Tag Archives: PS2

Malice (PlayStation 2 & Xbox)

Malice

Developer(s) – Argonaut Games

Publisher(s) – Mud Duck Productions & Evolved Games

Director – Phil Morris

Producer – Andy Pang

PEGI – 7

Malice was a game released back in 2004, loosely based on Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland. But truth be told, the finished product is nowhere near as imaginative or culturally impactful. In fact, the most interesting thing about this game is its development history. At first, it was intended for release on the original PlayStation back in the late 90s. However, due to the first of many production management mishaps, the idea was subsequently scrapped in favor of releasing the game as an Xbox launch title in late 2001.

In 2002, having failed to get the game out in time, it was announced that members of the band No Doubt were to lend their voice talents to the project. With lead singer Gwen Stefani providing the role of the game’s titular main character, Malice. The band said in an interview that they were particularly excited to see their music reach a wider audience in the video gaming industry. By early 2003, Argonaut had yet to get the game out to retailers. The company faced hardships, including financial problems (as they’d spent millions of dollars developing the game) and further corporate meddling. And even the untimely death of one of their conceptual artists, Alecsandar Ilic, who tragically passed away at the age of 30. It was announced on May 30th that the game had been canceled.

Afterward, a different company got publishing rights, and the project was subsequently revived. And the game was eventually released in 2004 to a very mediocre reception from both gamers and reviewers alike. And after having played it, it’s no wonder why.

Graphics – 4/10

Everything about this game is seemingly rushed, and the visuals are no exception. From the get-go, I kept thinking to myself that it looks like it could indeed easily run on the original PlayStation. As the game looked a generation old for the time. On top of that, I think the game just looks inherently generic. In that, the settings and the character, enemy, and boss designs are all pretty unimaginative and annoying in some cases. Like the crows in suits who let out irritating noises as they attack or take damage. Another issue I have with it is that it baffles me how it only runs at 30 frames per second when it just looks like it ought to run at 60, and how bad it looks.

Gameplay – 3/10

Even though it was released on the original PlayStation, the game’s play is too simplistic, insubstantial, and boring to have held up. A 3D platforming game, it has merely one side quest, unrefined combat, no replay value whatsoever, and terrible, drawn-out boss fights. I was fighting the second boss for about ten minutes with very little difficulty, just wanting above all else for it to be over.

Controls – 6/10

The main gripes I have about this game’s control scheme involve jumping mechanics. If jumping mechanics aren’t done right in a platforming game, players will know instantly that there’ll be problems throughout. One of the most stable elements of platforming games is the ability to jump from platform to platform. Another problem I had with this game was the inability to move my character while trying to attack. Every time the player presses the attack button, Malice stands completely still and swings her weapon, which eliminates any fluency in combat and unnecessarily complicates things.

Lifespan – 5/10

For even a late 90s platforming game to last less than 10 hours is absolutely unacceptable. If Argonaut Games truly wanted this game to last longer or do well, they needed an extra push in every department before launch. But unfortunately, they couldn’t do that. Presumably having blown a lot of their budget on hiring No Doubt to provide voice acting for the game. Which didn’t happen anyway.

Storyline – 3/10

The game’s story follows the quest of a red-haired goddess called Malice. Who is aiming to save the world by restoring power to a machine called the orrery and defeating an evil demon called Dog God? It’s laughable at best. No character can be taken seriously because the voice acting that was eventually used in the end is farcical. In addition, the story is extremely flawed and hardly makes any sense.

Originality – 0/10

There is absolutely nothing in this game that I haven’t seen before, and would never want to see again. I never want to see a combat system so unrefined, an in-game world that looks like someone threw up in the console. And a story that no one in their right mind would care to follow.

Furiious

My biggest piece of advice to anyone who picks this game up in a shop and reads the part of the synopsis on the box that says “fantastic graphics, fluid gameplay, compelling storyline, and funny characterization” is to not pay attention to it because of its false advertisement. Malice has none of those things.

Score

21/60

3.5/10 (Very Poor)

The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (PlayStation 2, Xbox, PC & Gameboy Advance)

The Lord of the Rings The Fellowship of the Ring

Developer(s) – WXP Games & Surreal Software

Publisher(s) – Black Label Game, Universal Interactive & Sierra Entertainment

Designer – Todd Clineschmidt

Producer – Nick Radovich

PEGI – 12

Released around the same time as the Peter Jackson film trilogy, and when the franchise was the subject of a great many licensed games. WXP Games’ Lord of the Rings interpretation was a 3D platforming adventure title. With an emphasis on side quests and a degree of exploration. Surpassing my expectations, this is, in fact, a fairly enjoyable title. And it’s a pity that the planned sequels were canceled, since I believe there were many ways in which the developers could have expanded upon what they had created with this game.

Graphics – 7/10

Though the majority of the conceptual design of this game is based on the film trilogy, there are certain elements that make it stand out from it. Such as the re-imagining of locations such as Barad-Dur and the Mines of Moria. The location that fails to stand out the most is the Shire. Since it is more or less identical to that of the films. But there are also other locations included, such as the forest in which Tom Bombadil dwells. Unlike the films, he also makes an appearance.

Gameplay – 7/10

As I pointed out, the game revolves around adventure. Elements of exploration, combat, and the occasional puzzle-solving. Players control Frodo, Gandalf, and Aragorn, and each character has their own set of abilities and purposes throughout the game. Giving it a fair amount of variety. For example, there are many side quests to be completed throughout the first part of the game. Whereas Aragorn and Gandalf’s roles are much more combat-oriented. The gripe I have with it is that the side quests virtually stop after the first part of the game. And I think the developers could easily have added a few more beyond that.

Controls – 10/10

Not only are there no problems with the game’s control scheme. But with the facility to control three different characters, the game is also kept interesting with players having to adapt to multiple styles of play. Which are all easy enough to get to grips with, and fast.

Lifespan – 6/10

For a game based on such a long book as even the first chapter of the trilogy, the game lasts a fair amount of time. At around 6 to 7 hours. But as I alluded to before, I can’t help but think that if the developers had added a few more side quests to both Aragorn’s and Gandalf’s sequences in the game, then it could easily have been made to last much longer.

Storyline – 9/10

Having read the books and watched the films, I was captivated by the story of The Lord of the Rings long before I started playing this game. For those who may not know the basic plot, Frodo Baggins is a hobbit living in the Shire. When he inherits a magic ring from his uncle Bilbo. His friend Gandalf arrives to inform him that the ring is, in fact, that of the dark lord Sauron. Who attempted to rule Middle-Earth with the power of the ring thousands of years prior to the start of the story.

Frodo resolves to destroy it by journeying to Mt Doom, the only place where it can be destroyed. Along with a company of friends and warriors from across the land. The manner in which it is portrayed in the game is very much akin to that of the book, but the only downside to it is the character of Frodo. Unlike Elijah Wood or even Christopher Guard’s portrayal of him, he seems far too jolly for the most part to me. And doesn’t seem to fully realize the gravity of the situation.

Originality – 6/10

At this time, gamers were rightfully in the mindset that licensed games were generally of much lesser quality than unlicensed games were. For the most part, this was true. And it wasn’t until Batman: Arkham Asylum in 2009 that this trend was broken. But this game wasn’t too bad compared to most others, in my opinion. Even though it follows many different trends that had already been established by other developers beforehand, every element of gameplay comes together well. And plays out adequately, despite the fact that there was indeed room for improvement.

Happii

In summation, The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring was a fairly commendable attempt to bring the license to the gaming industry and excelled above many other licensed games at that time. I think the sequels would most probably have been better if they had ever seen the light of day, but this would have been a sufficient starting point.

Score

45/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Ico (PlayStation 2 & PlayStation 3)

Ico

Developer(s) – Team Ico (SCE Japan Studios)

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Fumito Ueda

PEGI – 12

Inspired by Eric Chahi’s Another World, Fumito Ueda developed Ico, which was released in 2001. It has since become a cult classic among gamers. Personally preferring Ueda’s next game after this, Shadow of the Colossus, I found this game enjoyable to a certain extent. But I don’t think I would go so far as to call it a cult classic.

Graphics – 7/10

Whilst the setting of the game is fairly well-designed. And there are a few standout individual areas, such as the windmill and the graveyard, but the game’s visuals seemed a little repetitive to me after a while. But what I do have to respect this game for in terms of graphical presentation is the fact that it has gone on to inspire not only other game developers, such as Phil Fish and Vander Caballero, but also film directors. Such as Pan’s Labyrinth director, Guillermo del Toro. This game has also gone on to inspire the creation of such games as Twilight Princess, one of my personal favorites. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time, which I personally respect the game for.

Gameplay – 6/10

An aspect I don’t entirely respect this game for is its style of play. On the one hand, the game can get very samey. As the concept of what to do is to simply solve a puzzle, then kill some shadowy creatures, and rinse and repeat. Combat to me isn’t particularly fluent, and annoyingly, the hit detection isn’t great either. I found myself growing bored about two hours in. But on the other hand, the puzzles are very well thought out, which provides the game with a fair amount of challenge. So Ico isn’t completely unplayable. Its linearity for how big the setting of the game is doesn’t do it any favors either, the way I see it.

Controls – 9/10

As I pointed out before, the hit detection can be irritatingly inaccurate at times. And camera angles can seem somewhat awkward whilst climbing or traversing along buildings. But apart from that, there are thankfully no other problems to address.

Lifespan – 3/10

At best, Ico can only be made to last roughly 4 to 5 hours, which is unacceptable. As many side quests could easily have been added to make it last considerably longer. Despite its level of linearity. Its lack of additional content seems extremely unsavory. Especially as this was made in a time when 3D platforming had just about been perfected. And there were more games released at the time with much more substance to them. So by that logic, Ueda was always going to have a hard time competing with the likes of Jak & Daxter. As in Ico, there simply isn’t enough to do.

Storyline – 9/10

Although Ico could not have been able to compete with other games in terms of gameplay, it excels above many in terms of story. The tale involves a small boy called Ico, who has been imprisoned in a castle and manages to set himself free from the coffin he is put in. Finding a captive girl called Yorda, he releases her and resolves to help her escape from the castle along with him. Like Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, certain aspects of the story are told through gameplay. In that the two rely on each other to do certain things for both of them to progress. Conveying the themes of trust and cooperation, it all makes for an inspiring and emotional tale, with a few plot twists thrown in for good measure.

Originality – 8/10

Though I have my reservations about this game, the fact of the matter is that a game like Ico, which has gone on to inspire so many people across the last decade, has to be considered unique. However, the lack of imagination on the developer’s part stems from its lack of content in gameplay, in my opinion.

Happii

In summation, Ico can make for 4 or 5 hours of moderate entertainment and the telling of a well-written and well-conceived story, but to me, it is really missing a lot of gameplay variety and side quests, and again, it seems like a little bit too much of a fleeting experience.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Haven: Call of the King (PlayStation 2)

Haven

Haven

Developer(s) – Traveller’s Tales

Publisher(s) – Midway

Director – Jon Burton

Producer – Arthur Parsons

ELSPA – 3

Throughout the era of the PlayStation 2, GameCube, and Xbox, Midway was facing hard times in the industry. And they knew something needed to be done to make a lasting impression on gamers at the time. They decided to collaborate with Traveller’s Tales and release an almost all-or-nothing salvo on the PlayStation 2 (initially also planned for release on the GameCube and Xbox until the idea was ultimately dismissed). As one of their last hurrahs before they would eventually be absorbed back into their parent company, Warner Bros., though Haven: Call of the King was met with positive reviews by critics, it was also met with poor sales figures. The way I see it, I can understand one of these outcomes, but not the other. And my final opinion may surprise readers.

Graphics – 6.5/10

Even though the developers did try to create a vast world unlike any ever seen in a video game before, I found that influence certainly played a huge part in this title from the very beginning. The most obvious influence is behind the design of Vetch’s tower, which resembles a flaming cat’s eye. It should sound familiar, as The Lord of the Rings film trilogy was riding high at the time. And the main antagonist of the film, Sauron, took the form of a huge cat’s eye hovering over his tower of Barad-Dur. Even after the opening sequence, where this is first seen, I found that most of the rest of the game also seemed fairly generic to me.

Gameplay – 6/10

The best thing about the game’s play is the amount of variety that is on offer to players. Players can explore to a small extent, take part in races, rail-shooting sequences, and some fairly well-executed 3D platforming. But I can’t help but feel that the back of the game’s box presents a false advertisement. As the developers boasted “massive planets to visit and explore”. This suggested to me that there was much more of an open world than there actually is within the game. By that token, it’s my opinion that the game has far too much linearity. For one, of either the magnitude of the ambition that the developers clearly had regarding it.

Controls – 9/10

A positive that I can point out about this game is that, whilst the movement can seem a little bit stiff at times, there are no other issues with its control schemes for me to report. Once more, for a game with so many different ways of playing, this is quite impressive. It can sometimes prove pretty difficult for developers to keep track of games like that. I think if there had been any outstanding issues with the control scheme, then it may have turned players away from the many excellent 3D platformers that were being released on the PlayStation 2 at the time.

Lifespan – 7/10

With players being able to make Haven last for an average of 15-20 hours, I’d say the game has a fairly good lifespan for a 3D platformer. However, I can’t help but feel that the game could have easily been made to last considerably longer. If the developers had taken the time to fully realize what potential this game could have had if they had fully delivered on the exploration factor. It’s because of this that the game left me wanting considerably more than what I was given.

Storyline – 4/10

For me, the most disappointing thing about this game was its narrative. The story follows a slave called Haven. He embarks on a quest to save his people, and the rest of the universe, from its tyrannical ruler, Vetch. Attempting to provide an interesting take on the classic tale of the pawn reaching the end of the board, it was originally planned to be the first part of a video game trilogy. However, thanks to poor sales figures and most gamers taking merely a niche interest in the title, this never happened. And although I won’t give away what happens, what players were left with was a particularly unsatisfying and depressing cliffhanger ending.

It also made me regret that I had taken any time at all to invest in the characters. Such as Haven, Athellion, or even Vetch. As well as the voice acting being somewhat below par, there are also a lot of plot threads. Such as Haven accidentally striking his boss’s foot with a pickaxe, mistaking it for a rock. And remarking that anyone could have made the same mistake. As if people can’t tell the difference between a rock and someone’s foot. It was also very convenient that one of Vetch’s guards neglected to lock Haven’s cell later on in the game. Allowing him to escape from his prison.

Originality – 6/10

Despite the amount of ambition that both Midway and Traveller’s Tales had for Haven, it ultimately seemed to simply be a collection of many different video gaming tropes and ideas, as opposed to being a fully cohesive concept. I always find myself asking what the point of doing this is. Why develop a game when developers are going to neglect to add any flair to it and make it their own? Although it is somewhat interesting to be able to spot what kind of things influence a video game, it’s much more interesting to see what kind of new things developers can bring to the table. And I think the developers held back in that respect.

Niiutral

Overall, whilst Haven is by no means the worst 3D platformer to have been released on a PlayStation console, the fact that it remains overshadowed by many other great games of the time is justified in my opinion. Everything about it has been influenced by a collection of different games and media in one way or another. And while there is a small level of excitement to be had while playing, there isn’t enough for me to mention it in the same breath as some of either Midway or Traveller’s Tales’ better efforts.

Score

35.5/60

6/10 (Average)

Half-Life 2 (PC, Xbox, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 & Shield Portable)

Half-Life 2

Developer(s) – Valve

Publisher(s) – Valve & Sierra Entertainment

PEGI – 16

Following up on the immensely successful first-person shooter Half-Life, Half-Life 2 takes Gordon Freeman out of the lab and into the game’s outside world. Filled with more of the same alien-fighting and puzzle-solving action, the way I see it, it is a very worthy sequel to one of the greatest video games of all time, in my own personal opinion.

Graphics – 8/10

The most visible improvements made to the last time to me are in the sequel’s increased amount of variety in enemy design, as well as graphical quality. Though the scenery may not be quite as varied as in the first game, that taking place in an alien dimension as well as a vast research facility (indeed, both games could be accused of having generic elements), the atmosphere is just as terrifically horrifying and imposing as its predecessor.

Gameplay – 9/10

Like the first game before it, Half-Life 2 is an exceptional first-person shooter, with some new physics added in for good measure. These new gameplay mechanics were revolutionary at the time and would go on to inspire the creation of Valve’s own Portal, among many other future games. The combat sequences are just as challenging and enthralling as in the first game, and in lieu of Valve tradition, there is the element of outside-the-box puzzle-solving that the company has gained a reputation for, spanning almost twenty years.

Controls – 9.5/10

The only minor problem I had with the game’s control scheme was during the boat-riding sequences, whereby Gordon has to ride a speedboat to progress; it can be a little bit unnecessarily tricky to control at times, and crashes can become frequent for those unprepared. But otherwise, it plays out just like any exceptional first-person shooter should play out.

Lifespan – 6/10

Lasting about 12 to 15 hours, it only lasts about half the time as the original game, which, to me, was somewhat disappointing. It also seemed unusual to me, since the game was just as satisfying to play as the original, and they could have easily drawn it out at least a little longer than how long it ended up lasting. I would recommend anyone looking to play this game to get The Orange Box available for both Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3, since not only does it contain the original game, but also its sequels, Half-Life 2 Episode One and Half-Life 2 Episode 2 (as well as both Team Fortress 2 and the original Portal game).

Storyline – 8/10

Taking place roughly 20 years after the events of the previous game, Half-Life 2 follows the series’ main protagonist, Dr. Gordon Freeman, now under the employment of the mysterious G-Man. Gordon is brought out of stasis by the G-Man and led to a dystopian metropolis called City 17. Freeman finds himself helping a resistance faction known as the Black Mesa East to stop a multidimensional empire known as the Combine from harvesting Earth’s resources, including humanity itself. Just like the first game, there are plenty of twists and turns before the end, as well as the omnipresence of the G-man himself, spoon-feeding players just enough information to make them want to find out more about who he is, what he is, and to possibly be able to better see the bigger picture. One major improvement to the game’s story, I found, was the more effective use of voice acting throughout.

Originality – 8/10

Though for the most part, this game can just seem to be a pretty standard first-person shooter, especially to newcomers to the series, the new physics introduced to the game would go on to inspire many different developers to create a plethora of different games, not only within the confines of the genre but across other genres too. To me, it had a very positive impact on creativity within the gaming industry, especially as the transition from the sixth generation to the seventh generation of gaming was just around the corner at the time.

Happii

To conclude, Half-Life 2 is most definitely a classic game and one that I would thoroughly recommend to any fan of first-person shooters. Though I personally greatly prefer the original game, Half-Life 2 is an excellent attempt to follow up on what Valve did with the first and is definitely worth playing through at least once.

Score

48.5/50

8/10 (Very Good)

Grand Theft Auto: Vice City (PC, PlayStation 2, PlayStation 3, Xbox, iOS & Android)

Grand Theft Auto Vice City

Developer(s) – Rockstar North

Publisher(s) – Rockstar Games

Programmer(s) – Obbe Vermeij & Adam Fowler

Producer – Leslie Benzies

PEGI – 18

Following on from the immensely successful Grand Theft Auto III, Rockstar decided to take the Grand Theft Auto franchise back into the 80s. And to Grand Theft Auto: Vice City, making for one of the most critically acclaimed games of the sixth generation. Winning several gaming awards and being so far the only Western game to appear on Famitsu’s top 100 video games of all time. Ranking at number 76. Though I don’t consider games in the Grand Theft Auto series to be among my favorites, some of them are still very much worth playing. And Vice City is no exception.

Graphics – 8/10

It’s a lot more unique than any of the previous games, in my opinion. As well as providing a very realistic and vibrant take on the 1980s (giving players the option to ride vehicles like mopeds and Cadillacs), the in-game world is also very loud and colorful. In stark contrast to the gritty atmosphere associated with most of the games in the series to come both before and after it. By proxy, a lot of the architecture in the game seems much less tacked on than in many other installments. Making the scenery stand out to an even greater extent.

Gameplay – 9/10

Though gameplay remains largely the same, with players being given the option to either advance the storyline or wreak havoc and get into as much trouble with the police as they possibly can before a full-scale manhunt breaks out to the point of the authorities having to chase you down with squad cars and helicopters whilst they’re riding a tank through the streets (speaking from experience), the major improvement to gameplay made with Vice City was the option to build an empire.

To seize each establishment available to buy, and make as much money from doing so as possible. This aspect would be expanded upon even further in San Andreas. Giving a Grand Theft Auto game with more of an RPG feel to it. But in Vice City, it was like a breath of fresh air to me. At this point, I was becoming somewhat weary of many of the series’ stables after the last three games.

Controls – 8/10

Unfortunately, I’ve always found issues with the Grand Theft Auto control scheme. And Vice City is no exception in this respect either. Typically, problems arise while trying to aim with guns and trying to throw grenades. Another gameplay mechanic I’ve always found to be over-ambiguous is the ability to shoot guns from vehicles. It’s even harder to aim under those circumstances. It’s never a good idea to build upon existing control mechanics if the fundamentals haven’t been perfected yet. I can’t say whether or not these aspects have since been improved on following the release of Grand Theft Auto V. But at least other than these issues, there aren’t any others in Vice City.

Lifespan – 9/10

To accomplish everything in the game should take about 40 to 50 hours. Which, at the time, was extremely impressive for a game of its kind. Around the time of its release, the only games to last as long as this did were usually RPGs. And for an action-adventure title to last this long was unthinkable. Ever since, there have been many other games made in the same vein. Some of which are among my own personal favorites. Such as Just Cause 1 and 2, as well as Batman: Arkham City.

Storyline – 7/10

Compared to every other Grand Theft Auto game I’ve played, I’d say the story in Vice City is by some distance the most interesting. It follows Tommy Vercetti, a loyal member and recently promoted capo of the Forelli crime family, who is sent to Vice City to oversee a major drug deal. The deal goes wrong as the buyers are ambushed, with Vercetti and his associate Ken being the only two survivors of the attack.

Later, Tommy informs Don Sonny Forelli of the situation and vows to recover both the stolen cocaine and money and kill those responsible. Tommy’s vendetta unfolds into a series of more convoluted events and circumstances and makes for a classic gangster story reminiscent of the likes of Scarface and Goodfellas, made even more authentic by a pretty impressive cast of voice actors, including Burt Reynolds, Dennis Hopper, Danny Dyer, Gary Busey, Danny Trejo, and Ray Liotta, providing the voice of Tommy Vercetti.

Originality – 6/10

Though this game does ultimately play out like every other game in the Grand Theft Auto series, the developers managed to keep things fairly fresh by including a different art deco for the scenery and style, improvements to gameplay, maintenance of the long lifespan associated with Grand Theft Auto III, and a half-decent story. There have since been many Grand Theft Auto imitators (Just Cause even exceeding the quality of it in my opinion), but the 3D Grand Theft Auto games were worlds apart from the original three PlayStation games, and this game is, in my opinion, the second-best out of them behind San Andreas.

Happii

In Summation, Grand Theft Auto: Vice City is undoubtedly one of the better entries in the series and introduced enough changes to hold my interest for quite some time. It would also go on to influence a great deal of some of the best games of the seventh generation, but it is also a gaming experience that still holds up to this day.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec (PlayStation 2)

Gran Tuismo 3

Developer(s) – Polyphony Digital

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Designer – Kazunori Yamauchi

PEGI – 3

Released on the back of immense success on the original PlayStation with the first and second installments, Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec had a lot of hype to live up to the pending release and was able to do so in spectacular fashion. Even gaining a score of 39/40 from Japan’s Famitsu. Becoming only the eighth game in the publication’s history at that time to receive this honor. Though I do have the feeling that I spent a lot of time playing this game when I was a kid. But the more I’ve grown up, I’ve started to see this game as being more generic. I still enjoy playing it to this day.

Graphics – 10/10

It is very easy to look at this game nowadays and see a largely outdated and inferior experience to what is normally portrayed in racing games these days. Especially if you belong to a younger generation of gamers. But at the time, a video game that looked as good as this back in 2001 was nothing short of phenomenal. I remember it blew me away at the time.

But it also made me extremely excited for what games could expect to see later on in the shelf life of the PlayStation 2. We all thought the Dreamcast was something else compared to the likes of the Nintendo 64 and the original PlayStation. But it was games like this that helped Sony to take gaming visuals to the next level, so to speak. Aside from that, the game also has quite an impressive soundtrack. Featuring songs from bands such as Feeder and Ash.

Gameplay – 7/10

Very much like Driveclub, for example, I find this title to be enjoyable enough to play and hold my attention for a fair few hours. As far as most see it, it’s simply a carbon copy of the first two Gran Turismo games. But made bigger and better. Perhaps the most effective strategy to employ whilst developing a video game sequel. There’s nothing wrong with giving players more of what they already like and in greater quantities. And it made the third game just as good as its predecessors; arguably better.

Controls – 10/10

For me personally, this was the first game I played that incorporated a fair control scheme in a conventional racing game. And one that also made it feel like an authentic racing experience reminiscent of real-life competitive rally sports. Before that, the likes of Destruction Derby and TOCA Race Drivers were games that I couldn’t get to grips with at all. I even have trouble with Formula One games as it is. This is why I was baffled to get as good a time as I did when I tried out an actual F1 simulator at Play Blackpool.

Originality – 2/10

The only way in which this game innovated in any capacity is indeed in its visuals. Which, whilst exemplary at the time, would go on to be outdated relatively quickly. Especially as both Need for Speed and Project Gotham launched shortly after it, and blew it out of the water in terms of graphical advancement. But aside from this, the game is, in essence, the same as every other racing game to have come before and to come after. And especially these days, it’s far too difficult to be able to differentiate between them all in positive ways, in my opinion.

Happii

However, to summarize, Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec is, again, not a terrible game and is still quite enjoyable to play. And I would recommend it to anyone who may be a fan of the generic racing game, regardless. Racing games remind me of Alan Partridge’s theory of how, if there may be too much of something, another way of looking at it could be that people like it, so more of it should be made. Gran Turismo was certainly a catalyst for this theory to be put into play throughout the 2000s in gaming. And the third game was one of many that managed to impress at the time.

Score

29/40

7/10 (Fair)

Gift (PC & PlayStation 2)

Gift

Developer(s) – Eko System

Publisher(s) – Cryo Interactive & Wanadoo

ELSPA – 3

Released in 2000 as an extremely early PlayStation 2 title, Gift was a 3D platformer. Predating many of the amazing games in the genre released on the system. This set an entirely new standard within the industry. On the back of the success of the likes of Spyro the Dragon and Super Mario 64. Gift, however, falls drastically short of industry standards. It is most definitely the worst PlayStation 2 game I have ever played.

Graphics – 3/10

The developers made no effort to attempt to showcase the capability of the PlayStation 2 in its early stages. Instead of only creating something on par with the original PlayStation. The conceptual design is also extremely nonsensical and meaningless. Oftentimes, developers will attempt to create something very outlandish, which at first glance may seem like a bunch of random ideas. But most often from an extremely interesting and cohesive concept. But everything down to the main character in Gift simply makes for a senseless mixture of different ideas, which don’t go well together at all.

Gameplay – 2/10

Even worse than the game’s visuals is its style of play. The game is a 3D platforming puzzle game with some of the weakest combat elements I’ve ever seen in a video game. There is next to no variety in abilities and move sets. And the puzzle-solving elements are just as woeful. It also tried to incorporate some variety by having a semi-non-linear progression to it. But in the end, it merely comes across as an unimaginative rip-off of Crash Bandicoot.

Controls – 6/10

The controls are also hopelessly unresponsive. This adds even more to the frustration of engaging in combat with enemies. The jumping mechanics just about qualify as adequate, which is a small saving grace. If there were equal complications with them as there are in combat, it would be catastrophic since it is a 3D platformer.

Lifespan – 3/10

The game can merely be made to last an average of 6 hours, which is below par for not just what would be seen later on in the PlayStation 2’s lifespan. But also below par for what had already been seen on the likes of the original PlayStation and the Nintendo 64. Super Mario 64, Donkey Kong 64, and Spyro the Dragon could be made to last upwards of 20 hours each. Which, in turn, highlights this game’s lack of imagination and variety.

Storyline – 4/10

The story follows a creature called Gift, who is sent by the game’s developers to save a kidnapped princess character and save the day. Aside from some small comedic elements and the breaking of the fourth wall, the game’s story has very little else going for it. The opening cutscene would seem to suggest that this game is a comedy by genre, but the atmosphere it portrays throughout the rest of the title would suggest something different and inconsistent with the initially supposed tableau that the game opens on, which makes for a very contradictory experience.

Originality – 0/10

Aside from every other fault I have listed with this game so far, there is also absolutely nothing in the way of uniqueness that this game has going for it. Combat and puzzle-solving of its kind had been perfected with Ocarina of Time, and platforming of its kind had been perfected with Super Mario 64. And consequently, it presented players with an experience that would never have been capable of meeting expectations of any nature for a 3D platformer.

Furiious

Overall, Gift is a hopelessly lackluster gaming experience and one that I am not able to recommend under any circumstances. It’s unoriginal and riddled with errors. And certainly as forgettable as its level of obscurity would suggest.

Score

18/60

3/10 (Bad)

Final Fantasy X-2 (PlayStation 2, PlayStation 3 & PlayStation 4)

Final Fantasy X-2

Developer(s) – Square

Publisher(s) – Square Enix & Electronic Arts

Director – Motomu Toriyama

Producer – Yoshinori Kitase

PEGI – 12

The first direct sequel to be developed in the history of the series, Final Fantasy X-2 was created with the intention of presenting players with a much more positive atmosphere within the universe of Spira. Departing from the darker and more serious vibe that the original game gave off. It certainly lived up to that, as most of the main characters are much more carefree than in the previous game, which presents a few problems in the storyline. Nevertheless, it plays out very much in line with the Final Fantasy tradition. Arguably, more so than its predecessor.

Graphics – 9.5/10

From a technical standpoint, there were a few minor improvements made departing from Final Fantasy X. Most notably in the facial expressions of the central characters. A couple of the locations within the game have also been re-designed, with a few new locations within familiar ones thrown in for good measure. Such as the dungeons of Zanarkand and the floating ruins atop Mt Gagazet. Although the majority of the open world in the game is taken directly from the original game. Some players may criticize it, but I look at that as being both practical and realistic.

Gameplay – 8/10

The basic premise of gameplay works pretty differently from most other games in the franchise. It involves the main characters taking many different missions throughout Spira. With the option of choosing where they may go from the beginning. Eliminating the initial sense of linearity synonymous with most main entries in the Final Fantasy series. In addition, the combat also has a few changes. It relies on the active time system to determine which character attacks next.

Character classes also work much differently. Swapping out the sphere grid in favor of giving the player the option to make the character swap out their class at will. Making it easier for each character to become a jack of all trades. Though I prefer the sphere grid system from Final Fantasy X, this system worked particularly well. And to me, it was the last great Final Fantasy combat system. Before Square Enix changed it for the worse.

Controls – 10/10

Despite the new take on combat, it is still particularly simple to get to grips with. And otherwise, the rest of the game plays out more or less identically to the previous game. With which there were also no problems.

Lifespan – 8/10

Though it can’t be made to last over 100 hours like the original game, it can still be made to last a particularly long time. Around 50 hours or so, which is still adequate for an RPG. At first, I thought of it as being underwhelming for a game that had open-world exploration available as an option. But for a game that took merely 2 years to develop, it’s quite the achievement.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of Final Fantasy X-2 follows the female lead of the last game, Yuna, as she has since formed her own team of treasure hunters called the Gullwings, along with former party member Rikku and a new character called Paine. Yuna formed the team after she found a sphere seemingly containing footage of her love interest and the male lead of the last game, Tidus. Believing he may still be in Spira somewhere, she also resolves to find him. Though the story starts as being much happier than Final Fantasy X, it does eventually develop into something much darker and convoluted, which keeps the sub-series fresh. But it’s also marred down during the first half of the game by the fact that the dialogue between the main characters is much cheesier than in the previous game, as the Gullwings give off a vibe very reminiscent of Charlie’s Angels.

Originality – 7/10

Though the game follows very many tropes of the series that many players will be familiar with and, at this point, even accustomed to, it still makes for one of the standout experiences on the PlayStation 2. It gave testament to how innovative the original Square team could be before the merger between them and Enix, and then, in my opinion, at least, the Final Fantasy series was left to stagnate. Commercially and critically, it continues to do exceptionally well, but I’ve never been captivated by any of the newer games in the same capacity that I have with most other entries in the series before Final Fantasy XI. This, in my opinion, has been the last Final Fantasy game with any positive innovation attached to it.

Happii

Overall, Final Fantasy X-2, whilst not having the same sense of longevity as the original game, is nevertheless a very worthy sequel and worthy of the attention of anyone with either a PlayStation 2, 3, or 4. Despite the sometimes cringeworthy dialogue, the story does eventually evolve into something better and has many other elements keeping the series positively fresh at that point.

Score

47.5/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Final Fantasy XII (PC, PlayStation 2, PlayStation 4, Xbox One & Switch)

Final Fantasy XII

Developer(s) – Square Enix

Publisher(s) – Square Enix

Director(s) – Hiroyuki Ito & Hiroshi Minagawa

Producer – Akitoshi Kawazu

PEGI – 16

It’s my opinion that ever since Squaresoft and Enix merged into the entity Square Enix, and the subsequent departure of many of the central developers of previous Final Fantasy games, such as series creator Hironobu Sakaguchi and long-time composer Nobuo Uematsu, the Final Fantasy games have taken a huge turn for the worse in terms of quality. To me, Final Fantasy XII is the best example of that.

Graphics – 4/10

Although the graphics are technically marvelous, instead of the franchise’s tradition of bringing cinematic experiences to gaming, not only is this set in an already established universe, breaking series traditions, but I didn’t find it very conceptually compelling either. It seems to encompass a world heavily influenced by medieval fantasy and steampunk fiction. This was done with Final Fantasy IX and Breath of Fire IV to a certain extent. But both of those games did it infinitely better than this. As has every other Final Fantasy game since number VI.

Gameplay – 0/10

In all honesty, I couldn’t get through the prologue of this game without feeling acrimoniously disappointed by it. It was the first time I’d ever witnessed the combination of turn-based RPG combat and real-time combat. And I’d never been more sorry to see a franchise undergo such a negative change. I remember watching a video on YouTube published by a reviewer called Stan Burdman. In it, he voiced his opinions on the deterioration of the Final Fantasy franchise and commented that developers don’t improve on either turn-based RPG combat or real-time combat by combining them together, but rather they are both made worse. And I couldn’t agree more with that point. The video itself no longer seems to be on his channel, but he was the very first video game reviewer I ever found on YouTube. And I would highly recommend readers check him out.

https://www.youtube.com/user/stanburdman

Controls – 3/10

Since Final Fantasy XII was also very much a question of trial and error, since it was also one of the first games, unfortunately, to popularise this style of play, the control scheme was always going to be a matter of contention. And in my opinion, it’s handled very poorly within the combat system and only served to make this game feel like that much worse of an experience.

Lifespan – 10/10

In lieu of the Final Fantasy tradition, however, the game lasts about the amount of time that could be expected of a game of its kind. And does offer an extremely long experience for those who are more lukewarm to this style of play. Leveling up characters takes a long time. And there are a great many side quests to keep players entertained at least.

Storyline – 5/10

Aside from the game being set in an already familiar world, it also has an already familiar plot attached to it. Another Final Fantasy convention was unfortunately broken with the twelfth game. It takes place in the world of Ivalice, the same set as Squaresoft’s own RPG Vagrant Story. It tells the story of an orphan named Vaan, who, along with the traditional supporting cast of characters, is caught in the middle of a raging war. And must fight to bring peace to Ivalice.

Originality – 0/10

Though the game has a unique combat system, I think that it makes it unique in a much more negative way. In my opinion, it’s too much of a radical departure from other games in the series. This has led to a sharp decline ever since. As I pointed out, there is also hardly any originality in the visuals or the story. And in that respect, it makes it seem even more like a step down from every other exceptional game in the franchise.

Angrii

To sum up, Final Fantasy XII is unanimously my least favorite game in the Final Fantasy series. And one of the worst games ever made. I’ve hated this title ever since I first played it, and there haven’t been a lot of games released throughout the years to have disappointed me as much as this.

Score

22/60

3.5/10 (Very Poor)