Tag Archives: Puzzle

Heavy Rain (PC, PlayStation 3 & PlayStation 4)

Heavy Rain

Developer(s) – Quantic Dream

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – David Cage

Producer – David Cage

PEGI – 18

Released in the middle of 2010, one of the most exciting years in the seventh generation of gaming, in my opinion, Heavy Rain was a game developed in very much the same vein as a prior Quantic Dream game named Fahrenheit. Containing multiple character narratives and a string of moral choices, which affect the events throughout as well as the ending. For me, this game was a sign of the times. That many developers were choosing to allow stories in video games to take precedence over gameplay. Ever since, games like The Last of Us, Journey, and Outlast have been met with overwhelmingly positive critical reception. And I think Heavy Rain can be seen as a catalyst for this trope. One that I think the industry would be far better off without.

Graphics – 8/10

From a technical standpoint, the game’s visuals are top-notch. It’s easily one of the most realistic-looking games of the seventh generation. Making use of motion capture technology, extremely effective use of lighting, and flawless textural details. The game also does an excellent job of establishing a truly morbid and dark atmosphere. In stark contrast to the upbeat premise that the game begins on. The most outstanding criticism I would levy against the game’s presentation is how, during every load screen, the characters’ faces are displayed close-up as if to beat players over the head with how advanced the visuals are.

Gameplay – 2/10

The game plays out pretty much identically to Fahrenheit. And by proxy, it feels just as empty and dissatisfying to play. The only incentive on offer to people who play the game multiple times is through different endings, artwork, and developer commentaries. This, to me, says a lot about how much effort the developers put into this aspect if they felt the need to go to such great lengths to convince people that the story and visuals make up for the lack of gameplay when it clearly doesn’t.

Controls – 7/10

For an action-adventure game that isn’t particularly action-oriented compared to many other games, it isn’t surprising how much the game’s control scheme adds to the dullness associated with playing this game. The controls feel extremely stiff, and although there are a few context-sensitive sequences, reminiscent of God of War, they don’t last long enough, in my opinion, and there are also too few. It’s why I’ve always dreaded thinking what the PlayStation Move edition of the game is like. I’ve always found the idea laughable.

Lifespan – 3/10

One playthrough of this game can last merely 6 to 7 hours. This is quite typical of how long mainstream games have been made to last for a good number of years now. Although this game was clearly designed to be played multiple times, it’s easy enough to figure out how to get the best ending the first time around. And after that, there’s not much cause for playing the game again anyway.

Storyline – 7/10

Undoubtedly, the best thing about this game is the story. It centers mainly around a man called Ethan Mars, who, after the tragic death of his son Jason, is divorced from his wife. And living alone with only his second son, Shaun, to care for. Shaun then goes missing. And it is assumed that he has been taken by an infamous criminal going by the pseudonym of the Origami Killer. Ethan resolves to find Shaun and is put through a series of trials by the killer to test his commitment to his son. The story is also told through its additional characters. An FBI profiler named Norman Jayden, a journalist named Madison Paige, and a private detective named Scott Shelby. The story is extremely dark and at times downright depressing. But it can end either well or poorly, depending on the player’s desire.

Originality – 2/10

In my review of Fahrenheit, I commented that the only positive hint of uniqueness the game had going for it was its combination of action-adventure and point-and-click adventure gameplay. But now that the idea has been done before, Heavy Rain has even less going for it. It incorporates an identical style of gameplay and only has a good story to keep things even remotely interesting throughout. To me, this is much more of a negative thing. Since the story clearly came before the gameplay in the developer’s eyes. And made for what was, in my opinion, an extremely dull experience overall.

Angrii

To summarize, Heavy Rain is most definitely one of the worst games I played throughout the seventh generation. Since the majority of the effort was focused on the wrong aspects, the most important aspects were greatly neglected. Quantic Dream has managed to impress a lot of gamers over the years, but they have yet to impress me at all.

Score

29/60

4.5/10 (Mediocre)

Flockers (Xbox One, PlayStation 4 & Steam)

Flockers

Developer(s) – Team17

Lead Artist – Chris Black

PEGI – 16

A strategy game, Flockers plays out more or less identically to the game Lemmings, first developed by Psygnosis for the Amiga. The objective of the game is to lead as many of a designated flock of sheep as possible from one side of a 2-dimensional stage to the other. Though I do have my issues with this game, it does also have quite a bit of entertainment value. And I would ultimately recommend it.

Graphics – 7/10

The game is set in a world very reminiscent of what Team17 has been producing time and again for over 20 years. It’s wonderfully strange and outlandish. But at the same time, it’s also interesting to see how many references there are to games like Worms. Such as the mines and oil cans at the bottom of a lot of the different stages. By that token, there’s also a somewhat darker and grittier feel about the scenery and style of the game than there is in Worms. With obstacles such as circular saws and spikes, but most notably, the inclusion of blood.

Gameplay – 7/10

Although Flockers does essentially play out exactly like the classic Lemmings games, there is a little bit more incentive to play through each level multiple times. In the form of a high score system and a 3-star rating system similar to Angry Birds. As well as providing a very stern challenge, Flockers is also quite addictive. It can be extremely satisfying to think of the best ways of getting around each obstacle using the most elaborate methods possible. I did find it a little bit difficult to get to grips with at first. But thankfully, there are no unnecessary frustrations after that.

Controls – 10/10

After taking influence from a gameplay system very much established and perfected at this time. And also having worked on a port of the game themselves for the PlayStation Portable back in 2006, it was natural to assume there would be no issues with the control scheme, and so there aren’t any. It’s actually quite interesting to see how certain mechanics of both the Worms and Lemming series have been blended together by the developers to make Flockers.

Lifespan – 6/10

Given the game’s level of difficulty and abundance of different stages throughout, it would take players about 8 hours to rush through it. And then there would be cause to play through each level again to try and get all 3 stars, which would constitute about 14 hours. This is fairly impressive for a game of this kind. However, there has been talk on the internet about the developers possibly adding a stage edit mode. Which I think would increase the quality of the game, as well as its lifespan exponentially.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

Like almost every other one of Team17’s efforts, there is no ongoing narrative to Flockers. But only the basic premise of guiding a multitude of sheep from point A to point B. Like with many games like this that I’ve reviewed, I don’t feel that this title should lose out on marks for not having something that it didn’t need to begin with. The only element of the story is told through the opening FMV introducing the game’s premise. And although it doesn’t have the level of comic relief that Team 17 is most known for, like in the FMVs in Worms, I still don’t feel it deserves to lose any marks for so arbitrary a reason.

Originality – 4/10

The issue I have with this game, however, is how unoriginal it is compared with many of Team17’s past games. As far as I can tell, amidst the number of strange locations and visual styles they have employed in their titles, they have always shown signs of innovation in terms of gameplay. But with Flockers, I don’t think they have fully realized that and brought it to light this time.

Happii

Despite that, however, while there may indeed be nothing original about the overall gameplay formula, Flockers is a fairly enjoyable game and a must-have for any gamer looking for a legitimate challenge. It’s an evolutionary title as opposed to it being revolutionary, and will serve as a viable source of nostalgia for those who may miss Lemmings and want something new made in the same vein.

Score

44/60

7/10 (Fair)

Fez (PC, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4 & PlayStation Vita)

Fez

Developer(s) – Polytron Corporation

Publisher(s) – Trapdoor & Microsoft Studios

Director(s) – Marie-Christine Bourdua & Dominic Allair

Designer – Phil Fish

PEGI – 3

Released in 2012 after a five-year development cycle, which attracted an unusual amount of public exposure, as well as controversy stemming from the game’s lead designer, Phil Fish, Fez remains one of the most prominent examples of innovation amongst the indie gaming scene and was met with an overwhelmingly positive response upon release. Becoming one of only 13 games in the following year to receive a Metacritic aggregate score of over 90. Even though I did find it to be a fairly enjoyable game, it did have issues that need addressing.

Graphics – 9/10

One aspect, I have hardly any issues with, however, is the game’s visuals. There is an exceptional amount of variety in each different location throughout this title. And a great deal of imagination had clearly been put into it. Locations vary from forests to sewers to factories to lighthouses to hotels, even. In addition, there are also locations based on video gaming itself. Causing a good few cracks in the fourth wall, which I found to be particularly interesting.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

The objective of the game is to collect cubes and cube pieces (8 of which make an entire cube) to advance to each different location. There is a total of 64 cubes to collect, but the challenge of finding everything lies within the player’s ability to leave no stone unturned. This is made even harder by the fact that this game is presented through both a 2D and 3D perspective simultaneously. Players have the ability to rotate the scenery to uncover hidden items and even different locations.

It’s an extremely enjoyable experience. But in my opinion, severely marred by the fact that there are many overly convoluted puzzles that must be solved in order to find certain types of cubes. The anti-cubes. The infamous obsidian block puzzle is definitely the most prominent example of this since it was only solved after members of the Fez community got together and started pressing random buttons. And the solution was eventually stumbled upon.

Controls – 10/10

The game also has a perfectly good control scheme. Since the 2D side-scrolling formula had long since been perfected. And switching perspectives is seamless. It’s amazing how some of the most innovative ideas can also be some of the most simplistic in design. The map system can be somewhat difficult to follow at first. But that would largely be splitting hairs.

Lifespan – 5/10

To complete the game to 100% can take experienced players around 2 hours. But for players going through the game for the first time, it can take around 5 hours at most. Which, especially for an open-world game, is still quite below par. Part of the problem is that there are only a few objectives to undertake throughout the game of collecting cubes and cube bits. And unlike most conventional games, it doesn’t feature stable elements such as enemies to fight or a lot of side quests.

Storyline – 5/10

There isn’t a great deal in the way of the story either. It follows a character named Gomez, who one day stumbles upon a magic fez. This allows him to change perspectives in order to collect the cubes and restore the universe. Apart from that, not much else is elaborated upon. The game does break the fourth wall at the beginning by glitching out as soon as the chaos begins to ensue. And the game must then be started back up at that point. But after this, it becomes a case of simply finding the various references to games such as Super Mario Bros and The Legend of Zelda.

Originality – 8/10

Whilst it may be one of the simplest-looking games of the modern day, Fez is also one of the more creative. Two different concepts from two different genres of gaming were brought together to make something rather unique. And since being a source of inspiration behind games such as Monument Valley and Secrets of Raetikon. Whilst the conduct of its designer may have left a feeling of bitterness towards this game by the industry as a whole, it also left a strong impression on it.

Happii

In all, Fez, despite what faults I personally found with it, is by no means a bad game and is easy enough to cope with, given the aid of a strategy guide to go along with it. However, I, along with the entire industry, can only imagine what Fez 2 would have been like if it had been developed as originally planned.

Score

44.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

Fahrenheit (PlayStation 2, Xbox & PC)

Fahrenheit

Developer(s) – Quantic Dream

Publisher(s) – Atari

Director – David Cage

Producer – David Cage

PEGI – 16

The way I see it, David Cage and his development studio Quantic Dream have started a very unsavory trend among developers that has carried on into the seventh and eighth generations of gaming, which I have previously talked about. The practice of putting story before gameplay in a video game. And Fahrenheit is where it all started.

Graphics – 4/10

Compared with many other video games, despite the fact that this is set in New York City, this game is conceptually weak but somewhat graphically astute. Which, to me, is another recurring thing with Quantic Dream. Because motion capture was used to animate each character in the game, facial expressions are very convincing for the time and do a decent enough job of conveying emotion throughout the story. But other than that, there’s not much else to say about it. Or worth saying about it, that makes it stand out among other games. Another particularly prominent source of irritation was that, despite the display of graphical advancement to do with motion capture, the character designs are still pretty generic. Some of the clothes they wear are nothing short of ridiculous, too.

Gameplay – 2/10

Fahrenheit is a so-called interactive drama. In my language, that means that it’s a game that plays out far too much like a film. It can get particularly boring, particularly quickly, and is prominent. And one of the first standout examples of developers deviating too much from gameplay in favor of including an immersive story. And whenever I experience the disappointment of playing a game like this, it makes me both despair and worry about what direction mainstream gaming may be taken in.

Controls – 9/10

With the game’s control scheme, I found that it can be somewhat of a chore to move around since the movement mechanics are quite stiff. But otherwise, the rest of the game is straightforward to play through, at least. It reminded me a little of the Sims in the way that characters can interact with objects in each environment. Albeit significantly less enjoyable than the Sims, even if it has a small RPG element to it, similar to Sonic Adventure.

Lifespan – 3/10

Another aspect that makes this game seem like even more of a film is the fact that it only lasts somewhat longer than one. Fahrenheit can be completed in less than 6 hours. I think that’s just as well because even after one hour, this game can feel drawn out. Given the fact that there’s nothing else to do beyond playing through the main story.

Storyline – 7/10

The plot of Fahrenheit involves a series of murders in New York City. Whereby normal people become possessed by a supernatural force and are compelled to kill. The player takes control of multiple characters. They resolve to get to the bottom of this phenomenon and put a stop to it. At least despite every other fault this game has, David Cage does know how to tell a decent story. It does have a lot of depth to it. As well as a few twists and turns thrown in for good measure. And as I said before, the use of motion capture to import realistic facial expressions into the game helps to relay what emotions the characters are feeling to the player. It’s a technique that has been used extensively by developers ever since. Especially Quantic Dream, whilst producing the likes of Heavy Rain and Beyond: Two Souls.

Originality – 4/10

Although this game has been cited by most as being the first true interactive movie, I don’t see that as being a good thing. The only positive shred of originality I believe this game has to go for it is its combination of action-adventure and point-and-click adventure gameplay, which it seems to have incorporated. But other than that, like Another World before it, I think the game is unique, but for all the wrong reasons.

Angrii

In summation, Fahrenheit is, in my opinion, one of the worst video games of the sixth generation. I can’t help but think that if this dire trend of the story before gameplay hadn’t been implemented over the years because of games like this, the industry would be even stronger now than it is. Gameplay must always come before every other aspect.

Score

31/60

5/10 (Far Below Average)

Ether One (PC & PlayStation 4)

Ether One

Developer(s) – White Paper Games

PEGI – 7

Ether One is a first-person exploration adventure game. With a strong element of puzzle-solving attached to it. Though I found the gameplay to be somewhat bland at times, it was nonetheless a pretty intriguing title.

Graphics – 7/10

In terms of conceptual design, this game wanted very little. It was impressively diverse, containing a plethora of different locations to explore. And different atmospheres along the way, ranging from calm and tranquil to extremely thrilling. And at times foreboding too. The problems I have with it are regarding the technical side. I found that even though the game was powered using the latest version of the Unreal engine, one of the most advanced gaming engines on the market, the frame rate went up and down like a Rollercoaster. Even though it isn’t the most visually astute game I’ve ever seen.

Gameplay – 7/10

The game’s puzzle-solving element can be compared to that of Half-Life or Portal, in my opinion. In that, very little is self-explanatory and does require quite a bit of lateral thinking on the player’s part to get through. The player must use their better judgment to decide which items found are worth keeping in the long term in order to progress through the future arts of the game. Since there isn’t much action involved, the game can feel a little boring at times. But for the most part, it does well to entertain.

Controls – 10/10

Like many other indie first-person video games released these days, there are considerably fewer mechanics for players to have to worry about. And so, the control scheme poses even fewer problems than a conventional first-person shooter does, which is most often none anyway. These days, it’s only the worst shooting games that seem to have any kind of problems with controls, such as Brink. But this is not one of those games, thankfully.

Lifespan – 4/10

To complete the game can take around 5 to 6 hours, which, despite the fact that it is ultimately a linear progression of a game, is still particularly underwhelming. Given the fact that it does heavily encourage the concept of exploration. And normally, such games can be made to last considerably longer. Provided that there is enough to do along the way. There can be the discovery of a back story, which can add a little more longevity. But disappointingly, it is one of the shortest first-person games I’ve played.

Storyline – 8/10

The story of Ether One follows the endeavor of a self-titled character. Who is under the employ of a company called the Ether Institute of Telepathic Medicine, which specializes in mental health. As a restorer, his/her job is to investigate the thoughts of a 69-year-old dementia patient named Jean Thompson and reconstruct her memories using various artifacts retrieved from her subconscious. It’s a very unique story, in that it tackles issues that have never really been tackled to this great an extent in a video game before. And it makes for an extremely interesting insight into the issue.

Originality – 7/10

Even back in the days when a story in video games was starting to become much more prominent, there were few games to tackle political issues. The exceptions of which are Final Fantasy IX and Breath of Fire IV. But not only does this game do it particularly uniquely. But the core concept of gameplay also does well to add to this perpetuated issue. The topic of the human psyche is still able to capture the imagination of many to this very day.

Happii

Overall, Ether One, though flawed in certain ways, is a particularly interesting game and another step towards perpetuating the medium as a valid art form. Though somewhat lacking in gameplay, it conveys some very intriguing thoughts and asks some very serious questions; better than even many films to have come and gone.

Score

43/60

7/10 (Fair)

Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem (GameCube)

Eternal Darkness

Developer(s) – Silicon Knights

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Dennis Dyack, Tatsuya Hishida & Hiroyuki Yamada

Producer(s) – Shigeru Miyamoto, Satoru Iwata & Kenji Miki

ELSPA – 15

Released as a GameCube launch title back in 2002, along with the likes of Luigi’s Mansion, Pikmin, and Super Smash Bros Melee, Eternal Darkness was one of Nintendo’s first forays into the survival horror genre, which had been well and truly established throughout the previous generation with the advent of both Resident Evil and Silent Hill. But rather than referring to it as a survival horror, developers Silicon Knights cited it as a psychological thriller. Arguing that the story and overall atmosphere of Eternal Darkness weren’t as reminiscent of the B-list movie scene as Resident Evil Was. In my opinion, that certainly shows.

Graphics – 7/10

The game did a pretty decent job of showing players what the Nintendo GameCube was capable of on a graphical level in the early stages of its shelf life. But more important and noticeable than that, in my opinion, is the gritty and shadowy atmosphere of Alex’s grandfather’s Rhode Island mansion. There is limited visibility, and a lot of the furniture, namely the bookcases and the piano, is finished with what looks like Chinese lacquer. Giving an almost red color, alluding to blood. Possibly a reference to the HG Wells short story, The Red Room. It can also make players see Luigi’s Mansion in a somewhat different and more disturbing light than before, as both games are set in mansions. Most probably a reference to one another.

Gameplay – 6.5/10

For the most part, Eternal Darkness plays out very similarly to both Resident Evil and Silent Hill. Linear action-adventure games with an emphasis on puzzle solving. But what sets this game apart from both of the aforementioned examples, as well as every other survival horror game ever made, is the revelation of the sanity meter. An in-game meter, which depletes the longer players spend time fighting enemies.

Depletion of this meter causes unorthodox things to happen within the game. Such as the appearance of distorted imagery and scenery. And even the breaking of the fourth wall is designed to throw players off guard. For example, notices may pop up saying that the controller is unplugged when it isn’t. I’ve never seen anything remotely similar to this used in any other game apart from Don’t Starve. And in all honesty, it makes me wonder why the idea hasn’t caught on with most other leading developers in the survival horror genre. It is a very effective scare tactic to use within a video game.

Controls – 9/10

The control scheme of video games like the original Resident Evil and Silent Hill always frustrated me to an extent. since it seemed like a chore to turn the character around in a different or opposite direction. Most probably why they added the feature to turn 180 degrees with a single button. It would also make combat pretty awkward, too. It’s the same story in Eternal Darkness. But at least, like in games such as Tunguska, it doesn’t cause enough of a problem to render it virtually unplayable, at least.

Lifespan – 6/10

The game can be made to last roughly 11 to 12 hours. Whilst that isn’t that great, it is actually a fair bit longer than prior games of its kind to have been made to last. To put that in retrospect, that’s about the average amount of time it would take to finish the two playthroughs of Resident Evil 2. The one thing I wish could have been added to not just Eternal Darkness. But all other games made in the same vein were a bit more incentive than simply trying to unlock every possible ending. Some games, like Silent Hill 2, have things like additional weapons to unlock. But I find that things like that don’t really give a game enough replay value.

Storyline – 7/10

A fairly well-conceived story, it revolves around a young woman named Alexandra Roivas. Upon arriving at her late grandfather’s house to investigate his death, she stumbles upon a secret room in the mansion containing a volume called The Tome of Eternal Darkness. The book causes her to see into the experiences of past figures throughout human history. Alexandra must experience all of these past events to uncover the truth behind her grandfather’s death. The strongest point of this game’s story is undoubtedly the voice acting. Featuring the voice talents of several cast members of the Metal Gear Solid games, such as David Hayter, Greg Eagles, and one of my personal favorite video game voice actors, Jennifer Hale.

Originality – 7/10

Though the game is largely unoriginal in terms of both general gameplay and its main hub world, there is, however, a fair bit of visual diversity in the rest of the game’s settings. It takes place throughout a wide range of periods in human history. And depicting a wide range of different cultures. In terms of gameplay, there is also the inclusion of the sanity meter. And the unpredictable effects it can have on the game, as well as on the player.

Happii

In summation, Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem, to me, is one of the better action-adventure survival horror games out there. And I would highly recommend it to any fan of the genre who may have missed this title. It’s a classic example of how Nintendo isn’t just for kids. And it’s a survival horror experience that remains unlike any other to this day.

Score

42.5/60

7/10 (Fair)

Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back (PlayStation & PlayStation 3)

Crash Bandicoot 2

Developer(s) – Naughty Dog

Publisher(s) – Sony Computer Entertainment

Director – Jason Rubin

Producer – Mark Cerny

PEGI – 7

Following the overwhelming success of the first game, a sequel to Crash Bandicoot was inevitable, and hopes were high. Naughty Dog didn’t disappoint, as Crash Bandicoot 2 was met with many favorable reviews from critics and also went on to become one of the best-selling PlayStation games of all time. Though I think the series would go on to reach greater heights in the future, the second game is a slight improvement on the first for a fair few reasons.

Graphics – 8.5/10

Inevitably, the first improvement on the first is the visuals. Though they’re about as diverse as in the first game. The game takes place in many different environments. Such as jungles, ice caverns, and even sewers. As the developers wanted the game to have more of a gritty feel to it at one stage, the technical side of things was greatly improved. As there is a lot more textural detail added to both the characters and environments. Experiments are being made with things such as light mapping.

Gameplay – 8.5/10

The gameplay is also a very positive departure from the original. Not only does it feel less linear with the inclusion of various overworlds. Which the player can explore it at will, depending on how far into it they have progressed. But there are also many more side quests to complete. And even an improved ending for doing all of them. It’s not quite as radical a departure as Super Mario 64 was to the rest of the Super Mario series at that point. But it would go on to change the formula of the series for the better.

Controls – 10/10

As in the first, there are no issues with the controls whatsoever. Still being one of the better 3D platformers for the PlayStation at the time, Naughty Dog was able to rise above many developers for the console and make a control scheme that worked to adapt to the controller’s lack of an analogue stick.

Lifespan – 7/10

The second game can take as long as the first if rushed through. But if the player wants to do everything, it may end up taking around 10 hours to complete. Which, for a semi-linear platformer, isn’t too bad. Along with Symphony of the Night, this game would be instrumental in establishing that other games of its kind can be made to last longer than what was the industry standard for platforming games at the time.

Storyline – 6/10

Whilst on his way to retrieve a new battery for his sister Coco’s computer, Crash is then kidnapped by his arch-nemesis Dr. Cortex, who requests that he help him to recover 25 crystals under the pretence that Crash can use them to prevent an unknown impending doom. Whilst it’s still nowhere near the standard of storytelling that Naughty Dog would later become renowned for, it was still something different from what was normal at the time, which made it unique not only from other games but also from its predecessor.

Originality – 7/10

By changing the format as radically as the developers did, they also kept the series particularly fresh and made this game stand out amongst even the great plethora of 3D platformers that were being released at the time. It felt a lot more open than the first, despite overall linearity, which was most probably the bulk of the challenge they faced without them having to make a carbon copy of Super Mario 64.

Happii

Overall, Crash Bandicoot 2 was a massive improvement on the first game. And one of the more entertaining gaming experiences on the original PlayStation. Though I think the series would get even better with the introduction of the third game, this was certainly a worthy sequel.

Score

47.5/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Contrast (PlayStation 3 & PlayStation 4, PC, Xbox 360 & Xbox One)

Contrast

Developer(s) – Compulsion Games

Publisher(s) – Focus Home Interactive

PEGI – 12

Released around the same time as both the Xbox One and PlayStation 4, and acting as launch titles for both systems as well as being ported to their predecessors, Contrast is an independently developed 3D platformer with a heavy emphasis on puzzle-solving and item collecting. It also makes use of some fairly unique mechanics in terms of gameplay. Whilst I was impressed to some extent, especially, to begin with, I found the overall experience far too fleeting for me to be able to mention it in the same breath as many of the great games in the genre that have clearly inspired its creation.

Graphics – 7/10

The game itself is set in a time reminiscent of the early 1900s. Giving it a very strong film noir feel. It’s dark and gritty, and seamlessly sets the scene for how exactly both the game and the story play out. Characters throughout the game, except for three, are also represented as shadows of themselves. This also adds a very nice touch to both the visuals and the game’s general atmosphere. By contrast, however (hence the name), the use of lighting in the game also plays a much more pivotal role than in the average game. In terms of settings, it’s tone.

Gameplay – 8/10

The main element that sets this game apart is that there is a mechanic that requires the player character to move in and out of the shadow to either solve puzzles, reach otherwise unreachable areas, or find hidden secrets within the game, such as the collectible orbs or the Extra Life Easter egg in the first half of the game. The experience is challenging as well as satisfying for how short a time it lasts, and will require players to think on their feet. In particular, the puzzle in the Excelsior Hotel during the first half of the game can be fairly gruelling, I found.

Controls – 8/10

At first, the controls can take a little bit of getting used to. It plays more or less identically to Blood Omen 2, where they feel quite stiff. And the camera must be moved to make the player character rotate. Which, in turn, reminds me of how 3D platformers first played out on the original PlayStation when moving around felt more like a hindrance than an innovation. Examples of which are Blasto, Croc: Legend of the Gobbos, and even the original Tomb Raider. It’s just as well that there isn’t any combat element to it. As it would have been more difficult to handle without making use of a targeting system. Blood Omen 2 handled it surprisingly well. But even if this game had been made to last longer than it did, it wouldn’t have needed an element of combat, given the right amount of intricate puzzles.

Lifespan – 1/10

As mentioned, I don’t believe the game lasts anywhere near as long as it had the potential to. Clocking in at around 2 and a half hours. There has been a multitude of 3D platformers that have come and gone, that have been made to last many times more than that. Super Mario 64, Jak & Daxter, and Ratchet & Clank, to name but a few. It could be argued that a primary reason for this would be that the developers may have been on a budget since the game was independently developed. But games have been made to last even for an unlimited amount of time after having a small amount of money attached to their development. Don’t Starve, for example.

Storyline – 6/10

The story of Contrast follows a young girl named Didi. And her imaginary friend (the playable character), Dawn. Didi sneaks out of bed one night against her mother, Kat’s, wishes, to watch her mother perform as a cabaret singer at her local club, the Ghost Note. What follows is an unfolding of events chronicling the turbulent situation between Didi’s mother and father. And the serious financial and desperate situation Didi’s father, Johnny, has dropped himself into, involving gangsters, ongoing debts, and involvement with the mysterious and popular show business magician, Vincenzo.

I found that the first part of the game was portrayed as extremely suspenseful and dramatic. But I felt as if it lost momentum during the second half. And it seemed to be much more tame and unfitting in its atmosphere. And for the most part, didn’t seem to be going anywhere. I was satisfied with the ending. But the events immediately leading up to it made me lose the initial interest I had in the plot.

Originality – 6.5/10

The shadow-shifting mechanics in Contrast made for a somewhat standout experience. And puzzle-solving is on a much more prominent level than in other 3D platformers. But for me, the short lifespan was far too much of a negative factor for me to be able to label it as one of the greats. When Super Mario 64 was released, it set a trend that this game breaks. This could be a reason why it stands out, but it does so for the wrong reason, in my opinion.

Niiutral

Overall, Contrast, whilst an extremely short-lived gaming experience, does have its good moments and serves to maintain interest relatively well throughout. The story isn’t the most well-thought-out within gaming, but its graphics and gameplay make it worth at most one playthrough.

Score

36.5/60

6/10 (Average)

Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker (Wii U & Switch)

Captain Toad Treasure Tracker

Developer(s) – Nintendo EAD Tokyo Group No. 2 & 1-Up Studio

Publisher(s) – Nintendo

Director(s) – Kenta Motokura & Shinya Hiratake

Producer – Koichi Hayashida

PEGI – 3

Building upon the innovative mini-game found in Super Mario 3D World, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker follows the long-running supporting Super Mario character Toad (in the first game, where the character has served as the main protagonist since 1994’s Wario’s Woods for the NES), as he resolves to collect treasure and rescue his own damsel in distress, Toadette. Treasure Tracker to me marks the launch of yet another extremely enjoyable Super Mario spin-off series. And I would highly recommend it to anyone in possession of a Wii U.

Graphics – 9/10

The game is filled with a plethora of varied and, at times, extremely lush-looking stage designs; levels such as Clear Pipe Puzzleplex and especially Midnight in the Wandering Woods certainly stand out. But it’s also interesting to be able to identify what influence Nintendo has taken from not only past games in their own library but from Arabian culture throughout. The obvious one to me was the original variant of Super Mario Bros 2 that stayed in Japan, called Doki Doki Panic.

Instead of being sucked into a dream, like Mario and company are in Super Mario Bros 2, the four characters of Doki Doki Panic are instead sucked into a book. And the Arabian tableau is the setting of the story. An obvious nod to the book One Thousand and One Arabian Nights. The fact that each of the levels is also set out like chapters in books in Treasure Tracker would seem to corroborate this. The level at which this is most evident, however, is Double Cherry Spires in the second book. The architecture of the buildings and spires is quite clearly influenced by Arabian or Indian architecture, bearing a striking resemblance to buildings such as the Taj Mahal, for example.

Gameplay – 8/10

The game’s play revolves around Toad traveling a series of cube-shaped stages in search of three diamonds. And to fulfil one additional objective within each level, and then finish the stage by collecting the gold star. It is extremely enjoyable, to say the least, containing a half-decent amount of substance for a linear game. I do, however, think there is room to add more. But I believe that could be something to be saved for a possible sequel. And I do indeed hope there will be one after playing this game.

Initially, I thought that there was an element of false advertisement on Nintendo’s part, as I thought that the bonus book was only available if players already had a save file of Super Mario 3D World on their Wii U. And there would have only been 64 courses available otherwise, whilst the back of the box states that there are over 70. But the bonus book is also made available after players complete the first three books, too. And there is indeed a bare minimum of 74 courses available.

Controls – 10/10

Much to my surprise, there isn’t really a bad thing I can say about the game’s control scheme. Upon the first glance at Treasure Tracker during E3, I half-suspected that there would inevitably be issues with camera angles. And that obstruction would inadvertently play a huge part in this game. But I was fortunately very much appeased with how well that issue has been handled overall.

Lifespan – 6/10

Taking everything in the game into account, this title will last about 8 hours in all. It is somewhat below par for the average Nintendo title. But what needs to be considered is that the time game is very much a question of trial and error. And as I said, there is room for much more to do. At the moment, that’s why I’m hoping that this will be where a sequel could come in. Like any good idea, Treasure Tracker is worth building upon and developing. And it would be very exciting to see what Nintendo decides to do with it if they ever release a second game. But for something that started as a simple mini-game, I don’t see any reason why it should lose out on too many marks for making it last as long as it does.

Storyline – 5/10

The story behind the game is that Captain Toad and his partner Toadette are on a treasure hunt when Toadette is suddenly captured by a towering and treasure-hungry bird called Wingo. Thereby compelling Toad to defeat him and save Toadette. As a game associated with the Mario franchise, the story is very archetypal of most stories that have been seen in games of the franchise; a white knight resolves to save his damsel in distress from an evil tyrant.

Although my next argument will contain spoiler alerts, I don’t think players will be missing much regardless. The unique thing about the story is how, later on, the roles are reversed so that it’s Toadette out to save Toad from Wingo. And then the two of them escape separately, resolve to find another. And then set out to defeat Wingo once and for all. These plot threads provide a moderate change of pace. But nothing really special or standout.

Originality – 10/10

Though I have criticized the game for having a very unoriginal story, the fact of the matter is, there is no other game like Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker. The gameplay mechanics are insanely unique. And inspiration came from some unorthodox places. The game reminded Mario creator Shigeru Miyamoto of another video game idea he had some time before. Which was inspired by the concept of the Rubik’s Cube. The problem was that if it had been made in the style of a conventional platforming game, it would have been considered far too easy. Therefore, the ability to jump was eradicated. The game may have also featured Link from the Legend of Zelda series. Miyamoto rejected this idea, but still thought the game had potential, and all they needed was a different protagonist, so Toad was settled on.

Happii

Overall, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker is a highly enjoyable and unique gaming experience, and it comes highly recommended from not just me. But from a fellow reviewer at Dark Zero, Thomas McDermott. Here’s the link to his review for the site:

http://darkzero.co.uk/game-reviews/captain-toad-treasure-tracker-wii-u/

Nintendo needed to get off to a good start in 2015. And with this beauty of a game, it’s safe to assume that they have done just that.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons (PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 & PC)

Brothers a Tale of Two Sons

Developer(s) – Starbreeze Studios

Publisher(s) – 505 Games & Spike Chunsoft

Director – Josef FaresV,

PEGI – 16

The brainchild of Dutch film director Josef Fares, Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons was an indie game released in August of 2013, and won the VGA award for Best Xbox Game of 2013. Ahead of the likes of BioShock Infinite and Grand Theft Auto V. I decided to check it out, and though I can point out a few things about it, I was left fairly impressed by it.

Graphics – 9/10

Whilst the visuals are somewhat outdated from a technical standpoint, the conceptual design that has been implemented is nothing short of sensational. The game takes place in a surprisingly wide variety of different environments in such a short space of time, adding to the game’s overall mystique and level of diversity. But what I particularly like about this game is the way that it has been marketed. Like many Nintendo games, this has been made to look like a cutesy, innocent little puzzle game on the surface.

But as players continue to progress, they will find out that it also has a prominent dark side to it. So much so that I actually suggested this to Mullet Mike as a topic for an episode of Creepy Gaming. One minute, the player is traveling through a farm to avoid a dog. And the next minute, they’re traveling through a valley of dead giants, having to desecrate their corpses to advance. It surprises me greatly that this game was also nominated for Best Family Game at the 2014 BAFTA Video Games Awards.

Gameplay – 7/10

Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons is a puzzle adventure game. And the two genres go hand in hand particularly well in this title. What I would say about it is that the puzzles seem pretty elaborate at first glance. But I found that most of them are easy enough to figure out on the first attempt. And in that respect, it provided only a moderate challenge. To me, the best thing about how the game plays out is how both brothers’ personalities are represented through gameplay. And by the same token, it is used to tell the story as well as express several themes. Such as, of course, brotherhood, love, and co-operation.

Controls – 10/10

The game’s control scheme can seem a little bit confusing at first. But it’s ultimately easy enough to get to grips with. And from thereon, no problems should be encountered. Like the gameplay, the control scheme also works to convey the theme of co-operation, as both brothers rely on one another in order to advance. For example, the little brother relies on the big brother for strength to carry him across rivers due to his fear of swimming, and vice versa, the big brother relies on the little brother to squeeze through gaps in fences to find a way for him to also progress further along with the little brother.

Lifespan – 2/10

Disappointingly, the game can only last about 3 hours in its entirety. If that. And in my opinion, for all the substance, variety. And the artistic value that this game has is nowhere near good enough. It feels like too fleeting an experience for how much substance there is. I would liken this game to a gourmet meal. Beautifully presented and exceptionally refined, but lacking in portions.

Storyline – 9/10

The Story of Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons follows the story of two brothers named Naiee and Nyaa, who resolve to travel to the Tree of Life and collect its waters in order to heal their ailing father. The game’s story is extremely deep, emotional, and takes so many twists and turns before the end that it makes for an experience nothing short of unforgettable. Not only can it be described as unforgettable because of everything that happens throughout the course of the game. But because of how many different transitions the game’s atmosphere goes through, and the fact that the game itself makes the player care about the two brothers, and the hardships that they have to endure in order to reach their goal.

Originality – 8/10

Games have come and gone before with elaborate puzzles and an ever-changing atmosphere. But few games have come along that have told certain aspects through actual gameplay in the manner in which this game does so. Though morality mechanics have been used in other games, like Fable and InFamous, the way in which it happens in this title is particularly subtle, somehow.

Happii

To summarize, Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons is an exceptionally unique and presentable experience. Whilst the game’s fleeting lifespan doesn’t do it justice in my opinion, it will certainly make for an emotional and fun 3 hours.

Score

44/60

7/10 (Fair)