were questionable until the release of The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion. The other is King Kong.

Graphics – 7/10

For the most part, the visuals did a good enough job of showing what the Xbox 360 was capable of displaying in terms of graphical quality compared to sixth-generation visuals. The conceptual design isn’t too bad either. It features elements both new to the series. And elements reminiscent of the original game, such as level layouts and modes of transportation. The biggest problem I have with them, however, is that the developers seemingly abandoned the dark and gritty tone set by the original game, which I prefer greatly. And which I believe better fits into the basic premise of the series.

Gameplay – 5/10

In my opinion, the game plays out more or less like any other average first-person shooter that has been seen before. It didn’t help matters that at this point, the concept of spy-based first-person shooters had been thoroughly milked ever since the release of Rare’s own Goldeneye 007 for the Nintendo 64. One thing I would advise players looking to check this game out, however, is that they turn off the arrows that generate on the floor to let them know where it is they need to go. After a while, this feature can make the player feel like the game is holding their hand constantly. And it can make the entire experience pretty boorish and straightforward by proxy.

Controls – 10/10

Though it should rightfully have been expected that there wouldn’t be a problem with the controls. First-person shooting games had been at this point long embedded into the gaming mainstream. And seemingly never to budge, the developers also did quite a decent job of implementing third-person elements. Such as hiding behind walls to take cover. This feature would be perfected in future games such as Deus Ex: Human Revolution. But it’s interesting to see where it stemmed from.

Lifespan – 6/10

On average, this game can take around 6 to 7 hours to complete, which is the average lifespan of a linear first-person shooter; consequently, it isn’t anything special. In all my time playing video games, I’ve never been able to come across a true open-world spy-based first-person shooter. Looking at the industry now, to me, at least doesn’t seem like a bad idea. The only thing coming close to this from what I’ve played is Deus Ex: Human Revolution. I can hope that Deus Ex: Mankind Divided can provide the experience I have in mind when I think of this, but for the most part, I think the industry may have missed a trick.

Storyline – 5/10

Set as a prequel to the original game, it portrays Joanna Dark in a much more unrefined form, in her constant battle with the maniacal corporation DataDyne. My gripe with the game’s visuals can also be applied to the game’s story, too. It has a much less dark and morbid feel to it, and consequently, I had a harder time trying to take it seriously. The voice acting doesn’t help either, since it is, by and large, quite cheesy and not very well thought out.

Originality – 2/10

Aside from there being third-person mechanics, the game plays out much worse than the original Perfect Dark, in my opinion, since it doesn’t allow players the time to work out where they need to go and what it is they need to do. There’s much less to this game than both the original and almost every other game made of the same ilk. The market would later become saturated with much better shooting games, which would later render early games like this becoming no more than a footnote, since there is very little present to make it stand out among an ever-growing crowd.

Niiutral

In summation, Perfect Dark Zero is most definitely one of the most lackluster launch titles I’ve ever played. Though the original PlayStation had a considerably shakier start, there was definitely a drop in launch title standards with the seventh generation of games, except the Wii’s launch, and this game gives testament to that.

Score

35/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

Outlast (PC & PlayStation 4)

Outlast

Developer(s) – Red Barrels

Publisher(s) – Red Barrels

Project Manager – Paul-Andre Renaud

Producer – Louis St Denis

PEGI – 18

Originally released last year as a digital download for Steam, Outlast found its way onto PlayStation 4. But whilst I think it definitely will provide a very stern test for veteran survival horror fans, for me personally, it did little but to re-emphasize the ongoing reservation I have with survival horror games. The focus seems to be mostly on merely making the game as scary as possible and deviating far too much from gameplay. This is the most important aspect of any game. But in terms of scaring people, this game certainly doesn’t disappoint.

Graphics – 9/10

For an indie game, it is very well polished, and the attention to detail in the environments and scenery certainly makes this game stand out from a graphical point of view, at least. But the fact that this game is so well-presented could also be disturbing to others. The gritty and horrific atmosphere is depicted throughout the course of the game through the presence of disemboweled corpses and pools of blood along the floors and walls. The surviving inmates around Mount Massive Asylum, where the game is set, also make for some particularly unnerving sights. Along with some of the game’s primary antagonists, such as Dr. Trager and Chris Walker. But even before I entered the asylum at the start of the game, the atmosphere was still extremely frightening. As the game begins on a windy night, illuminated by a murky-looking sunset.

Gameplay – 4/10

As much as I enjoyed this game’s atmosphere and horrific settings, the gameplay certainly left a lot to be desired. Even for survival horror. The objective of this game is to simply run and hide, whilst exploring the asylum. Often using a night vision camcorder. That’s it. There’s no way in which players can defend themselves at all, as with virtually every other game in the genre.

Whenever enemies come into proximity, players have no choice but to either run or hide from them. Which, whilst unique in its own way, makes this game seem like less of a game and more of a film. To me, it’s not engaging enough to be able to be called a true video game. Apart from this, there’s merely one side quest, involving the collection of documents scattered across the asylum. Unfortunately, the game’s play is original, but in a very negative way.

Controls – 10/10

A first-person survival horror, there are absolutely no problems with the controls at all. A nice touch that the developers added was the door-opening mechanics that involve slowly opening them. It increases or maintains the constant feeling of tension, which is present throughout the entirety of the game.

Lifespan – 2/10

This game will take no more than five hours to finish, as there is hardly anything to do in it. Again, I find this is particularly bad, even for a survival horror title. In other games of the genre, there is a bit more replay value to be had. As some of them include alternative endings. But there isn’t anything like that in Outlast, unfortunately. It’s also particularly annoying given the size of the in-game world. And what could’ve potentially been added to the gameplay in a bid to make it last longer?

Storyline – 7/10

If this game really had to play out as much like a film as it does, then it was imperative that it at least had a decent story, and the story isn’t too bad to be fair. It tells of a freelance journalist named Miles Upshur, who is tipped off by an anonymous source about events happening at Mount Massive Asylum. He decides to go and investigate, but unfortunately, he ends up finding more than what he’d bargained for and immediately resolves to escape with his life. As far as survival horror stories go, whilst pretty typical, it is particularly scary.

The majority of the scares in this game come not from either the copious amount of jump scares or buckets of blood, but from the constant feeling of tension, which has been a device used not only in video games before it but in top-notch horror films as well as classic literature. I also like the element of players having to discover the back story of Mount Massive Asylum for themselves through the documentation found throughout the game. But the game’s story loses marks for its lack of uniqueness. I mean, how many games or films before it depicted people traveling to reportedly dangerous places and subsequently found more than they would’ve liked?

Originality – 4/10

In addition to the game’s overall story probably sounding very familiar to fans of horror in general, the uniqueness found in the game’s play also has an extremely negative impact. I think the only thing this game would probably be good for is testing horror fans’ limits, as it is at least an incredibly scary experience.

Niiutral

To summarize, all Outlast did for me was perpetuate my constant concern that most games in this particular genre focus too much on scaring people and take focus away from what truly matters: the gameplay. Whilst it does have very decent visuals and a story worthy of the fan’s attention, it doesn’t take long for Outlast to outlast its appeal, in my opinion.

Score

37/60

6/10 (Average)

Oni (PC & PlayStation 2)

Oni

Developer(s) – Bungie & Rockstar Games

Publisher(s) – Gathering of Developers

Designer – Hardy LeBel

ELSPA – 15

Heavily inspired by the infamous Japanese manga film, Ghost in the Shell, Oni is a third-person action game. Which, to me, can be described as wanting at best. Though the release of the PlayStation 2 marked a turning point in how Sony would approach the 3D action-adventure genre and release some of the best games of that kind. Such as Jak & Daxter and Ratchet & Clank, these early PlayStation 2 and PC titles don’t fall into that category in my opinion. There have been mixed reviews of this game, and I wanted a definitive answer, but I was disappointed by the result.

Graphics – 5/10

From the very first level, I thought very little of the variety and quality of visual design. Thinking nothing of it, other than it being bland. Though it had been influenced by one of my favorite Japanese films, it doesn’t seem to me like the developers capitalized on that properly. Since they clearly haven’t added any flair to that concept. In a bid to make the content of the game truly their own cohesive work. Also, compared to many early PlayStation 2 titles, I don’t think it does a particularly good job of showing off what the system was capable of on a graphical level either.

Gameplay – 5/10

In terms of gameplay, I found that things didn’t get significantly better by any means. There’s nothing about it to even make it stand out to any particular extent next to other early PlayStation 2 games like Operation Winback or even Gift. There is a little bit of variety to be experienced towards the end of Oni. But for the most part, it stays extremely repetitive and extremely unmemorable, the way I see it. I even felt fatigued by playing it before the first hour had passed. And it felt like a chore to play through it to the end.

Controls – 4/10

Like many 3D action-adventure games on the original PlayStation, Oni’s control scheme is dishearteningly broken. Everything about the game’s controls, from aiming weapons to moving around to traversing platforms to hand-to-hand combat, makes the game ever more dismal and unsatisfying to play. Although Bungie would later be known among the gaming companies for developing some of the best first-person shooters of all time, I guess 3D action-adventure games are not their strong suit.

Lifespan – 4/10

To soldier through the game’s main story campaign will take roughly 5 hours. But in all honesty, I think player interest will outlast its lifespan. I don’t believe there’s enough to do or see in the game that would make people want to play it for an extended period of time.

Storyline – 3/10

The story of Oni centers on a secret agent named Konoko. She works for the police force responsible for suppressing opposition to the laws of the dystopian society that Earth has become. But later embarks on a quest for self-discovery. There is one major twist in the plot at a point. But other than that, I don’t think there was much thought put into it at all. The voice acting is weak at best. And the characters are consequently very monotonous and very hard to identify with. It’s indeed not worthy of the excellent story it was influenced by.

Originality – 1/10

Again, the game draws inspiration from an excellent source. But that influence was not built upon enough to make it stand out anywhere near the same level as the controversial Japanese film. There’s no room for artistic interpretation or debate. And on top of that, there is nothing new or exciting brought to the table in terms of gameplay either.

Angrii

Overall, Oni is a dreadful gaming experience. And I would advocate that anyone who is sitting on the fence about it, as I was, not bother with it. Bungie has since gained well-deserved renown as a video game developer. But this early example merely lives in the shadow of what they have gone on to achieve, and in my opinion, rightfully so.

Score

22/60

3.5/10 (Very Poor)

Killzone: Shadow Fall (PlayStation 4)

Killzone: Shadow Fall

Developer(s) – Guerrilla Games

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Steven ter Heide

Producer – Qiong L.

PEGI – 18

Before Killzone: Shadow Fall, none of the Killzone games ever appealed to me. They just seemed like another clone of Call of Duty or Battlefield. Just with a more futuristic setting, with no outstanding gameplay features or any means of leaving any kind of lasting impression on me. After playing Shadow Fall, I discovered that I was more or less proven right. Despite how great the game looks, it does just play out relatively like any generic first-person shooter. But with an element of stealth added in. To me, Killzone: Shadow Fall is a pretty typical launch title; made simply to showcase the capabilities of its console in terms of both graphics and controls.

Graphics – 9.5/10

When I first laid eyes on this game, I’d never seen anything like it before. There was clearly an unfathomable amount of detail put into making this game look as stunning as possible in both graphical design and conceptual design. But I think the standout feature for me was how the levels in the middle of the game were set out. A lot of them are set in slums where the effects of the game’s events become most apparent. People are exiled and left to fend for themselves as a result of events such as war and political decline. Things like that have happened throughout the course of human history. And it’s portrayed in a very realistic manner.

Gameplay – 5/10

Unfortunately, the game’s visuals are indeed the only aspect that I can wax poetic about. To me, the gameplay is generic at best. For the most part, it is just a typical linear, run-and-gun first-person shooter. Similar to Medal of Honour and Call of Duty. There are a few stealth mechanics that stand out somewhat. But it’s all been done already. In fact, the only part of the game that truly stood out for me was the epilogue. Whereby the player takes control of an entirely different character to perform an additional assassination mission. But in my opinion, I certainly don’t think it’s worth having to play through the rest of the game to unlock the epilogue and play through it.

Controls – 10/10

A good thing I can say about this game, however, is that there are no problems with the controls. In fact, fairly decent use is made of the new control features that come with playing a game on the PlayStation 4, such as the touchpad.

Lifespan – 4/10

With side quests merely involving collecting things such as abandoned newspaper supplements and audiotapes, there didn’t seem to be enough to warrant even seven hours of gameplay in all. Games like this are more tailored for playing online. But I personally grew bored with playing online first-person shooters about as quickly as I started.

Storyline – 5/10

The story of Killzone: Shadow Fall follows a soldier called Lucas Kellen. He is tasked with helping to keep the peace between two factions fighting against each other. But soon after the game begins, tensions between the two factions reach a boiling point, and war soon breaks out. The lines between right and wrong begin to blur from Kellen’s point of view, and events soon unfold into something much more complicated. While the story is interesting at times, I found that it’s much too exclusive to fans of the series to truly appeal to any newcomers to the series. Playing through Shadow Fall certainly didn’t leave me with any desire to go back and play through the original Killzone trilogy, as Mass Effect 2 compelled me to go back and play through the first.

Originality – 3/10

The only remotely unique feature of Shadow Fall to me was the use of the OWL device in combat, which can be used to gain a tactical advantage over enemies. But other than that, there seem to be too many familiar first-person shooting elements in the game for me to be able to call it original.

Niiutral

To summarize, Killzone: Shadow Fall, to me, is a lot like a reality television show; it may look glamorous and extravagant on the surface, but it has little substance and only moderate instances of legitimate entertainment value.

Score

36.5/60

6/10 (Average)

The House of the Dead 2 (Arcade, PC, Dreamcast & Wii)

House of the Dead 2

Developer(s) – Wow Entertainment

Publisher(s) – Sega

PEGI – 16

Released three years after the original game, House of the Dead 2 received a mostly positive reception from critics. Most seemingly in agreement that it made significant improvements on the first titles in the series. Personally, I do have to say I spent a lot of time playing this game when I was younger. But looking back at it now, I realize many of its core faults with it.

Graphics – 7/10

Despite several glitches here and there, the visuals were very much ahead of their time. Since it was ported to the Sega Dreamcast as well as arcade cabinets. And the Dreamcast was capable of rendering much more advanced visuals than both the Nintendo 64 and the original PlayStation. The conceptual design was fairly well handled for the most part. The game is set in Venice, Italy. But the game also takes the player to different locations as it progresses. Such as a colosseum in Rome, and a once-thriving modern city. Those levels are set in broad daylight, however. Because of that, the game loses much more of its horror factor towards the end, the way I see it.

Gameplay – 7/10

Despite the many faults House of the Dead 2 has, the one aspect that was enjoyable at the time and is still enjoyable to this day is the gameplay. In a first-person rail shooter, the objective is simply to kill every zombie or monster that may block the player’s path in order to progress through each level. And defeat the various bosses waiting for them. When I was growing up, I was always lukewarm to rail-shooting games. But after the likes of Halo and Half-Life came to home consoles, they blew games like this out of the water. Since there was much more to them. Nevertheless, it’s only in terms of gameplay that I feel this title does hold up to a small extent.

Controls – 10/10

The control schemes in rail shooters are much simpler and more self-explanatory than even a first-person shooter. So consequently, there are no issues that will arise in this respect whilst playing it. The only functions players must grow accustomed to are simply aiming, shooting, and reloading.

Lifespan – 3/10

In lieu of the tradition of the genre, one playthrough of this game will only last an average of forty minutes. But what longevity there is in playing this game comes from the fact that it was designed to be played a multitude of times. Especially since there are a few alternative endings to unlock. Depending on certain circumstances throughout the game. I do feel, however, that much more could have been added to make it last at least twice as long. Or even an endless mode could have been added to the home console versions of the game.

Storyline – 2/10

The worst thing about this game is undoubtedly the storyline. Even though the industry was still in the process of getting out of the mindset that video games didn’t necessarily have to tell a story in order to be good, there were many different factors making this story especially bad. It follows AMS agents James and Gary trying to get to the bottom of a zombie epidemic that has broken out in Venice and is threatening to spread across the planet. Aside from the plot being extremely typical of most zombie films that have been released prior, the voice acting is particularly poor and embarrassing.

Anyone who may have thought the original Resident Evil had bad voice acting hasn’t heard anything yet until they experience what this game has to offer. It also now seems pretty stupid that the developers chose to keep the name The House of the Dead attached to the project. Since the setting contradicts the name greatly, as it’s no longer set in a house. Personally, I would have given it a more relevant name. And just stuck with the same text font, so that people would have recognized that it was from the same series of games. But alas, the developers settled on what they did.

Originality – 4/10

Aside from the story being very unoriginal, the gameplay, whilst enjoyable, didn’t really bring anything new to the genre; essentially playing out like a carbon copy of the first game. As well as other games in the genre, such as Time Crisis or Virtua Cop. Although the reload mechanism is much more accessible than in Time Crisis, there wasn’t anything beyond that that made it stand out from any other rail shooting title.

Angrii

Overall, House of the Dead 2 was a decent game, maybe 15 years ago. But now, it seems like a much less enjoyable experience for those many reasons. With so many zombie-based shooters finding their way into mainstream gaming these days, it would be hard for Sega to make another game in the series. Unless they do something drastic with the story as well as the gameplay.

Score

33/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

Halo 4 (Xbox 360 & Xbox One)

Halo 4

Developer(s) – 343 Industries

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Studios

Director – Josh Holmes

Producer – Chris Lee

PEGI – 16

Highly anticipated for a number of years until its release in 2012, Halo 4 was the third highest-selling game of 2012 and was played by over one million people within 24 hours of its launch. It introduced a new enemy race, as well as a new range of weapons to use in combat. This makes for a pretty intense experience instead of the Halo tradition. Nevertheless, I was left bitterly disappointed by how little the single-player experience had to offer. Especially compared with many other Halo campaigns, it’s well below par.

Graphics – 9/10

The visuals indeed did a very good job at showing off the budget. But aside from that, there is also the basis of visual diversity. With the conceptual design of many of the varied locations, a fair few of them look very new to the franchise. And the design of the new weapons and enemies. It could be argued that many elements seem recycled. Such as the conceptual design of the UNSC and the Covenant. And even levels set in forests and desert lands, but to do that would be to mock every other great video game franchise that has come before it. Mario, Zelda, etc.

Gameplay – 6/10

Although the main story mode is extremely intense and enjoyable for the time that it lasts, which is far too short, it seemed like the best was saved for the online multiplayer. which not everyone with an Xbox 360 would be able to take advantage of. It doesn’t matter what amount of money players spend on the game. Even two years after its release, an additional £40 has to be spent to get the majority of the gameplay out of it. Which some may consider a clever sales strategy. But to me, it seems very biased.

Controls – 10/10

There aren’t any issues with the controls. And it would have been most probably one of the most straightforward factors in making this game. Since all the developers would have had to have done was play a Halo game. And not disappoint fans by trying to needlessly change them up, and potentially make any silly mistakes in the process.

Lifespan – 3/10

The main story campaign will take a dismal 4 to 5 hours to finish. This, compared to most other Halo games, let alone most other first-person shooters, is far below acceptable standards. Other Halo games before it had exceptionally longer campaign modes. And still managed to put adequate emphasis. And with the astronomical budget attached to this game, there was no excuse for not sufficiently accommodating single players as well as online players. I was personally so thrown by the fact that it lasts so short a time that I was surprised the rest of the campaign wasn’t on the second disc.

Storyline – 5/10

The story follows the Master Chief, who, after being in stasis for some time, finds himself on a planet once inhabited by the ancient race of the Forerunners. It awakens a new enemy of ancient Forerunner warriors known as the Prometheans, and their leader, the Didact. The Master Chief must eliminate these threats in order to ensure the survival of humanity. The story is somewhat fresh, but it does ultimately work better for fans than newcomers. So it could cause problems for people introduced to the franchise with this game.

Originality – 1/10

Though it does somewhat well to stand out among most entries in the Halo series, it does very little to stand out among other first-person shooters. And no genuine innovation has been made, in my opinion. I would’ve thought that with it being put in the hands of a new developer, they may have tried something a bit more different. And deviated away from some of the many staples of the series. But not a great deal has been done in that respect.

Angrii

To sum up, Halo 4, to me, is the worst Halo game I’ve ever played for a good number of reasons. It’s far too short; there is a grave imbalance of both single-player and online multiplayer facilities. Even for an Xbox 360 game, not enough has been done to keep the series interesting for me to even be able to recommend it to a Halo fan.

Score

34/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

Half-Life 2 (PC, Xbox, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 & Shield Portable)

Half-Life 2

Developer(s) – Valve

Publisher(s) – Valve & Sierra Entertainment

PEGI – 16

Following up on the immensely successful first-person shooter Half-Life, Half-Life 2 takes Gordon Freeman out of the lab and into the game’s outside world. Filled with more of the same alien-fighting and puzzle-solving action, the way I see it, it is a very worthy sequel to one of the greatest video games of all time, in my own personal opinion.

Graphics – 8/10

The most visible improvements made to the last time to me are in the sequel’s increased amount of variety in enemy design, as well as graphical quality. Though the scenery may not be quite as varied as in the first game, that taking place in an alien dimension as well as a vast research facility (indeed, both games could be accused of having generic elements), the atmosphere is just as terrifically horrifying and imposing as its predecessor.

Gameplay – 9/10

Like the first game before it, Half-Life 2 is an exceptional first-person shooter, with some new physics added in for good measure. These new gameplay mechanics were revolutionary at the time and would go on to inspire the creation of Valve’s own Portal, among many other future games. The combat sequences are just as challenging and enthralling as in the first game, and in lieu of Valve tradition, there is the element of outside-the-box puzzle-solving that the company has gained a reputation for, spanning almost twenty years.

Controls – 9.5/10

The only minor problem I had with the game’s control scheme was during the boat-riding sequences, whereby Gordon has to ride a speedboat to progress; it can be a little bit unnecessarily tricky to control at times, and crashes can become frequent for those unprepared. But otherwise, it plays out just like any exceptional first-person shooter should play out.

Lifespan – 6/10

Lasting about 12 to 15 hours, it only lasts about half the time as the original game, which, to me, was somewhat disappointing. It also seemed unusual to me, since the game was just as satisfying to play as the original, and they could have easily drawn it out at least a little longer than how long it ended up lasting. I would recommend anyone looking to play this game to get The Orange Box available for both Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3, since not only does it contain the original game, but also its sequels, Half-Life 2 Episode One and Half-Life 2 Episode 2 (as well as both Team Fortress 2 and the original Portal game).

Storyline – 8/10

Taking place roughly 20 years after the events of the previous game, Half-Life 2 follows the series’ main protagonist, Dr. Gordon Freeman, now under the employment of the mysterious G-Man. Gordon is brought out of stasis by the G-Man and led to a dystopian metropolis called City 17. Freeman finds himself helping a resistance faction known as the Black Mesa East to stop a multidimensional empire known as the Combine from harvesting Earth’s resources, including humanity itself. Just like the first game, there are plenty of twists and turns before the end, as well as the omnipresence of the G-man himself, spoon-feeding players just enough information to make them want to find out more about who he is, what he is, and to possibly be able to better see the bigger picture. One major improvement to the game’s story, I found, was the more effective use of voice acting throughout.

Originality – 8/10

Though for the most part, this game can just seem to be a pretty standard first-person shooter, especially to newcomers to the series, the new physics introduced to the game would go on to inspire many different developers to create a plethora of different games, not only within the confines of the genre but across other genres too. To me, it had a very positive impact on creativity within the gaming industry, especially as the transition from the sixth generation to the seventh generation of gaming was just around the corner at the time.

Happii

To conclude, Half-Life 2 is most definitely a classic game and one that I would thoroughly recommend to any fan of first-person shooters. Though I personally greatly prefer the original game, Half-Life 2 is an excellent attempt to follow up on what Valve did with the first and is definitely worth playing through at least once.

Score

48.5/50

8/10 (Very Good)

Gears of War 3 (Xbox 360)

Gears of War 3

Developer(s) – Epic Games

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Studios

Designer(s) – Cliff Bleszinski, Lee Perry, Dave Nash & Jim Brown

PEGI – 18

Developed as the last game in the series’ main timeline, Gears of War 3 garnered either perfect or near-perfect scores from critics. Leading the franchise to gross over $1 billion in total. In my opinion, whilst the games aren’t terrible, Gears of War is one of the most overrated series in the history of video gaming. And the third game in the series is the worst out of the original trilogy for a multitude of reasons.

Graphics – 7/10

Though the game’s visuals are very technically astute, as in line with the franchise’s tradition, the main reason why I think they are such a negative departure from the rest of the series is that I couldn’t take the game’s conceptual design as seriously as in the two previous installments. Everywhere in the game, there exist sunny, calm, and tranquil environments in stark contrast to the many dark and gritty environments synonymous with the series, which I infinitely prefer. For example, the end level is a luxury island built for VIPs in the event of humanity losing the war.

Gameplay – 7/10

Although the game retains the same amount of satisfaction that the first and second games presented players with, it remains largely the same as them. With no true innovation made to keep things as interesting as they possibly could have been. There was one instance towards the end of the game whereby Marcus and the party had to travel underwater in a heavily fortified submarine, which offered some first-person shooting gameplay. But beyond this, there are barely any new weapons. And as such, it acts mostly as an extension to the first two titles.

Controls – 10/10

Since the gameplay remains largely the same, the game also makes use of the same control scheme, and as such, there are no problems with it. Though nothing overly ambitious was tried during the development of Gears of War 2, and despite doing what it did right, I feel as if they could have tried something newer than what was offered with the third game, since the fundamentals at this point had been mastered, and there was definitely room for innovation.

Lifespan – 5/10

Unfortunately, the third game only lasts around the same amount of time as both the first and second games, averaging at about 5 to 6 hours. But to me, the fact that there was still no innovation after two previous games made the lifespan seem fractionally more underwhelming; like the developers had simply been resting on their laurels as opposed to trying something new.

Storyline – 6/10

Another reason why I feel that Gears of War 3 is the worst out of the original three is that, unlike the second game, there isn’t a great deal to its story, making me care even less about things such as the mythology behind the series and the development of characters. Mirroring Dom’s efforts to try and find his wife in the last game, it’s Marcus who is trying to find his father, Adam Fenix, who went missing some time prior to the start of the game. It is believed that Adam has a solution to ending the conflict with both the locusts and the lambent, and is on a mission to find him and end the war for good. Bar one particularly emotional scene in the game, the plot is almost identical to that of Gears of War 2, which felt particularly disappointing.

Originality – 2/10

The developers made little to no effort to bring anything new to the table when it came to developing the second game, and they made even less innovation in the third. I think they should have left the series there and not developed Gears of War Judgement, which was even worse. There is a new game in the series planned for release on the Xbox One sometime in the near future, and it will be handled by a different developer, so there could be a glimmer of hope for the future of the franchise. But so far, I don’t believe it is a series worth even a fraction of the attention and acclaim that it has garnered.

Niiutral

Overall, Gears of War 3, whilst effectively following the tropes of the series as well as it could have done, is the original trilogy’s lowest point. Some video game trilogies, such as Mass Effect and God of War, have impressed me over the years, but only because the developers were not afraid to try new things. But to me, it isn’t the case with Gears of War.

Score

37/60

6/10 (Average)

Gears of War 2 (Xbox 360)

Gears of War 2

Developer(s) – Epic Games

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Game Studios

Producer – Rod Ferguson

Designer(s) – Cliff Bleszinski, Lee Perry, Dave Nash & Jim Brown

PEGI – 18

Released two years after the astoundingly successful first game in the series, Gears of War 2 gained similar critical and commercial acclaim. Attaining perfect scores from more than one gaming website. And had sold over 5 million copies worldwide by the end of 2009. However, whilst I don’t think this game is bad by any means, I don’t share quite the same level of enthusiasm about the sequel. As many other reviewers did upon the game’s release. And I think the developers could have done more with the $12,000,000 budget. Rather than invest the majority of it in the game’s visuals.

Graphics – 9/10

Among the best-looking Xbox 360 games at the time, the visuals are technically astounding. And there is even more diversity in conceptual design than in the previous game. Some stages take place in such locations as underground caves, Locust strongholds, and even in the stomach of a huge monster called a Riftworm. There is also a new hostile species introduced in the second game called the Lambent, which offers even more basis in visual diversity.

Gameplay – 8.5/10

The gameplay in the second installment is incredibly intense as well as satisfying. It’s pretty much like an extension of the first game in this respect. In a third-person shooter, the objective is to simply get from point A to point B and waste every single enemy in sight. The problem I have with it, however, as is indeed the main gripe I have about the entire game, is that there is no real innovation made in terms of gameplay to keep the Over series fresh enough. It plays out more or less identically to the first game, and there aren’t really any new features for me to be able to call it worthy of a sequel, as it perhaps could have been.

Controls – 10/10

Gears of War was one of the first third-person shooters I ever played that had a nigh-on-perfect control scheme. Following the many games in the genre that were released during the sixth generation. But had very primitive control schemes since the genre was in a period of relevant infancy. Thankfully, Epic Games didn’t try anything overly ambitious with the control scheme they already had. And chose to stick with the fundamentals of the first game.

Lifespan – 5.5/10

The second game lasts only about as long as the first, at around 5 to 6 hours. And I can’t help but feel that if the developers had decided to put more into the gameplay to keep the series fresh, then they could have, in turn, made the second game last even a little bit longer than it did. It could be argued that replay value can be had in going back and doing the collectibles’ side quest. But there isn’t much incentive within the game for doing so, and unless online multiplayer were to appeal to fans. Which only does for a limited amount of time, with a game, anyway, it can feel quite disappointing.

Storyline – 9/10

One advantage that Gears of War 2 has over the first is that there is a much more in-depth narrative. The story follows the newly promoted Sergeant Marcus Fenix. As the COG army prepares to launch an assault against their warring enemies, the Locust. At the same time, Marcus’ closest comrade, Dom Santiago, is currently trying to find his missing wife, Maria. It also plays a very prominent role in the story and catalyzes many of the game’s plot developments throughout.

Originality – 3/10

As I pointed out before, though the second game is almost as enjoyable to play as the first game, that’s all it is in terms of originality. The typical fashion in which a sequel is normally developed is for it to be made bigger and better than the original. And whilst playing, I was left with the impression that the second game was tailored to be neither bigger nor better. But to simply look sharper than the original game, and to have a better story. And whilst they can both be seen as two positive departures from the first Gears of War, I was given the impression that the developers had forgotten the most important aspect to have been modified: the gameplay.

Happii

In summation, Gears of War 2, despite its lack of innovation and in-depth modification of the original gameplay formula, still plays out identically to one of my favorite games of all time and is most definitely worth playing through once. The graphics were top-notch for the time. And the story is extremely compelling for a game that revolves around excessive masculinity and big guns. I just wish that more could have been added in terms of gameplay. This could have made it a better game than its predecessor. Since my level of anticipation was inevitably hyped up before the game’s release.

Score

45/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Frontlines: Fuel of War (PC, Xbox 360 & OnLive)

Frontlines Fuel of War

Developer(s) – Kaos Studios & nFusion Interactive

Publisher(s) – THQ

PEGI – 16

Frontlines: Fuel of War is a first-person shooter that plays out very much in the same vein as Battlefield, Medal of Honour, etc. Only with this title, the most interesting thing to talk about is its development history. The game was originally planned to be released for both the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3. But the PS3 version was canceled due to problems the developers were having with the console’s hardware. In my opinion, it’s no big loss.

Graphics – 2/10

Aside from having about as interesting a conceptual design as a breadstick, it’s particularly hard for me to imagine why the developers would have had trouble porting it to the PlayStation 3. It looks primitive in comparison with many other games released for either system at that time. It was made to look especially bad after Fallout 3 was released 8 months later. And despite issues, it was released by Bethesda on PlayStation 3.

Gameplay – 1/10

As a standard and non-standout FPS, the game incorporates about the same things as any other game of its kind. But to an even worse level of quality. All it involves is what I alluded to earlier. Kill, capture a position, pines, and repeat. There are no side quests, no legitimate incentives, and no replay value at all. Adding to the collection of my least favorite video games of the seventh generation.

Controls – 7/10

Even compared with other first-person shooters, the controls are fractionally harder to get to grips with, since the buttons are mapped out differently, and there is no proper way of precision aiming outside of zooming in, unlike almost every single entry in the Call of Duty series. Otherwise, however, there aren’t any other major issues to be concerned about, and to me, that’s about the only positive I can deduce from this title.

Lifespan – 5/10

Lasting about as long as the average army-based FPS, it clocks in at about 6 to 7 hours, but in all honesty, I’d be amazed to hear about anyone inclined to make it past one hour. Once more, I said, there are no additional features or quests outside the main campaign; thus, a game like this to last any longer than it does is largely unwarranted.

Storyline – 0.5/10

Basically, an army goes off to fight another army over territory and resources. In all honesty, it’d be quicker and more interesting to read a newspaper.

Originality – 0/10

Unfortunately, this game would not be the last of its kind to be released throughout mainstream gaming, but it was by no means the first either.

Furiious

In summation, the only saving grace Frontlines: Fuel of War has is that it has fallen deep into obscurity and is not coming back from it. I apologize to my readers that this review is as half-hearted as it is, but in my opinion, it is fitting of the game itself.

Score

15.5/60

3.5/10 (Very Poor)