Punch-Out!! (Arcade)

Punch-Out

Developer(s) – Nintendo IRD & Nintendo R&D1

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Producer – Genyo Takeda

ESRB – E10+

The original Punch-Out was one of the first franchises established by Nintendo, even before the release of Super Mario, and was met with positive reviews worldwide after its international release in 1984. The project was worked on by many now-famous Nintendo employees, such as Genyo Takeda and Shigeru Miyamoto, and is notable for being the first Nintendo game to have the soundtrack composed by the esteemed Koji Kondo, who would go on to compose some of Nintendo’s most familiar musical scores. To me, it is one of the most memorable arcade games of the 1980s, and I’m glad Nintendo chose to build upon the franchise over many of the others they had even back then.

Graphics – 6/10

The visuals have a fair bit of graphical detail for the time, and I’ve always been wise to how intelligent a move it was on Nintendo’s part to represent the playable character as a wireframe to get around many technical limitations of the time. The biggest problem that many people have had with this game, however, is the fact that almost every character is either hopelessly generic or an overblown racial stereotype, even though it was Shigeru Miyamoto who designed them. For example, there’s an Italian boxer named Pizza Pasta, and a wimpy French boxer named Glass Joe. Though personality would come into play more as the series progressed, despite the fact that racist caricatures of the characters would become even more pronounced, it all started quite primitively, especially since this was only an arcade game.

Gameplay – 7/10

The way the game plays out is actually particularly interesting. The player would use the bottom screen to fight, and the top screen would portray the stats and character portraits of the fighters. It also worked well as it was ported to the Game & Watch, and is also in turn seen as a precursor to the idea of the DS, interestingly enough. It also becomes a lot more challenging as it progresses, but the difficulty does mercifully come down after beating the game thrice, so it’s not too inaccessible.

Controls – 10/10

The general control scheme of Punch-Out is rather simple, and getting to grips with it will be self-explanatory for any gamer of today looking to try it out. The direct sequel would introduce some particularly strange mechanics, but still, players can pretty much jump from the first to the second without missing a beat. It was that straightforward, even back then.

Originality – 9/10

Though at the time the game seemed particularly simple in scope, it would go on to become instrumental in inspiring many of Nintendo’s future works, and consequently, this game is actually a very important piece of gaming history. Not only that, but it would also go on to inspire the creation of the licensed boxing video game sub-genre, especially as Mike Tyson lent his own name and likeness to a later installment of the series for the original Nintendo Entertainment System.

Happii

Overall, Punch-Out is a much more important game than most people probably realize. It would go on to serve as inspiration for a plethora of games and even consoles, and at the same time, managed to entertain a lot of people in the process, and is essential for any fan of retro gaming.

Score

33/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Psychonauts (PlayStation 2, Xbox & PC)

Psychonauts

Developer(s) – Majesco Entertainment & Budcat Creations (PS2)

Publisher(s) – THQ & Majesco Entertainment

Designer – Tim Schafer

Producer – Michael Tatro

PEGI – 12

Released fairly late in the sixth generation of gaming, in North America in mid-2005 and in Europe in early 2006, it garnered critical admiration. Earning several awards. But it was sorrowfully met with commercial failure. It’s a shame because all the favorable reviews of it ring true. It is highly enjoyable to play, it’s funny, it has an amazing story, and its level of uniqueness is extraordinary. It’s not often enough that games like Psychonauts come along. And given all these great qualities the game has, it’s not hard to see why it has since achieved cult status among gamers. Tim Schafer’s games have been unfairly ignored. And Psychonauts is no exception.

Graphics – 9/10

This is a game set not in huge castles, underground tunnels, or wide-open cities. But primarily inside the characters’ minds. That, in itself, is fascinating and insanely unique. Each level set in people’s heads is appropriately tailored to match the character’s demeanor and psychological profile. For example, the character Sasha Nein is intelligent and organized and therefore has a level inside his mind, which is very neat, but also complex in a way. It’s that level of uniqueness that makes this game what it is. Not many games can boast something like that.

The visuals, in general, have also seemingly aged pretty well after 8 years. In particular, the main character’s facial expressions seemed pretty advanced for the time. It is still a standout graphic feature to this day. But although the Main character, Razputin “Raz” Aquato, is considered one of the greatest heroes in gaming history, there’s no doubt in my mind that the human psyche is the star of the show. It makes up the settings of the game, and it’s the basis of the story. Some of the enemies in the game also amuse me quite a lot, too; namely, the Censors. Enemies try to flush out thoughts in the mind that don’t belong and attack the player. All the while saying “no” in amusing tones of voice.

Gameplay – 7/10

The gameplay is particularly satisfying overall. It’s really fun to discover the various psychic abilities that can be learned throughout the game. Including telekinesis, pyrokinesis, clairvoyance, levitation, and invisibility. It gives the game a very decent level of variety. But for how big and open this game is, I can’t help but feel there was quite a lot more that could’ve been added to make it last at least twice as long. The amount of side quests to do is pretty disappointing, I think.

Another one of the game’s plus points in terms of how it plays out, however, is that it is particularly challenging. I would advise players looking to play it to be prepared to learn how to use abilities well because it can be very testing at times. Especially whilst fighting against many of the game’s varied and very well-designed bosses. The side quests in the game give the game an almost RPG element to it. Which, for me in particular, is always a plus, as RPGs are one of my favorite types of games. But I still think much more could’ve been included.

Controls – 7/10

The controls are definitely among the most annoying aspects of this game. The main problem I found with them is during combat. It can get pretty awkward switching targets in fights with bosses or multiple enemies. And also, switching powers can become an unnecessary nuisance as well. Apparently, it’s best, though, to play this game on a PC. Using a controller can present these complications. But that’s no excuse in hindsight. When the developers decided to release this game for multiple systems, they needed to ensure that the control scheme was tailored accordingly. But of course, these complications thankfully don’t make the game unplayable.

Lifespan – 7/10

As I pointed out, it was this game’s gameplay elements, or rather the lack of them, that caused it to suffer in terms of lifespan as well. I think, just like Super Mario 3D World, if a few more side quests were added, this game could easily have made for at least 30 hours, which would be a distinguished amount of time for a platform game, to say the least. But unfortunately, it only lasts for about half that amount of time. It’s a shame because, with a game like this, players will want it to last as long as possible, as games like this rarely come about. Whilst it’s certainly worth more than one playthrough, it’s just regrettable that there’s not more to do in it, in my opinion.

Storyline – 9/10

Despite all the different minds, the character must traverse within to progress through the game. The one mind I would want to be able to get into is Tim Schafer’s. He has written a lot of the most distinct stories ever found in video games, and it would be interesting to know where exactly he draws inspiration from and how these ideas form in his head. The story of Psychonauts revolves around a ten-year-old boy called Raz, who has escaped from a circus against his father’s will to the nearby Whispering Rock Psychic Summer Camp to become a Psychonaut, an agent with psychic abilities used to fight evil.

Raz manages to impress the instructors at the camp, who see great potential in him, and they decide to offer him more advanced training at the camp. Soon, events unfold into a huge conspiracy at the camp, which Raz must uncover to prevent an impending danger to the other kids at the camp and finally complete his training as a Psychonaut. It’s a fantastically written story, complete with elements such as humor, tragedy, and culture. It’s just one of many elements that make this game a disastrously overlooked experience.

Originality –9.5/10

Psychonauts is all about originality. There is no other game like it. It’s probably the kind of concept that, if put together on paper, may seem like it just wouldn’t work. But when brought to life as an interactive story, it’s just difficult to think about how so many people chose to miss out on the chance of having this wonderful experience. Just like with Brütal Legend, Tim Schafer had expressed interest in expanding on the world of Psychonauts, but for now, no sequel or spin-off is in development. Maybe one day, he may make something happen; here’s hoping.

Happii

To put it simply, Psychonauts, whilst I think it suffers from a lack of quantity in lifespan and side quests, certainly makes up for quality in terms of conceptual design, story, humor, gameplay variety, and uniqueness. It is a must-have for any fan of platforming games; I highly recommend it.

Score

48.5/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Proteus (PC, PlayStation 3 & PlayStation Vita)

Proteus

Developer(s) – Curve Studios

Designer(s) – Ed Key & David Kanaga

PEGI – 3

Made free to play to PlayStation Plus subscribers some time ago, Proteus is a game. It simply has players walking around an open world and not doing much of anything else. To me, it is an awful, wretched game, whereby its biggest and most interesting talking point is in its development history. Like many other games of its kind. Originally, Proteus was intended to be an RPG in the same ilk as Skyrim or Oblivion. But when the developers realized the extent of the work that would have to be put into it to make that happen, they instead decided to make a game, which was, in their own words, “non-traditional and non-violent”.

Sony even insisted that more content be added to the final product before they ported it to PlayStation consoles. But the lead developer, Ed Key, admitted that he and the creators never attempted to steer the direction of the development of these features. Adding only a minor facility to the PlayStation Vita port of the game. To me, Ed Key has made Proteus sound like the most half-hearted video game ever developed. And it was certainly made apparent to me while playing.

Graphics – 6/10

One of the few aspects I can give at least a small amount of credit for is its visual style. The scenery makes heavy use of pixel art and makes for a few things in the game to marvel at. Though not a lot. There have been many more indie games that I have played and reviewed this year that have stood out to a much greater extent than this. Games like Don’t Starve and Chronicles of a Dark Lord. There was much more thought put into the visual concepts of those two games than there was in this. And that token alone makes this game pale in comparison. Although the soundtrack to this game is also pretty relaxing and well done as well.

Gameplay – 0/10

As I stated before, Proteus is a game whereby there are no objectives or things to do but to walk around a randomly generated in-game open world. I’m all for open worlds in video gaming. But not empty ones void of things to do. It’s because of this that I even hesitate to call Proteus a video game. Some people have gone so far as to label it an anti-game, which many actually consider controversial. But to the people who have coined that term, I say good call. The game provides no entertainment and no replay value. And it’s a wonder to me why the developers ever bothered to release it at all.

Controls – 4/10

Though there aren’t a lot of faults with the game’s control scheme, the fact of the matter is, there wasn’t a lot for the developers to get wrong. The game makes use of only a few buttons on the controller. Aside from the movement being pretty stiff, the fact that there’s nothing to do in the game warrants little use for most buttons, which certainly, by today’s standards, is embarrassing.

Lifespan – 2/10

To complete the game’s one arbitrary objective of changing through seasons in quick succession before the credits roll will take about 40 minutes. But beyond that, the game will only last as long as the player’s interest, which shouldn’t be any longer. My own personal interest didn’t even last long enough for me to want to finish it. The game can be finished multiple times in quick succession. But I only consider that to be part of the problem.

Storyline – 0/10

Not only does this game not have any kind of narrative attached to it, but there’s nothing in the way of a basic premise either. Nor did I find any kind of abstract or elaborate story elements open to any kind of interpretation whatsoever. It’s a shame that developers couldn’t even be bothered to add some kind of premise to the game to make it even vaguely more interesting than it turned out to be.

Originality – 0/10

This game is also in no way, shape, or form unique. Though the developers called this a non-traditional game, it doesn’t establish any warranted new video game traditions or break any boundaries of any kind. It lacks everything that a gamer would want in a game and introduces nothing new that a gamer may want to see in one.

Furiious

In summation, Proteus is a catastrophic excuse for a piece of software that shouldn’t really be considered a video game; easily the worst game I’ve played throughout 2014. Even by the lead developer’s own admission, it’s a title that turned out to be less than what he initially wanted it to be. So in effect, it’s unfinished work, and credit should never be given for incomplete work.

Score

12/60

2/10 (Terrible)

Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time (PC, PlayStation 2, GameCube, Xbox, PlayStation 3 Xbox 360 & Game Boy Advance)

Prince of Persia Sands of Time

Developer(s) – Ubisoft Montreal

Publisher(s) – Ubisoft

Director – Patrice Desilets

Producer – Yannis Mallat

PEGI – 12

Developed largely by the same team that created the original Splinter Cell, Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time critically and commercially went leaps and bounds ahead of the earlier attempt from both Red Orb Entertainment and Avalanche Studios to bring the franchise to the realm of 3D gaming. The intention behind the game’s creation was not only to revive one of gaming’s most recognizable franchises but also to breathe new life into the action-adventure genre. And they certainly did just that.

Graphics – 8/10

Aside from the FMVs, which look particularly good for a sixth-generation game, the game also excelled in terms of conceptual design. As well as in-game visuals. It’s interesting to witness how Ubisoft’s prolonged incorporation of Middle Eastern culture in video gaming possibly began. This would eventually lead them to establish a base of operations in Abu Dhabi. And in turn, increase the presence of the industry on the continent in general. In this respect, the game has had more of an impact than people may realize.

Gameplay – 8/10                

The game is an action-adventure 3D platformer, with quite a heavy emphasis on stylized combat and puzzle-solving. The combat system is incredibly enjoyable, with players being able to perform a vast amount of excellent-looking combos over time. The Dagger of Time weapon also provides an extremely unique twist on gameplay. Some say the inclusion of it merely oversimplified it. But I disagree. The game still provides a pretty stern challenge regardless. Especially as many of the puzzles in it can be quite testing.

Controls – 9/10

The platforming element of the game can take some getting used to at first. Since the game also introduced a lot of new mechanics concerning the character’s acrobatic skills, including the ability to run across walls, this idea, among others, serves as a precursor to Ubisoft’s own Assassin’s Creed series. Otherwise, however, there are no other issues regarding the controls. The way the combat was handled is also particularly reminiscent of Ocarina of Time. Which, to me, was an extremely positive thing.

Lifespan – 8/10

The game can be made to last about 15 to 20 hours, which, for a linear game, is fairly impressive. Normally, games like this can seemingly only be made to last for not even 10 hours, regardless of how many side quests developers may add. But what makes this even more impressive is that there are only one or two side quests. But it also makes me think that there would be nothing wrong with adding more than that.

Storyline – 9/10

The story follows the young Prince of Persia, who, whilst warring with a rival nation, comes across a dagger giving him the ability to manipulate time. When he, his father, and the royal vizier discover a huge hourglass known as the Sands of Time, the prince is tricked into releasing the sands and infesting an entire palace with monsters. The prince resolves to defeat the monsters and somehow undo the damage he has done. The story is wrought with twists and turns, making it one of the most interesting that I’ve ever experienced in any video game before. It also deals with many major themes, including love, betrayal, and the impact that time itself can have.

Originality – 8/10

With gameplay mechanics and a combat system extremely unique to gaming at the time, it’s no surprise to find just how influential a game this was. It would also go on to spawn not only two sequels, but also a live-action film published by Disney, starring Jake Gyllenhaal as the prince, and whilst it wasn’t a critical success, it became the highest-grossing film based on a video game. Some, including me, would also argue that it went leaps and bounds ahead of the classic games, which is a viable opinion since they merely followed the trend of what was popular at the time.

Happii

Overall, Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time is an extremely strong gaming experience, and I would highly recommend anyone who may not have played it to give it a try, especially as it has since been remastered for seventh-generation consoles. It’s an influential classic of the sixth generation and worth any gamer’s time.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Portal (PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 & PC)

Portal

Developer(s) – Valve

Publisher(s) – Valve & Microsoft Game Studios

PEGI – 12

Developed by Valve, the creators of Half-Life and Team Fortress, Portal was released in 2007. As a part of its Valve Orange Box collection for both Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3. The game is actually the spiritual successor to an independently developed title called Narbacular Drop. It was created by a group of students at the DigiPen Institute of Technology in Washington. The students were then subsequently hired by Valve’s Gabe Newell, who was impressed with Narbacular Drop. And they helped to develop one of the most innovative titles of the seventh generation. Portal. Although I found it hard to get into during my first playthrough some years ago, I recently played through the entirety of the game. And I was fairly impressed with it.

Graphics – 7/10

The game takes place in the fictional setting of Aperture Sciences Enrichment Centre, which is a science-fiction setting reminiscent of what Valve is synonymous with. There are a few things to make it stand out from the others here and there. For example, it seems to be a lot more eerily cleaner and organized than the likes of Black Mesa. But from a visual standpoint, this game truly shines.

And by proxy, its sequel, Portal 2, has many different hidden Easter eggs throughout the entirety of the game. Many of these are hidden dens reputed to belong to Doug Rattman, who is an unseen character. But pivotal to the game’s back story and overall plot. There is also an Easter egg towards the end of the game featuring a projector presentation outlining how Aperture Sciences competes with Black Mesa. Bringing the worlds of both Half-Life and Portal together.

Gameplay – 8/10

Portal is a game blurring the lines between first-person shooting and puzzle games. The objective is to complete a series of tests. They involve creating two different portals in order to get around and solve conundrums throughout the game. What I really like about this game. And something I don’t think is seen enough in the medium is that it challenges players to think outside the box. To consider that there may be more than one way of getting around particular problems. And different ways in which the portals can be utilized to do so. Although there is only one boss fight throughout the course of the game. Even that makes for one of the most creative boss fights I’ve ever experienced.

Controls – 10/10

Developed by a company perpetuating the first-person shooting genre, there was nothing to suggest that there would ever be a problem with Portal’s control scheme. And so there isn’t. With the help of the DigiPen student contributing to the game’s portal-shooting premise, the game has been made for one of the most imaginative titles not only of the seventh generation but also in terms of gaming in general. Puzzle games have come and gone like Kurushi. This has challenged the conventional methods of playing video games. But it’s no easy task, and Portal did this flawlessly.

Lifespan – 2/10

The game’s biggest downside, however, is how disapprovingly short-lived it is. Especially in comparison to many of Valve’s previous efforts. Though it’s nowhere near as short as Narbacular Drop, which can only be made to last ten minutes, if that, Portal can be made to last for just shy of 3 hours. Which, to me, was pretty disappointing. Thankfully, this is where the sequel would come in. But the first game was very much a question of trial and error. And no truer is that than in its lifespan, in my opinion.

Storyline – 9/10

One thing that I can always find myself saying about Valve is that they know how to create a very compelling narrative. The story of Portal follows a woman named Chell. She is required to undertake a series of puzzles to survive. Based on the use of a portal gun, which generates two different kinds of portals for her to be able to solve them. The tests are conducted at the Aperture Sciences Enrichment Center by a maniacal AI called GlaDOS (Genetic Lifeform and Disk Operating System). With the unusual and persistent promise of cake at the end of it.

Although the basic premise sounds very simplistic, as well as particularly weird, the character of GlaDOS makes for an interesting experience in terms of story. Providing the audience with a unique blend of both drama and comedy. There are a lot of suspenseful moments throughout the game, but they’re also balanced out by GlaDOS’s sadistic sense of humor. Though these elements are greatly expanded on in the second game, the first does provide a very strong starting point in establishing these elements, which hadn’t been found in a Valve game prior.

Originality – 10/10

In terms of both gameplay and story, to put it simply, there is no other game like Portal. It’s a prime example of why I think it’s excellent that more and more indie developers are being provided with a much bigger window of opportunity than ever before, because there have been a large number of them who have come up with some of the greatest titles to have ever been developed. Though Portal 2 would perfect the formula, the impact that the first game has had since its release is undeniable.

Happii

In summation, although it is far too short-lived a game for what it is, Portal is one of the most innovative titles in video game history and remains a favorite of many gamers to this day. I enjoyed the game for how long it lasted when I previously thought that I wouldn’t if I’d played through it in its entirety, and I would recommend the Orange Box collection to anyone who owns either an Xbox 360 or a PlayStation 3.

Score

46/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Pokémon Snap (Nintendo 64)

Pokemon Snap

Developer(s) – HAL Laboratory & Pax Softnica

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Yoichi Yamamoto, Koji Inokuchi & Akira Takeshima

Producer(s) – Satoru Iwata, Kenji Miki & Shigeru Miyamoto

PEGI – 3

Pokémon Snap was one of many spin-offs to the Pokémon game series for the Game Boy, developed during the fifth generation of gaming. The premise of the game revolves around taking pictures of wild pokémon. Catching them all (and I use the term loosely) in a different manner than gamers certainly would have been accustomed to at the time. This unique rail-shooter, for me, provided a lot of entertainment growing up. And it still holds up fairly well to this day, I find.

Graphics – 7/10

Featuring some of the best visual quality the Nintendo 64 had to offer, there are some fairly diverse settings as well as minimal in-game glitches. Something that had been a problem for the console early on. However, the frame rate can drop at times. Especially in the opening cinematic, it doesn’t become enough of a problem to warrant too many complaints or to hinder gameplay, most importantly. But what I like most about the visuals is how the pokémon are portrayed throughout the game. The settings speak of how each type of pokémon adapts to all the different environments present. Which in turn, provides a much more realistic representation reminiscent of conventional animal behavior. They portray the critters in a much different manner than in any of the conservative games in the series that came before it.

Gameplay – 7/10

The game revolves around taking pictures of pokémon across the different stages of the game and unlocking each stage. Whilst trying to rack up high scores by taking the best-quality pictures. It is very satisfying and fairly addictive to try and capture the perfect shot of each pokémon and to rack up as high a score as possible. But a major problem I found with this title was that there are only 64 of the original 151 pokémon present. Purely to coincide with the fact that it was released on the Nintendo 64. And as a result, the game is somewhat lacking in substance. I think if the developers had included all 151 pokémon, then there would have been a lot more for gamers to play with. In turn, a lot more calls for different level designs and for more substance in general.

Controls – 10/10

Although there are no problems with the control scheme, it is also fairly unique in a certain respect. It does blur the lines somewhat between first-person shooters and simulation games and combines elements of the two to make for something pretty exciting. Also is comparable to such future games as Dead Rising and Beyond Good & Evil.

Lifespan – 6/10

Although it can take only 2 hours to rush through each course and unlock all the extra items used to take pictures of certain pokémon, there is quite a bit of replay value to be had in re-visiting each course and trying to capture as many excellent pictures as possible. The Wii Virtual Console version added even more with the inclusion of the facility to share pictures with friends. But after grinding through each course and collecting everything, it does become a case of racking up the highest score possible, but as I said earlier, I can’t help but feel there would be much more to it with the inclusion of all 151 pokémon.

Originality – 10/10

Pokémon Snap was and still is among some of the most unique games ever developed. The only games like this that have come along since are the likes of Fatal Frame. There was no concept like it at the time. And it’s a concept that has never truly been fully replicated since.

Happii

In summation, Pokémon Snap has been praised as a refreshingly unique game, and I couldn’t agree more. It comes highly recommended by me and will make for a good few hours of fun gameplay.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Pokémon Shuffle (3DS)

Pokemon Shuffle

Developer(s) – Genius Sonority

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

PEGI – 3

Pokémon Shuffle is a free-to-play game that I’ve heard many times over as being described as Pokémon meets Candy Crush. And it’s easy to see why. Though it is more enjoyable to play than the aforementioned Candy Crush, it’s a lot more restrictive in comparison to not only that but most other app games as well.

Graphics – 6/10

Since this is essentially an arcade puzzle game, the only emphasis on visuals is how each section of the game board looks as the game progresses. The idea is to give the illusion of it taking place in several different locations. But in a game like this, visuals shouldn’t really take precedence anyway. So I don’t think the game should lose out on too many marks because of this. There is also a basis in visual diversity with the number of pokémon there are in it from all over the franchise.

Gameplay – 7/10

The game plays out almost identically to the likes of Candy Crush and Bejewelled. But unlike any of these examples, there’s also a fairly strong RPG element to it. In that, each pokémon fought can be captured. And re-used in different battles and can be leveled up over time. There is also a lot more incentive to play it than most other app games in this respect. Since there is nothing much to be gained from getting all three stars on a stage other than bragging rights.

The problem with this game, however, is that it is indeed a lot more restrictive in the sense that each stage takes the life of the player regardless of whether they win or lose a battle. Whereas, in games like Candy Crush, lives are kept if players win a stage. I think that if Nintendo does indeed plan to publish more games like this, they need to ease up on these kinds of restrictions. Otherwise, players will begin to lose patience and fast.

Controls – 10/10

These kinds of puzzle games have been in development for over 30 years now. And there would have been some serious problems if Nintendo hadn’t implemented a decent control scheme. The entire genre started to find its feet after it was ported to the original Game Boy. Making even further reasons why Nintendo should never have had problems. And so, there aren’t any.

Originality – 4/10

The most original thing about Pokémon Shuffle is how well the RPG element of the Pokémon series has been implemented, and it gives me hope that Nintendo will continue to implement series staples from other franchises into their upcoming smartphone games to differentiate them from others as much as possible. Otherwise, however, it essentially plays out like most other app games, and I think Nintendo needs to do even more to be able to compete with some of the more established app game developers.

Niiutral

In summation, Pokémon Shuffle is not without its charms, but it is far too restrictive in terms of how often it can be played, and it doesn’t do quite enough to distinguish itself from other games of its kind. Perhaps Nintendo will go on to make better games than this for smart devices, but there are far better games out there for the 3DS than this.

Score

27/40

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Pokemon Pinball (Game Boy Colour)

Pokemon Pinball

Developer(s) – Jupiter

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

PEGI – 3

Going beyond a simple spin-off game, Pokémon Pinball captured the feeling of the popular RPG franchise and gave players a lot more to do than in a conventional Pinball game, such as having to capture Pokémon using the different areas the ball can be launched into and completing an additional objective in the process. Though it would have been relatively easy to overlook this title, even during the time of its release, when Pokémon was one of the most popular brands around, I personally spent a lot of time playing this game as a child, and I think it still holds up to this day as one of the most memorable Game Boy experiences.

Graphics – 7/10

Having an unusual amount of visual diversity for a pinball game, the player is given a choice of either the red or blue board to go allude to the motif of the original two Pokémon games, there’s also the added feature of players having to select a location on the board before playing where different Pokémon can be captured in different locations; even giving the player the added facility to travel in between locations during rounds of pinball. It went beyond a simple spin-off pinball game in many different ways, but the fact that it has this much basis in visual design captured my imagination in a very positive way at the time.

Gameplay – 7/10

Aside from being unique in a multitude of ways, the game is also very enjoyable to play, and the extra incentive to be gained from doing so makes it my favorite form of pinball overall. It’s interesting since I personally have a kind of love-hate relationship with Pinball. On one hand, I love how addictive and immersive it is. But on the other hand, I’ve never liked how much chance there is involved in the game, as opposed to it being a question of skill. But since there’s more to do in Pokémon Pinball than in a regular game, the issue of addiction and chance is fractionally evened out from my point of view; it’s more about addiction than random chance.

Controls – 10/10

The control scheme for the game is simple, easy to come to terms with, and has no complications. The A button controls the left flipper, the right button on the d-pad controls the right, and the B tilt.

Originality – 8/10

What makes this game so unique is how well it differs from other Pinball games. In its additional objective, its RPG element, and its emphasis on a visual concept. This is unusually impressive for a game of its kind. To a great extent, Pokémon Shuffle gives me hope that Nintendo will be able to enter the smartphone gaming market. Without putting too many restrictions on their games. And to let gamers play them for as long or as often as they want.

Happii

Overall, Pokémon Pinball should not be as easy a game to overlook as it is. It’s an excellent addition to the Game Boy library. And a must-have for any fan of the franchise, as well as fans of Pinball.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Plok (Super Nintendo)

Plok

Developer(s) – Software Creations

Publisher(s) – Activision, Tradewest & Nintendo

Designer(s) – Ste & John Pickford, Lyndon Brooks & John Buckley

Producer(s) – John & Ste Pickford

PEGI – 3

Reborn out of an abandoned arcade game entitled Fleapit, Plok was a traditional 2D platformer typical of the type of game that Nintendo would most frequently publish at the time. It’s a pretty enjoyable game, and wonderfully weird in conceptual design, as many of Nintendo’s own efforts were. Interestingly, Mario and Donkey Kong’s creator, Shigeru Miyamoto, expressed a strong interest in working on the game himself. But in the end, Nintendo simply chose to publish the game in Europe. Designer Ste Pickford suspected the reason behind Nintendo’s ultimate reluctance was that they thought the game was too similar to the upcoming Yoshi’s Island for Nintendo to want to work on both. Although I think Nintendo unanimously made the right choice, that’s not to discredit Plok. For me, it still stands out as one of the better 2D side scrollers on the Super Nintendo.

Graphics – 7/10

As colorful and outlandish as most other efforts from Nintendo at the time, Plok features a fair bit of visual diversity in its level design. As well as some particularly strange enemies, such as walking vegetables and disembodied heads disguised as road signs. Even the main character himself is extremely strange in design. He is a red creature in a yellow t-shirt capable of firing his own limbs at enemies to fight. Although at first glance the game may seem pretty weak from a conceptual standpoint, I think players do have to wonder what was going through the developer’s heads whilst making this game.

Gameplay – 7/10

For a game that was quite archetypal for the mid-nineties, it’s surprising to discover just how much variety there is in the gameplay. Aside from simply having to get from point A to point B in lieu of the genre’s tradition, there are also bonus sequences that require players to race through courses on various vehicles. Most likely a reason why Nintendo may have felt it was too similar to Yoshi’s Island. There’s also a small element of Donkey Kong Country. Whereby the player can collect the four letters from Plok’s name to receive extra lives. And even a reference to Metroid in the way Plok jumps.

Controls – 10/10

As 2D side scrollers were the set standard at the time, the developers could have had even greater problems than they ended up having on a commercial level with this game if the control scheme hadn’t been handled correctly. Fortunately, however, there are no issues with the controls. And it plays out just as well as any other game in the genre, with no unnecessary complications.

Lifespan – 6/10

Plok can take just under 2 hours to complete. This was about the average lifespan of a video game at the time. It actually surprised me somewhat that this game lasted as short a time as it did, since the similarities between it and Yoshi’s Island in terms of variety in gameplay are very noticeable, and Yoshi’s Island could be made to last about an hour longer than that, even longer if the player tries to complete the game to 100%.

Storyline – 6/10

The story simply follows the main character, Plok, who, after having one of his many flags stolen, sets out to retrieve it. Only after doing so, he arrives back home to find that he had been distracted. Merely by somebody else to steal the rest of his flags. And Plok resolves to find them all again. Most games of that era, and the era before, were relatively light on story, and this is no exception. However, the developers did change things up as the game progressed, and there are a few interesting references. For example, one of the dud flags discovered at the end of one level is in the form of a pair of red dungarees; an obvious reference to Super Mario Bros.

Originality – 6/10

Taking into account both its gameplay variety and conceptual design, Plok stands out as much as any other game of its kind could have done at the time, which wasn’t an easy thing to do, so at least some credit is owed to its developers for that. It would have taken some serious talent to make a game in the genre stand out as much as possible, and this title certainly does that.

Happii

Overall, Plok is a pretty fun side scroller, and it comes recommended by me. It isn’t one of the greatest games of all time, but it’s certainly one of the most standout games of its respective era; it’s just a shame that Shigeru Miyamoto ultimately decided against dedicating the first-hand effort to it. We can only speculate how much better a game it would have turned out to be.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Plants Vs Zombies (Xbox 360, PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation Vita, Nintendo DS, iOS, Android, Blackberry & Bada)

Plants Vs Zombies

Developer(s) – PopCap Games

Publisher(s) – PopCap Games

Distributor(s) – Electronic Arts

Designer – George Fan

PEGI – 12

Inspired after playing Warcraft III tower defense mods, as well as one of his previous games, Insaniquarium, George Fan and PopCap released the original Plants Vs Zombies back in 2009, when it received overwhelmingly positive critical acclaim. And eventually went on to become a cultural phenomenon. Personally, I was addicted to Plats Vs Zombies for quite some time after I started playing it. I would recommend anyone with any of the platforms it’s available on to pick up a copy.

Graphics – 8/10

Taking place in a strange world where zombies are a looming threat, and planting various types of flora is the only way to stop them, the game’s visuals are presented in a very cartoon-like style. They are extremely varied in their different level settings, characters, and variations of different units to be either employed or combated against. It obviously took a great deal of imagination to come up with a concept as outlandish as the one presented in this game. They’re the kind of ideas I love to see in games. The kind that may sound ridiculous on paper. But ends up becoming something particularly special on a games console.

Gameplay – 9/10

The gameplay is unbelievably addictive as well as incredibly satisfying. Aside from the main storyline, there are also several other game modes to be experienced. Such as the various puzzle modes, side challenges, and the Zen garden mode. Which, the player can grow plants in a garden to make money. And much to my own personal delight, an endless mode. That there is indeed an endless mode to this game, of course, means that it also has an infinite lifespan. And lasts only as long as an individual’s commitment to the game. It really is extraordinary how much variety in gameplay was packed into such a title.

Controls – 8/10

One piece of advice I would be able to give to anyone who may be looking to try this game out (which I highly recommend) is that the best platform to play it on would most probably be a tablet, since, of course, the controls would be a touchscreen. And the screen itself would be sizable enough. Playing it on the console is feasible. But it’s a bit more annoying, since the game was originally designed to work on PC, and commands can’t be issued quite as fast. This could theoretically cost players a match if factored into enough times.

Originality – 7/10

There have been many different tower defense games to come along over the years, especially on the internet, but Plants vs. Zombies stands out among them all for its exceptional variety in gameplay, as well as its strangely compelling conceptual design. To me, it’s no wonder that this game has left such a durable legacy within the industry and has spawned a sequel and spin-off series.

Happii

In summation, Plants vs. Zombies is one of the most satisfying games to play from the seventh generation. I was personally thrown by just how good a game it is; there’s much more to it than meets the eye.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)