Tag Archives: RPG

The Binding of Isaac (PC, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Wii U, New Nintendo 3DS & Xbox One)

The Binding of Isaac

Designer(s) – Edmund McMillan & Florian Himsl

PEGI – 16

Created by Edmund McMillan, the same mind behind the infamously difficult Super Meat Boy, The Binding of Isaac is a Roguelike that can be seen as a love letter to the original Legend of Zelda game. But with its own very unique twists. Regardless of how morbid this game can seem to many people, it’s also a particularly enjoyable one to play. But be warned. It isn’t for those who are easily offended.

Graphics – 7/10

The visuals, rendered in the same artistic style as Super Meat Boy, contain a lot of uniqueness. Yet taboo elements in things like the various power-ups that can be found in the game. And especially in its creature roster. It was capped off by some of the most compellingly disturbing bosses I’ve ever seen. The only gripe I have with it is that the settings can get a little repetitive at times. But the various DLC packages and re-releases fixed that problem to a certain extent.

Gameplay – 8/10

Playing out with mainly the dungeon-crawling aspects of The Legend of Zelda series, it involves simply killing all enemies. And the boss at the end of each stage, then rinse and repeat. But each playthrough is different, as every section of every stage is randomly generated, presenting players with new power-ups and a new challenge every time. It’s quite testing, but not to the point of being unforgiving. After playing Super Meat Boy, it was like a breath of fresh air to me.

Controls – 10/10

There are also no issues with the controls. There are obstacles present in certain areas of each stage, such as floor spikes and bombs that could detonate unexpectedly. But whether or not the player survives is entirely dependent on their own level of skill. Which is how I think games like this should be. At times, players are required to think on their toes in order to accommodate for what abilities and perks they may or may not have. Especially during boss fights.

Lifespan – 10/10

As each playthrough presents a new challenge and experience every time, the game quite literally has infinite replay value. I love to see this in any game. But it’s particularly noteworthy when an indie developer manages to accomplish this. I hear many developers and critics citing that the budget may have been a factor in a game’s development cycle. But especially considering that this started as a mere Flash game, it says to me that the limitations stem from the developer’s imagination.

Storyline – 8/10

The story is extremely reminiscent of the Bible story of the same name. It follows a young boy named Isaac, who once lived peacefully with his mother until the voice of God called out to her to “cut her son off from the world’s evils”, and lock him in his room. God finally calls out to Isaac’s mother, demanding that she sacrifice her son to him as proof that she loves God above all. But before his mother can burst in to kill him, Isaac jumps down a trap door in his bedroom to plunge into the dangerous depths below. And into a world of danger. The story is extremely controversial. It contains several mature themes and taboos, including suicide, child neglect, religious hypocrisy, and infanticide; the list goes on. But above all, it’s very enjoyable for those willing to take heed to the lessons conveyed within it.

Originality – 7/10

Though there have been many Roguelike games to have come and gone, this is a game that stands out among most others. It goes where other games and developers are generally afraid to go. After Super Meat Boy, I resented the development of such a game. But The Binding of Isaac has made me respect Edmund McMillen a great deal more than I did as a developer. Especially since this was also a very personal game for him, as many of the game’s events were in fact based on his own childhood experiences.

Happii

Overall, The Binding of Isaac, whilst being the most controversial game I’ve ever played, is also one of the more enjoyable. It has everlasting replay value, as well as a story and premise that have rightfully propelled Edmund McMillen into a very special place in gaming history.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)

South Park: The Stick of Truth (Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 & PC)

South Park The Stick of Truth

Developer(s) – Obsidian Entertainment & South Park Digital Studios

Publisher(s) – Ubisoft

Director(s) – Chris Brion, Chris Parker & Zane Lyon

Producer(s) – Todd Benson & Matthew Singh

PEGI – 18

Hyped up for quite some time and having suffered from a fair few delays, South Park: The Stick of Truth had been a game that I was looking forward to a fair bit. When I saw that it was going to be a turn-based RPG, I was thinking to myself about the possibilities of factors such as variety in gameplay. And how long could it last? One of these concerns of mine was adequately met, whilst the other was not.

Graphics – 9.5/10

The developers were aiming to capture the feel of the show in the game’s visuals. And they did just that. Playing the game feels very much like playing an actual episode of South Park. So whilst the graphics aren’t cutting edge, there’s no call for them to be cutting edge. The visuals are as good as could be desired. One bad thing I would say about the game in terms of this axiom of judgment is that all the houses in the neighborhood area of South Park look exactly like one another, but are in different colors. But the thing is, that’s the way they are in the show as well.

And there are plenty of other unique-looking buildings and locations to compensate for that. In particular, I like how the developers designed Canada as an 8-bit environment. That was a very nice touch, and it did provide some diversity in visual style. But I think the worst instance of visual presentation in the game was the cutscene in which a UFO crash-lands in South Park. That part is rendered in 3D. And to me, it’s quite sloppy. It actually had the feel of the South Park first-person shooter that was released on the Nintendo 64 and PlayStation back in 1998.

Gameplay – 8/10

The game itself was also very enjoyable to play. It was a very nice throwback to old-style turn-based RPGs such as early Final Fantasy games or Dragon Quest. With learnable abilities, magic, and even summons to collect along the way. Although the game could have done with more, there are also a few side quests as well. Exploration is encouraged, but only to a certain extent. I think the gameplay aspect I can praise the most is the amount of variety it has. Like Final Fantasy, there are multiple party members at the player’s disposal. And they all have their own unique abilities and special moves. The combat system also presents the necessity to strategize, which is always a plus. The medium mode doesn’t present a lot of challenges. But for more intrepid players, the difficulty can be adjusted.

Controls – 10/10

As a 2D open-world turn-based RPG, the control scheme for games like this has long been perfect. And consequently, there should never have been any issues with the controls; nor are there, I’m happy to say. Many developers have tried to add different aspects of controls in turn-based RPGs in recent years to compensate for the characters simply standing still. Such as in Lost Odyssey, where bonus damage could be dealt with by pressing buttons at the correct times. But how the developers of this game have managed to do that is actually pretty impressive.

Lifespan – 3.5/10

Frustratingly, I’d finished this game in less than 14 hours. I’d say that at most, it would take players less than 20 hours to complete the game to 100%. And for a turn-based RPG, that’s nothing. Games like this can normally be made to last 80, maybe even 100 hours. Over five times longer than South Park: The Stick of Truth. Unfortunately, reminiscent of some games from the previous generation.

Such as Batman: Arkham Asylum, Dead Space, and Deus Ex: Human Revolution, this is one of those games that simply left me wanting more. If Trey Parker and Matt Stone ever wanted to release a sequel, I really wouldn’t mind more of the same in terms of gameplay. Just as long as it’s made to last far longer. My only hope now is that the planned DLC for the game can significantly increase its lifespan. Because, in its current state, it is far too short-lived.

Storyline – 7.5/10

Whilst the game’s story is extremely funny and very well thought out, I can’t help but think that it’s mostly open to one specific demographic. Fans of the series. Newcomers who may never have watched South Park before won’t be able to get laughs out of all the references to previous South Park episodes. And consequently, won’t get the most of what is to be had out of the game overall. But having said that, the main plot of the game is pretty appealing. The player takes control of a new kid who has just moved to South Park with his family. And whilst out looking to make friends, he inevitably finds Kyle, Stan, Cartman, and Kenny, who are all playing a huge kids’ game. Cartman and Kenny are the leaders of the Kupa Keep faction. And Kyle and Stan are the leaders of the Elven faction.

Cont…

The new kid is caught in the middle of the two groups waging war over an item called the Stick of Truth. According to the rules of their game, whoever controls the stick controls the universe. But it all turns into something much bigger than their little game, and the new kid must work to stop a threat looming over the entire town of South Park. Aside from the plot of the game being very good, in line with South Park tradition, the vulgarity dial is cranked up to 11.

For any readers who may be looking to try the game, but who may be easily offended. There is everything in this game, ranging from explicit violence, adult themes, foul language, toilet humor, full-frontal nudity, strong sexual content, political incorrectness, and disturbing imagery. Seven scenes of this game were even censored in not only the Middle East and Africa but also in Europe. Along with the PC version of the game also being censored in several other countries. So any players with children are strongly advised to make sure their kids don’t walk in on them playing this game.

Originality – 8.5/10

In terms of gameplay, whilst hearkening back to old-style Final Fantasy, South Park: The Stick of Truth is a unique take on the turn-based RPG genre as it has a unique story, unique level designs, and a unique enemy roster, ranging from elves and wolves to aliens and cows. The game can also be noted for its exceptional level of crudity. I have played many games that have caused a lot of controversy over the years, but it will be interesting to see how people react to this one.

Happii

Overall, South Park: The Stick of Truth was a very decent game to play through, but it did ultimately leave me wanting so much more out of it than what I got, and by that token, I felt pretty jaded by it. But it is worth playing once, and hopefully, it will be worth holding out for the planned DLC to come along and increase the game’s lifespan by at least some margin.

Score

47/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers (Sega Saturn, PlayStation & 3DS)

Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers

Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers

Developer(s) –Atlus

Publisher(s) – Atlus

Lead Artist – Kazuma Kaneko

PEGI – 12

Originally released for both the Sega Saturn and the PlayStation, Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers, for the longest time, never saw a release outside of Japan (with Sony Computer Entertainment America rejecting a proposed overseas port). Until it was eventually released in 2013 in both regions and Europe for the 3DS. After playing this game, whilst I would agree with the notion that there are far worse games out there, I’d say it was no surprise that Sony of America would reject a proposed port at first.

Since Final Fantasy VIII was out at the time. And it would most definitely have been lost in the crossfire. I think based on the fact that the same thing happened to Breath of Fire IV during the release of Final Fantasy IX. And people consider Breath of Fire IV to be a lost relic. It could have easily happened to Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers back then.

Graphics – 7/10

For the time at least, the graphics were fairly advanced, using many clever visual techniques used in many of its main competitors, such as Final Fantasy. Techniques like using hand-drawn stills as backgrounds. And FMVs to move the story forward. They made the game look pretty realistic. Conceptually, however, there’s much to suggest that Final Fantasy VII was a major influence. Since by that time, that series also deviated away from the typical RPG settings fans of the series were used to, in favor of a more cyberpunk setting.

Gameplay – 4.5/10

Since this game seemed to incorporate a more tedious form of exploration than many other RPGs around at the time. And there seemed to be less combat involved, I found it quite hard to get into. Especially towards the beginning. This imbalance of combat and exploration also makes me skeptical of the rest of the series. Since most other Megami Tensei games play out very similarly to one another.

Controls – 9/10

A first-person RPG, which, whilst somewhat unique, made the control scheme a little bit fiddly at times. It reminded me of another RPG I once played called Orcs & Elves. In which the movement was unnecessarily complicated. Otherwise, however, there are no other issues. The turn-based RPG formula had long since been perfected. And if they had managed to miss that aspect of it, there would have been considerably bigger problems than there ended up being in this title.

Lifespan – 8.5/10

As the strongest point of this game, it lasts a pretty decent amount of time, taking up to 30 to 40 hours to finish. Whilst this may still be below the standard of many other turn-based RPGs being released at the time, it’s still a long time from what most video games last. The biggest problem, however, is the danger of the lifespan most probably outlasting the boorish gameplay.

Storyline – 6/10

The story follows a group of characters who dwell within a virtual reality city created by a sinister corporation. They resolve to end their tyranny, as well as a group of cyber-terrorist hackers called cookies (led by a man named Masahiro Sakurai. Named after the developer of both the Kirby and Super Smash Bros series). The story is fairly well-conceived, but it can get a little bit confusing at times. It’s hard to follow, to begin with. Since events move at such a pace that not much time is given for players to think about what’s going on. But after that, it does become much easier to follow. It’s also interesting to think of what other stories influenced these games. Such as Ghost in the Shell, for example.

Originality – 6/10

Whilst it may be considerably unique from the rest of the Megami Tensei saga. With the settings and conceptual design being drastically different from any other entry in the series, there’s not much present to differentiate it from most other turn-based RPGs. Even for the time being. The game’s play doesn’t stand out particularly well. And it is easy to see how many other players had been so put off by the fact that it is a first-person RPG. Since the controls are indeed unnecessarily harder to get to grips with than the likes of Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest.

To summarize, Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers is not the most enjoyable game to play, but it does provide a relatively long experience and a well-thought-out story. Unfortunately, half-decent visuals and a good narrative aren’t enough for me to label this a classic. As many other people believe it is, there needs to be engrossing gameplay above all else, and I didn’t find any of them in this title.

Score

41/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Rogue Legacy (PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita & Xbox One)

Rogue Legacy

Developer(s) – Cellar Door Games

Designer(s) – Kenny & Teddy Lee

PEGI – 12

Rogue Legacy is a 2D randomly generated semi-open-world side-scroller RPG roguelike. Requiring the player to adapt to a wide variety of different dangers throughout. And coming up with as much gold and as many different upgrades with each playthrough. Although it is particularly demanding of its players in terms of individual skill. And it does take a bit of time to get the game’s fundamentals right to start, but it can turn into a very enjoyable gaming experience within a quick enough time frame, without it being far too inaccessible like the games that it was based on.

Graphics – 7/10

The visuals of Rogue Legacy are extremely reminiscent of those of some of the earlier years of console gaming. It contains finely designed 16-bit pixel art throughout. As well as some 8-bit music in its soundtrack. In many different ways, besides the graphics, the game can be seen as a love letter to several early Castlevania games, namely the original trilogy, as well as Symphony of the Night. Given the fact that the majority of the game takes place within and around a castle filled with tons of different enemies to have to overcome.

Gameplay – 8/10

The game requires the player to traverse Castle Hampson. And its other surrounding areas, to simply kill as many enemies as possible. And accumulate as much gold as possible to pay for upgrades. This will, in turn, make each succeeding player character stronger in order to eventually conquer the castle’s four bosses. And open the door to the game’s final boss. Every time a character dies, the player must then select an heir to that character. And return to the castle to simply rinse and repeat. What I like about this game so much is that the player character is almost always different in stature, ability, and strength, forcing players to compromise accordingly and adapt to multiple styles of play. The game demands diversity, exploration of gameplay variety, and experimentation. All whilst not being too punishing like many other retro 2D side scrollers.

Controls – 9/10

The only gripe I have with the controls is that they can be a little bit unresponsive at times, which in turn can lead to making unforced errors here and there. But by no means does this make the game unplayable. The control scheme, as well as the success of the game, heavily relies on the player’s ability to adapt to things such as character variety, enemy patterns, and being as prepared as possible for the unexpected.

Lifespan – 10/10

With an intense learning curve, as well as the ability to fight harder variations of the five bosses in the game, with the reward for beating them being an additional unlockable character, this game offers almost unlimited replay value, especially since it offers a different experience every time. It could be argued that one playthrough would take a few hours. But I believe playing through the entire game in one sitting will be a rarity.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

The game is also like an arcade title, in the respect that there is really no fixed plot, but only a basic premise, which is described through the basic premise of gameplay. There is a side quest in which the player must find a series of journals left behind by the castle’s prince, giving a small element of backstory, which, to me, acts as nothing more than a bonus, since this game didn’t need a fixed story, and by proxy, it isn’t marred down by any kind of feeble attempt at establishing one.

Originality – 6/10

Let it never be said that Rogue Legacy clearly has its influence in terms of both visual style and the basic premise of its gameplay. It even bears some resemblance to the same basic premise of many other video games before the story was as much of a focus as it is today. It does, however, score points in terms of originality for its positive modification of a very popular gaming formula, since no other game of its kind (that I’ve played anyway) has been able to offer such a huge amount of replay value.

Happii

To summarize, I would go so far as to say that Rogue Legacy is one of the greatest roguelike games I have ever played. It may sound like an extremely controversial opinion, but I’ve never played Rogue. But as it stands, this definitely makes the list of the best as far as I’m concerned.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor (PC, PlayStation 4 & Xbox One)

Middle Earth Shadow of Mordor

Developer(s) – Monolith Productions

Publisher(s) – Warner Bros. Interactive

Director – Michael de Plater

Producer – Mike Forge

PEGI – 18

Set in the world of JRR Tolkien’s epic fantasy The Lord of the Rings, Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor easily makes for the best game ever to be based on the popular license. Far surpassing my previous favorite based on Return of the King. Featuring addictive gameplay, breathtaking visuals, and an immersive story, it far surpassed my own expectations. And despite a couple of flaws, I consider it to be one of the best games of 2014.

Graphics – 8.5/10

The vast open world of Mordor set in the game, as well as the Orc characters and other supporting characters, give the game a beautifully dark and gritty atmosphere indeed. The attention to detail has also been made obvious with textures such as rainfall on buildings and the superb use of lighting throughout. However, what prevents this game from getting a perfect score in terms of visuals is that I did find a good number of glitches.

Most notably on the characters’ faces. Sometimes, characters’ faces can blacken out unexpectedly, making it obvious the fact that the game hasn’t been tested properly. Orcs have black blood in the game. And it could be argued that killing enemies is what causes this to happen, to give the effect of blood being splattered onto characters’ faces. But even if that is true, I still think it makes the game look flawed to a small extent.

Gameplay – 9/10

Regardless of this one big flaw in the game’s visuals, how excellently it plays out is more than enough to keep players hooked for an extremely long time. A love letter to fans of both the Batman Arkham series and Assassin’s Creed series, the gameplay is mission-based across a decently sized open world. With plenty of side quests and extracurricular activities to keep players busy. The game also introduces something very new to the medium. The nemesis system. How it works is that the game has Orc captains and war chiefs to command over lesser Orcs. And these enemies are much more powerful and unique in how they operate.

Orc captains can compete against each other to earn promotions and progress through the ranks as time passes. And regular Orcs can even rise the ranks for killing the player character. As Orc captains are killed by the player character, new captains are brought up through the ranks to replace them. The player also has the option to interrogate lesser Orc soldiers. In order to find out the identities of Orc captains and even learn their strengths and weaknesses, in order to determine how best to proceed while engaging them in combat. The nemesis system results in what is essentially an infinite side quest throughout the game. And ends up giving the title some serious value in terms of gameplay.

Controls – 9/10

The control scheme in Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor borrows elements from both Assassin’s Creed and the Batman Arkham series. The combat system is extremely refined. And stealth and acrobatics are essentials that players must employ to play the game most effectively. However, I found that the climbing mechanics, very much like those of the first Assassin’s Creed game, were a little bit inconsistent. Some things can be traversed and others can’t. And there isn’t any clear indication as to what can and can’t be traversed throughout the course of the game. And it can lead to unnecessary complications. Especially whilst the player is trying to escape overwhelming enemy numbers. Other than this, however, I have no further complaints. The combat system is handled exquisitely well. And the flaws in its controls don’t make it unplayable by any means.

Lifespan – 8.5/10

Even without any prolonged use of the nemesis system, this game can easily be made to last around 30 to 40 hours. Which is incredible for a game based on a pre-existing license. The Batman Arkham series has since included a long lifespan following Arkham Asylum. But for something, which could easily be the start of a new series of games based on the Middle-Earth mythos, this is incredible.

Storyline – 8/10

The game’s story is as wonderfully gripping as it is gut-wrenchingly dark and intense. It takes place in the interim between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. As the Orcs of Mordor prepare for the return of their master. The dark lord Sauron. Over 3000 years after the defeat of Sauron at the hands of Isildur, the city of Gondor has since posted rangers at the Black Gate to watch over the land of Mordor for suspicious activity. One of these rangers, Talion, is caught in the middle of the Orc invasion of Mordor and the Black Gate along with his wife and son. And the three of them are executed.

However, Talion is revived by an initially unnamed elven wraith, which merges with Talion, granting him ghostly abilities. Together, they resolve to learn of the wraith’s mysterious past and to avenge the death of Talion’s family by mounting an effective resistance against the armies of Mordor and their leader, the Black Hand of Sauron. Although it will inevitably be much harder for newcomers to the Middle-Earth mythos to take in everything that is happening since, for example, familiar characters such as Gollum will be largely unfamiliar, there is enough drama and suspense, and focus on the game’s narrative, in general, to keep newcomers interested. As well as fans of the books and films.

Originality – 7/10

The reason why I think Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor is somewhat unoriginal is that it borrows many ideas from already existing games, which makes the title mostly evolutionary as opposed to being revolutionary. That being said, the nemesis system does make it stand out greatly among most other eight-generation titles I’ve seen so far, and it is refreshing to see that mainstream developers are attempting to innovate within the industry, as opposed to it being exclusively indie developers.

Happii

To summarize, whilst it does indeed have its fair share of flaws, Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor is most definitely one of the best titles I’ve seen in the eighth generation of gaming yet, as well as being one of the standout titles of 2014. It’s enjoyable to play as well as pleasant to look at despite graphical flaws, and there is enough fan service present to both satisfy long-standing Tolkien fans and adequately introduce newcomers to the mythos.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Mercenary Kings (PC, PlayStation 4 & PlayStation Vita)

Mercenary Kings

Developer(s) – Tribute Games

Publisher(s) – Tribute Games

Artist – Paul Robertson

PEGI – 16

Being described as a mash-up between Metal Slug and Monster Hunter, Mercenary Kings is an indie 2D side-scrolling shoot ‘em up. It has a mild RPG element to it. In the form of collecting items to upgrade weapons and equipment. Out of all the indie games released on PlayStation 4, this is one that I would highly recommend above many others.

Graphics – 8/10

Hearkening back to the 16-bit era of consoles like the Super Nintendo and the Mega Drive, the game also takes place in a setting very reminiscent of the hormone-charged action films of the 1980s. Such as Rambo and Predator. Conceptually, it also stands out quite a lot thanks to the many wonderfully weird. And at times, downright amusing enemy designs are present. Such as that of flying pig heads and hostile radishes. One of the bosses is also extremely reminiscent of the mech that Ripley uses to take out the queen in another 80s film. Aliens.

Gameplay – 7/10

The objective of Mercenary Kings is relatively simple. But with a pretty interesting twist, complete set missions throughout Metroidvania-style environments. Whilst also collecting resources and items with which to periodically improve your equipment. Whilst earning money from completing missions for even more new gear. It is as addictive as it sounds. And whilst people have compared this game to Monster Hunter, it’s a lot more accessible. And by proxy, better, in my opinion.

Controls – 10/10

As yet another 2D side scroller, a common gameplay formula among indie developers, there should have been no excuse for this game to have had any issues. Since the formula has been long since perfect, and so there isn’t, thankfully. Even for veteran fans of the genre, it’s actually quite challenging to master the various enemy patterns and progress accordingly.

Lifespan – 4/10

I found that the biggest drawback to this game, however, is that the main storyline only clocks up about 3 to 4 hours. Which, for what is essentially a Metroidvania game, is pretty disappointing. Rogue Legacy, for example, could be made to last considerably longer. Given how long it would take to acquire each upgrade and unlockable. And how much of a legitimate challenge it was up to the third playthrough. But I think the same could have been done with this title as well, but alas, it hadn’t been.

Storyline – 6/10

The story follows King, the most skilled mercenary on Earth, who is sent to Mandragora Island to rescue engineer Dr. James Neil, who has been taken hostage by a villain named Claw and his gang of terrorists, and thereby also save Neil’s research into how mandrakes can be used as a means of bio-regeneration. As far as stories go, it’s about as cliché as any other story associated with the likes of Rambo and The Expendables trilogy, but in my opinion, it is able to hold the player’s interest for its duration.

Originality – 7/10

Like Valiant Hearts, this is yet another title to have been released to defy the tropes and conventions associated with most army-based video games. Though it clearly has been influenced by the Contra series, it’s been a while since a game like this has been released, and given how engaging and different it is compared with many other 2D side scrollers, I believe a sequel is in order.

Happii

In summation, Mercenary Kings is by far one of the best army-based video games I’ve ever played. It may be wanting in terms of story and many tropes seen in many other video games and films prior, but the focus has been primarily put into where it truly matters: the gameplay.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Kingdom Under Fire Circle of Doom

Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom (Xbox 360)

Developer(s) – Blueside

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Game Studios

PEGI – 16

The latest release in the Kingdom Under Fire series, pending the release of Kingdom Under Fire II, announced at the Tokyo Game Show, Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom follows the less familiar hack-and-slash formula of the series. As opposed to the more familiar gameplay aspects that the series is known for, which are real-time strategy. It received mixed reviews from critics following its release. And after having played it for some time, it’s plain to see why.

Graphics – 7/10

One good thing I can say about the game, however, is that it does have some fairly attractive graphics. Both technically and conceptually. It actually does a decent job of displaying early on what kind of visuals the Xbox 360 was capable of running. There’s also diversity in level design, from stages ranging from vibrant forests to gloomy canyons to hellish caves. Enemy design, however, is very generic. With the same kinds of enemies appearing in multiple stages of the game, but simply palette-swapped.

Gameplay – 3.5/10

The game’s play revolves simply around hacking and slashing from point A to point B, with a boss at the end of each stage of the game. Though Hyrule Warriors is fairly bad for repetition, the degree to which this game takes it is unfathomable from very early on. There is some basis for variety. As there are multiple playable characters to go through the story, who all have their own set of abilities. But in all honesty, that’s as far as variety goes.

The second biggest focus in the game, I found, was learning all these different kinds of abilities. To learn an ability, the player must kill a pre-designated number of specific types of enemies. When this is achieved, the player can then enter safe sanctuaries. There are scattered all throughout the game, to collect a new ability and then begin to learn a new one. Annoyingly, only two abilities can be learned at a time. Adding a little bit of unnecessary longevity to the game.

Controls – 8/10

Although there is nothing wrong with how the control scheme is mapped out, I found that movement could be particularly stiff. In a game where movement plays a pretty pivotal role during combat, this can cause a few unnecessary complications while playing. And the last thing anyone needs whilst playing a hack-and-slash game, or indeed any other type of game, is an element of unfairness hindering the game’s sense of challenge. Apart from that, however, I found that there were thankfully no issues that needed to be addressed.

Lifespan – 8.5/10

For those who are willing to soldier through the sheer level of repetition attached to this title, this game can actually be made to last particularly long for a hack-and-slash game. If players desire to reach 100%, learn every character’s ability, and reach the level cap with every character, it will most probably take around 45 to 50 hours. But how long the game lasts ultimately depends on the player’s reaction to the gameplay. If players are much more lukewarm to the style of the game than I was, then they will be playing for a long time.

Storyline – 4/10

There isn’t very much in the way of the story of Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom. But rather a mere basic premise and back story. Nibel, the lord of light, and Encablossa, the lord of darkness, made a pact. Stating that each would take turns ruling the world. However, weary of the mistreatment of his creatures, Nibel refuses to relinquish his rule to Encablossa, infuriating him. Encablossa, in response, gathers his army to attack the world, and it is now the quest of the playable characters to defeat Encablossa and his army.

Beyond that, the story is elaborated on a whole lot. And it certainly could have done with being explained a lot more in-depth than it was. Though, of course, it works better for fans of the series, I don’t think it works at all for players who started the series with it and will inevitably think much less of it than they may have if they started from the beginning. The character who I think makes for the most interesting plot threads is Regnier. As his campaign unfolds, a dark back story is slowly revealed. And that does add a nice shock factor to the game. But apart from that, I don’t think the story was expanded on as much as it should have been to properly introduce newcomers to the series.

Originality – 4/10

Though the developers tried something new with the two hack-and-slash games in the Kingdom Under Fire series, it didn’t work. Since they didn’t really add anything to it to differentiate it from the many other games like it. I think there are many things the developers could have done to try to remedy that problem. Such as making the story more interesting. Or taking a lot of the repetition out of the game and adding much more variety to it. But ultimately, it just feels like a very generic hack-and-slash title.

Angrii

In summation, Kingdom Under Fire: Circle of Doom is definitely one of the most unimaginative and repetitious games ever developed for the Xbox 360. Though not one of the worst games I’ve ever played, and it can actually offer quite a few hours of play to those willing to overlook how repetitive it is, it does feel like the game really needed an extra push, and the developers just didn’t try.

Score

35/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

Hoard (PC, PlayStation 3 & PlayStation Portable)

Hoard

Developer(s) – Big Sandwich Games

Publisher(s) – Big Sandwich Games

PEGI – 7

A vast majority of indie games that Sony seems to have been releasing on the PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, and PlayStation Vita have been RPGs, much to my personal delight. In my opinion, Hoard stands out as one of the best. It makes use of a very unique gameplay premise. And despite the repetition, it makes for an extremely enjoyable experience.

Graphics – 7/10

Like Transistor, Hoard makes use of an isometric top-down view. Which, in turn, gives the game the illusion of being in greater detail than it would look like up close. I’ve seen the same technique used in many other games, such as Diablo III, Champions of Norrath, and Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance. I’ve always been a fan of this technique being used in gaming. And it’s handled very well in Hoard. It does lose some marks for its lack of uniqueness in conceptual design, however.

Gameplay – 8/10

Although this game lacks uniqueness in one aspect, it does make up for it in terms of gameplay. The player takes control of a dragon and must collect as much gold and capture as many princesses as possible before the timer runs out. And must collect more than the CPU dragon in each stage of the game. There are several different game modes, including a survival mode. This gives the game an unprecedented amount of replay value. Even the online multiplayer is handled particularly well in my opinion.

Controls – 10/10

Since isometric gameplay has been around for some time, I think there would have been serious issues with this game if the control scheme hadn’t been handled properly. Fortunately, it has been handled properly. But the combat system also differs from many other games. And it actually makes Hoard stand out even more than perhaps players may assume at first glance.

Originality – 7/10

I think the reasons why this game stands out among most other indie RPGs released on the PlayStation console of late are many. It has a great amount of replay value, making it last for hours upon hours on end. The combat system differs from most other RPGs I’ve ever played. And it’s also one of the very few games in which the player is put in control of a dragon. It personally speaks to me since they were my favorite mythological beasts growing up. I have enjoyed a few games, including dragons, such as Spyro 2, and later Skyrim. But this title does very well to differentiate itself from even those two classics.

Happii

Overall, Hoard is an extremely addictive and enjoyable game, and it is an exceptional catalyst for keeping PlayStation 3 consoles powered on for at least a little while longer. It’s one of the very few games I’ll play multiplayer on, and several more game modes to keep players entertained for an extraordinary amount of time.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Final Fantasy X-2 (PlayStation 2, PlayStation 3 & PlayStation 4)

Final Fantasy X-2

Developer(s) – Square

Publisher(s) – Square Enix & Electronic Arts

Director – Motomu Toriyama

Producer – Yoshinori Kitase

PEGI – 12

The first direct sequel to be developed in the history of the series, Final Fantasy X-2 was created with the intention of presenting players with a much more positive atmosphere within the universe of Spira. Departing from the darker and more serious vibe that the original game gave off. It certainly lived up to that, as most of the main characters are much more carefree than in the previous game, which presents a few problems in the storyline. Nevertheless, it plays out very much in line with the Final Fantasy tradition. Arguably, more so than its predecessor.

Graphics – 9.5/10

From a technical standpoint, there were a few minor improvements made departing from Final Fantasy X. Most notably in the facial expressions of the central characters. A couple of the locations within the game have also been re-designed, with a few new locations within familiar ones thrown in for good measure. Such as the dungeons of Zanarkand and the floating ruins atop Mt Gagazet. Although the majority of the open world in the game is taken directly from the original game. Some players may criticize it, but I look at that as being both practical and realistic.

Gameplay – 8/10

The basic premise of gameplay works pretty differently from most other games in the franchise. It involves the main characters taking many different missions throughout Spira. With the option of choosing where they may go from the beginning. Eliminating the initial sense of linearity synonymous with most main entries in the Final Fantasy series. In addition, the combat also has a few changes. It relies on the active time system to determine which character attacks next.

Character classes also work much differently. Swapping out the sphere grid in favor of giving the player the option to make the character swap out their class at will. Making it easier for each character to become a jack of all trades. Though I prefer the sphere grid system from Final Fantasy X, this system worked particularly well. And to me, it was the last great Final Fantasy combat system. Before Square Enix changed it for the worse.

Controls – 10/10

Despite the new take on combat, it is still particularly simple to get to grips with. And otherwise, the rest of the game plays out more or less identically to the previous game. With which there were also no problems.

Lifespan – 8/10

Though it can’t be made to last over 100 hours like the original game, it can still be made to last a particularly long time. Around 50 hours or so, which is still adequate for an RPG. At first, I thought of it as being underwhelming for a game that had open-world exploration available as an option. But for a game that took merely 2 years to develop, it’s quite the achievement.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of Final Fantasy X-2 follows the female lead of the last game, Yuna, as she has since formed her own team of treasure hunters called the Gullwings, along with former party member Rikku and a new character called Paine. Yuna formed the team after she found a sphere seemingly containing footage of her love interest and the male lead of the last game, Tidus. Believing he may still be in Spira somewhere, she also resolves to find him. Though the story starts as being much happier than Final Fantasy X, it does eventually develop into something much darker and convoluted, which keeps the sub-series fresh. But it’s also marred down during the first half of the game by the fact that the dialogue between the main characters is much cheesier than in the previous game, as the Gullwings give off a vibe very reminiscent of Charlie’s Angels.

Originality – 7/10

Though the game follows very many tropes of the series that many players will be familiar with and, at this point, even accustomed to, it still makes for one of the standout experiences on the PlayStation 2. It gave testament to how innovative the original Square team could be before the merger between them and Enix, and then, in my opinion, at least, the Final Fantasy series was left to stagnate. Commercially and critically, it continues to do exceptionally well, but I’ve never been captivated by any of the newer games in the same capacity that I have with most other entries in the series before Final Fantasy XI. This, in my opinion, has been the last Final Fantasy game with any positive innovation attached to it.

Happii

Overall, Final Fantasy X-2, whilst not having the same sense of longevity as the original game, is nevertheless a very worthy sequel and worthy of the attention of anyone with either a PlayStation 2, 3, or 4. Despite the sometimes cringeworthy dialogue, the story does eventually evolve into something better and has many other elements keeping the series positively fresh at that point.

Score

47.5/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Final Fantasy XII (PC, PlayStation 2, PlayStation 4, Xbox One & Switch)

Final Fantasy XII

Developer(s) – Square Enix

Publisher(s) – Square Enix

Director(s) – Hiroyuki Ito & Hiroshi Minagawa

Producer – Akitoshi Kawazu

PEGI – 16

It’s my opinion that ever since Squaresoft and Enix merged into the entity Square Enix, and the subsequent departure of many of the central developers of previous Final Fantasy games, such as series creator Hironobu Sakaguchi and long-time composer Nobuo Uematsu, the Final Fantasy games have taken a huge turn for the worse in terms of quality. To me, Final Fantasy XII is the best example of that.

Graphics – 4/10

Although the graphics are technically marvelous, instead of the franchise’s tradition of bringing cinematic experiences to gaming, not only is this set in an already established universe, breaking series traditions, but I didn’t find it very conceptually compelling either. It seems to encompass a world heavily influenced by medieval fantasy and steampunk fiction. This was done with Final Fantasy IX and Breath of Fire IV to a certain extent. But both of those games did it infinitely better than this. As has every other Final Fantasy game since number VI.

Gameplay – 0/10

In all honesty, I couldn’t get through the prologue of this game without feeling acrimoniously disappointed by it. It was the first time I’d ever witnessed the combination of turn-based RPG combat and real-time combat. And I’d never been more sorry to see a franchise undergo such a negative change. I remember watching a video on YouTube published by a reviewer called Stan Burdman. In it, he voiced his opinions on the deterioration of the Final Fantasy franchise and commented that developers don’t improve on either turn-based RPG combat or real-time combat by combining them together, but rather they are both made worse. And I couldn’t agree more with that point. The video itself no longer seems to be on his channel, but he was the very first video game reviewer I ever found on YouTube. And I would highly recommend readers check him out.

https://www.youtube.com/user/stanburdman

Controls – 3/10

Since Final Fantasy XII was also very much a question of trial and error, since it was also one of the first games, unfortunately, to popularise this style of play, the control scheme was always going to be a matter of contention. And in my opinion, it’s handled very poorly within the combat system and only served to make this game feel like that much worse of an experience.

Lifespan – 10/10

In lieu of the Final Fantasy tradition, however, the game lasts about the amount of time that could be expected of a game of its kind. And does offer an extremely long experience for those who are more lukewarm to this style of play. Leveling up characters takes a long time. And there are a great many side quests to keep players entertained at least.

Storyline – 5/10

Aside from the game being set in an already familiar world, it also has an already familiar plot attached to it. Another Final Fantasy convention was unfortunately broken with the twelfth game. It takes place in the world of Ivalice, the same set as Squaresoft’s own RPG Vagrant Story. It tells the story of an orphan named Vaan, who, along with the traditional supporting cast of characters, is caught in the middle of a raging war. And must fight to bring peace to Ivalice.

Originality – 0/10

Though the game has a unique combat system, I think that it makes it unique in a much more negative way. In my opinion, it’s too much of a radical departure from other games in the series. This has led to a sharp decline ever since. As I pointed out, there is also hardly any originality in the visuals or the story. And in that respect, it makes it seem even more like a step down from every other exceptional game in the franchise.

Angrii

To sum up, Final Fantasy XII is unanimously my least favorite game in the Final Fantasy series. And one of the worst games ever made. I’ve hated this title ever since I first played it, and there haven’t been a lot of games released throughout the years to have disappointed me as much as this.

Score

22/60

3.5/10 (Very Poor)