Tag Archives: PS3

Murdered: Soul Suspect (Windows, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, Xbox 360 & Xbox One)

Murdered Soul Suspect

Developer(s) – Airtight Games

Publisher(s) – Square Enix

Director – Yosuke Shiokawa

Producer – Eric Studer

PEGI – 16

Murdered: Soul Suspect is an action-adventure puzzle game, borrowing elements from both LA Noire and Dead Space. Whereby investigations must be carried out, and ungodly creatures must be subdued to advance. But because this game seemed to have these elements borrowed from the aforementioned games, I took an almost immediate dislike to it. Also, for the fact that nothing new or particularly appealing was brought to the table in terms of gameplay.

Graphics – 6/10

The game doesn’t rely greatly on either conceptual design or graphical advancement. Indeed, I thought it might not even push the graphical boundaries of the PlayStation 3 or Xbox 360, let alone the PlayStation 4 or Xbox One. But I think the most impressive things about the game’s visuals are the use of a gritty atmosphere and well-executed shadow and lighting. They add a fair bit of tension to the game. Although for the most part, because the game relies so much on the use of gritty atmosphere and lighting, it does seem that tension only builds to a certain level and stops.

The game doesn’t get any scarier or more suspenseful past a certain point in each gameplay sequence. And it can make the game seem bland most of the time, I find. I think if the developers had perhaps concentrated a bit more on conceptual design and scenery, that would have added some more to the game’s overall atmosphere instead of having it only go so far, and not building to anything.

Gameplay – 4/10

A concern of mine about video games having too much story attached to them is that too much focus can be taken off gameplay. And for the most part, it seems the only objective of the overall game is finding out what happens next. This game is a shining example of that. The gameplay is extremely bland, especially for a semi-open world one. There are side quests, but all they ever involve is collecting things and nothing more.

It’s the same with normal gameplay, only there are also a few demons to kill in some instances, too. Not enough gameplay variety was added to this title. And consequently, made it play out far too much like a film. The idea of playing a video game as opposed to watching a film is that games immerse people more and make them feel more like they’re a part of it. This game, however, does little to capture that very feeling of immersion.

Controls – 10/10

There are no issues with the controls, but it couldn’t have been hard to get the formula right. Not only has the third-person adventure genre been worked on for a long time prior to this game’s release, but there is less variety in this genre than in other games of its kind. So there wouldn’t have been an excuse not to have the formula done correctly.

Lifespan – 3/10

For even a semi-open world game, that Murdered: Soul Suspect can be completed within five hours is nothing short of unacceptable. Even when I’ve reviewed Child of Light and South Park: The Stick of Truth, I’ve been less than impressed with how little time they’ve lasted. Since open-world games can be made to last the best part of 100 hours. The fact that this game is so short-lived is yet another reason why I believe it plays out too much like a film, since films can be made to last a similar amount of time. Especially if it may be a trilogy of films. But it’s just as well the game is so short-lived, since there’s hardly anything to do in it.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of the game revolves around a recently murdered detective called Ronan O’Connor. He must solve the mystery of his own murder in Limbo to be with his already deceased wife in Heaven. The game’s story isn’t too bad, and it does have a few decent twists and turns throughout. But it’s not considerably impressive, given how much emphasis on gameplay was sacrificed in order to develop it. I would have thought that a game that plays out too much like a film would have at least had an exceptional story attached to it. But I was wrong in this instance.

Originality – 2/10

With the small exception of it containing psychological horror as opposed to the kind of horror normally found in video games, there isn’t much else unique about Murdered: Soul Suspect that makes it stand out among many other games. In terms of graphics, gameplay, or story. It’s not the first time a game has played out as this one does. And it should never be considered the definitive one by any means at all.

Angrii

Overall, Murdered: Soul Suspect is an extremely fleeting experience, and nowhere near worth its current asking price. Or any asking price beyond maybe a fiver. Too much emphasis was put on the wrong factors, and it suffered because of it. Even the factors that were taken into consideration were not properly developed, in my opinion.

Score

31/60

5/10 (Far Below Average)

Mortal Kombat (PC, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 & PlayStation Vita)

Mortal Kombat 2011

Developer(s) – NetherRealm Studios

Publisher(s) – Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Director(s) – Ed Boon, Steven Beran & Alan Villani

Producer(s) – Hans Lo, Adam Urbano & Shaun Himmerick

PEGI – 18

Released in 2011 as an extremely successful revival of the widely acclaimed fighting game series, Mortal Kombat went on to win three gaming awards in the year of its launch. It was later re-released with additional content, and a sequel is coming out soon for next-gen consoles. As far as fighting games go, whilst I don’t indulge in them as much as I do in other genres of gaming, this is most definitely one of the best entries in the series. And had made me particularly excited about its future.

Graphics – 8/10

Conceptually, a lot of the different stages are remastered versions of previous ones found in many of the classic games. And in my opinion, they’ve never looked better. From a technical standpoint, in particular, the game has a great deal of textural detail. Depending on what stance players may take on graphic violence, it can be seen as either impressive or disturbing. The fatalities were made to be more violent than ever before. And in my opinion, it is one of the most violent games ever developed behind Abadox.

Gameplay – 7/10

A traditional fighting game, what I was most glad about was the fact that the developers strayed away from the concept of fighting in full 3D environments. And reverted to 2D stages. But kept the 3D graphics intact. To me, the previous style of fighting from Mortal Kombat 4 to Mortal Kombat Armageddon didn’t work anywhere near as well as the system in the original trilogy. And many other fighting games of the time. But aside from this, there is also a vast range of different ay modes in this game. As well as a plethora of different unlockables, aside from what can be downloaded as DLC.

Controls –10/10

Aside from the developers reverting to the layout of a traditional fighting game, the control scheme works extremely well. Not only does it work well to re-immerse long-time fans of the series. But it also works well for newcomers in the form of practice mode and move lists. I also like how much time is given to players to perform fatalities, since personally, I’ve never been able to execute one in any of the three original games.

Lifespan – N/A (10/10)

Though fighting games have an infinite lifespan by default, there’s still a great deal more present in this game than many others of its kind to keep players immersed in many different ways. Not only is there a story mode, but there is also the bonus of using points earned in battle to acquire things such as alternative costumes and conceptual art. But there is also an online multiplayer mode that can become quite addictive. The developers are working to enhance this aspect for the next game. But it’s still extremely satisfying in this case, too.

Storyline – 7/10

The overall story arc of this game is also handled in an extremely unique way for a fighting game. It acts as a revival of the series. And at the same time, it re-tells the events of the first three games. Whilst simultaneously carrying on the story from where it left off after the latest game to have come before it. Mortal Kombat Armageddon. The basic premise is that fighters from all the different realms of the universe convene to compete in the Mortal Kombat tournament. But there does end up being a lot of twists and turns before the end.

Originality – 6/10

In terms of uniqueness, this game does have a fair bit of originality about it, in the structure of its story, and how the incentive is earned whilst playing through it. But to an extent, the developers had to keep things as simple as possible in order to revive the series, which, beforehand, had been losing commercial momentum. I suspect the developers are saving more unique aspects of the series for the next game, Mortal Kombat X, judging by what I’ve seen so far, since new policies are being explored within the online multiplayer facility, and it also looks as if the developers are branching out more from a conceptual standpoint, in a similar fashion to how they did it with Mortal Kombat III.

Happii

In summation, Mortal Kombat is an exceptional fighting game, and I would recommend it to veteran fans who may not have tried it, as well as newcomers. The next game looks to be even better, but this title still serves as an ideal starting point for anyone curious about the series.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Mini Ninjas (Xbox 360, PC, PlayStation 3, Wii, DS & OnLive)

Mini Ninjas

Developer(s) – IO Interactive, Magic Pockets & Robosoft Technologies

Publisher(s) – Eidos Interactive, Warner Bros. & Feral Interactive

Director – Jeremy C. Petreman

Producer(s) – Jonas Lind & Luke Valentine

PEGI – 7

Developed as a game that the creators personally wanted to be able to play with their children, Mini Ninjas was a combat-oriented adventure game. It was well-received upon release. And ever since, there has been a fairly high demand for a sequel. To me, it all comes as no surprise after playing it for myself. Though perhaps too linear, it’s still a pretty enjoyable game for how long it lasts.

Graphics – 7.5/10

Making use of cel-shaded visuals, the game bears a striking resemblance to The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker. It’s not quite as strong in terms of conceptual design. But the attention to detail is extremely well adhered to. The scenery, particularly trees and grass, gives it as realistic a feel as a game like this could have. There’s also quite a bit of variety to be experienced in terms of individual-level design. The game takes place in a multitude of different locations. Many represent the contrast between natural and man-made structures synonymous with Japanese culture.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

Though there is quite a variety in level design, the true variety this game has to offer is in its gameplay. Eventually, the player will have access to six different characters, each with their own special abilities and fighting styles. The main character, Hiro, in particular, has many different types of magic spells to attack enemies, stop time, and possess wildlife, among many other things. There are also a fair few side quests to add to the game’s longevity. But I couldn’t help but think how much better it would have been if set in an open world. That’s why I believe it would be quite easy to develop a better game in a possible sequel.

Controls – 10/10

The controls also come with no complications. Even though there are many different functions to be taken advantage of throughout the game. And many different functions, mini-games that must be undertaken to advance. As well as the regular gameplay, there are boat-riding mechanics, as well as context-sensitive sequences in most boss fights. Which add an even greater element of legitimate challenge. Players may see it as being overly easy, but I’d personally have it this way rather than it being the other way round.

Lifespan – 4/10

Because of its linearity, the game can only be made to last around 7 to 8 hours, which I believe, given the sizeable amount of variety in gameplay, is far too short a time for it to last. It’s a shame that the franchise has been left to languish since the release of this game, since I think there is a lot of potential in it, as well as a lot of leeway to expand on the game’s core mechanics, and room for introducing even more than what was offered with the first game.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of the game follows a young ninja named Hiro, who, along with his best friend Futo, sets out to find and release four imprisoned ninjas, as well as defeat the evil samurai warlord, who resolved to dominate the world. The story is pretty basic in scope, and partly hearkens back to the days when the story in video games was scarce in general. But it’s kept relatively fresh with the comedy element that it has throughout. There are additional cut scenes to unlock, which also add more to that comedic element, but for the most part, the story merely offers even more leeway to expand on the franchise’s potential.

Originality – 6.5/10

Though it isn’t particularly unique to the entire gaming medium, Mini Ninjas certainly stands out among the many others released throughout the seventh generation. During an era when first-person shooters had become the most prominent genre of games, it was refreshing to me to be able to play a pretty laid-back adventure game hearkening back to the fifth generation of gaming. To me, it was like a breath of fresh air at the time. It had many elements that were not uncommon for its time, such as cel-shaded visuals and context-sensitive gameplay, but it had a level of variety that made it stand out among many others.

Happii

Overall, Mini Ninjas is a quietly satisfying and fun game to play. Though there was room for improvement, it has most definitely been illegitimately overlooked, and I would recommend it to anyone looking for a seventh-generation diamond in the rough.

Score

42.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor (PC, PlayStation 4 & Xbox One)

Middle Earth Shadow of Mordor

Developer(s) – Monolith Productions

Publisher(s) – Warner Bros. Interactive

Director – Michael de Plater

Producer – Mike Forge

PEGI – 18

Set in the world of JRR Tolkien’s epic fantasy The Lord of the Rings, Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor easily makes for the best game ever to be based on the popular license. Far surpassing my previous favorite based on Return of the King. Featuring addictive gameplay, breathtaking visuals, and an immersive story, it far surpassed my own expectations. And despite a couple of flaws, I consider it to be one of the best games of 2014.

Graphics – 8.5/10

The vast open world of Mordor set in the game, as well as the Orc characters and other supporting characters, give the game a beautifully dark and gritty atmosphere indeed. The attention to detail has also been made obvious with textures such as rainfall on buildings and the superb use of lighting throughout. However, what prevents this game from getting a perfect score in terms of visuals is that I did find a good number of glitches.

Most notably on the characters’ faces. Sometimes, characters’ faces can blacken out unexpectedly, making it obvious the fact that the game hasn’t been tested properly. Orcs have black blood in the game. And it could be argued that killing enemies is what causes this to happen, to give the effect of blood being splattered onto characters’ faces. But even if that is true, I still think it makes the game look flawed to a small extent.

Gameplay – 9/10

Regardless of this one big flaw in the game’s visuals, how excellently it plays out is more than enough to keep players hooked for an extremely long time. A love letter to fans of both the Batman Arkham series and Assassin’s Creed series, the gameplay is mission-based across a decently sized open world. With plenty of side quests and extracurricular activities to keep players busy. The game also introduces something very new to the medium. The nemesis system. How it works is that the game has Orc captains and war chiefs to command over lesser Orcs. And these enemies are much more powerful and unique in how they operate.

Orc captains can compete against each other to earn promotions and progress through the ranks as time passes. And regular Orcs can even rise the ranks for killing the player character. As Orc captains are killed by the player character, new captains are brought up through the ranks to replace them. The player also has the option to interrogate lesser Orc soldiers. In order to find out the identities of Orc captains and even learn their strengths and weaknesses, in order to determine how best to proceed while engaging them in combat. The nemesis system results in what is essentially an infinite side quest throughout the game. And ends up giving the title some serious value in terms of gameplay.

Controls – 9/10

The control scheme in Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor borrows elements from both Assassin’s Creed and the Batman Arkham series. The combat system is extremely refined. And stealth and acrobatics are essentials that players must employ to play the game most effectively. However, I found that the climbing mechanics, very much like those of the first Assassin’s Creed game, were a little bit inconsistent. Some things can be traversed and others can’t. And there isn’t any clear indication as to what can and can’t be traversed throughout the course of the game. And it can lead to unnecessary complications. Especially whilst the player is trying to escape overwhelming enemy numbers. Other than this, however, I have no further complaints. The combat system is handled exquisitely well. And the flaws in its controls don’t make it unplayable by any means.

Lifespan – 8.5/10

Even without any prolonged use of the nemesis system, this game can easily be made to last around 30 to 40 hours. Which is incredible for a game based on a pre-existing license. The Batman Arkham series has since included a long lifespan following Arkham Asylum. But for something, which could easily be the start of a new series of games based on the Middle-Earth mythos, this is incredible.

Storyline – 8/10

The game’s story is as wonderfully gripping as it is gut-wrenchingly dark and intense. It takes place in the interim between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. As the Orcs of Mordor prepare for the return of their master. The dark lord Sauron. Over 3000 years after the defeat of Sauron at the hands of Isildur, the city of Gondor has since posted rangers at the Black Gate to watch over the land of Mordor for suspicious activity. One of these rangers, Talion, is caught in the middle of the Orc invasion of Mordor and the Black Gate along with his wife and son. And the three of them are executed.

However, Talion is revived by an initially unnamed elven wraith, which merges with Talion, granting him ghostly abilities. Together, they resolve to learn of the wraith’s mysterious past and to avenge the death of Talion’s family by mounting an effective resistance against the armies of Mordor and their leader, the Black Hand of Sauron. Although it will inevitably be much harder for newcomers to the Middle-Earth mythos to take in everything that is happening since, for example, familiar characters such as Gollum will be largely unfamiliar, there is enough drama and suspense, and focus on the game’s narrative, in general, to keep newcomers interested. As well as fans of the books and films.

Originality – 7/10

The reason why I think Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor is somewhat unoriginal is that it borrows many ideas from already existing games, which makes the title mostly evolutionary as opposed to being revolutionary. That being said, the nemesis system does make it stand out greatly among most other eight-generation titles I’ve seen so far, and it is refreshing to see that mainstream developers are attempting to innovate within the industry, as opposed to it being exclusively indie developers.

Happii

To summarize, whilst it does indeed have its fair share of flaws, Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor is most definitely one of the best titles I’ve seen in the eighth generation of gaming yet, as well as being one of the standout titles of 2014. It’s enjoyable to play as well as pleasant to look at despite graphical flaws, and there is enough fan service present to both satisfy long-standing Tolkien fans and adequately introduce newcomers to the mythos.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)

The Last of Us (PlayStation 3 & PlayStation 4)

The Last of Us

Developer(s) – Naughty Dog

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director(s) – Bruce Straley & Neil Druckmann

Designer – Jacob Minkoff

PEGI – 18

Selling millions of copies worldwide and garnering many perfect scores from reviewers, as well as a near-perfect score of 38/40 from Famitsu, The Last of Us is considered one of the defining titles of the PlayStation 3’s library by gamers and critics alike. I, on the other hand…

Graphics – 8/10

One positive to discuss regarding this game, at least, is how good it looks. The game is both conceptually and graphically sound. Aside from representing the pinnacle of what the PlayStation 3 is capable of on a graphical level, for the most part, it also presents a very interesting, yet unsettling, take on how post-apocalyptic Earth would be governed under martial law. And how humanity would cope under such circumstances. Or how it wouldn’t. There are also a few glitches in the game here and there, but nothing overly noticeable. Certainly not on the same level as Aliens: Colonial Marines, which I reviewed last week. It’s interesting to see where Naughty Dog’s influence comes in. As similarities can be drawn with their own Uncharted series. One of the game’s main characters, Joel, also wears similar attire to that of Nathan Drake, the main character of Uncharted.

Gameplay – 3/10

The gameplay, however, is the aspect that I find most difficult to wax poetic about. Before playing, I had heard through bad word of mouth that this game had its downsides. Such as its level of linearity and lack of overall substance. But I initially thought to myself that it surely couldn’t have been as bad as people made out to me. But I actually found it worse than what people made out, unfortunately.

I found myself very disappointed with The Last of Us. The game only encourages exploration to a very small extent. And having players search areas where they think there may be hidden side quest items, but when there is nothing. Though it is common to have merely decorative areas, this game takes it to a pretty ridiculous level. It even reminded me of Murdered: Soul Suspect in terms of how repetitive it can get. But in this case, it’s to an even greater extent than that. At least there were side quests in Murdered: Soul Suspect. But in The Last of Us, there are considerably fewer.

Controls – 10/10

There are no issues with the game’s control scheme, but it plays out very similarly to any game in the Uncharted series. But with a greater emphasis on stealth as a combat option, I don’t think there should have been any issues with the control scheme, really. This control scheme was evolutionary during the time Naughty Dog developed Uncharted. And although the game loses no marks for not having any problems, it certainly didn’t do itself any favors by not adding anything new to the table.

Lifespan – 5/10

Discounting the DLC package, Left Behind, and The Last of Us can take an average time of 12 hours to complete. But whilst that may sound fairly impressive for a game of this kind compared to any game in the Uncharted series, most time will be spent watching the cutscenes and taking in the game’s story as opposed to players actually playing the game. Although it would seem to last twice as long as an Uncharted game, it’s far less enjoyable to play. And by that token can make it seem much more drawn out.

Storyline – 9/10

Without a shadow of a doubt, the best thing that can be attributed to this game is its extremely immersive story. Taking place on a post-apocalyptic Earth following the spread of a deadly advanced strain of the Cordyceps fungus, which turns humans into cannibalistic monsters known as clickers, Joel, a human survivor who lost his daughter twenty years before the game’s main events, finds himself escorting a young girl called Ellie across the United States to survive and put a stop to the deadly virus once and for all.

The narrative told in this game is incredible, with great voice acting. And a lot of emphasis on character development. And a good few twists and turns throughout. The overall atmosphere of the game alternates from being very intense and very emotional as the relationship between Joel and Ellie progresses throughout the course of the game. Although it is never worth sacrificing good gameplay in favor of immersing in the story. To me is become a recurring problem in mainstream titles; the game certainly has a great deal of substance in the story, nevertheless.

Originality – 3/10

Though I can’t deny the historical significance of this title for its excellent story, there is hardly anything either original or innovative about the gameplay in The Last of Us. And it’s not as if video games hadn’t had great stories attributed to them prior. There has been a much greater narrative told in video games before the release of The Last of Us, but have also included greater gameplay.

Niiutral

Overall, whilst having a fantastic and engrossing plot and conceptually and graphically astute visuals, there was definitely room for improvement in terms of both substance and innovation in gameplay. The gameplay is the most important aspect of any video game. And my biggest hope for Naughty Dog now is that they haven’t completely lost sight of that, pending the release of Uncharted 4.

Score

38/60

6/10 (Average)

Limbo (PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Wii U, Android & iOS)

. GLimbo

Developer(s) – Playdead & Double Eleven

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Studios & Playdead

PEGI – 16

First released in 2010 after an extremely long-winded development cycle of six years, Limbo took the industry by surprise. Garnishing a very positive response from critics and gamers alike. And went on to win many awards in the process. Becoming arguably one of the most prominent examples of how art can be portrayed through the medium of video games. Although I did find it to be a very abstract and interesting experience in terms of artistic value, I found the most important aspect to me, the gameplay, was not lacking in creativity, but in substance.

Graphics – 10/10

The visuals of the game, as well as the general atmosphere present throughout, are wonderfully dark, gritty, and morbid. The settings are also superbly varied, taking place in dangerous factories, rainy city streets, and eerie forestland. Whilst playing, the entire experience made me feel both unsettled and captivated at the same time. It made me think back to the game Heart of Darkness to a certain extent. Unlike in the late 90s, developers can no longer get away with a teen rating for showing explicit child death scenes. This game is also much more disturbing than the former. Heart of Darkness felt more like a video game variation of the film Labyrinth. Whereas this title feels more like playing through Hitchcock’s Psycho.

Gameplay – 4/10

Limbo is a traditional 2D side-scroller, but with a twist in terms of its mechanics. Along with a strong puzzle element. Whilst I found it legitimately challenging in the end, and that many sequences did extremely well to add to the tension of the game at times, it did leave me wanting so much more overall. Although Dino Patti and Jeppe Carlsen’s perseverance ended up paying off greatly in both a commercial and critical sense, reading about the development cycle itself makes me think that, like other indie games.

Too much time was spent considering what artistic direction they wanted to take the game in. As opposed to focusing the majority of their attention on what is, in my opinion, the most important aspect of any game: the gameplay. Although I also admire the fact that one of the developer’s goals was to not have the game hold the player’s hand throughout, it still wasn’t enough for me to label it as being one of the best.

Controls – 10/10

As a 2D side scroller, there would have been quite a few issues if the mechanics hadn’t been handled right. But thankfully, they have been, and the game poses no unnecessary complications or frustrations. But more noticeable than that is the fact that the game’s unique mechanics have been implemented into the title flawlessly. Only adding to its level of outlandish abstraction and wonderful sense of ingenuity.

Lifespan – 1/10

One thing that I’ve noticed is that there seems to be an ongoing dispute amongst critics concerning Limbo is its length of Limbo. Some have labeled the game’s lifespan as being ideal, whilst others have said that they believe it’s far too short, especially to have warranted a six-year development cycle. Personally, I agree with the arguably latter opinion, no matter how brutal it may seem to others. I certainly found it far too short and far too lacking in gameplay substance to warrant another playthrough. Another playthrough would, of course, be even shorter, since I spent the majority of the time on the SG88 Plays videos either scratching my head or dying. It’s certainly so far the worst and most tedious YouTube series I’ve ever recorded, by my own admission.

Storyline – 8/10

The story of Limbo reminds me very much of that of Journey; an abstract tale into an unknown land wrought with wonder, danger, and adventure; except, of course, this game is much darker and more morose than the former. There has been a whirlwind of debate about what the many different settings and elements of the game bring to the story, and how it all interconnects with the idea of either personal torture or the seven circles of Hell that possibly await the character after traversing through Limbo, and even parallels have been drawn with Dante Alighieri’s take on the Inferno.

Originality – 7/10

The game also doesn’t lack uniqueness and new ideas, as they are present throughout what small a course there is to it. It’s an extremely interesting take on the 2D side-scrolling genre, and it does extremely well to present an in-game world beyond the many stables and conventions that are synonymous with the industry these days, and what has been before the modern generation of the medium. Although I don’t believe it deserved nigh-on perfect scores as many critics have seen fit to bestow upon it, I can at least understand why they have so much admiration for it, and why it had become as popular as it has.

Niiutral

Overall, despite Limbo’s overwhelming abundance of artistic value, I consider it to be a much worse game than what the rest of the gaming media would suggest it to be. It’s a moderately enjoyable gaming experience marred by the fact that the developers prioritized abstraction and cryptics over substance in gameplay.

Score

40/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Lair

Lair (PlayStation 3)

Developer(s) – Factor 5

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director(s) – Julian Eggebrecht & Holger Schmidt

Producer – Brian D. Krueger

PEGI – 16

Lair was a highly anticipated launch title for the PlayStation 3. And made heavy use of the then-new Sixaxis motion controls, which have since become relatively scarce in many PlayStation games. People were blown away by the graphics but were disappointed by the gameplay and controls. And after playing this travesty of a game, it’s no wonder to me why they were.

Graphics – 6/10

The best thing I can say about the visuals is that they did an excellent job of showing off what the PlayStation 3 was capable of in its early stages. And the attention to detail was quite overwhelming at the time. However, on a conceptual level, there is next to nothing differentiating it from other games or forms of media set in a medieval fantasy world. Much less so than Dragon Age: Inquisition, and even less so than other obscure games of today.

Gameplay – 4/10

The gameplay revolves around riding a dragon and killing as many surrounding people as possible in a series of stages throughout the game. In a medieval fantasy game, most gamers would most probably expect at least some hint of an RPG element. But this game doesn’t even have that, disappointingly. The developers were going for a unique approach to gameplay. They tried to outline to other video game bloggers who had given it bad reviews by sending them a 21-page booklet with things like artwork and background story. But they were not convinced, and neither would I be.

Controls – 3/10

Since the developers were using a very new control scheme, Lair was always going to be a question of trial and error. And frankly, playing this game is like pulling teeth. It’s uncomfortable, and no one should ever have to go through it. They are extremely stiff and hinder gameplay in such a way that makes this game almost unplayable.

Lifespan – 5/10

Like many other mainstream games, they have found their way on the PlayStation 3. And throughout the seventh generation in general, Lair will last just under 10 hours, which is particularly underwhelming. As with most other aspects of this game, this says to me that the developers should have spent more time trying to get the fundamentals right and make a half-decent game as opposed to going out of their way to try and convince critics that it was a good game and failing miserably.

Storyline – 2/10

The game’s story is also extremely reminiscent of most plots associated with the medieval fantasy genre, and consequently, there isn’t much present to differentiate the game from others overall. It follows the adventures of a dragon rider called Rohn. He seeks to restore peace to a world divided by two opposing people. The Mokai and the Asylians. I’ve seen this type of plot in The Lord of the Rings and Warcraft, back when they were original to me. But I fail to understand how the developers could even fill an art book with 21 pages to send to critics.

Originality – 2/10

The only thing separating this game from others is the fact that it was one of the first to make use of the PlayStation 3’s Sixaxis controls, which went on to feature in very few games since. Only being effectively used in the likes of Ratchet & Clank: Tools of Destruction, God of War III, and Heavenly Sword. Some critics would also argue that this fact could make the game unique for the wrong reasons, since the game’s control scheme is most probably the worst aspect of it.

Furiious

In summation, Lair is a shining example of how not to develop a launch title; it isn’t enjoyable in the least bit and has next to no artistic merit attached to it. I just hope now that I don’t get a 21-page booklet through my door trying to tell me otherwise.

Score

22/50

3.5/10 (Very Poor)

Killer is Dead (Xbox 360 & PlayStation 3)

Killer is Dead

Developer(s) – Grasshopper Manufacture

Publisher(s) – Deep Silver

Director – Hideyuki Shin

Producer(s) – Yoshimi Yasuda & Shuji Ishikawa

PEGI – 18

Killer is Dead was launched at the back end of 2013 and was released to mixed reviews in different countries. In Japan, its country of origin, it was released to mostly positive reviews. Whilst the Western world was far more critical of the game, citing its allegedly nonsensical story and repetitive gameplay. Ray Carsillo of Electronic Gaming Monthly even went as far as to say that Killer is Dead had “the most ridiculous, nonsensical plot yet”.

Graphics – 8/10

As with many games I’ve reviewed up to this point in the blog, the best thing about it is how good it looks. There is a great deal of very decent use of cel-shaded graphics in this game. The game’s style is pretty compelling, and the settings are exceptional. Many segments of the game transpire in maze-like houses and even in a mansion on the moon. Although there are a few glitches here and there, they’re barely noticeable.

What players will be concentrating on most is the very effective use of lighting. This adds a very prominent sense of grit to the overall feel of the game. As the plot has gritty elements to it, with plenty of violence to accompany it. Blood sprays out in comic book-like geysers. Similar to other cel-shaded games like Madworld and No More Heroes. Some of the characters, including the main character, also have robotic limbs similar to Deus Ex. This makes for a few unique character designs, too. Albeit amidst some fairly generic-looking characters.

Gameplay – 5.5/10

After the first three hours or so, I found myself getting particularly bored with this game. It’s an action hack-and-slash game very similar to DMC: Devil May Cry. But just a lot more linear with equally unrefined combat. The game is set out in stages, requiring players to essentially get from point A to point B with a boss at the end of it. Although some of the boss’s fights at the end of each stage were pretty well thought out and some of them even fascinatingly disturbing (particularly the boss fight with Alice around the beginning of the game), they weren’t enough to save it overall, in my opinion.

There is only one side quest, which involves the main character working as a gigolo and wooing clients into bed by giving them presents and having players take suggestive snapshots of them. More explicit content is shown every time a player successfully woos one particular woman into bed. Which, in my opinion, is a particularly cheap way to get people to continue playing the game. As there doesn’t seem to be much more incentive for players other than gaining new weapons. The game, for me, lacks substance overall. Particularly, in chapter 5, there is not much to do other than walk around a strange moonlit landscape in slow motion, watch a few cutscenes, and kill a boss at the end of it. That chapter was clearly added as filler, the way I see it.

Controls – 9.5/10

Apart from the one minor flaw of it sometimes being difficult to hit breakable objects, which hold in-game items, there’s nothing at all else to complain about in terms of controls. Although the combat system is pretty bland and unelaborated on, that’s down to gameplay.

Lifespan – 6/10

If the cutscenes are skipped, which is a good idea given how ridiculous the game’s story is, this game can be easily completed within ten hours. For me, the incentive to play through the side quests was far too cheap. And the main gameplay can become far too monotonous to keep players engrossed in it for any extended amount of time anyway. Many better and longer hack-and-slash games were released last year. Including God of War: Ascension.

Storyline – 3/10

The game’s story centers on an assassin called Mondo Zappa. He carries out assassination missions for the Bryan Execution Firm along with his infinitely annoying and dim-witted assistant, Mika. They’re both tasked by their boss, Bryan Roses, to kill dangerous criminals all around the globe. Like Heart of Darkness, there are certain elements of the story that make it overall seem very far-fetched.

And make it seem like a lot of stuff was randomly put together in order to create a fully cohesive concept, and for me, it fell apart very quickly. It doesn’t help that there is some pretty bad voice acting in it as well. In particular, the character Mika is without a doubt one of the worst characters I’ve ever seen in a video game. She throws tantrums, cries a lot, and becomes far too childishly enthusiastic about her situation for me to be able to take her seriously. I don’t even think the main character, Mondo, can be taken seriously, as his catchphrase “The job… killer is dead” makes little to no sense.

Originality – 6/10

In terms of conceptual design, this game was always going to be able to stand out visually, as there are some unique settings and character designs, but no uniqueness lies in gameplay, which, for me, lessens it way too much for me to be able to call it a decent game. But with no standout personalities and a few fairly good boss fights, the overall feel of the game can get boring after a while.

Niiutral

To summarize, Killer is Dead is playable, but shouldn’t be considered a classic by any means. There are other games of its kind that I would more highly recommend than this. I may have found a few decent games released in 2013 following my initial skepticism, but I think this is definitely one to steer clear of.

Score

36/60

6/10 (Average)

Journey (PlayStation 3 & PlayStation 4)

Journey

Developer(s) – Thatgamecompany & Tricky Pixels

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Jenova Chen

Producer – Robin Hunicke

PEGI – 12

Developed by Thatgamecompany and first released back in 2012, Journey went on to become one of the most critically acclaimed video games of the seventh generation. Winning five BAFTA awards among many others, as well as nominations. And becoming a catalyst for proving that video games can be considered a valid art form. Personally, whilst I can appreciate this game for the different direction it has helped to take the industry in and helped to popularise the medium among a greater number of people, it does have its faults. These compelled me to rate it significantly lower than many other video game critics have.

Graphics – 10/10

The aspect that I couldn’t possibly fault, however, is the game’s visuals. A unique and beautiful blend of cel-shaded graphics and wonderful conceptual design. And some very realistic-looking sand and sea textures thrown in for good measure, Journey is one of the most elegant video games I’ve ever laid eyes upon. It reminds me of Shadow of the Colossus, in that there is also an air of mystery about where the game is set. And the events that take place long before it begins.

Gameplay – 4/10

The objective of the game is simply to get from A to B, whilst along the way, solving a few puzzles here and there. There is a side quest of collecting runes across the land, which extends the length of the player character’s scarf. For all its artistic value, I’ve always found there is far too little substance in gameplay for me to be able to label it quite the ground-breaking experience that most reviewers are willing to label it as. Especially given how linear it is, too.

Controls – 10/10

As a 3D platformer, there are no problems with the control scheme of the game. Since the genre came into true prominence throughout the fifth generation of gaming. It was further developed throughout the sixth, with Sony themselves being at the forefront of it since the days of the PlayStation 2. In terms of innovation, however, there is very little present with respect to controls. Since there aren’t any unique mechanics present. Even the flying mechanics were perpetuated in Super Mario 64 long before the release of this title.

Lifespan – 2/10

Disgustingly, to me, Journey can only last up to 3 to 4 hours. Depending on how much of the game the player wishes to complete in a single playthrough. Also, aside from the sake of passing by different players each time with vague elements of interaction with them, there is very little replay value to be had, in my opinion. Rushed, it can take as little as 2 hours to complete. A standard that had long since proven to be below par. With the advent of the entire 3D platforming genre back in the late 90s.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of the game is very compelling, but in a much more abstract sense than in many other video games. It follows the player character’s journey to reach a huge mountain. With a glowing crevice in the middle of its top. Whilst simultaneously being shown insights into the history of the long-forgotten civilization, he/she finds ruins strewn across the land. The story does extremely well to bring out raw emotion in players and to make them feel the awe, fear, and struggle that their character goes through along the way.

Originality – 5/10

As I stated, I can fully understand and value what Thatgamecompany strived to achieve in this title. It was clearly a game made for the sake of art. And that’s where the majority of its innovation lies. It has changed the way many people look at video games forever. However, in terms of gameplay, there is no innovation to experience. There have been many gamers who have come and gone long before Journey, which has presented players with a lot more substance and entertainment.

And yet have done just as good a job representing video games as a valid art form. Many are even greater than this. It made me excited that this title worked to bring that frame of mind to light. But at the same time, I also fear that many more video games in the future may be developed with the same state of mind. And that more and more developers may simply choose to concentrate on the artistic aspect. As opposed to that which matters most, the gameplay.

Niiutral

Overall, Journey does have a lot of redeeming value in some aspects. And it deserves critical acclaim to a certain extent. But as a gamer who believes the most important aspect is the gameplay, I can’t help but look at it as being vastly overrated. Ryan Clements of IGN once said of it that not all gamers would appreciate a game with a deliberate, melancholic pace and short duration. And I believe he hit the nail on the head.

Score

38/60

6/10 (Average)

Injustice: Gods Among Us (PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Xbox 360, Wii U, PC, Android & iOS)

Injustice

Developer(s) – NetherRealm Studios & High Voltage Software

Publisher(s) – Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Director – Ed Boon

Producer – Shaun Himmerick

PEGI – 16

Following on from Mortal Kombat Vs DC Universe, Injustice: Gods Among Us is a fighting game conceived by Mortal Kombat co-creator Ed Boon. Starring a cast of many different characters from DC Comics franchises. Including Batman, Superman, The Flash, Aquaman, and the Green Lantern. Since its US release back in April 2013, the game has sold almost 1 million copies. It received many positive reviews based on its gameplay and level of graphical detail. However, whilst I think it’s not a bad game, I did find it to have drawbacks.

Graphics – 7/10

With this game featuring characters such as Batman and The Joker, I couldn’t help but compare it to the Arkham series. And in drawing my comparisons, I found that whilst Injustice does have some detail in its visuals, it doesn’t have anywhere near as much detail as any of the games in the Arkham series. The characters, in particular, look pretty detailed during fights when they are seen from a certain distance away. But when cutscenes play during the story mode.

And when characters can be seen up close, they just don’t look as detailed to me. In particular, Superman’s facial expressions look less than convincing. And I thought to myself that if most other characters didn’t wear headgear or domino masks, they would all look as substandard as Superman. Although that may seem like a clever technique to some, I can’t help but feel that their facial clothing hides more than just their real identities. However, I can’t fault the diversity in stage design. Which was very well thought out and is pretty intricate for a fighting game in particular.

Gameplay – 7/10

I think Injustice plays out well enough for a fighting game. There are a lot of game modes to unlock throughout, which offer quite a bit of variety. And the RPG-like element of leveling up the player’s profile in order to unlock more things makes the game quite interesting to play. The gripe I had with it is that apart from extra game modes, alternative costumes, and concept art, there’s not much more incentive to play it. Chiefly,

I don’t like the fact that there are no hidden characters to unlock. Which, for me, is probably the biggest attraction of playing a fighting game. Instead, there are 6 additional download-only characters. And the character Darkseid is exclusive to the iOS port of the game. Even if players are willing to spend extra money to buy the ultimate edition of the game, the additional characters are not unlocked using conventional means. And to me, that just takes a lot of the fun out of it.

Controls – 10/10

As another one of these gameplay formulas, which has been developed and modified over many years, there should never have been any issues with the controls. And there are none, thankfully. I actually found it particularly interesting to find how characters handle a lot like Mortal Kombat characters. For example, I noticed that Batman handles a lot like Scorpion. The Joker handles similarly to Reptile, and the Green Lantern handles very much like Ermac.

Lifespan – 10/10

Although I’d say that it will take only a few hours to play through the main story mode. And experienced fighting game players could probably complete all the additional game modes relatively quickly, the fact of the matter is that Injustice, like any other fighting game, is one of these games that can simply be picked up and played at any time. There’s no worry attached to it, regarding making conventional progress or outlasting a certain lifespan.

Storyline – 4.5/10

Whilst I was playing this game, I could never fully understand what was going on, and I still wouldn’t be able to without the aid of an online synopsis of it. Basically, what happens is that the DC heroes and villains are plunged into an alternative reality and pitted against their alternative counterparts. Aside from it being more open to fans of the DC Universe, making it biased in that respect, I found that events seemed to move along far too quickly, and attention kept shifting from place to place and character to character too fast for me to be able to think about exactly what was happening. Everything just happens with very little explanation.

Originality – 6/10

Whilst I can praise Injustice for its uniqueness in conceptual design and certain gameplay elements, I believe that it lacks originality in its shortage of gameplay incentive; as with a lot of fighting games, there are normally a lot of hidden characters to be found. Whilst most games don’t have a storyline, which is nigh on impossible to follow, that may make it unique, but in an extremely negative sense.

Happii

So overall, I think Injustice: Gods Among Us is fairly enjoyable, but it does indeed have its flaws, and I can’t think of a reason why NetherRealm Studios should expand any further on the concept of the story, as I think even DC fans will have trouble trying to keep up.

Score

44.5/60

7/10 (Fair)