Tag Archives: Monument Valley

Monument Valley II

Monument Valley II (Android, iOS, PC, PS4, PS5, XOne, X/S, Switch)

Developer(s) – Ustwo Games

Publisher(s) – Ustwo Games

Released three years after the successful launch of the first game. Monument Valley II was also met with critical acclaim. Going on to sell almost three and a half million copies within the first year. And even picking up the award for best mobile video game of 2017. It offers an almost identical experience to that of the first game. It’s pretty much an extension of which, ostensibly. I found it fractionally better than the first game, though it did come with a lot of the same issues as the first game as well. And they hadn’t really been meaningfully addressed.

Graphics – 8/10

The game’s technical and conceptual design has remained largely the same. Making use of colourful and isometric environments to perpetuate the puzzle element of the last game. With very much the same type of atmospheric soundtrack to accompany the visuals throughout. Though as aesthetically pleasing as in the first game, the developers didn’t do a great deal to make it stand out from it in its own right. Putting the two of them together, unless you play them a few times, players would probably be hard-pressed to tell much of a difference between the two games in this respect. 

Gameplay – 7/10

And like the graphics, the gameplay has ostensibly remained the same as well. The only minor difference is that in some levels, the player must control two characters instead of one and have both of these characters solve puzzles simultaneously in order to progress further throughout the game. It works fairly well, but it doesn’t really mix things up as much as what a play could come to expect from a sequel. For a game with two characters to control at the same time, it doesn’t offer the level of innovation that Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons did, for example. In my opinion, an extra push in terms of gameplay could’ve been implemented to make it truly stand out. But it seems they only tried to a certain extent. 

Controls – 10/10

The control scheme also remains the same, with the exception of the two-character sequences. But even this concept is easy enough to get used to from the get-go. So, although again there isn’t a great amount of innovation here, it’s a better alternative than the developers having potentially tried something too outlandish with the control scheme. And made the game worse than it needed to have been.

Lifespan – 2/10

The biggest issue I had with the previous game was the lifespan. And nothing has been done to address this. With the game lasting there around the same amount of time as the original. At this point, players could come to expect the developers to have added a lot more than what had been added to switch gameplay up to an adequate degree. And make the sequel last even a little bit more than the first game. But unfortunately, aside from the one additional mechanic, there’s nothing. 

Storyline – 4/10

One of only a few minor tweaks that have been made to this game at all, compared to the original, is in terms of story. The story of Monument Valley II follows a character named Ro and her child as they initially traverse the world around them together. And later become separated, with Ro’s child having to overcome obstacles herself to find her mother again. The additional substance comes in the respect that the second game feels a little more like a coming-of-age story. A little more is done to convey the character’s feelings and emotions than in the first game. But it still feels like the overall narrative is conveyed in a far too minimalistic way. So it’s worth a certain amount more emotional investment on the part of the player. 

Originality – 6/10

As I’ve alluded to, nothing has really changed in terms of how unique the game is. It still perpetuates the same style of visuals, gameplay, and atmosphere as the first. There have only been very minor alterations made, which, to a very small extent, make it stand out compared to its predecessor. But it didn’t really do a great deal to stand out among other games at the time. Since the overall concept was already familiar after the first game. In this respect, as in most others, the sequel perpetuates a degree of creative stagnation. And didn’t exactly break new ground.

Niiutral

Overall, Monument Valley II is only better than the original game to a very small extent. Although a third game would subsequently be released, the second did not do well enough to break the mould and address the issues of the previous game. In many ways, despite the critical acclaim it garnered everywhere else, to me, it represents wasted potential in pretty much every respect.

Score

37/60

6/10 (Average)

Monument Valley (Android, iOS, PC, PS4, PS5, XOne, X/S, Switch)

Developer(s) – Ustwo Games

Publisher(s) – Ustwo Games

Director(s) – Neil McFarland

Programmer(s) – Peter Pashley, Manesh Mistry & Van Le

PEGI – 3

Initially released on iOS, later Android, and then a host of different consoles over multiple generations, Monument Valley is an indie puzzle game. It incorporates a standout visual style and relaxing atmosphere. Similar to the likes of Fez, Braid, and The Witness. It relies on players manipulating each environment in various ways to progress the character through a series of levels. It was an immediate hit on the app stores when it first came out. And has since spawned two sequels. 

I’d had this game on my radar for quite some time. But I’d never gotten around to playing it until recently. Ultimately, while I found that there was a fair bit to enjoy with this title, I felt that there wasn’t enough of what it was offering for it to be able to stand as a gaming classic. 

Graphics – 8/10

Inspired by Japanese art and a multitude of indie games that came before it, the game’s visuals are by far the most impressive thing about this title. They are aesthetically pleasing. Making exceptional use of colour and lighting to portray a wide variety of different captivating scenes. Even though the visual style is consistent throughout, the developers did really well to make each level feel unique and memorable in its own right. The soundtrack also complements the game perfectly. Making for one of the most relaxing gameplay experiences I’ve known for a long time. 

Gameplay – 7/10

The player must guide the player character, Ida, through a series of different levels and puzzles. These are solved by moving objects and building around them to pave the way to the next area until the game is complete. One of the two common criticisms I was aware of going into this game was how easy a lot of reviewers thought it was. And that it doesn’t present the level of challenge that it had the potential to do. To me, it presented around the right amount of challenge. Especially given that this is the first game. And for a puzzle game, something like this was a relatively new concept at the time. 

Controls – 10/10

Regardless of what platform the player is playing this game on, be that mobile, PC, or console, the controls pose no issues whatsoever. If I were forced to choose, I’d say the best way of playing is on PC with a mouse. The visuals are too good to enjoy on just a smartphone, in my opinion. And playing it with a mouse simplifies things the most out of any other means of controlling the game.

Lifespan – 2/10

The other aspect for which this game was commonly criticised at the time of its release was just how short a game it is. And I agree with the general consensus when it comes to this. Clocking in at just short of an hour and a half, it falls well short of industry standard. Especially that of a typical smartphone game. Which can be made to last as long as players care to keep coming back.

There was simply far too much scope for expansion and potential for this game to have lasted as short a time as this does. Even at the time, the first game came out. Like I pointed out before, there have been two sequels created to Monument Valley. But each entry clocks in at the same amount of time as the others. It has been disappointing to learn.

Storyline – 3/10

The story of Monument Valley follows the player character, Ida. Who journeys through each of these optically illusory environments? To be forgiven for some unnamed transgression she has committed. The story is pretty minimalistic. And I’m flabbergasted as to how there is supposedly a film of this game coming out sometime in the future, as it would take quite some imagination to build on a story concept as underdeveloped as this. 

It may be that the sequels built on this as they went on, and that the filmmakers have more source material to work with now. But it would be interesting to see how that pans out. But based on the first game alone, there’d need to be quite some work done to it. Because for me, it’s too hard to imagine how they’d pull that off. 

Originality – 6/10

But as the story is minimalistic, the concept of gameplay does relatively well to make this title stand out among the indie scene. It was certainly a very different experience at the time of its release from what players would’ve normally been used to. Puzzle games seem to be one of the few genres of focus for indie games, with titles like The Bridge, Puzzledorf, and The Swapper (among many others). But whilst having drawn inspiration from several different titles, this game still does well to stand out as its own fully cohesive concept.

Niiutral

Overall, Monument Valley is an enjoyable, visually appealing, and standout game. But there’s just not enough to warrant repeated playthroughs. Though it is worth going through once. In the criminally short time that it lasts, I do wish that this concept would be worked on more than it has been since the release of the first game.

Score

36/60

6/10 (Average)