Monthly Archives: July 2016

Chip N’ Dale: Rescue Rangers (NES)

Chip N Dale

Developer(s) – Capcom

Publisher(s) – Capcom

Designer – Masayoshi Kurokawa

Producer – Tokoru Fujiwara

Rating – N/A

As the first game I ever played, Chip N’ Dale: Rescue Rangers for the NES has always held a special place in my own video gaming repertoire. And one that I think still very much holds up to this day. Back when 2D side-scrolling was the standard in the medium and on the console, Chip N’ Dale, to me, stands out as one of the better efforts, among many other unlicensed games in the genre, such as Robodemons and Menace Beach. And even among some of Capcom’s more popular efforts, like Mega Man.

Graphics – 8/10

There is a lot of extremely effective use of colour in Chip N’ Dale, just like Mega Man before it. Capcom was the first developer to bring the new standard of adding black outlines to both character sprites and scenery. Thus making it easier for certain shades of the same colour. Such as blue, to blend in better with one another. And also to make the sky texture stand out better than everything else. It’s evident that they also used the same technique in Chip N’ Dale. And it worked flawlessly. The soundtrack to this game is also extremely impressive and stands out greatly among most 8-bit NES soundtracks.

Gameplay – 7/10

What I think makes Chip N’ Dale better than the original Mega Man is that it’s a lot more accessible. The difficulty curve hasn’t been set anywhere near as high as the Blue Bomber’s first game, but regardless, it remains a fair challenge. It’s also interesting to see what influence Capcom took from Nintendo, and the second instalment of Super Mario Bros, with players having to pick up objects and throw them at enemies in order to advance, not to mention the mechanics of being able to select multiple playable characters.

Controls – 10/10

It was even by this early point in gaming that the 2D side-scrolling formula had been more or less perfected, especially since Capcom had had a fair amount of prior experience with the likes of Mega Man, and then would have in the future with Strider, it was natural to assume there would be no problems with the Chip N’ Dale’s controls scheme, and so there is none.

Lifespan – 7/10

At the time, it wasn’t considered below standard for a game to last as little time as less than an hour, and since this game lasts about as long as the average Mario or Sonic game, I don’t think it should lose too many marks for not lasting any longer than it did. There were exceptionally longer games around at the time, such as the original Final Fantasy or the first Metroid game, but depending on player skill, they can be made to last a fair amount of time for what technological advancement at that time would allow.

Storyline – 5/10

The story, however, was particularly generic and typical of the time, really. It follows Chip and Dale on a mission to save their damsel in distress, Gadget, from their archenemy, Fat Cat. Throughout the NES era, that was the usual structure of most video game narratives, and there’s really nothing present in this game to differentiate it from other narratives of the time.

Originality – 6/10

Though this game clearly has its influences, everything from Mega Man to Super Mario Bros 2 to even Castlevania to a certain extent, this was my own personal introduction to video gaming and would lead me to experience all the great video games that I have experienced to date. A lot of the boss fights still stand out to me, as does the soundtrack, and the game itself is certainly a lot more enjoyable to play than many other games on the NES, licensed by Nintendo or otherwise.

Happii

To summarize, Chip N’ Dale: Rescue Rangers still speaks to me as an excellent catalyst whereby to have been introduced to the medium at all. And one of the best games on the NES. It’s a must-have for any retro gamer and still stands out in terms of visuals for the time, as well as substance in gameplay.

Score

43/60

7/10 (Fair)

Child of Light (PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Wii U & PC)

Child Of Light

Developer(s) – Ubisoft Montreal, Ubisoft Bucharest, Ubisoft Ukraine & Ubisoft Massive

Publisher – Ubisoft

Director – Patrick Plourde

Producer – Jeffrey Yohalem

PEGI – 7

Much like Ubisoft’s previous effort, South Park: The Stick of Truth, Child of Light is a turn-based RPG. But developed using the same engine as what was used to develop the most recent batch of Rayman games. But in my opinion, this game is superior to South Park in many different ways.

Graphics – 10/10

The world of Lemuria is one of the most exquisitely beautiful and unique video game worlds ever designed, in my opinion. As one of the most conceptually compelling games I’ve seen for some time, it presents players with something particularly memorable in its scenery, visual style, and impressive enemy roster reminiscent of that of classic Final Fantasy instalments. I could argue the case that the character sprites may seem inconsistent, with some rendered in 3D while most have been rendered in 2D. But to me, that’s splitting hairs. No matter what dimension the characters have been rendered in, they have all been designed spectacularly. The visuals are also accompanied by an extremely impressive and atmospheric soundtrack.

Gameplay – 8.5/10

I first saw footage of this game about 3 months ago. And I expected that it would probably be no more than a simple 2D side-scrolling adventure game. So imagine my surprise and delight when I discovered it to be a turn-based RPG as well. It’s an extremely addictive and fun game to play overall. Complete with side quests and a great variety. But unlike South Park: The Stick of Truth, there is much more call for character alteration. I personally found that South Park, whilst having variety, could be played using a regular set of characters virtually from start to finish. But with Child of Light, the heightened presence of strategy greatly necessitates the constant switching between characters. And therefore providing a much more variable experience overall. On top of that, Lemuria is also a much bigger in-game world than South Park.

Controls – 10/10

Whilst it was to be expected that there would be no problems with the controls (the turn-based RPG formula having been long since perfected), this game adds some pretty unique mechanics to the formula through the timeline system reminiscent of the Attack Time Bar system found in previous games in the genre. And the mechanic of flying across each screen to encourage exploration.

Lifespan – 2/10

The downside to this game is that it’s even shorter than South Park: The Stick of Truth. 14 hours was bad enough for a turn-based RPG in my opinion. But Child of Light can only be made to last for perhaps 8 hours at most. If Ubisoft, or any other game developer for that matter, truly wants to make a much greater game in this genre, they have to develop it to last much longer, in my opinion. As I stated in my review of South Park: The Stick of Truth, games like this can normally be made to last from 80 to 100 hours. And both South Park and Child of Light fall criminally short of that.

Storyline – 8.5/10

The story of Child Light follows a young girl named Aurora from 1985 Austria, who contracts an illness, which causes her to fall into a prolonged sleep. She wakes up to find herself in the world of Lemuria, which has had its sun, moon, and stars stolen by the Black Queen. It’s Aurora’s job, with the help of several allies, to recover these celestial bodies and reunite with her father in her own world.

The story is very reminiscent of both Sleeping Beauty and many films in the Studio Ghibli library, such as Kiki’s Delivery Service and Spirited Away. In that, it features a young girl coming of age and learning to survive in the world. The dialogue in the story is structured through rhyme. The story essentially feels like an extremely long poem, which is very original for a video game. There are times when the poetry is somewhat hit-and-miss. But for the most part, it adds positively to this extremely artistically driven game. While it may not be as funny as South Park, it certainly has a lot more artistic value attached to it in every way.

Originality – 9/10

To call this game unique is an understatement. It has uniqueness attached to it in every aspect, from the stunning, hand-painted visuals to the greatly necessary variety in gameplay. And the intricate and wonderful story. The influence of this title can be very easily identified. But all its influences have had an extremely positive effect and allowed for the making of a very different and gripping experience.

Happii

Overall, Child of Light is an artistic tour de force of a video game. With great gameplay, great visuals, and a great story. I think if it were to have been made to last a whole lot longer, then it would have been a much greater force to be reckoned with. But regardless, this game is, to me, one of the standout titles of 2014.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Champions of Norrath (PlayStation 2)

Champions of Norrath

Developer(s) – Snowblind Studios

Publisher(s) – Sony Online Entertainment & Ubisoft

Designer(s) – Paul Knutzen & Chris Avellone

PEGI – 12

Set in the EverQuest universe and garnering a great deal of critical acclaim upon release, Champions of Norrath is a top-down hack-and-slash adventure game with more of a focus on online multiplayer than many other PlayStation 2 titles. However, the fact that it makes use of the Dark Alliance engine led me to draw inevitable comparisons between this game and one of my favorite PlayStation 2 games of all time, Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance. And put against that game, it doesn’t even compare despite its stronger points.

Graphics – 7/10

Like in Dark Alliance, the game utilizes a top-down view. Which makes it seem like it has much more graphical detail from a distance than it actually does. The problem is that whilst the visuals aren’t terrible, textural detail is far less present. Even though an upgraded version of the Dark Alliance engine was used to create this game. Not only that, but it also suffers from frame rate issues. When Dark Alliance didn’t at all. The best thing about the visuals is how the game differs in conceptual design. Not only from Dark Alliance but also from a good number of pseudo-medieval video games, with very different-looking settings and scenery.

Gameplay – 10/10

The one thing I can’t fault this game for, however, is the gameplay. Which is just as addictive and immersing as Dark Alliance. It revolves around the same concept. Kill everything in sight, loot the corpses, return to the hub area and sell unwanted items, fight each boss as it comes, rinse, and repeat. Of course, there is also the added feature of online multiplayer for people with access to PS2 NetPlay. And the facility is also quite well handled, exceeding my expectations of what it would be like.

Controls – 10/10

The game plays out identically to Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance. And consequently, there are no issues with the controls at all. The only difference is the method by which items are equipped and stored in the player’s inventory. But to me, that would merely be splitting hairs. There is the same degree of strategy involved in combat. Making the game just as enjoyable to play.

Lifespan – 6/10

The game’s lifespan is also on the same level as Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance, lasting roughly 10 to 15 hours, which, in my opinion, is far too short for a game of its gameplay value and general calibre. A game this addictive can easily be made to last much longer, and after two Baldur’s Gate games, I initially thought that the developers may have realized that based on the critical and commercial success of the former two games, but sadly, that wasn’t the case.

Storyline – 7/10

Aside from being somewhat typical of its genre, the story also has other flaws. It follows a group of Norrath’s champions battling to drive away the forces of evil from the land. Whilst it can be argued that the story in Dark Alliance is no different, there was a lot more depth in the story in the former, and a series of sub-stories to keep things even more interesting; not to mention the voice acting was infinitely better with contributions from many highly acclaimed actors and actresses, including Jennifer Hale, Tony Jay and even John Rhys Davies of Lord of the Rings fame. But in Champions of Norrath, the voice acting can be described as mediocre, even laughable, despite the inclusion of Michael Bell, Greg Ellis, and even Malcolm McDowell.

Originality – 5/10

Though the gameplay is just as enjoyable as in Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance, the fact of the matter is that there is not a great deal else present for gamers to be able to differentiate it from its spiritual predecessor, or other games, save for the scenery and style. The inclusion of online play was fairly well implemented but would be improved upon for the sequel, and was still a question of trial and error at the time, as indeed was online multiplayer itself.

Happii

In summation, although it can be heavily and negatively compared to the Dark Alliance games, it doesn’t mean that Champions of Norrath is bad; not by a long shot. Just as much emphasis was put on gameplay, and there were no flaws in it, at least. Given the choice, I would much rather see flaws in aspects like the story and even originality to a certain extent, as gameplay is, and should be considered the most important aspect of any video game.

Score

45/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (PlayStation & Sega Saturn)

Castlevania Symphony of the Night

Developer(s) – Konami Computer Entertainment Tokyo & Konami Computer Entertainment Nagoya

Publisher(s) – Konami

Director – Toru Hagihara

Producer – Toru Hagihara

PEGI – 12

Castlevania: Symphony of the Night is often regarded as the commercial and artistic pinnacle of the entire Castlevania series. At the time of its release, 2D gaming was going out of fashion, and 3D gaming was considered the next best thing. The future of the industry. For a lot of people, Symphony of the Night served as a reminder that traditional 2D side-scrolling video games can still be played and enjoyed regardless of what style might be the more popular. And it also left a lasting legacy behind, as the release of the game prompted the coinage of the term Metroidvania. For the style of play that involves 2D open-world exploration. After finally playing this game, I can say that I haven’t been disappointed, although it did leave me wanting more in the end.

Graphics – 9/10

Symphony of the Night also sent out a significant message to do with visuals in video games. That they should be judged not by their level of graphical advancement, but by their artistic merit. And this game certainly delivers on artistic merit. The environments in this game are wonderfully designed and add to the atmosphere very effectively. A lot of gloomy and scary-looking locations, such as the library, as well as the outlandish roster of enemies throughout, certainly make the game look original as well as excellent in terms of conceptual design. I think the most annoying enemies in the game are the flaming ghosts, which make particularly annoying sounds when they die. But that’s not down to visuals at all, but the sound. And the game certainly makes up for that in its stellar soundtrack.

Gameplay – 9/10

As this game coined an extremely popular genre, it was always going to have at least some depth to it. And I wasn’t disappointed. As I said, it’s rare that I’ve seen this level of freedom in a 2D side-scrolling game. And it makes me regret that I didn’t try when it first came out. In terms of combat, the game is fairly challenging in line with the franchise’s tradition. But the true satisfaction to be had is from levelling up the character as the player progresses. It’s that RPG element that makes the game even more appealing to me. Although it can seem repetitive at times, and it does get somewhat easier later on, I’d rather have it that way than have it be impossibly hard like the original trilogy was.

Controls – 10/10

In terms of controls, I’m happy to say that there are no problems with them. Players should not experience any difficulty with them as far as I’m concerned. This game was released at a time when countless 2D side-scrolling games had been released prior. So it was to be expected that there would be no issues with the control scheme. And there aren’t any.

Lifespan – 6/10

In my opinion, Castlevania: Symphony of the Night doesn’t last anywhere near long enough, and like Batman: Arkham Asylum and Deus Ex: Human Revolution, it left me wanting a whole lot more. A first playthrough may take around 15 hours to complete. Which, to me, for the amount of depth there is in gameplay, is unacceptable. Although that is fairly long for a 2D side scroller, I’m confident that more could have been added to it.

Storyline – 7.5/10

Whilst most entries in the series before focused solely on the Belmont family resolving to defeat Dracula, Castlevania: Symphony of the Night follows Dracula’s son, Alucard, who is questing to stop Dracula’s resurrection and finds himself in various different situations throughout Dracula’s castle along the way. It’s a positive departure from what was typically found in previous entries in the series in that the story has a lot more depth to it. The one bad thing I would say about it is that the voice acting is pretty bad in some instances. Even in the latest versions of the game, which were re-dubbed by different actors and actresses.

Originality – 8/10

A portion of this game’s staggering level of uniqueness can be found in its conceptual design and in the multitude of different enemies to fight. But, of course, the main reason why this game stands out among others is its gameplay. The reason why it has left behind such a legacy is that it is considered its own genre by some: Metroidvania. Although Super Metroid, the other game that this term stems from, came first out of the two, Symphony of the Night, in effect, kept the 2D side-scrolling genre alive and helped to inspire the development of many future games of its kind after it had been abandoned for some time.

Happii

To summarize, whilst it doesn’t last anywhere near as long as it should have done in my opinion, Castlevania: Symphony of the Night is most definitely worth playing through at least once or twice. It’s an important piece of gaming history as well as a particularly enjoyable title.

Score

49/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Castlevania III: Dracula's Curse

Castlevania III: Dracula’s Curse (Nintendo Entertainment System)

Developer(s) – Konami

Publisher(s) – Konami & Palcom

Director – Hitoshi Akamatsu

Designer – I. Urata

Rating – N/A

Essentially a carbon copy of the first game, Castlevania III: Dracula’s Curse took the majority of the principal mechanics of the game. And gave it multiple passages, taking away much of the linearity of the first, as well as having a fresh coat of paint in terms of visuals. Though it is indeed fractionally more enjoyable than the first game, in my opinion, it still had its flaws.

Graphics – 8/10

Though the limited colour palette of the NES is still relatively evident in this game, the visuals are a dramatic improvement on the first game. Featuring more detailed scenery and characters. Though many elements of the first have been recycled for use in the third, it still made for one of the better-looking games on the system, in my opinion. The soundtrack is also as epic as ever. Something that the series would come to be known for as the years passed.

Gameplay – 6/10

The basic gameplay premise of the original Castlevania title was brought back for use in the third game, with players having to use their wicked cunning to overcome any obstacles or enemies thrown at them. Aside from giving players more to play for, certain paths are also not as unforgiving as the first game. And it’s ultimately a lot more accessible because of it. The series would go on to accommodate a greater range of players as it progressed. Still, to me, this was the ideal turning point. Since it would have also geared potential fans up for the different directions the series would be taken throughout future generations of video gaming.

Controls – 9/10

A lot of the same issues that cropped up in the first game also, unfortunately, cropped up in the third, too, with a good few glitches that cause players to fall beneath disappearing platforms. However, the issue isn’t as big a problem in the first game. And there aren’t any others to address, thankfully.

Lifespan – 7/10

Designed to be played multiple times, the third game lasted much longer than what was the average lifespan of a video game for the time. Totalling about three and a half hours for experienced players. But taking into account the time it can take to master each facet of the game, whilst not unforgiving, it still provides a fairly stern challenge, and it can be made to last even longer.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of Castlevania III: Dracula’s Curse was made to be an origin narrative of the entire series. Set in 1476, it features Trevor Belmont, as opposed to the more familiar Simon Belmont. It was at that time that the first struggle between Dracula and the Belmont clan. This time, Trevor can also be accompanied by one of two different characters, depending on what path the player takes: either a sorceress called Sypha Belnades or Dracula’s son, Alucard. It added a little bit more than the average story in gaming. But it didn’t break any new ground in this respect at the time. Since games of the day were pretty light on the story in any case. It didn’t feature many of the story elements found in video games today.

Originality – 8/10

Although the game didn’t introduce many new story elements to the gaming industry, and largely stuck to the same principles as most games on the NES, it still perpetuated the same ideas as Simon’s Quest did. Games didn’t have to follow a linear path. They could go in several different directions and play out differently from one another. That ideal may have been toned down somewhat with this game. But it still made for an experience, unlike many other 2D side scrollers on the NES.

Happii

Castlevania III: Dracula’s Curse is my favorite out of the original three Castlevania games. Though things would get even better for the series as it progresses in my opinion, it was still a very positive departure from the shaky start that it had gotten to.

Score

44/60

7/10 (Fair)

Castlevania II: Simon’s Quest (Nintendo Entertainment System)

hgusCastlevania II

Developer(s) – Konami

Publisher(s) – Konami

Director – Hitoshi Akamatsu

Programmer(s) – Nobuhiro Matsuoka & Yasuo Kuwahara

Rating – N/A

Drawing comparisons with the original Metroid game, released a year before, Castlevania II: Simon’s Quest made a departure from the linear style of play of the original game. It included an open-world environment back in a time when the concept was in its infancy. And before it eventually became an industry standard. Whilst I didn’t find it anywhere near as annoying as the first game, the second isn’t without its flaws.

Graphics – 8.5/10

Graphically, the second game is a massive improvement on the first. Making use of even more colours and variety in character sprites on a console with an extremely limited colour palette. It was also one of the first games developed to have a day-to-night transition. This has since become yet another industry standard in video gaming. Many have expressed opinions about the sprite for Simon Belmont, being less detailed than in the first game. But I would disagree. New enemies are also added to the sequel on top of classic ones from the previous games, which were inspired by horror movie culture. But unlike the first game, the second has a bit more originality about it in terms of visual style and variety.

Gameplay – 6/10

Many readers may have expected me to think infinitely more highly of the second game than the first, since the difficulty had been dialed down considerably, thus making it a lot more accessible to a lot more players, and that, of course, it is non-linear. But as I pointed out, Castlevania II: Simon’s Quest is not flawless. The game was developed at a time when open-world games were virtually unheard of. Thus, a lot of the industry standards for open-world games had not been either met or established.

Standards such as the inclusion of an in-game map or quest markers. Not having any of these consequently makes Simon’s Quest a very awkward game to play without a strategy guide. Not a lot can be figured out by the player on their own. And a strategy guide is more or less mandatory if players desire to finish the main story. Let alone complete it to 100%.

Controls – 9/10

Like the first game, the controls can be a little bit slow to respond at some of the most crucial times. For me, it marred the quality of the first game to some extent. And the developers made the same mistake again with the second game. And would also do with the third in the main NES trilogy, too. Otherwise, however, there are no other problems with the game’s control scheme. And the majority of what it boils down to is the player’s own individual skill.

Lifespan – 8/10

Although the game can only be made to last for a few hours, the fact of the matter remains that this was exceptionally long for an NES game, since a single cartridge could hold only a fraction of the memory that a modern game can. After all, it was exceptionally long games back in the day. This would eventually inspire the creation of even exceptionally longer games throughout the course of the industry’s history. And I think if that standard hadn’t been set, video games would not be a fraction of what they have evolved into over the last 25 years or so.

Storyline – 5/10

There is a bit more depth to the second story than there was to the first. The second takes place some years after the first game, with the main protagonist, Simon Belmont, out to break a curse that had been placed upon him by Dracula following their previous confrontation. To break the curse, Simon must collect the 5 pieces of Dracula’s spirit and take them to the ruins of his castle to seal them, defeating him and ridding himself of the curse.

There’s a little bit more of a twist to the story to help it effectively deviate from most other story-driven games of the time. But the problem that hinders it almost as much as the first game was the poor attention to detail during the localization process. A lot of the dialogue in the game was very poorly translated. And many clues that were integral to what had to be done throughout the game ended up being misunderstood. And it took a lot of seriousness away from the overall game.

Originality – 7/10

Although 2D side-scrolling was standard at the time, Castlevania II: Simon’s Quest also ended up pioneering a lot of future video game standards that are still adhered to today. And any game that could do that with the limited technology available at the time deserves an honourable mention. It was refreshing as well as important for the industry that so many different franchises would branch off into all kinds of different directions in terms of gameplay during the NES days. And in a lot of ways, this game was at the forefront of that.

Happii

In summation, Simon’s Quest, whilst not without its annoyances, is certainly an improvement on the previous game in many ways. As well as being a very historically important title. Without games like Simon’s Quest and Metroid, there would be no open-world games. And the transition from 2D to 3D would have been a lot more awkward if standards like what this game set hadn’t been set beforehand.

Score

43.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

Castlevania (Nintendo Entertainment System)

Castlevania

Developer(s) – Konami

Publisher(s) – Konami

Director – Hitoshi Akamatsu

Rating – N/A

The original Castlevania, originally titled Akumajou Dracula (Japanese for Devil’s Castle Dracula), has been considered by the likes of PC World and Nintendo Power to be one of the greatest video games of all time. It has kicked off a library of sequels, spin-offs, and prequels in a franchise that has been going for almost 30 years. Whilst I don’t think the original game is one of the worst I’ve played, it was the first game I ever played where I thought the level of difficulty was nothing short of unreasonable. Three years after my first playthrough, I still can’t see the overwhelming appeal that many others see in it.

Graphics – 8/10

The best thing I can say about this game is that the visuals were extremely well executed, especially for the time. The NES only had a very limited colour palette. This made visually realizing video games particularly difficult on the system in many cases. But in this case, Konami made it look easy. Not only did they manage to create some excellent scenery, but they also did so. But they also manage to create a very fitting atmosphere, too. On top of that, like Strider, there are some superbly designed boss fights (in terms of concept, anyway). Including the likes of Medusa, the Grim Reaper, and of course, Dracula. Not to mention that the soundtrack to the game was very well composed, too.

Gameplay – 5/10

Just like Mega Man, which I reviewed some time ago, this game will work better for some than it will for others in terms of gameplay. The main reason is that it’s extremely hard. For example, the boss fight with the Grim Reaper is considered to be one of the hardest boss fights in video gaming. If not, the hardest. Most of the courses in the game are just as testing. With such obstacles as flying Medusa heads and suits of armour attacking players from several different angles, it can cause a lot of frustration at the best of times. I don’t mind challenges in video games. But not to the point where developers make an overly hard game for the hell of it. And consequently make the game unnecessarily inaccessible.

Controls – 9/10

A problem with the controls that I found whilst playing Castlevania for the first time. And have become a frequent source of frustration since they can be slow to respond at times. Especially when jumping from one platform to another. And in my opinion, that can add even more unnecessary frustration to a game made for the sake of it being excessively difficult. Otherwise, however, there are no problems, and the rest is all down to player skill.

Lifespan – 6/10

I should think that experienced players would be able to complete the original Castlevania in roughly half an hour. What was the average lifespan of a video game was. But for most players, most of the time will be spent dying. Players will die over, and over, and over again in this game, and it can become very frustrating very quickly. But for the people who relish challenges like this, it can potentially make for hours of entertainment.

Storyline – 4/10

The story of the original Castlevania game revolves around the vampire hunter Simon Belmont. Who must defeat Dracula, as his ancestors have throughout the ages? Again, like Strider, it was all pretty standard stuff, except much less is elaborated on. Even for the time, it felt quite empty in terms of story, but this game was developed in a time when the story mattered little in video games anyway. At least gameplay took priority, I guess.

Originality – 8/10

Regardless of its lack of substance in the story, I can commend this game for being particularly unique for the time. It was the first time that many gamers experienced a challenge on this level, and although many gamers (including myself) may express disdain for it, the fact of the matter is that many other gamers don’t, and they have since grown to want more games like it, which is fair enough, at least for that certain demographic.

Niiutral

In summation, I wish that the original Castlevania could have indeed been a bit more accessible to other players, who may have wanted to play through the game without as much difficulty to more easily appreciate it for the other aspects, which, in my opinion, save it from even being an average one. I can’t help but feel that with a difficulty setting in place, the franchise could have possibly gone on to the kind of heights that video game franchises of comparable longevity can brag about.

Score

40/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker (Wii U & Switch)

Captain Toad Treasure Tracker

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Tokyo Group No. 2 & 1-Up Studio

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Kenta Motokura & Shinya Hiratake

Producer – Koichi Hayashida

PEGI – 3

Building upon the innovative mini-game found in Super Mario 3D World, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker follows the long-running supporting Super Mario character Toad (in the first game, where the character has served as the main protagonist since 1994’s Wario’s Woods for the NES), as he resolves to collect treasure and rescue his own damsel in distress, Toadette. Treasure Tracker to me marks the launch of yet another extremely enjoyable Super Mario spin-off series. And I would highly recommend it to anyone in possession of a Wii U.

Graphics – 9/10

The game is filled with a plethora of varied and, at times, extremely lush-looking stage designs; levels such as Clear Pipe Puzzleplex and especially Midnight in the Wandering Woods certainly stand out. But it’s also interesting to be able to identify what influence Nintendo has taken from not only past games in their own library but from Arabian culture throughout. The obvious one to me was the original variant of Super Mario Bros 2 that stayed in Japan, called Doki Doki Panic.

Instead of being sucked into a dream, like Mario and company are in Super Mario Bros 2, the four characters of Doki Doki Panic are instead sucked into a book. And the Arabian tableau is the setting of the story. An obvious nod to the book One Thousand and One Arabian Nights. The fact that each of the levels is also set out like chapters in books in Treasure Tracker would seem to corroborate this. The level at which this is most evident, however, is Double Cherry Spires in the second book. The architecture of the buildings and spires is quite clearly influenced by Arabian or Indian architecture, bearing a striking resemblance to buildings such as the Taj Mahal, for example.

Gameplay – 8/10

The game’s play revolves around Toad traveling a series of cube-shaped stages in search of three diamonds. And to fulfil one additional objective within each level, and then finish the stage by collecting the gold star. It is extremely enjoyable, to say the least, containing a half-decent amount of substance for a linear game. I do, however, think there is room to add more. But I believe that could be something to be saved for a possible sequel. And I do indeed hope there will be one after playing this game.

Initially, I thought that there was an element of false advertisement on Nintendo’s part, as I thought that the bonus book was only available if players already had a save file of Super Mario 3D World on their Wii U. And there would have only been 64 courses available otherwise, whilst the back of the box states that there are over 70. But the bonus book is also made available after players complete the first three books, too. And there is indeed a bare minimum of 74 courses available.

Controls – 10/10

Much to my surprise, there isn’t really a bad thing I can say about the game’s control scheme. Upon the first glance at Treasure Tracker during E3, I half-suspected that there would inevitably be issues with camera angles. And that obstruction would inadvertently play a huge part in this game. But I was fortunately very much appeased with how well that issue has been handled overall.

Lifespan – 6/10

Taking everything in the game into account, this title will last about 8 hours in all. It is somewhat below par for the average Nintendo title. But what needs to be considered is that the time game is very much a question of trial and error. And as I said, there is room for much more to do. At the moment, that’s why I’m hoping that this will be where a sequel could come in. Like any good idea, Treasure Tracker is worth building upon and developing. And it would be very exciting to see what Nintendo decides to do with it if they ever release a second game. But for something that started as a simple mini-game, I don’t see any reason why it should lose out on too many marks for making it last as long as it does.

Storyline – 5/10

The story behind the game is that Captain Toad and his partner Toadette are on a treasure hunt when Toadette is suddenly captured by a towering and treasure-hungry bird called Wingo. Thereby compelling Toad to defeat him and save Toadette. As a game associated with the Mario franchise, the story is very archetypal of most stories that have been seen in games of the franchise; a white knight resolves to save his damsel in distress from an evil tyrant.

Although my next argument will contain spoiler alerts, I don’t think players will be missing much regardless. The unique thing about the story is how, later on, the roles are reversed so that it’s Toadette out to save Toad from Wingo. And then the two of them escape separately, resolve to find another. And then set out to defeat Wingo once and for all. These plot threads provide a moderate change of pace. But nothing really special or standout.

Originality – 10/10

Though I have criticized the game for having a very unoriginal story, the fact of the matter is, there is no other game like Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker. The gameplay mechanics are insanely unique. And inspiration came from some unorthodox places. The game reminded Mario creator Shigeru Miyamoto of another video game idea he had some time before. Which was inspired by the concept of the Rubik’s Cube. The problem was that if it had been made in the style of a conventional platforming game, it would have been considered far too easy. Therefore, the ability to jump was eradicated. The game may have also featured Link from the Legend of Zelda series. Miyamoto rejected this idea, but still thought the game had potential, and all they needed was a different protagonist, so Toad was settled on.

Happii

Overall, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker is a highly enjoyable and unique gaming experience, and it comes highly recommended from not just me. But from a fellow reviewer at Dark Zero, Thomas McDermott. Here’s the link to his review for the site:

http://darkzero.co.uk/game-reviews/captain-toad-treasure-tracker-wii-u/

Nintendo needed to get off to a good start in 2015. And with this beauty of a game, it’s safe to assume that they have done just that.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Bubsy 3D (PlayStation)

Bubsy 3D

Developer(s) – Eidetic

Publisher(s) – Accolade & Telstar

Designer – Michael Berlyn

ELSPA -11

One of the earliest launch titles released for the original PlayStation back in 1996, Bubsy 3D was a failure in exceptional portions, both commercially and critically. It was destined for disaster from the start. As the developers had in fact no prior experience with either 3D art rendering or video game control adaptation. As a result, it came to be remembered as one of the worst video games ever developed. And for more good reasons than even this.

Graphics – 0/10

Aside from having the frame rate of a children’s pop-up book, causing the game to play out unintentionally longer than it ought to have. And the scenery and style of the game were poorly handled. And the conceptual design is either nonsensical or non-existent. On top of that, the game is also infested with glitches. And most often, the background scenery is largely unfinished in more or less every single level in the game.

Gameplay – 0/10

One of the earliest 3D platformers to have come to be throughout the fifth generation of gaming, most critics have called it a blatant and cheap rip-off of Super Mario 64. And to me, it’s impossible to argue with that. The objective involves nothing exciting other than to simply take the player character from point A to point B. Unlike even other early 3D platformers, which had secondary objectives that needed to be undertaken in order to advance, and extracurricular activities along the way. This game, however, has nothing like that. The underwater levels provide a vague change of pace. But by that time, most players will have turned the PlayStation off.

Controls – 0/10

The issues that this game had in terms of controls would go on to affect the quality of many other early PlayStation games, such as Croc: Legend of the Gobbos, Blasto, and even the original Tomb Raider. But it’s in this game where this issue is at its most prominent and annoying. Due largely to the lack of an analogue stick at this point, players had to rely on using the D-pad to move characters across 3D environments. And it failed to work for several reasons, such as camera angles, etc. But because of this game’s unforgiving frame rate, it can take seconds for players to even change direction properly.

Lifespan – 0/10

In all, Bubsy 3D clocks in at about 3 hours. But the average gamer will most probably end up playing it for less than 3 minutes when they find out just how loathsome it really is. This was about the average lifespan of a video game at this point. Which wouldn’t have made it stand out to any kind of degree anyway.

Storyline – 0/10

The story involves a bobcat named Bubsy, who is captured by an alien race. And subsequently escapes to save his home planet. Chances were even at the time that this game was never going to provide any kind of redeeming value in terms of story, as this aspect was just starting to find prevalence in other genres of gaming other than RPGs at the time, but something particularly annoying the developers tried to do was to provide a pretty weak comedic element by having Bubsy spout out various phrases during gameplay, which after a while, can become unfathomably irritating. Mercifully, the developers added a facility to turn the voice on or off at the player’s will.

Originality – 0/10

As I mentioned, the game remains fresh in the memory of all who played it as being one of the worst, making it stand out for all the wrong reasons. The majority of gamers and critics have gone on to label E.T for the Atari 2600 as being the worst game of all time, but I believe that there are far worse games out there, including this atrocity.

I find it criminal that Howard Scott Warshaw has gotten so much bad press for his work on E.T under some particularly biased circumstances, when Michael Berlyn simply decided to make a video game despite his lack of knowledge of, or prior research into, the medium, and has not received criticism on the same level. He did want to improve on the game, having seen Super Mario 64, but by this time, Accolade was pressing them to get the game out; the lesson to be learned for developers who may be reading this review is to do your research beforehand.

Furiious

In summation, I put more effort into writing this review than the entire development team put into making Bubsy 3D. It’s simply one of the worst video games ever made and should be avoided at all costs.

Score

0/60

0/10 (Unplayable)

Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons (PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 & PC)

Brothers a Tale of Two Sons

Developer(s) – Starbreeze Studios

Publisher(s) – 505 Games & Spike Chunsoft

Director – Josef FaresV,

PEGI – 16

The brainchild of Dutch film director Josef Fares, Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons was an indie game released in August of 2013, and won the VGA award for Best Xbox Game of 2013. Ahead of the likes of BioShock Infinite and Grand Theft Auto V. I decided to check it out, and though I can point out a few things about it, I was left fairly impressed by it.

Graphics – 9/10

Whilst the visuals are somewhat outdated from a technical standpoint, the conceptual design that has been implemented is nothing short of sensational. The game takes place in a surprisingly wide variety of different environments in such a short space of time, adding to the game’s overall mystique and level of diversity. But what I particularly like about this game is the way that it has been marketed. Like many Nintendo games, this has been made to look like a cutesy, innocent little puzzle game on the surface.

But as players continue to progress, they will find out that it also has a prominent dark side to it. So much so that I actually suggested this to Mullet Mike as a topic for an episode of Creepy Gaming. One minute, the player is traveling through a farm to avoid a dog. And the next minute, they’re traveling through a valley of dead giants, having to desecrate their corpses to advance. It surprises me greatly that this game was also nominated for Best Family Game at the 2014 BAFTA Video Games Awards.

Gameplay – 7/10

Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons is a puzzle adventure game. And the two genres go hand in hand particularly well in this title. What I would say about it is that the puzzles seem pretty elaborate at first glance. But I found that most of them are easy enough to figure out on the first attempt. And in that respect, it provided only a moderate challenge. To me, the best thing about how the game plays out is how both brothers’ personalities are represented through gameplay. And by the same token, it is used to tell the story as well as express several themes. Such as, of course, brotherhood, love, and co-operation.

Controls – 10/10

The game’s control scheme can seem a little bit confusing at first. But it’s ultimately easy enough to get to grips with. And from thereon, no problems should be encountered. Like the gameplay, the control scheme also works to convey the theme of co-operation, as both brothers rely on one another in order to advance. For example, the little brother relies on the big brother for strength to carry him across rivers due to his fear of swimming, and vice versa, the big brother relies on the little brother to squeeze through gaps in fences to find a way for him to also progress further along with the little brother.

Lifespan – 2/10

Disappointingly, the game can only last about 3 hours in its entirety. If that. And in my opinion, for all the substance, variety. And the artistic value that this game has is nowhere near good enough. It feels like too fleeting an experience for how much substance there is. I would liken this game to a gourmet meal. Beautifully presented and exceptionally refined, but lacking in portions.

Storyline – 9/10

The Story of Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons follows the story of two brothers named Naiee and Nyaa, who resolve to travel to the Tree of Life and collect its waters in order to heal their ailing father. The game’s story is extremely deep, emotional, and takes so many twists and turns before the end that it makes for an experience nothing short of unforgettable. Not only can it be described as unforgettable because of everything that happens throughout the course of the game. But because of how many different transitions the game’s atmosphere goes through, and the fact that the game itself makes the player care about the two brothers, and the hardships that they have to endure in order to reach their goal.

Originality – 8/10

Games have come and gone before with elaborate puzzles and an ever-changing atmosphere. But few games have come along that have told certain aspects through actual gameplay in the manner in which this game does so. Though morality mechanics have been used in other games, like Fable and InFamous, the way in which it happens in this title is particularly subtle, somehow.

Happii

To summarize, Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons is an exceptionally unique and presentable experience. Whilst the game’s fleeting lifespan doesn’t do it justice in my opinion, it will certainly make for an emotional and fun 3 hours.

Score

44/60

7/10 (Fair)