Tag Archives: Nintendo

Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem (GameCube)

Eternal Darkness

Developer(s) – Silicon Knights

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Dennis Dyack, Tatsuya Hishida & Hiroyuki Yamada

Producer(s) – Shigeru Miyamoto, Satoru Iwata & Kenji Miki

ELSPA – 15

Released as a GameCube launch title back in 2002, along with the likes of Luigi’s Mansion, Pikmin, and Super Smash Bros Melee, Eternal Darkness was one of Nintendo’s first forays into the survival horror genre, which had been well and truly established throughout the previous generation with the advent of both Resident Evil and Silent Hill. But rather than referring to it as a survival horror, developers Silicon Knights cited it as a psychological thriller. Arguing that the story and overall atmosphere of Eternal Darkness weren’t as reminiscent of the B-list movie scene as Resident Evil Was. In my opinion, that certainly shows.

Graphics – 7/10

The game did a pretty decent job of showing players what the Nintendo GameCube was capable of on a graphical level in the early stages of its shelf life. But more important and noticeable than that, in my opinion, is the gritty and shadowy atmosphere of Alex’s grandfather’s Rhode Island mansion. There is limited visibility, and a lot of the furniture, namely the bookcases and the piano, is finished with what looks like Chinese lacquer. Giving an almost red color, alluding to blood. Possibly a reference to the HG Wells short story, The Red Room. It can also make players see Luigi’s Mansion in a somewhat different and more disturbing light than before, as both games are set in mansions. Most probably a reference to one another.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

For the most part, Eternal Darkness plays out very similarly to both Resident Evil and Silent Hill. Linear action-adventure games with an emphasis on puzzle solving. But what sets this game apart from both of the aforementioned examples, as well as every other survival horror game ever made, is the revelation of the sanity meter. An in-game meter, which depletes the longer players spend time fighting enemies.

Depletion of this meter causes unorthodox things to happen within the game. Such as the appearance of distorted imagery and scenery. And even the breaking of the fourth wall is designed to throw players off guard. For example, notices may pop up saying that the controller is unplugged when it isn’t. I’ve never seen anything remotely similar to this used in any other game apart from Don’t Starve. And in all honesty, it makes me wonder why the idea hasn’t caught on with most other leading developers in the survival horror genre. It is a very effective scare tactic to use within a video game.

Controls – 9/10

The control scheme of video games like the original Resident Evil and Silent Hill always frustrated me to an extent. since it seemed like a chore to turn the character around in a different or opposite direction. Most probably why they added the feature to turn 180 degrees with a single button. It would also make combat pretty awkward, too. It’s the same story in Eternal Darkness. But at least, like in games such as Tunguska, it doesn’t cause enough of a problem to render it virtually unplayable, at least.

Lifespan – 6/10

The game can be made to last roughly 11 to 12 hours. Whilst that isn’t that great, it is actually a fair bit longer than prior games of its kind to have been made to last. To put that in retrospect, that’s about the average amount of time it would take to finish the two playthroughs of Resident Evil 2. The one thing I wish could have been added to not just Eternal Darkness. But all other games made in the same vein were a bit more incentive than simply trying to unlock every possible ending. Some games, like Silent Hill 2, have things like additional weapons to unlock. But I find that things like that don’t really give a game enough replay value.

Storyline – 7/10

A fairly well-conceived story, it revolves around a young woman named Alexandra Roivas. Upon arriving at her late grandfather’s house to investigate his death, she stumbles upon a secret room in the mansion containing a volume called The Tome of Eternal Darkness. The book causes her to see into the experiences of past figures throughout human history. Alexandra must experience all of these past events to uncover the truth behind her grandfather’s death. The strongest point of this game’s story is undoubtedly the voice acting. Featuring the voice talents of several cast members of the Metal Gear Solid games, such as David Hayter, Greg Eagles, and one of my personal favorite video game voice actors, Jennifer Hale.

Originality – 7/10

Though the game is largely unoriginal in terms of both general gameplay and its main hub world, there is, however, a fair bit of visual diversity in the rest of the game’s settings. It takes place throughout a wide range of periods in human history. And depicting a wide range of different cultures. In terms of gameplay, there is also the inclusion of the sanity meter. And the unpredictable effects it can have on the game, as well as on the player.

Happii

In summation, Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem, to me, is one of the better action-adventure survival horror games out there. And I would highly recommend it to any fan of the genre who may have missed this title. It’s a classic example of how Nintendo isn’t just for kids. And it’s a survival horror experience that remains unlike any other to this day.

Score

42.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

EarthBound (Super Nintendo & Wii U Virtual Console)

 EarthBound

Developer(s) – Ape & HAL Laboratory

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Shigesato Itoi

Producer(s) – Shigesato Itoi & Satoru Iwata

PEGI – 12

EarthBound was a game released late in the shelf life of the Super Nintendo. Part of the obscure Nintendo series known as Mother, EarthBound is also known as Mother 2 in Japan. Due to the low sales figures attached to the game in both Japan and America, it never saw a physical release in Europe. Looking back, I wish that I did have this game as part of my childhood. Because it is one of the best 16-bit games I’ve played. And it has found its way onto my top ten list of 16-bit games that I did two weeks ago as the new number 6 entry.

Graphics – 7/10

At first, the settings and style of the game can seem pretty generic. Especially by today’s standards. For example, the first four towns in the game are unimaginatively named Onett, Twoson, Threed, and Fourside. But it’s later on in the game with locations such as Yucca Desert and the Cave of the Past. That’s the point at which the game starts to get really good in terms of visual presentation. Not only that, but there is also an extremely diverse enemy roster. Including opponents such as nightmares, krakens, giant ants, and gang members. And a race of extraterrestrials known as Starmen. It’s concepts like these that remind me of how imaginative Nintendo’s personnel are.

After his work on games such as this, it was no wonder that Hiroshi Yamauchi chose to hand Nintendo over to the current president, Satoru Iwata, who worked on this game. However, I think the biggest fault I could point out about the game’s graphics is the inconsistency of the designs of the character sprites. A lot of the female characters have differently shaped mouths. Presumably to highlight how much makeup they all individually wear. But a lot of them were pretty badly done. For example, Pokey’s mother was given a huge pink smile to seemingly make it look as if she wears more makeup than other women. But to me, it just makes her look like a clown.

Gameplay – 8/10

What I like about EarthBound is that, unlike a lot of other turn-based RPGs, it also provides a particularly stern challenge as well as extremely addictive gameplay. It differs from the likes of Final Fantasies VII through X. The fact is that players are not able to simply beat up on whatever they please for the most part. As with all turn-based RPGs, the further the player progresses, the tougher the enemies become.

But that’s done a lot more effectively in EarthBound. But what the aforementioned Final Fantasy games lack in challenge, I find that they more than make up for in in-gameplay variety. And whilst EarthBound does indeed have a lot of variety to it, it just doesn’t have as much. But having said that, this is so far the best 16-bit turn-based RPG I’ve ever played so far. But in the future, I may yet be proven otherwise. As I haven’t properly played through Final Fantasies III, IV, V, or VI.

Controls – 10/10

Like South Park: The Stick of Truth, for example, before the release of EarthBound, the turn-based RPG genre was very prominent in Japan by the late 80s and early 90s. And then throughout the late 90s, everywhere else. By that token, the control formula had been well and truly mastered by developers. And there were never going to be any issues. I also think that EarthBound may have been one of the first games that had ATMs that could be used to withdraw and deposit money. As EarthBound was developed by many of the same people who developed Pokémon (another turn-based RPG), it’s intriguing to know where that particular feature originated from.

Lifespan – 8/10

Overall, EarthBound can be made to last around 30-40 hours. Although that may seem like a fraction of how long many other future games would be made to last, it must have been considered exceptionally long at the time. Especially as most gamers in North America, for example, would’ve been more accustomed to playing traditional 2D side-scrolling games as opposed to turn-based RPGs. EarthBound was released in the mid-90s before Final Fantasy VII was released. And took the genre into the global mainstream. 30 to 40 hours is also particularly long for a turn-based RPG that virtually has very few side quests compared to other games of its kind. Most of the time is spent on leveling up characters due to the game’s exceptional level of challenge, I find.

Storyline – 9/10

Undoubtedly, this is by some margin the best aspect of this game in many, many ways. Over the years, it has yielded controversy, humor, fan debate, and a cult following. And to me, it is a very important early example of how video games can indeed be considered a viable art form. The story of EarthBound follows a young boy called Ness, who is woken up one night by a meteor that has fallen near his house. He investigates, and he is approached by a fly called Buzz Buzz. Who warns Ness that he is from a future universe dominated by an entity called Giygas. And that Ness must embark on a quest to defeat Giygas in the present. And thus stop his reign of terror. The story itself is simple enough.

But it’s the additional content to be found throughout the course of the game that adds to the story and makes it so excellent and full of substance. The game is rife with cultural jokes and references concerning the Western world. For example, a mode of transportation in the game is a yellow submarine. And one of the enemies in the game is a diamond dog. The settings were also heavily influenced by Western culture.

There’s also a lot of fourth-wall humor. An example of that is when one of the adult NPCs tells Ness that children like him should be at home playing Nintendo games. But aside from fourth-wall humor and numerous cultural references, there are also some very poetic themes to the game. Such as motherhood, which is rife throughout the entire franchise, and life and death. Giygas. I think I could probably write an entire essay on that. But I’d like to possibly save that for another week.

Originality – 9/10

This game was destined to stand out among others and age very well in this respect. Because EarthBound was developed at a time when stories in video games were virtually in their infancy. And nowhere near as much emphasis was put on it back then as there is now. But what truly differentiates this effort from most other turn-based RPGs out there is the fact that EarthBound is set in pre-apocalyptic modern times. Unlike most games of its kind, which are typically set in medieval, post-apocalyptic, or steampunk eras.

SAMSUNG DIGITAL CAMERA

In summation, Nintendo defied convention in many ways than one with EarthBound. With its unique approach to gameplay challenge, substance in the story, clever cultural references, and conceptual design. It’s certainly a misunderstood game for how poorly it sold, to begin with, and I could not recommend it enough. It’s also unique in that it is the first game on this blog to achieve this high score.

Score

51/60

8.5/10 (Great)

Duck Tales (Nintendo Entertainment System & Game Boy)

Developer(s) – Capcom

Publisher(s) – Capcom & Disney Interactive Studios

Designer – Yoshinori Takenaka

Producer – Takuro Fujiwara

PEGI – 7

Released back in 1989, and has many key personnel from the team behind Mega Man, including the franchise’s creator Keiji Inafune, taking charge of character design, Duck Tales went on to become a critical and commercial success on the back of the immensely popular Disney cartoon series. It’s regarded by many as one of the best. And indeed, one of the most challenging Game Boy games ever developed. And I found that whilst it is challenging, it was developed in such a way that it didn’t make it inaccessible to me, unlike Mega Man. And I ended up spending a lot of time on this game when I was a kid as a result.

Graphics – 8/10

Though the NES version had a massive assortment of colorful environments, despite the console’s limited color palette. What the original Game Boy lacked in color variety and technological advancement, developers had to make up for in conceptual design. Duck Tales is a classic example of this. Set in a variety of 5 different locations. Including the Himalayas, the Amazon River, and even the Moon. It, in turn, allowed for a wide assortment of enemy designs and different types of scenery to accompany each stage. The soundtrack is also arguably one of the best 8-BIT music arrangements in gaming. Tracks for the Amazon and the Moon stand out to a majority of players.

Gameplay – 8/10

Like Mega Man, Duck Tales is also a non-linear 2D platformer. Players are given the facility to complete the game in any order they desire. There are also unlockable areas within each of the five different levels. Giving players cause to revisit levels multiple times adds to the game’s longevity. It was also one of the first video games to include multiple endings, since there is a good ending. And a bad ending to unlock is dependent on how much money the player accumulates.

Controls – 10/10

Though the 2D platforming game formula had been well and truly mastered at this time, Duck Tales introduced one particular mechanic that made things pretty interesting. The pogo stick jump. Scrooge can use his cane as a pogo stick to attack enemies as well as traverse dangerous platforms in order to reach otherwise impassable or secret areas hidden throughout the game. It would have been particularly difficult for developers to introduce new ideas into a formula that had arguably been definitively perfected by Nintendo with the advent of Super Mario Bros. But Capcom managed to keep it fresh with their plethora of Mega Man games as well as Duck Tales.

Lifespan – 6/10

Clocking in at around an hour and a half, it lasts around the average of what a game was expected to last at that time. Less experienced players will spend more time on it. Since it can take a while to master the control mechanics to effectively get past each challenge the game throws at them. But there had been a select few games on the NES that lasted a great deal longer than this. And so the game wasn’t able to stand out in this respect at least.

Storyline – 5.5/10

The game also marginally stands out in terms of story. It simply revolves around the same concept as the cartoon series. Scrooge McDuck, along with his nephews Huey, Dewey, and Louie, and his friend Launchpad McQuack, are on an adventure to increase Scrooge’s fame ahead of his closest rival, Flintheart Glomgold. It’s only slightly more unique than most video game plots at that time since it doesn’t revolve around a white knight having to save the damsel in distress. But although most people didn’t play games for the story at this time, there is indeed a lack of it in this title.

Originality – 7/10

As I alluded to, it was extremely difficult to make a winning 2D side-scrolling game at a time when Nintendo had pioneered the industry standards with the original Super Mario Bros. But Capcom managed to accomplish that with Duck Tales by introducing additional control mechanics. As well as a non-linear progression, along with hidden secret areas. It was one of many licensed Disney games that Capcom went on to develop that sticks out in the minds of gamers everywhere. And helped to establish them as powerhouses within the industry.

Happii

In all, Duck Tales is indeed one of the best platformers on the Game Boy, as well as the NES. And a gaming experience that still very much holds up to this day. Though it conformed to many of the story limitations synonymous with gaming at the time, it excelled in the aspect that truly matters. The gameplay.

Score

44.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze

Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze (Wii U & Switch)

Developer(s) – Retro Studios, Monster Games & Nintendo SPD

Publisher – Nintendo

Director(s) – Ryan Harris & Vince Joly

Producer – Kensuke Tanabe

PEGI – 3

Following on from Nintendo’s previous success with the re-vamp of the Donkey Kong Country style of play in Donkey Kong Country Returns on the Wii, Tropical Freeze takes the same classic formula and adds one or two extras into the mix. And frankly, it makes for a fairly entertaining game in my opinion. Whilst it has some different elements from other video games, effective use is made of them. And it’s a joy to play.

Graphics – 8/10

It’s been some time since I’ve seen an FMV (Full Motion Video) cutscene in a licensed first-party Nintendo game. And the introductory FMV gives the game a pretty decent first impression. As does the first glimpse of the in-game visuals. The conceptual design of each of the six stages is particularly well done. Indeed, a sure sign that passion went into it is that concept art for the game can be unlocked. As an incentive for collecting every puzzle piece on a single level.

The decent mixture of different environments. Ranging from vast jungles to rainy and sunny beaches bring something entirely new to the table, whilst also featuring elements that hearken back to not only the original Donkey Kong Country. But also in games such as Diddy Kong Racing, as in the level Irate Eight, there is a giant octopus. This looks very much like the octopus that has to be raced in the game to advance.

Gameplay – 8/10

In terms of map layout, Tropical Freeze bears a striking resemblance to New Super Mario Bros. U., but in terms of gameplay, it’s just as challenging; if not more so. Not only does this game present a good few stern challenges in its boss fights. But also in the completion of side quests, as it can sometimes be difficult to find every hidden item in each level. Given how cleverly some of them are hidden. What I also like about the gameplay is the very decent amount of variety. Not only do classic elements return.

Such as the mountable rhino in the original Donkey Kong Country game, but there are also new gameplay elements to be experienced with the inclusion of the three supporting characters venturing alongside Donkey Kong. Incidentally, they also hearken back to the gameplay features of previous Nintendo games. Diddy Kong’s jetpack ability is very reminiscent of his role in Donkey Kong 64, as well as Peach’s role in Super Mario Bros. 2. Dixie Kong’s hovering ability is very similar to Yoshi’s hovering ability in the Yoshi’s Island series, and Cranky Kong’s spring ability is Identical to Scrooge McDuck’s ability in the old Duck Tales Game Boy game.

Controls – 9/10

Unfortunately, I did find the game’s controls to be somewhat unresponsive at times. I experienced trouble trying to roll along the ground to dodge enemy attacks. The game would sometimes interpret it as me trying to do the ground pound attack instead. But otherwise, there are no other outstanding issues with the controls.

Lifespan – 7/10

To get everything done in this time, it should take around 15 hours, which for a linear 2D side scroller is fair enough. Previous games in the genre tend to be much shorter than that. And it’s always good to see games like this being made to last as long as possible. It’s better to have an extraordinarily long linear 2D side scroller than a disappointingly short open-world 2D side scroller like Symphony of the Night. For how well that game played out, I was left wanting more.

Storyline – 7/10

From what I’ve seen of the seventh generation, Nintendo seems to be taking some of its longest-running franchises in new directions. Particularly in terms of story. I’ve seen it in A Link Between Worlds and Super Mario 3D World, and Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze is no exception. Donkey Kong’s birthday celebration is cut short after his home island is frozen over by a new batch of enemies called the Snomads. Donkey, along with his friends Diddy and Dixie and his grandfather Cranky, embarks on an adventure to retake their home island from the Snomads and their leader, Lord Frederick. It’s still pretty simplistic but different from the norm. It’s a positive change that presents a new story and new enemies. And an entirely new objective. Unlike previous entries, it doesn’t have Donkey Kong looking for his hoard of bananas and instead focuses on something entirely dissimilar.

Originality – 7/10

Although the overall premise of Tropical Freeze has been repeated many times over in video gaming, Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze has been given a fresh coat of paint with different gameplay elements and graphical concepts. This adds a bit of flair and makes it stand out from most others.

Happii

Overall, Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze is a game well worth playing at least once. There are some very stern challenges to be overcome. And a fair amount of incentive to be had for playing the game to its fullest. Although there may not be enough on the Wii U in terms of quantity, Nintendo is very much still able to deliver quality.

Score

46/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Contra III: The Alien Wars (Super Nintendo)

Contra III

Developer(s) – Konami & Factor 5

Publisher(s) – Konami

Designer – Nobuya Nakazato

Rating – N/A

Released for the Super Nintendo in 1992, and under multiple titles in different regions, such as Contra Spirits in Japan and Super Probotector: Alien Rebels in Europe, Contra III: The Alien Wars puts players in the shoes of two new heroes, as they repel a full-scale assault from the hostile aliens of the Red Falcon organization. Personally, I find it to be much more accessible than the previous two games. Even without the inclusion of the Konami Code, and by proxy, far better.

Graphics – 8/10

Of course, the greatest leap from the second to the third game was in its visuals. Taking advantage of the vastly superior technology of the SNES, the level of detail had been greatly improved. And even more intense and explosive special effects have been included, adding to the series’ already highly charged atmosphere. From a conceptual standpoint, the third game is also much more thrilling and scarier than the previous games. The opening cinematic, for example, was particularly imposing for a lot of players.

Gameplay – 8/10

The gameplay in Contra III: The Alien Wars is also as intense and fast-paced as ever. Offering perhaps not as much of a challenge as in the first two games. But still a legitimate one. I guess Konami thought to make it much more accessible in order to appeal to as many gamers as possible. And in my opinion, this was the right choice to make. They would also go on to do the same with Castlevania when it came time to port Super Castlevania IV to the Super Nintendo. And continued to do so as the series progressed.

Controls – 10/10

Games in the Contra series before this had pretty decent controls compared to many other NES games, but for the third instalment, they have been improved dramatically. With more fluency and smoothness, it’s a lot easier to get to grips with than in previous games, and the general movement feels nowhere near as stiff. Taking advantage of this key feature is actually integral to mastering the game, especially when it comes to the harder playthrough and certain stages.

Lifespan – 6/10

Clocking up at roughly 4 hours after both playthroughs of the game, depending on skill level, lasts about as long as a standard platformer. This is acceptable enough since this was the average lifespan of a game at that time. It would be a good few years before the standard length of a game would be increased with the advent of mainstream RPGs back in 199. But games like this still provided a challenge stern enough to last even longer for players as they improve their skills.

Storyline – 7/10

The story simply involves two heroes as they join the fight for humanity against the Red Falcon organization. As the alien horde invades the Earth overnight, it is on the brink of apocalypse. It slightly deviates from the typical gaming scenario, whereby the white knight resolves to save the damsel in distress. But it’s still quite basic, as that was how games were at the time. Extremely light on the story. But this game does make a little more of an effort than many other games. Incorporating a cinematic cutscene in the beginning. And bringing out a great deal of raw emotion in players to add to the gameplay.

Originality – 6/10

2D side scrollers at the time were the standard play style synonymous with most games at the time. But it is unique from my perspective since it was the first time I’d witnessed a game that had a sense of maturity about it. Making me think that they can be more than just about calm environments, fun levels, and enemies. For most gamers, it was Doom that had that same impact, but I didn’t play Doom throughout my childhood, instead of going to play it for the first time many years later.

Happii

In summation, Contra III: The Alien Wars is most definitely my favorite out of the original three games and remains one of my favorite Super Nintendo games of all time. It provided something very different from what I was used to during the fourth generation of gaming, and it is still an experience holding up to this day.

Score

45/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Codename S.T.E.A.M (Nintendo 3DS)

has CodeName STEAM

Developer(s) – Intelligent Systems

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Paul Patraschu

Producer(s) – Toru Narihiro & Hitoshi Yamagami

PEGI – 12

Marking the directorial debut of Paul Patraschu with the assistance of Nintendo veteran Hitoshi Yamagami, Codename S.T.E.A.M was released on the 3DS in early 2015. It was met with mixed to positive reviews. And only managed to sell around 1800 copies in its first week. From what I understand, Nintendo was looking to combine tropes of both Japanese and Western gaming with this title. But in my opinion, it fell way too short of its intended degree of success.

Graphics – 7/10

One aspect of the game that I can’t criticize too much is the visuals. Inspired by steampunk culture, as well as the works of cosmic horror writer HP Lovecraft, the game also game takes advantage of cel-shading to present players with a cartoony, yet quite gritty take on a futuristic Earth. Taking place in a variety of different cities and world landmarks, such as London, England, Monument Valley, and even the land of Oz at one point.

Gameplay – 4/10

Unfortunately, the concept of the gameplay is nowhere near as creative. Mixing third-person shooting mechanics with turn-based RPG mechanics similar to the original Fallout is, without a doubt, one of the worst ideas I’ve ever seen come out directly from Nintendo. If not, the worst. What was designed to be innovative and the evolution of the two genres can become very frustrating very quickly. Players will struggle to find any legitimate fun in the game. To me, it would have made more sense to have simply focused more on the third-person shooting aspect (as indeed I thought Nintendo had done when I first laid eyes on it). And not tried to add a half-hearted RPG element to it.

Controls – 4/10

The game’s control scheme is frustrating in the same way as the first Fallout game was frustrating. Players and enemies have to take turns to even move. This makes playing the game feel more like a chore than a pleasure. But it also adds an unwarranted element of impracticality in both the sense of gameplay and story. It supposedly has a narrative set in the future. But it’s hard to believe that technology would evolve to the point that people need a huge can of fuel on their backs in order to move.

Lifespan – 6.5/10

For those who are willing to persevere, and who are more lukewarm to this kind of gameplay than me, there is a fairly long experience to be had in Codename S.T.E.A.M at least. Lasting an average of around 18 to 20 hours. There is also the multiplayer mode on top of that. This adds even more to the game’s longevity. I think most gamers will probably decide they’ve had enough of it after about 5 minutes. But the campaign still lasts a great deal longer than the average game in the genre.

Storyline – 6/10

The game’s story follows a steampunk soldier named Henry Fleming, who, with the help of various fellow soldiers, as well as a multitude of characters from across the Oz universe, as well as HP Lovecraft’s Cthulhu mythos, embarks on a mission to save the world, as well as several different major world monarchs such as Queen Elizabeth II, from an army of aliens. Aside from the story’s concept simply coming off as a mishmash of different ideas rolled into one largely nonsensical package, the game’s voice acting is also extremely lacklustre. Even with the likes of Adam Baldwin, Will Wheaton, and Paul Eiding lending their voice talents to the game, the entire experience comes off as being even more half-hearted than it already is in most other aspects.

Originality – 6/10

Although Nintendo dared to try something different with a genre that, in all fairness, lacked great innovation, to me, it simply came across as unique, but for all the wrong reasons. On the whole, this game actually made me quite fearful. At one point, Nintendo was considered to be the great innovator of the industry. Offering gamers experiences unlike any other. Yet as the years have progressed, they have, to a certain extent, not only chosen to rely on the same formula with each console to be released but sometimes fail to perpetuate innovation. This game is one of their most recent examples of this.

Angrii

Overall, Codename S.T.E.A.M is an extremely lackluster gaming experience. And in my opinion, a contender for the worst 3DS game to have ever been released. What was designed to be a unique gaming experience like no other simply comes off as a terrible compilation of random ideas. Which perhaps may work in terms of visual presentation, but not much else.

Score

33.5/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

ClayFighter (Super Nintendo)

ClayFighter

Developer(s) – Visual Concepts, Ringler Studios & Danger Productions

Publisher(s) – Interplay Entertainment

PEGI – 12

ClayFighter was a game released during the midpoint of the fourth generation of gaming, developed to contend with the likes of Mortal Kombat and Street Fighter, minus the excessive violence. After playing this game for even two minutes, it makes me glad that I didn’t grow up playing it. I think if I did, there would have been an inevitable prerequisite based on nostalgia. Compelling me to have liked it to a certain extent. But in my opinion, it is one of the worst fighting games I’ve ever played; if not, the worst.

Graphics – 1/10

From a conceptual standpoint, especially compared with many other fighting games at the time, this game is an absolute embarrassment. It supposedly features visuals inspired by claymation, but it isn’t made noticeable to any great extent. To me, it is just a mishmash of stupid ideas after stupid ideas. Aside from pointless characters such as Bad Mr. Frosty the snowman and Ichybod Clay the Pumpkin (I wish I was making this up), there are also even more generic-looking characters, such as Taffy and The Blob, which are basically just indiscriminate blobs of clay. For a development studio called Visual Concepts, this game certainly doesn’t live up to that name.

Gameplay – 1/10

The game’s play is also substandard, as well as outright boring. The idea was to develop a game to compete with the likes of Street Fighter and Mortal Kombat, but if the developers weren’t even willing to add any more gameplay features than what was included, they never stood a chance. ClayFighter has no combos, no fatalities, no brutalities, and not even one secret character to unlock as far as I’m aware. Like many developers before them, they put their efforts into all the wrong places and came up with a complete mess of a game.

Controls – 5/10

If the game’s play wasn’t bad enough, there are even issues with the controls, feeling stiff as well as redundant. For a game that had significantly fewer features than those of most of its competitors at the time, I suspected that there shouldn’t have been any kind of problems with the controls, but alas, these issues cropped up.

Originality – 0/10

Though the characters in this game may differentiate from many other characters in many other fighting games, they differ from them for all the wrong reasons. They stand out for being particularly uninteresting and, for the most part, completely nonsensical. In particular, N-boss is made up of a series of spheres, which make faces based on his mood.

Furiious

To summarize, I would rather be locked in a room with Adrian Chiles than have to ever play ClayFighter again. It would be a close call, but I think Chiles would provide only fractionally more entertainment.

Score

7/40

1.5/10 (Painful)

Chip N’ Dale: Rescue Rangers (NES)

Chip N Dale

Developer(s) – Capcom

Publisher(s) – Capcom

Designer – Masayoshi Kurokawa

Producer – Tokoru Fujiwara

Rating – N/A

As the first game I ever played, Chip N’ Dale: Rescue Rangers for the NES has always held a special place in my own video gaming repertoire. And one that I think still very much holds up to this day. Back when 2D side-scrolling was the standard in the medium and on the console, Chip N’ Dale, to me, stands out as one of the better efforts, among many other unlicensed games in the genre, such as Robodemons and Menace Beach. And even among some of Capcom’s more popular efforts, like Mega Man.

Graphics – 8/10

There is a lot of extremely effective use of colour in Chip N’ Dale, just like Mega Man before it. Capcom was the first developer to bring the new standard of adding black outlines to both character sprites and scenery. Thus making it easier for certain shades of the same colour. Such as blue, to blend in better with one another. And also to make the sky texture stand out better than everything else. It’s evident that they also used the same technique in Chip N’ Dale. And it worked flawlessly. The soundtrack to this game is also extremely impressive and stands out greatly among most 8-bit NES soundtracks.

Gameplay – 7/10

What I think makes Chip N’ Dale better than the original Mega Man is that it’s a lot more accessible. The difficulty curve hasn’t been set anywhere near as high as the Blue Bomber’s first game, but regardless, it remains a fair challenge. It’s also interesting to see what influence Capcom took from Nintendo, and the second instalment of Super Mario Bros, with players having to pick up objects and throw them at enemies in order to advance, not to mention the mechanics of being able to select multiple playable characters.

Controls – 10/10

It was even by this early point in gaming that the 2D side-scrolling formula had been more or less perfected, especially since Capcom had had a fair amount of prior experience with the likes of Mega Man, and then would have in the future with Strider, it was natural to assume there would be no problems with the Chip N’ Dale’s controls scheme, and so there is none.

Lifespan – 7/10

At the time, it wasn’t considered below standard for a game to last as little time as less than an hour, and since this game lasts about as long as the average Mario or Sonic game, I don’t think it should lose too many marks for not lasting any longer than it did. There were exceptionally longer games around at the time, such as the original Final Fantasy or the first Metroid game, but depending on player skill, they can be made to last a fair amount of time for what technological advancement at that time would allow.

Storyline – 5/10

The story, however, was particularly generic and typical of the time, really. It follows Chip and Dale on a mission to save their damsel in distress, Gadget, from their archenemy, Fat Cat. Throughout the NES era, that was the usual structure of most video game narratives, and there’s really nothing present in this game to differentiate it from other narratives of the time.

Originality – 6/10

Though this game clearly has its influences, everything from Mega Man to Super Mario Bros 2 to even Castlevania to a certain extent, this was my own personal introduction to video gaming and would lead me to experience all the great video games that I have experienced to date. A lot of the boss fights still stand out to me, as does the soundtrack, and the game itself is certainly a lot more enjoyable to play than many other games on the NES, licensed by Nintendo or otherwise.

Happii

To summarize, Chip N’ Dale: Rescue Rangers still speaks to me as an excellent catalyst whereby to have been introduced to the medium at all. And one of the best games on the NES. It’s a must-have for any retro gamer and still stands out in terms of visuals for the time, as well as substance in gameplay.

Score

43/60

7/10 (Fair)

Castlevania III: Dracula's Curse

Castlevania III: Dracula’s Curse (Nintendo Entertainment System)

Developer(s) – Konami

Publisher(s) – Konami & Palcom

Director – Hitoshi Akamatsu

Designer – I. Urata

Rating – N/A

Essentially a carbon copy of the first game, Castlevania III: Dracula’s Curse took the majority of the principal mechanics of the game. And gave it multiple passages, taking away much of the linearity of the first, as well as having a fresh coat of paint in terms of visuals. Though it is indeed fractionally more enjoyable than the first game, in my opinion, it still had its flaws.

Graphics – 8/10

Though the limited colour palette of the NES is still relatively evident in this game, the visuals are a dramatic improvement on the first game. Featuring more detailed scenery and characters. Though many elements of the first have been recycled for use in the third, it still made for one of the better-looking games on the system, in my opinion. The soundtrack is also as epic as ever. Something that the series would come to be known for as the years passed.

Gameplay – 6/10

The basic gameplay premise of the original Castlevania title was brought back for use in the third game, with players having to use their wicked cunning to overcome any obstacles or enemies thrown at them. Aside from giving players more to play for, certain paths are also not as unforgiving as the first game. And it’s ultimately a lot more accessible because of it. The series would go on to accommodate a greater range of players as it progressed. Still, to me, this was the ideal turning point. Since it would have also geared potential fans up for the different directions the series would be taken throughout future generations of video gaming.

Controls – 9/10

A lot of the same issues that cropped up in the first game also, unfortunately, cropped up in the third, too, with a good few glitches that cause players to fall beneath disappearing platforms. However, the issue isn’t as big a problem in the first game. And there aren’t any others to address, thankfully.

Lifespan – 7/10

Designed to be played multiple times, the third game lasted much longer than what was the average lifespan of a video game for the time. Totalling about three and a half hours for experienced players. But taking into account the time it can take to master each facet of the game, whilst not unforgiving, it still provides a fairly stern challenge, and it can be made to last even longer.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of Castlevania III: Dracula’s Curse was made to be an origin narrative of the entire series. Set in 1476, it features Trevor Belmont, as opposed to the more familiar Simon Belmont. It was at that time that the first struggle between Dracula and the Belmont clan. This time, Trevor can also be accompanied by one of two different characters, depending on what path the player takes: either a sorceress called Sypha Belnades or Dracula’s son, Alucard. It added a little bit more than the average story in gaming. But it didn’t break any new ground in this respect at the time. Since games of the day were pretty light on the story in any case. It didn’t feature many of the story elements found in video games today.

Originality – 8/10

Although the game didn’t introduce many new story elements to the gaming industry, and largely stuck to the same principles as most games on the NES, it still perpetuated the same ideas as Simon’s Quest did. Games didn’t have to follow a linear path. They could go in several different directions and play out differently from one another. That ideal may have been toned down somewhat with this game. But it still made for an experience, unlike many other 2D side scrollers on the NES.

Happii

Castlevania III: Dracula’s Curse is my favorite out of the original three Castlevania games. Though things would get even better for the series as it progresses in my opinion, it was still a very positive departure from the shaky start that it had gotten to.

Score

44/60

7/10 (Fair)

Castlevania II: Simon’s Quest (Nintendo Entertainment System)

hgusCastlevania II

Developer(s) – Konami

Publisher(s) – Konami

Director – Hitoshi Akamatsu

Programmer(s) – Nobuhiro Matsuoka & Yasuo Kuwahara

Rating – N/A

Drawing comparisons with the original Metroid game, released a year before, Castlevania II: Simon’s Quest made a departure from the linear style of play of the original game. It included an open-world environment back in a time when the concept was in its infancy. And before it eventually became an industry standard. Whilst I didn’t find it anywhere near as annoying as the first game, the second isn’t without its flaws.

Graphics – 8.5/10

Graphically, the second game is a massive improvement on the first. Making use of even more colours and variety in character sprites on a console with an extremely limited colour palette. It was also one of the first games developed to have a day-to-night transition. This has since become yet another industry standard in video gaming. Many have expressed opinions about the sprite for Simon Belmont, being less detailed than in the first game. But I would disagree. New enemies are also added to the sequel on top of classic ones from the previous games, which were inspired by horror movie culture. But unlike the first game, the second has a bit more originality about it in terms of visual style and variety.

Gameplay – 6/10

Many readers may have expected me to think infinitely more highly of the second game than the first, since the difficulty had been dialed down considerably, thus making it a lot more accessible to a lot more players, and that, of course, it is non-linear. But as I pointed out, Castlevania II: Simon’s Quest is not flawless. The game was developed at a time when open-world games were virtually unheard of. Thus, a lot of the industry standards for open-world games had not been either met or established.

Standards such as the inclusion of an in-game map or quest markers. Not having any of these consequently makes Simon’s Quest a very awkward game to play without a strategy guide. Not a lot can be figured out by the player on their own. And a strategy guide is more or less mandatory if players desire to finish the main story. Let alone complete it to 100%.

Controls – 9/10

Like the first game, the controls can be a little bit slow to respond at some of the most crucial times. For me, it marred the quality of the first game to some extent. And the developers made the same mistake again with the second game. And would also do with the third in the main NES trilogy, too. Otherwise, however, there are no other problems with the game’s control scheme. And the majority of what it boils down to is the player’s own individual skill.

Lifespan – 8/10

Although the game can only be made to last for a few hours, the fact of the matter remains that this was exceptionally long for an NES game, since a single cartridge could hold only a fraction of the memory that a modern game can. After all, it was exceptionally long games back in the day. This would eventually inspire the creation of even exceptionally longer games throughout the course of the industry’s history. And I think if that standard hadn’t been set, video games would not be a fraction of what they have evolved into over the last 25 years or so.

Storyline – 5/10

There is a bit more depth to the second story than there was to the first. The second takes place some years after the first game, with the main protagonist, Simon Belmont, out to break a curse that had been placed upon him by Dracula following their previous confrontation. To break the curse, Simon must collect the 5 pieces of Dracula’s spirit and take them to the ruins of his castle to seal them, defeating him and ridding himself of the curse.

There’s a little bit more of a twist to the story to help it effectively deviate from most other story-driven games of the time. But the problem that hinders it almost as much as the first game was the poor attention to detail during the localization process. A lot of the dialogue in the game was very poorly translated. And many clues that were integral to what had to be done throughout the game ended up being misunderstood. And it took a lot of seriousness away from the overall game.

Originality – 7/10

Although 2D side-scrolling was standard at the time, Castlevania II: Simon’s Quest also ended up pioneering a lot of future video game standards that are still adhered to today. And any game that could do that with the limited technology available at the time deserves an honourable mention. It was refreshing as well as important for the industry that so many different franchises would branch off into all kinds of different directions in terms of gameplay during the NES days. And in a lot of ways, this game was at the forefront of that.

Happii

In summation, Simon’s Quest, whilst not without its annoyances, is certainly an improvement on the previous game in many ways. As well as being a very historically important title. Without games like Simon’s Quest and Metroid, there would be no open-world games. And the transition from 2D to 3D would have been a lot more awkward if standards like what this game set hadn’t been set beforehand.

Score

43.5/60

7/10 (Fair)