Pix the Cat (PlayStation 4, Xbox One & Switch)

Pix The Cat

Developer(s) – Pasta Games

PEGI – 3

Seemingly developed as a love letter to fans of the second-generation classic Pac-Man and the early mobile phone game Snake, Pix the Cat combines gameplay elements of both titles. It offers a gaming experience, unlike anything I’ve ever seen before. Although I found it to have its flaws, I ended up really enjoying this title for what it was. And how much fun there is to be had whilst playing.

Graphics – 6/10

The visuals in the game are loud and imposing, which for an arcade game is infinitely unusual. Although a similar style has been seen before in the championship edition of Pac-Man, Pix the Cat takes it to a whole new level. The exaggerated perpetuation of early second-generation titles relied on a wide array of colors to stand out. Making Pix the Cat look captivating.

But that being said, I feel that there is a danger of the visual style coming across as too distracting. And deviating players away from the gameplay. Another con is that the stage layout can be confusing at times. The objective of the game involves entering stages from stages. They appear smaller on the current stage being played on, making them difficult to spot at times. Though some would argue that this is part of the game’s level of challenge, I see it as an unnecessary complication.

Gameplay – 6/10

However, regardless of unnecessary complications, the game is still pretty addictive and enjoyable to play. It revolves around the player character collecting several eggs on the screen, which hatch into ducks. And bringing them to several circles, often found on the other side of the screen, until all the eggs are brought to all the circles. Thus allowing the player to advance to the next screen until the timer runs out.

Players can maintain a combo chain by consistently collecting all the eggs on the screen. And taking them to all the circles on the screen in single fell swoops without going back and collecting eggs twice in a single screen. But the gameplay mechanics are nowhere near as complicated as I’m perhaps making them out to be. Pix the Cat represents the epitome of gaming simplicity, synonymous with the generations it has been inspired by.

The problem I personally found with the gameplay was that I felt the compulsion to try to maintain combos for the entire time limit. Whenever I accidentally broke my combo, I felt the need to start again. Which in turn, eliminated any sense of fluency within the game. But I wouldn’t count that as being too much of a bad element. It’s simply an easy game to learn, but hard to master.

Controls – 9/10

In the beginning, I did find the controls to be a little bit stiff, but otherwise, there are no problems. Since this game represents the epitome of gaming simplicity, this is also reflected in the game’s control scheme, which is by no means a bad thing. Many games have come and gone. And have incorporated control schemes designed to be innovative. But have ended up coming up with a whole new series of complications, so I never tend to slate a game that purposefully doesn’t try to be innovative with its control scheme.

Lifespan – 10/10

As an obvious throwback to 70s arcade titles, such as Asteroids and Pac-Man, replay value. In turn, the game’s lifespan only lasts as long as an individual player’s interest in the game, which I can guarantee will be a particularly long time. There are several game modes to keep things interesting. But the game follows the age-old formula of players simply trying to reach a high score as its main objective. And again, there’s nothing wrong with that. Provided the game is satisfying and engrossing enough, which in this case, it is.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

The game’s basic premise simply revolves around the titular character hatching duck eggs and taking them in circles. In lieu of arcade game tradition, Pix the Cat is extremely light on story. And in my opinion, shouldn’t lose marks for not having that, which it doesn’t need. Though it may be viewed as a nice touch for an arcade game in this day and age to include some form of narrative, I think there was too much of a high risk of adding a story to the first installment of a game that already includes so many outlandish elements. And it may have ruined the overall gaming experience. But thankfully, this title has been kept simple enough for this problem not to occur.

Originality – 7/10

Though this title clearly has its influences, like many indie titles I’ve reviewed this year, both gameplay concepts have been handled nicely, and the result is something fairly unique. Gameplay elements of second-generation titles were inherently similar to one another, but the best ones, such as Dig Dug and Yars’ Revenge, always had certain characteristics and properties that made them stand out, and this is no exception.

Happii

Overall, though flawed, Pix the Cat is still a particularly enjoyable game to play, and I would recommend it to anybody wishing to experience gaming simplicity or to players seeking to experience a sense of nostalgia within the current generation. It gives testament to the fact that although this style of play may be yesterday’s news in terms of mainstream gaming, it does have its loyal fan base, and it’s not been completely fazed out within the industry.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Pikmin (GameCube & Wii)

Pikmin

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Shigefumi Hino & Masamichi Abe

Producer – Shigeru Miyamoto

PEGI – 3

Released as a launch title for the GameCube, heavily based on the Super Mario 128 tech demo showcased shortly before the launch of the console, Pikmin is the only first-party Nintendo series falling under the genre of real-time strategy and introduced an entirely new mythos, cast of characters, and basic gameplay premise. It would turn out to be yet another successful series for Nintendo and develop a pretty loyal fan base, and I think the developers did a fairly good job of introducing gamers to the series with the first installment.

Graphics – 9/10

On a technical level, this game is nothing short of brilliant. It was inspired by the aforementioned early tech demo, which displayed 128 Mario sprites running around and performing various actions. Several separate character sprites with AI were not possible on the Nintendo 64 and were, at the time, considered a huge deal and a major technical breakthrough in gaming. But aside from that, there is also some extremely interesting conceptual design in the form of not only the Pikmin themselves but also in the form of the various different environments and enemies, hints of which would also find their way into other GameCube games, such as Wario World.

Gameplay – 6/10

The concept of the game’s play was extremely well thought out and is particularly enjoyable to indulge in, as well as satisfying to be able to excel in. The reason I have issues with it is very much the same issues I had with Majora’s Mask. The time limit. Each in-game day equates to about half an hour. Gamers have 30 days to collect as much as possible. This can make gamers feel like they are being needlessly rushed, in my opinion. With a world this big and full of things to do, it’s better if players are given the option to take their time to enjoy every ounce of it. And complete as much as possible, and I think Nintendo realized that whilst making the sequels.

Controls – 10/10

Whilst there aren’t really any technical issues with the game’s control scheme, at the time, it was also astonishing to think that so many different characters containing such textural details could all be controlled and moved around at the same time in the fashion that is presented. To me, it was amazing enough that the same could be accomplished in a conventional real-time strategy game on PC. But at the time, this game seemed to take that idea to a whole new level.

Lifespan – 6/10

Taking the time limits into consideration, it is fairly impressive that this game can be made to last for almost 20 hours. And consequently, I don’t think the game should lose many marks in this category. But as the sequels would highlight, there was potential to make a game like this last considerably longer. And so in this respect, the first game can be seen as a question of trial and error.

Storyline – 8/10

Of course, with a new mythology and set of characters came a new story premise from Nintendo. And they certainly didn’t disappoint. The narrative follows a space-faring extraterrestrial named Captain Olimar. He crash-lands on a mysterious planet after a meteorite hits his ship. He realizes the planet has high levels of oxygen. A gas deadly to his species. He will die within the next 30 days if he can’t find a way to repair his ship and escape the planet.

To do this, he employs the help of the Pikmin. The planet’s strange native species that Olimar must use to gather parts of his ship and protect himself from other hostile wildlife. What I like about the plot is that it seems to be slightly darker than most other Nintendo games, having a fairly morbid premise. And pushing the boundaries of what they were able to get away with on a 3+ rating. And behind a colorful and vibrant visual style.

Originality –10/10

Of course, Pikmin wasn’t the first real-time strategy developed, nor the last. But the fact of the matter remains that there is no other game of its kind like it. Differentiating from not only every other series of real-time strategy series but from every other video game in general. The only video games even remotely like Pikmin are Overlord and Overlord II. And whilst they both have their own unusual traits, they aren’t even anywhere near as wonderfully unusual as in the games they drew inspiration from.

Happii

To summarize, whilst the formula would be improved with the arrival of both the second and third games, Pikmin was nonetheless an extremely enjoyable launch title and was a strong title for Nintendo to start the sixth generation with. Alongside Luigi’s Mansion and Super Smash Bros Melee. I’ve played many real-time strategy games throughout the years, but those in the Pikmin series stand out among the best in my opinion.

Score

49/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Perfect Dark Zero (Xbox 360)

Perfect Dark Zero

Developer(s) – Rare Ltd

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Game Studios

Director – Chris Tilston

Producer(s) – Richard Cousins, Lee Schuneman & Chris Kimmel

PEGI – 16

Released as a launch title for the Xbox 360 in 2005, following Microsoft’s purchase of Rare from Nintendo as a second-party developer back in 2003, Perfect Dark Zero, like Kameo: Elements of Power, was originally intended to be a GameCube game. But instead released on the Xbox 360. Garnishing critical acclaim and generating profits equivalent to four times its development costs. After playing this game myself, I see very little special about it, especially compared to the original Nintendo 64 game. It was one of two games I played on the Xbox 360. This made me think that the console’s early years were questionable until the release of The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion. The other is King Kong.

Graphics – 7/10

For the most part, the visuals did a good enough job of showing what the Xbox 360 was capable of displaying in terms of graphical quality compared to sixth-generation visuals. The conceptual design isn’t too bad either. It features elements both new to the series. And elements reminiscent of the original game, such as level layouts and modes of transportation. The biggest problem I have with them, however, is that the developers seemingly abandoned the dark and gritty tone set by the original game, which I prefer greatly. And which I believe better fits into the basic premise of the series.

Gameplay – 5/10

In my opinion, the game plays out more or less like any other average first-person shooter that has been seen before. It didn’t help matters that at this point, the concept of spy-based first-person shooters had been thoroughly milked ever since the release of Rare’s own Goldeneye 007 for the Nintendo 64. One thing I would advise players looking to check this game out, however, is that they turn off the arrows that generate on the floor to let them know where it is they need to go. After a while, this feature can make the player feel like the game is holding their hand constantly. And it can make the entire experience pretty boorish and straightforward by proxy.

Controls – 10/10

Though it should rightfully have been expected that there wouldn’t be a problem with the controls. First-person shooting games had been at this point long embedded into the gaming mainstream. And seemingly never to budge, the developers also did quite a decent job of implementing third-person elements. Such as hiding behind walls to take cover. This feature would be perfected in future games such as Deus Ex: Human Revolution. But it’s interesting to see where it stemmed from.

Lifespan – 6/10

On average, this game can take around 6 to 7 hours to complete, which is the average lifespan of a linear first-person shooter; consequently, it isn’t anything special. In all my time playing video games, I’ve never been able to come across a true open-world spy-based first-person shooter. Looking at the industry now, to me, at least doesn’t seem like a bad idea. The only thing coming close to this from what I’ve played is Deus Ex: Human Revolution. I can hope that Deus Ex: Mankind Divided can provide the experience I have in mind when I think of this, but for the most part, I think the industry may have missed a trick.

Storyline – 5/10

Set as a prequel to the original game, it portrays Joanna Dark in a much more unrefined form, in her constant battle with the maniacal corporation DataDyne. My gripe with the game’s visuals can also be applied to the game’s story, too. It has a much less dark and morbid feel to it, and consequently, I had a harder time trying to take it seriously. The voice acting doesn’t help either, since it is, by and large, quite cheesy and not very well thought out.

Originality – 2/10

Aside from there being third-person mechanics, the game plays out much worse than the original Perfect Dark, in my opinion, since it doesn’t allow players the time to work out where they need to go and what it is they need to do. There’s much less to this game than both the original and almost every other game made of the same ilk. The market would later become saturated with much better shooting games, which would later render early games like this becoming no more than a footnote, since there is very little present to make it stand out among an ever-growing crowd.

Niiutral

In summation, Perfect Dark Zero is most definitely one of the most lackluster launch titles I’ve ever played. Though the original PlayStation had a considerably shakier start, there was definitely a drop in launch title standards with the seventh generation of games, except the Wii’s launch, and this game gives testament to that.

Score

35/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

PaRappa the Rapper 2 (PlayStation 2)

PaRappa The Rapper 2

Developer(s) – NanaOn-Sha

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Masaya Matsuura

Artist – Rodney Greenblat

PEGI – 7

Receiving largely mixed reviews upon release, in stark contrast to the first game, PaRappa the Rapper 2 is a slightly longer and even more embarrassing game. Adding only a few new features and nothing else. Whilst I reviewed the first PaRappa the Rapper, I said that things got worse, and I wasn’t kidding.

Graphics – 3/10

Once again designed around the artistic style pioneered by American artist Rodney Greenblat, the sequel uses the same kind of 2D characters and colorful 3D environments. Only this time, since this was a relatively early PlayStation 2 title, the graphics are fairly outdated. In fact, I’d go so far as to say the game actually looks like it could run on Nintendo 64 hardware. A lot of the cutscenes portraying wide-open spaces seem to corroborate this, too.

Gameplay – 0/10

The gameplay remains largely the same as in the first title and is just as unbearable. The only new aspect added is that of a few mini-games in between some of the main eight levels. And warm-up phases before each one. But none of these things can be considered a saving grace in my opinion. I’ve always thought rhythm games to be among some of my least favorite gaming genres. And since there’s nothing here to suggest that this game does anything significantly different, it does little to change my perception.

Controls – 10/10

Although there are no issues with the controls, it wasn’t a significant challenge to get them right in the first game. And there’s nothing to suggest that they should have faced any kind of hardship whilst developing the sequel either. There’s nothing innovative, exciting, or different about it compared to other games. And whilst the lack of errors is the best thing I can point out about this game, I would have expected nothing else. Lest there be even bigger problems.

Lifespan – 1/10

Clocking up at about one hour and twenty minutes, the second game is about twice as long as the first. But still, an abysmal amount of time for even an early sixth-generation game to last. RPGs had already entered the mainstream by this time, and 3D adventure games could be made to last significantly longer than they ever had before. A game like this would pale in comparison, and nine times out of ten, it still does.

Storyline – 0/10

Following on from the first game, Parappa goes to a burger shop with his friend to find that food everywhere is mysteriously transforming into noodles. He investigates further, along with a group of allies, to find that the son of a famous burger shop owner is behind it and plots to have noodles take over the world. I’ve spoiled the ending for anyone reading, but I doubt anyone in their right mind would care.

Originality – 4/10

When I reviewed the first game last year, just after the E3 conference, I said that I would almost rather not have seen the rhythm gaming genre perpetuated at all. Even if PaRappa was effectively the game that started it all. But given the fact that no significantly exciting new features have been added in the sequel, I’d say it has even less basis in originality than the first.

Furiious

Overall, PaRappa the Rapper 2 is worse than the first game by some distance and is, in my opinion, one of the worst games ever developed for the PlayStation 2. With talk of a third game possibly coming to PlayStation 4 following PaRappa’s appearance in PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale, I can only hope it is released as a 3D platformer or something. And not another lackluster rhythm game.

Score

18/60

3/10 (Bad)

PaRappa the Rapper (PlayStation & PlayStation Portable)

PaRappa The Rapper

Developer(s) – NanaOn-Sha

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Designer – Mayasa Matsuura

PEGI – 3

Credited as the first true rhythm game as a precursor to the 1978 game Simon, PaRappa the Rapper went on to become the 7th best-selling game of 1997 and garnered many positive reviews from critics, as well as two gaming awards and net sales of 1.4 million units worldwide. But even at the time, I was less than impressed by the game, and have never been able to understand the appeal behind it.

Graphics – 5/10

One of the main talking points of the game is the unusual art direction. This was implemented to visually realize the game. Inspired by American graphic artist Rodney Greenblat, it features 2D characters in a 3D environment. Hats off to the developers for trying something that was very new at the time, but the general design of the game was about the only original thing the game had going for it in terms of graphics. The character designs are particularly poor, and by that token, the overall visual style of the game can only be appreciated for so long, the way I see it.

Gameplay – 0/10

PaRappa the Rapper may have begun the entire rhythm game genre, but it has always been, and most probably always will be, an extremely bad genre of video games. To me, the only thing that the rhythm games have been good for is influencing the idea of including context-sensitive gameplay in certain games. Such as God of War or Dante’s Inferno. But as a standalone genre, I don’t think it’s worth anybody’s time.

Controls – 10/10

There are no issues with the game’s control scheme, at least, but how hard could it have been to implement? Compared to adventure games, RPGs, and so forth, I fail to see how there could have been much thought and effort put into how players play the game.

Lifespan – 0.5/10

Even for players unfamiliar with the rhythm game genre, this game will take about 40 minutes to complete, which is utterly pathetic. By that token alone, the developers can’t justify charging full price at a time when there were many more and greater games out by then.

Storyline – 0/10

When I first played PaRappa the Rapper as a kid, I thought the story seemed as ridiculous as the gameplay and decided not to touch it again after the first level. After watching how the rest of the game’s story plays out, I discovered I wasn’t missing anything. The best thing I can say about the game’s story and the titular character is that they promote self-confidence. PaRappa lives by his motto of “I gotta believe”, and it helps him to attain his goals throughout the game. But other than this one flicker of positivity, there’s not much else I can praise the game’s story for. The voice acting, as well as the basic premise, is laughable at best.

Originality – 5/10

Although Parappa the Rapper perpetuated an original idea, which led to an entire genre, I personally would rather not have seen it happen at all. Developers had put much more thought into their games than the developers of PaRappa the Rapper clearly did, and because of that, it’s clear to see why many rhythm game series have been discontinued since, such as Space Channel 5, Guitar Hero, and Rock Band.

Angrii

In summation, Parappa the Rapper is an awful, wretched game that to me should never have seen the light of day. A sequel followed, which is even worse in my opinion, and there are rumors of a third game in the works. In which case, count me out.

Score

20.5/60

3/10 (Bad)

Papo & Yo (PC & PlayStation 3)

Papo & Yo

Developer(s) – Minority

Publisher(s) – Minority

Designer – Vander Caballero

PEGI – 12

Papo & Yo is an adventure game similar to how The Last Guardian plays out. However, due to a great number of factors and problems plaguing this title, I would hardly call this game a placeholder.

Graphics – 6/10

The best thing I can say about the game’s visuals is that the atmosphere varies greatly from place to place. Keeping the overall feel of the game either intense or calm, according to which areas the player is progressing through. Apart from that, however, the game’s visual design is conceptually weak as well as graphically questionable. It contains some noticeable glitches throughout, as well as inconsistent textural design. Particularly concerning the character Monster.

Gameplay – 5/10

The objective of Papo & Yo is pretty straightforward. Navigate through a linear progression, solving puzzles and guiding a huge monster for the most part. The puzzle-solving element is fairly elaborate, but I was particularly disappointed to find how just how linear the game is. I thought that with the multiple paths there are to take, to begin with, there would have been much more to find than there is. But the only thing to do aside from the story progression is to find each Easter egg of a teddy bear tied to a plank of wood. Some of them can be pretty hard to find. But the side quest offers extremely little in the way of replay value.

Controls – 8/10

Even though this gaming formula has been done many times before. A lot more has been done in previous games in the genre than in this; the controls feel quite stiff. And sometimes, even platform detection can be inconsistent. Otherwise, there are no other problems. It is quite clever how the tutorial system is handled. In the form of cardboard boxes that can be found throughout the course of the game, explaining the control scheme to players.

Lifespan – 1/10

Clocking in at merely 2 hours tops, a 3D platformer with this short lifespan is utterly unforgivable in my opinion. Especially when there was so much room to add so much more depth in gameplay than what there turned out to be. This game, to me, like Banjo-Kazooie, may be a sign of the direction the industry is going. However, I think following a trend like this would have an extremely negative impact. The fact is that this came from the indie movement. Whereas many games have more depth in gameplay than even mainstream releases, this is also a cause for concern.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of the game is by far the best aspect of it. This is why I believe it may prove to be a negative sign of the times. It follows a young boy named Quico, who, whilst suffering the latest tirade from his dysfunctional father, suddenly finds himself in a strange world where he must guide a monster around in order to solve various puzzles throughout. The game’s director, Vander Caballero, based the story on his childhood, whereby he, unfortunately, suffered continuous abuse from his own father, and through the game’s story, players will be able to sense the full force of his conviction throughout, at least making the game memorable for its pretty immersive narrative.

Originality – 5/10

Taking into account how well the game’s story differentiates it from other games, it still leaves a great deal to be desired in terms of gameplay, in my opinion, as well as visual presentation. There’s no reason to suggest why the game’s core concept couldn’t be built upon in the development of a spiritual successor, but the original game, unfortunately, does little to stand out among some of the better 3D platformers released throughout the years.

Angrii

To summarize, Papo & Yo, despite its decent story, is a particularly flawed game and could’ve done with a lot more added to make it much more of an immersive gaming experience. It may be argued that a smaller budget may result in a smaller game, but there have already been a plethora of indie developers who have proved that wrong, and that the only limits are within the developer’s imagination.

Score

32/60

5/10 (Far Below Average)

Papers Please (PC & PlayStation Vita)

Papers Please

Designer – Lucas Pope

PEGI – 16

Described by its creator, Lucas Pope, as a dystopian document thriller, Papers Please puts players in an unlikely situation for a video game. As an agent of a passport office in a dystopian society. It’s one of these ideas for a video game that I take a personal interest in. Those that may sound ridiculous and tedious on paper. But once put on a computer can make for something, particularly special.

Graphics – 7/10

Though the visuals may not be cutting-edge, it’s in their conceptual design that it truly stands out from a ton of different video games in general. Let alone indie games. The color palette of the setting is very morbid and colorless, which, to me, adds to the overall atmosphere and despair associated with an unfair society that the game is trying to perpetuate. It looks like something straight out of a newspaper. This also emphasizes its political aspect.

Gameplay – 8/10

The objective of Papers Please is to process as many people into the country of Arstotzka as possible before the time runs out. People’s passports and other documentation must be checked to ensure it is valid and up to date. Any discrepancies can be inspected to ensure that the citizen in question is clear to enter the country. And if their discrepancy cannot be cleared up, they can then either be denied entry. Or even detained, depending on whether they may be on a wanted criminals list. Or in possession of weapons or contraband. For a concept based on what would in real life likely be an extremely repetitive job, it’s surprising how much suspense can be felt whilst playing.

Controls – 10/10

Since this is essentially a simulator game, the control scheme should never have come into question. Since there have been countless games like it released beforehand. And so it doesn’t. The game depends solely on the pressing of icons using a mouse, very much like on a PC itself. So consequently, there are absolutely no issues with the game’s controls.

Originality – 7/10

Papers Please deserves acclaim for being an independently developed video game, and yet, being able to stand out to the extent that it does among every other simulator game ever developed by some of the most familiar developers in gaming. People may have thought that Goat Simulator was unique, but Papers, Please offers players much more entertainment in a much more unlikely scenario.

Happii

In summation, Papers Please is one of the best independently developed games I’ve found on Steam so far, and a game I would highly recommend. It may look morbid and monotonous at first glance, but beneath the surface lies an extremely entertaining game.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Pandemonium (PlayStation)

Pandemonium

Developer(s) – Toys for Bob, Crystal Dynamics, Ideaworks 3D & Eidos Interactive

Publisher(s) – EA, Crystal Dynamics & Eidos Interactive

ESLPA – 3+

One of the earliest examples of a 2.5D platforming game, and released as a launch title for the original PlayStation, Pandemonium served as a breath of fresh air among a great deal of 3D platformers released early on in the PlayStation’s shelf life that, to say the least, left a lot to be desired. I personally found it to be a pretty enjoyable game. At the time, it was as good and as creative as most other concepts for video games. And I fail to understand why it wasn’t built upon any further than it was.

Graphics – 8/10

The visuals did an extremely good job of showcasing what the original PlayStation was capable of on a graphical level. It even has considerably fewer glitches than many other early PlayStation platformers. Such as Croc or Bubsy 3D. The game also excels on a conceptual level. Featuring several extremely unique level designs and several unusually fascinating objects appearing in-game, such as huge watermelons used for making high jumps.

Gameplay – 7/10

As well as being one of the first games of its kind, it also has a fair bit of variety in gameplay attached to it, in the form of being able to play as either one of the two different characters intermittently, who have different abilities. The female character Nikki can double-jump, whilst the male character Fargus can cast spells and perform a rolling attack, similar to Crash Bandicoot’s spin attack. The gripe I have about it, however, is that instead of using the then-new feature of saving via memory card, the developers instead utilized password saves, which by this time had more or less gone out of fashion. To me, it severely defeats the object of taking video games into the next generation and can become quite a hindrance at times.

Controls – 9/10

Unlike many early PlayStation games, only a few issues arise concerning the control scheme. Because the perspective and camera angles are much different from those of the conventional side-scrolling game, it can be a small annoyance to navigate through different passageways and make certain turns. Otherwise, however, there are no further complications, and handled fairly well for what was clearly a question of trial and error.

Lifespan – 6/10

Although this game is fairly short, it shouldn’t lose out on too many marks, since the industry was just undergoing the transition between the fourth and fifth generations of gaming, and 3 to 4 hours was about the average lifespan of a game back then. The bar would be raised much higher within this particular genre upon the release of Castlevania: Symphony of the Night. But for a game to last this short was by no means unforgivable.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of Pandemonium follows the adventures (or rather misadventures) of two friends called Fargus and Nikki, who, whilst experimenting with various magic spells, manage to unwittingly cast a more advanced spell, which summons a huge monster called Yungo, who completely swallows a nearby village whole. After consulting the book, the duo learns that they must travel across the land.

And obtain a wish from a machine called the Wishing Engine to reverse the damage they have done. Aside from the fact that the two main characters are a pair of idiots, it’s as wacky and weird as most other storylines in games were at the time, and shouldn’t lose out on too many points, since not only was there a great deal of emphasis on the story at the time anyway but on a creative level, the fifth generation of gaming was an extremely strange time for the medium anyway.

Originality – 8/10

As well as containing some wonderfully strange aspects, like the in-game items, enemies, and even the overall concept, Pandemonium was also instrumental in establishing a new sub-genre of gaming, which has, in recent years, made quite the resurgence and been adopted by many different developers, including Nintendo. Games like Trine, New Super Mario Bros, and Limbo have taken the industry by storm, and it was games like this, as well as NiGHTS, that served as the basis for it all.

Happii

Overall, Pandemonium exceeded my expectations when I got around to playing it. On the surface, it looks like a bog-standard launch title, but it turned out to be one of the best for the PlayStation, in my personal opinion.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Outlast (PC & PlayStation 4)

Outlast

Developer(s) – Red Barrels

Publisher(s) – Red Barrels

Project Manager – Paul-Andre Renaud

Producer – Louis St Denis

PEGI – 18

Originally released last year as a digital download for Steam, Outlast found its way onto PlayStation 4. But whilst I think it definitely will provide a very stern test for veteran survival horror fans, for me personally, it did little but to re-emphasize the ongoing reservation I have with survival horror games. The focus seems to be mostly on merely making the game as scary as possible and deviating far too much from gameplay. This is the most important aspect of any game. But in terms of scaring people, this game certainly doesn’t disappoint.

Graphics – 9/10

For an indie game, it is very well polished, and the attention to detail in the environments and scenery certainly makes this game stand out from a graphical point of view, at least. But the fact that this game is so well-presented could also be disturbing to others. The gritty and horrific atmosphere is depicted throughout the course of the game through the presence of disemboweled corpses and pools of blood along the floors and walls. The surviving inmates around Mount Massive Asylum, where the game is set, also make for some particularly unnerving sights. Along with some of the game’s primary antagonists, such as Dr. Trager and Chris Walker. But even before I entered the asylum at the start of the game, the atmosphere was still extremely frightening. As the game begins on a windy night, illuminated by a murky-looking sunset.

Gameplay – 4/10

As much as I enjoyed this game’s atmosphere and horrific settings, the gameplay certainly left a lot to be desired. Even for survival horror. The objective of this game is to simply run and hide, whilst exploring the asylum. Often using a night vision camcorder. That’s it. There’s no way in which players can defend themselves at all, as with virtually every other game in the genre.

Whenever enemies come into proximity, players have no choice but to either run or hide from them. Which, whilst unique in its own way, makes this game seem like less of a game and more of a film. To me, it’s not engaging enough to be able to be called a true video game. Apart from this, there’s merely one side quest, involving the collection of documents scattered across the asylum. Unfortunately, the game’s play is original, but in a very negative way.

Controls – 10/10

A first-person survival horror, there are absolutely no problems with the controls at all. A nice touch that the developers added was the door-opening mechanics that involve slowly opening them. It increases or maintains the constant feeling of tension, which is present throughout the entirety of the game.

Lifespan – 2/10

This game will take no more than five hours to finish, as there is hardly anything to do in it. Again, I find this is particularly bad, even for a survival horror title. In other games of the genre, there is a bit more replay value to be had. As some of them include alternative endings. But there isn’t anything like that in Outlast, unfortunately. It’s also particularly annoying given the size of the in-game world. And what could’ve potentially been added to the gameplay in a bid to make it last longer?

Storyline – 7/10

If this game really had to play out as much like a film as it does, then it was imperative that it at least had a decent story, and the story isn’t too bad to be fair. It tells of a freelance journalist named Miles Upshur, who is tipped off by an anonymous source about events happening at Mount Massive Asylum. He decides to go and investigate, but unfortunately, he ends up finding more than what he’d bargained for and immediately resolves to escape with his life. As far as survival horror stories go, whilst pretty typical, it is particularly scary.

The majority of the scares in this game come not from either the copious amount of jump scares or buckets of blood, but from the constant feeling of tension, which has been a device used not only in video games before it but in top-notch horror films as well as classic literature. I also like the element of players having to discover the back story of Mount Massive Asylum for themselves through the documentation found throughout the game. But the game’s story loses marks for its lack of uniqueness. I mean, how many games or films before it depicted people traveling to reportedly dangerous places and subsequently found more than they would’ve liked?

Originality – 4/10

In addition to the game’s overall story probably sounding very familiar to fans of horror in general, the uniqueness found in the game’s play also has an extremely negative impact. I think the only thing this game would probably be good for is testing horror fans’ limits, as it is at least an incredibly scary experience.

Niiutral

To summarize, all Outlast did for me was perpetuate my constant concern that most games in this particular genre focus too much on scaring people and take focus away from what truly matters: the gameplay. Whilst it does have very decent visuals and a story worthy of the fan’s attention, it doesn’t take long for Outlast to outlast its appeal, in my opinion.

Score

37/60

6/10 (Average)

Operation WinBack (Nintendo 64 & PlayStation 2)

Operation Winback

Developer(s) – Omega Force

Publisher(s) – Koei

ELSPA – 11+

Operation WinBack, or WinBack: Covert Operations, as it was known in America, was a late Nintendo 64 title. And an early PlayStation 2 title, ported to the following generation console. Most likely due to the unprecedented amount of critical acclaim it received at the time. I do have to say, as a prerequisite, that I spent a lot of time playing this game during the early years of the PlayStation 2’s shelf life. But as fairly good as it still is, and how influential it would later prove to be, I don’t think it entirely holds up to this day.

Graphics – 6/10

The best thing I can point out about this game’s visuals is how good it looked from a graphical standpoint at the time. On both the Nintendo 64 and PlayStation 2. It looked far better than most other games of its kind on the original PlayStation. And then its subsequent PlayStation 2 port did a pretty good job of showcasing what the console was capable of in its early stages. However, what I can’t wax poetic about is the conceptual design. It looks pretty generic. It was heavily influenced by the original Metal Gear Solid game. And I think the resemblances are plain to see.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

One of the better third-person shooters released at the dawn of the genre, WinBack’s cover system was revolutionary. And made playing the game that much easier to cope with than other future releases, such as Second Sight. Although the running and gunning aspect of this game is fairly addictive, there’s not much else the game has to offer in terms of gameplay. No side quests or collectible items throughout. The only objective is to play through as fast as possible to get the best ending. The fact that the players are encouraged to rush through the game is very foreboding in itself.

Controls – 9.5/10

The movement mechanics are a little bit stiff, but otherwise, there are no problems. It’s actually quite interesting to see how well the developers handled this early attempt at a third-person shooter compared with many other future releases. Not only was the cover system revolutionary. But the manual aiming system that players could use would go on to influence a variety of different games. Though the original Metal Gear Solid influenced the visual style of WinBack, there were these gameplay mechanics that would go on to in turn influence the development of Metal Gear Solid 2.

Lifespan – 4/10

When rushed through, the game can take about 5 hours to finish. Considering this is a game influenced by the original Metal Gear Solid, it is unacceptable. It was bad enough finding out that there was no way in which to save the other members of the S.C.A.T team (indeed, that’s what I thought the purpose of having their stats on the pause menu might have been for. Though in reality, it has no bearing on the gameplay at all, which makes me question the reason for having them there in the first place. But the fact that there are no other activities in the game other than to run and gun when there could have easily been something else added to it, is very disappointing in my opinion.

Storyline – 5/10

The narrative follows the main character, Jean-Luc Cougar, and the S.C.A.T team during their efforts to take back a powerful government weapon. From a terrorist group called the Crying Lions. Not only is the plot extremely influenced by and reminiscent of the first Metal Gear Solid. But the voice acting is also extremely below-par. There was the use of spoken dialogue in the Nintendo 64 version. Which, in hindsight, is preferable to having to listen to the half-hearted efforts of the voice actors in the PlayStation 2 version.

Originality – 7/10

Despite the fact that there isn’t a great deal of originality in terms of the overall gameplay formula. This will leave players thinking that so much more could have been added to give them a lot more to play for throughout. The fact of the matter remains that the control scheme not only went on to influence Metal Gear Solid. But also some of the more successful future titles in the third-person shooting genre. Such as Kill Switch, Second Sight, and Gears of War. The fact that this game served as an early prototype for some of the most successful game series in history. As well as being a prototype for many other games in the early stages of the genre, it makes it stand out a fair bit.

Niiutral

Overall, Operation WinBack’s running and gunning mechanics can be fairly addictive for how short the game lasts. But I do think the game is wanting in content. I can’t help but feel that with either better voice actors or no voice actors at all. As well as a good few side quests are thrown in for good measure, this game could have stood out even more among early PlayStation 2 titles than it ended up doing. But sadly, this wasn’t the case.

Score

37/60

6/10 (Average)