Tunguska: Legend of Faith (PC & PlayStation)

Tunguska Legend of Faith

Developer – Exortus Software

Publisher – Take-Two Interactive

Graphic Director – Alexei Danikine

Producer – Lee Brown

ELSPA – 11+

Tunguska: Legend of Faith was a game released in 1998. And ported to both the PC and the original PlayStation. I tried to research it further for the purpose of the review. But it seems to have been lost from the entire industry. There’s no Wikipedia article about it, and people would be hard-pressed to find a review of it (which is hopefully where I come in). And although it was indeed published by Take-Two Interactive, it doesn’t even appear on their Wikipedia list of games they’ve published.

However, this can all only be a good thing, as it is an awful, wretched game. Even for the time, it was so undeniably bad in every single way. In the development company’s lifespan, the Germany-based company, Exortus Software, only managed to get two games out to retail. A game called WorldSpiral: Liath, and this monstrosity. The way I see it, it’s no wonder they folded if they were putting out games like this.

Graphics – 5/10

Whilst the visual quality is fairly average for the time, and all things considered, it has not aged well compared to other early PlayStation games. And it’s also conceptually weak. All the corridors throughout the castle in the game look the same as one another. There is no one standout feature other than maybe some of the traps strewn across the place. And even they aren’t anything special to look at. The opening cutscene at the beginning of the game was fairly well done. But from there, it only gets far, far worse.

Gameplay – 1/10

The game is anything but enjoyable to play. All it involves is basically walking around a castle, fighting a few people along the way, and trying to run past traps; occasionally solving the odd boorish puzzle. The combat system is extremely ridiculous, and the game also gets unreasonably hard as the player progresses. The fighting is repetitive, there are absolutely no side quests to do in between playing through the main story, and it has no replay value whatsoever. It is for the good of the industry that this game is left as obscure as it is.

Controls – 1/10

Tunguska more than gave testament to the initial wanting quality of the PlayStation’s control scheme; it took it to a greater degree of inadequacy. With a control scheme similar to Resident Evil, only with hand-to-hand fighting sequences, the fighting system is confusing at best. There are often when the camera pans too far away from the in-game character, and it’s difficult to see exactly what’s going on.

The command registration system is also very inaccurate, as what the player wants the character to do when they press certain buttons doesn’t always happen, and the character can be killed very easily as a result. Also, the mechanic of having to enter another room by clicking on a door on a separate screen to get it open is extremely unnecessary. Why did they not just have a system whereby the player presses a certain button once they reach the door, and then it opens? Why does a separate screen have to pop up? It’s absolutely ridiculous.

Lifespan – 1/10

On average, this game will take less than 2 hours to complete. But I’m very confident that most players will lose interest before then if they ever choose to play this game. Video games that fall under the genre need to last much longer than that, and it doesn’t even feel as if the developers tried at all to prolong the lifespan of the game.

Storyline – 0/10

Now, this is the aspect in which this game falls apart faster than an opinion about football expressed by Adrian Chiles. The ridiculous narrative centers on a condemned criminal named Jack Riley, who is falsely imprisoned for the murder of his wife. As he gets the electric chair, he is transported to another dimension, where he must traverse through a castle and uncover its secrets. By doing so, he comes back to life, and he is miraculously cleared of his crimes. That’s all that happens. It’s uninteresting at best. I have just spoiled the entire story by revealing what happens in the end, but to be honest, I would not consider this a major loss.

Originality – 0/10

Tunguska is original in all the wrong ways. I.e., it’s original in the sense of how bad it is. Not many games can boast such a profound and blatant level of inadequacy. I feel as if the budget used to develop this game could’ve been put to much better use.

Furiious

To put it simply, stay away from Tunguska, folks…stay away.

Score

8/60

1/10 (Farcical)

Transistor (PC & PlayStation 4)

Transistor

Developer(s) – Supergiant Games

Publisher(s) – Supergiant Games

Director – Amir Rao

Artist – Jen Zee

PEGI – 12

Throughout 2014, Transistor garnered a lot of acclaim from both gamers and critics alike, being praised for its magnificent story, immersive gameplay, and impressive visual style. It even won an IGN award for the game with the best graphics of 2014. And was nominated for 8 additional awards. I also ended up liking this game for what it is, Indeed this is one of the games that handles the aforementioned gameplay formula fairly well.

Graphics – 10/10

Not only has this game been designed in such a way that glitches are non-existent. And with an isometric top-down view, so that everything seems to be at a certain distance, making it seem in greater detail. But it’s also conceptually flawless. At first, it seemed easier to draw comparisons between this game and Final Fantasy VII. But the further into it I played, the more I began to realize how much of its own concept it truly is. The futuristic architecture and character designs are unlike anything I’ve ever seen in a video game before and easily deserve a perfect score.

Gameplay – 7/10

As I pointed out, Transistor is one of the very few games that have handled well the mixture of both turn-based RPG combat and real-time combat. The main reason for that, I think, is that the gameplay is paused when players are inputting their commands. This makes battles so much easier to cope with than in the likes of Final Fantasy XII and Dragon Age: Origins. But unfortunately, that’s all that players will have to do throughout the game. Since there are only a few side quests throughout. The game also has a particularly linear progression for an RPG.

Controls – 9/10

The only reservation I have with the control scheme is that, because of the game’s style of play, it can be unnecessarily difficult to land certain hits whilst chaining commands together in real-time. Especially since enemies can unexpectedly move around. And become nigh-on impossible to hit in the middle of trying to chain combos together. Fortunately, this doesn’t hinder the gameplay too much. And there are no other issues with the controls to address.

Lifespan – 4/10

Unlike many other RPGs, Transistor has an unusually linear path, and as such, the game only lasts about 7 to 15 hours, which for a game of its genre, is extremely underwhelming in my opinion. Especially since there are other, and much longer, RPGs out there that have adopted a similar style of gameplay before it. I’ve heard people tell me that if an indie game has a long lifespan, then it counts as a bonus. But I highly disagree with this. It’s up to the developers to make the last however long they want it to last. And it’s always been and always will be my opinion that the longer a game lasts, the better. And to me, Transistor is not a great example of that, indie game or not.

Storyline – 9/10

In lieu of RPG tradition, however, the game’s story is nothing short of masterful. It follows a famous singer called Red, who is constantly attacked by a robotic armed force called the Process around the city of Cloudbank. Coming across a mysterious sword known as the Transistor. Buried in the chest of an unknown man, but imbued with the man’s voice. As well as Red’s own voice. Red takes the Transistor and is continuously pursued by the Process, who want the weapon for an unknown purpose. Slowly but surely, all the unknowns of the story are answered, and frankly, it makes for an incredible story.

Originality – 7.5/10

Though there may not have been a great deal of imagination put into the gameplay, with minimal side quests and an extremely linear progression, the game’s uniqueness comes in the form of both its excellent conceptual design as well as its story and amount of immersive plot twists and superb voice acting throughout. In particular, Logan Cunningham’s portrayal of the Transistor is a performance riddled with an array of different emotions that make it easy to forget that they are coming from an inanimate object.

Happii

To summarize, the best things about Transistor are both the graphics and the story. It could have been done with a fair bit more added in terms of gameplay. Nevertheless, it isn’t terrible. The combat is pretty intense and makes for a fairly stern challenge, but I think a great amount of improvement could be made for the release of a possible sequel.

Score

46.5/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Tower of Guns (PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4 & Xbox One)

Tower of Guns

Developer(s) – Terrible Posture Games

PEGI – 7

Tower of Guns is a Roguelike first-person shooter. With elements of many different games of its kind. Including Doom and Borderlands. Expecting a simple run-of-the-mill shooter beforehand, I was pleasantly surprised to discover how excellent a game it is. This is a testament to how far the indie movement has come since its recent establishment.

Graphics – 7/10

Making use of cel-shaded visuals and robotic enemies, the game is not only conceptually interesting. However, the developers have cleverly made it suitable for a wide demographic since there is no depiction of graphic violence. Whilst it could be argued that many of the different enemies are quite generic, the bosses are anything but that. Ranging from robotic goat heads (a homage to the last boss in Doom II) to a room of spikes. The only gripe I have with the visuals is that the developers rushed to render them since there are a fair few glitches. But when enough enemies appear on the screen at any one time, it can severely affect its frame rate.

Gameplay – 10/10

The game simply involves shooting through the many enemies that appear on the screen and advancing to the next level. The game also encourages exploration to a certain extent. Offering items in hidden areas, which players must discover in a manner similar to either Doom or Duke Nukem 3D. There is also an endless mode. Allowing players to play for as long as they either desire or as long as their abilities will allow them before they are killed. The amount of weapon variety in the game is also pretty impressive. The player has to unlock each one through different means as they go, therefore providing even more replayability. Each room is also randomly generated, so that each playthrough also presents players with a new challenge every time.

Controls – 10/10

The game control scheme is definitely the most simplistic I’ve experienced in a modern-day first-person shooter. To me, this is like a breath of fresh air, having played a lot of first-person shooters with overly ambitious control schemes such as Brink. And to an extent, Destiny. It’s extremely straightforward, and most fans will be able to go from any other game in the genre to this one without skipping a beat. It would also serve as an excellent starting point for any gamers looking to get into the genre, but who don’t know where to start.

Originality – 6/10

Though no other developers had ever thought of creating a Roguelike FPS before this, there is no denying that this game has its influences. Such as Borderlands in its visual style, and Doom in its basic premise of gameplay (indeed, FPS games today are still considered by old-school gamers to be Doom clones). And even Half-Life in its ominous soundtrack. However, in a market that is now saturated by this particular genre of video game, it’s extremely difficult to make a shooter that stands out to any extent. And I think props are due to Terrible Posture Games for developing a shooter with this much replay value on a budget.

Deliirious

Overall, Tower of Guns is an exceptional title. In my personal opinion, one of the best indie experiences of the eighth generation of gaming. There have been many great indie games developed since Minecraft. And competition has become fierce. But if most games are as immersive as this, then indie games will prove to be even more popular in the coming years.

Score

33/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Tomodachi Life (3DS)

Tomodachi Life

Developer(s) – Nintendo SPD

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

PEGI – 3

Dabbling in the life simulation genre (something relatively rare for Nintendo), Tomodachi Life challenges gamers to create their own world. And inhabit it with a populace, who must be kept happy and kept on track to do such things as stay full, stay fashionable, and realize their ambitions. And find true love. Even though this game was hyped up something fierce. Nintendo even went so far as to upset an entire community by not including the option to pursue same-sex relationships in the game (something I won’t condone in the slightest). Still, I wasn’t particularly impressed with it.

Graphics – 4/10

Whilst most games that feature the Miis as central characters don’t necessarily have much in terms of concept going for them, it seems to me like Tomodachi Life borrows elements from the likes of Wii Fit and Wii Sports Resort. And to me, the idea of a game having adopted elements from already generic-looking games doesn’t really bode well. The small pluses are that the game is well-polished enough. The amounts of different foods and clothes offer a small level of variety in terms of visual presentation. But I don’t think anywhere near enough was added to keep it fresh.

Gameplay – 4/10

I think the same thing can be said for the game’s play, too. A small amount of variety. But not enough to keep players wanting to play. I’d played this game all week and found it to become very repetitive very quickly. There is some value to playing it in that the characters can be made to say some funny things depending on their mood. And I did like the brief interspersions of turn-based RPG combat that can be experienced once the island’s fairground is unlocked. But other than that, I didn’t really find any deeper substance than that in terms of gameplay.

Controls – 10/10

As a simple and at least relaxing life simulator experience, on a globally familiar handheld console, there was never going to be any kind of problem with the game’s control scheme. This kind of game had been developed and published by others many times before the release of Tomodachi Life. I look at this game as basically being a glorified version of the Tamagotchi. And in all honesty, I found them harder to cope with back when they were the in things.

Lifespan – 10/10

Since there is no fixed lifespan, there is no worry about players having to worry about making conventional progress. And this is a game that can simply be picked up and played whenever. However, I think that without a great level of depth in gameplay, it’s somewhat safe for me to assume that there could be many players out there who would play the game for a couple of hours at a time for a few days. And then simply not touch it ever again. Because, in that time, they will most probably have experienced most of what the game has to offer.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

Though there is no preset story and only a basic premise behind Tomodachi Life, whereby different people’s lives can be led, that’s what makes the game unique in a sense. A lot of different stories concerning a massive variety of characters can be told in a short amount of time. And there aren’t many games I think of off the top of my head, that incorporate such a system. The game also has a varied and sometimes wonderfully weird sense of humor to it as well. This, I think, adds a small level of artistic expression to the overall experience.

Originality – 3/10

The problem is that the system whereby the game’s story is encompassed is about the only original thing this game has going for it, in my opinion. There’s nothing overly unique about the gameplay. And though Nintendo may be relatively new to the life simulation genre, I would have thought they would be capable of bringing something new to the table to break the mold of previous games in the same category. I was excited about the release of this game after watching various trailers for it. But I now believe I was misled into thinking that this game could have been more than what it turned out to be.

Niiutral

In summation, although certain aspects of Tomodachi Life save it from being a terrible title, I still feel that it’s a gaming experience unworthy of Nintendo. They have developed some of the greatest and legendary video games to have been put out to retail. But I don’t feel that this stands out as one of the greater titles in their library by any means.

Score

41/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Titanfall (Xbox 360 & Xbox One)

Titanfall

Developer(s) – Respawn Entertainment

Publisher(s) – Electronic Arts

Director – Steve Fukuda

Producer – Drew McCoy

PEGI -16

One of the most highly anticipated games of last year, Titanfall, was supposed to be Microsoft’s ace in the hole concerning the Xbox One. The title would attract more people to align with their system as opposed to the PlayStation 4. Unfortunately, it didn’t work out that way, and for good reason in my opinion.

Graphics – 6/10

Compared with the conceptual design of many other science fiction games, it feels to me like the game is wanting. As for me, it looks like a watered-down version of the game Hawken. Marred down by elements of both Call of Duty and Battlefield. The reason why it doesn’t lose too many marks in this category is that, from a technical standpoint, the game is visually flawless. There are no glitches in sight, and everything is extremely well-polished.

Gameplay – 3/10

In a lot of ways, I can best describe this game as a middle finger to anyone who bought an Xbox One around the time of its launch. It was a game eagerly anticipated for years, but ended up being overwhelmingly restricted in terms of gameplay, as not only is an Xbox Live subscription mandatory to play it. But there isn’t even a single-player campaign mode; players have to instead contend with an online multiplayer campaign mode. Some would argue that Destiny was the same. But a PlayStation Plus subscription isn’t mandatory. And players can enjoy it whilst not having to pay an extra £40 on top of what they paid for the game.

Controls – 10/10

There are no issues with the control scheme, thankfully, since it ultimately plays out like any other run-of-the-mill first-person shooter. Even when players embark on one of the titan robots, it plays out more or less exactly the same as it would if they were on foot. Whilst there may be no problems, henceforth why it loses no marks in this category, there’s nothing special about them either. It’s proof of how difficult it can be in this day and age to make an FPS that stands out among most.

Originality – 4/10

Because of the bog-standard control scheme and the visible lack of difference between playing on foot or in a titan, I don’t think for a second that Titanfall is the revolutionary game-changing title it was advertised as being at the time of its release. The restrictive gameplay makes it stand out somewhat. But for all the wrong reasons. To me, this title can be seen as not only vastly overrated. Since it miraculously won over 60 gaming awards last year. But it can be seen as a lesson on how not to make a video game.

Angrii

In summation, Titanfall is most definitely one of the worst games of 2014. It’s one of many reasons to buy a PlayStation 4 as opposed to an Xbox One, and makes me think that if the developers want an entire franchise to spawn from this one wretched game, then making the sequel multi-platform should be the tip of the iceberg. Major improvements need to be made in every other aspect, in my opinion.

Score

23/40

5.5/10 (Below Average)

Titan Attacks (PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4 & PlayStation Vita)

Titan Attacks

Developer(s) – Puppy Games

PEGI – 7

Titan Attacks is an arcade shooter extremely similar to Space Invaders, which involves the simple concept of shooting down oncoming waves of aliens and advancing through the many stages of the game. Although it’s a fairly fun game to play, I thought there were many other aspects that left me wanting. I couldn’t help but compare it to Space Invaders, as at times, I didn’t know if I was playing that or Titan Attacks.

Graphics – 5.5/10

Not only does it play out almost identically to Space Invaders. But it also looks almost identical to Space Invaders. The character sprites are very similar, and in a way, I think the ship the player controls throughout the game is very similar to the one found in the arcade classic, too. I thought the most standout and stunning visual aspect of this game was the scenery and the pretty wide variety of color palettes used throughout each of the five stages. They can positively add to the feeling of nostalgia. But every other visual aspect in the game would suggest to me that there wasn’t a great deal of effort or thought put into the game’s overall visual concept.

Gameplay – 7/10

I’m happy to at least say that this game is a fairly fun one. It’s pretty enjoyable to play, and the most original aspect of this game also happens to be the most satisfying, in my opinion. Players have the option to spend in-game currency accumulated in each level on upgrades to the ship. Such as improved weapons and shield maintenance. That aspect at least adds something that didn’t come with the original Space Invaders. And it makes for an overall moderately exciting gaming experience.

Controls – 10/10

As expected, there are no problems with this game’s control scheme. Just like the best arcade games of the ’70s and ’80s, player progression relies heavily on skill. I’m pleased to see that the developers of this game at least seemingly designed it with that rule firmly in mind.

Lifespan – N/A (10/10)

It will take less than an hour to progress through each of the game’s five different stages. But once this is complete, it then becomes a survival-endless scenario. Players must follow the simple and age-old video gaming objective of repeating the game at progressively harder difficulties in order to gain the highest score possible. This is the kind of game that can simply be played at the player’s leisure. Without the worry of making in-game progress in the sense that most younger gamers are familiar with nowadays. And there’s nothing wrong with a game like that if it’s done right. And it has been done right in this case.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

Again, as with every great arcade game back in the first and second generations of gaming, there is no highly developed story to Titan Attacks, but only a basic premise. To stop an alien invasion. There never needs to be a particularly deep story in an arcade game, as an attempt at which could ruin it. Since they’re solely about gameplay.

Originality – 3/10

The only things that make this title unique to Space Invaders are the diversity in set designs and the ship upgrade facilities. But there’s not much in this game to differentiate it from others past Space Invaders, unfortunately. Even adding that small RPG element has been a trope used in some other recent indie arcade games like Dead Nation and Mercenary Kings.

Happii

In summary, although Titan Attacks seems like nothing more than a heavy modification of an existing idea on the surface, it is still fun to play. And it doesn’t lose marks for getting some other aspects right, too. Those things for me are enough to even save it from being considered an average game, in my opinion.

Score

45/60

7/10 (Fair)

Theme Hospital (PC, PlayStation & PlayStation Network)

Theme Hospital

Developer(s) – Bullfrog Studios & Krisalis Software

Publisher(s) – EA

PEGI – 12

Theme Hospital is a simulator game, whereby the player must manage various hospitals by researching breakthrough medical advances. Employing competent and committed staff, and of course, successfully treating as many patients as possible. The game is notable for its immersive gameplay and twisted sense of humor. If history had gone a different way, that humor may be seen as even darker by others. As the fictional and comedic diseases used in the game. Discrete Itching and Chronic Nose hair were put in to replace the originally planned inclusion of real-life illnesses into the game. While that does add some controversy, it was thankfully nevertheless tailored to be much more light-hearted and comedic. And most importantly, gameplay came first.

Graphics – 5/10

While comic relief is added in the game’s graphics through some of the comedic looks of some of the patients with ridiculous diseases, such as Bloaty Head, there was never going to be much else in terms of concept in a hospital simulator game. There are a few full-motion videos adding a bit more to the game’s comedic value as well as the darker aspect of its humor. But other than these small elements, there’s not much else to look at, unfortunately.

Gameplay – 8/10

Theme Hospital was one of the most addictive games I ever played growing up. And that level of addiction still holds up to this day, the way I see it. I remember it was one of the first games that made me understand how something that could be seen as mundane and repetitive in real life can be made to seem extremely entertaining. There have been many other games come and gone that have tried to replicate that feeling with the same level of success. Indeed, most recently, I’ve been playing the game Papers Please, which could easily fall under this category. But very few have succeeded on the same level as this game.

Controls – 10/10

The simulation and real-time strategy gaming genre had long been perfected before the release of Theme Hospital. And so it was unlikely, to begin with, that there would be any problems with the game’s control scheme, and so there aren’t. Theme Hospital, though relatively difficult to master, is simple to get to grips with.

Lifespan – 3/10

The biggest issue I have with this game, however, is that there is a fixed lifespan, making the game very short-lived for one in its genre. The game’s main mode can be completed in less than six hours. And for a game that can be made to last an infinite amount of time, that’s almost unforgivable. Unlike Rollercoaster Tycoon, there doesn’t exist any kind of endless mode. Whereby players can just build and maintain a hospital, and stick to it. They simply have to meet all the hospital’s requirements. And then move on to the next until the game is complete. That, in turn, also affects the gameplay, as this makes it a lot less satisfying to play than it easily could have been.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

Theme Hospital doesn’t have any kind of established story or even much in the way of a basic premise, but nor did it need anything like that to be any more enjoyable. The only element of the story is in the game’s humor, which can make the ambiance of the game both funny and taboo at the same time, but otherwise, there isn’t much else to talk about in terms of the story. There’s no need for the game to lose marks for not having something that it didn’t necessarily have to have.

Originality – 8/10

Simulator games had been around for some time before this, but this game was in a class of its own. It garnished a great level of popularity among players and is still unlike anything I’ve ever played since. It was instrumental in shaping a lot of my own personal viewpoints about gaming, and I hope that more titles like this come along in the near future, with the same, or an even greater level of originality attached to them.

Happii

Overall, whilst it hasn’t stood the test of time, as well as other games of the 90s have, Theme Hospital is still fairly addictive and fun to play, and its dark and twisted humor and great level of uniqueness have made it a cult classic, and I would still recommend it to anyone reading who hasn’t tried it yet.

Score

45/60

7.5/10 (Good)

The Swapper (PC, Wii U, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4 & PlayStation Vita)

The Swapper

Developer(s) – Facepalm Games & Curve Studios

Publisher(s) – Facepalm Games

Writer – Tom Jubert

PEGI – 7

The Swapper combines elements of puzzle games and the 2D side-scrolling open-world aesthetics of a Metroidvania game. Talking about this game in the same breath as the likes of Super Metroid and Castlevania: Symphony of the Night may make the game sound exciting. But even with the inclusion of a semi-open world, it doesn’t even come close to matching the quality of the aforementioned examples.

Graphics – 10/10

The most praise I can offer The Swapper is in its visuals; they are more or less flawless. There are no graphical glitches, and the design of the settings is wonderfully unique. And the attention to detail on the developer’s part is staggering. There is also a very effective use of textures, such as lighting and shadows, to add to the overall atmosphere of the game. Though it isn’t survival horror, there is a heightened sense of urgency throughout that perhaps the player will feel in a much different way than in the likes of Resident Evil 4 or Silent Hill. The game’s visual concept does draw similarities with Dead Space in its character designs. But there are plenty more differences to make it stand out in at least this sense.

Gameplay – 5/10

One way in which The Swapper doesn’t stand out, however. And the one aspect it should have done to attain the most important points, in my opinion, is in its gameplay. Players have to solve puzzles throughout by duplicating the player character. And swapping between the duplicates to perform multiple tasks at the same time. There is also one side quest, which involves finding a series of terminals giving details of the game’s back story.

As well as ten additional hidden terminals throughout the game. Taking into account the size of the in-game world. And the amount of space available to include additional content, I don’t think there is anywhere near enough substance in gameplay compared to what could have potentially been added. And there is hardly any incentive for completing the game’s side quests unless you happen to be playing it on a PlayStation console. In this case, there are PlayStation trophies to collect for each hidden terminal found.

Controls – 10/10

As a formula long since perfected, there should have been no issues with the control scheme in any case. And so there aren’t. But it is also interesting to see how the developers have added some interesting gameplay mechanics to the 2D side-scrolling formula.

Lifespan – 1/10

Due to its lack of substance in gameplay, and the main focus being put on the story (indeed, where there is normally a director and producer listed on most video game Wikipedia pages, there is only a writer on The Swapper’s page), this title can only be made to last two and a half hours tops, which, especially for an open-world game, is unacceptable. Since there was clearly room for so much more to be added, it seemed to me like that much more of an incredibly fleeting experience.

Storyline – 7/10

In a time when humanity’s natural resources on Earth have been exhausted, and they have resorted to deep space exploration to keep themselves alive, the story of the Swapper follows a person who lands on the planet Chori V and investigates a derelict ship called the Theseus. But in typical science fiction fashion, he/she ends up finding more than what they bargained for, and the unnamed person resolves to escape the ship with his/her life, and from the watchers, a murderous race of minerals with rudimentary intelligence, who had killed the initial crew of the Theseus.

The story is interesting to follow from beginning to middle, but although I won’t give away what happens in the end, I will say how I felt so jaded by it. There is a choice for the player to make at the end, but either way, it makes the story seem ultimately pointless. If the player makes one of the two choices, another character even closes the game with the line “Does it really matter anymore?” It makes me hope that there will be a sequel, albeit with major improvements to gameplay, that will elaborate on the game’s mythology. Otherwise, I think the developers may very well have ended up shooting themselves in the foot by making other gamers feel the same way.

Originality – 6/10

Despite the visuals of the game being top-notch in my eyes and some standout modifications to the 2D side-scrolling formula, in terms of overall gameplay, it seems neither evolutionary nor revolutionary. Great Metroidvania games have come and gone, such as Symphony of the Night and Aria of Sorrow, and even some of the latest generations have yielded a few, such as the re-vamped Strider and Dust: An Elysian Tail. But it’s fair to me to say that this title doesn’t fall under that category.

Angrii

To summarize, The Swapper is a much worse game than I previously thought. Despite being impressed by its visuals and attention to detail, I hadn’t realized how short and lacking in substance it was, and I always begrudge video games like that being released in the first place.

Score

34/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

The Stanley Parable (PC)

The Stanley Parable

Developer(s) – Davey Wreden & Galactic Café

Rating – N/A (Profanity & mature themes)

The Stanley Parable was developed about three years ago, as an attempt by its creator, Davey Wreden, to go against the kind of narratives typically found in video game stories. And my goodness, he accomplished that. It’s unlike any other interactive story I’ve ever experienced, in that it’s a lot more interesting and open-ended. However, I wish a bit more could have been added in terms of gameplay to keep it a little bit more interesting.

Graphics – 6/10

Though the visuals can indeed seem extremely generic and dull at first. As the game progresses, they become thoroughly more varied and engrossing, taking place in factories and lush fields. And even Matrix-style computer rooms, depending on which direction the player takes. The fact that there are so many places to go throughout the course of the game itself makes for a fairly wide degree of visual diversity for a game that takes place mainly in an office building.

Gameplay – 4/10

The game takes on a first-person mode but only contains a handful of things to do in-game. There are no enemies to fight or puzzles to solve; only the facility to go off in multiple directions. Thus affecting what ending the player is treated to. As I said, I wish the developer had added at least a little bit more to make the gameplay a bit more enjoyable. But ultimately, it feels more like watching a film, unfortunately. It’s impossible for me to fully appreciate games that are made solely for the sake of art. And having next to no basis in viable gameplay.

Controls – 10/10

As a first-person with next to no other functions apart from walking and turning. And interacting with certain objects and buttons, there was hardly anything the developer could have gotten wrong during the making. As there weren’t any problems to address. So there is this positive to deduce, at least. If there had been any issues with the controls, then it would have inevitably led to me having major issues with this game.

Lifespan – 6/10

It will take roughly 10 hours for players to take each route and witness each individual ending, since there are a fair few to discover. The only basis in gameplay this title truly has, in my opinion.

Storyline – 8/10

The story of The Stanley Parable is most definitely the greatest aspect of this game. No matter how confusing it may be to people, after a while. It follows an ordinary man called Stanley, who is guided by the player through a series of different paths leading to different places with a plethora of different events unfolding; all the while being narrated by British actor Kevin Brighting. Aside from the surrealist goings-on that happen throughout the course of each playthrough, Brighting does provide an extremely good narration, and at times also even brings an element of dark humor, as well as breaking the fourth wall.

Originality – 7/10

Though this game does have one of the most unique stories ever told in a video game (indeed, one to go against other video game narratives by design), the gameplay remains largely unoriginal, and consequently, I can’t call it the overly unique game that many other critics have taken to calling it. It’s all very well and good to have such a strange story add to the game’s charm, but for me, the most important aspect in any game is the gameplay, and unfortunately, this title comes up short in that respect.

Niiutral

To summarize, The Stanley Parable is indeed an extremely strange game with an interesting story. However, for all the room there is in the game’s environment, it seems criminal to me that the developers did not add any more basis in gameplay than what there ended up being.

Score

41/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

The Hobbit (Xbox, PC, PlayStation 2, GameCube & Game Boy Advance)

The Hobbit

Developer(s) – Inevitable Entertainment, The Fizz Factor & Saffire

Publisher(s) – Sierra Entertainment

Designer – Chuck Lupher

Producer(s) – Jaime Grieves

PEGI – 7

Amidst the newfound popularity of the Tolkien mythos surrounding the Lord of the Rings film trilogy directed by Peter Jackson, and amidst an ongoing dispute regarding the rights to the Tolkien license, with multiple games based on the books and films being developed at the time, The Hobbit was released to mixed reviews from critics. Who cited the gameplay as being uninspiring, and its failure to appeal to younger gamers.

In the industry, licensed games have, for the most part, been generally frowned upon. And seen as simply being a modern form of shovelware. With the owners of their respective licenses simply releasing games to coincide with films for the most part. However, there are a select few licensed games that go above and beyond what is expected of them. And end up offering some legitimately enjoyable gaming experiences. In my opinion, whilst The Hobbit may not be among the best, it’s certainly not among the worst, I find.

Graphics – 6.5/10

One aspect that the game falls short on somewhat is the visuals. Whilst they may have looked fairly impressive at the time, they don’t hold up nearly as well on a technical level as many other games of their kind do. Such as Final Fantasy X and Metal Gear Solid 2, to name but a few. Like the game based on the first volume of The Lord of the Rings trilogy, developed by WPX Games & Surreal Software, it largely conforms to the same conceptual design as in the films. But there are a couple of standout elements that did fairly well to separate it from both the initial Peter Jackson film trilogy. And the aforementioned game at the time of its release, at least (before the Hobbit film trilogy came out years later, as well as Lego The Hobbit). Such as locations like Lake Town, Mirkwood, and Erebor.

Gameplay – 7/10

For the most part, playing out like a traditional 3D platformer, the game also has a few little side quests thrown in for good measure during the first half of it. Like the previously mentioned Lord of the Rings game. Most notably involving completing the tasks for the dwarves before the party departs for The Lonely Mountain. There is also a small stealth aspect. This fits in fairly well with the tableau of the story of Bilbo Baggins being hired as a thief. And which I moderately enjoyed. Stealth can be quite a tricky aspect to pull off in games. As it can eliminate fluency if it requires players to play through the same area a certain number of times. But for the most part, it’s done fairly well in this title, in my opinion.

Controls – 10/10

As far as 3D platforming in this game goes, I had no gripes with it whatsoever. Which, in all fairness, was to be expected, I think. As the genre had well and truly taken prominence at this time. Following the release of games such as Super Mario 64 and Jak & Daxter. Combat and stealth are also both handled adequately well. And there are no unnecessary complications with the game’s control scheme present to add any kind of unwarranted level of frustration.

Lifespan – 6/10

The game can be made to last an average of 8 hours, even taking in the completion of side quests throughout the course of the game, which, whilst it isn’t great by any means, is still fractionally longer than the game based on The Lord of the Rings license, which can be made to last around 6 to 7 hours. As the game conforms to a very linear progression, it wasn’t expected to have a great lifespan in any case, but I can’t help but think that with a little bit more imagination on the developer’s part, it could have been made to last at least a little while longer; certainly, the first part of the game is set in the Shire.

Storyline – 8/10

Depicting the events of the classic children’s novel written by JRR Tolkien, The Hobbit follows the exploits of Bilbo Baggins of the Shire. He is persuaded by the wizard Gandalf and his band of 13 dwarves to accompany them on an adventure to retake the dwarven city of Erebor from the dragon Smaug. The story itself isn’t an issue at all since it’s enjoyable in any form that it’s told. Be that through a game, a film, or most notably, of course, a classic book. The biggest problem I had with it, however, is that the voice acting is quite lackluster. Even by video game standards at that time. And thus, it’s much more difficult to take seriously than in other forms of media in which the story would be told.

Originality – 6/10

The game does retain a slight element of uniqueness. It incorporates the aforementioned stealth element. Which, at this point, was only really seen in the Sly Cooper games. However, for the most part, it plays out like most other 3D platformers that were released before their time, and consequently, I don’t think it can be considered either evolutionary or revolutionary. The stealth mechanics in the Sly Cooper games were much more sophisticated than in this title. And in terms of normal 3D platforming mechanics, it fails to stand out amidst many of the classics in the genre that had been released prior.

Happii

In summation, despite its lack of originality and less-than-satisfactory voice acting, The Hobbit is nevertheless a fairly enjoyable gaming experience. And shouldn’t be entirely overlooked. Whilst the visuals may not hold up to this day on a technical level, and whilst more could have been added to increase the game’s longevity, the developers did a good job for the most part, and it’s certainly worth at least one playthrough, for both fans of the Tolkien mythos and the 3D platforming genre.

Score

43.5/60

7/10 (Fair)