Sly 3: Honour Among Thieves (PlayStation 2, PlayStation 3 & PlayStation Vita)

Sly 3

Developer(s) – Sucker Punch Productions

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

PEGI – 7

Taking place sometime after the events of Sly 2: Band of Thieves, the third Sly game kept to the core mechanics of the previous installment. But also presented a few changes to it as well. In my opinion, those changes were made for the worse. Since it took away much of what made the second game as exceptional as it was. And I was left pretty disappointed by it.

Graphics – 8.5/10

The one thing the developers didn’t take away, at least, was the exceptionally great cel-shaded style of the visuals. An outlandish conceptual take on the modern world, filled with plenty of anthropomorphic animals. The settings are also as wonderfully diverse as they were in the previous game. Taking place in various parts of the world, ranging from Venice to Yuendumu to Kinderdijk. It also features an interesting blend of old and new supporting characters. From both the first and the second game, add more to the story element.

Gameplay – 4/10

As I mentioned, Sly 3 sticks to the same core concept as Sly 2. The player must travel from city to city, advancing the plot and using stealth mechanics. With a range of different abilities to overcome a multitude of different perilous situations, the characters find themselves in perilous situations everywhere they go. With the added feature of some new characters to control.

The problem is that many of the side quests that made the second game as immersive as it was were substituted for side quests. These have the player redoing certain challenges found throughout the story, but having to fulfill additional criteria. Such as doing them in a certain amount of time, etc. To me, whilst many there consider it to be better than the second game, it was a massive step down in my opinion. It demonstrated a lack of imagination on the developer’s part. Especially when I think of all the imagination that went into Sly 2. And how much it was a genuine improvement in the first game.

Controls – 10/10

Since the game runs on the same core principles as both the first and the second, the control scheme hasn’t changed. And thus, the developers didn’t take it upon themselves to try to fix something that wasn’t broken. The controls are as wonderfully fluent as many of the greatest 3D platformers to have ever been developed over the years. And regardless of what installment may be coming under review, the stealth mechanics make them stand out greatly.

Lifespan – 3/10

Clocking in at a mere 9 hours on average, this is yet another reason why I view this game as being a drastic step down from its predecessor. The second game could easily be made to last around 20 to 25 hours. With everything that there was to do outside the main story quests. But since the side quests are different, I think many gamers will inevitably be disinclined to undertake the side quests. Upon discovery of what they are. As indeed I was.

Storyline – 8/10

Set one year after Sly 2, Sly Cooper, along with his colleagues Bentley and Murray, as well as a plethora of new allies, venture out to seek the fabled Cooper Vault, reputed to hold a vast amount of heirlooms. Collected by Sly’s descendants over the years. Personally, the ending of Sly 2 blew me away. But Sly 3 continued that level of character development and built upon it even further. For a game series that started by relying on a strong element of comedy, I never thought I would be able to take it as seriously as I ended up being able to.

Originality – 4/10

To me, because the developers took away a lot of the elements that helped to take the Sly series to the next level, there is considerably less originality about the third game. They did try something new with the inclusion of more than three playable characters, a concept that would carry on into the fourth game. But to me, it meant considerably less than what it could have potentially meant if the developers had chosen to handle the side quests in a fashion more reminiscent of Sly 2. I think Sanzaru took this on board whilst developing Sly Cooper: Thieves in Time. And I’m glad they changed as much from this game as they did.

Niiutral

In summation, Sly 3, in my opinion, is so much less than what it could have been had the developers not decided to make as many negative changes as they did following Sly 2. Even though the original game had less substance, I think the developers misused what substance they added to the third, making it worse. A classic case of quantity over quality.

Score

37.5/60

6/10 (Average)

Sly Cooper & the Thievius Raccoonus (PlayStation 2 & PlayStation 3)

Sly Cooper and the Thievius Raccoonus

Developer – Sucker Punch Productions

Publisher – Sony Computer Entertainment

PEGI – 7

The Sly Cooper series first appeared in 2002 on the PlayStation 2. Around that time, Sony started to find much greater success with developing 3D platforming games than they had done previously with the original PlayStation. Having released games such as Jak & Daxter and Ratchet & Clank. Whilst sales of the game were pretty poor during the time of its release, the game has become a cult classic among gamers. It has warranted the development of three sequels. Though I don’t believe the first to be the best (Indeed, I believe that honor goes to Sly 2: Band of Thieves), I don’t think it’s a terrible game. It just needed an extra push, and I think the developers saved that for the sequel.

Graphics – 8/10

Relating to Week 4’s unique article, Sly Cooper was released at a time when cel-shading was first established as a popular form of visual representation in video games. Consequently, this game was always going to stand out. At the time, it was an extremely significant change from the norm. It also made for several compelling level designs as well as character designs. Although some of the bosses look a little bit bland, the last boss, in particular, was very well designed. And the main character is cast equally so. Looking at some of the levels, which are set on rooftops, it’s also plain to see where the developers took inspiration from when they were creating InFamous. Though this would become even more evident in the sequel and onwards, the opening level of the first game alone is enough for players to make this assumption.

Gameplay – 5.5/10

Sly Cooper & the Thievius Raccoonus is a 3D platforming game with stealth elements reminiscent of games like Metal Gear Solid and Splinter Cell. But even with this somewhat unique aspect of gameplay, I still felt playing it left a lot to be desired. There are so few side quests that completing the game to 100% can simply be done as the player goes along, as normal. And there’s not much call for re-visiting levels, save for completing the time trial challenges. In this respect, it reminds me of the third Crash Bandicoot game, Warped, only with less content and fewer side quests. There is a bit of incentive to play the game to 100%, however, in the form of additional abilities. Such as running faster or being invisible. The game also has a bit of variety in that respect, too.

Controls – 10/10

At least in terms of controls, there are no problems. Sucker Punch had found critical success before Sly Cooper with their first game. Another debatably unfairly obscure game for the Nintendo 64 called Rocket: Robot on Wheels. So that there would be no problems with the controls would have been expected. Especially taking into account the elaborately challenging nature of Sucker Punch’s first game, released back in 1999.

Lifespan – 4/10

Unfortunately, even completing the game to 100% can take players less than 10 hours. Which, compared with other platformers, especially at the time, is nothing. With games like Jak & Daxter and Ratchet & Clank came more content and substance in gameplay, and I found that the original Sly Cooper game severely lacked that. And by that token, it would seem no wonder that the first game couldn’t compete with other games. Such as the two aforementioned examples.

Storyline – 7.5/10

The game’s story is just about as simple in general concept, and as crazy in design as many other video gaming franchises before it. But I found that it wouldn’t really be greatly expanded on or elaborated on until the next game. The plot follows an anthropomorphic raccoon thief called Sly Cooper. He, along with his two closest friends, a turtle called Bentley and a hippo called Murray, set out to recover missing pages from the book passed down from generation to generation of Sly’s family.

The Thievius Raccoonus. Overall, the game’s story is okay. But it only starts to get most interesting towards the end, and I don’t think there was enough added to keep it overly compelling. At least the story is simple enough not to create any confusion, I guess. I believe it to be the worst-case scenario when games or films become so convoluted that they become nigh-on impossible to follow.

Originality – 5/10

Although the game would inevitably be considered unique in terms of visuals, it’s by no means unique in terms of gameplay. The unique gameplay mechanics were the stealth element, which would again be more elaborated on with future installments.

Niiutral

Overall, the original Sly Cooper game isn’t an overly terrible game. It was a simple case of trial and error. Only compared to future games in the series, as well as other games around at the time, it seems to me that it was extremely obvious that it was a case of trial and error.

Score

40/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)  

Silent Hill 2 (PlayStation 2, Xbox, Windows, PlayStation 3 & Xbox 360)

Silent Hill 2

Developer(s) – Konami Computer & Entertainment Tokyo

Publisher(s) – Konami

Director – Masashi Tsuboyama

Producer – Akahiro Imamura

PEGI – 16

After the success of the first Silent Hill game, the sequel did not disappoint overall. It was met with positive reviews and huge sales figures, selling over one million copies worldwide in its first month. I, however, wasn’t overly impressed after playing through it. Although I think it is better than a lot of other survival horrors that have come out before it. What I like about it is that it’s a psychological horror game. This differentiates it from most other games in the genre in an extremely positive way.

Graphics – 9/10

Although there is a protagonist, an established antagonist for the franchise, and several supporting characters in this game, there’s no doubt in my mind that the town of Silent Hill itself is, in many ways, the star of the show. The atmosphere of the place is absolutely horrific, with most scares in the games coming not from a massive amount of jump scares, bloodstains throughout, or a staggeringly high body count. But from its constant build-up of tension, the sense of gritty realism in the settings, and the lack of light throughout the game. The thought that anything could jump out of either the darkness in the numerous buildings the player has to traverse or from out of the outdoor fog is enough to keep players constantly on edge.

Gameplay – 4.5/10

I find that the gameplay is only fractionally more enjoyable than that of Outlast, for example, since there are means of self-defense in addition to a few alternative endings to unlock. Ultimately, it again felt more like I was watching a film than playing a game, as the only objective seemed to be simply uncovering the story. The alternative endings and a few unlockable weapons are the only two forms of incentive that come with playing through the game multiple times. Reviewers have commented on how they think that the second game is the highest point in the franchise, and that doesn’t really make me want to try any of the other entries.

Controls – 10/10

Although reviewers have criticized this game for its controls, I didn’t really find any problems with it. The best thing about this game’s control scheme is the excellent use of camera angles. This, in a way, adds more to the atmosphere and overall feel of the game. They were very well done.

Lifespan – 6/10

Depending on how much exploration is done throughout a single playthrough, the game can last up to about twelve hours. This is about the average lifespan of a typical survival horror. This and the scarcely satisfying gameplay just give testament that there is a massive imbalance of focus on both horror and gameplay. It makes me wonder why there are so many developers who can’t seem to get the balance right. Even if this game lasted longer, the gameplay would be drawn out. And repetition would definitely be over-emphasized. So there wouldn’t be much point in making it last any longer than it does anyway, without further substance in gameplay.

Storyline – 8/10

For what this game lacks in more important aspects, whilst not making up for what it lacks, it certainly delivers in terms of story. A psychological thriller with elements of the supernatural will leave players feeling enthralled. And emotionally drained throughout. With its coverage of taboo subjects, such as incest and domestic violence. And with the mystery of what is true and not true, or what is real and not real. The protagonist, James Sunderland, is drawn to the town of Silent Hill by a message that he recently received from his wife, Maria, saying she was there waiting for him. Even though she’d been dead for three years before the start of the game.

As James explores further into the town, he enters a battle with his own personal demons. And subconscious desires to realize a horrifying truth and understand the errors of his ways. So as you may imagine, there are a few twists and turns before the end. It all makes for an extremely compelling plot. The voice acting can seem a bit laughable at times. But ultimately, the characters in Silent Hill 2 are very well-conceived, and how they develop throughout the course of the game makes for an excellent tale. Another interesting thing is that whilst the character Pyramid Head steals the show as the game’s primary antagonist, he’s not even the scariest character, the way I see it. By far, that honor would go to Eddie, and I will go further into why I think that later on.

Originality – 7/10

With Silent Hill 2 relying on tension as the source of its horror, and with a story and concepts that defy convention, the Silent Hill genre is particularly unique in its own right, not just the second game. But where it lacks originality is in gameplay. It ultimately plays out like most games in its genre, and it seems as if the developers didn’t even try to defy convention in that respect.

Happii

In summary, Silent Hill 2, whilst it severely lacks in gameplay, has a lot to experience in terms of story, and I suppose it is worth playing through once because stories that are compelling don’t come around often. But the way I see it, whilst certain elements do save it from being a terrible game, even saving it from being an average one, I don’t think it should be considered a classic.

Score

44.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers (Sega Saturn, PlayStation & 3DS)

Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers

Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers

Developer(s) –Atlus

Publisher(s) – Atlus

Lead Artist – Kazuma Kaneko

PEGI – 12

Originally released for both the Sega Saturn and the PlayStation, Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers, for the longest time, never saw a release outside of Japan (with Sony Computer Entertainment America rejecting a proposed overseas port). Until it was eventually released in 2013 in both regions and Europe for the 3DS. After playing this game, whilst I would agree with the notion that there are far worse games out there, I’d say it was no surprise that Sony of America would reject a proposed port at first.

Since Final Fantasy VIII was out at the time. And it would most definitely have been lost in the crossfire. I think based on the fact that the same thing happened to Breath of Fire IV during the release of Final Fantasy IX. And people consider Breath of Fire IV to be a lost relic. It could have easily happened to Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers back then.

Graphics – 7/10

For the time at least, the graphics were fairly advanced, using many clever visual techniques used in many of its main competitors, such as Final Fantasy. Techniques like using hand-drawn stills as backgrounds. And FMVs to move the story forward. They made the game look pretty realistic. Conceptually, however, there’s much to suggest that Final Fantasy VII was a major influence. Since by that time, that series also deviated away from the typical RPG settings fans of the series were used to, in favor of a more cyberpunk setting.

Gameplay – 4.5/10

Since this game seemed to incorporate a more tedious form of exploration than many other RPGs around at the time. And there seemed to be less combat involved, I found it quite hard to get into. Especially towards the beginning. This imbalance of combat and exploration also makes me skeptical of the rest of the series. Since most other Megami Tensei games play out very similarly to one another.

Controls – 9/10

A first-person RPG, which, whilst somewhat unique, made the control scheme a little bit fiddly at times. It reminded me of another RPG I once played called Orcs & Elves. In which the movement was unnecessarily complicated. Otherwise, however, there are no other issues. The turn-based RPG formula had long since been perfected. And if they had managed to miss that aspect of it, there would have been considerably bigger problems than there ended up being in this title.

Lifespan – 8.5/10

As the strongest point of this game, it lasts a pretty decent amount of time, taking up to 30 to 40 hours to finish. Whilst this may still be below the standard of many other turn-based RPGs being released at the time, it’s still a long time from what most video games last. The biggest problem, however, is the danger of the lifespan most probably outlasting the boorish gameplay.

Storyline – 6/10

The story follows a group of characters who dwell within a virtual reality city created by a sinister corporation. They resolve to end their tyranny, as well as a group of cyber-terrorist hackers called cookies (led by a man named Masahiro Sakurai. Named after the developer of both the Kirby and Super Smash Bros series). The story is fairly well-conceived, but it can get a little bit confusing at times. It’s hard to follow, to begin with. Since events move at such a pace that not much time is given for players to think about what’s going on. But after that, it does become much easier to follow. It’s also interesting to think of what other stories influenced these games. Such as Ghost in the Shell, for example.

Originality – 6/10

Whilst it may be considerably unique from the rest of the Megami Tensei saga. With the settings and conceptual design being drastically different from any other entry in the series, there’s not much present to differentiate it from most other turn-based RPGs. Even for the time being. The game’s play doesn’t stand out particularly well. And it is easy to see how many other players had been so put off by the fact that it is a first-person RPG. Since the controls are indeed unnecessarily harder to get to grips with than the likes of Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest.

To summarize, Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers is not the most enjoyable game to play, but it does provide a relatively long experience and a well-thought-out story. Unfortunately, half-decent visuals and a good narrative aren’t enough for me to label this a classic. As many other people believe it is, there needs to be engrossing gameplay above all else, and I didn’t find any of them in this title.

Score

41/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Shantae (Game Boy Colour & DS)

Shantae

Developer(s) – Way Forward Technologies

Publisher(s) – Capcom

Director – Matt Bozon

Producer – John Beck

PEGI – 7

An early indie game, five years in the making and going through a number of developmental ideas before release, Shantae is a traditional 2D platformer. But with elements of the Metroidvania genre thrown in for good measure. I was actually quite surprised to find out how good a game Shantae is. I would recommend it to anyone who may have a Game Boy or DS and is looking for a hidden gem.

Graphics – 9/10

At the time of its launch, the platform initially appeared, and the game could easily be considered revolutionary in terms of visuals. Aside from being extremely colorful, the universe of Shantae is extremely detailed and varied. Featuring a conceptual design inspired by not only Middle-Eastern culture but also pirate culture. It’s a very interesting blend. This has gone on to be a constant throughout the rest of the series and works astonishingly well.

Gameplay – 7/10

Having elements of the Metroidvania genre attached to it, there’s quite a fair bit to play for in the game. And quite a bit of satisfaction to be had out of it for the time it lasts. Aside from the encouragement of exploration and challenging enemies, there is also a series of mini-games present. Involving activities such as racing and belly dancing to gain more in-game money. The belly dancing, in particular, can be quite a satisfying challenge if the player is able to complete the higher-ranked dancing sequences. But regardless, it presents a fair enough level of challenge without being far too inaccessible.

Controls – 8/10

For the most part, the control scheme of the game is pretty straightforward. Moving and combat are easy to get to grips with. And how the in-city exploration was handled is pretty unique. The biggest problem with it, however, is that it has an open world, but no map system. I think that this is actually not only the biggest flaw in the game in terms of controls, but the biggest flaw in the game in general. It was something that was made complicated, but didn’t need to be so.

Lifespan – 6/10

Though it is on the Game Boy Colour, and it could be argued that memory usage would have factored into it, 4 hours still seems to me as particularly underwhelming for a Metroidvania game. I can’t help, but with perhaps a few more mini-games, or some side quests attached to it, it could have been made to last a fair bit longer. It was around this time that open-world 2D platformers were being made to last longer than many others in the past. Such as Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, so where this game may have been ahead of its time from a graphical standpoint, it was lacking in terms of lifespan.

Storyline – 6/10

Although the general atmosphere and visual style of the game were different from many others, the story wasn’t anywhere near as good. It follows Shantae, a half-human, half-genie hybrid. She is charged with protecting a small town called Scuttle Town. One day, the town is attacked by the pirate Risky Boots. She steals a prototype steam engine for her diabolical plan. And so Shantae resolves to get it back from her. For a video game story, it is pretty typical. Only kept somewhat interesting by small elements of humor here and there.

Originality – 6/10

Though it may have been particularly advanced for the time in terms of graphics, especially on a handheld system, I think it lacked uniqueness somewhat in terms of gameplay. It did have some standout mechanics for the time. Such as the ability to transform into various animals to get around, but ultimately, the most standout thing was indeed not only the graphical marvel of the visuals but also the game’s conceptual influences.

Happii

Overall, despite the absence of a map system and a prolonged lifespan, Shantae is still a fairly enjoyable game and worthy of the attention of anyone who may own a Game Boy. It isn’t the best platformer to have ever been released, but it indeed has its charms.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Senran Kagura Burst (3DS)

Senran Kagura Burst

Developer(s) – Tamsoft

Publisher(s) – Marvelous AQL & XSEED Games

PEGI – 16

A fairly popular video game series in Japan, Senran Kagura has not long started making waves in the country. And has been met with a relatively high amount of critical acclaim. Senran Kagura Burst was no different, garnering average scores of 7 or 8 out of 10. Personally, I didn’t see that much appeal in terms of gameplay and found it more repetitive than anything else. Nevertheless, it’s still a pretty interesting title to talk about.

Graphics – 7/10

Making heavy use of cel-shaded visuals, the graphics are about the best aspect of the game. Aside from the many different types of outfits worn by characters, there’s also some basis in the diversity of the level designs. However, the characters’ outfits are very unique and different from one another. As well as in other Japanese series of games, or even media in general, they’re nowhere near the kinds of outfits that ninjas would wear. Or be expected to wear. Contrary to popular belief, ninjas never wore jet black.

But instead wore navy blue colors in order to better hide in the moonlight. They could also weigh no more than 60kg. This probably makes most of them illogical candidates since their breasts look like they weigh that alone. Whilst on the topic, the overly sexual appearance of the female characters is the main reason why I don’t understand why this game didn’t get any more attention than it did. Especially since it was released on a Nintendo console. But I think things like this are what Nintendo needs to emphasize that their consoles aren’t just for kids. They just need to make sure that the gameplay is much more immersive before they decide to port it.

Gameplay – 5/10

The gameplay encompasses a mixture of action-adventure and hack-and-slash elements. Unfortunately, it can get overly repetitive after a while. And although there is a small RPG element to it, I think that aspect should have been built upon even further to make it a lot more interesting. At least with Hyrule Warriors, for example, there were different game modes to keep players busy. But in this game, there isn’t a great deal of incentive to warrant even a second playthrough.

Controls – 9/10

The only issue I had with the game’s control scheme is that, due to the nature of the game and the layout of the in-game screens, it can be difficult for players to see what they’re doing sometimes. Since there can be a ton of enemies present at any one given time. And the player character can be behind them. Otherwise, however, there are no further problems. It actually plays out a little like the Ninja Gaiden game on the original DS.

Lifespan – 4/10

Clocking up at about 5 hours, a game with even mild RPG elements should be made to last even a little while longer. Although there was an additional story added with the release of Senran Kagura Burst over the original game, I still don’t feel that the title has enough to offer to warrant the oftentimes ridiculous prices I’ve seen attached to this game, even pre-owned copies of it. I would understand if they were Japanese imports, and consequently rarer. But £35-£40 is far too high an asking price for a game with as little substance as it has.

Storyline – 5/10

The story follows a group of high school students who are secretly taught the ways of ninjitsu and are tasked with completing various missions throughout the course of the game. The dialogue is spoken in Japanese, therefore making the game seem more authentic. And not being marred down by potentially bad English voice acting, the story seems quite vague. Not only that, but from the point of view of someone who understands the true practices of ninjitsu, it doesn’t make the story as authentic as it most probably should have been.

Originality – 5/10

In terms of gameplay, there is absolutely no uniqueness to it whatsoever; only a run-of-the-mill hack-and-slash title with only a few RPG elements to keep it mildly more interesting than the average game of its kind. However, it does stand out to a certain extent in terms of conceptual design, even though there have been other gaming franchises made in the same vein, such as Deathsmiles and Arcana Heart.

Angrii

To summarize, Senran Kagura Burst certainly isn’t one of the most engrossing games I’ve ever played. And is pretty overpriced, given how little content there is. It may have some interesting visuals. But I can’t help but feel that the developers relied on the game’s level of sex appeal too much.

Score

35/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

Secret Ponchos (PC & PlayStation 4)

Secret Ponchos

Developer(s) – Switchblade Monkeys

Publisher(s) – Switchblade Monkeys

PEGI – 16

Secret Ponchos is exclusively a player vs. player game that revolves around both ranged and close-quarters combat. All things considered, I quickly lost interest in this game, given how biased and poorly executed I thought the gameplay was. And how the concept of player vs. player doesn’t work particularly well in a top-down action game.

Graphics – 7/10

The one positive I can point out about the game, at least, is that the visuals are fairly unique in terms of conceptual design, since I find that there aren’t many games out there set in the Wild West. Indeed, there was quite a big call for it before the release of Red Dead Redemption. The game also makes pretty effective use of things like cloth textures and lighting. Which I find must be pretty difficult in cel-shaded games.

Gameplay – 3/10

As I said, I found the gameplay to be pretty dull and dissatisfying, as well as biased in terms of challenge. It’s easy for opponents to predict what players will do, and it’s hard to avoid certain attacks with certain character classes, making advancement unnecessarily hard.

Controls – 5/10

Whilst there isn’t anything wrong with the control scheme from a technical standpoint, the fact that this game is player vs. player only is, in itself, the reason why the basic control scheme becomes such a problem, since, in my opinion, the entire concept doesn’t work. I think if even Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance, one of my favorite games of all time, was developed in a fashion similar to this, I would have been bitterly disappointed.

Originality – 5/10

Although there aren’t many other top-down player vs. player games out there, it makes this title unique, but in a much more negative way, since it introduced me to a concept and style of gameplay that I would have much rather not been introduced to. I can’t help but feel that if any other great top-down games revolved around such a concept, I would have thought considerably less of them, too. It also makes me wonder how great a game this could have been if there were a single-player mode.

Angrii

Overall, Secret Ponchos is one of the worst games I’ve played on the PlayStation 4. Its concept works very poorly. And I wouldn’t care to see this style of play implemented in any other video game again.

Score

20/40

5/10 (Far Below Average)

Second Sight (PlayStation 2, Xbox & GameCube)

Second Sight

Developer(s) – Free Radical Design

Publisher(s) – Codemasters

Lead Designer – Mike Armstrong

PEGI – 16

Back in the sixth generation of gaming, 3D third-person shooting was more or less in its infancy; long before games such as Gears of War and Mass Effect would go on to populate and revolutionize the genre. And deliver some of the greatest gaming experiences to date. As a genre in its early stages, I had trouble enjoying many third-person shooters on the PlayStation 2, including Max Payne, Operation WinBack, and Headhunter. And Second Sight. Though I think it stands out better than most others of that time, not many of the fundamentals were done quite right. And the game suffered because of it, in my opinion.

Graphics – 5/10

From what had been seen already on the PlayStation 2. Such as Silent Hill 2, Metal Gear Solid 2, and Final Fantasy X. The game’s visuals are not only substandard from a technical point of view. But also from a conceptual one. The settings are extremely bland. Made up of what players would find in most typical Medal of Honour or Call of Duty games. And nothing about them makes it stand out from most other games. Even for the time. The most positive thing I can say in terms of visuals is that it’s a very polished game with minimal glitches.

Gameplay – 5.5/10

I have played many worse games than this and many less variable ones, too. Indeed, having psychic powers at your disposal certainly offers some diversity in gameplay. But as far as the run-and-cover-based shooting is concerned, I found it pretty frustrating, especially since some sequences can simply be bypassed by players with a sacrifice to some health. And where’s the fun to be had in that? I can appreciate that many of the game mechanics in Second Sight could be seen as precursors to some of the ideas seen in later classic games. Such as the Mass Effect trilogy. But with this title, it was very much a question of trial and error. But with a lot more errors than I would have personally liked.

Controls – 6/10

As I mentioned before, third-person shooting games have a long way to go at this point to be perfect. Many developers at the time focused on genres such as first-person shooters, 3D platformers, and especially RPGs. Control schemes for those kinds of games had long since been developed almost to the point of perfection. But with third-person shooting, it was a very different story in my opinion. Specifically, in Second Sight, I found the controls for using psychic powers in Second Sight to be quite a chore. And at times, incredibly difficult to get to grips with. At the time, it wasn’t often that games in the genre had as much variety as there is in this title. And so it was always going to be a question of trial and error in this respect too.

Lifespan – 2.5/10

Even if it isn’t rushed, this game can only take about three and a half hours to finish. There are minimal side quests. The main objective of the game seems to be only to find out what happens next in the story. I despair whenever I find a game that has little to no side quests when there was quite clearly room for at least one, since it would suggest laziness on the part of the developers to me.

Storyline – 7/10

By far, the best thing I can attribute to this game is its story. It follows a parapsychology researcher and former soldier named John Vattic. He is on an expedition to recover his memory and discover the reasons and machinations behind his newly found range of psychic abilities. There are quite a few twists and turns throughout to keep things interesting. And whilst the voice acting may be a little bit off at times (as was somewhat of a stable thing back then), the dialogue is pretty well written, and the story has a lot of suspense attached to it.

Originality- 5/10

The most unique things about this game are its added variety in gameplay compared with most other games in the genre, and of course, it’s a pretty well-conceived plot. But where it loses marks is through its bland conceptual design, which hampers the game quite a bit. At times, it reminded me very much of Hitman: Contracts, which is one of my least favorite video games of all time. I can appreciate that there were signs of the developers wanting to deliver something very unique for the time, and it worked well for quite a lot of people, but not for me.

Angrii

In summation, Second Sight could have been seen as a great game in scope if the developers had gotten the basics right, but sadly, that wasn’t the case. Though it has become a cult classic for many other gamers since its release, I had too hard a time trying to see its full appeal, and am unable to completely appreciate it.

Score

26/60

4/10 (Poor)

San Francisco Rush: Extreme Racing (PC, Arcade, Nintendo 64 & PlayStation)

San Francisco Rush Extreme Racing

Developer(s) – Atari Games, Midway Games & Climax

Publisher(s) – Atari Games & Midway Games

Designer – Ed Logg

ESRB – KA

Originally released as an arcade game back in 1996, San Francisco Rush was a generic racing game similar to the likes of Gran Turismo and Ridge Racer. That, especially at the time, could never measure up to the quality of the many kart racing games that had already been released. Although I do have to say, as a prerequisite, that I spent a fair bit of time playing this game when I was growing up, I look back at it now and think that it scarcely holds up.

Graphics – 5/10

The best thing I can say about the game’s visuals is that they were pretty advanced for the time, and a lot of the textural details that were incorporated were very well handled. The problem is that it is part of a genre that has borne witness to many shovelware titles. Ever since the days of the Atari, it has never been going to stand out among the others to any kind of extent. Not to mention that there are glitches galore. It may be pretty advanced for the time. But for the most part, extremely unpolished.

Gameplay – 3/10

The game consists of eight selectable vehicles and four selectable tracks, depending on the selected difficulty. And simply race across for either the best time or first position. Otherwise, there isn’t much else to it. Since it was originally designed as a pay-to-play arcade cabinet, there is a very limited number of options in terms of variety. And consequently, it turns out to be even worse on consoles. Disappointingly, the only other option available to players is the facility to change their car’s color.

Controls – 4/10

The main issue I have with the game’s control scheme is that turning corners, no matter how sharp or straight they may be, can feel like a chore for the most part. To make matters worse, certain turns were added to certain tracks that are almost impossible to try to traverse without crashing and having to reset the player’s own position.

Originality – 0/10

Not only does this game not stand out in terms of visuals, as I pointed out earlier. But there is actually considerably less variety in this game than there was even in other games of its kind around at the time. Later on, games such as Gran Turismo would be released, which would blow games like this out of the water. But, for the time being, it was either Mario Kart, which was infinitely more fun, or a generic racer. To me, nothing has really changed since then. Since I care very little for modern generic racers that are released even today, such as Forza or Driver. But for me, this game definitely began my distaste for the genre.

Furiious

To summarize, the biggest redeeming quality of San Francisco Rush is not in its gameplay or visuals. But in pretty funny music that plays whilst players register their high score. It’s the only element present that works to differentiate it from other generic racing games. And in all honesty, it was most probably the only thing keeping me at the table like a bad gambler when I was a kid.

Score

12/40

3/10 (Bad)

Ryse: Son of Rome (Xbox One & PC)

Ryse Son of Rome

Developer(s) – Crytek Frankfurt

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Studios

Director – Cavat Yerli

Producer – Vidanjor Niyazi

PEGI – 18

Originally released as a launch title for the Xbox One, Ryse: Son of Rome was designed to showcase what the Xbox One was capable of at the earliest stage of its shelf life; however, in the long term, the most interesting thing about this game has been the history behind its development and beyond. Phil Spencer of Microsoft claimed that it certainly wouldn’t be compatible with the Kinect peripheral, which could potentially throw many gamers for a loop. Since it was originally meant to be compatible.

But it defeated the object of bundling the console with the sensor, to begin with. After the development and release of the game, relations between Crytek and Microsoft soured. A dispute over the ownership of the Ryse IP would lead to the cancellation of a planned sequel. But I think this was for the best since I believe very little in the prospect of it turning into a prolific series of games. I thought very little of the game overall.

Graphics – 9/10

The best aspect of the title, as expected, or perhaps as intended, is the visuals. Looking better than most other Xbox 360 games on a technical level, it gave gamers an extremely good idea of the kind of graphics they could expect to see throughout the beginning of the eighth generation. And how they could be improved upon in the near future. The conceptual design is also fairly diverse. The game takes place in several different kinds of locations. As opposed to just taking place in the typical Roman coliseum or great cities, as most gamers would have initially expected.

Gameplay – 5/10

The gameplay, whilst easy enough to master after a time, unfortunately, becomes extremely repetitive extremely quickly. It relies heavily on combat. Mixing the mechanics of both God of War and Assassin’s Creed. Albeit presenting gamers with a much more linear experience than both of the aforementioned examples. There are only a few side quests to go back and do. Giving it a small bit of replay value. But like other launch titles of the time, like Knack, they offer little in the way of incentive for playing it again.

Controls – 10/10

Though the control scheme of this game was inspired by many other seventh-generation games and therefore lacks uniqueness in this respect, it does the things that it does more than well enough. And there are no unnecessary complications with it. The context-sensitive finishing moves that can be executed are actually a nice touch. Making combat somewhat interesting.

Lifespan – 2/10

Unforgivably, one playthrough of Ryse: Son of Rome can be made to last around 2 to 3 hours, which, for a game that had as big a budget as it did, and for a game that had at least a few side quests, is pathetic. The Xbox One’s announcement and launch periods seemed to me like a catalog of errors, and in hindsight, it’s no wonder that they failed to hit the ground running or catch up with the PlayStation 4 in terms of sales figures.

Storyline – 7/10

Though I don’t think it could be described as a saving grace, the game’s story isn’t too bad. It involves a Roman soldier named Marius Titus. As he works his way through the ranks of the Roman army. And along the way, he uncovers the truth behind the murder of his family. The story draws inspiration from both God of War and the film Gladiator, though, whilst there is a fair bit of depth to it, it falls very short of either one of those inspirations.

Originality – 0/10

To me, Ryse: Son of Rome follows too many pre-existing tropes used in video games countless times before it for me to call it unique. If Crytek truly wanted to create a franchise from this one game, then major adjustments would have had to be made. And every aspect drastically improved upon. There may be scope for them to do this if they decide to in the future. They could probably set it in an entirely different period in history. Or a bigger in-game world if they so desired. In any case, it wouldn’t take much effort to top the original.

Angrii

In summation, Ryse: Son of Rome is one of the weaker launch titles I have come across. The gameplay is bland, it lasts too short an amount of time, even for a linear AAA game, and it fails to stand out in the long term.

Score

33/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)