Tag Archives: Steam

Undertale (PC, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Xbox One & Switch)

Undertale

Developer(s) – Toby Fox

PEGI – 12

Developed by Toby Fox over a period spanning over 2 years following a successful Kickstarter campaign, Undertale was heavily inspired by the Super Mario RPG series. It combines turn-based RPG mechanics with real-time combat. It has a narrative deeply reminiscent of many more surreal games, including Anodyne and EarthBound. Though I have voiced my concerns about developers combining Turn-based combat with real-time combat in the past in reviews of games like Dragon Age: Origins and Final Fantasy XII, the way it’s handled in this game is much more adaptable and sensible than in most others. And it made for a very engaging experience.

Graphics – 7/10

At first glance, the visuals seem extremely basic in terms of graphical quality. But as the game progresses, players will start to notice subtle details throughout that really make it stand out. Such as reflections in pools of water, raindrops, snowflakes, and surprisingly effective use of shadow and lighting. The conceptual design, however, is where this game truly differentiates itself from others. It takes place in a wide variety of different locations. It has an insane amount of different character designs. My own personal experiences of witnessing many cosplayers dress up as characters from this game speak for themselves. And give testament to how much of a cult following this game has garnered since its release.

Gameplay – 8/10

The game focuses on a combat system highly resembling that of any classic Final Fantasy or Dragon Quest game. But it is in how players must evade enemy attacks that it becomes extremely enjoyable. The attack evasion system plays out like bullet hell games such as Galaxian or Gradius. With players having to evade an onslaught of objects on the screen. After being disappointed by a plethora of games that have tried and failed to combine turn-based and real-time combat, it was enormously refreshing to find a combat system that does this. And one that actually works well. It gives testament to Toby Fox’s ability as a game designer if he can succeed where many mainstream developers have failed spectacularly.

Controls – 10/10

Even with a very different control scheme from most other games of this kind to have been released over the last 25 years, the control scheme in Undertale presents players with no unnecessary complications or annoyances. Movement is straightforward, as are the combat mechanics. And like many RPGs before it, the developer didn’t try to fix what wasn’t broken, and the game is the best it could be in this respect.

Lifespan – 3/10

Lasting around 6 to 7 hours, Undertale falls way short of the standard lifespan of an average turn-based RPG. And this stands out as the worst thing about the game, in my opinion. If it had much less of a linear progression than it does, then potentially it could have been made to last far longer. Arguably, it can be put down to the fact that the developer worked on a budget. But there have been indie games made on a budget with virtually infinite replay value. Thus, even under the circumstances, the game still feels far too short for it ought to have been.

Storyline – 10/10

The story of Undertale follows a player-named human child who has fallen into a mysterious realm called the Underground. Where monsters were once equal to humans, but were banished following a war that broke out between them. The human sets out on a journey to find the king of the Underground, Asgore Dreemurr. And reach the barrier leading back to the surface world.

The game’s story was heavily inspired by Internet culture, as well as the concept of motherhood, further taking influence from Nintendo’s Mother series; the character Toriel, in particular, is perhaps the most prominent example of this. The story has a unique blend of comedy, tragedy, and moral ambiguity, as players are presented with choices of befriending, fleeing, or killing enemies, which in turn influence the direction in which the story goes. It certainly stands out as one of the better and more subtle narratives told in an indie game. It is worth experiencing at least once.

Originality – 10/10

Though the game takes inspiration from a variety of different sources, such as Internet culture and other game series. Even UK comedy shows such as Mr. Bean present players with a gaming experience largely unlike most others. I was overwhelmingly satisfied to witness how well combat was handled against many other RPGs released throughout the previous generation of gaming, and most other aspects of it also contributed to making this a truly unforgettable experience, like its story and subtle graphical details. It can be looked upon as one of the most remarkable achievements in gaming in general, made even more remarkable by the fact that it was all the work of one man with limited financial backing, but with an unlimited imagination.

Happii

Overall, Undertale is an engaging, subtle, and extraordinary video game that will have players amazed and immersed from beginning to end. Though my biggest concern stems from wishing that it could have been made to last a little longer, what there is in the way of story and gameplay makes for an experience unlike many others. And I recommend it to any fan of the RPG genre.

Score

48/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Ultratron (PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, PC, Xbox One & Wii U)

Ultratron

Developer(s) – Puppy Games

Publisher(s) – Curve Digital

PEGI – 7

Released on the back of the success of three other arcade-style games, Revenge of the Titans, Droid Assault, and Titan Attacks, Ultratron was released earlier this year to much positive critical acclaim. And was ported to a variety of different systems along the way. As far as I’m concerned, it is the best arcade-style game to have been released this year. Exceeding the quality of Titan Attacks. And for that matter, every other game I’ve played published by Curve Digital.

Graphics – 8/10

Although the visual style of the game is largely reminiscent of the other three titles Puppy Games has developed, it also has its own specific charm to it in its enemy and boss designs, as well as various stage designs as well. There are also more subtle references and allusions to other games they have worked on within this title. Such as the color palettes of each level. As well as other classic 8-BIT games, in addition to what games that influenced the gameplay. Such as Pac-Man and Berzerk.

Gameplay – 9/10

As well as Ultratron being much more addictive than Titan Attacks, it’s also a lot more legitimately challenging without being to the point of inaccessibility. The bonus levels and the levels where enemies are shooting at the player constantly can seem all the more satisfying. If they are accomplished 100%. Or accomplished without the player taking a single hit. Like Titan Attacks and the other titles, Puppy Games have developed, and the upgrade system is also once again present to give players all the more to play for with each level and to either modify or refine what tactics they use. And how best to approach their own unique style of play.

Controls – 10/10

Though this kind of game had been developed many times before in the past. As a result, there would have been no errors expected to have been present with the game’s control scheme. I like the different system of using the right analog stick to shoot rather than the main button on the pad. Just like Insomniac Games did with another very similar video game within Ratchet & Clank: A Crack in Time, called My Blaster Runs Hot. It just makes things far simpler. But without taking any unnecessary risks, and potentially ruining the control scheme altogether.

Originality – 6/10

Ultratron, as well as the other three titles Puppy Games have developed, can only largely be considered a modification of an existing invention. And, therefore, it suffers somewhat in terms of uniqueness. Though it comes as much less obvious in its visuals than Titan Attacks, I would like to see Puppy Games come up with their very own cohesive concept for a new arcade-style game as opposed to simply attempting to refine something that has been done many times over the last thirty years. Although it has been refreshing to experience them again, they need something more unique to set them apart a bit better, in my opinion.

Happii

In summation, despite its moderate lack of originality, Ultratron is certainly one of the best indie gaming experiences released. It is also the best game of its ilk to come out in 2015. It’s addictive and fun, as well as being able to provide a fair challenge. And any fan of old-school gaming should certainly give it a try.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)

The Stanley Parable (PC)

The Stanley Parable

Developer(s) – Davey Wreden & Galactic Café

Rating – N/A (Profanity & mature themes)

The Stanley Parable was developed about three years ago, as an attempt by its creator, Davey Wreden, to go against the kind of narratives typically found in video game stories. And my goodness, he accomplished that. It’s unlike any other interactive story I’ve ever experienced, in that it’s a lot more interesting and open-ended. However, I wish a bit more could have been added in terms of gameplay to keep it a little bit more interesting.

Graphics – 6/10

Though the visuals can indeed seem extremely generic and dull at first. As the game progresses, they become thoroughly more varied and engrossing, taking place in factories and lush fields. And even Matrix-style computer rooms, depending on which direction the player takes. The fact that there are so many places to go throughout the course of the game itself makes for a fairly wide degree of visual diversity for a game that takes place mainly in an office building.

Gameplay – 4/10

The game takes on a first-person mode but only contains a handful of things to do in-game. There are no enemies to fight or puzzles to solve; only the facility to go off in multiple directions. Thus affecting what ending the player is treated to. As I said, I wish the developer had added at least a little bit more to make the gameplay a bit more enjoyable. But ultimately, it feels more like watching a film, unfortunately. It’s impossible for me to fully appreciate games that are made solely for the sake of art. And having next to no basis in viable gameplay.

Controls – 10/10

As a first-person with next to no other functions apart from walking and turning. And interacting with certain objects and buttons, there was hardly anything the developer could have gotten wrong during the making. As there weren’t any problems to address. So there is this positive to deduce, at least. If there had been any issues with the controls, then it would have inevitably led to me having major issues with this game.

Lifespan – 6/10

It will take roughly 10 hours for players to take each route and witness each individual ending, since there are a fair few to discover. The only basis in gameplay this title truly has, in my opinion.

Storyline – 8/10

The story of The Stanley Parable is most definitely the greatest aspect of this game. No matter how confusing it may be to people, after a while. It follows an ordinary man called Stanley, who is guided by the player through a series of different paths leading to different places with a plethora of different events unfolding; all the while being narrated by British actor Kevin Brighting. Aside from the surrealist goings-on that happen throughout the course of each playthrough, Brighting does provide an extremely good narration, and at times also even brings an element of dark humor, as well as breaking the fourth wall.

Originality – 7/10

Though this game does have one of the most unique stories ever told in a video game (indeed, one to go against other video game narratives by design), the gameplay remains largely unoriginal, and consequently, I can’t call it the overly unique game that many other critics have taken to calling it. It’s all very well and good to have such a strange story add to the game’s charm, but for me, the most important aspect in any game is the gameplay, and unfortunately, this title comes up short in that respect.

Niiutral

To summarize, The Stanley Parable is indeed an extremely strange game with an interesting story. However, for all the room there is in the game’s environment, it seems criminal to me that the developers did not add any more basis in gameplay than what there ended up being.

Score

41/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

The Escapists (Steam, PlayStation 4, Xbox One)

The Escapists

Developer(s) – Team17

PEGI – 7

Different from anything Team17 has ever done before, I found myself fascinated with The Escapists. But I was disappointed to find how short a time one playthrough can be made to last. Set in a prison that the player must escape from with the aid of the other inmates. It also delivers an unusually light-hearted and comedic portrayal of prison life.

Graphics – 7/10

The visuals are extremely reminiscent of games in the 16-bit era, such as EarthBound or any of the original Pokémon games. Whilst it could be viewed as a step back from the more modernized visuals from Worms Revolution or even Flockers to a certain extent, they still work fairly well to portray the aforementioned light-heartedness of the game’s overall atmosphere. And in turn, Team17’s subtly warped sense of humor.

Gameplay – 7/10

Overall, as well as being particularly different from most top-down 16-bit games of the way back when, it’s also extremely satisfying to play for how short a time it can be completed in. There are quite a lot of side quests to do between other missions allocated by other inmates. There is also quite a strong Minecraft influence throughout. Crafting items from collectibles is integral to the ultimate objective of the game, which is to escape the prison.

Controls – 10/10

As Team17 has worked with PC hardware since its founding, there should never have been any issues with the game’s control scheme. Especially not with a game like this. Since what I can gather must be one of the easiest control schemes to work on.

Lifespan – 4.5/10

As I mentioned earlier, for how much substance there is in gameplay, it is disappointing to think that one playthrough of this game can take an average of 7 hours to finish. I personally hate it when a game’s lifespan outlasts its gameplay value. I encountered this many times throughout the seventh generation. With the release of such games as Batman: Arkham Asylum, Deus Ex: Human Revolution, and South Park: The Stick of Truth. Considering that this game would also have taken considerably less time and effort to develop than any of the aforementioned examples, it just makes it that much more unforgivable.

Storyline – N/A (10/10)

Again, instead of the tradition set by the developers, The Escapists doesn’t have a fixed story. But only a basic premise, whereby the player character must find a way to escape the prison in which the game is set. Though I think it would have at least been interesting to have some kind of backstory added to it to again possibly add even more to the game’s comedic element, I was happy to see that the game wasn’t at least marred by any attempt to create any kind of singular narrative.

Originality – 7/10

Though there have been countless top-down RPGs over the years, from Pokémon to EarthBound to Final Fantasy to Chronicles of a Dark Lord, there is something about The Escapists that does set it apart from the rest. It differs in a negative way in how short a time it lasts compared to most others. But positively, in that the gameplay and the objectives involved are drastically different. And don’t feel quite as repetitive without being addictive at the same time.

Happii

To summarize, The Escapists is a pretty good game, but could have done with lasting so much longer than it did. I feel that out of all the games that Team17 has made, where lifespan is largely non-applicable, I can’t help but feel that if the same had been applied to this title, then it could have ended up being something particularly special.

Score

45.5/60

7.5/10 (Good)

The Binding of Isaac (PC, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Wii U, New Nintendo 3DS & Xbox One)

The Binding of Isaac

Designer(s) – Edmund McMillan & Florian Himsl

PEGI – 16

Created by Edmund McMillan, the same mind behind the infamously difficult Super Meat Boy, The Binding of Isaac is a Roguelike that can be seen as a love letter to the original Legend of Zelda game. But with its own very unique twists. Regardless of how morbid this game can seem to many people, it’s also a particularly enjoyable one to play. But be warned. It isn’t for those who are easily offended.

Graphics – 7/10

The visuals, rendered in the same artistic style as Super Meat Boy, contain a lot of uniqueness. Yet taboo elements in things like the various power-ups that can be found in the game. And especially in its creature roster. It was capped off by some of the most compellingly disturbing bosses I’ve ever seen. The only gripe I have with it is that the settings can get a little repetitive at times. But the various DLC packages and re-releases fixed that problem to a certain extent.

Gameplay – 8/10

Playing out with mainly the dungeon-crawling aspects of The Legend of Zelda series, it involves simply killing all enemies. And the boss at the end of each stage, then rinse and repeat. But each playthrough is different, as every section of every stage is randomly generated, presenting players with new power-ups and a new challenge every time. It’s quite testing, but not to the point of being unforgiving. After playing Super Meat Boy, it was like a breath of fresh air to me.

Controls – 10/10

There are also no issues with the controls. There are obstacles present in certain areas of each stage, such as floor spikes and bombs that could detonate unexpectedly. But whether or not the player survives is entirely dependent on their own level of skill. Which is how I think games like this should be. At times, players are required to think on their toes in order to accommodate for what abilities and perks they may or may not have. Especially during boss fights.

Lifespan – 10/10

As each playthrough presents a new challenge and experience every time, the game quite literally has infinite replay value. I love to see this in any game. But it’s particularly noteworthy when an indie developer manages to accomplish this. I hear many developers and critics citing that the budget may have been a factor in a game’s development cycle. But especially considering that this started as a mere Flash game, it says to me that the limitations stem from the developer’s imagination.

Storyline – 8/10

The story is extremely reminiscent of the Bible story of the same name. It follows a young boy named Isaac, who once lived peacefully with his mother until the voice of God called out to her to “cut her son off from the world’s evils”, and lock him in his room. God finally calls out to Isaac’s mother, demanding that she sacrifice her son to him as proof that she loves God above all. But before his mother can burst in to kill him, Isaac jumps down a trap door in his bedroom to plunge into the dangerous depths below. And into a world of danger. The story is extremely controversial. It contains several mature themes and taboos, including suicide, child neglect, religious hypocrisy, and infanticide; the list goes on. But above all, it’s very enjoyable for those willing to take heed to the lessons conveyed within it.

Originality – 7/10

Though there have been many Roguelike games to have come and gone, this is a game that stands out among most others. It goes where other games and developers are generally afraid to go. After Super Meat Boy, I resented the development of such a game. But The Binding of Isaac has made me respect Edmund McMillen a great deal more than I did as a developer. Especially since this was also a very personal game for him, as many of the game’s events were in fact based on his own childhood experiences.

Happii

Overall, The Binding of Isaac, whilst being the most controversial game I’ve ever played, is also one of the more enjoyable. It has everlasting replay value, as well as a story and premise that have rightfully propelled Edmund McMillen into a very special place in gaming history.

Score

50/60

8/10 (Very Good)

Portal (PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 & PC)

Portal

Developer(s) – Valve

Publisher(s) – Valve & Microsoft Game Studios

PEGI – 12

Developed by Valve, the creators of Half-Life and Team Fortress, Portal was released in 2007. As a part of its Valve Orange Box collection for both Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3. The game is actually the spiritual successor to an independently developed title called Narbacular Drop. It was created by a group of students at the DigiPen Institute of Technology in Washington. The students were then subsequently hired by Valve’s Gabe Newell, who was impressed with Narbacular Drop. And they helped to develop one of the most innovative titles of the seventh generation. Portal. Although I found it hard to get into during my first playthrough some years ago, I recently played through the entirety of the game. And I was fairly impressed with it.

Graphics – 7/10

The game takes place in the fictional setting of Aperture Sciences Enrichment Centre, which is a science-fiction setting reminiscent of what Valve is synonymous with. There are a few things to make it stand out from the others here and there. For example, it seems to be a lot more eerily cleaner and organized than the likes of Black Mesa. But from a visual standpoint, this game truly shines.

And by proxy, its sequel, Portal 2, has many different hidden Easter eggs throughout the entirety of the game. Many of these are hidden dens reputed to belong to Doug Rattman, who is an unseen character. But pivotal to the game’s back story and overall plot. There is also an Easter egg towards the end of the game featuring a projector presentation outlining how Aperture Sciences competes with Black Mesa. Bringing the worlds of both Half-Life and Portal together.

Gameplay – 8/10

Portal is a game blurring the lines between first-person shooting and puzzle games. The objective is to complete a series of tests. They involve creating two different portals in order to get around and solve conundrums throughout the game. What I really like about this game. And something I don’t think is seen enough in the medium is that it challenges players to think outside the box. To consider that there may be more than one way of getting around particular problems. And different ways in which the portals can be utilized to do so. Although there is only one boss fight throughout the course of the game. Even that makes for one of the most creative boss fights I’ve ever experienced.

Controls – 10/10

Developed by a company perpetuating the first-person shooting genre, there was nothing to suggest that there would ever be a problem with Portal’s control scheme. And so there isn’t. With the help of the DigiPen student contributing to the game’s portal-shooting premise, the game has been made for one of the most imaginative titles not only of the seventh generation but also in terms of gaming in general. Puzzle games have come and gone like Kurushi. This has challenged the conventional methods of playing video games. But it’s no easy task, and Portal did this flawlessly.

Lifespan – 2/10

The game’s biggest downside, however, is how disapprovingly short-lived it is. Especially in comparison to many of Valve’s previous efforts. Though it’s nowhere near as short as Narbacular Drop, which can only be made to last ten minutes, if that, Portal can be made to last for just shy of 3 hours. Which, to me, was pretty disappointing. Thankfully, this is where the sequel would come in. But the first game was very much a question of trial and error. And no truer is that than in its lifespan, in my opinion.

Storyline – 9/10

One thing that I can always find myself saying about Valve is that they know how to create a very compelling narrative. The story of Portal follows a woman named Chell. She is required to undertake a series of puzzles to survive. Based on the use of a portal gun, which generates two different kinds of portals for her to be able to solve them. The tests are conducted at the Aperture Sciences Enrichment Center by a maniacal AI called GlaDOS (Genetic Lifeform and Disk Operating System). With the unusual and persistent promise of cake at the end of it.

Although the basic premise sounds very simplistic, as well as particularly weird, the character of GlaDOS makes for an interesting experience in terms of story. Providing the audience with a unique blend of both drama and comedy. There are a lot of suspenseful moments throughout the game, but they’re also balanced out by GlaDOS’s sadistic sense of humor. Though these elements are greatly expanded on in the second game, the first does provide a very strong starting point in establishing these elements, which hadn’t been found in a Valve game prior.

Originality – 10/10

In terms of both gameplay and story, to put it simply, there is no other game like Portal. It’s a prime example of why I think it’s excellent that more and more indie developers are being provided with a much bigger window of opportunity than ever before, because there have been a large number of them who have come up with some of the greatest titles to have ever been developed. Though Portal 2 would perfect the formula, the impact that the first game has had since its release is undeniable.

Happii

In summation, although it is far too short-lived a game for what it is, Portal is one of the most innovative titles in video game history and remains a favorite of many gamers to this day. I enjoyed the game for how long it lasted when I previously thought that I wouldn’t if I’d played through it in its entirety, and I would recommend the Orange Box collection to anyone who owns either an Xbox 360 or a PlayStation 3.

Score

46/60

7.5/10 (Good)

Plants Vs Zombies (Xbox 360, PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation Vita, Nintendo DS, iOS, Android, Blackberry & Bada)

Plants Vs Zombies

Developer(s) – PopCap Games

Publisher(s) – PopCap Games

Distributor(s) – Electronic Arts

Designer – George Fan

PEGI – 12

Inspired after playing Warcraft III tower defense mods, as well as one of his previous games, Insaniquarium, George Fan and PopCap released the original Plants Vs Zombies back in 2009, when it received overwhelmingly positive critical acclaim. And eventually went on to become a cultural phenomenon. Personally, I was addicted to Plats Vs Zombies for quite some time after I started playing it. I would recommend anyone with any of the platforms it’s available on to pick up a copy.

Graphics – 8/10

Taking place in a strange world where zombies are a looming threat, and planting various types of flora is the only way to stop them, the game’s visuals are presented in a very cartoon-like style. They are extremely varied in their different level settings, characters, and variations of different units to be either employed or combated against. It obviously took a great deal of imagination to come up with a concept as outlandish as the one presented in this game. They’re the kind of ideas I love to see in games. The kind that may sound ridiculous on paper. But ends up becoming something particularly special on a games console.

Gameplay – 9/10

The gameplay is unbelievably addictive as well as incredibly satisfying. Aside from the main storyline, there are also several other game modes to be experienced. Such as the various puzzle modes, side challenges, and the Zen garden mode. Which, the player can grow plants in a garden to make money. And much to my own personal delight, an endless mode. That there is indeed an endless mode to this game, of course, means that it also has an infinite lifespan. And lasts only as long as an individual’s commitment to the game. It really is extraordinary how much variety in gameplay was packed into such a title.

Controls – 8/10

One piece of advice I would be able to give to anyone who may be looking to try this game out (which I highly recommend) is that the best platform to play it on would most probably be a tablet, since, of course, the controls would be a touchscreen. And the screen itself would be sizable enough. Playing it on the console is feasible. But it’s a bit more annoying, since the game was originally designed to work on PC, and commands can’t be issued quite as fast. This could theoretically cost players a match if factored into enough times.

Originality – 7/10

There have been many different tower defense games to come along over the years, especially on the internet, but Plants vs. Zombies stands out among them all for its exceptional variety in gameplay, as well as its strangely compelling conceptual design. To me, it’s no wonder that this game has left such a durable legacy within the industry and has spawned a sequel and spin-off series.

Happii

In summation, Plants vs. Zombies is one of the most satisfying games to play from the seventh generation. I was personally thrown by just how good a game it is; there’s much more to it than meets the eye.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Papers Please (PC & PlayStation Vita)

Papers Please

Designer – Lucas Pope

PEGI – 16

Described by its creator, Lucas Pope, as a dystopian document thriller, Papers Please puts players in an unlikely situation for a video game. As an agent of a passport office in a dystopian society. It’s one of these ideas for a video game that I take a personal interest in. Those that may sound ridiculous and tedious on paper. But once put on a computer can make for something, particularly special.

Graphics – 7/10

Though the visuals may not be cutting-edge, it’s in their conceptual design that it truly stands out from a ton of different video games in general. Let alone indie games. The color palette of the setting is very morbid and colorless, which, to me, adds to the overall atmosphere and despair associated with an unfair society that the game is trying to perpetuate. It looks like something straight out of a newspaper. This also emphasizes its political aspect.

Gameplay – 8/10

The objective of Papers Please is to process as many people into the country of Arstotzka as possible before the time runs out. People’s passports and other documentation must be checked to ensure it is valid and up to date. Any discrepancies can be inspected to ensure that the citizen in question is clear to enter the country. And if their discrepancy cannot be cleared up, they can then either be denied entry. Or even detained, depending on whether they may be on a wanted criminals list. Or in possession of weapons or contraband. For a concept based on what would in real life likely be an extremely repetitive job, it’s surprising how much suspense can be felt whilst playing.

Controls – 10/10

Since this is essentially a simulator game, the control scheme should never have come into question. Since there have been countless games like it released beforehand. And so it doesn’t. The game depends solely on the pressing of icons using a mouse, very much like on a PC itself. So consequently, there are absolutely no issues with the game’s controls.

Originality – 7/10

Papers Please deserves acclaim for being an independently developed video game, and yet, being able to stand out to the extent that it does among every other simulator game ever developed by some of the most familiar developers in gaming. People may have thought that Goat Simulator was unique, but Papers, Please offers players much more entertainment in a much more unlikely scenario.

Happii

In summation, Papers Please is one of the best independently developed games I’ve found on Steam so far, and a game I would highly recommend. It may look morbid and monotonous at first glance, but beneath the surface lies an extremely entertaining game.

Score

32/40

8/10 (Very Good)

Limbo (PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Wii U, Android & iOS)

. GLimbo

Developer(s) – Playdead & Double Eleven

Publisher(s) – Microsoft Studios & Playdead

PEGI – 16

First released in 2010 after an extremely long-winded development cycle of six years, Limbo took the industry by surprise. Garnishing a very positive response from critics and gamers alike. And went on to win many awards in the process. Becoming arguably one of the most prominent examples of how art can be portrayed through the medium of video games. Although I did find it to be a very abstract and interesting experience in terms of artistic value, I found the most important aspect to me, the gameplay, was not lacking in creativity, but in substance.

Graphics – 10/10

The visuals of the game, as well as the general atmosphere present throughout, are wonderfully dark, gritty, and morbid. The settings are also superbly varied, taking place in dangerous factories, rainy city streets, and eerie forestland. Whilst playing, the entire experience made me feel both unsettled and captivated at the same time. It made me think back to the game Heart of Darkness to a certain extent. Unlike in the late 90s, developers can no longer get away with a teen rating for showing explicit child death scenes. This game is also much more disturbing than the former. Heart of Darkness felt more like a video game variation of the film Labyrinth. Whereas this title feels more like playing through Hitchcock’s Psycho.

Gameplay – 4/10

Limbo is a traditional 2D side-scroller, but with a twist in terms of its mechanics. Along with a strong puzzle element. Whilst I found it legitimately challenging in the end, and that many sequences did extremely well to add to the tension of the game at times, it did leave me wanting so much more overall. Although Dino Patti and Jeppe Carlsen’s perseverance ended up paying off greatly in both a commercial and critical sense, reading about the development cycle itself makes me think that, like other indie games.

Too much time was spent considering what artistic direction they wanted to take the game in. As opposed to focusing the majority of their attention on what is, in my opinion, the most important aspect of any game: the gameplay. Although I also admire the fact that one of the developer’s goals was to not have the game hold the player’s hand throughout, it still wasn’t enough for me to label it as being one of the best.

Controls – 10/10

As a 2D side scroller, there would have been quite a few issues if the mechanics hadn’t been handled right. But thankfully, they have been, and the game poses no unnecessary complications or frustrations. But more noticeable than that is the fact that the game’s unique mechanics have been implemented into the title flawlessly. Only adding to its level of outlandish abstraction and wonderful sense of ingenuity.

Lifespan – 1/10

One thing that I’ve noticed is that there seems to be an ongoing dispute amongst critics concerning Limbo is its length of Limbo. Some have labeled the game’s lifespan as being ideal, whilst others have said that they believe it’s far too short, especially to have warranted a six-year development cycle. Personally, I agree with the arguably latter opinion, no matter how brutal it may seem to others. I certainly found it far too short and far too lacking in gameplay substance to warrant another playthrough. Another playthrough would, of course, be even shorter, since I spent the majority of the time on the SG88 Plays videos either scratching my head or dying. It’s certainly so far the worst and most tedious YouTube series I’ve ever recorded, by my own admission.

Storyline – 8/10

The story of Limbo reminds me very much of that of Journey; an abstract tale into an unknown land wrought with wonder, danger, and adventure; except, of course, this game is much darker and more morose than the former. There has been a whirlwind of debate about what the many different settings and elements of the game bring to the story, and how it all interconnects with the idea of either personal torture or the seven circles of Hell that possibly await the character after traversing through Limbo, and even parallels have been drawn with Dante Alighieri’s take on the Inferno.

Originality – 7/10

The game also doesn’t lack uniqueness and new ideas, as they are present throughout what small a course there is to it. It’s an extremely interesting take on the 2D side-scrolling genre, and it does extremely well to present an in-game world beyond the many stables and conventions that are synonymous with the industry these days, and what has been before the modern generation of the medium. Although I don’t believe it deserved nigh-on perfect scores as many critics have seen fit to bestow upon it, I can at least understand why they have so much admiration for it, and why it had become as popular as it has.

Niiutral

Overall, despite Limbo’s overwhelming abundance of artistic value, I consider it to be a much worse game than what the rest of the gaming media would suggest it to be. It’s a moderately enjoyable gaming experience marred by the fact that the developers prioritized abstraction and cryptics over substance in gameplay.

Score

40/60

6.5/10 (Above Average)

Kaiju Panic (PC)

Kaiju Panic

Developer(s) – Mechabit Games

PEGI – 7

Developed by Mechabit Games, a small development company based in Liverpool, Kaiju Panic is a tower defense game. Heavily influenced by Japanese culture in terms of conceptual design. And encouraging players to adopt an extremely heavy tactical approach to progress. As I said in my Play Manchester Article, this was my favorite indie game to be displayed at the show. And after having played the finished product, it has become my favorite indie game to have been released this year, too.

Graphics –9/10

Visually, the game seems to be somewhat of a love letter to the SNES classic, EarthBound, featuring a wide variety of vibrant and colorful modern-day environments. And containing an even wider variety of monsters to have to fend off. And characters to have to rescue along the way. I was particularly impressed by what I saw throughout. Not only is its core conceptual design extremely creative, but there is certainly scope for the developers to build upon the mythology of the game even more. Making me extremely excited for the future of what could potentially be a very distinct and very successful franchise.

Gameplay – 10/10

The gameplay is also just as creative, as well as being insanely addictive. Plays must work to protect cities from an attack carried out by sinister monsters called Kaiju. Players do this by gathering civilians, mining for resources, and building gun turrets of different varieties in order to battle different types of Kaiju that have distinct weaknesses. For example, certain Kaiju may be weak against corrosive attacks. Whilst others may be weak against laser-based attacks. The game demands that players try out different methods. Forcing them to adopt different tactics to suit different levels and progress through the game. There are also unlockable perks and upgrades to be obtained. Adding even more replay value to it.

Controls – 9.5/10

Personally, it took me a little bit of time to get used to the game’s control scheme. Since the player has to use the mouse to look around each level and observe what activity occurs. They must also use the keyboard to move the character around. Often at the same time. But once players get used to it, there are no issues to be experienced in Kaiju Panic. And therefore, the game plays out as well as any other PC-based tower defense game or real-time strategy game. I, of course, have to commend the developers for daring to try something different. And making it work very well overall.

Lifespan – 7/10

Taking everything into account, the game can be made to last at least 20-25 hours. Which, whilst quite impressive, ultimately left me wanting more. In turn, however, that again made me excited about what kind of directions the developers could take in a potential sequel. In my opinion, there is a great amount of possibility to not only expand on the lore and mythology of the game, but to expand on the core concept of gameplay. And the number of different gameplay modes, too.

Storyline – 7/10

Simplistic in general concept, the story of Kaiju Panic follows a general, with the help of Earth’s citizens, who must fend off a planetary invasion orchestrated by the Kaiju. Although the game’s story can be viewed as straightforward in scope, it is kept interesting by the series of cutscenes that occur between each level, and how events unfold that depict distinct events that happen around the core plot. Some of them also provide the game with a small comedic element, which I found gave it a pretty distinct charm.

Originality – 8/10

Although there have been many games of its kind to have come and gone over many years, I think the developers did a particularly good job of making this one stand out among the vast majority of them. Employing a unique conceptual design, along with a distinct style of play and control scheme, I’ve come across very few indie games so far that incorporate such a great deal of originality, and to me, it has been instrumental in showing exactly what indie developers are capable of if they truly believe that what they have created can work, and extremely well. And in my opinion, this title certainly works extremely well indeed.

Happii

Overall, Kaiju Panic is one of the best indie games I have played. It’s charming, addictive, and creative, and if a franchise is ever born from this title, it certainly has a great deal of potential for the future. I highly recommend it.

Score

50.5

8/10 (Very Good)