Journey (PlayStation 3 & PlayStation 4)

Journey

Developer(s) – Thatgamecompany & Tricky Pixels

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Jenova Chen

Producer – Robin Hunicke

PEGI – 12

Developed by Thatgamecompany and first released back in 2012, Journey went on to become one of the most critically acclaimed video games of the seventh generation. Winning five BAFTA awards among many others, as well as nominations. And becoming a catalyst for proving that video games can be considered a valid art form. Personally, whilst I can appreciate this game for the different direction it has helped to take the industry in and helped to popularise the medium among a greater number of people, it does have its faults. These compelled me to rate it significantly lower than many other video game critics have.

Graphics – 10/10

The aspect that I couldn’t possibly fault, however, is the game’s visuals. A unique and beautiful blend of cel-shaded graphics and wonderful conceptual design. And some very realistic-looking sand and sea textures thrown in for good measure, Journey is one of the most elegant video games I’ve ever laid eyes upon. It reminds me of Shadow of the Colossus, in that there is also an air of mystery about where the game is set. And the events that take place long before it begins.

Gameplay – 4/10

The objective of the game is simply to get from A to B, whilst along the way, solving a few puzzles here and there. There is a side quest of collecting runes across the land, which extends the length of the player character’s scarf. For all its artistic value, I’ve always found there is far too little substance in gameplay for me to be able to label it quite the ground-breaking experience that most reviewers are willing to label it as. Especially given how linear it is, too.

Controls – 10/10

As a 3D platformer, there are no problems with the control scheme of the game. Since the genre came into true prominence throughout the fifth generation of gaming. It was further developed throughout the sixth, with Sony themselves being at the forefront of it since the days of the PlayStation 2. In terms of innovation, however, there is very little present with respect to controls. Since there aren’t any unique mechanics present. Even the flying mechanics were perpetuated in Super Mario 64 long before the release of this title.

Lifespan – 2/10

Disgustingly, to me, Journey can only last up to 3 to 4 hours. Depending on how much of the game the player wishes to complete in a single playthrough. Also, aside from the sake of passing by different players each time with vague elements of interaction with them, there is very little replay value to be had, in my opinion. Rushed, it can take as little as 2 hours to complete. A standard that had long since proven to be below par. With the advent of the entire 3D platforming genre back in the late 90s.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of the game is very compelling, but in a much more abstract sense than in many other video games. It follows the player character’s journey to reach a huge mountain. With a glowing crevice in the middle of its top. Whilst simultaneously being shown insights into the history of the long-forgotten civilization, he/she finds ruins strewn across the land. The story does extremely well to bring out raw emotion in players and to make them feel the awe, fear, and struggle that their character goes through along the way.

Originality – 5/10

As I stated, I can fully understand and value what Thatgamecompany strived to achieve in this title. It was clearly a game made for the sake of art. And that’s where the majority of its innovation lies. It has changed the way many people look at video games forever. However, in terms of gameplay, there is no innovation to experience. There have been many gamers who have come and gone long before Journey, which has presented players with a lot more substance and entertainment.

And yet have done just as good a job representing video games as a valid art form. Many are even greater than this. It made me excited that this title worked to bring that frame of mind to light. But at the same time, I also fear that many more video games in the future may be developed with the same state of mind. And that more and more developers may simply choose to concentrate on the artistic aspect. As opposed to that which matters most, the gameplay.

Niiutral

Overall, Journey does have a lot of redeeming value in some aspects. And it deserves critical acclaim to a certain extent. But as a gamer who believes the most important aspect is the gameplay, I can’t help but look at it as being vastly overrated. Ryan Clements of IGN once said of it that not all gamers would appreciate a game with a deliberate, melancholic pace and short duration. And I believe he hit the nail on the head.

Score

38/60

6/10 (Average)

Jet Force Gemini (Nintendo 64)

Jet Force Gemini

Developer(s) – Rareware

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director – Peter Beanland

Producer – Chris Stamper

ELSPA – 11+

Developed by Rare and inspired by numerous works of science fiction and previous Nintendo games such as Super Metroid and Super Mario 64, Jet Force Gemini is a run-and-gun shooter emphasizing exploration, intense combat, and item collecting. It was warmly received by critics upon release. Albeit not without criticism. In my opinion, the criticism levied against this game was justified. I personally found it far too problematic to be able to call it one of the better games for the Nintendo 64. I ran into numerous issues with this title that I found impossible to overlook.

Graphics – 7/10

With a conceptual design influenced by several popular sci-fi series like Star Wars, Stargate, Dune, and Battle of the Planets, the game’s visuals are most definitely the best redeeming quality it has to offer. It takes place in wonderfully varied locations ranging from spaceships and caves to castles and swamps. The different types of locations are reminiscent of many of Rare’s previous games developed under Nintendo, like Diddy Kong Racing or Donkey Kong 64. And to me, it was a positive demonstration of how Nintendo’s influence had a very positive effect on the once-renowned development company before being bought out by Microsoft.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

The objective of Jet Force Gemini is to explore wide-open locations, collect items, and save the NPC inhabitants, known as the Tribals. And gun down everything else in sight. The combat is indeed quite intense. But for what lack of a stable control scheme there is, it can also seem very unreasonably demanding. Not only is it not the most accessible game on the Nintendo 64, but there is a needless insistence on fulfilling most criteria within the game in order to properly complete it. Not everyone may be able to save all the Tribals, as it demands. This may also lead to a level of repetition depending on how many times players are forced to replay each level.

Controls – 4/10

By far the worst thing about Jet Force Gemini is how relentlessly bad the control scheme was handled. Although there is an auto-aim mode in place to help players pick off enemies on the ground, the game insists players use a clunky precision targeting mode to take care of enemies on higher ground. This is extremely easy to lose patience with. In a lot of ways, it reminds me of how the ground missions in Star Fox Assault played out. A lot of unnecessary complications, which, if excluded, could have made for a much greater game than what it turned out to be.

Lifespan – 6/10

The title can be made to last an average of around 7 to 8 hours. For those who are willing to look past the bad controls. Emphasis on exploration does fairly well to add to its longevity. And there is also additional gameplay value to be had in the numerous different multiplayer modes. The biggest concern going into the game for the player will, however, ultimately be how well they can adapt to the control scheme. And speaking from experience, it will not be an easy task.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of the game follows the titular Jet Force Gemini team as they battle the evil Mizar and his horde of insect drones. In a time when video games were in the process of being established as a viable art form, Jet Force Gemini does have some redeeming qualities in this respect. But nowhere near as much as many other Nintendo 64 games would portray; notably The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask. The fifth generation was a wonderfully weird and varied time for video games. And whilst this title didn’t have anywhere near as much of an impact in the way of storytelling as many others, it certainly wasn’t one of the worst video game stories either.

Originality – 6/10

This title does stand out among many other releases for the Nintendo 64. Albeit for some of the wrong reasons. Though gameplay was much different than the likes of Super Mario 64 or Goldeneye 007, I don’t think Rare was quite able to make as much use of the analog stick controls. As they did with Goldeneye 007, and then later, Perfect Dark. If they had perhaps made a follow-up to Jet Force Gemini, the control scheme may have come with much-needed improvements. But unfortunately, this is a supposition, and impossible to know for certain.

Angrii

In summation, despite some redeeming qualities this game has going for it, Jet Force Gemini has far too many problems for me to be able to call it one of Rare’s greatest works before the Microsoft acquisition. The company released some of the best games on the Nintendo 64, but unfortunately, this is not one such title.

Score

35.5/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

Iron Snout (PC)

Iron Snout

Developer(s) – SnoutUp Games

PEGI – 12

Starting life as a simple flash game, Iron Snout has since been ported to Steam. Whereupon its official release on the online gaming service has received an overwhelmingly positive response for its addictive, yet simple style of gameplay and quirky art style. Having played this game myself, it’s simple to understand where all the hype comes from. Especially for a game that is currently free to play. It is indeed a compulsive and extremely satisfying gaming experience. And it has a lot more depth than first impressions may suggest.

Graphics – 7/10

The game’s visuals are of the quality that a gamer can come to expect with an independently developed Flash game: basic and cartoony. But with its own small sense of creative charm. Iron Snout seemingly follows the tableau of The Little Red Riding Hood made evident by certain enemies. And with the concept of the natural order of wolves preying on pigs. Although if players are proficient enough, it will largely seem like the other way around. Many Flash game developers, such as Edmund Macmillan, have come to be known for their exemplary conceptual design. But whilst this game isn’t anywhere as diverse in visual representation as The Binding of Isaac or Super Meat Boy, this game does retain some value in this respect.

Gameplay – 8/10

Where this game’s real strength lies is undoubtedly in its gameplay. Indeed, as should be the case with any game, in my opinion. The object of Iron Snout is to kill as many enemies as possible before the player character’s health runs out. It seems like a simple enough objective. But as I alluded to, there is a certain depth to it that makes it much easier said than done. Different kinds of enemies can appear on-screen at any given time. Forcing players to have to strategize in accordance with what they are faced with. It forces players to largely have to think on their feet. This sets this game apart from a typical Flash game. The stratagem involved was most certainly a welcome addition.

Controls – 10/10

The game’s control scheme is as simple as a control scheme could get. And therefore, a player’s level of success is measured by how quickly and sharply they can react to what is on the screen at any given time. The only buttons involved are the directional buttons of the PC keyboard. Which keeps controlling the game, thankfully simple for how much there is to think about whilst playing.

Originality – 7/10

Rarely have I personally come across Flash games that I believe have the potential to become released to a more mainstream gaming audience. I’ve seen it with the likes of The Binding of Isaac and X-Type+, but a vast majority of them seem to have less potential attached to them, and as a result, I have generally avoided reviewing such games. But if more games like this are developed, which are able to stand out as much as this title does, it could very easily change my perceptions of such in time.

Happii

Overall, I was extremely surprised by just how good a game Iron Snout is. It’s addictive, challenging, fairly well presented, and is available to play right now, at any time, and at no cost. For all these reasons, it is highly recommended by me.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Injustice: Gods Among Us (PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Xbox 360, Wii U, PC, Android & iOS)

Injustice

Developer(s) – NetherRealm Studios & High Voltage Software

Publisher(s) – Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Director – Ed Boon

Producer – Shaun Himmerick

PEGI – 16

Following on from Mortal Kombat Vs DC Universe, Injustice: Gods Among Us is a fighting game conceived by Mortal Kombat co-creator Ed Boon. Starring a cast of many different characters from DC Comics franchises. Including Batman, Superman, The Flash, Aquaman, and the Green Lantern. Since its US release back in April 2013, the game has sold almost 1 million copies. It received many positive reviews based on its gameplay and level of graphical detail. However, whilst I think it’s not a bad game, I did find it to have drawbacks.

Graphics – 7/10

With this game featuring characters such as Batman and The Joker, I couldn’t help but compare it to the Arkham series. And in drawing my comparisons, I found that whilst Injustice does have some detail in its visuals, it doesn’t have anywhere near as much detail as any of the games in the Arkham series. The characters, in particular, look pretty detailed during fights when they are seen from a certain distance away. But when cutscenes play during the story mode.

And when characters can be seen up close, they just don’t look as detailed to me. In particular, Superman’s facial expressions look less than convincing. And I thought to myself that if most other characters didn’t wear headgear or domino masks, they would all look as substandard as Superman. Although that may seem like a clever technique to some, I can’t help but feel that their facial clothing hides more than just their real identities. However, I can’t fault the diversity in stage design. Which was very well thought out and is pretty intricate for a fighting game in particular.

Gameplay – 7/10

I think Injustice plays out well enough for a fighting game. There are a lot of game modes to unlock throughout, which offer quite a bit of variety. And the RPG-like element of leveling up the player’s profile in order to unlock more things makes the game quite interesting to play. The gripe I had with it is that apart from extra game modes, alternative costumes, and concept art, there’s not much more incentive to play it. Chiefly,

I don’t like the fact that there are no hidden characters to unlock. Which, for me, is probably the biggest attraction of playing a fighting game. Instead, there are 6 additional download-only characters. And the character Darkseid is exclusive to the iOS port of the game. Even if players are willing to spend extra money to buy the ultimate edition of the game, the additional characters are not unlocked using conventional means. And to me, that just takes a lot of the fun out of it.

Controls – 10/10

As another one of these gameplay formulas, which has been developed and modified over many years, there should never have been any issues with the controls. And there are none, thankfully. I actually found it particularly interesting to find how characters handle a lot like Mortal Kombat characters. For example, I noticed that Batman handles a lot like Scorpion. The Joker handles similarly to Reptile, and the Green Lantern handles very much like Ermac.

Lifespan – 10/10

Although I’d say that it will take only a few hours to play through the main story mode. And experienced fighting game players could probably complete all the additional game modes relatively quickly, the fact of the matter is that Injustice, like any other fighting game, is one of these games that can simply be picked up and played at any time. There’s no worry attached to it, regarding making conventional progress or outlasting a certain lifespan.

Storyline – 4.5/10

Whilst I was playing this game, I could never fully understand what was going on, and I still wouldn’t be able to without the aid of an online synopsis of it. Basically, what happens is that the DC heroes and villains are plunged into an alternative reality and pitted against their alternative counterparts. Aside from it being more open to fans of the DC Universe, making it biased in that respect, I found that events seemed to move along far too quickly, and attention kept shifting from place to place and character to character too fast for me to be able to think about exactly what was happening. Everything just happens with very little explanation.

Originality – 6/10

Whilst I can praise Injustice for its uniqueness in conceptual design and certain gameplay elements, I believe that it lacks originality in its shortage of gameplay incentive; as with a lot of fighting games, there are normally a lot of hidden characters to be found. Whilst most games don’t have a storyline, which is nigh on impossible to follow, that may make it unique, but in an extremely negative sense.

Happii

So overall, I think Injustice: Gods Among Us is fairly enjoyable, but it does indeed have its flaws, and I can’t think of a reason why NetherRealm Studios should expand any further on the concept of the story, as I think even DC fans will have trouble trying to keep up.

Score

44.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

InFamous: Second Son (PlayStation 4)

InFamous Second Son

Developer – Sucker Punch Studios

Publisher – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Nate Fox

Producer – Brian Fleming

PEGI – 16

InFamous: Second Son follows on from the dramatic improvements that Sucker Punch made with the second game. It delivers an even greater gaming experience than its predecessor. A lot of issues I’d previously had with the InFamous gaming formula were answered. As well as the few initial reservations I’d had when I played the demo at the lock-in event earlier this month. And this is my verdict.

Graphics – 9.5/10

When I first looked at actual gameplay, I noticed that the setting of Seattle, Washington, was a lot darker, gloomier, and grittier than either Empire City or New Marais from the first and second games, respectively. Although I found that most of the game’s story takes place in the daytime, I felt that it did retain that foreboding atmosphere whenever it turned nighttime, or when it started raining. I felt by that token, the game could also be taken more seriously than its predecessors.

The fact that the player character’s skin doesn’t turn either black and white or pale if the player decides to take the evil route also means that Second Son can be taken more seriously than in the first two games. A graphical element that took me some time to warm to with both InFamous 1 and 2 was the comic book-like cutscenes. But this time around, they play a less prominent role. Only being used to explain the backstories of certain characters. To me, that also gave Second Son an even more heightened sense of realism.

Cont…

Another interesting thing I found about the game’s setting is that, whilst it takes place in an entirely different city, there are some elements which are very reminiscent of the previous games. For example, the DUP booths remind me of the wooden huts in New Marais. And both the Space Needle and the DUP headquarters remind me of Alden’s Tower in the first game. But that’s not to say that they are the only nods to previous games made by Sucker Punch.

Their take on Seattle is also littered with Sly Cooper Easter eggs. Such as neon signs, billboards, and a badge of the Sly Cooper logo on the main character’s jacket. And in a children’s playground, there are drawings on the wall of the three main characters from that series: Sly, Bentley, and Murray. But whilst the game is painstakingly detailed and atmospheric, the visuals lose out on a perfect score on account of a few graphical glitches here and there. But otherwise, this is one of the most visually compelling games I’ve played for some time.

Gameplay – 9.5/10

Playing the game was equally as exciting as looking at it. And I found it just as enjoyable to play as the other entries in the series. There has never been as much gameplay variety in the series as there is in Second Son. With a much greater arsenal of superpowers at the player’s disposal than ever before. And a plethora of unique side quests to do aside from the main story. And even a side quest played through the PlayStation 4 and the internet via the website infamouspapertrail.com.

Although I was sorry to see the departure of the facility, to create missions and shared them over the PlayStation Network. And the melee combat isn’t as stylish as in InFamous 2. But the final product still makes for some serious fun to be had. The side quests are also literally a lot more creative. One of which involves painting graffiti art around the city. There is also a great incentive for completing the game in the form of an additional superpower.

Controls – 10/10

The fact that I am able to give InFamous: Second Son a perfect score in terms of controls is particularly significant as far as I’m concerned. I had previously had issues with the control scheme whilst playing through the first two games. This game answered my previous reservations. I found that the biggest problem came with trying to climb walls to reach the top of buildings.

But Sucker Punch addressed these issues in several extremely subtle ways. For example, having smoke powers meant that the character could travel through air vents. Instantly taking him from the bottom of a wall to a rooftop with much less difficulty. When the player acquires the neon power, it is also possible to run at inhuman speeds as well as run up walls to the top of buildings. This also made Second Son much easier to cope with than InFamous 1 and 2.

Lifespan – 8/10

Lasting just as long as the previous two games, InFamous: Second Son can make for over 40 hours of gameplay if players choose to play through twice. Taking both the good and evil routes. By the same token, there is quite a bit of replay value to be had. However, I do hope that Sucker Punch brings out a few DLC packs in addition to the ongoing InFamous Paper Trail sidequest because the world of InFamous: Second Son is very much worth expanding on further.

Storyline – 8.5/10

Taking place seven years after the events of InFamous 2, the story of InFamous: Second Son follows Delsin Rowe. A member of a Native American tribe situated on the outskirts of Seattle. After realizing he is a conduit (a human who can harness superpowers), he and his tribe are attacked by Brooke Augustine. A powerful conduit and the leader of the DUP. Authorities are intent on protecting humans from the threat of conduits (re-branded by them as “bio-terrorists”).

Delsin travels to Seattle along with his brother Reggie to harness Augustine’s power and reverse the damage she has done to the rest of Delsin’s tribe. When I first heard that Delsin was going to be an anti-hero in contrast to the previous InFamous protagonist, Cole MacGrath, it made me question how big a role morality would have compared to the previous two games. However, I found that the element of morality plays a much more prominent role in terms of both gameplay and story.

Moral choices affect the outcome of the game to a greater extent. And I also felt that the knock-on effects of how the player chooses to play out the story have much more of an impact on the narrative. But I think the most significant improvement made to the story is that the characters are much more believable and either likable or detestable. Depending on the direction the story is taken in. Either way, how Delsin’s character develops throughout the course of the game makes him an even more compelling character than Cole, in my opinion.

Originality – 8.5/10

Overall, despite the improved amount of variety in gameplay, side quests, visual presentation, and story, InFamous: Second Son essentially plays out like the previous two games. And the general premise remains the same. But in all honesty, that’s why I like it so much. I’ve been a fan of InFamous since the series’ inception back in 2009. And although the formula is somewhat similar to Grand Theft Auto, I find InFamous much more enjoyable to play. And what elements have been added to keep it fresh do well enough to differentiate it from its predecessors. As well as many other games.

Deliirious

In summation, InFamous Second Son to me represents the first look of mainstream excellence in the eighth generation of gaming. It’s intense, atmospheric, explosive, and incredibly exciting. To me, it is definitely the best game of 2014. Unanimously, my game of the year.

Score

54/60

9/10 (Excellent)

InFamous: First Light (PlayStation 4)

InFamous First Light

Developer(s) – Sucker Punch Studios

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Nate Fox

Producer – Brian Fleming

PEGI – 16

Also acting as a standalone game as well as DLC, InFamous: First Light brings players back to Central Seattle to play through a prologue to the original game. Documenting the back story of the supporting character, Abigail “Fetch” Walker. Though most of the gameplay largely remains the same, I was both impressed and somewhat disappointed by it at the same time.

Graphics – 9.5/10

Just as in the original game, First Light portrays a very dark and gritty take on Central Seattle. It went leaps and bounds ahead of what Sucker Punch Studios has ever done with the InFamous series in terms of presentation. The heightened sense of realism compared to previous games in the series is also very prominent. And I think the further emphasis the developers put on using neon as scenery and a general constant adds a further presence of grittiness to the setting of the entire saga. Although there is less scenery to look at overall, I think the developers have done a very good job of adding something very interesting to their already existing artwork.

Gameplay – 9/10

Since Infamous: First Light is essentially an add-on to an already existing game, I expected there would be considerably less content and substance in gameplay. But I found that while there is much less than in Second Son, it was still a great joy to play for how long it lasts. There are a few side quests scattered here and there, and also a fair amount of variety. I was disappointed by how toned down the range of abilities was compared to the original game and how the morality mechanics aren’t present, as they are in every other game in the series, but the training programs that can be done give it a fair bit of replay value, at least.

Controls – 10/10

Just like in Second Son, Many of the control issues that had been apparent in the first two games in the series had been addressed. It is much easier to move around and to engage enemies. And there aren’t any unnecessary complications present that are annoying, as opposed to being innovative. It can be somewhat hard to control the new neon graffiti art mechanics. But to me, it’s not annoying enough for it to lose any marks.

Lifespan – 3/10

In relation to the much more restricted gameplay, DLCs usually last considerably less time than the original game. And I’m sad to say that First Light is no exception. The main story can last merely two to three hours. Even taking in side quests. However, the game isn’t without replay value, of course, since the ultimate objective of undertaking the various training programs found in the DLC is to simply beat the high score. Interestingly, introducing the franchise to a grassroots video gaming basis.

Storyline – 8.5/10

The story of InFamous: First Light tells the backstory of Abigail “Fetch” Walker. A conduit that can harness the power of neon, imprisoned in the DUP facility, Curdan Cay. All the while being trained to harness her powers by the DUP leader, Brooke Augustine. Whilst simultaneously documenting the chain of events that led her there. And of her life on the streets of Seattle with her brother, Brent. In my opinion, the story is just as gripping and full of twists and turns as the original game. And although morality mechanics have been taken out of the gameplay formula, the theme of morality is very much present in the game’s story, as well as the contemplation of the effects of making tough decisions, story elements that have been stable throughout the entire series.

Originality – 7/10

Although I wish that more could have been added to First Light to make it last longer. And by the same token, I hope that this is merely the first of many DLC packages for the original game. I think that adding as much replay value as they have to it in a way that is fairly unusual for a game of the same caliber as InFamous: Second Son is pretty unique. And also a very smart move. It’s by that token that I believe First Light also works relatively well as a standalone game.

Happii

Overall, InFamous: First Light is a decent add-on to what is still my pick as the greatest game of 2014. InFamous: Second Son. Though it lasts a pretty short amount of time, the time players will spend on it will be enjoyed. And replay value can be had on top of that.

Score

47/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Ico (PlayStation 2 & PlayStation 3)

Ico

Developer(s) – Team Ico (SCE Japan Studios)

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Fumito Ueda

PEGI – 12

Inspired by Eric Chahi’s Another World, Fumito Ueda developed Ico, which was released in 2001. It has since become a cult classic among gamers. Personally preferring Ueda’s next game after this, Shadow of the Colossus, I found this game enjoyable to a certain extent. But I don’t think I would go so far as to call it a cult classic.

Graphics – 7/10

Whilst the setting of the game is fairly well-designed. And there are a few standout individual areas, such as the windmill and the graveyard, but the game’s visuals seemed a little repetitive to me after a while. But what I do have to respect this game for in terms of graphical presentation is the fact that it has gone on to inspire not only other game developers, such as Phil Fish and Vander Caballero, but also film directors. Such as Pan’s Labyrinth director, Guillermo del Toro. This game has also gone on to inspire the creation of such games as Twilight Princess, one of my personal favorites. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time, which I personally respect the game for.

Gameplay – 6/10

An aspect I don’t entirely respect this game for is its style of play. On the one hand, the game can get very samey. As the concept of what to do is to simply solve a puzzle, then kill some shadowy creatures, and rinse and repeat. Combat to me isn’t particularly fluent, and annoyingly, the hit detection isn’t great either. I found myself growing bored about two hours in. But on the other hand, the puzzles are very well thought out, which provides the game with a fair amount of challenge. So Ico isn’t completely unplayable. Its linearity for how big the setting of the game is doesn’t do it any favors either, the way I see it.

Controls – 9/10

As I pointed out before, the hit detection can be irritatingly inaccurate at times. And camera angles can seem somewhat awkward whilst climbing or traversing along buildings. But apart from that, there are thankfully no other problems to address.

Lifespan – 3/10

At best, Ico can only be made to last roughly 4 to 5 hours, which is unacceptable. As many side quests could easily have been added to make it last considerably longer. Despite its level of linearity. Its lack of additional content seems extremely unsavory. Especially as this was made in a time when 3D platforming had just about been perfected. And there were more games released at the time with much more substance to them. So by that logic, Ueda was always going to have a hard time competing with the likes of Jak & Daxter. As in Ico, there simply isn’t enough to do.

Storyline – 9/10

Although Ico could not have been able to compete with other games in terms of gameplay, it excels above many in terms of story. The tale involves a small boy called Ico, who has been imprisoned in a castle and manages to set himself free from the coffin he is put in. Finding a captive girl called Yorda, he releases her and resolves to help her escape from the castle along with him. Like Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, certain aspects of the story are told through gameplay. In that the two rely on each other to do certain things for both of them to progress. Conveying the themes of trust and cooperation, it all makes for an inspiring and emotional tale, with a few plot twists thrown in for good measure.

Originality – 8/10

Though I have my reservations about this game, the fact of the matter is that a game like Ico, which has gone on to inspire so many people across the last decade, has to be considered unique. However, the lack of imagination on the developer’s part stems from its lack of content in gameplay, in my opinion.

Happii

In summation, Ico can make for 4 or 5 hours of moderate entertainment and the telling of a well-written and well-conceived story, but to me, it is really missing a lot of gameplay variety and side quests, and again, it seems like a little bit too much of a fleeting experience.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

The House of the Dead 2 (Arcade, PC, Dreamcast & Wii)

House of the Dead 2

Developer(s) – Wow Entertainment

Publisher(s) – Sega

PEGI – 16

Released three years after the original game, House of the Dead 2 received a mostly positive reception from critics. Most seemingly in agreement that it made significant improvements on the first titles in the series. Personally, I do have to say I spent a lot of time playing this game when I was younger. But looking back at it now, I realize many of its core faults with it.

Graphics – 7/10

Despite several glitches here and there, the visuals were very much ahead of their time. Since it was ported to the Sega Dreamcast as well as arcade cabinets. And the Dreamcast was capable of rendering much more advanced visuals than both the Nintendo 64 and the original PlayStation. The conceptual design was fairly well handled for the most part. The game is set in Venice, Italy. But the game also takes the player to different locations as it progresses. Such as a colosseum in Rome, and a once-thriving modern city. Those levels are set in broad daylight, however. Because of that, the game loses much more of its horror factor towards the end, the way I see it.

Gameplay – 7/10

Despite the many faults House of the Dead 2 has, the one aspect that was enjoyable at the time and is still enjoyable to this day is the gameplay. In a first-person rail shooter, the objective is simply to kill every zombie or monster that may block the player’s path in order to progress through each level. And defeat the various bosses waiting for them. When I was growing up, I was always lukewarm to rail-shooting games. But after the likes of Halo and Half-Life came to home consoles, they blew games like this out of the water. Since there was much more to them. Nevertheless, it’s only in terms of gameplay that I feel this title does hold up to a small extent.

Controls – 10/10

The control schemes in rail shooters are much simpler and more self-explanatory than even a first-person shooter. So consequently, there are no issues that will arise in this respect whilst playing it. The only functions players must grow accustomed to are simply aiming, shooting, and reloading.

Lifespan – 3/10

In lieu of the tradition of the genre, one playthrough of this game will only last an average of forty minutes. But what longevity there is in playing this game comes from the fact that it was designed to be played a multitude of times. Especially since there are a few alternative endings to unlock. Depending on certain circumstances throughout the game. I do feel, however, that much more could have been added to make it last at least twice as long. Or even an endless mode could have been added to the home console versions of the game.

Storyline – 2/10

The worst thing about this game is undoubtedly the storyline. Even though the industry was still in the process of getting out of the mindset that video games didn’t necessarily have to tell a story in order to be good, there were many different factors making this story especially bad. It follows AMS agents James and Gary trying to get to the bottom of a zombie epidemic that has broken out in Venice and is threatening to spread across the planet. Aside from the plot being extremely typical of most zombie films that have been released prior, the voice acting is particularly poor and embarrassing.

Anyone who may have thought the original Resident Evil had bad voice acting hasn’t heard anything yet until they experience what this game has to offer. It also now seems pretty stupid that the developers chose to keep the name The House of the Dead attached to the project. Since the setting contradicts the name greatly, as it’s no longer set in a house. Personally, I would have given it a more relevant name. And just stuck with the same text font, so that people would have recognized that it was from the same series of games. But alas, the developers settled on what they did.

Originality – 4/10

Aside from the story being very unoriginal, the gameplay, whilst enjoyable, didn’t really bring anything new to the genre; essentially playing out like a carbon copy of the first game. As well as other games in the genre, such as Time Crisis or Virtua Cop. Although the reload mechanism is much more accessible than in Time Crisis, there wasn’t anything beyond that that made it stand out from any other rail shooting title.

Angrii

Overall, House of the Dead 2 was a decent game, maybe 15 years ago. But now, it seems like a much less enjoyable experience for those many reasons. With so many zombie-based shooters finding their way into mainstream gaming these days, it would be hard for Sega to make another game in the series. Unless they do something drastic with the story as well as the gameplay.

Score

33/60

5.5/10 (Below Average)

Hyrule Warriors (Wii U, 3DS & Switch)

Hyrule Warriors

Developer(s) – Omega Force & Team Ninja

Publisher(s) – Nintendo & Koei Tecmo

Director – Masaki Furusawa

Producer(s) – Hisashi Koinuma, Yosuki Hayashi & Eiji Aonuma

PEGI – 12

Hyrule Warriors is a title that combines elements from both the hack-and-slash gameplay from the Dynasty Warriors series and the world of Nintendo’s Legend of Zelda series. As well as its many RPG aspects. Going into this title, I was instinctively skeptical. Since the Zelda series is one of my favorites, I saw the entire joint venture as a huge gamble on Nintendo’s part. However, I was quite surprised to find out how good a game it actually is.

Graphics – 6.5/10

Instead of the Zelda tradition, the game is conceptually diverse. It incorporates a plethora of different elements from different games in the series. And also a lot of the different visual styles of the different games, too. The in-game visuals are very reminiscent of the likes of Twilight Princess and Skyward Sword. And some of the cutscenes take on a style more akin to a cartoon, similar to Wind Waker. There are also a lot of nice-looking FMV sequences throughout the game to accompany all this.

It makes me wonder why Nintendo has scarcely approved of the use of FMVs in their games. After all, they also worked pretty well in Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze, too. Some of the new characters do a good job of keeping the series fairly free, too. The best example of that to me is the Volga. An enemy character based on the boss of the Fire Temple in Ocarina of Time. Volvagia. The issues I have with the graphics stem from the technical side of things. I have spotted a good few glitches while playing. And sometimes the frame rate can drop when enough enemies are on the screen. It made me question the hardware capabilities of the Wii U.

Gameplay – 7.5/10

Despite the fact that the game is very repetitive. As the main objective is to simply dispatch everything in sight until each enemy base is taken, it’s also very addictive. Omega Force has had a lot of experience developing games in the hack-and-slash genre l, and they are good at what they do. The popularity of Dynasty Warriors in Japan, as well as its spin-offs, speaks volumes. There are multiple game modes to choose from, giving players plenty to do throughout. And a great amount of in-game incentive for doing it, including new weapons, items, and characters.

The fact that there is also a substantial amount of playable characters also gives the game a fair bit of variety. I think Team Ninja has done a much better job of collaborating with Nintendo this time around. More than what they did during the development of Metroid: Other M, anyway. Hyrule Warriors is much easier to enjoy for me. Not only is it much easier to get to grips with than Metroid: Other M, but it doesn’t feel like too radical a departure from the main series. As indeed was one of the biggest concerns I had before playing it.

Controls – 8/10

The quality of the controls depends largely on what peripheral is used. Playing the game on the Wii U GamePad, as per the developer’s primary intention, does come with its limitations. Not only do the GamePad’s facilities not truly add much to the gameplay. Except for displaying previous progress notifications and players being able to use the touchpad to select secondary items. But after a while, playing the game with the GamePad can end up causing pain in the hands of players if they aren’t careful. I feel as if it is important that I address this issue to anyone who is looking to play the game but may only have the Wii U GamePad to play it on.

Since the gameplay in Hyrule Warriors is very intense and action-packed, players may end up tensing their hands across the side of the GamePad. And doing this can cause quite a bit of pain after a good few hours. My advice to players would be to make sure that they try to keep their hands relaxed and be careful not to tense them up around the GamePad regularly. Most game controllers are designed for players to naturally wrap their hands around. But the Wii U GamePad’s design makes doing this considerably harder. All that being said, however, there are no issues with the actual control scheme of the game itself. And since it centers mainly on button-mashing, I find that mastering the basics won’t be too much of a problem.

Lifespan – 8/10

Though gameplay remains the same throughout, there are still enough things to do to warrant around 30 to 40 hours of playing; maybe even longer if players wish to achieve 100%. There is enough intense and action-packed combat. There is both a strong RPG presence and enough in the way of having to level up each character and gaining new weapons and abilities, to keep players interested for an extraordinarily long time for a game of its kind. Out of all the elements of the Legend of Zelda series present in Hyrule Warriors, a delightfully long lifespan is one that I am particularly happy to see attained by the developers.

Storyline – 6/10

Taking place outside of the official Zelda timeline, the events of the story follow Link. Who, with the aid of several other characters from across the series, such as Impa and Sheik, must work to eliminate a new threat headed by the sorceress Cia. Who intends to revive Ganondorf in order for him to lay waste to the land of Hyrule and usurp the throne from Princess Zelda. The game works better for fans of the series in a lot of different ways. But no truer is this than in the narrative. It helps to move the plot forward if players already know who everybody in the game is. As they all come from several different games in the series. If not, some characters will inevitably come off negatively compared to how they were portrayed in previous games.

Cont…

For example, the character Agitha had a fairly subtle role in Twilight Princess. But in Hyrule Warriors, she comes off as considerably less subtle and more unintelligent. And series newcomers will not understand the references to her character in Twilight Princess that are present in Hyrule Warriors. I won’t give away exactly what happens, but one thing that won’t work quite so well for fans of the series is that one particular plot thread is repeated from another game. And thus discounts one fairly major plot twist.

However, having addressed all these issues, I didn’t find the game’s plot to be terrible by any means. Although it still follows the same basic premise that the series has done for almost 30 years now, all the different elements from different Zelda games have been brought together nicely to make for a fairly well-written new story. It goes to show, at least, that Nintendo is indeed willing to break traditions and take their franchises in new and different directions.

Originality – 6/10

Though for the most part, this game draws heavily on pre-existing elements from 2 different video game franchises, I found that both of these concepts have been taken into fair consideration by the developers, and the result is something that is somewhat unique in its own right. It may not be the most original end result to spawn from Nintendo collaborating with another developer, but I think if either party had strayed too far from either concept, the game may not have turned out to be as good as it is.

Happii

To summarise, Hyrule Warriors, despite its flaws, is a very addictive game and is most certainly worth investing a good few hours in. Despite the many times that Nintendo has either teamed up with or handed over some of its longest-running series to other developers, I was worried that something terrible might have come of this in a particular endeavor. But much to my delight, I was proven wrong.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

(Written for http://darkzero.co.uk/)

Hotline Miami (PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita & Android) 

Hotline Miami

Developer(s) – Dennation Games & Abstraction Games

Publisher(s) – Devolver Digital

Programmer – Jonatan Söderstrom

PEGI – 16

Inspired by numerous films and documentaries such as Cocaine Cowboys, Drive, and Kick-Ass, Hotline Miami was created by Jonatan Söderstrom. Having worked on the game since he was 18, it was first released in 2012. Later, going on to garner a great amount of critical acclaim. On the other hand, however, I was left with a very different and much more negative view of the game. Since I found there to be many complications with it, which made it nigh-on unplayable overall.

Graphics – 8/10

The one aspect of this game that I shouldn’t criticize too much, however, is its visuals. Taking place in dark, gritty, trippy, and colorful 8-BIT environments reminiscent of 80s culture. As inspired by the documentary Cocaine Cowboys, it stands as a testament to how far pixel art has come in recent years. The only gripe I have with it in this respect is that the settings and enemies can seem pretty repetitive after a while. But not so much so that it makes the game seem rushed in respect of its conceptual design.

Gameplay – 5/10

Although I had a few issues with the visuals of the game, I had many issues with every other aspect of it. The gameplay is no exception. After having previewed the game several times, my first impression was that it could be extremely fun and addictive. But it turned out to be everything but that. It combines top-down shooting with stealth, and therefore, there is next to no fluency. With players having to constantly backtrack and start again, it is mercilessly inaccessible.

Aside from all that, it’s also one of the most repetitious games I’ve ever sat down and played. Each level simply involves the player having to run through a building, kill everything in sight, and walk back out again. The only side quest is to unlock each different mask, granting the player new abilities. There is a small RPG element to it in this respect. But only one of the abilities can be equipped at any one given time throughout any one given level. Taking out a lot of variety that the game could have potentially had.

Controls – 5/10

Hotline Miami’s control scheme is also a huge mess. Relying on a questionable targeting system, it can be a massive chore just to move around. Let alone aim weapons or perform melee attacks. Hit detection can also come into question at times. Since not every clear-cut melee attack seems to damage enemies. Making the game even more needlessly inaccessible.

Lifespan – 2/10

As well as being an overly difficult, awkward to control, and downright repetitive game, it’s also an extremely short one, lasting no more than around 2 hours. Whilst many critics may argue that this is excusable since the developer would have been on a budget, as is often the case with indie games, I would argue against it. Since there are many games out there that have been developed on a budget that has been made to last much longer, even forever. To me, it’s all down to the developer’s imagination. And I see no reason why this game could have had an endless mode to add towards its longevity, at least.

Storyline – 2/10

The story in Hotline Miami is also even more of a mess than the game’s control scheme. The game follows a man called Jacket, who is forced to undertake a series of assassination jobs; all the while, his world becomes evermore surreal, and various terrible things happen to him and the people he cares about. After the first chapter, I stopped caring about the story, since not only is it difficult to follow at the best of times, but it is also presented out of chronological order.

Though the developer intentionally implemented all this, none of it worked for me at all. Once more, it’s not as if the gameplay makes up for the lack of story, as was the case with most 8-BIT games released around the time when this title takes place, 1989, so to have the story as distorted as it seems to me is more of a frustration than a surreal artistic expression.

Originality – 5/10

I can appreciate the fact that the developer attempted to make the game stand out in terms of visuals and overall concept. It also stands out in terms of gameplay, albeit for all the wrong reasons. I’m not sure whether any significant improvements were made with the sequel, Hotline Miami 2: Wrong Number, and there may come a time when I play and review that game, but there certainly would have been significant room for improvement as far as I’m concerned.

Angrii

Overall, Hotline Miami is one of the most overrated debacles I’ve witnessed within the indie gaming scene. The gameplay is repetitious, the controls are broken, the lifespan is laughable, and the story seems about as nonsensical as a glass hammer.

Score

27/60

4.5/10 (Mediocre)