Tag Archives: RPG

Dark Souls II (PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, PS4,Xbox One & PC)

Dark Souls II

Developer(s) – From Software

Publisher(s) – From Software & Namco Bandai

Director(s) – Tomohiro Shibuya & Yuka Kitamura

PEGI – 16

Dark Souls II was one of the most talked about, publicized, commercially successful, and critically acclaimed games of 2014. It’s been cited for its reportedly great gameplay, stunning visuals, and abundant replay value. However, after playing it, I’m struggling to understand what all the hype was about. It’s not because of how difficult a game it certainly is. But because I genuinely didn’t find anything that most critics have praised this game for so fervently.

Graphics – 6/10

The game is conceptually fair in terms of visuals. The game is set in a world very reminiscent of a typical fantasy RPG or fantasy film, such as The Lord of the Rings. But I can’t help but think that the graphics are severely outdated. To me, it looks like a game that ought to have been released when the seventh generation had not long begun. The graphics aren’t even on par with the likes of BioShock and Mass Effect. And they were both released back in 2007.

I had high expectations of the visuals in this game. Especially after the opening FMV, which was very nicely done, in all fairness. But as far as in-game graphics are concerned, there just doesn’t seem to be a great deal that stands out, in my opinion. There are a few unique-looking bosses among a great number of bosses in the game. But the enemy and character designs leave a lot to be desired, the way I see it. Looking closely, I believe the game also looks to be in a somewhat unpolished state as well. And especially given visuals as outdated as the ones found in this game, it is unacceptable.

Gameplay – 5/10

There’s nothing overly outstanding about the visuals in the game. And in my opinion, the same can be said about how the game plays out, too. Dark Souls II is a hack-and-slash RPG. Comparable to games such as Fable and Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning. Before I played it, I did expect that I would be deterred from playing it for any extended period of time. Due to how difficult I’d heard both this and the first game were. But whilst it is indeed pretty difficult, I just found myself growing very bored with it very quickly.

Combat doesn’t feel very fluent at all, in my opinion. And I can’t help but feel that the game must get overly repetitive for people who have played it for a while. But one of the biggest gripes I have with this game is how each boss plays out. Although a few of them do stand out in a conceptual sense, such as The Rotten or the Duke’s Dear Freja, a great many of them don’t. A great number of them are simply knights in different sets of armor, who all attack extremely similarly, and by that token, require more or less the same strategy to take down. By all these faults I’ve been able to highlight, it just seems insane to me how so many people have taken such a liking to it.

Controls – 8/10

Although it was a technique used by developers in order to heighten the difficulty of the game, I found that the game’s controls were somewhat annoying. For the most part, it seemed that bigger enemies are more agile than the player character. I spent twenty minutes trying to kill an ogre. But it seemed like it was faster than me. Which, to me, just gave the game an extremely unnecessary, unrealistic feel to it. However, apart from this, there are no other problems. And more intrepid players must master a pretty intense learning curve in order to progress.  That’s at least one positive thing I can say about this game.

Lifespan – 10/10

Another positive that I can point out is that the game lasts a particularly long time. One playthrough can take up to 40 hours. But this game was designed to be played multiple times, and gamers who may find it more enjoyable to play than I do can get over 100 hours out of it. Personally, I couldn’t even play past 100 minutes of it without succumbing to boredom. But this game clearly does work better for others than it did for me. I think it depends if people are willing to step up to the game’s relentless difficulty and can look past flaws like outdated visuals. But I can’t.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of Dark Souls II follows a customizable character on his/her journey to find a cure for an undead curse they are afflicted with. Though that is the basic premise of the story, it does unfold into something a little bit deeper. And it’s fairly well done as far as RPGs go. And although I won’t give away exactly what happens, there are a few small plot twists and a decision to face at the end. This gives the game a small morality element. These few story features at least save this game from being a terrible game. Even an average one.

Originality – 5/10

I didn’t find the game to stand out to any great extent from a gameplay perspective, having been able to draw many similarities with Fable, Kingdoms of Amalur, and Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom. But what makes this game unique to a small extent is a level of challenge that is rarely seen in video games today, and other gamers with different tastes will welcome it with open arms.

Niiutral

In Summation, Dark Souls II is not an overly terrible game; it’s just not an RPG for everyone. It clearly works better for many other people than me, but I really struggled to find what it is that so many other people see in it. Though it lasts a long time and provides a decent challenge, I think it really needed an extra push on top of what the game contains, and it’s not made obvious that the developers tried. I would describe it as just above average (taken into account that others will enjoy it more than I do), but that’s as far as I’d go.

Score

40/60

6/10 (Above Average)

Written for Darkzero.co.uk

Citizens of Earth (Wii U, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita & Steam)

Citizens of Earth

Developer(s) – Eden Industries

Publisher(s) – Atlus

PEGI – 12

Developed as a love letter to the Super Nintendo classic EarthBound, Citizens of Earth is a turn-based RPG set in a modern universe with immersive gameplay and jab after jab at US politics. Although I didn’t find it quite the game it could have been, I found that there was enough to keep me fairly engrossed from beginning to end.

Graphics – 7/10

In some ways, the developers did make an effort to deviate from the obvious EarthBound influence. Portrayed through things like its modern setting and use of psychedelic backdrops during fight sequences, to make something a little bit more unique. Most notably in the game’s visual style, which adopts more of a cartoony feel. In turn. This coincides with a lot of the childish and naïve personalities of many of the characters. Including the main character, the Vice President of Earth. There is also a variety in set design as well as the enemy roster. This includes such opponents as hecklers and political protesters. In itself, adding to the game’s quirky sense of humour.

Gameplay – 8/10

In terms of gameplay, it seems to be influenced not only by EarthBound. But also by Pokémon in the form of the game’s many playable characters. And also South Park: The Stick of Truth, in which friends can be added to the player’s profile. But in this instance, they come with many more benefits. Overall, the game is very satisfying to play. It offers a very different take on the genre. The fact that the main character doesn’t even fight alongside his recruited citizens is also another jab at politicians in itself.

Controls – 8/10

The map system in the game can be quite needlessly complicated at times. This can especially cause problems in a turn-based RPG. Players need to know where they go next and where certain side quests may be. And what exactly they need to do to activate or complete them. It was pretty disappointing to learn that not all of these had been handled as well as they should have been in this game. Especially as this was published by Atlus, one of the lead developers of RPGs in Japan, pioneering the Megami Tensei series, which I will be getting into later. But otherwise, there are no other issues with the control scheme, thankfully.

Lifespan – 6.5/10

The game can last within the region of around 20 to 25 hours. Whilst this isn’t unforgivable, it is still somewhat underwhelming. It’s below par for a game of its kind, since, as I’ve pointed out on numerous occasions before, they can be made to last significantly longer than that. From 80 to 100 hours to give a figure. I had encountered the same problem with the likes of South Park: The Stick of Truth and Child of Light. Hopefully, developers will take note of this and look to make improvements in the future.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of Citizens of Earth revolves around the newly appointed Vice President of Earth recruiting as many citizens as possible to join his cause and fight his battles for him. Though it may not be as intricate or as well thought out as Shigesato Itoi thought out the story of EarthBound, the developers still incorporated the same kind of witty humour. And jabs at the Western culture that Nintendo did with their Super Nintendo masterpiece.

Originality – 6/10

Even though this game is very much heavily and openly based on a classic, it’s certainly not a lost cause in terms of originality. It does differ from many other turn-based RPGs with certain gameplay mechanics, general visual style, and its enemy roster. There aren’t many other games that also tackle the issue of politics like this one does, either.

Happii

In summation, Citizens of Earth is a pretty enjoyable game, but it’s far too short for me to be able to call it a classic. My biggest hope is that, in light of Atlus picking this game up after a failed Kickstarter campaign to get it going, there will be a sequel to this game, which will be made bigger and better than its predecessor, because overall, it’s a very good idea, and it shouldn’t go to waste.

Score

43/60

7/10 (Fair)

Chronicles of a Dark Lord: Rhapsody Clash (PC)

Rhapsody Clash

Developer(s) – Kisareth Studios

ESRB – T for Teen

Following on from and influenced by games of the same ilk, such as Theatrhythm: Final Fantasy and Theatrhythm Dragon Quest, Kisareth Studios this year developed their own take on the rhythm RPG in Chronicles of a Dark Lord: Rhapsody Clash. A musical take on the events of both Episode I: Tides of Fate and Episode II: War of the Abyss. Although the idea had been explored before the release of this, this was my own personal introduction to it. And I was impressed, to say the least.

Graphics – 8.5/10

The game presents players with the beautifully crafted hand-drawn style and conceptual design of the two main games in the series. Taking place in several primary locations throughout the in-game world of Cora, all at pivotal moments throughout the game’s story. From the fields of battle setting the scene of the initial fight between Magus Lee and his father Exodes to the Abyssal plains, where Magus and his party do battle with the Abyssal lord Anto Calias. Most relevant to the game, however, its soundtrack consists of a collection of the most catchy and memorable scores found throughout the series. And adds just as much to its general atmosphere.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

The object of the game is to overcome each stage by pressing the corresponding buttons in time to each track. And thereby deplete the enemy’s HP before the player’s HP is depleted. It sounds easy in terms of concept, but in terms of challenge, it’s a very different story. The game has four difficulty modes. Which can be played through and mastered. All of which offer challenge, but thankfully not to the point of it becoming completely inaccessible, much to my personal delight. Just like the first two games, which get inexplicably harder as they progress. Even compared to other turn-based RPGs, they aren’t as seemingly impossible as others.

Controls – 10/10

The original two CoaDL games have a very straightforward control scheme attached to them, which presents no problems to anyone playing. And this game has even less in the way of complication. To criticize a game like this for not taking any risks in terms of controls to me simply feels too much to me like splitting hairs. Since there didn’t need to be any risks taken. Especially if a game can provide as much entertainment and replay value as this one can.

Lifespan – 6.5/10

Completing one playthrough of the game can take less than an hour on the simplest difficulty settings. But as the player progresses, they will find that with each more advanced difficulty setting, not only does the level of challenge of course increase, but also more courses are available for players to have to overcome. Adding to a single campaign’s longevity. There is also replay value to be had in attempting to beat the player’s own high score. Warranting much more than one playthrough. Though it isn’t overwhelming in terms of lifespan, it’s by no means too short. Many other games released in recent years have left me feeling much more disappointed by how short they are than this.

Storyline – 7.5/10

As I mentioned, Rhapsody Clash retells the stories of the first two games in the CoaDL series through several key events and battles against the more threatening and pivotal enemies found throughout. Though it is indeed the same great story, told in a fairly unique way, I would highly recommend that gamers play the two main games in the series first. They’re the best starting point for potential fans of the series. As well as a pair of marvellous games.

Originality – 8/10

Although the idea of mixing the rhythm and RPG genres has been explored before, Rhapsody Clash offers a very different take on the hybrid genre. And to me, it shows that Kisareth Studio wasn’t afraid to take the series in a new direction. It was a pleasant surprise for me personally, since I’ve never been a fan of rhythm games. After having played and reviewed such titles as Parappa the Rapper. And it convinced me that with the right amount of innovation, something exceptional can be made of it.

Happii

Overall, Chronicles of a Dark Lord: Rhapsody Clash, whilst not being the best starting point to the spin-off series, is nevertheless a game worth playing through at least twice. Ahead of Kisareth’s plans to bring the first two games to iOS and Android. It’s a very entertaining spin-off title. Which I would thoroughly recommend

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Chronicles of a Dark Lord Episode II: War of the Abyss (PC)

War of the Abyss

Developer(s) – Kisareth Studios

Publisher(s) – Kisareth Studios

ESRB – T for Teen

Continuing the saga of the sinister dark lord of the Kisareth Empire, Magus Lee, Chronicles of a Dark Lord Episode II: War of the Abyss was released last week on Desura, and after having been given the green light to release the first game on Steam, Kisareth hoped to get the second instalment to the franchise released on Valve’s online gaming service even faster. And after having played it, I can’t see why that would have been unreasonable.

Graphics – 9/10

Following on from the splendid hand-drawn visuals of the first game, Kisareth has stepped up its game by providing infinitely more detailed scenery, settings, character sprites, and enemies. The world in the second game is a lot more open and vast than that of its predecessor. And there is a lot more diversity in the game’s visuals. Particularly in its enemy designs. Influences from other sources have been made far less obvious with a lot of the unique enemies that can be found in the game. Such as the Abyssal Soldiers and the Scorlanis. As well as there is more effort put into the hand-drawn visuals, the character portraits have also been re-imagined. Deviating from the Japanese anime style used in the last game. And making use of a more unique visual style.

Gameplay – 9.5/10

The gameplay remains largely the same; a traditional turn-based RPG reminiscent of the likes of Classic Final Fantasy or Dragon Quest games. And as such, it is wonderfully addictive, immersive, and challenging, like its predecessor. The game also throws the player straight into the thick of the action, starting from the battle between Magus and his allies and the dark god Xe’on. Creating an extremely explosive first impression on gamers.

The developers have also rethought the level-up system by introducing the scion grid. This is used to upgrade the character’s weapons and teach them new fighting abilities. It’s somewhat similar to Final Fantasy XIII’s crystarium system, albeit. Much less complicated and easier to work with. In any case, it’s much more satisfying to level up characters than it was in the previous game. And therefore, more enjoyable to play, to say the least. Although there are no more random encounters. And enemies instead appear onscreen, there is still plenty of room for level grinding and hours of fun gameplay. There is also more to play for throughout the game, as the story splits off into several different directions. Giving the player multiple characters to work with intermittently maintains a massive amount of variety.

Controls – 9.5/10

The only very minor gripe I had about the game’s control scheme was that managing the scion grid was a little bit awkward. They make use of a scrolling system similar to a mouse on a computer. Which is pretty slow and makes me think it would have been easier to tailor it in the same manner as every other menu found in the game. But apart from that, the game’s control scheme is flawless, thankfully having no other unnecessary complications that make it impossible to cope with.

Lifespan – 7/10

War of the Abyss lasts roughly 25 to 30 hours, making it slightly longer than its predecessor. Typically, turn-based RPGs can be made to last around 80 to 100 hours, and whilst 30 hours is still a very substantial amount of time for a video game to last, I think if Kisareth wants the Chronicles of Dark Lord saga to go from being an indie cult classic to something much bigger and successful, then the next game has to last much longer since although episodes I and II are exceptional games, they have both left me hungry for more Chronicles of a Dark Lord excellence.

Storyline – 8/10

Taking place a year after the events of the first game, Magus Lee, the Kisareth Empire, and the rest of the world of Cora face a much greater threat from the forces of the Abyss. And it falls to under Magus, his clan, and a mixture of both old and new allies to put a stop to the looming invasion. The story of the second game is just as wonderfully engrossing and daring as the first. With just as great a sense of character development, tragedy, and tension throughout to keep this narrative as magnificent as ever. Coupled with the conveyance of both friendship and family unity. This, albeit, is at times handled in a delightfully dark manner. Some side quests involve sadistically punishing some NPCs who may displease Magus. Presenting players with choices of how best to go about doing this.

Originality – 8.5/10

With a new level-up system, new narrative, new characters, and a plethora of new enemy creatures in the game’s bestiary, the franchise has been kept very much original with War of the Abyss, speaking of Kisareth’s own company policy of providing players with fresh new perspectives on gameplay and visual style. In particular, developing a turn-based RPG that stands out from the many others that have been released over the years is no easy task. And I believe Kisareth has done that in style, not only with the second game. But with the whole series so far.

Happii

In summation, Chronicles of a Dark Lord Episode II: War of the Abyss is better than its predecessor, and Kisareth has managed to deliver yet another greatly immersive gaming experience. It’s almost like an extension of the first game. But with much better visuals, more engrossing gameplay, and lasting fractionally longer. My biggest hope now is that the next game in the series dwarfs the size of the first and the second combined. As a game series that could potentially be of the same magnitude as either Final Fantasy or Dragon Quest, it deserves to have a game that lasts as long as the games in the aforementioned examples.

Score

49/60

8/10 (Very good)

Chronicles of a Dark Lord Episode I: Tides of Fate (PC)

Chronicles of a Dark Lord Episode 1 Tides of Fate

Developer(s) – Kisareth Studios

ESRB – T for Teen

Released some time ago, Chronicles of a Dark Lord Episode I: Tides of Fate is a game that I’ve wanted to get my hands on for some time. After contacting the vice-president of Kisareth Studios, CEO Tanya Botelho sent me a copy of the game. And I’ve been thoroughly impressed by it.

Graphics – 8.5/10

Chronicles of a Dark Lord contains a fantastically designed and atmospheric in-game world with a stellar soundtrack to accompany it. I was told that the developers at Kisareth take pride. Especially in how the design of the world and its elements pan out. And to me, their dedication certainly shows. Another thing I especially like about this game is that, unlike many games that it draws inspiration from, it has a very unique enemy roster, ranging from creatures like Bane Flowers and flying scorpions named the Scorlanis. But the best thing about the game’s visuals that I can point out is that it relies heavily on hand-drawn graphics. A technique that has been incorporated into some of the best games of all time. Such as Final Fantasies VII, VIII, and IX, and Grim Fandango. Because of this, the battle sequences in the game speak of attention to detail.

Gameplay – 9/10

As a traditional turn-based RPG, this game is extremely addictive. As well as being very satisfying to progress through. I’ve always gotten enjoyment out of playing these kinds of games to witness how character strength and ability develop over time. And Chronicles of a Dark Lord is no different. With learnable skills and magic to accumulate as the game progresses, it’s immensely fulfilling just to play through the main story. Let alone the very decent amount of side quests to accompany it. Another thing that I like about how this game plays out is that although there is a huge emphasis on the story, none of that hinders how enjoyable it is to play. This is not only a problem I’ve experienced with many other games I’ve reviewed this year, but in other recent turn-based RPGs to an extent, such as Child of Light.

Controls – 10/10

Chronicles of a Dark Lord incorporates as simple a control scheme as can be found in a video game. And as such, I’m happy to report that there are no unnecessary complications with playing the game to address. A lot of turn-based RPGs over the years have tried to modify this formula with varying degrees of success. But it’s been refreshing to experience a title taking it back to basics. And encompassing no frustrations.

Lifespan – 6.5/10

The game can make for roughly 20 to 25 hours of gameplay, which, though somewhat short compared to many other games of the kind that have come and gone, isn’t unforgivable. As I said, there is a decent amount of side quests to add to the game’s longevity. And I don’t think it would leave players wanting more on the same scale as I think South Park: The Stick of Truth would have inevitably done for many people who played it.

Storyline – 8/10

The story of the game follows the dark lord Magus Lee, leader of the Kisareth Empire. Who embarks on a quest with various allies to thwart the advancement of a much greater evil. Though my own synopsis may sound fairly basic, the game’s story overall is anything but that. Right from the start, there are twists and turns. This keeps it engrossing as well as intense throughout. How Magus’ character develops over time also makes it an especially memorable experience. But I don’t wish to give away any more than that. Since it is most definitely worth gamers finding out for themselves.

Originality – 8/10

Though this game is by no means without its influences, many ideas and inspirations from many different sources have been brought together by Kisareth to form something very special and unique. I think if Kisareth plans to develop this series past the forthcoming second game in the series, it could make for an extremely exciting franchise. The game offers an experience that many mainstream developers these days sadly seem very reluctant to deliver. It’s hard to be able to make a turn-based RPG stand out among most other games of its genre. But Kisareth has done an extremely good job of achieving that.

Happii

Overall, Chronicles of a Dark Lord Episode I: Tides of Fate is an exceptional game that is certainly worthy of a lot more attention. Though it has built up a cult following over the last few years, putting the game on Steam would help to bring it to a much wider audience. And I’m hoping that’s where factors like this review come in.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Child of Light (PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Wii U & PC)

Child Of Light

Developer(s) – Ubisoft Montreal, Ubisoft Bucharest, Ubisoft Ukraine & Ubisoft Massive

Publisher – Ubisoft

Director – Patrick Plourde

Producer – Jeffrey Yohalem

PEGI – 7

Much like Ubisoft’s previous effort, South Park: The Stick of Truth, Child of Light is a turn-based RPG. But developed using the same engine as what was used to develop the most recent batch of Rayman games. But in my opinion, this game is superior to South Park in many different ways.

Graphics – 10/10

The world of Lemuria is one of the most exquisitely beautiful and unique video game worlds ever designed, in my opinion. As one of the most conceptually compelling games I’ve seen for some time, it presents players with something particularly memorable in its scenery, visual style, and impressive enemy roster reminiscent of that of classic Final Fantasy instalments. I could argue the case that the character sprites may seem inconsistent, with some rendered in 3D while most have been rendered in 2D. But to me, that’s splitting hairs. No matter what dimension the characters have been rendered in, they have all been designed spectacularly. The visuals are also accompanied by an extremely impressive and atmospheric soundtrack.

Gameplay – 8.5/10

I first saw footage of this game about 3 months ago. And I expected that it would probably be no more than a simple 2D side-scrolling adventure game. So imagine my surprise and delight when I discovered it to be a turn-based RPG as well. It’s an extremely addictive and fun game to play overall. Complete with side quests and a great variety. But unlike South Park: The Stick of Truth, there is much more call for character alteration. I personally found that South Park, whilst having variety, could be played using a regular set of characters virtually from start to finish. But with Child of Light, the heightened presence of strategy greatly necessitates the constant switching between characters. And therefore providing a much more variable experience overall. On top of that, Lemuria is also a much bigger in-game world than South Park.

Controls – 10/10

Whilst it was to be expected that there would be no problems with the controls (the turn-based RPG formula having been long since perfected), this game adds some pretty unique mechanics to the formula through the timeline system reminiscent of the Attack Time Bar system found in previous games in the genre. And the mechanic of flying across each screen to encourage exploration.

Lifespan – 2/10

The downside to this game is that it’s even shorter than South Park: The Stick of Truth. 14 hours was bad enough for a turn-based RPG in my opinion. But Child of Light can only be made to last for perhaps 8 hours at most. If Ubisoft, or any other game developer for that matter, truly wants to make a much greater game in this genre, they have to develop it to last much longer, in my opinion. As I stated in my review of South Park: The Stick of Truth, games like this can normally be made to last from 80 to 100 hours. And both South Park and Child of Light fall criminally short of that.

Storyline – 8.5/10

The story of Child Light follows a young girl named Aurora from 1985 Austria, who contracts an illness, which causes her to fall into a prolonged sleep. She wakes up to find herself in the world of Lemuria, which has had its sun, moon, and stars stolen by the Black Queen. It’s Aurora’s job, with the help of several allies, to recover these celestial bodies and reunite with her father in her own world.

The story is very reminiscent of both Sleeping Beauty and many films in the Studio Ghibli library, such as Kiki’s Delivery Service and Spirited Away. In that, it features a young girl coming of age and learning to survive in the world. The dialogue in the story is structured through rhyme. The story essentially feels like an extremely long poem, which is very original for a video game. There are times when the poetry is somewhat hit-and-miss. But for the most part, it adds positively to this extremely artistically driven game. While it may not be as funny as South Park, it certainly has a lot more artistic value attached to it in every way.

Originality – 9/10

To call this game unique is an understatement. It has uniqueness attached to it in every aspect, from the stunning, hand-painted visuals to the greatly necessary variety in gameplay. And the intricate and wonderful story. The influence of this title can be very easily identified. But all its influences have had an extremely positive effect and allowed for the making of a very different and gripping experience.

Happii

Overall, Child of Light is an artistic tour de force of a video game. With great gameplay, great visuals, and a great story. I think if it were to have been made to last a whole lot longer, then it would have been a much greater force to be reckoned with. But regardless, this game is, to me, one of the standout titles of 2014.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Champions of Norrath (PlayStation 2)

Champions of Norrath

Developer(s) – Snowblind Studios

Publisher(s) – Sony Online Entertainment & Ubisoft

Designer(s) – Paul Knutzen & Chris Avellone

PEGI – 12

Set in the EverQuest universe and garnering a great deal of critical acclaim upon release, Champions of Norrath is a top-down hack-and-slash adventure game with more of a focus on online multiplayer than many other PlayStation 2 titles. However, the fact that it makes use of the Dark Alliance engine led me to draw inevitable comparisons between this game and one of my favorite PlayStation 2 games of all time, Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance. And put against that game, it doesn’t even compare despite its stronger points.

Graphics – 7/10

Like in Dark Alliance, the game utilizes a top-down view. Which makes it seem like it has much more graphical detail from a distance than it actually does. The problem is that whilst the visuals aren’t terrible, textural detail is far less present. Even though an upgraded version of the Dark Alliance engine was used to create this game. Not only that, but it also suffers from frame rate issues. When Dark Alliance didn’t at all. The best thing about the visuals is how the game differs in conceptual design. Not only from Dark Alliance but also from a good number of pseudo-medieval video games, with very different-looking settings and scenery.

Gameplay – 10/10

The one thing I can’t fault this game for, however, is the gameplay. Which is just as addictive and immersing as Dark Alliance. It revolves around the same concept. Kill everything in sight, loot the corpses, return to the hub area and sell unwanted items, fight each boss as it comes, rinse, and repeat. Of course, there is also the added feature of online multiplayer for people with access to PS2 NetPlay. And the facility is also quite well handled, exceeding my expectations of what it would be like.

Controls – 10/10

The game plays out identically to Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance. And consequently, there are no issues with the controls at all. The only difference is the method by which items are equipped and stored in the player’s inventory. But to me, that would merely be splitting hairs. There is the same degree of strategy involved in combat. Making the game just as enjoyable to play.

Lifespan – 6/10

The game’s lifespan is also on the same level as Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance, lasting roughly 10 to 15 hours, which, in my opinion, is far too short for a game of its gameplay value and general calibre. A game this addictive can easily be made to last much longer, and after two Baldur’s Gate games, I initially thought that the developers may have realized that based on the critical and commercial success of the former two games, but sadly, that wasn’t the case.

Storyline – 7/10

Aside from being somewhat typical of its genre, the story also has other flaws. It follows a group of Norrath’s champions battling to drive away the forces of evil from the land. Whilst it can be argued that the story in Dark Alliance is no different, there was a lot more depth in the story in the former, and a series of sub-stories to keep things even more interesting; not to mention the voice acting was infinitely better with contributions from many highly acclaimed actors and actresses, including Jennifer Hale, Tony Jay and even John Rhys Davies of Lord of the Rings fame. But in Champions of Norrath, the voice acting can be described as mediocre, even laughable, despite the inclusion of Michael Bell, Greg Ellis, and even Malcolm McDowell.

Originality – 5/10

Though the gameplay is just as enjoyable as in Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance, the fact of the matter is that there is not a great deal else present for gamers to be able to differentiate it from its spiritual predecessor, or other games, save for the scenery and style. The inclusion of online play was fairly well implemented but would be improved upon for the sequel, and was still a question of trial and error at the time, as indeed was online multiplayer itself.

Happii

In summation, although it can be heavily and negatively compared to the Dark Alliance games, it doesn’t mean that Champions of Norrath is bad; not by a long shot. Just as much emphasis was put on gameplay, and there were no flaws in it, at least. Given the choice, I would much rather see flaws in aspects like the story and even originality to a certain extent, as gameplay is, and should be considered the most important aspect of any video game.

Score

45/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Breath of Fire IV (PlayStation & PC)

Breath of Fire IV

Developer(s) – Capcom

Publisher(s) – Capcom & SourceNext

Designer – Makoto Ikihara

Producer – Hironobu Takeshita

ELSPA – 11

Released around the same time as Final Fantasy IX, and when Squaresoft and Enix were considered the two most prominent RPG video game development companies, Breath of Fire IV was still met with positive reviews and a great reception from fans of the series and has since become a cult classic among gamers today. However, after playing it for a fair amount of time, whilst not thinking it’s a bad game, I don’t believe that it really lives up to all the hype I’ve heard about it since I watched that video. Though people believe it to be unjust that this game was overshadowed, I can’t say I agree with that.

Graphics – 7/10

The scenery and style of the game were very well designed. It reminded me of the game Grandia, whereby 2D character sprites would inhabit a fully 3D world. In particular, I enjoyed walking through the village of Chamba. This is very atmospheric and gloomy, and it added an extremely unexpected level of tension for a time. But unlike Grandia, the level design is not as diverse. And a lot of the other villages and towns later on in the game can seem very repetitive. I remember that whilst I was playing Grandia, I was very much taken in by how unique places like Parm and the Zil Ruins looked. But for me, there just seemed to be much less of that level of captivation in terms of conceptual design.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

As a turn-based RPG, it is pretty satisfying to play the game and level up the player characters. And gaining more and more skills and powers as the game goes on. But the problem lies in the fact that there’s not as much variety in Breath of Fire IV in comparison to other big-name RPGs at the time. Such as Final Fantasy. I also find that despite its criminally short lifespan, South Park: The Stick of Truth had more variety in gameplay than this.

There are a few side quests present, such as fishing and so on. But there are nowhere near as many side quests as a lot of other games of its calibre and world size. I find it especially surprising, as Capcom wouldn’t have been on a budget at the time following the sales of Resident Evil 1 and 2. So I think the only limitations involved would have come in the form of the developer’s imagination.

Controls – 9/10

There are no issues with the controls, save for the fact that the camera angles can be awkward at times. And that having to often adjust it can be a bit of a hassle. This would be another advantage that other RPGs of the time would have over Breath of Fire IV. Some of them would simply use hand-drawn graphics. Making the entire setting one big picture for players to traverse across. But because Breath of Fire has a fully 3D environment, camera angles do consequently often have to be adjusted for players to be able to tell where they’re going.

Lifespan – 5/10

I’ve since found out that this game can be completed in just over 20 hours. And whilst that isn’t as short a lifespan as South Park: The Stick of Truth, it’s still very short for a turn-based RPG. Although that may have been considered somewhat long for a game in most other genres at the time, there were still games at that time. These were made to last three, maybe even four times longer.

Storyline – 8.5/10

Despite this game lacking substance in gameplay compared to its competitors at the time, one thing I can’t criticize too much about it is its story. After it starts a little slowly, it does get progressively better as it goes on. It deals with several adult themes and alludes to many real-life political occurrences. Breath of Fire IV follows the story of a dragon god called Fou-Lu. He formed an empire years prior to the start of the game. But became weary of humanity and put himself into stasis.

He awakens at the start of the game to rule again. But he finds he is split into two people. One being himself, and the other being an amnesiac called Ryu. Ryu is taken in by a girl called Nina and her friend Cray. They have set out to find Nina’s sister, Elina, who went missing on a diplomatic mission. It does turn into something much deeper over time, and it does certainly make for a very exceptional story in a time when gameplay stories were first becoming much more prominent than they had been previously.

Originality – 6.5/10

At the time, there didn’t seem to be that many stories in games, which touched on political instability and alluded so elaborately to nuclear war, but more annoyingly to me, it severely lacked innovation in gameplay compared to other RPGs of its time, and to me, it shows how Capcom seemed to focus less on gameplay in general in the midst of the release of Resident Evil, which again focused more on the story as well as horror.

Happii

In summation, Breath of Fire IV isn’t terrible by any stretch of the imagination, but I couldn’t help but feel that it could have been an infinitely better game than what it turned out to be. After playing it, I feel as if people do indeed give it too much credit, and I do believe that it’s overshadowed by Final Fantasy IX wasn’t unjustified by any means.

Score

43.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

Bloodborne (PlayStation 4)

Bloodborne

Developer(s) – From Software & SCE Japan Studio

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Hidetaka Miyazaki

Producer(s) – Masaaki Yamagiwa & Teruyuki Toriyama

PEGI – 16

One of the most highly anticipated games of the eighth generation, and one of the commercially and critically successful at this point, Bloodborne basically takes the gameplay premise of the Demon Souls and Dark Souls series into an entirely different world. Wrought with new dangers, new settings, and a whole new range of weapons at the player’s disposal. Unfortunately, I didn’t enjoy playing it, as I found it to be even harder. And therefore less accessible than Dark Souls II. But it does have its finer points, saving it from being a complete disaster, and I’d like to address them.

Graphics – 10/10

The visuals are among the best I’ve seen throughout the eighth generation so far. Every facet of the game is wonderfully detailed. And there’s hardly a glitch in sight. It’s certainly a huge step up from the mediocre graphics I found Dark Souls II to have. Especially for a seventh-generation title. On top of that, the conceptual design is also top-notch. Taking place in the city of Yharnam, it has an extremely strong feel of Victorian England. As well as the Italian Renaissance, with Gothic architecture decorating the streets, and some of the characters wearing what look like plague doctors’ masks. One of the weapons also looks like an oversized straight razor. A possible reference to the story of Sweeney Todd.

Gameplay – 3/10

The premise of gameplay is the same as any game in From Software’s most prominent series of RPGs. Hack and slash through every enemy in sight, and die as few times as possible. Though many have been extremely lukewarm to this style of play over the last few years, I remain unconvinced, especially taking into account how hard From Software has made these games. It makes absolutely no sense to me why developers make games hard for the sake of them being hard.

I’ve had gripes with it ever since I played the first Castlevania. And realized that the reason why developers put difficulty levels in games is to make them as accessible as possible. For developers to break that trend either way, to me, sets an extremely bad precedent. And I’d personally rather not have it that way. My biggest hope going into Bloodborne when I tried it at a lock-in event before release was that From Software had made the game accommodate as many people as possible. Sadly, that isn’t the case.

Controls – 8/10

Since the game was also developed using the same engine as the likes of Dark Souls II, it also has the same issues in terms of controls: annoyingly stiff movement, making it seem like bigger enemies have unrealistically better reflexes, and are more agile. It’s a good job that there aren’t any other problems for players to have to cope with in the process; otherwise, I would have run into a plethora of different, separate issues at certain parts of the game whilst playing.

Lifespan – 7/10

The game has a fairly impressive lifespan, however. Though one separate playthrough may take only 12 hours, there are actually three different endings to the game, making for a minimum of 36 hours. There’s also a multiplayer mode present to add even more to the game’s longevity, which, for players of a higher skill level, will be very accommodating. It’s not often that a mainstream game can be made to last as much time as that nowadays.

Storyline – 7/10

The story follows the player character traveling through the city of Yharnam, seeking a cure known as Paleblood for unknown reasons. He soon realizes that the city is ridden with an illness turning its populace into hostile creatures, and that he must overcome Yharnam’s many trials to recover the Paleblood. Compared to Dark Souls II, the story is a lot more tense and dramatic. And with multiple endings, giving it much more substance in the story than the latter.

Originality – 6/10

Though the gameplay premise has been done many times before, and all by the same developer, it’s mostly the game’s conceptual design that makes it stand out among others. Hidetaka Miyazaki is a very renowned designer throughout the gaming industry, but I’ve always thought of him as being fairly overrated, especially as there are quite a few similarities between both the Demon Souls and Dark Souls series in terms of concept. But it’s in Bloodborne where I think he has shown what he can really do.

Happii

In summation, Bloodborne is nowhere near as good a game as it had the potential to be if only the developers had added an easy mode, or even normal difficulty, compared to what players were given. It isn’t the worst game I’ve played all year, however, and it does have its place within the industry. Unfortunately, it’s just not entirely for me.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)