Tag Archives: Liverpool

Lara Croft & the Temple of Osiris (PC, PlayStation 4 & Xbox One)

Lara Croft And The Temple of Osiris

Developer(s) – Crystal Dynamics

Publisher(s) – Square Enix

PEGI – 12

Developed after the Tomb Raider re-vamp of 2013, and taking just over a year to complete, Lara Croft & the Temple of Osiris introduces an extremely different style of gameplay to anything I’d ever seen prior in the Tomb Raider series in the form of an isometric top-down combat-oriented adventure RPG. Reminiscent of the likes of Diablo, Baldur’s Gate, or the original 2 Fallout games. Personally, whilst this isn’t the first Tomb Raider game like it (that being Lara Croft & the Guardian of Light), it was my introduction to this different style. And I was pleasantly surprised by how good this game is. And while it does have its faults, especially for a game of both its caliber and potential, I found myself enjoying it more than any of the classic games.

Graphics – 8.5/10

Conceptually, the game looks excellent. Taking place in an ancient Egyptian tomb. Featuring a multitude of mythical creatures and enemies for Lara and company to contend with throughout. It features some very attractive-looking scenery. Although the game was developed using seventh-generation graphics, it still looks to be in stunning detail since everything is viewed from a distance during gameplay. A technique commonly used in games of this kind. Up close during cut scenes, the visuals may look a little bit outdated. But bearing in mind that it only took a year to develop, they still aren’t bad, considering.

Gameplay – 9/10

The concept of gameplay makes it much more addictive and enjoyable than any of the classic Tomb Raider games, in my personal opinion. As well as an engrossing main quest, there are also side quests to undertake throughout. As well as the facility to upgrade Lara’s equipment. Adding a strong RPG element to it, as well as the extra replay value to be had in revisiting different areas of the game in order to pick up as much treasure as possible. In order to open the various chests throughout and upgrade equipment to its fullest.

Controls – 10/10

Another huge advantage that this game has over its many classic predecessors that many gamers seem to hold in high regard is that the control scheme is infinitely better. Since it involves a completely different style of play, it isn’t marred by the same issues the original PlayStation games had during the time gaming was in the middle of the 2D to 3D transition back in the late 90s. And combat is handled just as well as any other game of its kind.

Lifespan – 4/10

The biggest drawback to this game is that, despite what replay value there is to be had, it can only take around 4 to 6 hours to complete to 100%. Which is way below par compared to other games of the genre. Especially Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance and the original Diablo. If Crystal Dynamics ever contemplated making a third Tomb Raider game like this, it would be simple to improve on the formula. All they would have to do is make it in the typical fashion of how a sequel is normally made. Bigger and better. But unfortunately, this game doesn’t last anywhere near as long as it had the potential to last. Personally, if I had to wait longer than a year, if it meant playing a longer game, I would have gladly waited patiently for it.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of the game follows renowned explorer Lara Croft. As she and a fellow archaeologist, Carter Bell, stumble upon the temple of the Egyptian god Osiris and attempt to recover the god’s fabled staff. After finding it, they find themselves locked within the temple, but inadvertently release Horus and Isis. The last of the old gods was imprisoned by the god of the underworld, Set. Lara and her three companions venture through the temple to resurrect the god Osiris and thus prevent Set’s return. The plot itself is fairly solid and intense. But I found that, bar the mild humor that the character of Carter Bell brings to the table, the voice acting was just a little bit off in my opinion. But overall, it doesn’t do too much to make the story impossible to either follow or enjoy.

Originality – 6/10

Though the overall idea may be relatively new to its respective franchise, it’s nothing new to the gaming medium overall. Isometric RPGs had already proven to be a popular style of play among gamers. And whilst there are certain elements that make this title stand out, it’s more evolutionary than revolutionary. Regardless, it was a breath of fresh air to me, having tried to contend with so many bad Tomb Raider games in the past. And I would like to see it expanded upon in the future.

Happii

Overall, Lara Croft and the Temple of Osiris is, to date, the best Tomb Raider game I have ever played. Bar my completion of the Tomb Raider re-vamp. As well as the release of Rise of the Tomb Raider later this year. It’s certainly a cut above all the classic games that helped to bring the franchise into prominence. And I would recommend it to fans of either this genre or fans of the series, as well as newcomers.

Score

44.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

Lair

Lair (PlayStation 3)

Developer(s) – Factor 5

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director(s) – Julian Eggebrecht & Holger Schmidt

Producer – Brian D. Krueger

PEGI – 16

Lair was a highly anticipated launch title for the PlayStation 3. And made heavy use of the then-new Sixaxis motion controls, which have since become relatively scarce in many PlayStation games. People were blown away by the graphics but were disappointed by the gameplay and controls. And after playing this travesty of a game, it’s no wonder to me why they were.

Graphics – 6/10

The best thing I can say about the visuals is that they did an excellent job of showing off what the PlayStation 3 was capable of in its early stages. And the attention to detail was quite overwhelming at the time. However, on a conceptual level, there is next to nothing differentiating it from other games or forms of media set in a medieval fantasy world. Much less so than Dragon Age: Inquisition, and even less so than other obscure games of today.

Gameplay – 4/10

The gameplay revolves around riding a dragon and killing as many surrounding people as possible in a series of stages throughout the game. In a medieval fantasy game, most gamers would most probably expect at least some hint of an RPG element. But this game doesn’t even have that, disappointingly. The developers were going for a unique approach to gameplay. They tried to outline to other video game bloggers who had given it bad reviews by sending them a 21-page booklet with things like artwork and background story. But they were not convinced, and neither would I be.

Controls – 3/10

Since the developers were using a very new control scheme, Lair was always going to be a question of trial and error. And frankly, playing this game is like pulling teeth. It’s uncomfortable, and no one should ever have to go through it. They are extremely stiff and hinder gameplay in such a way that makes this game almost unplayable.

Lifespan – 5/10

Like many other mainstream games, they have found their way on the PlayStation 3. And throughout the seventh generation in general, Lair will last just under 10 hours, which is particularly underwhelming. As with most other aspects of this game, this says to me that the developers should have spent more time trying to get the fundamentals right and make a half-decent game as opposed to going out of their way to try and convince critics that it was a good game and failing miserably.

Storyline – 2/10

The game’s story is also extremely reminiscent of most plots associated with the medieval fantasy genre, and consequently, there isn’t much present to differentiate the game from others overall. It follows the adventures of a dragon rider called Rohn. He seeks to restore peace to a world divided by two opposing people. The Mokai and the Asylians. I’ve seen this type of plot in The Lord of the Rings and Warcraft, back when they were original to me. But I fail to understand how the developers could even fill an art book with 21 pages to send to critics.

Originality – 2/10

The only thing separating this game from others is the fact that it was one of the first to make use of the PlayStation 3’s Sixaxis controls, which went on to feature in very few games since. Only being effectively used in the likes of Ratchet & Clank: Tools of Destruction, God of War III, and Heavenly Sword. Some critics would also argue that this fact could make the game unique for the wrong reasons, since the game’s control scheme is most probably the worst aspect of it.

Furiious

In summation, Lair is a shining example of how not to develop a launch title; it isn’t enjoyable in the least bit and has next to no artistic merit attached to it. I just hope now that I don’t get a 21-page booklet through my door trying to tell me otherwise.

Score

22/50

3.5/10 (Very Poor)

LA Noire (PC, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 & Switch)

LA Noire

Developer(s) – Team Bondi

Publisher(s) – Rockstar Games

Director – Brendan McNamara

Producer(s) – Naresh Hirani & Josh Needleman

PEGI – 18

One of the most highly anticipated games of 2011, and almost a decade in the making, LA Noire was released to great critical acclaim. Many critics comment that the game is indistinguishable from a film. Personally, I don’t understand how that would be a good thing. And whilst I don’t think it is a terrible game, it is indeed incredibly overrated.

Graphics – 9/10

The best aspect of it, in my opinion, is the visuals. Using motion capture technology, actors were integrated into the game to play their respective characters. And to make the experience as realistic and as cinematic as possible. They are some of the best graphics to have been rendered throughout the seventh generation of gaming. Since not only is it a decent-looking game from a technical standpoint. But the developers also did a pretty decent job of depicting the era that the game is set in. With the fashion style of many characters, aspects of film noir, and architectural details, among other factors.

Gameplay – 6/10

What I wasn’t impressed with, however, was the gameplay, as, despite the developer’s efforts to provide innovation within the industry, it seemed underwhelming for how big a world is included in it. And how linear a progression it takes on. Much like Grand Theft Auto, it’s a glorified game of Cops & Robbers. But the payer is this time on the side of good. But aside from taking part in arrests and shoot-outs, the player must also interrogate criminals and witnesses by using their facial expressions to determine whether they are either telling the truth, saying something doubtful, or flat-out lying. This is where the remnants of innovation are shown. I can’t help but feel that the game, even along with the additional DLC release for it, was way below par compared with many other games that Rockstar has put out over the years.

Controls – 10/10

As the game was most likely developed using a similar engine to that of any other Grand Theft Auto game, there aren’t any problems with its control scheme. Since a lot of practice has been had. The interrogation mechanics were also very well handled, as were things such as movement and aiming. Which, to me, had been a problem in some Grand Theft Auto games, in particular. It was refreshing to see that the development team had taken things like this into consideration at least.

Lifespan – 5/10

Since the gameplay is extremely wanting compared to any Grand Theft Auto title, it also lasts a considerably shorter time. Especially as GTA games have practically unlimited replay value, as many YouTube users have proven. A major difference is that since the player is on the side of good, going kill-crazy is a lot more taxing on the player. They will be demoted within the police department. So, therefore, it’s less time-consuming than doing the same thing in a Grand Theft Auto game. It’s pretty daunting to think that the developers couldn’t have added a facility to be able to infinitely prevent crime in LA Noire, in a similar way that they add the facility to infinitely commit it in Grand Theft Auto.

Storyline – 7/10

As was heavily advertised before the game’s release, it also has a fairly gripping story attached to it. With some pretty decent performances from many of the actors involved. The game revolves around recently promoted police inspector Cole Phelps, played by Mad Men’s Aaron Staton, who is eventually caught up in a huge scandal gripping Los Angeles, which he must stop. The game’s story is also very true to the time that it was set in. Back when President Harry S Truman was in office, and in the process of funneling money back into the country following the American Depression and World War II, more people than ever were in pursuit of the American Dream, of which there are indeed aspects in this game.

Originality – 6/10

Even though this title plays out fairly differently from Grand Theft Auto, it does so in a fashion, in my opinion, that makes it seem considerably worse than the former, let alone other mainstream games, especially considering how much time and money were poured into the project over a great number of years. It certainly wasn’t the most exciting game to have been released in 2011, with the likes of Rage, Batman: Arkham City, and Skyrim having seen the light of day within that time.

Happii

Overall, LA Noire was a fairly well-developed game, but massively overrated in my opinion. To me, all the signs seem to indicate that the developers concentrated more on story than gameplay, unlike in many Grand Theft Auto titles, which most often than not, provide a decent equilibrium between these two aspects.

Score

43/60

7/10 (Fair)

Knack (PlayStation 4)

Knack

Developer(s) – SCE Japan Studios

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Mark Cerny

Producer – Yusuke Watanabe

PEGI – 12

Released as a launch title for the PlayStation 4, Knack showcased early on in the console’s shelf life what it was capable of doing on a graphical level. Mainly through the visual aspects of the game’s titular character. It is a pretty nice-looking game. And I did find it kept me entertained for a few hours. But that’s as far as it went. As with many launch titles, it was ultimately very insubstantial compared to what games would be released for the console in its first full year.

Graphics – 9/10

As was undoubtedly intended by the developers, the visuals are by some distance the best thing about the game. The level of graphical detail is represented through Knack as he absorbs different materials into his body to gain different abilities. Such as ice, wood, and metal, were unlike anything I’d ever seen in any other video game. There were some glitches throughout. But they were barely noticeable. Instead, attention will be drawn to not only the design of Knack but to many of the different locations throughout the game. Some of them stand out really well from the rest of the game. Such as the Legendary Land and the many different underground temples. Former Naughty Dog employee Mark Cerny directed the game. And his influence is made extremely apparent.

Gameplay – 7/10

Another aspect whereby Cerny’s influence shines through is within the gameplay. Playing out very much like the classic Crash Bandicoot games, it is a linear 3D stage-based 3D platformer with an emphasis on combat (albeit somewhat more varied) and collecting hidden treasures throughout the game. However, I thought it was a little bit repetitive at times. And it does fall short of what could potentially have been done with it. Such is the nature of most launch titles.

Perhaps the developers may be saving a greater level of variety for a possible sequel. Which I think should be an open-world game. That’s what I think they should have done with the Crash Bandicoot series, even before those games ended up on sixth-generation hardware. Certainly, if the developers had a desire to make a franchise out of Knack, following the release of the sequel, then they needed to make a game worlds apart from the first.

Controls – 6/10

For a launch title, though there aren’t many problems with the actual control scheme, I was underwhelmed with how little it did to show off the controller’s new features, such as the touch screen. Even some basic buttons have no use at all. I think it’s partly because of this that the game’s combat system greatly adds to the game’s sense of repetition.

Lifespan – 5/10

Overall, the game can be completed to 100% within about ten hours. That being said, after two playthroughs. There is a small amount of replay value to be had within the game in playing through it a second time and collecting hidden items that may have been missed the first time around. But other than this, there’s really next to no cause for playing through it again.

Storyline – 6/10

The game’s story also does very little to impress or engross. The story follows Knack, a creature discovered by a scientist, Dr. Vargas, who can harness the power to bind ancient relics together and give them consciousness. Vargas believes that Knack could potentially be an invaluable weapon in the ensuing war between mankind and a race of goblins. But it gradually comes to light that there is an even bigger threat for Knack to prevent.

The problem is that there’s nothing really unique about it apart from its basic premise. There is hardly any character development involved. And it is consequently extremely hard to identify or show any concern for any of them. I’ve also noticed that in terms of story, it is very similar to most other video game stories about treasure hunting, such as Uncharted, Tomb Raider, etc. Despite setback after setback, the heroes always find a way to save the day. Perhaps this could be seen as Cerny’s influence yet again cropping in. Though in this case, in a much more negative way.

Originality – 5/10

The most original thing about the game is simply the design of Knack himself, the in-game locations, and a couple of the enemy designs. Granted, however, a lot of them, in particular, are heavily recycled throughout the game. In terms of both story and gameplay, there isn’t a great deal present to differentiate it from other games. This makes me believe that with the sequel, a lot of drastic changes and improvements would have to be made.

Niiutral

Overall, Knack can draw from players a few hours of fun, but there was most definitely room for improvement in almost every aspect. People may be surprised by my opinion of this, given how happy I was with the console’s launch period, but that was mostly down to the plethora of indie games released for it early on; the console’s early mainstream scene paled in comparison, and Knack is a shining example of that.

Score

38/60

6/10 (Average)

Kirby’s Adventure (Nintendo Entertainment System)

Kirbys Adventure

Developer(s) – HAL Laboratory

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Masahiro Sakurai

Producer(s) – Satoru Iwata, Shigeru Miyamoto & Takao Shimizu

PEGI – 3

One of the last games to be released on the Nintendo Entertainment System before software support ended back in 1994, Kirby’s Adventure is also considered to be one of the best games on the system. Making use of some impressive graphics for the time, as well as extremely varied gameplay. Aspects contributing to the overwhelmingly positive critical acclaim it received upon its release. Whilst I don’t think it quite deserved a perfect score, I do agree that it is most definitely one of the better games on the Nintendo Entertainment System. And just as good as its Game Boy counterpart, Kirby’s Dream Land, if not better.

Graphics – 9/10

As I alluded to, as this game was one of the last released on the NES, it was released at a time when the console’s graphical capability had been fully explored and expanded upon. And developers were in the process of pushing the boundaries of what else they could theoretically be capable of. Before completing the transition to the 16-bit era. Advanced 8-bit rendering techniques were incorporated into Kirby’s Adventure, such as giving characters black outlines. And making full use of the console’s limited color palette to present one of the most colorful and visually diverse games on the system.

The conceptual design, whilst reminiscent of Super Mario Bros 3, is also wonderfully varied, with many different landscapes used as levels. And incredibly varied enemy and boss designs. There’s actually quite an interesting story surrounding both this game and Kirby’s Dream Land about the color of the main character, Kirby. The character’s creator, Masahiro Sakurai, had originally envisioned the character to be pink. But Mario’s designer, Shigeru Miyamoto, wanted him to be yellow. There was also confusion on the part of Nintendo of America, which thought that because the Game Boy was a monochromatic system, Kirby was supposed to be white. Henceforth, Kirby was colored white on the box art for Kirby’s Dream Land.

Gameplay – 8/10

The game is a 2D side scroller, as was typical for the time. Though it doesn’t conform to many of the set trends synonymous with most games released within the genre. Kirby has the ability to swallow enemies and take on their combat abilities. Giving the game a surprising amount of variety. Different abilities include laser beams, attacking with a sword, fire powers, ice powers, and even the ability to use loud sounds like a crowd control move. When put together, it is extremely enjoyable to play. There were few games released for the NES with comparable amounts of variety to this title.

Controls – 9/10

The only vague problem I had with the game’s control scheme is how the flying mechanics work. Players use the up button to have Kirby float in the air to reach otherwise unreachable areas. And then the attack button deflates back to a walking state. It made visible the fact that more buttons were certainly needed in future consoles to accommodate a greater amount of variety in controls. Otherwise, however, there are no other issues to address.

Lifespan – 8/10

Kirby’s Adventure is also an exceptionally long game for its time. Lasting an average of around 2 and a half hours. Most games would normally last around 40 minutes or an hour, but for a 2D side scroller to last this long was exemplary. Even if the bulk of innovation in the genre had been made before the release of this game. Super Mario introduced the idea of multiple levels. And Mega Man introduced the idea of black outlines in 8-bit games. But Kirby’s Adventure is a by-product of how all these different ideas can be brought together to make something extremely special.

Storyline – 7/10

Though gamers would have had to rely on the instruction manual to learn of any story involved, as customary for the time, the story of Kirby’s Adventure somewhat stands out. Since it’s the gameplay, it does not follow the same tropes used in most games of that era. It follows Kirby on his quest to recover the Star Rod from his nemesis, King Dedede, in order to restore power to the Fountain of Dreams. This game was also the first to feature the character, Meta Knight. Who would go on to be, in my opinion, one of the most unfairly neglected characters in Nintendo history. For more information about why I think this, check out this article:

http://darkzero.co.uk/game-articles/nintendo-we-volume-4-meta-knight-mania-the-curse-of-the-castle-in-the-clouds/

Originality – 7/10

Back in the NES days, it was becoming increasingly difficult for video games to stand out from one another. Especially 2D side scrollers. But in my opinion, Masahiro Sakurai managed to do just that, and in some emphatic style too. With its exemplary conceptual design, along with some fun and varied gameplay, it certainly went leaps and bounds ahead of many different third-party efforts released on the NES, especially those designed by Colour Dreams, and did well to prolong the shelf life of the console for another year or so before Nintendo went on to create bigger and better things with this franchise among their many others.

Happii

Overall, Kirby’s Adventure is a very well-crafted title and satisfying to play, as well as excellent to look at for the time being. Witnessing the birth of the franchise, it’s no wonder to me why it would become one of the most prolific in Nintendo’s history over the last 20 years, and continues to be to this day.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Kingdom Under Fire Circle of Doom

Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom (Xbox 360)

Developer(s) – Blueside

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Game Studios

PEGI – 16

The latest release in the Kingdom Under Fire series, pending the release of Kingdom Under Fire II, announced at the Tokyo Game Show, Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom follows the less familiar hack-and-slash formula of the series. As opposed to the more familiar gameplay aspects that the series is known for, which are real-time strategy. It received mixed reviews from critics following its release. And after having played it for some time, it’s plain to see why.

Graphics – 7/10

One good thing I can say about the game, however, is that it does have some fairly attractive graphics. Both technically and conceptually. It actually does a decent job of displaying early on what kind of visuals the Xbox 360 was capable of running. There’s also diversity in level design, from stages ranging from vibrant forests to gloomy canyons to hellish caves. Enemy design, however, is very generic. With the same kinds of enemies appearing in multiple stages of the game, but simply palette-swapped.

Gameplay – 3.5/10

The game’s play revolves simply around hacking and slashing from point A to point B, with a boss at the end of each stage of the game. Though Hyrule Warriors is fairly bad for repetition, the degree to which this game takes it is unfathomable from very early on. There is some basis for variety. As there are multiple playable characters to go through the story, who all have their own set of abilities. But in all honesty, that’s as far as variety goes.

The second biggest focus in the game, I found, was learning all these different kinds of abilities. To learn an ability, the player must kill a pre-designated number of specific types of enemies. When this is achieved, the player can then enter safe sanctuaries. There are scattered all throughout the game, to collect a new ability and then begin to learn a new one. Annoyingly, only two abilities can be learned at a time. Adding a little bit of unnecessary longevity to the game.

Controls – 8/10

Although there is nothing wrong with how the control scheme is mapped out, I found that movement could be particularly stiff. In a game where movement plays a pretty pivotal role during combat, this can cause a few unnecessary complications while playing. And the last thing anyone needs whilst playing a hack-and-slash game, or indeed any other type of game, is an element of unfairness hindering the game’s sense of challenge. Apart from that, however, I found that there were thankfully no issues that needed to be addressed.

Lifespan – 8.5/10

For those who are willing to soldier through the sheer level of repetition attached to this title, this game can actually be made to last particularly long for a hack-and-slash game. If players desire to reach 100%, learn every character’s ability, and reach the level cap with every character, it will most probably take around 45 to 50 hours. But how long the game lasts ultimately depends on the player’s reaction to the gameplay. If players are much more lukewarm to the style of the game than I was, then they will be playing for a long time.

Storyline – 4/10

There isn’t very much in the way of the story of Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom. But rather a mere basic premise and back story. Nibel, the lord of light, and Encablossa, the lord of darkness, made a pact. Stating that each would take turns ruling the world. However, weary of the mistreatment of his creatures, Nibel refuses to relinquish his rule to Encablossa, infuriating him. Encablossa, in response, gathers his army to attack the world, and it is now the quest of the playable characters to defeat Encablossa and his army.

Beyond that, the story is elaborated on a whole lot. And it certainly could have done with being explained a lot more in-depth than it was. Though, of course, it works better for fans of the series, I don’t think it works at all for players who started the series with it and will inevitably think much less of it than they may have if they started from the beginning. The character who I think makes for the most interesting plot threads is Regnier. As his campaign unfolds, a dark back story is slowly revealed. And that does add a nice shock factor to the game. But apart from that, I don’t think the story was expanded on as much as it should have been to properly introduce newcomers to the series.

Originality – 4/10

Though the developers tried something new with the two hack-and-slash games in the Kingdom Under Fire series, it didn’t work. Since they didn’t really add anything to it to differentiate it from the many other games like it. I think there are many things the developers could have done to try to remedy that problem. Such as making the story more interesting. Or taking a lot of the repetition out of the game and adding much more variety to it. But ultimately, it just feels like a very generic hack-and-slash title.

Angrii

In summation, Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom is definitely one of the most unimaginative and repetitious games ever developed for the Xbox 360. Though not one of the worst games I’ve ever played, and it can actually offer quite a few hours of play to those willing to overlook how repetitive it is, it does feel like the game really needed an extra push, and the developers just didn’t try.

Score

35/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

Killzone: Shadow Fall (PlayStation 4)

Killzone: Shadow Fall

Developer(s) – Guerrilla Games

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Steven ter Heide

Producer – Qiong L.

PEGI – 18

Before Killzone: Shadow Fall, none of the Killzone games ever appealed to me. They just seemed like another clone of Call of Duty or Battlefield. Just with a more futuristic setting, with no outstanding gameplay features or any means of leaving any kind of lasting impression on me. After playing Shadow Fall, I discovered that I was more or less proven right. Despite how great the game looks, it does just play out relatively like any generic first-person shooter. But with an element of stealth added in. To me, Killzone: Shadow Fall is a pretty typical launch title; made simply to showcase the capabilities of its console in terms of both graphics and controls.

Graphics – 9.5/10

When I first laid eyes on this game, I’d never seen anything like it before. There was clearly an unfathomable amount of detail put into making this game look as stunning as possible in both graphical design and conceptual design. But I think the standout feature for me was how the levels in the middle of the game were set out. A lot of them are set in slums where the effects of the game’s events become most apparent. People are exiled and left to fend for themselves as a result of events such as war and political decline. Things like that have happened throughout the course of human history. And it’s portrayed in a very realistic manner.

Gameplay – 5/10

Unfortunately, the game’s visuals are indeed the only aspect that I can wax poetic about. To me, the gameplay is generic at best. For the most part, it is just a typical linear, run-and-gun first-person shooter. Similar to Medal of Honour and Call of Duty. There are a few stealth mechanics that stand out somewhat. But it’s all been done already. In fact, the only part of the game that truly stood out for me was the epilogue. Whereby the player takes control of an entirely different character to perform an additional assassination mission. But in my opinion, I certainly don’t think it’s worth having to play through the rest of the game to unlock the epilogue and play through it.

Controls – 10/10

A good thing I can say about this game, however, is that there are no problems with the controls. In fact, fairly decent use is made of the new control features that come with playing a game on the PlayStation 4, such as the touchpad.

Lifespan – 4/10

With side quests merely involving collecting things such as abandoned newspaper supplements and audiotapes, there didn’t seem to be enough to warrant even seven hours of gameplay in all. Games like this are more tailored for playing online. But I personally grew bored with playing online first-person shooters about as quickly as I started.

Storyline – 5/10

The story of Killzone: Shadow Fall follows a soldier called Lucas Kellen. He is tasked with helping to keep the peace between two factions fighting against each other. But soon after the game begins, tensions between the two factions reach a boiling point, and war soon breaks out. The lines between right and wrong begin to blur from Kellen’s point of view, and events soon unfold into something much more complicated. While the story is interesting at times, I found that it’s much too exclusive to fans of the series to truly appeal to any newcomers to the series. Playing through Shadow Fall certainly didn’t leave me with any desire to go back and play through the original Killzone trilogy, as Mass Effect 2 compelled me to go back and play through the first.

Originality – 3/10

The only remotely unique feature of Shadow Fall to me was the use of the OWL device in combat, which can be used to gain a tactical advantage over enemies. But other than that, there seem to be too many familiar first-person shooting elements in the game for me to be able to call it original.

Niiutral

To summarize, Killzone: Shadow Fall, to me, is a lot like a reality television show; it may look glamorous and extravagant on the surface, but it has little substance and only moderate instances of legitimate entertainment value.

Score

36.5/60

6/10 (Average)

Killer is Dead (Xbox 360 & PlayStation 3)

Killer is Dead

Developer(s) – Grasshopper Manufacture

Publisher(s) – Deep Silver

Director – Hideyuki Shin

Producer(s) – Yoshimi Yasuda & Shuji Ishikawa

PEGI – 18

Killer is Dead was launched at the back end of 2013 and was released to mixed reviews in different countries. In Japan, its country of origin, it was released to mostly positive reviews. Whilst the Western world was far more critical of the game, citing its allegedly nonsensical story and repetitive gameplay. Ray Carsillo of Electronic Gaming Monthly even went as far as to say that Killer is Dead had “the most ridiculous, nonsensical plot yet”.

Graphics – 8/10

As with many games I’ve reviewed up to this point in the blog, the best thing about it is how good it looks. There is a great deal of very decent use of cel-shaded graphics in this game. The game’s style is pretty compelling, and the settings are exceptional. Many segments of the game transpire in maze-like houses and even in a mansion on the moon. Although there are a few glitches here and there, they’re barely noticeable.

What players will be concentrating on most is the very effective use of lighting. This adds a very prominent sense of grit to the overall feel of the game. As the plot has gritty elements to it, with plenty of violence to accompany it. Blood sprays out in comic book-like geysers. Similar to other cel-shaded games like Madworld and No More Heroes. Some of the characters, including the main character, also have robotic limbs similar to Deus Ex. This makes for a few unique character designs, too. Albeit amidst some fairly generic-looking characters.

Gameplay – 5.5/10

After the first three hours or so, I found myself getting particularly bored with this game. It’s an action hack-and-slash game very similar to DMC: Devil May Cry. But just a lot more linear with equally unrefined combat. The game is set out in stages, requiring players to essentially get from point A to point B with a boss at the end of it. Although some of the boss’s fights at the end of each stage were pretty well thought out and some of them even fascinatingly disturbing (particularly the boss fight with Alice around the beginning of the game), they weren’t enough to save it overall, in my opinion.

There is only one side quest, which involves the main character working as a gigolo and wooing clients into bed by giving them presents and having players take suggestive snapshots of them. More explicit content is shown every time a player successfully woos one particular woman into bed. Which, in my opinion, is a particularly cheap way to get people to continue playing the game. As there doesn’t seem to be much more incentive for players other than gaining new weapons. The game, for me, lacks substance overall. Particularly, in chapter 5, there is not much to do other than walk around a strange moonlit landscape in slow motion, watch a few cutscenes, and kill a boss at the end of it. That chapter was clearly added as filler, the way I see it.

Controls – 9.5/10

Apart from the one minor flaw of it sometimes being difficult to hit breakable objects, which hold in-game items, there’s nothing at all else to complain about in terms of controls. Although the combat system is pretty bland and unelaborated on, that’s down to gameplay.

Lifespan – 6/10

If the cutscenes are skipped, which is a good idea given how ridiculous the game’s story is, this game can be easily completed within ten hours. For me, the incentive to play through the side quests was far too cheap. And the main gameplay can become far too monotonous to keep players engrossed in it for any extended amount of time anyway. Many better and longer hack-and-slash games were released last year. Including God of War: Ascension.

Storyline – 3/10

The game’s story centers on an assassin called Mondo Zappa. He carries out assassination missions for the Bryan Execution Firm along with his infinitely annoying and dim-witted assistant, Mika. They’re both tasked by their boss, Bryan Roses, to kill dangerous criminals all around the globe. Like Heart of Darkness, there are certain elements of the story that make it overall seem very far-fetched.

And make it seem like a lot of stuff was randomly put together in order to create a fully cohesive concept, and for me, it fell apart very quickly. It doesn’t help that there is some pretty bad voice acting in it as well. In particular, the character Mika is without a doubt one of the worst characters I’ve ever seen in a video game. She throws tantrums, cries a lot, and becomes far too childishly enthusiastic about her situation for me to be able to take her seriously. I don’t even think the main character, Mondo, can be taken seriously, as his catchphrase “The job… killer is dead” makes little to no sense.

Originality – 6/10

In terms of conceptual design, this game was always going to be able to stand out visually, as there are some unique settings and character designs, but no uniqueness lies in gameplay, which, for me, lessens it way too much for me to be able to call it a decent game. But with no standout personalities and a few fairly good boss fights, the overall feel of the game can get boring after a while.

Niiutral

To summarize, Killer is Dead is playable, but shouldn’t be considered a classic by any means. There are other games of its kind that I would more highly recommend than this. I may have found a few decent games released in 2013 following my initial skepticism, but I think this is definitely one to steer clear of.

Score

36/60

6/10 (Average)

Kameo: Elements of Power (Xbox 360)

Kameo Elements of Power

Developer(s) – Rare

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Game Studios

Designer – George Andreas

PEGI – 12

Kameo: Elements of Power is an adventure game developed by Rare.  Originally, it was intended to be a launch title for the GameCube back in 2001. A screenshot of the GameCube game can actually be seen on the box for early GameCube consoles. Alongside another canceled title, Donkey Kong Racing. It was eventually re-imagined as the very first title announced for release on the Xbox 360 back in 2005. Though launch titles are, for the most part, hit or miss, and this game has its flaws, I didn’t find Kameo anywhere near as bad as I thought I would.

Graphics – 6/10

Conceptually, the game reminded me very much of Spyro the Dragon. Even the title logo is extremely similar. By that token, there’s not a great deal in the game to make it stand out to an exceptional extent. But there are a few elements, such as the multiple playable character design, for example. In terms of visuals, the best thing that was achieved with this title was showing gamers what the Xbox 360 was capable of on a graphical scale. As indeed a launch title should. In particular, the water effects are very realistic-looking for the time. But gamers would be treated to better-looking games in the future.

Gameplay – 7/10

The game relies heavily on the player assigning different controllable creatures to different buttons on the controller. And using these creatures to access different areas in the game, and for use in combat. There’s also a fair amount of emphasis put on things like adventure, puzzle-solving, and exploration. I found it to be moderately enjoyable to play. There’s a fair amount of variety to experience in the multiple playable characters that accumulate throughout the course of the game. Which, in a sense, reminded me a lot of Skylanders. Only six years earlier. There are also a fair few side quests throughout the game, which is always a plus.

Controls- 7/10

The main problem I found with the controls as they were pretty stiff and difficult to cope with at times. Movement, especially in combat, can feel like quite a chore. And it adds a lot of unnecessary complication to the game overall. Also, I can’t help but feel that the controls were stiff, which also hindered gameplay because there is a lot to keep up with, since different characters had entirely different abilities. And by that token, the stiff controls took a lot of fluency out of the game, too. But it is also interesting to understand how the game would have possibly worked better on the GameCube in terms of controls.

Lifespan – 5/10

In total, Kameo can take less than 10 hours to play, which is particularly underwhelming for a game. Especially as it puts a fair amount of emphasis on elements such as exploration and adventure. I couldn’t help but feel even more let down by this due to the fact that the game had been in development for so long, and Rare did have a fair amount of time to add more to it before it was released.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of Kameo: Elements of Power involves its titular character, a shape-shifting fairy, on an adventure to rescue the elemental ancestors and defeat the evil dark troll king, Thorn. I found the story to be a little less generic than I first expected it would be. Although the basic premise has been repeated many times in video gaming as well as in other forms of media, there are a few twists and turns before the end; although I found one fairly major plot twist, in particular, to become virtually from the get-go.

Originality – 6/10

In terms of gameplay, Kameo: Elements of Power seems to vaguely serve as a precursor to the idea behind Skylanders’ style of gameplay. But in terms of things like visual concept and story, I don’t think it stands out even as well as other launch titles have done in the past. If it had been released on the GameCube, I think it would have had a tough time competing with Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem in particular, given how unique that game was and still is.

Niiutral

In summation, Kameo: Elements of Power does have its gameplay value, and did showcase the Xbox 360 graphical power very capably. For the generic-looking launch title, it would appear, on the surface, it’s actually not as bad a game as a player may expect it to be, especially for a Microsoft-published Rare title.

Score

37/60

6/10 (Average)

Kaiju Panic (PC)

Kaiju Panic

Developer(s) – Mechabit Games

PEGI – 7

Developed by Mechabit Games, a small development company based in Liverpool, Kaiju Panic is a tower defense game. Heavily influenced by Japanese culture in terms of conceptual design. And encouraging players to adopt an extremely heavy tactical approach to progress. As I said in my Play Manchester Article, this was my favorite indie game to be displayed at the show. And after having played the finished product, it has become my favorite indie game to have been released this year, too.

Graphics –9/10

Visually, the game seems to be somewhat of a love letter to the SNES classic, EarthBound, featuring a wide variety of vibrant and colorful modern-day environments. And containing an even wider variety of monsters to have to fend off. And characters to have to rescue along the way. I was particularly impressed by what I saw throughout. Not only is its core conceptual design extremely creative, but there is certainly scope for the developers to build upon the mythology of the game even more. Making me extremely excited for the future of what could potentially be a very distinct and very successful franchise.

Gameplay – 10/10

The gameplay is also just as creative, as well as being insanely addictive. Plays must work to protect cities from an attack carried out by sinister monsters called Kaiju. Players do this by gathering civilians, mining for resources, and building gun turrets of different varieties in order to battle different types of Kaiju that have distinct weaknesses. For example, certain Kaiju may be weak against corrosive attacks. Whilst others may be weak against laser-based attacks. The game demands that players try out different methods. Forcing them to adopt different tactics to suit different levels and progress through the game. There are also unlockable perks and upgrades to be obtained. Adding even more replay value to it.

Controls – 9.5/10

Personally, it took me a little bit of time to get used to the game’s control scheme. Since the player has to use the mouse to look around each level and observe what activity occurs. They must also use the keyboard to move the character around. Often at the same time. But once players get used to it, there are no issues to be experienced in Kaiju Panic. And therefore, the game plays out as well as any other PC-based tower defense game or real-time strategy game. I, of course, have to commend the developers for daring to try something different. And making it work very well overall.

Lifespan – 7/10

Taking everything into account, the game can be made to last at least 20-25 hours. Which, whilst quite impressive, ultimately left me wanting more. In turn, however, that again made me excited about what kind of directions the developers could take in a potential sequel. In my opinion, there is a great amount of possibility to not only expand on the lore and mythology of the game, but to expand on the core concept of gameplay. And the number of different gameplay modes, too.

Storyline – 7/10

Simplistic in general concept, the story of Kaiju Panic follows a general, with the help of Earth’s citizens, who must fend off a planetary invasion orchestrated by the Kaiju. Although the game’s story can be viewed as straightforward in scope, it is kept interesting by the series of cutscenes that occur between each level, and how events unfold that depict distinct events that happen around the core plot. Some of them also provide the game with a small comedic element, which I found gave it a pretty distinct charm.

Originality – 8/10

Although there have been many games of its kind to have come and gone over many years, I think the developers did a particularly good job of making this one stand out among the vast majority of them. Employing a unique conceptual design, along with a distinct style of play and control scheme, I’ve come across very few indie games so far that incorporate such a great deal of originality, and to me, it has been instrumental in showing exactly what indie developers are capable of if they truly believe that what they have created can work, and extremely well. And in my opinion, this title certainly works extremely well indeed.

Happii

Overall, Kaiju Panic is one of the best indie games I have played. It’s charming, addictive, and creative, and if a franchise is ever born from this title, it certainly has a great deal of potential for the future. I highly recommend it.

Score

50.5

8/10 (Very Good)