Tag Archives: Liverpool

Malice (PlayStation 2 & Xbox)

Malice

Developer(s) – Argonaut Games

Publisher(s) – Mud Duck Productions & Evolved Games

Director – Phil Morris

Producer – Andy Pang

PEGI – 7

Malice was a game released back in 2004, loosely based on Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland. But truth be told, the finished product is nowhere near as imaginative or culturally impactful. In fact, the most interesting thing about this game is its development history. At first, it was intended for release on the original PlayStation back in the late 90s. However, due to the first of many production management mishaps, the idea was subsequently scrapped in favor of releasing the game as an Xbox launch title in late 2001.

In 2002, having failed to get the game out in time, it was announced that members of the band No Doubt were to lend their voice talents to the project. With lead singer Gwen Stefani providing the role of the game’s titular main character, Malice. The band said in an interview that they were particularly excited to see their music reach a wider audience in the video gaming industry. By early 2003, Argonaut had yet to get the game out to retailers. The company faced hardships, including financial problems (as they’d spent millions of dollars developing the game) and further corporate meddling. And even the untimely death of one of their conceptual artists, Alecsandar Ilic, who tragically passed away at the age of 30. It was announced on May 30th that the game had been canceled.

Afterward, a different company got publishing rights, and the project was subsequently revived. And the game was eventually released in 2004 to a very mediocre reception from both gamers and reviewers alike. And after having played it, it’s no wonder why.

Graphics – 4/10

Everything about this game is seemingly rushed, and the visuals are no exception. From the get-go, I kept thinking to myself that it looks like it could indeed easily run on the original PlayStation. As the game looked a generation old for the time. On top of that, I think the game just looks inherently generic. In that, the settings and the character, enemy, and boss designs are all pretty unimaginative and annoying in some cases. Like the crows in suits who let out irritating noises as they attack or take damage. Another issue I have with it is that it baffles me how it only runs at 30 frames per second when it just looks like it ought to run at 60, and how bad it looks.

Gameplay – 3/10

Even though it was released on the original PlayStation, the game’s play is too simplistic, insubstantial, and boring to have held up. A 3D platforming game, it has merely one side quest, unrefined combat, no replay value whatsoever, and terrible, drawn-out boss fights. I was fighting the second boss for about ten minutes with very little difficulty, just wanting above all else for it to be over.

Controls – 6/10

The main gripes I have about this game’s control scheme involve jumping mechanics. If jumping mechanics aren’t done right in a platforming game, players will know instantly that there’ll be problems throughout. One of the most stable elements of platforming games is the ability to jump from platform to platform. Another problem I had with this game was the inability to move my character while trying to attack. Every time the player presses the attack button, Malice stands completely still and swings her weapon, which eliminates any fluency in combat and unnecessarily complicates things.

Lifespan – 5/10

For even a late 90s platforming game to last less than 10 hours is absolutely unacceptable. If Argonaut Games truly wanted this game to last longer or do well, they needed an extra push in every department before launch. But unfortunately, they couldn’t do that. Presumably having blown a lot of their budget on hiring No Doubt to provide voice acting for the game. Which didn’t happen anyway.

Storyline – 3/10

The game’s story follows the quest of a red-haired goddess called Malice. Who is aiming to save the world by restoring power to a machine called the orrery and defeating an evil demon called Dog God? It’s laughable at best. No character can be taken seriously because the voice acting that was eventually used in the end is farcical. In addition, the story is extremely flawed and hardly makes any sense.

Originality – 0/10

There is absolutely nothing in this game that I haven’t seen before, and would never want to see again. I never want to see a combat system so unrefined, an in-game world that looks like someone threw up in the console. And a story that no one in their right mind would care to follow.

Furiious

My biggest piece of advice to anyone who picks this game up in a shop and reads the part of the synopsis on the box that says “fantastic graphics, fluid gameplay, compelling storyline, and funny characterization” is to not pay attention to it because of its false advertisement. Malice has none of those things.

Score

21/60

3.5/10 (Very Poor)

The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (PlayStation 2, Xbox, PC & Gameboy Advance)

The Lord of the Rings The Fellowship of the Ring

Developer(s) – WXP Games & Surreal Software

Publisher(s) – Black Label Game, Universal Interactive & Sierra Entertainment

Designer – Todd Clineschmidt

Producer – Nick Radovich

PEGI – 12

Released around the same time as the Peter Jackson film trilogy, and when the franchise was the subject of a great many licensed games. WXP Games’ Lord of the Rings interpretation was a 3D platforming adventure title. With an emphasis on side quests and a degree of exploration. Surpassing my expectations, this is, in fact, a fairly enjoyable title. And it’s a pity that the planned sequels were canceled, since I believe there were many ways in which the developers could have expanded upon what they had created with this game.

Graphics – 7/10

Though the majority of the conceptual design of this game is based on the film trilogy, there are certain elements that make it stand out from it. Such as the re-imagining of locations such as Barad-Dur and the Mines of Moria. The location that fails to stand out the most is the Shire. Since it is more or less identical to that of the films. But there are also other locations included, such as the forest in which Tom Bombadil dwells. Unlike the films, he also makes an appearance.

Gameplay – 7/10

As I pointed out, the game revolves around adventure. Elements of exploration, combat, and the occasional puzzle-solving. Players control Frodo, Gandalf, and Aragorn, and each character has their own set of abilities and purposes throughout the game. Giving it a fair amount of variety. For example, there are many side quests to be completed throughout the first part of the game. Whereas Aragorn and Gandalf’s roles are much more combat-oriented. The gripe I have with it is that the side quests virtually stop after the first part of the game. And I think the developers could easily have added a few more beyond that.

Controls – 10/10

Not only are there no problems with the game’s control scheme. But with the facility to control three different characters, the game is also kept interesting with players having to adapt to multiple styles of play. Which are all easy enough to get to grips with, and fast.

Lifespan – 6/10

For a game based on such a long book as even the first chapter of the trilogy, the game lasts a fair amount of time. At around 6 to 7 hours. But as I alluded to before, I can’t help but think that if the developers had added a few more side quests to both Aragorn’s and Gandalf’s sequences in the game, then it could easily have been made to last much longer.

Storyline – 9/10

Having read the books and watched the films, I was captivated by the story of The Lord of the Rings long before I started playing this game. For those who may not know the basic plot, Frodo Baggins is a hobbit living in the Shire. When he inherits a magic ring from his uncle Bilbo. His friend Gandalf arrives to inform him that the ring is, in fact, that of the dark lord Sauron. Who attempted to rule Middle-Earth with the power of the ring thousands of years prior to the start of the story.

Frodo resolves to destroy it by journeying to Mt Doom, the only place where it can be destroyed. Along with a company of friends and warriors from across the land. The manner in which it is portrayed in the game is very much akin to that of the book, but the only downside to it is the character of Frodo. Unlike Elijah Wood or even Christopher Guard’s portrayal of him, he seems far too jolly for the most part to me. And doesn’t seem to fully realize the gravity of the situation.

Originality – 6/10

At this time, gamers were rightfully in the mindset that licensed games were generally of much lesser quality than unlicensed games were. For the most part, this was true. And it wasn’t until Batman: Arkham Asylum in 2009 that this trend was broken. But this game wasn’t too bad compared to most others, in my opinion. Even though it follows many different trends that had already been established by other developers beforehand, every element of gameplay comes together well. And plays out adequately, despite the fact that there was indeed room for improvement.

Happii

In summation, The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring was a fairly commendable attempt to bring the license to the gaming industry and excelled above many other licensed games at that time. I think the sequels would most probably have been better if they had ever seen the light of day, but this would have been a sufficient starting point.

Score

45/60

7.5/10 (Good)

The Legend of Zelda: Tri Force Heroes (3DS)

The Legend of Zelda Tri Force Heroes

Developer(s) – Nintendo EPD & Grezzo

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Designer – Hiromasa Shikata

Producer – Eiji Aonuma

PEGI – 7

Released in 2015 as a direct sequel to the critically acclaimed A Link Between Worlds, Tri Force Heroes took the Legend of Zelda series in a new direction reminiscent of the Game Boy Advance installment Four Swords. Whereby players can play either solo or as part of a trio to solve numerous puzzles. And fight against enemies and bosses, and harness the power of different garments that can be bought throughout the game. Despite the fact that Nintendo was willing to try something new with the franchise, I still found it to be one of the weaker entries in the series. But overall, not one of the worst games I’ve ever played personally.

Graphics – 8/10

Taking place in the land of Hytopia, and taking a fairly distant departure from the usual locations and basic structure associated with most Zelda games set in the land of Hyrule, the game has a fair bit of diversity in terms of visual presentation. Although it’s a little more light-hearted than other entries in the series and doesn’t include as many dark locations as the likes of Ocarina of Time, Majora’s Mask, and Twilight Princess, it has much of the same charm that came with installments like The Wind Waker or Minish Cap.

Gameplay – 7/10

Arguably more so than other Zelda gems, Tri Force Heroes has a very heavy focus on the element of puzzle-solving. With players having to either work together or alone. Using all three links to overcome each different obstacle in each level and defeat the boss at the end of it. There are also bonus challenges with each level that range from completing them in a set amount of time. Or clearing them whilst taking little to no damage. The biggest gripe I have with the gameplay is that the bosses can become quite repetitive after a while. This falls way short of Legend of Zelda standards. The series has become renowned over the years for its diversity in boss fights.

Controls – 9/10

The controls can be a little bit difficult to get to grips with at first. But once this has been achieved, which won’t take too long, it plays out more or less as well as any other game in the series. There is a lack of control features compared to most other games. Since more often than not, players will choose one item for each Link toward the beginning of each level. And will have to stick with the said items for the level’s duration. But otherwise, there are no other issues with the game’s controls to address.

Lifespan – 5/10

Underwhelmingly, the game can only be made to last around 15 to 20 hours. To me personally, as a Legend of Zelda fan, and who likes to leave no stone unturned whilst playing a Zelda game, it would be like a speed run. The problem lies mainly in the fact that Tri Force Heroes has a much more linear progression than most other games in the franchise. This, in turn, goes against every reason why Shigeru Miyamoto created the original game in the first place. Making seems all the more disappointing.

Storyline – 6/10

Aside from the game not lasting very long, the story isn’t truly up to much, either, in my opinion. Princess Styla is one day cursed by a witch known as The Lady to wear an ugly black jumpsuit. And if that sentence alone isn’t enough to make you despair, I don’t want to know what is. The King of Hytopia, in turn, calls upon a hero who can lift the curse and bring peace to the land; enter Link. That’s all there is to it. There aren’t any of the amazing plot twists or dark undertones to accompany it. This makes almost every other installment of the series a great game in its own right. And numerous plot holes. For example, there is nothing to suggest that Princess Styla couldn’t simply wear something over the jumpsuit.

Originality – 6.5/10

I would say that the game does have some uniqueness to it, but for the most part, it stands out for the wrong reasons. The puzzles can be fairly elaborate and challenging, and there is a little replay value to be had in the additional objectives to be completed throughout each level, but whenever a Zelda game springs to mind, I most often think of an experience to be lost within and to have to invest a lot of time in doing everything that needs to be done. Unfortunately, I found it impossible to feel the same way about this game.

Niiutral

Overall, Tri Force Heroes, whilst it isn’t even the worst installment in the Zelda series (by far, that honor would go to the Wand of Gamelon), it falls way short of expectations, and makes no effort to perpetuate all the things that make the franchise as great as it is. However, that’s not to say that it’s a terrible game; there is some enjoyment to be had out of it for the short time that it lasts, and the quality in gameplay greatly outweighs what little quality it has in store.

Score

41.5/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask (Nintendo 64)

The Legend of Zelda Majoras Mask

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Eiji Aonuma & Yoshiaki Koizumi

Producer – Shigeru Miyamoto

PEGI – 12

Considered to be the black sheep of the series, The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask offered a very different video gaming experience from that of its legendary predecessor, The Ocarina of Time. As well as being a fairly enjoyable game, in my opinion, it also excels in storytelling on a level that most games didn’t at the time. And even on a level that most games don’t have today.

Graphics – 10/10

As polished and conceptually wonderful as its predecessor, Majora’s Mask remains to this day one of the best-looking video games of all time. Certainly one of the best-looking on the Nintendo 64. Although there are recycled elements taken from Ocarina of Time, it has even been theorized by many that this could be part of the story itself. But though most of the supporting NPCs aren’t new, the setting and the overall visual style certainly are. They’re exciting, immersing, and at times wonderfully disturbing too. Not only do they work to effectively differentiate it from Ocarina of Time. But they work to effectively differentiate it from any other game in the series. As well as other games in general.

Gameplay – 7/10

Overall, the game is almost as satisfying and exciting to play through as the first. With plenty of intense combat to engage in, and intricate puzzles to solve. The added feature of using various masks, granting Link many different abilities, also offers a fun twist to the overall Legend of Zelda gameplay formula. Offering variety in a very different way than in other games in the series. However, the one thing that personally inconvenienced me about this game was the time limit that was implemented. The player gets 3 in-game days to undertake each quest at a time until the world is destroyed. Canceling out everything that had been done before the start of the 3 days.

Even though it was suggested by Shigeru Miyamoto and put in to heighten the game’s sense of challenge (as well as being a possible dark allegory of how all human endeavor is ultimately pointless), to me, it severely hindered what should be, in my opinion, a game without elements like that. I think that even taking into account the infamous 4th-day glitch (a well-known glitch. Which can be implemented to add a day to the time limit), that element shouldn’t be present at all. I think leaving that would have given players more time to enjoy the game more positively and fluently. If players find themselves repeating the same task over and over again, they can convey a level of frustration unlike any other game.

Controls – 8/10

In the Great Bay Temple, Link is required to wear the Zora mask to get around. This allows him to swim deeper and faster underwater. The problem with this is that the controls for these sections of the game are pretty unrefined. And it is easy to find plenty of obstruction throughout. Other than that, however, the control scheme remains largely the same as that of Ocarina of Time. And has now said this. The other masks do provide a fairly decent twist on the first game’s controls.

Lifespan – 7/10

Although Major’s Mask doesn’t last as long as its predecessor, there is still a fair amount to do within the game.  That overall will warrant about 25-30 hours, which isn’t bad at all. Aside from the main story quest, there are a good few side quests to undertake throughout. This also adds greatly to the game’s atmosphere and subtly conveys many of the varied and rich story elements found throughout.

Players may assume that it would have been easier to make a Zelda game that lasted just as long as Ocarina of Time. Since the gaming engine and various elements in the second game already existed prior to the start of development, the fact of the matter is that the development process was a bit more convoluted than people may have realized. Since it was originally planned for release on the ill-fated Nintendo 64DD, several other projects were in the works at the time.

Storyline – 10/10

The best thing about The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask for me, however, is undoubtedly the story. Following on as a direct sequel to Ocarina of Time, Link is on a quest to find his former companion, Navi the Fairy. He is ambushed by a mysterious character called Skull Kid. Who steals from Link both the Ocarina of Time and his horse Epona. Giving chase, Link subsequently finds himself in a foreign land called Termina, which is under threat by Skull Kid. Who plans to use a powerful weapon called Majora’s Mask to crash the moon into Termina and thus destroy the world. It is up to Link to recover Majora’s Mask and stop the looming apocalypse.

However, my short synopsis does not do this game justice. As well as incorporating several dark situations and subject matters, the game also deals with a large number of mature topics and themes on a level. This was rarely seen in Nintendo games at the time. And it is still so to this day. There is also a widely popular theory about Majora’s Mask that has been circulating on the internet for a long time now. Drawing connections between the game’s story and the Kübler-Ross model of grief. That could make for a whole other series of articles in itself. As I said, Majora’s Mask is considered the black sheep of the Legend of Zelda series. And after having played it, it’s not hard to see why.

Originality – 8/10

Though gameplay remains largely instead of the Legend of Zelda tradition, the magnitude of the game’s story. As well as both the decent amount of in-game variety and visual style helped to keep the franchise unprecedentedly unique at the time. It still holds up to this day as one of the most standout games ever made. Consequently, this game has remained adored by the gaming community. And that adoration reached a new generation of Nintendo fans since the game was re-released on the 3DS.

Happii

Overall, although I found the 3-day time limit to severely hinder the quality of the gameplay, the fact of the matter is that The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask is a game bigger than itself. It stands out as one of the greatest games of the fifth generation. Though it has split fans of the series firmly down the middle, Nintendo was not scared to try something completely different. And I think they accomplished that with this game flawlessly.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)

The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds (3DS)

The Legend of Zelda A Link Between Worlds

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Group No 3 & Monolith Soft

Publisher – Nintendo

Director – Hiromasa Shikata

Producer – Eiji Aonuma

PEGI – 7

A throwback to the SNES classic, A Link to the Past, A Link Between Worlds revisited a very similar landscape to that imagined by Nintendo back in the early 90s. It had arrived with a newer coat of paint in terms of visuals as well as a modified approach to gameplay. With a few new mechanics and features. Whilst it doesn’t come very close to matching the same quality as A Link to the Past, in my opinion, I still found it to be a very decent game. And an exciting new take on the Legend of Zelda universe.

Graphics – 8.5/10

The newly polished setting from A Link to the Past looks spectacular, with classic locations of the series. Such as Death Mountain and Kakariko Village. But throughout the game, the standout feature in terms of visuals was the new dungeons added. They’re almost as elaborate and intriguing as the ones found in A Link to the Past. But whilst one of the two early dungeons has a unique boss, the other has a recycled boss. In the latter half of the game, however, the scenery gets much better. When the constant switching between the worlds of Hyrule and Lorule becomes necessary.

The dungeons in Lorule are a lot more elaborate and original, with more unique-looking bosses. These do well to differentiate it as much from A Link to the Past as possible. The main problem I have with the game’s graphics is the general enemy design. Most are simply recycled 3D versions of the enemies found in A Link to the Past. It would’ve been a good idea to throw one or two more new enemies in for good measure. But the game lacks uniqueness in that respect. With most entries in the title, different enemies always seem to be added. But with A Link Between Worlds, the developers seem to have taken a small step back. Nevertheless, the game’s overall style does present a mostly even balance between classic and new. Mostly with the new dungeons designed.

Gameplay – 8/10

For me, this game took some getting into at first. For the opening hour or so, it just seemed like I was playing nothing more than a glorified version of A Link to the Past. It uses virtually the same game mechanics as the 1991 classic. But when I first entered Lorule, that was when I found that the game really started to come into its own. It is certainly worth persevering through to experience the positive change of gameplay that lasts throughout the rest of the game. There is a gameplay mechanic new to the series that allows the player to merge links into walls and traverse along them to reach certain areas. This was actually inspired by the Phantom Ganon boss fight from Ocarina of Time. It’s incorporated early on into the game.

But it’s put to better use in the second half. Having to be used to solve more elaborate puzzles within more intricate dungeons. Its use is even necessitated to fight certain bosses as well. There was one other gameplay mechanic that I didn’t like at first, but I grew used to it. To get the in-game items that are typically found in dungeons, instead, they are found in a shop, which, at first, the player has to rent. And that is taken away every time the player dies in the game.

Cont…

At first, I struggled to see the point of it. But after advancing further into the game, I found they could be bought outright for a higher price. I realized it was simply to better incorporate the need for the game’s currency, which is fair enough. These new mechanics present players with positive changes from the normal features typically found in Zelda games, like Breath of the Wild, for example. They make for a very decent game, overall.

Controls – 10/10

As someone who played through A Link to the Past back at the game’s commercial apex, I was never going to have a problem getting to grips with how it plays out. It uses a control scheme virtually identical to the old Super Nintendo game. But that’s not to say that newcomers to the series or to this in a particular style of play will experience any problems with it. The controls are straightforward, with the only new outstanding control element being the wall-merging ability. Which, again, no player would have problems with.

Lifespan – 7/10

Although it does take a fair bit of time to play through the main story, instead of the Zelda tradition, there was also a surprising lack of side quests. Normally, Zelda games have a fair amount of them. But I was bewildered to find how few of them there are in this installment. There’s a side quest to do, which involves collecting ore to enhance the power of the master sword at the blacksmiths, and another involving a witch who provides a fast-travel gameplay mechanic (again, reminiscent of the one found in A Link to the Past). But for me, the amount of side quests falls well short of the normal amount usually found in a lot of other Zelda games. This game could’ve been done with a few more, in my opinion. But A Link Between Worlds will make for around 10-12 hours of gameplay, which isn’t too bad.

Storyline – 8/10

Whilst not a huge departure from other titles in the series, the game’s story is still very engrossing nonetheless. In A Link Between Worlds, Link is out to save the land of Hyrule, Princess Zelda, and seven sages from a priest called Yuga. After gaining the three pendants of courage, power, and wisdom and retrieving the master sword, Link travels to Hyrule Castle to confront Yuga. But he finds he is too late, and Yuga has imprisoned Zelda and the sages inside portraits. He uses these to manifest into the franchise’s iconic villain, Ganon.

Before he transforms, Link follows Yuga into an alternate, darker version of Hyrule called Lorule and is asked by the princess of Lorule, Hilda, to save both worlds and defeat Ganon. The story unfolds into something much more elaborate with a few excellent plot twists along the way. Whilst the lack of side quests was a letdown for me personally, I found this game’s story to be very enthralling indeed. Which with the inclusion of Lorule, I believe, could potentially present new possibilities for where the franchise could go in the future. It may all make for an even further departure from normal Zelda story elements and bring more new things to the table.

Originality – 8/10

I think that although many elements are undeniably recycled from A Link to the Past, there is indeed enough in this title to make it stand out from other games of its kind, as well as other entries in the series. For me, this is the best original DS Zelda game by some distance. I wasn’t very impressed with either The Phantom Hourglass or Spirit Tracks. The control scheme incorporated in both those games thoroughly annoyed me. Undoubtedly, the most unique aspect of this game is the design of the dungeons and bosses. It’s elements like that, which have kept this franchise fresh and will continue to do so for years to come.

Happii

Overall, this game made for a very well-designed and enjoyable experience. It is definitely not only one of the standout titles for the 3DS. But it is indeed one of the standout titles of 2013. I said in a previous article that I would revisit last year’s game releases to see if any games are worth playing, and this one definitely is.

Score

49.5/60

8/10 (Very Good)

The Last of Us (PlayStation 3 & PlayStation 4)

The Last of Us

Developer(s) – Naughty Dog

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director(s) – Bruce Straley & Neil Druckmann

Designer – Jacob Minkoff

PEGI – 18

Selling millions of copies worldwide and garnering many perfect scores from reviewers, as well as a near-perfect score of 38/40 from Famitsu, The Last of Us is considered one of the defining titles of the PlayStation 3’s library by gamers and critics alike. I, on the other hand…

Graphics – 8/10

One positive to discuss regarding this game, at least, is how good it looks. The game is both conceptually and graphically sound. Aside from representing the pinnacle of what the PlayStation 3 is capable of on a graphical level, for the most part, it also presents a very interesting, yet unsettling, take on how post-apocalyptic Earth would be governed under martial law. And how humanity would cope under such circumstances. Or how it wouldn’t. There are also a few glitches in the game here and there, but nothing overly noticeable. Certainly not on the same level as Aliens: Colonial Marines, which I reviewed last week. It’s interesting to see where Naughty Dog’s influence comes in. As similarities can be drawn with their own Uncharted series. One of the game’s main characters, Joel, also wears similar attire to that of Nathan Drake, the main character of Uncharted.

Gameplay – 3/10

The gameplay, however, is the aspect that I find most difficult to wax poetic about. Before playing, I had heard through bad word of mouth that this game had its downsides. Such as its level of linearity and lack of overall substance. But I initially thought to myself that it surely couldn’t have been as bad as people made out to me. But I actually found it worse than what people made out, unfortunately.

I found myself very disappointed with The Last of Us. The game only encourages exploration to a very small extent. And having players search areas where they think there may be hidden side quest items, but when there is nothing. Though it is common to have merely decorative areas, this game takes it to a pretty ridiculous level. It even reminded me of Murdered: Soul Suspect in terms of how repetitive it can get. But in this case, it’s to an even greater extent than that. At least there were side quests in Murdered: Soul Suspect. But in The Last of Us, there are considerably fewer.

Controls – 10/10

There are no issues with the game’s control scheme, but it plays out very similarly to any game in the Uncharted series. But with a greater emphasis on stealth as a combat option, I don’t think there should have been any issues with the control scheme, really. This control scheme was evolutionary during the time Naughty Dog developed Uncharted. And although the game loses no marks for not having any problems, it certainly didn’t do itself any favors by not adding anything new to the table.

Lifespan – 5/10

Discounting the DLC package, Left Behind, and The Last of Us can take an average time of 12 hours to complete. But whilst that may sound fairly impressive for a game of this kind compared to any game in the Uncharted series, most time will be spent watching the cutscenes and taking in the game’s story as opposed to players actually playing the game. Although it would seem to last twice as long as an Uncharted game, it’s far less enjoyable to play. And by that token can make it seem much more drawn out.

Storyline – 9/10

Without a shadow of a doubt, the best thing that can be attributed to this game is its extremely immersive story. Taking place on a post-apocalyptic Earth following the spread of a deadly advanced strain of the Cordyceps fungus, which turns humans into cannibalistic monsters known as clickers, Joel, a human survivor who lost his daughter twenty years before the game’s main events, finds himself escorting a young girl called Ellie across the United States to survive and put a stop to the deadly virus once and for all.

The narrative told in this game is incredible, with great voice acting. And a lot of emphasis on character development. And a good few twists and turns throughout. The overall atmosphere of the game alternates from being very intense and very emotional as the relationship between Joel and Ellie progresses throughout the course of the game. Although it is never worth sacrificing good gameplay in favor of immersing in the story. To me is become a recurring problem in mainstream titles; the game certainly has a great deal of substance in the story, nevertheless.

Originality – 3/10

Though I can’t deny the historical significance of this title for its excellent story, there is hardly anything either original or innovative about the gameplay in The Last of Us. And it’s not as if video games hadn’t had great stories attributed to them prior. There has been a much greater narrative told in video games before the release of The Last of Us, but have also included greater gameplay.

Niiutral

Overall, whilst having a fantastic and engrossing plot and conceptually and graphically astute visuals, there was definitely room for improvement in terms of both substance and innovation in gameplay. The gameplay is the most important aspect of any video game. And my biggest hope for Naughty Dog now is that they haven’t completely lost sight of that, pending the release of Uncharted 4.

Score

38/60

6/10 (Average)

Luigi’s Mansion (GameCube & 3DS)

Luigis Mansion

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Hideki Konno

Producer(s) – Shigeru Miyamoto & Takashi Tezuka

PEGI – 7

Released as a launch title for the GameCube after undergoing an extremely in-depth and long-winded development cycle, Luigi’s Mansion took on a much darker and grittier tone than anything seen in the Super Mario series prior. Featuring Mario’s brother Luigi as the main character, as he traverses through a creepy mansion. Wielding nothing but a vacuum cleaner to clean the house of a ghost infestation in the style of Ghostbusters. Going on to become the best-selling game of November 2001, and garnishing a great deal of critical acclaim, the game has rightfully earned its place among the best of Nintendo’s repertoire. It is a game I have personally come back to again and again.

Graphics – 8/10

Unlike any other Super Mario game, the title took the scary and dark atmosphere of the many ghost house levels found in the rest of the series and ran with it. Not only is there a huge haunted house with many twists and turns. But the surrounding area is also extremely morbid and out of place. Signifying death and the foretelling of death with elements such as crows and dead trees.

But of course, it’s inside the mansion where the majority of this game’s chills are housed. Featuring not only a wide range of eerie apparitions haunting the place for Luigi to deal with, but extremely effective use of lighting throughout. In areas that have yet to be explored thoroughly, light is limited only to Luigi’s torch. And it does an extremely good job of building tension, which is one of the most popular tropes of horror in general. Be that in books or films, as well as games.

Gameplay – 9/10

The objective of the game is to clear the mansion of as many ghosts as possible using Luigi’s newly acquired weapon, the Poltergust 3000. There are many hidden areas in the mansion, as well as a fair few side quests in each stage. Including tracking down 50 Boos hidden within different parts. The game also has somewhat of an arcade feel to it. Players have to collect as much money and treasure as possible throughout each segment. Thus, racking up as impressive a high score as possible. It plays out unlike any other Super Mario game ever developed. Or any other Nintendo game ever developed, for that matter. It’s extremely satisfying to do everything there is to do and uncover every secret there is to find.

Controls – 9/10

In terms of controls, the game doesn’t pose too many problems. It can take a little bit of time to get used to how Luigi both moves and aims with the Poltergust 3000. Since the c-stick is used to move him around, whilst he is using the weapon to collect things like money and treasure throughout each room. But thankfully, this does nothing to hinder the quality of the combat system. As control is then swapped out for the main analog, making things much easier without the worry of over-complication.

Lifespan – 6.5/10

Disappointingly, the game can only be made to last around 5 to 6 hours. Early in development, there was talk of the inclusion of an RPG element in the game. And I’ve always wondered how that would have worked out. As a fan of the genre, I can’t help but think that the introduction of such mechanics would have drastically improved the game and made it even more interesting than it turned out to be. And most definitely added much more longevity to it.

Storyline – 8/10

Luigi’s Mansion follows Mario’s brother, Luigi, as he wins a mansion in a competition he strangely didn’t even enter. Upon arriving at the mansion, he soon discovers that it is wrought with danger. And he meets a new character in the series, Professor E. Gadd. Gadd trains Luigi to use his invention, the Poltergust 3000, to get rid of the ghosts inside. And to free his brother, who is trapped somewhere inside the creepy haunted house. Whilst it does ultimately play out in the fashion of a typical Super Mario game (only this time, it’s Mario who’s in danger), it’s the dark and gritty atmosphere that keeps it interesting and unique from every other Super Mario game. And it showed that the series creator, Shigeru Miyamoto, was not scared to take risks by taking the normally innocent series in a more interesting artistic direction.

Originality – 9.5/10

Aside from standing out from the rest of the Super Mario Bros games that players have been challenged with over the years, this game also offers an extremely unique twist on the survival horror genre. Which, at the time, was becoming increasingly popular after the advent of both Resident Evil and Silent Hill. The genre would go on to become extremely prominent on the GameCube itself, with the likes of Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem. As well as a ton of Resident Evil games released for the system. But out of all of them, none had quite the same atmospheric feel as this game did. And consequently, I think it’s the best experience of its kind on the console.

Happii

Overall, Luigi’s Mansion is not only one of the best Super Mario games released but also one of the best games to have ever been released by Nintendo. It showed that Luigi didn’t have to constantly live in the shadow of the more commercially successful brother, but instead, he could be made to traverse through the shadows in order to rescue him.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Loadout (PC & PlayStation 4)

Loadout

Developer(s) – Edge of Reality

Publisher(s) – Edge of Reality

Distributor(s) – Valve Corporation

PEGI – 18

An arcade–type third-person shooter, Loadout is a free game on both PC and PlayStation 4, which has garnered mixed reviews from critics. Nevertheless has a very dedicated fan base. After playing for a while, I failed to see any kind of lasting appeal. Especially after realizing the game is only free to a certain extent.

Graphics – 5/10

In terms of its conceptual design, comparisons can be drawn between this game and Team Fortress 2. It also makes use of cel-shaded visuals and cartoon-like characters, also. Ang with some pretty colorful environments to go with it all. But it’s also pretty weak since the initial characters given to start off with are particularly generic. And it’s only after paying for new costumes and characters that players are treated to a bit of variety in the graphics. But in all honesty, I don’t believe that this kind of thing should have to be paid for. People should have it in the game to experience from the get-go to be able to more effectively enjoy it for what it is, free to play or not.

Gameplay – 5/10

As well as the game not looking very good, it also doesn’t play out very well in my opinion. There are several multiplayer modes to play through. As well as a campaign mode. But I didn’t find any of them to be entertaining to any great extent. The initial weapon choice is extremely limited, and since there are many more experienced players to compete with from the beginning, more time will probably be spent dying as opposed to killing, taking much of the potential fluency out of the whole experience.

Controls – 9/10

The only gripe I have about the game’s control scheme is that because it isn’t structured in quite the same way as most other third-person shooters, it can take a bit of time to get to grips with, and the reason for this is difficult to understand since there isn’t anything special in terms of controls to differentiate it from other game made in the same vein, such as Uncharted, Gears of War or especially Mass Effect. Otherwise, the control scheme poses no other problems once accustomed to it.

Originality – 3/10

Aside from not having anything different about the control scheme, there’s really nothing different about Loadout whatsoever; the visuals, the gameplay, the conceptual design, the story, etc. A lot of these kinds of games have cropped up over the last year or so, being advertised as free to play, but only for players to find that they’re privileged to the full experience. That may be unique, but it’s a trend that I hope doesn’t catch on.

Furiious

In summation, Loadout is a pretty disappointing title, even if it’s free to play. There is nothing special in terms of gameplay or visual design, and the only shred of originality about it actually has a pretty negative impact on the game.

Score

22/40

3.5/10 (Very Poor)

Limbo (PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Wii U, Android & iOS)

. GLimbo

Developer(s) – Playdead & Double Eleven

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Studios & Playdead

PEGI – 16

First released in 2010 after an extremely long-winded development cycle of six years, Limbo took the industry by surprise. Garnishing a very positive response from critics and gamers alike. And went on to win many awards in the process. Becoming arguably one of the most prominent examples of how art can be portrayed through the medium of video games. Although I did find it to be a very abstract and interesting experience in terms of artistic value, I found the most important aspect to me, the gameplay, was not lacking in creativity, but in substance.

Graphics – 10/10

The visuals of the game, as well as the general atmosphere present throughout, are wonderfully dark, gritty, and morbid. The settings are also superbly varied, taking place in dangerous factories, rainy city streets, and eerie forestland. Whilst playing, the entire experience made me feel both unsettled and captivated at the same time. It made me think back to the game Heart of Darkness to a certain extent. Unlike in the late 90s, developers can no longer get away with a teen rating for showing explicit child death scenes. This game is also much more disturbing than the former. Heart of Darkness felt more like a video game variation of the film Labyrinth. Whereas this title feels more like playing through Hitchcock’s Psycho.

Gameplay – 4/10

Limbo is a traditional 2D side-scroller, but with a twist in terms of its mechanics. Along with a strong puzzle element. Whilst I found it legitimately challenging in the end, and that many sequences did extremely well to add to the tension of the game at times, it did leave me wanting so much more overall. Although Dino Patti and Jeppe Carlsen’s perseverance ended up paying off greatly in both a commercial and critical sense, reading about the development cycle itself makes me think that, like other indie games.

Too much time was spent considering what artistic direction they wanted to take the game in. As opposed to focusing the majority of their attention on what is, in my opinion, the most important aspect of any game: the gameplay. Although I also admire the fact that one of the developer’s goals was to not have the game hold the player’s hand throughout, it still wasn’t enough for me to label it as being one of the best.

Controls – 10/10

As a 2D side scroller, there would have been quite a few issues if the mechanics hadn’t been handled right. But thankfully, they have been, and the game poses no unnecessary complications or frustrations. But more noticeable than that is the fact that the game’s unique mechanics have been implemented into the title flawlessly. Only adding to its level of outlandish abstraction and wonderful sense of ingenuity.

Lifespan – 1/10

One thing that I’ve noticed is that there seems to be an ongoing dispute amongst critics concerning Limbo is its length of Limbo. Some have labeled the game’s lifespan as being ideal, whilst others have said that they believe it’s far too short, especially to have warranted a six-year development cycle. Personally, I agree with the arguably latter opinion, no matter how brutal it may seem to others. I certainly found it far too short and far too lacking in gameplay substance to warrant another playthrough. Another playthrough would, of course, be even shorter, since I spent the majority of the time on the SG88 Plays videos either scratching my head or dying. It’s certainly so far the worst and most tedious YouTube series I’ve ever recorded, by my own admission.

Storyline – 8/10

The story of Limbo reminds me very much of that of Journey; an abstract tale into an unknown land wrought with wonder, danger, and adventure; except, of course, this game is much darker and more morose than the former. There has been a whirlwind of debate about what the many different settings and elements of the game bring to the story, and how it all interconnects with the idea of either personal torture or the seven circles of Hell that possibly await the character after traversing through Limbo, and even parallels have been drawn with Dante Alighieri’s take on the Inferno.

Originality – 7/10

The game also doesn’t lack uniqueness and new ideas, as they are present throughout what small a course there is to it. It’s an extremely interesting take on the 2D side-scrolling genre, and it does extremely well to present an in-game world beyond the many stables and conventions that are synonymous with the industry these days, and what has been before the modern generation of the medium. Although I don’t believe it deserved nigh-on perfect scores as many critics have seen fit to bestow upon it, I can at least understand why they have so much admiration for it, and why it had become as popular as it has.

Niiutral

Overall, despite Limbo’s overwhelming abundance of artistic value, I consider it to be a much worse game than what the rest of the gaming media would suggest it to be. It’s a moderately enjoyable gaming experience marred by the fact that the developers prioritized abstraction and cryptics over substance in gameplay.

Score

40/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Lego City Undercover (PC, Wii U, Switch, PlayStation 4 & Xbox One)

Lego City Undercover

Developer(s) – TT Fusion, Nintendo SPD & Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Designer – Lee Barber

Producer – Loz Doyle

PEGI – 7

Having wanted to develop a video game based on the Lego City toy line for quite some time, Traveller’s Tales agreed to work with Nintendo to bring Lego City Undercover exclusively to Wii U. Combining the familiar formula of most other Lego-themed video games with elements of the Grand Theft Auto series, it was met with positive reviews from critics. It presented players with a moderately new twist on Lego games at that time.

Graphics – 8/10

To me, this game is a great example of how Lego, in general, can capture the imaginations of people who either play with Lego (as I did when I was a kid). As opposed to many of the other Lego games, which were based largely on pre-existing intellectual properties. Such as Star Wars and The Lord of the Rings. With Undercover, there are quite a few sly cultural references. And even some references to certain Nintendo games, but for the most part, the player can get a sense that very little can be off-limits in terms of conceptual design.

Gameplay – 9/10

Aside from the game looking great, it plays out great, too. Outside the main story, there exists a multitude of different side quests to complete throughout a massive open-world environment unparalleled by any of the more linear worlds found in most other Lego games. The amount of customization and variety on offer is also extremely impressive since a wide range of abilities is needed to complete everything that can be completed. Instead of the Lego game tradition, replay value is also on offer. Since players will also have to go back to story missions with newly gained abilities to collect things they will have inevitably missed the first time around.

Controls – 10/10

Like in every other Lego game, the control scheme is also extremely simplistic and easy to get to grips with. The use of the Wii U GamePad also offers a fairly unique twist on how open-world games are normally played. For example, there exist side missions, whereby the player must use the GamePad to scan the TV in order to find criminal suspects before making an arrest. It is also used as a glorified Head-Up Display, containing a map and icons indicating where side quests are located.

Lifespan – 10/10

Since there are a ton of things to do in this game, it can easily be made to last up to 100 hours, which certainly makes it the longest Lego game ever developed. There’s a lot of open-world space in the game, and a lot of great use of it. The story mode will take the better part of 10 hours alone. But after that, the game will have only just begun.

Storyline – 6/10

The biggest drawback to this game is that the story isn’t particularly engaging, in my opinion. It involves a police detective called Chase McCain. He is on a mission to capture a notorious criminal called Rex Fury. Other than the basic premise, there’s not that much present in terms of the story. The only thing that saves it from being irredeemable is that there is a fairly strong comedic element. With cultural references all over the place, and a few clever little in-jokes to accompany them.

Originality – 6/10

Though it is possible to differentiate Lego City Undercover from every other Lego game, since there were a few new features introduced, it doesn’t stand out against many other video games out there. The Grand Theft Auto element of it makes this even more obvious. I would describe it best as being evolutionary as opposed to revolutionary, since it made innovation. But only in its own circle, and brought little new to the industry overall.

Happii

In Summation, despite Lego City Undercover playing out very familiarly compared to many other games, it is a very enjoyable experience, and worth every hour of playing. It’s another game that, to me, gives testament to how the Wii U is a better console than commercial figures show.

Score

49/60

8/10 (Very Good)