Tag Archives: Puzzle

Pokémon Snap (Nintendo 64)

Pokemon Snap

Developer(s) – HAL Laboratory & Pax Softnica

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Yoichi Yamamoto, Koji Inokuchi & Akira Takeshima

Producer(s) – Satoru Iwata, Kenji Miki & Shigeru Miyamoto

PEGI – 3

Pokémon Snap was one of many spin-offs to the Pokémon game series for the Game Boy, developed during the fifth generation of gaming. The premise of the game revolves around taking pictures of wild pokémon. Catching them all (and I use the term loosely) in a different manner than gamers certainly would have been accustomed to at the time. This unique rail-shooter, for me, provided a lot of entertainment growing up. And it still holds up fairly well to this day, I find.

Graphics – 7/10

Featuring some of the best visual quality the Nintendo 64 had to offer, there are some fairly diverse settings as well as minimal in-game glitches. Something that had been a problem for the console early on. However, the frame rate can drop at times. Especially in the opening cinematic, it doesn’t become enough of a problem to warrant too many complaints or to hinder gameplay, most importantly. But what I like most about the visuals is how the pokémon are portrayed throughout the game. The settings speak of how each type of pokémon adapts to all the different environments present. Which in turn, provides a much more realistic representation reminiscent of conventional animal behavior. They portray the critters in a much different manner than in any of the conservative games in the series that came before it.

Gameplay – 7/10

The game revolves around taking pictures of pokémon across the different stages of the game and unlocking each stage. Whilst trying to rack up high scores by taking the best-quality pictures. It is very satisfying and fairly addictive to try and capture the perfect shot of each pokémon and to rack up as high a score as possible. But a major problem I found with this title was that there are only 64 of the original 151 pokémon present. Purely to coincide with the fact that it was released on the Nintendo 64. And as a result, the game is somewhat lacking in substance. I think if the developers had included all 151 pokémon, then there would have been a lot more for gamers to play with. In turn, a lot more calls for different level designs and for more substance in general.

Controls – 10/10

Although there are no problems with the control scheme, it is also fairly unique in a certain respect. It does blur the lines somewhat between first-person shooters and simulation games and combines elements of the two to make for something pretty exciting. Also is comparable to such future games as Dead Rising and Beyond Good & Evil.

Lifespan – 6/10

Although it can take only 2 hours to rush through each course and unlock all the extra items used to take pictures of certain pokémon, there is quite a bit of replay value to be had in re-visiting each course and trying to capture as many excellent pictures as possible. The Wii Virtual Console version added even more with the inclusion of the facility to share pictures with friends. But after grinding through each course and collecting everything, it does become a case of racking up the highest score possible, but as I said earlier, I can’t help but feel there would be much more to it with the inclusion of all 151 pokémon.

Originality – 10/10

Pokémon Snap was and still is among some of the most unique games ever developed. The only games like this that have come along since are the likes of Fatal Frame. There was no concept like it at the time. And it’s a concept that has never truly been fully replicated since.

Happii

In summation, Pokémon Snap has been praised as a refreshingly unique game, and I couldn’t agree more. It comes highly recommended by me and will make for a good few hours of fun gameplay.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Pokémon Shuffle (3DS)

Pokemon Shuffle

Developer(s) – Genius Sonority

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

PEGI – 3

Pokémon Shuffle is a free-to-play game that I’ve heard many times over as being described as Pokémon meets Candy Crush. And it’s easy to see why. Though it is more enjoyable to play than the aforementioned Candy Crush, it’s a lot more restrictive in comparison to not only that but most other app games as well.

Graphics – 6/10

Since this is essentially an arcade puzzle game, the only emphasis on visuals is how each section of the game board looks as the game progresses. The idea is to give the illusion of it taking place in several different locations. But in a game like this, visuals shouldn’t really take precedence anyway. So I don’t think the game should lose out on too many marks because of this. There is also a basis in visual diversity with the number of pokémon there are in it from all over the franchise.

Gameplay – 7/10

The game plays out almost identically to the likes of Candy Crush and Bejewelled. But unlike any of these examples, there’s also a fairly strong RPG element to it. In that, each pokémon fought can be captured. And re-used in different battles and can be leveled up over time. There is also a lot more incentive to play it than most other app games in this respect. Since there is nothing much to be gained from getting all three stars on a stage other than bragging rights.

The problem with this game, however, is that it is indeed a lot more restrictive in the sense that each stage takes the life of the player regardless of whether they win or lose a battle. Whereas, in games like Candy Crush, lives are kept if players win a stage. I think that if Nintendo does indeed plan to publish more games like this, they need to ease up on these kinds of restrictions. Otherwise, players will begin to lose patience and fast.

Controls – 10/10

These kinds of puzzle games have been in development for over 30 years now. And there would have been some serious problems if Nintendo hadn’t implemented a decent control scheme. The entire genre started to find its feet after it was ported to the original Game Boy. Making even further reasons why Nintendo should never have had problems. And so, there aren’t any.

Originality – 4/10

The most original thing about Pokémon Shuffle is how well the RPG element of the Pokémon series has been implemented, and it gives me hope that Nintendo will continue to implement series staples from other franchises into their upcoming smartphone games to differentiate them from others as much as possible. Otherwise, however, it essentially plays out like most other app games, and I think Nintendo needs to do even more to be able to compete with some of the more established app game developers.

Niiutral

In summation, Pokémon Shuffle is not without its charms, but it is far too restrictive in terms of how often it can be played, and it doesn’t do quite enough to distinguish itself from other games of its kind. Perhaps Nintendo will go on to make better games than this for smart devices, but there are far better games out there for the 3DS than this.

Score

27/40

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Papo & Yo (PC & PlayStation 3)

Papo & Yo

Developer(s) – Minority

Publisher(s) – Minority

Designer – Vander Caballero

PEGI – 12

Papo & Yo is an adventure game similar to how The Last Guardian plays out. However, due to a great number of factors and problems plaguing this title, I would hardly call this game a placeholder.

Graphics – 6/10

The best thing I can say about the game’s visuals is that the atmosphere varies greatly from place to place. Keeping the overall feel of the game either intense or calm, according to which areas the player is progressing through. Apart from that, however, the game’s visual design is conceptually weak as well as graphically questionable. It contains some noticeable glitches throughout, as well as inconsistent textural design. Particularly concerning the character Monster.

Gameplay – 5/10

The objective of Papo & Yo is pretty straightforward. Navigate through a linear progression, solving puzzles and guiding a huge monster for the most part. The puzzle-solving element is fairly elaborate, but I was particularly disappointed to find how just how linear the game is. I thought that with the multiple paths there are to take, to begin with, there would have been much more to find than there is. But the only thing to do aside from the story progression is to find each Easter egg of a teddy bear tied to a plank of wood. Some of them can be pretty hard to find. But the side quest offers extremely little in the way of replay value.

Controls – 8/10

Even though this gaming formula has been done many times before. A lot more has been done in previous games in the genre than in this; the controls feel quite stiff. And sometimes, even platform detection can be inconsistent. Otherwise, there are no other problems. It is quite clever how the tutorial system is handled. In the form of cardboard boxes that can be found throughout the course of the game, explaining the control scheme to players.

Lifespan – 1/10

Clocking in at merely 2 hours tops, a 3D platformer with this short lifespan is utterly unforgivable in my opinion. Especially when there was so much room to add so much more depth in gameplay than what there turned out to be. This game, to me, like Banjo-Kazooie, may be a sign of the direction the industry is going. However, I think following a trend like this would have an extremely negative impact. The fact is that this came from the indie movement. Whereas many games have more depth in gameplay than even mainstream releases, this is also a cause for concern.

Storyline – 7/10

The story of the game is by far the best aspect of it. This is why I believe it may prove to be a negative sign of the times. It follows a young boy named Quico, who, whilst suffering the latest tirade from his dysfunctional father, suddenly finds himself in a strange world where he must guide a monster around in order to solve various puzzles throughout. The game’s director, Vander Caballero, based the story on his childhood, whereby he, unfortunately, suffered continuous abuse from his own father, and through the game’s story, players will be able to sense the full force of his conviction throughout, at least making the game memorable for its pretty immersive narrative.

Originality – 5/10

Taking into account how well the game’s story differentiates it from other games, it still leaves a great deal to be desired in terms of gameplay, in my opinion, as well as visual presentation. There’s no reason to suggest why the game’s core concept couldn’t be built upon in the development of a spiritual successor, but the original game, unfortunately, does little to stand out among some of the better 3D platformers released throughout the years.

Angrii

To summarize, Papo & Yo, despite its decent story, is a particularly flawed game and could’ve done with a lot more added to make it much more of an immersive gaming experience. It may be argued that a smaller budget may result in a smaller game, but there have already been a plethora of indie developers who have proved that wrong, and that the only limits are within the developer’s imagination.

Score

32/60

5/10 (Far Below Average)

Oddworld: New N’ Tasty! (PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Wii U & Xbox One)

Oddworld New N Tasty

Developer(s) – Just Add Water

Publisher(s) – Oddworld Inhabitants

Director(s) – Stewart Gilray & Lorne Lanning

PEGI – 12

Back around when the original PlayStation was first released, and in competition with the likes of the Nintendo 64, Sega Saturn, and the Atari Jaguar, the traditional 2D side-scrolling style of gameplay was being fazed out fast to make way for 3D open-world games. Which were taking precedence equally as fast. Despite this, however, there were a handful of games released in the 2D side-scrolling genre throughout the fifth generation, including Yoshi’s Story, Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, and the first games in the Oddworld series. Abe’s Odyssey and Abe’s Exodus. Oddworld: New N’ Tasty basically takes Abe’s Odyssey. It gives it a fresh coat of paint as well as a slightly different perspective on gameplay. Making the scenery seem less linear in turn. The gameplay stays completely true to the great amount of variety the original had to offer. And I would thoroughly recommend the remake.

Graphics – 8/10

As I said, aside from being given a complete makeover in terms of visuals, the game also seems a lot more visually diverse than the original incarnation of Abe’s Odyssey. With backdrops being a lot more visible than the latter, and with the inevitable inclusion of enhanced details in the form of more in-depth textures (particularly on Abe and his race, the Mudokens). And a more effective use of the contrasts between light and darkness. This, in turn, adds even more to the game’s already dark and gritty atmosphere.

Gameplay – 8/10

Differing from the many different 2D side scrollers released both during the fifth generation and today, New N’ Tasty stayed true to not only the intense puzzle-solving element but also to the significance of the game’s one side-quest. To rescue as many of the other Mudokens as possible or kill as many as possible to unlock either one of the multiple endings; one of the first games I ever played to have ever included multiple endings, as well as elements of the 2.5D side-scrolling genre.

Controls – 10/10

Unlike many other video games released early in the PlayStation’s shelf life, there were next to no issues with the control scheme. And there are even fewer in New N’ Tasty. Though it may not seem as impressive in comparison to the original game, I’m thankful that no new issues have arisen. And that the developers haven’t made any silly mistakes.

Lifespan – 6/10

Unfortunately, however, the lifespan remains around the same as the original game, clocking up at about 3 to 4 hours. Though this isn’t unforgivable, and fairly long for a game of its kind, I think it would have been a plus for the developers to have added a little bit more in terms of gameplay. In my opinion, the ideal solution would have been to bundle Abe’s Odyssey and Abe’s Exodus, complete with the same huge lick of pain. Nevertheless, it is an entertaining game for the time it lasts.

Storyline – 8/10

The majority of the original game’s surrealism stemmed from its different and unusual cast of characters, premise, and story. In New N’ Tasty, it is retold with all of its wonderful weirdness kept intact. It follows the story of Abe. A member of a humanoid-amphibian race called the Mudoken, who is a slave alongside his fellow people at the biggest meat processing plant in all of Oddworld, Rupture Farms. One night, when Abe is working late, he stumbles upon a board meeting.

Highlighting how the company’s profits are plummeting, executives are pondering the solution. Abe is horrified to learn of Rupture Farms’ plan to use Mudoken meat in the production of their latest product. New N’ Tasty. Abe immediately resolves to escape Rupture Farms. While in the process, saving as many of his people as possible. With multiple endings and plenty of twists and turns throughout, it is indeed one of the most unique stories ever told in a game and stands out among a plethora of others.

Originality – 8/10

Although many 2D side scrollers had been developed, and the be-all and end-all of such is considered to this day to be Super Mario Bros (and rightfully so), the Oddworld series delivered a new perspective on the formula, so to speak. And New N’ Tasty expands on that new perspective. It gives me hope for the future since I believe there is quite a lot that could be done with the characters and gameplay premise. But this game (then and now) is an excellent starting point, in my opinion.

Happii

Overall, Oddworld: New N’ Tasty does an excellent job of bringing Abe’s Odyssey to a new audience. Hopefully, it is a sign that the series will continue past this point. It’s been languishing in video game obscurity for far too long, in my opinion. Hopefully, this formula can be improved on for a possible sequel and beyond.

Score

46/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Octodad: Dadliest Catch (PC & PlayStation 4)

Octodad Dadliest Catch

Developer(s) – Young Horses

Director – Kevin Zuhn

PEGI – 7

Octodad is a quest-based linear adventure game. This has players controlling an octopus fitting in with human society. And performing mundane tasks typical of the average family man. Whilst it is an extremely different experience from the norm. And one of the most outlandish ideas for a video game I’ve ever encountered, unfortunately, I wasn’t overly impressed like I thought I would be. Having played the demo of it prior.

Graphics – 5/10

In terms of visuals, except for the main character, Octodad, nothing really stood out from either a graphical or conceptual point of view, in my opinion. The overall scenery and style of the game are particularly simplistic and bland. And dauntingly, there doesn’t seem to have been a great amount of effort put into it. Taking place in areas such as back gardens, supermarkets, and generic-looking ships, it’s almost as if the scenery and style of the game speak of the mundane day-to-day life of the average man, which is being portrayed in the game.

Gameplay – 5/10

With a small array of boring tasks to do and criteria to fulfill. And with one side quest involving finding several different styles tied in each chapter, the gameplay was just about as exciting as the visuals. Not very much at all. There’s no real substance put into it in terms of gameplay. Which, to me, makes it a particularly fleeting and ultimately forgettable experience. It was extremely difficult for me to see the appeal that a lot of other people seemingly see in it.

Controls – 6/10

Though it’s by no means perfect, the game’s control scheme is its most noteworthy aspect, the way I see it. The player moves the character around and interacts with objects and items in the game by moving each individual limb with individual buttons. Whilst I can appreciate how different the game’s control scheme is compared with that of a typical game, what I can’t appreciate it for is how frustrating it can eventually become. To me, it’s a question of trial and error.

Lifespan – 1.5/10

Lasting just over 2 hours, taking in times when I struggled profusely with the game’s controls, I think it’s just as well that this game lasts this short a time. Since there is nowhere near enough activity to have kept it interesting for an extended period of time. And in all honesty, I wouldn’t advocate anyone play it even for the first time.

Storyline – 5.5/10

The story of Octodad follows the titular octopus character integrating with modern-day human life, taking a wife, and having two children. And performing day-to-day chores, whilst all the time avoiding an evil chef, who plans to cook him. Whilst it’s somewhat different from the control scheme, it’s not exactly memorable, the way I see it. The best things about the story are the clever cultural references throughout, along with references to other video games. And the small comedic element when certain characters break the fourth wall. But other than that, the game’s story isn’t overly immersive, in my opinion.

Originality – 6/10

Whilst the game is unique in its control scheme and somewhat unique from a story point of view, there hasn’t been much creativity put into the main aspect. The gameplay. Also taking into account the game’s severe lack of conceptual design, I think there should have been much more added to this game. To keep players wanting to play for as long as possible.

Angrii

Overall, I think the developers of Octodad deviated far too much from making gameplay as interesting as possible to focus on how unique the control scheme is. And seemed to think they could create a successful game solely on that premise. But it takes much more than a unique control scheme to make the deepest and most meaningful gaming experiences. And this game, in my opinion, severely underqualifies.

Score

29/60

4.5/10 (Mediocre)

Murdered: Soul Suspect (Windows, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, Xbox 360 & Xbox One)

Murdered Soul Suspect

Developer(s) – Airtight Games

Publisher(s) – Square Enix

Director – Yosuke Shiokawa

Producer – Eric Studer

PEGI – 16

Murdered: Soul Suspect is an action-adventure puzzle game, borrowing elements from both LA Noire and Dead Space. Whereby investigations must be carried out, and ungodly creatures must be subdued to advance. But because this game seemed to have these elements borrowed from the aforementioned games, I took an almost immediate dislike to it. Also, for the fact that nothing new or particularly appealing was brought to the table in terms of gameplay.

Graphics – 6/10

The game doesn’t rely greatly on either conceptual design or graphical advancement. Indeed, I thought it might not even push the graphical boundaries of the PlayStation 3 or Xbox 360, let alone the PlayStation 4 or Xbox One. But I think the most impressive things about the game’s visuals are the use of a gritty atmosphere and well-executed shadow and lighting. They add a fair bit of tension to the game. Although for the most part, because the game relies so much on the use of gritty atmosphere and lighting, it does seem that tension only builds to a certain level and stops.

The game doesn’t get any scarier or more suspenseful past a certain point in each gameplay sequence. And it can make the game seem bland most of the time, I find. I think if the developers had perhaps concentrated a bit more on conceptual design and scenery, that would have added some more to the game’s overall atmosphere instead of having it only go so far, and not building to anything.

Gameplay – 4/10

A concern of mine about video games having too much story attached to them is that too much focus can be taken off gameplay. And for the most part, it seems the only objective of the overall game is finding out what happens next. This game is a shining example of that. The gameplay is extremely bland, especially for a semi-open world one. There are side quests, but all they ever involve is collecting things and nothing more.

It’s the same with normal gameplay, only there are also a few demons to kill in some instances, too. Not enough gameplay variety was added to this title. And consequently, made it play out far too much like a film. The idea of playing a video game as opposed to watching a film is that games immerse people more and make them feel more like they’re a part of it. This game, however, does little to capture that very feeling of immersion.

Controls – 10/10

There are no issues with the controls, but it couldn’t have been hard to get the formula right. Not only has the third-person adventure genre been worked on for a long time prior to this game’s release, but there is less variety in this genre than in other games of its kind. So there wouldn’t have been an excuse not to have the formula done correctly.

Lifespan – 3/10

For even a semi-open world game, that Murdered: Soul Suspect can be completed within five hours is nothing short of unacceptable. Even when I’ve reviewed Child of Light and South Park: The Stick of Truth, I’ve been less than impressed with how little time they’ve lasted. Since open-world games can be made to last the best part of 100 hours. The fact that this game is so short-lived is yet another reason why I believe it plays out too much like a film, since films can be made to last a similar amount of time. Especially if it may be a trilogy of films. But it’s just as well the game is so short-lived, since there’s hardly anything to do in it.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of the game revolves around a recently murdered detective called Ronan O’Connor. He must solve the mystery of his own murder in Limbo to be with his already deceased wife in Heaven. The game’s story isn’t too bad, and it does have a few decent twists and turns throughout. But it’s not considerably impressive, given how much emphasis on gameplay was sacrificed in order to develop it. I would have thought that a game that plays out too much like a film would have at least had an exceptional story attached to it. But I was wrong in this instance.

Originality – 2/10

With the small exception of it containing psychological horror as opposed to the kind of horror normally found in video games, there isn’t much else unique about Murdered: Soul Suspect that makes it stand out among many other games. In terms of graphics, gameplay, or story. It’s not the first time a game has played out as this one does. And it should never be considered the definitive one by any means at all.

Angrii

Overall, Murdered: Soul Suspect is an extremely fleeting experience, and nowhere near worth its current asking price. Or any asking price beyond maybe a fiver. Too much emphasis was put on the wrong factors, and it suffered because of it. Even the factors that were taken into consideration were not properly developed, in my opinion.

Score

31/60

5/10 (Far Below Average)

Limbo (PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Wii U, Android & iOS)

. GLimbo

Developer(s) – Playdead & Double Eleven

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Studios & Playdead

PEGI – 16

First released in 2010 after an extremely long-winded development cycle of six years, Limbo took the industry by surprise. Garnishing a very positive response from critics and gamers alike. And went on to win many awards in the process. Becoming arguably one of the most prominent examples of how art can be portrayed through the medium of video games. Although I did find it to be a very abstract and interesting experience in terms of artistic value, I found the most important aspect to me, the gameplay, was not lacking in creativity, but in substance.

Graphics – 10/10

The visuals of the game, as well as the general atmosphere present throughout, are wonderfully dark, gritty, and morbid. The settings are also superbly varied, taking place in dangerous factories, rainy city streets, and eerie forestland. Whilst playing, the entire experience made me feel both unsettled and captivated at the same time. It made me think back to the game Heart of Darkness to a certain extent. Unlike in the late 90s, developers can no longer get away with a teen rating for showing explicit child death scenes. This game is also much more disturbing than the former. Heart of Darkness felt more like a video game variation of the film Labyrinth. Whereas this title feels more like playing through Hitchcock’s Psycho.

Gameplay – 4/10

Limbo is a traditional 2D side-scroller, but with a twist in terms of its mechanics. Along with a strong puzzle element. Whilst I found it legitimately challenging in the end, and that many sequences did extremely well to add to the tension of the game at times, it did leave me wanting so much more overall. Although Dino Patti and Jeppe Carlsen’s perseverance ended up paying off greatly in both a commercial and critical sense, reading about the development cycle itself makes me think that, like other indie games.

Too much time was spent considering what artistic direction they wanted to take the game in. As opposed to focusing the majority of their attention on what is, in my opinion, the most important aspect of any game: the gameplay. Although I also admire the fact that one of the developer’s goals was to not have the game hold the player’s hand throughout, it still wasn’t enough for me to label it as being one of the best.

Controls – 10/10

As a 2D side scroller, there would have been quite a few issues if the mechanics hadn’t been handled right. But thankfully, they have been, and the game poses no unnecessary complications or frustrations. But more noticeable than that is the fact that the game’s unique mechanics have been implemented into the title flawlessly. Only adding to its level of outlandish abstraction and wonderful sense of ingenuity.

Lifespan – 1/10

One thing that I’ve noticed is that there seems to be an ongoing dispute amongst critics concerning Limbo is its length of Limbo. Some have labeled the game’s lifespan as being ideal, whilst others have said that they believe it’s far too short, especially to have warranted a six-year development cycle. Personally, I agree with the arguably latter opinion, no matter how brutal it may seem to others. I certainly found it far too short and far too lacking in gameplay substance to warrant another playthrough. Another playthrough would, of course, be even shorter, since I spent the majority of the time on the SG88 Plays videos either scratching my head or dying. It’s certainly so far the worst and most tedious YouTube series I’ve ever recorded, by my own admission.

Storyline – 8/10

The story of Limbo reminds me very much of that of Journey; an abstract tale into an unknown land wrought with wonder, danger, and adventure; except, of course, this game is much darker and more morose than the former. There has been a whirlwind of debate about what the many different settings and elements of the game bring to the story, and how it all interconnects with the idea of either personal torture or the seven circles of Hell that possibly await the character after traversing through Limbo, and even parallels have been drawn with Dante Alighieri’s take on the Inferno.

Originality – 7/10

The game also doesn’t lack uniqueness and new ideas, as they are present throughout what small a course there is to it. It’s an extremely interesting take on the 2D side-scrolling genre, and it does extremely well to present an in-game world beyond the many stables and conventions that are synonymous with the industry these days, and what has been before the modern generation of the medium. Although I don’t believe it deserved nigh-on perfect scores as many critics have seen fit to bestow upon it, I can at least understand why they have so much admiration for it, and why it had become as popular as it has.

Niiutral

Overall, despite Limbo’s overwhelming abundance of artistic value, I consider it to be a much worse game than what the rest of the gaming media would suggest it to be. It’s a moderately enjoyable gaming experience marred by the fact that the developers prioritized abstraction and cryptics over substance in gameplay.

Score

40/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Ico (PlayStation 2 & PlayStation 3)

Ico

Developer(s) – Team Ico (SCE Japan Studios)

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Fumito Ueda

PEGI – 12

Inspired by Eric Chahi’s Another World, Fumito Ueda developed Ico, which was released in 2001. It has since become a cult classic among gamers. Personally preferring Ueda’s next game after this, Shadow of the Colossus, I found this game enjoyable to a certain extent. But I don’t think I would go so far as to call it a cult classic.

Graphics – 7/10

Whilst the setting of the game is fairly well-designed. And there are a few standout individual areas, such as the windmill and the graveyard, but the game’s visuals seemed a little repetitive to me after a while. But what I do have to respect this game for in terms of graphical presentation is the fact that it has gone on to inspire not only other game developers, such as Phil Fish and Vander Caballero, but also film directors. Such as Pan’s Labyrinth director, Guillermo del Toro. This game has also gone on to inspire the creation of such games as Twilight Princess, one of my personal favorites. Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time, which I personally respect the game for.

Gameplay – 6/10

An aspect I don’t entirely respect this game for is its style of play. On the one hand, the game can get very samey. As the concept of what to do is to simply solve a puzzle, then kill some shadowy creatures, and rinse and repeat. Combat to me isn’t particularly fluent, and annoyingly, the hit detection isn’t great either. I found myself growing bored about two hours in. But on the other hand, the puzzles are very well thought out, which provides the game with a fair amount of challenge. So Ico isn’t completely unplayable. Its linearity for how big the setting of the game is doesn’t do it any favors either, the way I see it.

Controls – 9/10

As I pointed out before, the hit detection can be irritatingly inaccurate at times. And camera angles can seem somewhat awkward whilst climbing or traversing along buildings. But apart from that, there are thankfully no other problems to address.

Lifespan – 3/10

At best, Ico can only be made to last roughly 4 to 5 hours, which is unacceptable. As many side quests could easily have been added to make it last considerably longer. Despite its level of linearity. Its lack of additional content seems extremely unsavory. Especially as this was made in a time when 3D platforming had just about been perfected. And there were more games released at the time with much more substance to them. So by that logic, Ueda was always going to have a hard time competing with the likes of Jak & Daxter. As in Ico, there simply isn’t enough to do.

Storyline – 9/10

Although Ico could not have been able to compete with other games in terms of gameplay, it excels above many in terms of story. The tale involves a small boy called Ico, who has been imprisoned in a castle and manages to set himself free from the coffin he is put in. Finding a captive girl called Yorda, he releases her and resolves to help her escape from the castle along with him. Like Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, certain aspects of the story are told through gameplay. In that the two rely on each other to do certain things for both of them to progress. Conveying the themes of trust and cooperation, it all makes for an inspiring and emotional tale, with a few plot twists thrown in for good measure.

Originality – 8/10

Though I have my reservations about this game, the fact of the matter is that a game like Ico, which has gone on to inspire so many people across the last decade, has to be considered unique. However, the lack of imagination on the developer’s part stems from its lack of content in gameplay, in my opinion.

Happii

In summation, Ico can make for 4 or 5 hours of moderate entertainment and the telling of a well-written and well-conceived story, but to me, it is really missing a lot of gameplay variety and side quests, and again, it seems like a little bit too much of a fleeting experience.

Score

42/60

7/10 (Fair)

Hohokum (PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4 & PlayStation Vita)

Hohokum

Developer(s) – Honeyslug & Santa Monica Studios

Publisher(s) – Sony

Artist – Richard Hogg

Producer – Zach Wood

PEGI – 3

Hohokum, created with the assistance of British artist Richard Hogg and six years in the making, is an art game developed with the purpose of offering players a more relaxed gaming experience than what is considered to be conventional. Personally, it didn’t work for me for a multitude of reasons.

Graphics – 7/10

The best thing about the game, by some distance, is the direction of the visuals taken in the game’s design. Making use of many different colors and abstract surroundings and environments, it certainly speaks of art in this respect. It actually reminds me of the work of Sanna Annuka. She also designed the cover art for the album Under the Iron Sea by one of my favorite bands, Keane. The difference is that Annuka’s work is much more provocative than Richard Hogg’s.

Gameplay – 3/10

The objective of the game is to interact with certain elements of the in-game world to give them color. Thus, moving the player on to the next area until the game is finished. Though it was made with unconventional goals attached to it, I failed to get much enjoyment out of what I was doing the whole time and became bored with the game quickly. It was made with the intention of relaxing players. But personally, that’s not part of what I look for in a good video game, and I wouldn’t want to have it in one.

Controls – 7/10

The control scheme seemed to me to be far too convoluted. There are quite a few functions, but no use for the majority of them. The basics can be mastered within a small space of time, and getting a general feel for how the game plays out is easy enough, but the entire thing seemed far too complicated in this respect.

Originality – 6/10

I can appreciate the fact that the developers were clearly trying something new and making an attempt to defy many conventions that have been perpetuated over the years. But the problem is that the game is different for the wrong reasons, and in this respect, it reminded me of Proteus, an aimless experience unlike any other. If there is some kind of grand design behind this game, I couldn’t interpret what it was, and after having played it, I’m very much disinclined to try again.

Angrii

Overall, Hohokum is one of the weaker indie gaming experiences that Sony has ported to their consoles in recent years. The fact that it took six years to make also compels me to think that many drastic changes were made during its development cycle; most of them seemingly for the worse.

Score

23/40

5.5/10 (Below Average)

Hexic (Xbox 360)

Hexic

Developer(s) – Carbonated Games & Astraware

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Game Studios

Designer – Alexei Pajitnov

PEGI – 3

Designed by the man behind the immensely successful puzzle game Tetris, Hexic is a game that focuses on a similar principle, the manipulation of falling objects. But it is still an extremely addictive game reminiscent of many of Alexei Pajitnov’s previous works. When the Xbox 360 was first released, and this game came pre-loaded on Xbox 360 hard drives, I spent a lot of time playing it. And still, occasionally revisit too.

Graphics – N/A (10/10)

It could be argued that there was fractionally more basis in visual diversity in Tetris. Since there is Russian imagery and architecture to be found in things like the start menu. But games like this don’t really need to stand out from a visual perspective since they rely solely on gameplay. So I don’t think there’s any call for them to lose out on marks for not having great visuals. Even Candy Crush Saga would get a pass at this, in my opinion. Since no one I have met who plays it on a regular basis has ever commented on how great the visuals may be. Only one of the ways they think the game is addictive.

Gameplay – 10/10

With several different gameplay modes and a level of challenge that would satisfy even Tetris players, Hexic is an absolute joy to play for hours on end. Even after players may unlock every Xbox achievement, there’s more than enough basis in replay value for them to come back to this title again and again. I doubt there’s as much history shrouded around this game as there was with Tetris, but it is just as addictive.

Controls – 8/10

The only issue I had with the game’s control scheme is that it can be awkward at times to move the cursor to the pieces the player wants or needs to manipulate. However, players may argue that this is part of the challenge. And it’s certainly something I don’t think this game should lose too many marks over. Especially since there are no issues otherwise.

Originality – 4/10

Even considering how much it differs from Tetris, it’s still not a terribly original idea in my opinion. As I said before, Hexic focuses on the same basic premise as Tetris. And by proxy, it focuses on the same premise as the many games of its kind that were released prior. And the many games of its kind that would be released afterward, too. To me, even though many of these kinds of games may be addictive in gameplay, the be-all and end-all are the only ones that can stand out to any great extent. And I believe looking for another one has genuinely become too much of a needle-in-a-haystack situation.

Happii

In summation, regardless of its lack of uniqueness and its one issue concerning controls, Hexic is a pretty enjoyable game for one that can be played for free and will provide rewarding value on an unprecedented scale. Alexei Pajitnov may have set the standard when he developed Tetris. But this title is proof that he still knows how to create an addictive game.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)