Category Archives: Video Game Reviews

I am Scouse Gamer 88; an amateur Liverpudlian game reviewer making his opinion heard about as many video games as possible. Scroll through and read all my video game reviews from A to Z. All my thoughts and opinions on some of the very best and very worst games released!

Throughout my career, I have reviewed a great of games; be that AAA mainstream titles or independently developed indie hits. In my 30+ years, I have had extensive experience playing every kind of game. Ranging from critically acclaimed beloved titles to forgotten flops.

I take great pride and put great care into what I do, and I hope you enjoy reading my reviews as much as I writing them!

Outlast (PC & PlayStation 4)

Outlast

Developer(s) – Red Barrels

Publisher(s) – Red Barrels

Project Manager – Paul-Andre Renaud

Producer – Louis St Denis

PEGI – 18

Originally released last year as a digital download for Steam, Outlast found its way onto PlayStation 4. But whilst I think it definitely will provide a very stern test for veteran survival horror fans, for me personally, it did little but to re-emphasize the ongoing reservation I have with survival horror games. The focus seems to be mostly on merely making the game as scary as possible and deviating far too much from gameplay. This is the most important aspect of any game. But in terms of scaring people, this game certainly doesn’t disappoint.

Graphics – 9/10

For an indie game, it is very well polished, and the attention to detail in the environments and scenery certainly makes this game stand out from a graphical point of view, at least. But the fact that this game is so well-presented could also be disturbing to others. The gritty and horrific atmosphere is depicted throughout the course of the game through the presence of disemboweled corpses and pools of blood along the floors and walls. The surviving inmates around Mount Massive Asylum, where the game is set, also make for some particularly unnerving sights. Along with some of the game’s primary antagonists, such as Dr. Trager and Chris Walker. But even before I entered the asylum at the start of the game, the atmosphere was still extremely frightening. As the game begins on a windy night, illuminated by a murky-looking sunset.

Gameplay – 4/10

As much as I enjoyed this game’s atmosphere and horrific settings, the gameplay certainly left a lot to be desired. Even for survival horror. The objective of this game is to simply run and hide, whilst exploring the asylum. Often using a night vision camcorder. That’s it. There’s no way in which players can defend themselves at all, as with virtually every other game in the genre.

Whenever enemies come into proximity, players have no choice but to either run or hide from them. Which, whilst unique in its own way, makes this game seem like less of a game and more of a film. To me, it’s not engaging enough to be able to be called a true video game. Apart from this, there’s merely one side quest, involving the collection of documents scattered across the asylum. Unfortunately, the game’s play is original, but in a very negative way.

Controls – 10/10

A first-person survival horror, there are absolutely no problems with the controls at all. A nice touch that the developers added was the door-opening mechanics that involve slowly opening them. It increases or maintains the constant feeling of tension, which is present throughout the entirety of the game.

Lifespan – 2/10

This game will take no more than five hours to finish, as there is hardly anything to do in it. Again, I find this is particularly bad, even for a survival horror title. In other games of the genre, there is a bit more replay value to be had. As some of them include alternative endings. But there isn’t anything like that in Outlast, unfortunately. It’s also particularly annoying given the size of the in-game world. And what could’ve potentially been added to the gameplay in a bid to make it last longer?

Storyline – 7/10

If this game really had to play out as much like a film as it does, then it was imperative that it at least had a decent story, and the story isn’t too bad to be fair. It tells of a freelance journalist named Miles Upshur, who is tipped off by an anonymous source about events happening at Mount Massive Asylum. He decides to go and investigate, but unfortunately, he ends up finding more than what he’d bargained for and immediately resolves to escape with his life. As far as survival horror stories go, whilst pretty typical, it is particularly scary.

The majority of the scares in this game come not from either the copious amount of jump scares or buckets of blood, but from the constant feeling of tension, which has been a device used not only in video games before it but in top-notch horror films as well as classic literature. I also like the element of players having to discover the back story of Mount Massive Asylum for themselves through the documentation found throughout the game. But the game’s story loses marks for its lack of uniqueness. I mean, how many games or films before it depicted people traveling to reportedly dangerous places and subsequently found more than they would’ve liked?

Originality – 4/10

In addition to the game’s overall story probably sounding very familiar to fans of horror in general, the uniqueness found in the game’s play also has an extremely negative impact. I think the only thing this game would probably be good for is testing horror fans’ limits, as it is at least an incredibly scary experience.

Niiutral

To summarize, all Outlast did for me was perpetuate my constant concern that most games in this particular genre focus too much on scaring people and take focus away from what truly matters: the gameplay. Whilst it does have very decent visuals and a story worthy of the fan’s attention, it doesn’t take long for Outlast to outlast its appeal, in my opinion.

Score

37/60

6/10 (Average)

Operation WinBack (Nintendo 64 & PlayStation 2)

Operation Winback

Developer(s) – Omega Force

Publisher(s) – Koei

ELSPA – 11+

Operation WinBack, or WinBack: Covert Operations, as it was known in America, was a late Nintendo 64 title. And an early PlayStation 2 title, ported to the following generation console. Most likely due to the unprecedented amount of critical acclaim it received at the time. I do have to say, as a prerequisite, that I spent a lot of time playing this game during the early years of the PlayStation 2’s shelf life. But as fairly good as it still is, and how influential it would later prove to be, I don’t think it entirely holds up to this day.

Graphics – 6/10

The best thing I can point out about this game’s visuals is how good it looked from a graphical standpoint at the time. On both the Nintendo 64 and PlayStation 2. It looked far better than most other games of its kind on the original PlayStation. And then its subsequent PlayStation 2 port did a pretty good job of showcasing what the console was capable of in its early stages. However, what I can’t wax poetic about is the conceptual design. It looks pretty generic. It was heavily influenced by the original Metal Gear Solid game. And I think the resemblances are plain to see.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

One of the better third-person shooters released at the dawn of the genre, WinBack’s cover system was revolutionary. And made playing the game that much easier to cope with than other future releases, such as Second Sight. Although the running and gunning aspect of this game is fairly addictive, there’s not much else the game has to offer in terms of gameplay. No side quests or collectible items throughout. The only objective is to play through as fast as possible to get the best ending. The fact that the players are encouraged to rush through the game is very foreboding in itself.

Controls – 9.5/10

The movement mechanics are a little bit stiff, but otherwise, there are no problems. It’s actually quite interesting to see how well the developers handled this early attempt at a third-person shooter compared with many other future releases. Not only was the cover system revolutionary. But the manual aiming system that players could use would go on to influence a variety of different games. Though the original Metal Gear Solid influenced the visual style of WinBack, there were these gameplay mechanics that would go on to in turn influence the development of Metal Gear Solid 2.

Lifespan – 4/10

When rushed through, the game can take about 5 hours to finish. Considering this is a game influenced by the original Metal Gear Solid, it is unacceptable. It was bad enough finding out that there was no way in which to save the other members of the S.C.A.T team (indeed, that’s what I thought the purpose of having their stats on the pause menu might have been for. Though in reality, it has no bearing on the gameplay at all, which makes me question the reason for having them there in the first place. But the fact that there are no other activities in the game other than to run and gun when there could have easily been something else added to it, is very disappointing in my opinion.

Storyline – 5/10

The narrative follows the main character, Jean-Luc Cougar, and the S.C.A.T team during their efforts to take back a powerful government weapon. From a terrorist group called the Crying Lions. Not only is the plot extremely influenced by and reminiscent of the first Metal Gear Solid. But the voice acting is also extremely below-par. There was the use of spoken dialogue in the Nintendo 64 version. Which, in hindsight, is preferable to having to listen to the half-hearted efforts of the voice actors in the PlayStation 2 version.

Originality – 7/10

Despite the fact that there isn’t a great deal of originality in terms of the overall gameplay formula. This will leave players thinking that so much more could have been added to give them a lot more to play for throughout. The fact of the matter remains that the control scheme not only went on to influence Metal Gear Solid. But also some of the more successful future titles in the third-person shooting genre. Such as Kill Switch, Second Sight, and Gears of War. The fact that this game served as an early prototype for some of the most successful game series in history. As well as being a prototype for many other games in the early stages of the genre, it makes it stand out a fair bit.

Niiutral

Overall, Operation WinBack’s running and gunning mechanics can be fairly addictive for how short the game lasts. But I do think the game is wanting in content. I can’t help but feel that with either better voice actors or no voice actors at all. As well as a good few side quests are thrown in for good measure, this game could have stood out even more among early PlayStation 2 titles than it ended up doing. But sadly, this wasn’t the case.

Score

37/60

6/10 (Average)

Oni (PC & PlayStation 2)

Oni

Developer(s) – Bungie & Rockstar Games

Publisher(s) – Gathering of Developers

Designer – Hardy LeBel

ELSPA – 15

Heavily inspired by the infamous Japanese manga film, Ghost in the Shell, Oni is a third-person action game. Which, to me, can be described as wanting at best. Though the release of the PlayStation 2 marked a turning point in how Sony would approach the 3D action-adventure genre and release some of the best games of that kind. Such as Jak & Daxter and Ratchet & Clank, these early PlayStation 2 and PC titles don’t fall into that category in my opinion. There have been mixed reviews of this game, and I wanted a definitive answer, but I was disappointed by the result.

Graphics – 5/10

From the very first level, I thought very little of the variety and quality of visual design. Thinking nothing of it, other than it being bland. Though it had been influenced by one of my favorite Japanese films, it doesn’t seem to me like the developers capitalized on that properly. Since they clearly haven’t added any flair to that concept. In a bid to make the content of the game truly their own cohesive work. Also, compared to many early PlayStation 2 titles, I don’t think it does a particularly good job of showing off what the system was capable of on a graphical level either.

Gameplay – 5/10

In terms of gameplay, I found that things didn’t get significantly better by any means. There’s nothing about it to even make it stand out to any particular extent next to other early PlayStation 2 games like Operation Winback or even Gift. There is a little bit of variety to be experienced towards the end of Oni. But for the most part, it stays extremely repetitive and extremely unmemorable, the way I see it. I even felt fatigued by playing it before the first hour had passed. And it felt like a chore to play through it to the end.

Controls – 4/10

Like many 3D action-adventure games on the original PlayStation, Oni’s control scheme is dishearteningly broken. Everything about the game’s controls, from aiming weapons to moving around to traversing platforms to hand-to-hand combat, makes the game ever more dismal and unsatisfying to play. Although Bungie would later be known among the gaming companies for developing some of the best first-person shooters of all time, I guess 3D action-adventure games are not their strong suit.

Lifespan – 4/10

To soldier through the game’s main story campaign will take roughly 5 hours. But in all honesty, I think player interest will outlast its lifespan. I don’t believe there’s enough to do or see in the game that would make people want to play it for an extended period of time.

Storyline – 3/10

The story of Oni centers on a secret agent named Konoko. She works for the police force responsible for suppressing opposition to the laws of the dystopian society that Earth has become. But later embarks on a quest for self-discovery. There is one major twist in the plot at a point. But other than that, I don’t think there was much thought put into it at all. The voice acting is weak at best. And the characters are consequently very monotonous and very hard to identify with. It’s indeed not worthy of the excellent story it was influenced by.

Originality – 1/10

Again, the game draws inspiration from an excellent source. But that influence was not built upon enough to make it stand out anywhere near the same level as the controversial Japanese film. There’s no room for artistic interpretation or debate. And on top of that, there is nothing new or exciting brought to the table in terms of gameplay either.

Angrii

Overall, Oni is a dreadful gaming experience. And I would advocate that anyone who is sitting on the fence about it, as I was, not bother with it. Bungie has since gained well-deserved renown as a video game developer. But this early example merely lives in the shadow of what they have gone on to achieve, and in my opinion, rightfully so.

Score

22/60

3.5/10 (Very Poor)

Okami (PC, PlayStation 2, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, Wii & Switch)

Okami

Developer(s) – Clover Studio, Ready At Dawn & HexaDrive

Publisher(s) – Capcom

Director – Hideki Kamiya

Producer – Atsushi Inaba

PEGI – 12

First released late into the sixth generation on PlayStation 2, Okami was released to an overwhelming amount of critical acclaim. Even winning the awards of Official PlayStation Magazine’s and IGN’s Game of the Year for 2006. Later being ported to the Wii and HD-rendered for release on the PlayStation Network. As well as on eighth-generation consoles, Okami’s cult following over the years has grown. Fans are fascinated by the number of various sources of inspiration that inspired the game’s development. After finally playing this game for myself, I also consider it to be a timeless classic.

Graphics – 9/10

Released at a time when the industry was seeing an influx of games incorporating cel-shaded visuals, a time I’ve talked about extensively, the scenery and style of this game are eerily lifeless when an area hasn’t been restored by the player. And achingly beautiful when it has. The level of influence taken by the developers, ranging from things like Japanese folklore, legends, and stories, is so vast that an entirely separate article can be written about it.

In my opinion, being one of the best-looking games on PlayStation 2, the overall atmosphere of the game also creates a very intimate contrast between common elements. Such as beauty and ugliness, light and darkness, and good and evil. It also touches on Japan’s great admiration for the preservation of nature. This has been prevalent in other parts of Japanese culture, such as the many films released by Studio Ghibli.

Gameplay – 8.5/10

The gameplay in Okami is very reminiscent of that of Ocarina of Time, which was more than enough to intrigue me. But in this instance, the formula has been taken by the developers and modified to present something insanely different. There are some excellent boss fights as well as a strong presence of puzzle-solving and other individual features, such as the celestial brush mechanics. This allows players to pause the game and paint on the scenery in order to interact with it. Aside from all this, the game also has a decent amount of side quests in between. As indeed any great game should.

Controls – 9/10

The only gripe I have about the game’s control scheme is that the celestial brush system was a little bit hard to work with at times. As a feature new to gaming, it was always going to be a question of trial and error. But I found there were times when it would unnecessarily hinder progress. Otherwise, I found no problems.

Lifespan – 6.5/10

An average of 20 hours is tolerable compared to many other games out there, but it’s certainly not great for a game of this magnitude. Especially considering that Ocarina of Time can be made to last twice as long. Even with all the content there is in Okami, I would welcome the release of a third game in the series following Okamiden on the 3DS. Solely to improve even further on what has been achieved with the first game.

Storyline – 8/10

Heavily based on Japanese folklore, the story of Okami follows the Shinto sun goddess Amaterasu on her quest to seal away a great evil. The eight-headed demon Orochi. Though its basic premise is simple, this game’s story is fantastic, extremely well-written, and very well pieced together. The developers at Clover Studios did a flawless job of taking inspiration from different sources and forming a fully cohesive concept. Elements of the story seem to have been influenced by many Studio Ghibli films directed by Hayao Miyazaki. Such as Princess Mononoke, Ponyo, and Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind. In that, much focus is put on the beauty of nature and the importance of preserving it.

Originality – 9/10

In every aspect, this game has been influenced in one way or another, but in my opinion, there is nothing else like it. Especially for a video game, I think it’s in a class of its own. It’s games like this, Ico, Legend of Zelda, and Shadow of the Colossus, which remind me of how fascinating Japanese culture is. And since this game is one that goes into much more intricate detail than many other games out there, it certainly makes it stand out.

Happii

In summation, Okami is one of the greatest games I’ve played in quite some time. And I would advocate that anyone who hasn’t played it give it a try. Though it doesn’t last as long as I personally believe it could have done, it’s certainly worth investing the half-decent amount of time required to play the game to its fullest.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Of Orcs & Men (Xbox 360, PC & PlayStation 3)

Of Orcs and Men

Developer(s) – Cyanide Spiders

Publisher(s) – Focus Home Interactive

PEGI – 16

Released in 2012 on PC and seventh-generation hardware, Of Orcs and Men was a game that received respectable acclaim from critics. But scorn on aggregate websites such as Metacritic and GameRankings. After playing this title for myself, I thoroughly agree with the aggregate website reviews. The game is very half-hearted in almost every respect. Featuring a seemingly broken and mercilessly repetitive combat system, among many other problems.

Graphics – 7/10

The game’s best feature is its level of detail in graphics. Which, technologically, can be compared to some of the best-looking games of the generation. Including the first three Batman Arkham games. The level of detail found in the scenery and character models is pretty impressive. But it’s lacking in terms of conceptual design, especially compared to many games or series based on medieval fantasy. Such as The Lord of the Rings, Warcraft, or Baldur’s Gate. Where this is most evident, in my opinion, is in the conceptual design of the enemies. They are very generic-looking and don’t truly provide any additional variety.

Gameplay – 3/10

The game is an action RPG that plays out very similarly to Dragon Age: Origins, which, to me personally, never bodes well. The player is put in control of two characters. An orc named Arkhail and a goblin named Styx. Arkhail is used for head-on combat. Whilst Styx is used to take a more stealthy approach, given each challenge the player must overcome along the way. Undoubtedly, the best elements of the gameplay are those that require the use of stealth. This, in turn, understandably explains why the developers wanted to expand upon that with the release of Styx: Master of Shadows, and the follow-up Styx: Shards of Darkness. The combat system is incredibly boring and repetitive. And even though both characters can level up and gain new abilities, the game can simply be button-mashed through. Regardless of what abilities players are able to take advantage of.

Controls – 3/10

Apart from the combat system presenting problems in terms of controls as well as gameplay, I also found that the general movement felt very clunky and stiff. It presents particular problems when going through the stealth sequences. Problems I found to have been carried on into Styx: Master of Shadows. And problems I hope will be rectified with the release of Styx: Shards of Darkness. The controls, in my opinion, are even worse than those of Dragon Age: Origins. Whilst combat in the two games felt extremely similar, the movement controls of Dragon Age Origins at least felt fluent enough.

Lifespan – 5/10

Clocking in at around 11 hours, the game is also painfully short, as well as relentlessly bad in general. There are no side quests in addition to the main story arc. And there is absolutely nothing in the way of replay value to warrant any more than a single playthrough if players can bring themselves to get even that far.

Storyline – 4/10

The game’s narrative is also extremely uninspiring, especially for one that I think would have inevitably had so much potential at first. The story follows Arkhail and Styx. As they are sent beyond their homeland to hatch a plan to fight back against mankind, who have enslaved and oppressed their kind for many years of war. Arkhail, in particular, is a much more lackluster character than his position as the lead would seem to suggest initially. The only character that has anything about him at all in terms of personality is Styx. This again explains why he became the central focus in later games in this series.

Originality – 4/10

Like Dragon Age: Origins (but to a much greater and more uncomfortable extent), the game felt like more of a fighting game than an action RPG, given the amount of button-mashing that was involved. But on top of that, it provided no new elements to this particular style of combat that combines elements of both real-time combat and turn-based combat. Certainly not to the extent that Transistor did. To me, Transistor took that style of gameplay and made it vaguely enjoyable. Whilst this game does little to change my perception that this style of play is overall a bad idea.

Angrii

To summarize, Of Orcs and Men is definitely one of the worst seventh-generation games I’ve had the misfortune of playing. It’s bland, repetitive, boring, and uninspiring. The narrative is weak, the gameplay is weak, and the only redeeming quality it has is that the visuals are technologically exceptional. Which, whilst commendable, doesn’t redeem the overall experience by any stretch of the imagination.

Score

26/60

4/10 (Poor)

Oddworld: New N’ Tasty! (PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Wii U & Xbox One)

Oddworld New N Tasty

Developer(s) – Just Add Water

Publisher(s) – Oddworld Inhabitants

Director(s) – Stewart Gilray & Lorne Lanning

PEGI – 12

Back around when the original PlayStation was first released, and in competition with the likes of the Nintendo 64, Sega Saturn, and the Atari Jaguar, the traditional 2D side-scrolling style of gameplay was being fazed out fast to make way for 3D open-world games. Which were taking precedence equally as fast. Despite this, however, there were a handful of games released in the 2D side-scrolling genre throughout the fifth generation, including Yoshi’s Story, Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, and the first games in the Oddworld series. Abe’s Odyssey and Abe’s Exodus. Oddworld: New N’ Tasty basically takes Abe’s Odyssey. It gives it a fresh coat of paint as well as a slightly different perspective on gameplay. Making the scenery seem less linear in turn. The gameplay stays completely true to the great amount of variety the original had to offer. And I would thoroughly recommend the remake.

Graphics – 8/10

As I said, aside from being given a complete makeover in terms of visuals, the game also seems a lot more visually diverse than the original incarnation of Abe’s Odyssey. With backdrops being a lot more visible than the latter, and with the inevitable inclusion of enhanced details in the form of more in-depth textures (particularly on Abe and his race, the Mudokens). And a more effective use of the contrasts between light and darkness. This, in turn, adds even more to the game’s already dark and gritty atmosphere.

Gameplay – 8/10

Differing from the many different 2D side scrollers released both during the fifth generation and today, New N’ Tasty stayed true to not only the intense puzzle-solving element but also to the significance of the game’s one side-quest. To rescue as many of the other Mudokens as possible or kill as many as possible to unlock either one of the multiple endings; one of the first games I ever played to have ever included multiple endings, as well as elements of the 2.5D side-scrolling genre.

Controls – 10/10

Unlike many other video games released early in the PlayStation’s shelf life, there were next to no issues with the control scheme. And there are even fewer in New N’ Tasty. Though it may not seem as impressive in comparison to the original game, I’m thankful that no new issues have arisen. And that the developers haven’t made any silly mistakes.

Lifespan – 6/10

Unfortunately, however, the lifespan remains around the same as the original game, clocking up at about 3 to 4 hours. Though this isn’t unforgivable, and fairly long for a game of its kind, I think it would have been a plus for the developers to have added a little bit more in terms of gameplay. In my opinion, the ideal solution would have been to bundle Abe’s Odyssey and Abe’s Exodus, complete with the same huge lick of pain. Nevertheless, it is an entertaining game for the time it lasts.

Storyline – 8/10

The majority of the original game’s surrealism stemmed from its different and unusual cast of characters, premise, and story. In New N’ Tasty, it is retold with all of its wonderful weirdness kept intact. It follows the story of Abe. A member of a humanoid-amphibian race called the Mudoken, who is a slave alongside his fellow people at the biggest meat processing plant in all of Oddworld, Rupture Farms. One night, when Abe is working late, he stumbles upon a board meeting.

Highlighting how the company’s profits are plummeting, executives are pondering the solution. Abe is horrified to learn of Rupture Farms’ plan to use Mudoken meat in the production of their latest product. New N’ Tasty. Abe immediately resolves to escape Rupture Farms. While in the process, saving as many of his people as possible. With multiple endings and plenty of twists and turns throughout, it is indeed one of the most unique stories ever told in a game and stands out among a plethora of others.

Originality – 8/10

Although many 2D side scrollers had been developed, and the be-all and end-all of such is considered to this day to be Super Mario Bros (and rightfully so), the Oddworld series delivered a new perspective on the formula, so to speak. And New N’ Tasty expands on that new perspective. It gives me hope for the future since I believe there is quite a lot that could be done with the characters and gameplay premise. But this game (then and now) is an excellent starting point, in my opinion.

Happii

Overall, Oddworld: New N’ Tasty does an excellent job of bringing Abe’s Odyssey to a new audience. Hopefully, it is a sign that the series will continue past this point. It’s been languishing in video game obscurity for far too long, in my opinion. Hopefully, this formula can be improved on for a possible sequel and beyond.

Score

46/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Octodad: Dadliest Catch (PC & PlayStation 4)

Octodad Dadliest Catch

Developer(s) – Young Horses

Director – Kevin Zuhn

PEGI – 7

Octodad is a quest-based linear adventure game. This has players controlling an octopus fitting in with human society. And performing mundane tasks typical of the average family man. Whilst it is an extremely different experience from the norm. And one of the most outlandish ideas for a video game I’ve ever encountered, unfortunately, I wasn’t overly impressed like I thought I would be. Having played the demo of it prior.

Graphics – 5/10

In terms of visuals, except for the main character, Octodad, nothing really stood out from either a graphical or conceptual point of view, in my opinion. The overall scenery and style of the game are particularly simplistic and bland. And dauntingly, there doesn’t seem to have been a great amount of effort put into it. Taking place in areas such as back gardens, supermarkets, and generic-looking ships, it’s almost as if the scenery and style of the game speak of the mundane day-to-day life of the average man, which is being portrayed in the game.

Gameplay – 5/10

With a small array of boring tasks to do and criteria to fulfill. And with one side quest involving finding several different styles tied in each chapter, the gameplay was just about as exciting as the visuals. Not very much at all. There’s no real substance put into it in terms of gameplay. Which, to me, makes it a particularly fleeting and ultimately forgettable experience. It was extremely difficult for me to see the appeal that a lot of other people seemingly see in it.

Controls – 6/10

Though it’s by no means perfect, the game’s control scheme is its most noteworthy aspect, the way I see it. The player moves the character around and interacts with objects and items in the game by moving each individual limb with individual buttons. Whilst I can appreciate how different the game’s control scheme is compared with that of a typical game, what I can’t appreciate it for is how frustrating it can eventually become. To me, it’s a question of trial and error.

Lifespan – 1.5/10

Lasting just over 2 hours, taking in times when I struggled profusely with the game’s controls, I think it’s just as well that this game lasts this short a time. Since there is nowhere near enough activity to have kept it interesting for an extended period of time. And in all honesty, I wouldn’t advocate anyone play it even for the first time.

Storyline – 5.5/10

The story of Octodad follows the titular octopus character integrating with modern-day human life, taking a wife, and having two children. And performing day-to-day chores, whilst all the time avoiding an evil chef, who plans to cook him. Whilst it’s somewhat different from the control scheme, it’s not exactly memorable, the way I see it. The best things about the story are the clever cultural references throughout, along with references to other video games. And the small comedic element when certain characters break the fourth wall. But other than that, the game’s story isn’t overly immersive, in my opinion.

Originality – 6/10

Whilst the game is unique in its control scheme and somewhat unique from a story point of view, there hasn’t been much creativity put into the main aspect. The gameplay. Also taking into account the game’s severe lack of conceptual design, I think there should have been much more added to this game. To keep players wanting to play for as long as possible.

Angrii

Overall, I think the developers of Octodad deviated far too much from making gameplay as interesting as possible to focus on how unique the control scheme is. And seemed to think they could create a successful game solely on that premise. But it takes much more than a unique control scheme to make the deepest and most meaningful gaming experiences. And this game, in my opinion, severely underqualifies.

Score

29/60

4.5/10 (Mediocre)

No More Heroes (Wii, PS3 & Switch)

No More Heroes

Developer(s) – Grasshopper Manufacture

Publisher(s) – Marvellous Entertainment, Ubisoft & Rising Star Games

Designer – Goichi Suda

PEGI – 16

Developed as a social commentary to a certain extent, and tame by Suda51’s standards, though still pretty violent, No More Heroes is a hack-and-slash semi-open world game. Many critics and fans of the game regarded it as being one of the better third-party video games on the Wii. Whilst I personally think that’s true. And I did spend a lot of time playing this game at that point; I did have a few issues with it.

Graphics – 8/10

Making use of cel-shaded visuals popularised by many games released on Nintendo’s previous console, the GameCube, No More Heroes takes place in an open world somewhat reminiscent of Vice City called Santa Destroy. Although the setting doesn’t stand out among many other games, the many different characters certainly do. With opponents such as Bad Girl, Destroyman, Holly Summers, and Dr. Peace. In conjunction with the comic book-like art style, the characters are very reminiscent of either classic heroes or classic villains throughout comic book history. But they all have a twisted sense of uniqueness about them.

Gameplay – 7/10

I think the best way to describe this game is what would happen if Grand Theft Auto met God of War. The game thrives on intensity and violence. And at times, context-sensitive combat, with a fair amount of challenging boss fights thrown in for good measure. But at the same time, exploration is encouraged to a degree, with side quests available to players. They must complete in order to advance to each subsequent stage of the game. I did find it quite satisfying to play through. But for the size of the in-game world, I felt as if more could have been added to fill a lot of dead space.

Controls – 8/10

At this point, the Wii was a relatively new console and early into its shelf life. So motion controls will still have been a question of trial and error to a certain extent. However, there are a select few fundamentals that this game didn’t get right. The bike riding mechanics, for example, are pretty difficult to get the hang of. And even when the basics of it are mastered, a lot of time will still be spent crashing into cars and walls. Aside from that, the remote and nunchucks can also prove to be unresponsive at times during context-sensitive combat sequences. Otherwise, there are no other issues to address, and basic combat is handled quite well.

Lifespan – 6/10

To complete the game to 100% the first time around, players can generally spend about 20 to 25 hours doing it. Which, whilst not unforgivable, is still a little bit underwhelming for a game of its size and potential. There is replay value to be had since there is an extended ending to unlock after completing the game on hard mode. But that also makes it inaccessible to a certain extent. Now every gamer will be comfortable with taking on playing the game at a greater difficulty in order to unlock something offering no real incentive.

Storyline – 8/10

The story of No More Heroes follows a stereotypical otaku named Travis Touchdown. For purposes unknown to the gamer for the longest time, he is competing within the United Assassins’ Association to become their foremost-ranked assassin. The story does unfold into something much more interesting. And more convoluted than it seems at first glance, I think it’s marred down severely by Travis’s persona. I think he is one of the most annoying video game protagonists of all time. His persona gradually changes for the better in the second game. But throughout the first installment, I couldn’t help but get a sense of dramatic irony. Travis is being manipulated to suit somebody else’s needs. And the fact that he couldn’t seem to realize it sooner was cringeworthy in my opinion.

Originality – 7/10

Though there had been a fair few games made in the same vein before this effort, I do have a fair bit of respect for Goichi Suda’s ability to come up with many different and twisted concepts and designs for his video games. And this is no exception. In terms of gameplay, I have criticized a few of his efforts. such as Killer is Dead and Shadows of the Damned. But what they’ve all had in common is that they have had no problem standing out among other video games in terms of visual presentation.

Happii

Overall, No More Heroes is indeed one of the better third-party experiences on the Wii despite its faults. And I would recommend it to anyone who may be in the mindset that the console is solely for playing party games. Though the second game would make some drastic improvements, that’s not to discount the first by any stretch of the imagination.

Score

46/60

7.5/10 (Good)

New Super Mario Bros 2 (3DS)

New Super Mario Bros 2

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Group No 4

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Yusuke Amano

Producer(s) – Takashi Tezuka & Hiroyuki Kimura

PEGI – 3

A direct sequel to the well-received DS revival of the classic 2D side-scrolling formula of the series, New Super Mario Bros 2 was described by Satoru Iwata as being a “completely new side-scrolling action Super Mario in 2D as a key title for the Nintendo 3DS”. To me, however, whilst it was a fairly decent game in its own right, it doesn’t have the kind of innovation in gameplay, as Iwata seemed to imply that it did.

Graphics – 7/10

Where this game impresses most in terms of visual presentation is from a technical standpoint, in my opinion. It is certainly one of the better-looking titles on the system in this respect, and I think compared with other portable Mario games, there is a lot more textural detail. Mostly made evident by the many objects and elements made out of gold, which go along with the entire tableau of the game. It does suffer somewhat from a conceptual standpoint, however. Since many of the different themes of the individual world had been seen not only in the original New Super Mario Bros but also in New Super Mario Bros Wii before it.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

Playing out like most other classic Super Mario games, it follows the same 2D side-scrolling formula that Nintendo built upon vastly with the creation of the original NES classic. The difference is that in this game, coin-collecting has a slightly greater bearing on gameplay than in most other titles in the series. The problem is that it doesn’t have as much bearing as players would most probably have expected before playing, and the reward for collecting one million coins is nothing more glorious than a new title screen. Nonetheless, it plays out as well as any other 2D side-scrolling Mario game. And there’s not much wrong with that.

Controls – 10/10

Nintendo not only reinvented the overall idea of what a good 2D side scroller should be, but also for the better. But they also fine-tuned the control scheme of any typical game of its kind. Making it much easier to cope with than in other 2D side scrollers prior. Therefore, there should have been no problems with the controls of this installment, and there are not. I’ve always found the tiny Mario a little bit hard to cope with, but that’s semantics.

Lifespan – 7/10

With a lifespan of around 15 to 20 hours, depending on how many coins the players wish to end up collecting, it may not be the longest experience ever developed. But it still exceeds the average lifespan of most other 2D side scrollers. From the third and fourth generations of gaming or otherwise. I don’t begrudge games like this lasting that long, since they can seem linear. Especially these days. Since the formula has been repeated time and again, they still make for exceptionally fulfilling experiences if done right.

Storyline – 4/10

Once again, Mario is pitted against Bowser to save his constant damsel in distress, Princess Peach. This concept has been exhausted since even the later days of the NES. And it is, in my opinion, one of the most beaten dead horses in video game history; if not, the most. These days, it can be automatically assumed that people don’t play Super Mario Bros for the plot. Except for a few standout games, like most games in the Super Mario RPG series, for example.

Originality – 4/10

Although it is always entertaining to pick up a new Super Mario Bros game, they aren’t always kept as fresh as most gamers would probably like them to be. New Super Mario Bros 2 is literally a shining example of this with all the gold riddled across it. Another huge gripe I have about this game is the exceptionally poor quality of the majority of boss fights. Most of which are increasingly harder variations of the four rotating rhino bosses first found in Super Mario World. The Super Mario series has never been particularly renowned for its boss fights anyway. But this takes the cake.

Niiutral

Overall, despite its many different faults, New Mario Bros 2 may be one of the worst entries in the series, in my opinion. But that isn’t to say it’s a terrible game; just a very unoriginal and repetitious one. Nintendo has gone on to make a few more varied and unique games in the series. But this isn’t one of their most standout efforts, unfortunately.

Score

39/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Murdered: Soul Suspect (Windows, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, Xbox 360 & Xbox One)

Murdered Soul Suspect

Developer(s) – Airtight Games

Publisher(s) – Square Enix

Director – Yosuke Shiokawa

Producer – Eric Studer

PEGI – 16

Murdered: Soul Suspect is an action-adventure puzzle game, borrowing elements from both LA Noire and Dead Space. Whereby investigations must be carried out, and ungodly creatures must be subdued to advance. But because this game seemed to have these elements borrowed from the aforementioned games, I took an almost immediate dislike to it. Also, for the fact that nothing new or particularly appealing was brought to the table in terms of gameplay.

Graphics – 6/10

The game doesn’t rely greatly on either conceptual design or graphical advancement. Indeed, I thought it might not even push the graphical boundaries of the PlayStation 3 or Xbox 360, let alone the PlayStation 4 or Xbox One. But I think the most impressive things about the game’s visuals are the use of a gritty atmosphere and well-executed shadow and lighting. They add a fair bit of tension to the game. Although for the most part, because the game relies so much on the use of gritty atmosphere and lighting, it does seem that tension only builds to a certain level and stops.

The game doesn’t get any scarier or more suspenseful past a certain point in each gameplay sequence. And it can make the game seem bland most of the time, I find. I think if the developers had perhaps concentrated a bit more on conceptual design and scenery, that would have added some more to the game’s overall atmosphere instead of having it only go so far, and not building to anything.

Gameplay – 4/10

A concern of mine about video games having too much story attached to them is that too much focus can be taken off gameplay. And for the most part, it seems the only objective of the overall game is finding out what happens next. This game is a shining example of that. The gameplay is extremely bland, especially for a semi-open world one. There are side quests, but all they ever involve is collecting things and nothing more.

It’s the same with normal gameplay, only there are also a few demons to kill in some instances, too. Not enough gameplay variety was added to this title. And consequently, made it play out far too much like a film. The idea of playing a video game as opposed to watching a film is that games immerse people more and make them feel more like they’re a part of it. This game, however, does little to capture that very feeling of immersion.

Controls – 10/10

There are no issues with the controls, but it couldn’t have been hard to get the formula right. Not only has the third-person adventure genre been worked on for a long time prior to this game’s release, but there is less variety in this genre than in other games of its kind. So there wouldn’t have been an excuse not to have the formula done correctly.

Lifespan – 3/10

For even a semi-open world game, that Murdered: Soul Suspect can be completed within five hours is nothing short of unacceptable. Even when I’ve reviewed Child of Light and South Park: The Stick of Truth, I’ve been less than impressed with how little time they’ve lasted. Since open-world games can be made to last the best part of 100 hours. The fact that this game is so short-lived is yet another reason why I believe it plays out too much like a film, since films can be made to last a similar amount of time. Especially if it may be a trilogy of films. But it’s just as well the game is so short-lived, since there’s hardly anything to do in it.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of the game revolves around a recently murdered detective called Ronan O’Connor. He must solve the mystery of his own murder in Limbo to be with his already deceased wife in Heaven. The game’s story isn’t too bad, and it does have a few decent twists and turns throughout. But it’s not considerably impressive, given how much emphasis on gameplay was sacrificed in order to develop it. I would have thought that a game that plays out too much like a film would have at least had an exceptional story attached to it. But I was wrong in this instance.

Originality – 2/10

With the small exception of it containing psychological horror as opposed to the kind of horror normally found in video games, there isn’t much else unique about Murdered: Soul Suspect that makes it stand out among many other games. In terms of graphics, gameplay, or story. It’s not the first time a game has played out as this one does. And it should never be considered the definitive one by any means at all.

Angrii

Overall, Murdered: Soul Suspect is an extremely fleeting experience, and nowhere near worth its current asking price. Or any asking price beyond maybe a fiver. Too much emphasis was put on the wrong factors, and it suffered because of it. Even the factors that were taken into consideration were not properly developed, in my opinion.

Score

31/60

5/10 (Far Below Average)